Episode 11

Painful burns, Pauline protests, PMO

20 June 202653 min

Show notes

We cover the inner workings of the Prime Minister's Office, Pauline's Press Club speech, populist campaign and political risks, immigration and multiculturalism, press club questions, and public perception and political shifts. The impact to the two-party system, media influence, and political positioning on the Australian political landscape. The role of humour and engagement in political communication and predicts future political developments and actions.

Chapters

  • 00:00 Introductions and Drink Choices
  • 10:27 Bipartisan Cooperation and Political Shifts
  • 21:21 Populist Campaign and Political Risks
  • 27:18 Press Club Questions and Chaos in Politics
  • 32:18 Political Insider vs. Outsider
  • 37:47 Progressive Politics and Populist Challenge
  • 43:04 Challenges of Political Leadership
  • 54:29 Kiss of Death Predictions

Full transcript

Read itHide it

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.

speaker-0: Welcome to What's Your Poison, the show where people who disagree about almost everything agree that it's better to do so over a drink. My name is Damed Damianovsky. I'm a principal here at General Strategic. And my evil twin is Peter Lewis, one of the most progressive campaigners in the country at Essential Media. Peter, it is good to see you for another week.

speaker-1: Great to be in the ⁓ General Strategic bunker today. Well, as you know, I'm a big critic of shrinkflation, but I've found a five hundred mil can, which is the first time I've seen anything grow for a while, a super dry asahi out of the general strategic fridge.

speaker-0: What's your poison this week? Half a litre of beer seems like a good quantity to get through any of your troubles. ⁓ what about ⁓ this week I'm actually going for an iniquity again from my friends at Barrel Lane. So this is a another ⁓ whiskey from Australia, but this time it's a South Australian distilled whiskey. I'm quite a big fan of the iniquity if I'm honest. I've I've had a few of their their drops and I've yet to be disappointed. ⁓ I'm on a tour of Australian whiskies at the moment.

speaker-1: Yeah, what's your poison this? Keen viewers would also notice that you are the walking wounded this week and you are you are in a degree of pain and I believe with some relief under the belt with the alcohol it should make for a lively discussion.

speaker-0: So the the the doctors did so I I had some third degree burns on myself which has not been great. I've not had a burn of that level from some very hot oil while cooking. ⁓ I had to go to the emergency and thankfully they didn't have to yet ⁓ deglove me in any way, which is the the pr the technical term for when they have to remove the skin off your hand. but they did give me some really strong endone and they said, you know be gentle with your drinking while you're on endo.

speaker-1: Okay, well we'll use that as a caution. Before we before we crack in this week, ⁓ and we're gonna mainly look at One Nation, particularly around the frame of this week's Press Club, which was a big I was I've I've never asked you, what the hell did you do for Morrison? Like it was this strategy and what what what what is that for listeners? 'Cause

speaker-0: Yeah, it's look, it's a good question. I I I'd argue we didn't do we didn't do enough for Morrison in the end. so th there was a handful of us within the PMO, and for those who don't know, the PMO is the the office of the Prime Minister, the Prime Minister's office. The way they're normally split up, if you look at any prime minister's office over the years, is you you have ⁓ I'm gonna say sixty, seventy percent of the people in that office usually are relating to areas of policy. So you have an economics person who deals just with the economic stuff, an environment person, a housing person, whatever it is. And they're usually people who are specialized in that field. They know something about that. They know something about that. And they interact with departments and ministers and and they're really the PMs part of the brain. If you they're the whore crux relating specifically to that little topic area, and they'll be ahead of ⁓ policy. Most PMOs will also have a speech writer, ⁓ a press unit, which is basically the ones who in the past used to deal with ⁓ just the newspapers, radios, and TVs. These days they deal with social media and their own assets, all that kind of thing. They'll have what's called a program team, which is people who anything related to the logistics, as you can imagine, moving How to get to Hawaii, how to get to Hawaii, how to go on holiday. So moving a prime minister around is always an ordeal. You have big summits with other heads of state, you have events in local public.

speaker-1: Why?

speaker-0: You a lot of stuff, right? So that takes a team to kind of coordinate all of that kind of thing. ⁓ so that that that would be called the the program team. And then there's a handful of people who do what's called research and tactics usually. So a dirt unit basically for the parliamentary battle that goes on whenever they're in parliament.

speaker-1: Revealing there is a dirt unit deep inside the former Prime Minister's.

speaker-0: Every prime minister's office will have some equivalent of a dirt unit. What most of ⁓ lacked was A unit which basically looks at a slightly bigger picture and steps back and goes, Yes, there's a lot of day to day shit that happens and media cycles and who's attacking us on what today, but who's there to kind of step back and go, Well, how does this all fit together? Is there a strategy behind it or how are we how are we keeping to that strategy and how are we communicating to the Australian public that we're doing that well? ⁓ and that was essentially our job and it was it was quite a innovative For Australia to have this idea of a strategy and communications unit where you got the headspace to sit back and go, Well what what are we doing here? Like what should we be doing here? How does this ladder up into a better life for your average? ⁓ look up

speaker-1: Retrospectively, how do you rate your performance? COVID COVID would have blown up long term plans, so you naturally

speaker-0: And and look that that was the biggest thing for us is I think we you know, all the best late plans and then you get hit with something like COVID makes it really difficult to execute on a strategy. That said, the parts of the strategy and the fundamentals of it that were executed were executed well, right? That ⁓ the those of us in the team spent most of COVID hunkered down sixteen hour days, ensuring that most Australians had a reasonably clear understanding of what was going on, what restrictions when they were in place were in place, what they should do, what they shouldn't do, how to keep themselves safe, vaccine like we were very well communicated to by our government over those that two year period. now you you might not like what was communicated, but the point is you knew

