Episode 12
Unions, Victorians, and Stefanovics
With Danae Bosler
Show notes
We discuss the Brisbane vibe, then dig into unions and collective bargaining in the workplace. We discuss Victoria's upcoming election, some of the controversy and the fallout it caused, the disunity and public opinion of the Liberal Party, the rise of One Nation and its influence, how public perception and politics have shifted post-lockdown, the role of billionaires in policy, and the risk that long-term government poses to democracy.
We dig into the risks and challenges of a fourth-term government, Australia's political shift to the right, the rise of podcasting and media influence, our predictions and political insights.
We also cover the impact of a Liberal government on workers and renewable energy projects, the role of freedom of speech and platform accountability, the influence of money and sponsorship in podcasting, and the events we're anticipating in the political landscape.
Chapters
- 00:00 Cheers to Brisbane
- 23:23 Victorian State Election
- 29:23 One Nation's Growth and Political Implications
- 38:59 Billionaires, Policy, and Public Opinion
- 46:11 Australia's Political Shift to the Right
- 55:33 Predictions and Political Insights
Full transcript
Read itHide it
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.
Peter LewisWelcome to What's Your Poison? The show where people who disagree on just about everything agree that it's best to do so over a drink. My name's Peter Lewis. I'm the principal of the Progressive Strategy Shop. Essential. Joining me is my evil twin, the principal at General Strategic and a man who lives for the next Liberal Party fundraiser, Darmay Dobzhianovsky. Hello, mate. I know you're back from a great week. in Brisbane for the budget where you were even sucking on a Forex, which I think is the first time I've seen you actually drink beer. Tell us about that and also tell me what your poison is this week.
Damian DamjanovskiI I'll good to see you, Peter. Always good to see you after a long week. And I had actually never tried a Forex before. ⁓ and I was stuck in a situation where there was a craft beer and a Forex, but there was no bottle opener, so I had to go for the Forex because it was a twist top. ⁓ and it was remarkably good. I was very refreshing. So I was ⁓ very pleasantly surpr surprised by the Forex. So thank you to the
Peter LewisAnd how is life in the vanguard of the LNP?
Damian Damjanovski⁓ pretty good. I mean, look, if you're in Queensland at the moment, I think there's a odd vibe in Brisbane, which I would describe as an optimism that seems to be lacking in Sydney and especially Melbourne at the moment. Like, even just walking around the streets and talking to people in Brisbane, there definitely seems to be an optimism. I don't think it's Olympics related. There just seems to be a better disposition happening up there at the moment. And I'm gonna put that down to an LMP government, really. Like
Peter LewisWhen you feel it, eat. Nothing like locking up young children to get everyone feeling better about the world.
Damian DamjanovskiBetween Chris Offli Janetsky, this is what happens when you put WOGS in charge of a state, good things happen, right? We had it here under Berigiclian, we had it under Perite. When Woggs are in charge of a state, good things happen.
Peter LewisVery good.
Damian DamjanovskiThat said, this week I'm leaning into my inner bogan and I am doing a Southern Comfort mixed with full cream Coca-Cola. So digging into my youth. What is your poison this week, Mr. Lewis?
Peter Lewis⁓ it's neat, I want a bit of coke. ⁓ I've just got something from up the road at the Milton Hotels in-house brewery up the back, a Crispy Boy Lager. So at the end of a really good week, the highlight for me was hosting a small meal at a hotel in Glebe the other night with Bishop ⁓ Tony Percy to talk about the encyclical and the Pope's work. And I got a group of people in tech and politics and the Catholics having a bit of a yarn. And it was, was a terrific night done over again. a drink and people from across the aisle sharing some ideas. I didn't invite you because you're too pro-AI, but I'll invite you to the next one.
Damian DamjanovskiThat would have been fantastic. ⁓ I d I don't know if I'm too pro AI, but I'm definitely pro AI. And now, Peter, you've got a very interesting guest that I'm I'm excited to chat to this week. Tell us a little bit about Danai ⁓ before she tells us a little bit about herself.
Peter Lewisanyone on there. Yeah, So what can I tell you about Danai? So Assistant Secretary of the Victorian Trades Hall Council, for some reason unions named their most powerful people after people in the typing pool from the 70s. And ⁓ maybe we can understand a bit more about why, but Danai is also one of the leading strategists for the upcoming Victorian election in the union movement. and a woman who liberally calls people comrade. And I'm sure she'll share that honorific with you if you'll accept it as well, But hi, ⁓ Dene and Dame. How are you and what's your poison?
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Thanks for having me comrades. I'll go straight to it. I'm actually double parked, but don't take that the wrong way. I like to sometimes start with a cup of tea as well as a Shiraz. So I've got a Victorian Shiraz on the go separately. I'll have, I'll drink from them with the tea. Well, I just, it's, you know what it's like. You say that things are good up in Brisbane, but I just say it's the weather.
Peter LewisWith the tape. With the tape.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Like that's all that's going on right now. The weather's nicer in Brisbane than it is in Melbourne. So I need a little bit of tea to warm up first and then I'll move to the Victorian Shiraz.