speaker-1: I think to be fair, so w I was on the other side, so we were out of power. I was spending most of my time locked in my attic doing Guardian Essential Reports. and what was very interesting was the public was behind the government, particularly for that first twelve months. And there was also this degree of goodwill. What there was an inflection point though where it all became political as well. I ⁓ the other point to make was that in that first period of lockdown, I think Alban Easy made the very shrewd decision to just stay out of the picture and let you guys

speaker-0: And and Labour was very supportive of almost all the actions. Now there's a couple of reasons for that. One of it is these weren't political decisions. Neither side was making a political decision at the time because there was a central rally point, which is there, you know, the Eurasia thing of there's a clearly defined enemy and we understand what we're trying to do. We're all agreeing that what we want to do is keep people safe physically and keep the economy going, right? So everyone understood and bought into that kind of dual purpose of what we're trying to do. Now

speaker-1: And keep the economy.

speaker-0: Now, as the vaccine program was rolling out, like when it was past the 50% point, things were going well, restrictions were lifting, business as usual started creeping back in very quickly. People started getting political really quickly, and it all fell apart. So it was a very interesting time because for us in the office, you got to, and for me especially, you you got to see the best of what an Australian style democracy is capable of between coordinating states. the Commonwealth, different parties, crossbenches, like everyone was on board. well through that. I mean the some of the Labour st the Labour states were probably some of the most collaborative in that process. And like I know like in hindsight when they're well

speaker-1: Everyone got above by working together as well. Which is so I think is an interesting lead in to what we're gonna talk about today, which is the disruption of the outsiders. And if we look at it in a time frame, so this we're talking twenty one twenty twenty one ⁓ was that period of peak COVID and there was basically

speaker-0: And trusting government was at its absolute

speaker-1: Trusting government was at its highest, bipartisan cooperation was at its strongest. Five years later, the party that was in government is struggling for its survival. The other side is facing as you know, the backlash as well, and the numbers are saying that they're coming for both sides, both major parties. So that's an interesting frame of for what was Pauline Hansen's first ever national press club speech. She's and

speaker-0: She is.

speaker-1: I s assume she's never accepted an invitation. I assume they've

speaker-0: She she has been invited in the past, she's never accepted before. She's always seen the press club as kind of the institutional representative of that press gallery institution that she as she showed clearly loathes if they're not on her side.

speaker-1: So let's dig into this a bit and I I feel like there's the spectacle, there's the substance and maybe the consequence. Let's start with the spectacle. What did you make of it?

speaker-0: Look, I thought The the overarching tone was basically Pauline wanting to stick her middle finger up at the institutions in what she perceives to be one of the hearts of the institutions, right? It's the press club where she's never accepted an invitation before. She's g so when you do these press club speeches, you're given a very tight time frame. She decided, no, screw you guys, I'm gonna go for as long as I want to go for. She did she did things her way, she was completely unapologetic, she was happy to basically tell off journalists in the room. It was her way of sticking the middle finger to the in to the the man, the establishment, while simultaneously signalling to the Australians who do support her as being an outsider of saying, I'm still an outsider, this is what you're gonna get.

speaker-1: Yeah, there was so there was a few bits that stood out to me, interested in your thoughts. So I'll do three. The first was I don't think she mentioned the Liberals once in the speech. It was very clear her she isn't her target in her mind now is Albanese and Labour and it was all around lies, ⁓ rather than you know and we'll talk about the policy later. The second was there was a real a moment that really to me smacked of the way Trump manages the media where Sarah Martin from The Guardian asked A very valid question, I thought, about whether her daughter on taxpayer dime working for a New South Wales Senator, but working out of Tasmania, where she's trying to sort of put together ⁓ a a run for a Senate seat. And rather than answering the question, Pauline just went Sarah and the Guardian, my chosen, to say this is all this is all a now. I I think there are times when the media has played Pauline the woman not the issue, but I thought that was a totally legitimate issue to raise in in that forum, given that Hansen doesn't take questions from The Guardian anywhere else. But gee, she unleashed it with all with all ⁓

speaker-0: Well again I think she wanted people to see that she is not on side like she is not gonna play this game by anyone else's rules.

speaker-1: Ban you guys from the election.

speaker-0: And and yeah, and she's basically going, I don't care how popular I am, I don't care how much money I have behind me or who's behind me, I'm gonna continue to do this my way, not anyone else's way, and I think that helps recruit her second phase cohort of pe you know, that that first phase where up until what two years ago, you know, they they were always polling I mean you tell me what six seven six, seven percent, right? So these are the same numbers of your average friendly grocer in your neighborhood where it's like, yeah, one in ten not even one in ten, one in twelve. twenty people will go there. The people who used to support her are the ones who agreed with her on the problem is those bloody migrants from XYZ. Now this new trench it's different. These are different people. They this is a different cohort who's going who are becoming poorly and curious, handsome curious.

speaker-1: And even just outside system curious. But it feels like you got a bit of a twinkle in your eye when you're talking about Pauline.

speaker-0: So I'm ⁓ look, I I'm not sure that I'd vote for it at this point. One, I do admire the fact that and increasingly I hear people who I would never imagine previously would have even entertained Pauline proudly declaring the fact that they are supporting Pauline, whether just with you know advocating for her positions or actually giving her money and subscribing, right? So to build that movement is actually quite an achievement. And Australia hasn't done that in a very long time. Like we haven't really had

speaker-1: A movement yet or a meme? Because the structure is the challenge. A movement actually has a structure behind it.

speaker-0: What's the difference? She has structure, she has donations, she has a she's run in a in a state like in a state election, she's run many federal elections, like no, she hasn't necessarily had a candidate in every seat. But if anything, Pauline Hansen's One Nation Party in its current form with its current leadership has more continual experience than the big political parties. How many campaigns did Erickson run before he did the Elbow campaign?

speaker-1: ⁓ he'd run he'd run as he'd been the assistant secretary through like he was blooded and he was very good, but I don't know the point there.

speaker-0: Well, on on our side, like the you what I Like Pauline's been doing for thirty years. Like that's not an insignificant amount of time.

speaker-1: ⁓ in and out. so the one other thing about the spectacle I do want to tag is you know, love ⁓ to death, get up. They've got like they've they've been around for a long time trying to disrupt politics on the progressive side. That was such an own goal doing this so people didn't see it. Somebody had sneaked in beforehand and put up a Pass without a fresh pass. and they'd s there was like a roll down banner that was obviously batch like, you know, remotely and then halfway through the speech message is one that needs to get out that she has voted against workers' ⁓ rights for thirty years like consistently but it just sent the message that people were trying to shut her down. Morris Riley saying, no it wasn't me and he sort of jumped up and then they had someone rip it down and to her credit she just continued on. but yeah sometimes activism can backfire if it's not thought through and I just

speaker-0: Reinforce the factory. Yeah, pick your time, pick the forum, pick the message, right?

speaker-1: Like if it had been funny, like w one of the things we've been saying is Pauline Hansen, like her team have been doing humour, but this was old school. It was

speaker-0: ⁓ Yeah, it was yeah it was boring. It was a boring protest as well. Like it was this very slowly unfurling banner with a message that was not interesting enough to justify the slowness of the banner coming down. Like there was no reveal at the end of it. You're like, ⁓ man.

speaker-1: particularly for people that like it's also that audience ⁓ so there's a primary audience which are probably about the same audience as we've got which are absolute political tragics and then there is the snippet on the news which is again a small audience and all the snippet would have said is they're trying to shut it down again and she was probably reproducing that and putting it out on her networks as well. So

speaker-0: And so now getup will probably get a lifetime ban from the press club. I assume.

speaker-1: Yeah, I I think it's interesting. I I I can't remember anyone go because it is and the press club is an interesting institution. Like and again, it's a set piece. I know that you do a lot of events there with y ⁓ Universities Australia, for instance. And it's a big deal. Like if if if one of your clients gets a press club, they'll probably get one or two most in their career and they take it really seriously. You've got to fill the room.

speaker-0: It's neutral ground, right? It's meant to be neutral Swiss ground where it is a platform for people, regardless of where they're from, to come and, you know, present their case and then be, you know, questioned on it by journalists professionally. Like th that's the whole point of the press club. So when you defile that with this these kind of kiddish stunts, kinda glad get up. And for those who don't know for f if you're from the right of ⁓ politics

speaker-1: They're like advanced ballistic. Yeah. Although I think advanced saw themselves as get up varieties. And like but the other and let's just divert for one tiny second. So I think in its tr in its history, get up's been more sinned against than sinning. I think that it it was the first click divism, progressive clicktivism in Australia. I thought under a number of ⁓ its early iterations and leaderships, including, you know, Simon Shaikh and Brett Solomon, it was very effective and it it it kind of created that.

speaker-0: They've had some good early successes.

speaker-1: Fun stunts and things, right? ⁓ one of the first ones they did was when David Hicks came out of Guantanamo. They gave him a platform because no one on the media would talk to him and stuff. But the at some point it's sort of been captured by the worst of and I you know, again, I I think it's important to have those sorts of noisy voices in there, but just be productive and I and I and I think and we'll get to this at the end 'cause I think both of us politically got a vested interest in thinking through how we deal with a populist party like One Nation, but that ain't the the strategy.

speaker-0: Yeah, it's it's one of those things where you look at it and you go, It was ultimately pointless 'cause nobody's talking about what getup the message that get up was trying to get across. you know, their their new media and social media guy, I don't know that he's particularly good because if that's the best, if that's the money like how it is. Yeah. But like the the not gonna give him the the satisfaction of naming him. But like if you're going to spend the political capital in doing that stunt that you can only really do once.

speaker-1: No.

speaker-0: Like you gotta nail that message. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. And if no one's talking about it, you've failed, right? So

speaker-1: Talking about it for the wrong reason. Let's talk about the substance of the speech though, because I thought ⁓ that was it it was a wild ride, and what struck me was there was just bits of red meat being thrown out everywhere, yeah, without much of a coherent sort of stand-up underneath that. So let's let's go through it. But in terms of the classic memories and latest hits, we definitely had Australia's a monoculture stop immigration, climate.

speaker-0: The area of traveling.

speaker-1: Climate change is a hoax, net zero, nuclear, defund SBS, pull out of the UN. ⁓ there was also the transgender stuff, women are women, and then some weird snippets which ⁓ build more social housing ⁓ and regulate AI. So, you know, I was going, you know, so there was it was almost like there was a little bit for everyone, but it just didn't to me hang together.

speaker-0: Find this. It doesn't necessarily adhere to a classical image of left-right politics. It's and it's part of the genius of it I think is there's a there's a little bit of something for everyone, but ultimately there's not a lot behind it, right? And like like and I'm happy to talk about some of her suggestions because I I think there are some interesting things in there. I I don't disagree with her on the SBS thing. Like I learn English off SBS, but in a modern internet age where nobody in the cultural communities that I know tunes into SBS for their foreign news. They watch it directly on YouTube. What is the role of SPS? Yeah, exactly. You you got you know Pornhub Pornhub and all these other things. So it's like What's the point of SBS? Because we're all funding for it. We're paying for it. And I'm not saying that it's a bad service. What I'm saying is it's a redundant service. If someone wants to come out and buy SBS and run it as a commercial enterprise, go for gold. But does the taxpayer need to keep paying for this when we're also paying for the ABC? That's a legitimate question. Like

speaker-1: But it's not gonna be what's gonna it's not gonna be the thing that's gonna turn your vote at the next election.