Damian DamjanovskiYou can't hang on, you can't you can't resign all of Victoria's issues that have been getting worse and worse over the past decade to purely weather based events. Because I'm pretty sure during the gold rush when Melbourne was at its heyday on a global scale, the weather was even worse than it is at the moment. So I don't think it's purely a weather based thing, but I applaud the effort. I applaud the effort, absolutely. And I applaud being double parked. for so
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Thank you for letting me. Mm.
Peter LewisDamn right.
Damian DamjanovskiI'm Dana, I'm not a union guy, as you might be able to guess, having not only served in a coalition in a coalition minister's office, but also just not being of that colour. Gimme the elevator pitch because I remember when I was a kid, when I worked at Kmart, I got compulsorily signed up for the SDA. Separate to that, I've never had any involvement or compulsion to ever join or participate in a union. And to be perfectly honest, I'm actually genuinely still surprised that people these days do basically get involved with unions. Tell me about it.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Mm. Yeah, let me talk you through it. Well firstly, union membership's actually ticking up for the first time in a long time in Australia, which is ⁓ really great to see. The majority of union members, the millions of union members in Australia, kind of look like me. ⁓ For those listening, I'm a middle-aged woman. So middle-aged women is the type set for union members. So it's overwhelmingly nurses, teachers, the community sector. ⁓ people that work in public services or community services is what matters here. And to use an analogy which I hate to use because I Peter is going to come to it later but we might end up talking about soccer slash football. We always do better when we're on a team. Like a collective effort. I know that the world is turning towards individualism now and maybe that's your jam leaning into I can get ahead better on my own and that I can negotiate a better deal on my own, but overwhelmingly and in large workplaces still, you're not going to negotiate a better deal on your own. And EBAs consistently, so enterprise bargaining agreements, which are negotiated by unions, and this is data that came out this year out of the federal department, so this isn't data from me. the best pay rises are still being won under EBAs. It's not under the award, it's not under individual negotiations. The best pay rises are still being won under EBAs. So ⁓ if you're not a top-notch lawyer who can negotiate your own deal and negotiate your own bargain, ⁓ you're better off in a union along with the millions of other Australians that choose to join a union so that they can... have a better deal at work. And it's not just about your pay rises, you guys would know, it's about your jobs, your conditions and all of the things that are associated with it. And there's the world, the world of works constantly changing workplace surveillance, AI, Peter and I have had long conversations about AI in the workplace. And I probably land somewhere in the middle of you two actually, to be fair, because I know Peter's a bit of a Luddite on some of this. So proudly so, proudly. So
Peter LewisProudly out. Proudly out.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: You know, there's so much change happening in the workplace and unions need to be there because workers want us there.
Damian DamjanovskiThat's it.
Peter LewisSo, Damai, are you a union hater or are you a union, I don't get it, because I've got this theory that people who have come from a background in Eastern Europe, which is your background I know, have a natural reticence to large scale collective structures because you grew up under the Soviet. I know you came very young, but is it a cultural...
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Hmm.
Peter Lewispush against collectivism? Why do you ⁓ hate us?
Damian DamjanovskiAll right, let me take a minute to un unpack unpack that. ⁓ firstly, just for as a point of clarity, Yugoslavia was never under the Soviet yoke. Yugoslavia was proudly a founder of the non-alignment treaty along with Egypt and India. So we were never a Soviet country. We sh we had a partially socialist, partially capitalist system under ⁓ Marshall Tito. That aside. ⁓
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Mm. Mm.
Damian DamjanovskiYou might remember that wonderful meme from Mad Men if you've ever watched it, where ⁓ one of the guys walks into the elevator ⁓ with John Hamm and goes, I feel sorry for you. And John Ham turns to turns to him and says, I don't even think about you. ⁓ that's probably where I sit on the union front where I think ⁓ Dan, I completely understand where you're coming from and respect that there's this like strong
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Hmm.
Damian Damjanovskinegotiating power of the collective when it comes to certain industries. Where I get lost is when I hear the ACTU pushing ALBO for another voice referendum, this, that, and the other, I go, what's this got to do with it? My understanding of unions is, as Dani and very, very articulately went through there, is it's the ability to collectively bargain for a better pay. Okay, I get that. But all the other issues that come into it, I go, ⁓ you lost me.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Hmm.
Peter LewisWould you like to explain solidarity to Dame or should I, Dana? Why don't you have a crack?
Danae Bosler, VTHC: ⁓ When it comes to solidarity, we recognise now that, and for the vast majority of our union members, they actually want us involved in the broader social justice issues as well too. Unions have always been deeply involved in social justice issues. I was talking about it today, we have Hanging Up on the Wall at Trades Hall, a picture of Nelson Mandela. One of the first things Nelson Mandela did when he... was freed was come to Australia, come to Melbourne, come to meet with unions in Melbourne, because it was unions in Melbourne who were part of the movement to change and stand in solidarity with workers in South Africa rising up and Nelson Mandela being freed. like unions have had a long history of being involved in global movements, in global solidarity, in... freedom and in peace I would say and our members still overwhelmingly ask us to do that like I'll be honest it's our members who are like hey we need to stand up on this we need to speak up on this what are we I'm getting calls from union members all the time asking me to do more you know
Peter LewisAnd is that partly because there were so few structures left, like we're such an individualized society. unions have declined significantly from the 80s. was 60 % of the workforce. I think you're struggling to get, you know, high double figures or teens now. So people have voted with their feet, but there's also been this huge pressure away from collectivism, right?