speaker-0: No, but the collection and the vibe of these things, as you know from all the focus groups, it's the vibe of these things when someone goes, Well, this multiculturalism thing, I don't know that it's working out. We're a monoculture. I don't like her framing. But but Noel Pearson wrote about this about the idea of plural monoculturalism rather than multiculturalism might be a more successful model. So

speaker-1: But y you were very ⁓ eloquent a few weeks ago on your own side of politics, blowing the migration, immigration dog whistle budge in reply. But you seem like not as harsh on Hansen.

speaker-0: No, no, so I I think there's a difference between saying migrants are bad and we should just stop migration, which was or you know, we should take all these benefits away from migrants because they're migrants, versus what part of Pauline is saying, which is when people come here, what should we expect of them? Should we expect a migrant to go, Hey, welcome to Australia? You just be exactly as you are. Don't worry about how we collectively work together. You just keep up what you were doing in whatever Village you came from or whatever US backwater town you came from, you just keep that up here. ⁓ I don't think I don't think those bars are high enough. Yeah, yeah. Like I came here from a completely different culture. You learn the language, you learn the accent, you learn the ways, you adapt, you become Australian. Like that that's the whole point. That's the journey you're meant to go on, because you go, This place works because we work together. Now if you're from a culture where it doesn't work that way and you you have to stick in your culture to your tribe because your tribe's perse prosecuted or you know persecuted or you know, you your tribe has hated the other tribe for ten thousand years. Like, I don't want you to bring that shit here. What I'd like you to do is bring your food, leave your baggage.

speaker-1: So I'm interested how the politics of this play out and whether Australia's move like so how d like in a way she she na latched on to Isis Brides and and and Bondi, but the gener

speaker-0: And she she's gotten good bumps from both.

speaker-1: Yeah, but the but the general thing was you need to be more like us. Now, how does that play? I think particularly with the Indian diaspora and the Chinese Australian communities, I think there is real risks for like well it's not a risk for her because I I just think it makes it very hard for her to make ground in there. So tell me why.

speaker-0: disagree. So I mean the Indian Australian I mean as you know the the Indian Australian community and the Chinese Australian community aren't they aren't monolithic communities, right? The Chinese Australian community is actually 60 different communities. That's correct. Same with the Indian Australians. The Indian Australian community is more on board with the idea of becoming Australian than anyone else. And they're one of the most avid supporters of buying into that Australian lifestyle because partly because we have a shared colonial heritage, right? There is a element of cricket. And cricket and sport and all these things, right? Indian Australians are actually some of the biggest supporters of Pauline Hanson's One Nation because the fact that they see themselves reflected in that 'cause they don't look at it through the lens of, you know, ⁓ I'm I have a different skin colour or I you know, I'm wearing a turban or whatever, therefore I'm different. They go, no, no, I'm Because I believe in these values, I buy into this value set and way of life, right? And they don't think other immigrants are necessarily doing

speaker-1: This is interesting. So she y if she is using the race I I'll call it the race card to create it's not a majority against a minority as much as a majority looking in at themselves and sort of coming in. So the monoculture is another way of saying one nation, really, right? So it's interesting and I will be sort of delving to that in the next essential. The other sorry

speaker-0: The I'm sorry. No, you go.

speaker-1: Well I thought the other th interesting thing about the press club, I thought she was under the most pressure when like so I I also thought that probably half the questions from the gallery were people trying to beat her. So dumb. Whereas I thought the most effective questions were genuine curiosity. So the best one, I can't remember who did it, but she'd said we're gonna pull out of the UN and so their question was all our shipping treaties are negotiated through the N UN, so what's gonna do to our global supply chains?

speaker-0: Yeah, yeah. It was a great question. I c I think I don't know if that was a mass of a question or something.

speaker-1: ⁓ but anyway, so but it's also In a way saying I I and I think the dynamic of her in the gallery and the broader political elites of which I guess we are part has been you've got no right to be in this room. The sense now is she's through the polling, you earn the right to be in the room, but then you've got to start playing by the rules and defending your policies and defending your your your your theory of government. So the last one I'll say out of that was that she did have that really back to you know the Failed get up stunt was actually making a serious point that she's she says she's on your side if you're a worker, but she actually isn't. And then she had a spray about small business it not being easy enough to sack workers and like yeah, the last really effective populist campaign that I was involved in was rights at work, which was workers' rights against the Howard government. And there is a real risk that if she lands in that particular like I think the two risks for her.

speaker-0: Well,

speaker-1: Because she's everything everywhere all at once, you've given enough on climate for all those young people who believe in climate to say she's gonna kill the planet. You're giving the unions enough to say she's going to reduce your your rights at work. And I think the business community are gonna be totally horrified of what she's gonna do to the economy. So all those bits together means that while she's building this populist alliance, there is actually a broad alliance of people. Where there she's put so much out there that there are lots of points where

speaker-0: Yeah. But the thing is they they're not all gonna rally against the same point. And it's a really good strategy to I think the thing is that a lot of the opponents can't coordinate well enough to find a singular angle of attack. There's not a thing that will bring her down. Like she's but I mean she's been to jail for God's sake for

speaker-1: But I I I feel like the chaos might end up being the thing. So I we we're not jumping ahead yet and we're not making predictions. But I would say this that th last election Australians ended up voting for stability over chaos. And I think there is no w un unless things get so bad that people want to throw the card table.

speaker-0: No, no, but And but I think isn't that what we're seeing? I mean that what you're seeing in the poll numbers? It's like it's hockey stir where people are going and it's what Pauline's been saying for thirty years, right? She's basically for thirty years gone the the two main guy the uniparty as she calls it hilarious, but like the the establishment Don't know what the hell it's doing and they don't have your interests at heart, they're just doing it for themselves. And everyone's like, Yeah, yeah, Pauline, whatever. Now we're at a point where people are going, We've given you guys three and a half years. What the hell have you done? Like things have gotten worse. You said that you were stable, you were gonna fix the the energy price, the this, the that, the energy. It's like, what the hell have you done in the last three and a half years? And eventually people start listening to Pauline and going, you know what, maybe it is time to kick these guys out. Because even the multiculturalism thing, she's not going, ⁓ Everyone needs to get the hell out. She's going, look, there's an implicit set of social rules here. Let's have a look inside and go, are there dickheads in here who are not playing by those social rules? And if they're not, why do we have them here? And I don't know if that's a crazy if you I I'm curious if you find that a r crazy right wing framing of it.

speaker-1: All right, well let's t think about

speaker-0: But it's very easy to go from crazy right wing to well, it kinda seems like common sense. Like if I was at a party and there's two people there being dickheads at the party and everyone else is having a great time, eventually someone's gonna ask the dickheads so

speaker-1: So that so that is I think a consequence of a two party system that has also been influenced by the way that media works, politics works, the algorithm works, which is you find small points of difference and have really loud and vigorous fights and everyone else is going, why can't they get on and do the job? And that's become where the two major parties are. So there is one way of looking at this as left versus right. You can cut the numbers up and if you do that and you sort of put one nation on the right, it's about fifty-five, forty-five now to the right. But then the other one that's really interesting, if you break it up into inside or outside, if you combine the Labour Lead and all the other votes, like the the majority is still like it's fifty-two to the major parties, but that used to be seventy percent. Like that's where was more than that. It used to be about forty, forty, so eighty percent. So that's I feel like

speaker-0: Do you feel like a political insider? Or or or within the Labour Party do you feel like an insider? Do you feel like you belong?

speaker-1: I've never been a member of the party 'cause I've always I've been a fellow traveller. I've worked with the unions, I've been an independent polster, so I thought my job's not to be and also it means you don't have to go to fundraisers, which is awesome. I think I am ⁓ of the I've worked professionally in this world media politics. So by definition I'm an insider. but I also think I'm someone that still thinks government needs to work rather than someone that thinks tear it down. And some on bad days I say tear the whole bloody thing down. Yeah. But I still think the only thing worse than what we've got would be what we're seeing in America, for instance. So I don't know.

speaker-0: And in your mind, the is the handsome progression a path to Trumpism? Is that what we're doing? 'Cause before you answer that, like because of the fact that we're a you know, compulsory voting preferential democracy Mathematically it's a lot harder to get to a Trump style leadership here than it is over there. 'Cause 'cause here to get to a Trump style leadership, you don't just have to convince one s the majority of one side, you genuinely have to get a majority of people. Like you have to get to a true populist position, which is really hard.

speaker-1: But once you've got more than fifty percent rejecting the major parties, you're starting to be on that so that that whole thing breaks down of there there being that like and the whole system's based on those two parties. Now now in America what happened was Trump took over one of those two parties and then won it. Like this is a different thing that's going on here. We might get to what it means to the two parties in a sec, 'cause I actually think there's a silver lining for Labour after out of all this, but I'll I'll hold that. back. But before we get there, like you know, she's gone from seven to about thirty percent. ⁓ probably eighty percent of those votes are people that were voting liberal coalition liberal so where does that leave your your side of politics?

speaker-0: It's so fascinating. So I mean depends y you get wildly different answers from the people I've spoken to anyway. You get wildly different answers on this. What seems apparent out there is there is a huge divide within the coalition of we need to win those people back because we can't get back to a strong position without them versus we need to leave those people behind because we can't get to a strong position unless we move mid closer to the center. Because as you know, that's how bell curves work, right? To get to that majority, even with a lower primary, y you need to get to that centre. Remembering that preferences are the thing that matters in Australia, right? Like it it's not about You know, if you have a room full of a hundred people and thirty people say, I want pepperoni pizza, that doesn't mean that everyone gets pepperoni pizza. You need people to go, all right, well if if not pepperoni, what other two things are you comfortable eating? And people go, All right, well, I'd go a Hawaiian Supreme. And I go anything but a vegetarian. Vegetarian is my last option, right? Absolutely not. No, no, no.

speaker-1: Are you fruit on pizza? ⁓ Chicken?

speaker-0: I barely even have cheese on my pizza. I want meat. but it's that thing of and and pizza selection in a party is such a great way to explain preferential voting to people because that's really what it is. It's we're not saying every ⁓ fifty plus one percent of people have to agree that this is the number one option. It's we have to all decide what's the least worst option, what our preferences are. And so when you're in that kind of a system Having someone like Pauline come in and convince enough people that we should give her a shot is not just people going, Yeah, she's my number one choice. It's two, three, four, five. So if you're the Liberal Party or the Labour Party or anyone, you need to find how to get to that middle and we're currently split between whether or not we get there by winning the Pauline voters back or moving away from And I think the party itself has not decided.

speaker-1: But isn't the middle the problem? Because your other problem is you've lost your left wing as well to the teals. And so

speaker-0: Not all but like it's kinda like Tim Wilson's a great example of like you can do a great ground campaign and get those people back, right? He and his

speaker-1: But I would argue that he would not have won that seat back if the whole focus had been sending like his party was seen as mainly focused on trying to match Pauline Hansen.