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah. Yeah. And the percentage numbers I find really hard to like, averages just don't work in this kind of sector. Like if you're talking about the nurses, they're at 95%, do know what I mean? If you're talking about teachers, they're at more than half as well too. And then other sectors of the workforce, just, a union might not even be present.
Peter LewisThanks
Danae Bosler, VTHC: you know, small business in a whole bunch of those places, unionism just might not be present at all in those places. And I think we've still got work to do there. So the averages of where unionism lands in the middle kind of doesn't feel like it sits right. But, you know, that's my first response to that one.
Damian DamjanovskiSo but d d do unions feel like they still have this to to Peter's point, obviously it's gone down from, you know, high sixties to to the low teens kind of thing. And yes, there might be a an uptick, so it's you know, that's a given, but
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiDo unions still feel like they have this kind of place in the public dialogue around how we're shaped? Like ⁓ the reason I brought up the voice thing I think it's the most recent thing that I saw from the ACTU, which is hey, let's pressure Albert to do another voice thing. And I go, again, as a non-union guy, I go, but we all voted on this. Like we've already decided, like, move along. Like this is the will of the people. Like this wasn't a political maneuver. It's like Australians all sat down, went to the ballot box, we made a decision. Why are you still prosecuting this?
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiIs this the unions just looking for relevance or just looking for a fight because they've got nothing to do?
Danae Bosler, VTHC: I think on the topic of the referendum, was actually goes back to what Peter was talking about. It's the solidarity element is that the comrades in the First Nations movement came to us and said, hey, we want you to stand in solidarity with us on this. And I'm kind of looking at it from a different lens because I'm in Victoria where we have had treaty, for example, and the processes of treaty down here for a much, much longer time. So it feels like a more natural ⁓ fit for us down here. But I really think. In terms of social justice, there's just not a lot of other vehicles for making change left in this country. Do you know what I mean? Like places where people get together and organise and decide we want to change a policy or we want to change something in my neighbourhood, in my city, in my country. Like it used to be, you go to your church groups and you get involved there. Like where else do people get a sense of community these days where you're hanging out with like-minded people? The internet.
Damian DamjanovskiWell, I mean the the internet, which is where which is where most people or that's where most people organize and and and drive political outcomes these days, right? Is they they do it through either, you know, if you're on the progressive side through getup, if you're on the conservative side through other vehicles, like
Peter LewisLord.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Mm.
Peter LewisBut you still need to get people together to make it work, I think. I guess my, think the fact that the unions are still strong in the public sector is revealing because that's where there has not been such an anti-agenda union agenda. And like the whole union busting was like there were industries in union busting through the 80s and 90s. Like, I don't know how prevalent they are now because I think a lot of the unions have been busted. But, you know, it One of the interesting things after you guys lost power, for instance, after a decade was that the wage profit ratio got all out of whack. And one of the things that's happened under labor, just by making little changes to the laws here and there, people had more bargaining power and real wages have actually gone up. And I think that's kind of interesting, particularly in the context of maybe something we'll talk about later, which is the rise of AI. Anyway.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: But not to poke, not to poke the bear. Do you think that we weren't? one of the huge reasons that you lost in 2007. Do you think we weren't one of the huge reasons that the last two federal elections where the Libs have lost? Union members were out in absolute force. Like I can remember when we flipped government in Victoria after one term, which is the first time it happened since the 50s, where we flipped a Liberal government labour after just one term and a bunch of Lib MPs went onto Sky and were like, there were unionists all over the polls. They were talking to people. They were at the door.
Damian Damjanovski⁓ yeah.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: I mean direct pre-poll.
Peter LewisI'm dirty.
Damian Damjanovski⁓ I I I I don't disagree. ⁓ the ability for unions to organize members is phenomenal. ⁓ and obviously, you know, union money and and union fees fees from union dues paying members flowing into the Labour Party for campaigning machines. I I do know that a lot of Labour politicians simultaneously insist that, you know, companies should stick to their knitting and not make political commentary that church groups shouldn't be involved in campaigning and
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah. Hmm.
Peter LewisHold on, hold on, The unions were the institution that created the Labor Party. It's not a transaction, it's actually a relationship and it's deeply embedded. And this is one of the advantages that Labor has got over the conservative side of politics. And again, I don't know what the end game of this looks like, but there is a structural solidity because you've got those ties into
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah.
Peter Lewisworkplaces like hospitals with nurses or schools with teachers. So it's more grounded and it's, and I know your side always says, ⁓ they've given all this money to labor, but why wouldn't they? If that is their institute and when members signed off on it and said they're cool with it and their political action.
Damian DamjanovskiTot totally. But but on a higher level, Peter, I guess what I'm saying is what it where I always get fearful of is when you have multiple ⁓ structural institutions dependent on one another, because then all those structures have a perverse incentive to continue maintaining the structures. So obviously it's in the interests of not just union members, but also unions to ensure that the workforce in a hospital remains unionized. So they are they're never going to go against their own interests, which is to maintain a union. That's how any structure works. Do you know what I mean? Like that that's the problem is that is the
Peter Lewistheir interest in the interest of the unionists. ⁓
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Hmm.
Damian Damjanovskii it's always gonna have the perverse incentive of keeping a union alive and in business.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: My only observation I was going to make here, because you mentioned church groups being on pre-poll, and I spent a lot of time with church groups on pre-poll, is when we're out hanging out at pre-poll, we're out there in our union gear with a union message, not for the political party. Because union members don't just vote Labor these days. Let's be very clear, union members vote the full spectrum as well too. And I remember being on a pre-poll for a whole week in a federal electorate that I won't name, but the Brethren were out in force there as well too. And I tell you, they're not very good organisers. Like we could have shitload better conversations than they did. So they've got a bit of work to do to be having conversations.
Peter LewisTheir main work, you got to watch them in Victoria in the last federal election, they were on the ground in New South Wales, just bullying volunteers. But that's probably a story from the day. Hey, before we go into Victorian politics, I forgot to give my hot take because I just want to, the soccer was on today, the World Cup, I think it was an LL draw. I kind of knew it was on. I thought I should watch it. I feel a bit icky watching the World Cup. And I feel it's just there is
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah. Mm. Yep.
Peter LewisYou watch it and you know that everyone in the stands is part of the 1%. You know, everyone on the field is being paid the equivalent of the GDP of a small nation. You know that it's basically being used as a fig leaf for creeping fascism in America. You know that the head of FIFA gave Trump the world peace prize. Like it just feels to me all wrong. And I know it's giving joy to people around the world.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah.
Peter Lewisbut I just can't do it at the moment. So tear me down.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah. ⁓ look, I'll lean into it, is that look, we all know FIFA is just like the most evil corporation on the face of the earth. Like I recognise that, that, you know, I can see why you feel sick about supporting FIFA. My view about it though, is that it is one of the, it's one of the sports that is most globally played. Like it is just played in so many countries. And the other thing about soccer slash football is it's very accessible. It's a really accessible sport and you see it being played by kids. millions of kids all over the world. So that I love and that I lean into. And yes, it was a nil or draw, but I think that means we came second. And so we're progressing through to the next round. And so I should say congratulations to the Socceroos who are all members of all keen listeners. And I'm sure particularly they'll be tuning in now. And so we should say congratulations to the Socceroos, all members of well of the Professional Footballers Association. So they are union members too. So a shout out to them.
Peter LewisI, a royal cane, listens to what you're poisoned as well, so that's
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: many sports players are union members too. I had to get that in there. I had to get that in there.
Damian DamjanovskiI I that's a it's a good one, Dana. If you can ⁓ if you can get a spruok in there, that's fantastic. I Peter, I I get where you're coming from, but I think this is a disease of all professional sports, which is when there's a lot of money involved, especially when it comes to sponsorships and television rights, there much like unions, there's gonna be corruption when there's a lot of money involved, as we all know and have seen.
Peter LewisWould you look for the guy in the back?
Damian DamjanovskiBut the beautiful game is the beautiful game for a reason. It is a global game where as long as you got a ball and a piece of grass roughly the size of a pitch. I mean, you know, kids in Serbia were playing it while they were getting bombed in NATO kind of thing. Like this is a game that transcends language, boundaries, race, religion. ⁓ I get
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah.
Peter LewisMm.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiI get the ick of at a higher professional level, it feels a bit gross because there are kids there getting paid stupid amounts of money to play a game. But the reason they're getting paid stupid amounts of money is we all wanna watch them. They've they've
Peter Lewisbring joy. This isn't the first time I've done this too, I haven't told you this. In 2000 I boycotted the Sydney Olympics because I was outraged at the corruption of the IAEA and I campaigned against the Sydney Olympics back in like four or five years later and remember like that night when it was Sydney I said I'm gonna fucking I'm gonna leave the country when it's on and I followed through no one else did I followed through and I dragged my poor wife
Danae Bosler, VTHC: We're feeding the machine. Yeah.
Peter Lewisaround Europe and then I remember on the opening ceremony we're in this little Italian village and everyone was you know gathered around the screens. just remember thinking to myself you are such a dickhead. So because I was sticking to my principles I was sticking to my principles at my own detriment and I feel like I'm probably going to do the same thing with this World Cup although I don't think you guys are going to be talking about us winning the World Cup finally in time soon like it'll be the next round it out won't it?
Danae Bosler, VTHC: you
Damian DamjanovskiWhy would you boycott the Sydney Olympic I I was a volunteer there, I was a kid.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah. And like not to get down the rabbit hole, but there's no such thing as ethical consumption under capitalism. So just lean in and watch the soccer. If you wanna watch the soccer, watch it.
Damian DamjanovskiProbably in the knockout round, yeah. Depending on who it goes against. Well, it's it's that you you have to accept the fact that ⁓ again, like in politics, like there is going to always be a percentage of corruption or disrepute that is part of the system. That's just ⁓ it's shrinkage in the system.
Peter LewisYeah.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Hmm.
Peter LewisBut aren't you defined by the lines where you draw the lines? And maybe I'm drawing them in self-defeating places, but I still like the fact that I'm able to draw lines. don't know. Anyway, let us move on to Victoria,
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Mm.