speaker-0: To some de I mean, he won that seat with Peter Dutton's leader, with, you know, a lot of the errors that happened during that election campaign. He won that back against Zowie Daniel, right? A staunched heal. On a number of fronts, and I'm not saying he won by some massive margin, but the fact is he won it back. Like there is a clear pathway back there for ⁓ the centre left. There's also clear pathways back for the centre right. I think the error in the coalition is the fact that they're trying to decide to do one or the other and forgetting the core tenets of not just Menzies but John Howard going, this is a broad church. This is a place where, unlike the Labour Party that says, this is our opinion on everything, no one say anything otherwise, this is a place where people with differing opinions can get together and go, we all agree the economy, families and government getting the hell out of our lives are the kind of most important thing. Let's work towards that. We can disagree on heaps of stuff, but that's what the fundamental tenants are.

speaker-1: I'll I'll push back with you on and I I don't hold a flame for Labour, but I there is something more like your your sense that everyone can have their say and that's a sign of a democratic party. The Labor Party is based on the tradition of institutional demo democracy. So unions which are democratic organizations elect delegates to conference as do local branches and they set a policy platform that the party is charged.

speaker-0: Yeah.

speaker-1: But then when they get there they lock in. And that was always the solidarity idea. So is that anti democracy? It's a different

speaker-0: version I'm not saying it's anti democratic, but it's a different version. It is a different version. It's it's different mechanisms for ideally they're trying to get to a similar outcome. But the whole point of the Liberal Party and why it's named that way is you and I should be able to disagree on a bunch of stuff but still campaign and work towards the same end goals as part of the same party. That's always been the strength of the Liberal Party. That's why it was founded. So when the coalition has these arguments of, ⁓ no, we need to chase Pauline Hansen, ⁓ no, we need to chase the Teals, I go th it's entirely wrong. The the point of the party is you're meant to do both. You're meant to be able to demonstrate that you can stretch wider than the other guys. And that's what will get you to that, all right, well I if I don't have a pepperoni, I'll have the barbecue chicken.

speaker-1: I'm gonna move away from pizzas when I'm thinking about Labour's challenge. I I'll I'll try I'll try to land it with a food analogy at the end of it and one that doesn't burn you. so I actually think for the progressive side of politics, we've got some really good roadmaps in what not to do with a populist challenge. So the US showed what's not to do is to label your opponents deplorable and

speaker-0: Dumb.

speaker-1: beneath you and apparently I I kind of rate Sarah Hanson Young from the Greens, but apparently she used the deplorable term and I think that's not not not smart. We also know in the UK where Starmer tried to chase them to the right, that's not gonna work. You've actually got to s I I think the the opportunity here for Labour, which has been deliberately cautious and centrist almost to a fault, is there is the demand from one nation is to actually be more assertive in standing up for ordinary people against the system. And it's you know, maybe with maybe if they land the the recalibration of tax they can do it, but there are other things that they can It opens the door for probably a more ambitious policy because I do think that now you're gonna be seeing the next election where of course Labour's gonna be fighting to convince people that whoever is leading the coalition, I doubt very much doubt it's gonna be Angus Taylor is not re do you reckon they'll just let him they'll feed him to the 'cause it's it's him or hasty probably. Who interestingly

speaker-0: It'll be Angus. Another year and a half till an election. A lot can happen.

speaker-1: Correct. So th anyway, th they will run that flag, but they're also gonna be, you know, having to run f contests against Greens and against One Nation, which are kind of it's gonna be a similar vibe, those seats, which is Give up on the mainstream parties because they're not looking after your interests. No, we're doing real things. So I think it it's actually gonna be a momentum for more ambition within Labor. and this idea of just occupying the center, it's it's it's got them two terms, but I think the third term is gonna ask more of them than that. Yeah.

speaker-0: Because those two terms have been in increasingly fewer primary votes, right? Which is an indicator of where people put them. So

speaker-1: the fragmentation.

speaker-0: Yeah, so that's that's a key thing. I mean, the Labour in the UK did an interesting job with the new Labour, right? Where they did their h kind of whole reinvention of this is not your dad's Labour, there's a whole new thing. So there are blueprints out there for how you can stay the same party but reinvent yourself. I don't know if you can do it while you're in government, right? 'Cause as you know, like the the big issue is you you're an outsider for for this long, you know, banging on the windows going, Everything's wrong. If we had our chance we'd do everything differently. All right, here's your chance. Chance, you spend six to nine months learning where the furniture is, you know, where the where the phones are, what extension to print, like all that kind of stuff. And by that point, people are going, so what have you done for me? And you go, all right, well, we've now finally found our feet. Labor obviously spent a lot of that political capital at that point with the voice referendum, going, we're gonna do a big thing, flat on its face for many different reasons, which we won't get into here. And then you go, All right, well now what are you gonna do? They go, All right, well we'll take it a bit slower. We're not gonna do huge amounts of changes and suddenly three years have passed, three and a half years have passed, and you go

speaker-1: So a sign of how much of a non-insider I am. I don't actually know if they've got a strategy in it in the PMO at the moment.

speaker-0: My understanding is there isn't, not n not a similar one, from my knowledge of the PMO.

speaker-1: And the mail I get is that Albo still runs a lot of it himself. He brings journos direct, he's freelancing a lot of the time. Which which

speaker-0: Which really hard because I think again, if you if you're not inside the political circle, you don't know, but when you're in opposition, you don't get a lot of resources at your disposal. You have a handful of staff, but but you're everything, right? You're you're basically like a small business where you have to do the books, you have to do the this, that and the other, you don't have big researchers. When you're in government, you have the instrument of the commonwealth behind you. If you need something, there are departments with tens of thousands of people that can help you get there. So

speaker-1: But also say I don't think that's a good idea on everything you wanna do. Exactly. So it's both it's both a Yeah, it it it's ⁓ a facilitator of doing things and also a handbraker.