Peter LewisI don't follow Victorian politics very closely. What's going on down there?
Danae Bosler, VTHC: ⁓ There's been it's been a big week down here. I would say it's a big week every week in Victoria, but there was an incident this week between Moira Deeming and Matthew Guy who have a long history that would take hours and hours to unpack. So I'm not going to go down that rabbit hole of unpacking that. But Moira did claim and took a matter that was at a public community event that they were both at and reported it to the police. And I think also
Damian DamjanovskiSorry, a Macedonian community event. ⁓
Danae Bosler, VTHC: ⁓ sorry. ⁓ thank you. Sorry, comrade. I stand corrected.
Peter LewisDo have any inside mail here, Dharmak? Do have any inside mail?
Damian DamjanovskiSorry? No, no, it was a it was a youth Macedonian church community event.
Peter LewisRight, so what happened?
Danae Bosler, VTHC: ⁓ There was a, what has been shown on CCTV footage which came out rapidly I would say after the news dropped within about a couple of hours there's some CCTV footage and Moira Deeming had alleged that Matthew Guy had I think sexually harassed her as well too or sexually assaulted her and the footage showed a staff member sitting in between the two of them and that Matthew Guy leaned around and put an arm around her. There's also photos that they potentially took together on the night that I've seen have come out since then. But it just speaks to, it's Moira, mate. Yes, yes, thank you so much. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And there's been a long running dispute over between the two of them went to court six months ago, I wanna say now they went to court and Moira won it. ⁓ So she's been able to, yeah, yeah.
Peter LewisSo what's the backstory on Maura Daeming? She was a trans lady?
Damian DamjanovskiI wouldn't call her a trans lady.
Peter LewisNo, anti-trans, like women are women. So what's the elephant? Yeah. she's back on the tame, like full of stereo.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, so she c she she got ⁓ I think I don't think she was expelled from the party, but she she definitely got demoted or or iced out. Yeah, so basically there was a there was some kind of anti trans rally happening that wasn't necessarily well, I mean, it was anti trans, but Moira was talking on the perspective of the rights of ⁓ women to feel secure. I think it was in
Peter LewisAnd didn't she sue one of their opposition leaders? Who was that guy?
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah. Mm.
Damian Damjanovskisporting change rooms or something. So so her stance is basically ⁓ if you're a, you know, a natural born woman, that you should feel safe going to a women's change room and feeling sure that there's not going to be, you know, trans men being women, however you want to label that, in there, right? So that's that's the kind of protection that she's ⁓ advocating for. ⁓ and then I think that ⁓ I believe that Rally then got ⁓ usurped by neo-Nazis or something like that happened, and then she got pulled into that, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. So yeah. ⁓ and so the party kind of iced her out. Moira then sued, won, and now she made this claim against Matthew Guy saying that he sexually assaulted her. ⁓ her account of the event and
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah, the company you keep, yeah. Mm.
Damian Damjanovskiwhat was seen on the C C T V footage might be slightly different. ⁓ and the police have basically cleared him.
Peter LewisAnd so how's that going to play out? So how's that going to play out in the context of the upcoming election? Like it looks like it's a house in turmoil.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Well. Well, yeah, to me it just speaks to a broader story of just a long, long narrative of disunity in that party, right? Like huge disunity in that party where five months out from an election and this is unfolding, but not my side of the fence.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, I'd I'd I'd add to ⁓ Dani's kind of view there that Given the current opinion polling, and Peter, you can you can maybe ⁓ shed more light on this than I can, but the the Labour Party's definitely on the nose when it comes to Victoria. They've had a, you know, a very long, long stint of Dan Andrews followed by a very not so successful stint by Jacinta Allen. ⁓ there's definitely an appetite for change ⁓ and a change of colour. I think ⁓ Jess and the team down there have done a pretty good job of kind of keeping to the line, but they've got a few outlier.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Hmm. Mm.
Damian Damjanovskimembers like Moira who seem to be intent on bringing the whole House down with them ⁓ and they're gonna have to deal with that. I mean we're still well October's the election down there, so we're still a f a few months away. Most Victorians probably haven't quite turned their attention to the election yet. ⁓ but they probably will be come August, September.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah.
Peter LewisJust out of interest, do you reckon Moira is a good faith actor who passionately believes in an issue and it's just got out of hand or has been cynically manipulating for her own?
Damian DamjanovskiHonestly, I think this is kind of one of the and we've talked about this on the show before. I think this is one of the perpetual issues of the Liberal Party at the moment, which is It's trying to figure out if it's a center right party or a far right party. And I think on both sides you have good faith actors who deeply believe different things. The more redeeming types who believe that the only way f the only pathway back for the party is to firmly be a ⁓ center right, like to be a far right party is at odds with ⁓ you know, the other good faith actors who believe that they need to be closer to the center. ⁓ and I think they both deeply believe that their pathway is the only pathway back for coalition governments across the country. Personally, I I do believe they're both wrong. I think it it has to be a broad church. That's the only way the coalition has ever worked in this country, is as a broad church. It is the only way it can work, is if it can stretch from the middle out to the right. That's that's what the Liberal Party is and has always been since the time. Yeah.