speaker-0: Yeah. It's ⁓ lot of sense checking. Rightly or wrongly. A huge hammer. But my point is that like for someone like Albanese, who spent so long as an outsider being ev putting every hat on, to then be in power and realise you're not that anymore. All you are now, you're just the talent. We actually need you to step the hell and you know, Scott was guilty of this as well. It's like we need you to step the hell back from trying to figure everything out yourself. Why was he

speaker-1: like because I've got the feeling like this is my take on Yeah I this is my take on Morrison that he once he got in it was a shit show. Shorten was gonna win he just said I'm like literally I'm the marketing guy. I I'm the one person that can pull this off and he mastered that period of visual image he he called himself Scomo. He made himself likeable for a period

speaker-0: Yeah. This is what they all do, right? Al Albo got the round glasses, he lost the like they all do this. There's a Julia got the new haircut. Yeah.

speaker-1: But then but then in power. And he's so he he he did that ⁓ no he was already in power. Sorry, I'm talking rubbish. So he was already in power. But what was

speaker-0: Like without giving too much. No, that's like what was the matter misnomers is because he worked for Tourism Australia and because it stuck, Scotty from Marketing did really well anyway. Was that the pedestrian ⁓ no, ⁓ I don't think it was. I think it was actually pedestrian. Yeah. So Scott is more of a economics guy than a marketing guy.

speaker-1: Very good. Potato guys? Right.

speaker-0: And that will probably tell you everything you need to know about the difference between the persona because as you know, all of these guys have a public persona and that is very different from the person, right? The persona of Scott was a

speaker-1: Who's driving the Sharky stuff?

speaker-0: Probably ten thousand focus groups and twenty thousand consultants and

speaker-1: if it is because I think a lot of the time having done the focus groups you don't that styling stuff like that tends to be just it doesn't come out of a group it's just like

speaker-0: Sometimes it does. Not all of it, but sometimes it does. But there's usually someone there's usually one or two consultants who come up and go, We need to clean up your image a little bit, we need to, you know, tidy up the eyebrows, give you better glasses, you need to lose a bit of weight. But but you know what I mean? Like you always have those things of like, you know, Julia Gillard when she ran, she you know, changed the hairstyle and the look and all that. And the thing is Pauline

speaker-1: Are you talking to me here? 'Cause I'm making no Yeah, like which anyway.

speaker-0: Has always been Pauline. Yeah. So Hansen has always been the small business lady, fish and chips shop owner, who said it like she is with the bright red hair. Like, I don't think she takes cues from consultants. Whereas both of the parties now have such a and you we're part of it, but like you have this ecosystem of consultants behind them that's trying to tweak and optimize every single part of it that you lose the authenticity. And you go, Well, is the politician to blame or is it the thirty consultants?

speaker-1: So let's just before we go to Kiss of Death, how the rise of Hansen, ⁓ in the context of the way politics is done at the moment, w what's that gonna force the the the the major parties to do? Not so much in policy but in the way they connect. So I and I'll shout out to Ed Coper who's a a colleague on my side of politics, he's written a terrific book called Angertainment. I know you've got a copy of it as well. And a lot of people have focused on his analysis of how anger drives the algorithm, which is like yesterday's news. What I thought was interesting was his formulation for how you respond to that, which is his acronym be nice, which is don't which is an acronym of behavior, narrative, ideas acrostic. But the big thing was that don't don't try to tell people they're wrong, meet them where they are, which is kind of basic politics, but also use the culture to do it. Don't try to sort of force people back into your work.

speaker-0: It's it but this is marketing one ⁓ one stuff, right? Which I think a lot of politicians don't know because they've never done it is you have to meet the market for knowledge. There's no point like the worst thing you could ever try to do is educate people or be like, No, no, you need to be better or you need to be more civil or this, that and the other. Is then you meet them for knowledge and then you gently push them in the direction you nudge them towards where you want them to be. I don't know that either party's gonna learn the lessons from Pauline because she's moving at a pace that is much too fast for them because she has the advantage of being a small mover and they don't.

speaker-1: How much is and I I I don't know the answer to this question, but how much of her momentum is being driven by Gina Money and Republican consultants? Do we know?

speaker-0: I don't think we know. I would say my guess would be that so her team, who's been there for a while, James Ashby, her chief of staff, is a extremely good operator and has been for many years, adding Barnaby into the tent, who is a seasoned political operator and an extraordinarily good retail politician. If you think about all the stuff Barnaby's done been through, he's been our deputy PM multiple times. Like he gets people to vote for him and he gets people to listen, even though On the face of it, there's many other people we should be listening to that isn't Barnaby.

speaker-1: like they've also through Barnaby and his partner who's part of the News Limited, Eco S they've almost brung Sky News and the worst elements of News Limited across with them to the cause now.

speaker-0: Well, like you said, right, the engurtainment stuff. If it bleeds it leads. So if if people wanna watch Pauline, like any media, Murdoch media, any media is gonna give it

speaker-1: Pauline Gh.

speaker-0: It's there's a reason why Ted O'Brien didn't get a lot of headlines. It's not because he's not a nice guy. It's because it's Ted O'Brien, right? He's he's the he's not fun to listen to. ⁓ and I think Pauline is because she then stuffs up because she says silly the same reason Bob Cattery is

speaker-1: So angertainment will work for getting people to say the systems fuck, the system's the system I don't know if we can put that on YouTube. But is it gonna work but it is also gonna drive the backlash against some of her

speaker-0: Potentially policies. Potentially. But th then that's weighed up against people's anger at the institutions, right? So we need to f like peop the parties need to figure out which one outweighs which one more at the moment. And I think that's ⁓

speaker-1: I think the onus is on both of the major parties to say if you don't like the status quo, you're not electing us to maintain th and then there is a real contest of ideas. And I I feel like they haven't I I know that the best part of Labour believes they are in government to shift things in favor of ordinary

speaker-0: But what Pauline knows and what Barnaby knows and what Trump knows and what all these people know is people hate eating vegetables. But if you wrap it in bacon, they'll gobble it down, right? People come for the personalities. I mean, what did Pauline do after that press club? She changed her profile photo on her Instagram to the photo that get up used on the poster, right? That's a personality. That's someone who's happy to take the piss out of themselves and not take it too seriously. Yeah. Try getting Ted O'Brien to do that. Try getting you know, Jason Clare to have that level of a sense of humor or Chris Bowen. Like they they take themselves so seriously that they disconnect with their

speaker-1: Who do you reckon the funniest person on your side of politics is, out of interest? So she's

speaker-0: ⁓ Jane Hume. Genuine cracker. I mean Jane and Tim would probably be the two up there. Tim is like will take the piss out of himself more than anyone. Jane has that kind of dry wit, but I think they're the two funniest. What about on yours? I'm struggling. There's gotta be someone with a sensitivity. Ed Husick's not that bad. He he like he takes a piss out of himself, doesn't take himself too seriously now.

speaker-1: Now that he's outside. ⁓ When the stakes are high, you you know, but particularly on and I was doing a one of my my joys is that I'm a long term client as the SDA. So I went up to Newcastle, their national executive, and did a presentation and we were talking about One Nation and they one of them said, Why isn't the leftette funny anymore? And it was because as soon as you crack a joke, you're offending somebody and and humor and this is the the difficulty outside like the progressive side of politics. Humor the last bit of humor was probably Bob. hawk sculling beers like 30 years ago because if you if you take the piss you you are roadkill and it's really it's damaging because you know back to Ed Coper's point like the only way you beat anger is with humor and empathy. But if you can't be funny and everything's within the constraints of I don't want to offend that person

speaker-0: It's amazing. It's just And when you're in politics and you're at the top, you you're not allowed to punch down. You can only punch sideways or up. Which is why it works for Pauline, 'cause she's an outsider. So she's punching sideways or up at the establishment. If she becomes the establishment, she won't be able to do that.

speaker-1: A and that's the thing with those please explain videos which we go on about, they make th they they're definitely punching up.

speaker-0: Yeah, they have to. Yeah. But like during the SCOMO PMO, one of my favorite bits that we ever did and one of the best performing pieces of media or content we ever did was a video with the Sushi Mango guys, which was entirely humor based. W but we only did one. But it was Scott taking the piss out of himself to a large degree, right?

speaker-1: I think that ukulele on ⁓ sixty minutes wasn't better.

speaker-0: Yeah, to be funny. I I think a lot of people got a lot of value out of that one, but I think you're right. Like politics in Australia has lost its sense of humor and when you do that it makes it really hard to deflate the fact that people are genuinely struggling out there.

speaker-1: God. But also amplifies the bad like there like, you know, it is like our our right track, wrong track is worse than it's ever been in like fifteen years of polling. Like is that it's in the twenties the number of people that think the country and we are still one of the wealthiest countries of on earth in the wealthiest moments in human history. And it's all

speaker-0: Yeah. And we feel like that. So we're in the one percent of the one percent of the one percent and we feel like things are going to hell.

speaker-1: 'cause that's what we get in our feed every day. Anyway, what do you reckon? Should we go into Kiss of Death? Have you

speaker-0: Yeah, so firstly I'd like to proudly say that my kiss of death last week of ⁓ Australia doing well against Turkey came true, so I'm very, very happy to hear that.

speaker-1: Good, good, good. what what's what's what what are you gonna put to the sword this?

speaker-0: I'm curious and I have a feeling the AFP are going to either press charges or make some c take some kind of action against get up next week. For what happened at the Pauline Hansen press conference. I think they're gonna make an example of it.

speaker-1: Be the first time. my kiss of death is going to be that I think that the the Senate questioning of KPMG is going to have a longer shelf life. So that was today. I know that your colleague Matt Rowley is all over this with your concept of societal capital. Go to General Strategic and you can see what he's talking about. but so this is we've had PWC now KPMG talking about the way.

speaker-0: EY in there somewhere. ⁓

speaker-1: This ridiculous notion that you can have auditing firms that are also giving general advice to corporate also general advice to government. So the whole thing. But my my my mail is that the the focus is gonna move from individual you know ⁓ consultancies to the whole sector and I think that will be interesting. I don't know if happen in the next seven days, but it's definitely something that's gonna happen.

speaker-0: ⁓ I'm very fascinated to watch that. as always it's been an enjoyable chat.

speaker-1: doing a one-on-one every now and then. We'll get a guest back next week. If people have got suggestions of people they'd like to see having a drink, just drop it in LinkedIn or Substack or the little places that we live.

speaker-0: Happy to talk to interesting people. So if there's someone you're dying to hear from, we'll happily get them on the show. If you haven't already, please subscribe to this channel wherever you're watching it, whether it's on YouTube, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Podcasts, or anywhere else. Share it with someone if you think someone would enjoy it. Leave a comment and tell us how we're doing because we don't really know. And we're hoping to hear back from you. Otherwise, we will see you again next week. Cheers.