Peter LewisSo, Dono, what's the pendulum like there and are the libs, my impression was the libs were a bit of a rump, but are they in the game?
Danae Bosler, VTHC: I'm just...
Damian Damjanovski⁓ they're definitely in the game though. I they've they've got the they've got the it's theirs to lose basically at this point.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah. So the most recent polling that I saw, and this is just statewide, so it's not in fine, fine granular ⁓ detail. We've got some of that polling coming through, but not yet. Yeah, has the libs in the primary position on about 30%. So got libs in the strongest position there. The thing I'd say is that Labor needs to lose 15 seats in the lower house, that is. So like it is a massive swing that needs to occur. And can I see the Labor losing 15 seats and Libs picking up 15 seats and not losing any of their seats, absolutely no way, not on the face of this earth, not when you've got one nation chomping away at the far right way more than it's chomping away at the far left. We will come to that because we will come to the conversation, not the far left, know, chomping away at the far right. We'll come to that conversation shortly. But like I can see the Nats, the Nats who are propping up the Libs in Victoria. can lose a lot of seats to One Nation. Like, regional Victoria, you think they're cranky in Melbourne, you should go to regional Victoria. Like, they are, they're...
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. And and and One Nation has been the the black swan event that the coalition has been convinced is never going to happen for the past ten years. We've we've reached that black swan event now where, you know, South Australia, it wasn't a non-start. I like they're still they still got some momentum and you know, One Nation picked up some seats and centers, but Victoria's, I think, now that One Nation's in full swing, so to speak, the Gina money's started pouring in. We're seeing their campaigning mechanism get better and better. We're seeing a lot of people, like 77,000 people donating to their ⁓ what is it, Fire the Liar campaign recently. That's a lot of small donors. That is a huge number of small donors and a lot of people who probably have never given to a political party before, giving 50, 60, 70 bucks.
Peter LewisMmm.
Damian DamjanovskiHow that translates into votes in Victoria is going to be a really interesting test for Albanese for a federal election, but will definitely affect the outcome for Victoria.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah.
Peter LewisSo it's interesting, like from a distance, ⁓ and I've been Sydney based, particularly through the pandemic, you guys had one of the most brutal lockdowns on earth. ⁓ It seems to me a lot of the libertarian and right-wing movements have come out of the anti-lockdown movement. I'm interested in your sense of how real that is on the ground ⁓ and how much that ⁓
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah. Yeah, yeah.
Peter Lewisthat trauma that you went through, which I think is a fair description of it, is still shaping the way politics plays out in Victoria.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Mmm. Yeah, I'd say a couple of things, which is firstly that the last state election was November 2022. that was the back end of the COVID period. By November 2022, we were all right. And Labor was overwhelmingly returned, smacked it in in the polls. That's the first thing I'd say. And so I was really nervous about what was going to be the consequences of COVID lockdown. And it turned out Victorians were actually, it's not like we, any of us enjoyed the lockdowns. Like we all hated it, but we all did. did it because we knew that we had to and that we were saving people's lives. I've got a diabetic uncle, I've got a cousin with cancer, like they would have not have survived through COVID, do know what I mean? So there was that appetite. And then I'm spending, what's the knock on effects now is kind of the second part of the question there, is I'm spending a huge amount of my time right now on the doors talking to workers and also on the phones talking directly to union members into the lead up to the election.
Damian DamjanovskiMm.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: And lockdown is not one of the top issues that they're talking about, right? The number one issue that people are talking about is cost of living.
Peter LewisNo, it's not that it's more than what it did to the state. I feel like I've got half my business down there and I go there and I feel like it's still more, it was more damaged than what we went.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Mm.
Damian DamjanovskiIt's it was ⁓ th there's it's really funny, Peter, I find ⁓ and you'll Dana, you'll have to excuse me for this, but I I recall forever and a day going to Melbourne meant that you had to put up with people from Melbourne selling you on Melbourne. It's this thing that everyone in Melbourne does where if you're not from Melbourne, they have to do a spiel about how great Melbourne is and how you should live there and the laneways but but
Danae Bosler, VTHC: here. mainly to people from Sydney as well too. Yeah, the Sydney people.
Peter Lewisand a younger sibling. Younger sibling.
Damian DamjanovskiIt's the it's the whole it's the younger unattractive sibling thing of like no one cares, but all right, like They all are constant tourism advocates and like living advocates for Melbourne. But after lockdowns, it changed. After lockdowns, every those conversations have turned into, ⁓ it's so terrible down here. It doesn't matter how terrible you had it anywhere else. It wasn't as terrible as Melbourne. We had the worst lockdowns, all the streets ⁓ have potholes in them. Every store is up for lease, like everything's, you know, there's machetes everywhere, the bins don't work. Like it's just this laundry list of issues, and it feels like a tail end of lockdown syndrome that just the the the state can't seem to shake for some reason.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah. Yeah. And I'm gonna lean into the fact that I'm an Assistant Secretary of Victorian Trades Hall Council and I'm not gonna take it lying down this blatant attack on Melbourne and Victoria. Like it is my job here to come in and defend this fine, fine city that is Victoria. That's actually like doing okay. I think our crime stats are better than yours in Sydney. So like, let's all just, you know, check it out. ⁓
Peter LewisYou
Damian DamjanovskiPlease. Yeah, 'cause there's stuff worth stealing up here.
Peter LewisHa ha!
Danae Bosler, VTHC: So like, I'm gonna put a little cap on it and be like, hey, chill out on Melbourne. Like, it's not that bad. It's actually a pretty grouse city. It's actually one of the most affordable cities. It's a shitload affordable than where the rest of you are as well too. And people are moving here. The Age was reporting it. You know, I was reading the Saturday Age last weekend.
Peter LewisWe do love, we love that you care about us more than we care about you. We love it.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisthink you're becoming bigger than Sydney, actually, Melbourne.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah, Sydney people are moving down here. We've got a massive intake from interstate because you guys can't afford to buy houses up there, let alone rent them. And so, you know, there is, but I do want to say, but I do want to, yeah, I do want to acknowledge, I do want to acknowledge that there's a broader mood as well too. There is a broader mood. People are globally feeling the pressure, fuel crisis, rising war, all that kind of stuff.
Damian DamjanovskiWell that's the yes, but
Peter LewisThat's a different story. Sydney's beauty is its weakness.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: the polling suggests that people are feeling more likely that the country is going in a different direction. And yes, in Victoria, that is at a higher percentage point. So I'm not going to pretend that it's not. And there's reasons for that. And we've got work to do. We've got more work to do. It's not enough doing what we've done. There's so much more to do.
Peter LewisSo, and. But you know, the grievance is what a party like One Nation latches onto. So I was asking you before we came on, so who's the One Nation leader? And they're a hit in the polls and there are no candidates. What does that mean?
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah. Yeah. They're ahead in the polls and they've got basically zero candidates. So they have one ⁓ MP in the upper house down here, Ricky Lee Terrell, and her campaign manager previously worked for her and is now kind of the state campaign lead. Campaign director, state manager is Warren Pickering, who's been around a while as well too. I did see quoted in the paper earlier this week because Pauline has been thinking about... ⁓ Helicoptering in someone potentially from the Northern Territory From Queensland there we go. Yeah. Well, I think he turned it down because he wanted to keep making billions of dollars with Hancock ⁓ Hancock industries, but she did say which is worth quoting that ⁓ she does value loyalty And so I think Ricky Lee Tyrrell and Warren Pickering who've been around for a while I assume that they'll be granted some loyalty from Pauline as well, too, but who knows?
Peter LewisWainsland.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Get a Queenslander to fix it. But this is basically people still going. I'm I'm voting for it because I'm voting for both Pauline and I'm voting against the status quo. And to be honest, ⁓ as an outsider, to me it's surprising that that Victorian Labour hasn't been able to get its act together because these numbers have been in decline for quite a while. And to see the party with all the resources of government not being able to get its act together in that time frame is always shocking. Like
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah, it's a protest vote. Yeah. For a cup, yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiYou know, the the whether it's hubris, whether it's just blindness to what's happening, I don't know what it is, but ⁓ four year fixed terms. Like there's plenty of time to to kind of fix the issues, but they just haven't seemed to be able to get their their heads around it.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Mm.
Peter LewisI, sorry.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Well, if you look at, I was just gonna say in November, One Nation was only polling at 6 % or something like that. So it really has, I would say it's come up on us like a bus, but also come up out of nowhere. Do know what I mean? Like I get, but has been building and building and building, sorry. Do you know what I mean? So like it's both things at the same time.
Peter LewisDo you feel that there's a... Do you feel One Nation is a threat to Labor seats? And if so, which parts? And then what is the conversation with, what does a campaign in a One Nation Labor contest look like to you?
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. So we've been studying it because we have seen it coming. We are worried about it. And so ⁓ we've got a report that came out earlier this year called Antidote, which is about the rise of the far right in Australia and that we think that unionism and some of the values of unionism can be the antidote to help to help tackle that. This is not new. This is not radical or anything like that. Like far right movements have been cycling through the system ⁓ both in Europe and in other parts of the world for many, many decades. But we've been particularly interested in how As we've seen in like the UK, for example, the far right starts by eating away at ⁓ the far right parties or the centre right parties. But before long, it's going to start coming and it has started coming after working class people and people that vote Labor, you might say, in Australia. And we're absolutely seeing that play out in the polling down here as well, too. And it will be in the ring. So if you picture Melbourne, it's the outer ring of Melbourne. Those suburbs.
Damian DamjanovskiWell work.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: through the outer, for people who aren't from Melbourne, the outer circle of Melbourne, but I could list suburbs, but that might not mean much. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiDan, I could I just just for clarity, how how would you in not just in your role but in your world, how would you define far right? Just so we're all on the same page when we're talking about it?
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah, to put a political party to it, it'd just be One Nation would be one of the easy ways to kind of group it. I wouldn't put the Liberal Party in that category if that's what you're...
Damian DamjanovskiNo, no, I'm I'm more curious about the ⁓ either the ideologies or the the world view that you would see as being far right. 'Cause obviously if you're on the far right, anything in the center looks like lefty lunacy to do you know what I mean? Like your where you stand shifts your perspective on where you perceive everyone else is.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah. Yeah.
Peter LewisAnd I'm not even sure if far right and far left, because I actually feel it more like there's the insider-outsider inflection now. And that's where I think, I don't think One Nation is going to drag Labour voters to the far right. I think they're actually going to get them the other way around going, this isn't working. It isn't delivering. And, know, it's interesting amongst all the things that she runs on, some of them are cultural, but the economic stuff is not far away from, you know, progressive.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Well yeah, because it th these workers are the ones being the hardest. I'm gonna ask you a follow-up question on Gina in a minute, Peter. But like Dan I was it's that th those workers are the ones being the hardest hit by and and ⁓ this is both at a state level and a federal level, right? So if you're in Victoria where you've had a Labour government in place for over a decade
Peter LewisMinus generalized business interests I might add.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiWhere you've got Albow two terms in, you go, hang on, I'm meant to be the one they're looking after, and I'm the one copying the brunt of it. So it's not hard to see why anyone who is a nurse or a teacher or any of these people going, Hey, this housing crisis thing didn't crop up overnight. You still haven't done diddly squat about it. You haven't done that much about my wages. Cause yeah, you've given me some wage rises, but inflation's gone up twice as fast. Like life is getting worse under labor, not better.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, it feels like life is getting, and people, that's what people are telling us. It feels like life is getting harder. And for many, they're saying it's for the next generation. My kids can't afford to buy a house. How are my kids gonna afford to buy a house? And I think the problem is that, is that people are looking for something, ⁓ like something big, some kind of radical change. Like I think the negative gearing and CGT, all those kinds of changes are a good thing. And it has made differences. Some of the changes that we've introduced down in Victoria. that have helped with housing prices and that have helped with renting and all that kind of stuff have made a difference, but it's so incremental. And I feel like people want something more than just incrementalism right now. And that's why the far word appeals to them, right? Like they want something that's transformational and radical and really taking,
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. 'Cause if you open up One or two new coal plants down in Victoria, power prices would come shooting right down. ⁓ that's off the agenda. Peter, I was gonna ask you before we move on, I I am gonna ask you this because we've we haven't chatted about this before ever, I don't think you and I. And and ⁓ Dana, this is open to you as well. If you were gonna work for an Aussie billionaire, who would you work for? If you had to pick one Aussie billionaire.
Peter Lewisit. Anyway.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Not even close. Not even close.
Peter LewisLike, disclosure, we for a number of years were working on a campaign on early learning that was funded by Twiggy. I've also been a little bit involved in some of his initiatives on AI. I actually got a story for another day, an invite up to Bloody Minduru. I went up to the episode of Succession. So I think, you know, if you had to choose your billionaire, he's on the side of the angels at the moment. But ⁓ I think it's a
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Mm. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiSo he's a the thinking the thinking man's billionaire.
Peter LewisI think it's a horrible world, like every billionaire is a policy failure. ⁓ It's a horrible world where social movements need to rely on billionaires to do anything. It should be members of organisations like unions that actually have the funds to do it without the strings attached.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiWhat what must you think of trillionaires in that case?
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah. Yeah. I was, was so the one that popped into my head was I can't, to be honest, don't ask me what the policy was, but a couple of months ago we put out a new policy position. was quite a, it was. ⁓
Peter LewisDon't know any. ⁓
Damian DamjanovskiDanai, do you have a do you have a
Danae Bosler, VTHC: The policy is not the key part of the story. The key part of the story is that Mike Cannon Brooks came out and sported it and like retweeted it and was sharing it. And we were all like, ⁓ now we're confused. We're confused about this, you know? There's another millionaire who I'm like, haven't met him.
Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm. Double bay Jesus has entered the picture.
Peter LewisHey, I'm just going back to the risk, the risk for labor, like labor's success in holding government makes them the status quo. And you've got a government in ⁓ Victoria now, I think it's going for their fourth term. so there's another element here too, I just want to sort of unpick. So I lived through labor successes in New South Wales, but them winning the fourth term was the worst thing that ever happened. So it had been Bob Carth for three election wins.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Comrade CG, yeah. Mmm.
Peter LewisThen there was Morris Yemmer, who no one remembers, came in and he won off the back of rights at work. Basically, it was 2007. We were running a dry run to get rid of Howard and he was the beneficiary. There was also a terrible liberal leader, guy called Peter Dedman, who promised to cut 29,000 jobs and got photographed in his smug budgie smugglers. So he was like Tony Abbott with at any of the charm. But the fourth term was just like
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Mm. Mm.
Peter LewisRome was burning, there were all these sorts of scandals, they'd had power too long. And then they got, they went through, I think three or four leaders, they went through Yemma, Nathan Rees and Christina Canelli. And then they got smashed and they were out of power for 12 years, I think. do think there is like,
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah.
Peter Lewisdemocracy needs turnover and I'm interested in your thoughts on whether a fourth term is actually what you would wish for in a perfect world.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: ⁓ I wish for a fourth term. And the other thing that makes it a risk, you know, makes it challenging. Yes, it's a fourth term government. It's a very long time since Labor has ever done that in Victoria, if ever. I also know it would be the first time a woman is elected in her own right as well as the Premier, but that's a whole nother separate.
Peter LewisIs she going to make it to the finish line there?
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yes.
Damian DamjanovskiSomeone's gotta finish that airport rail link one day in Victoria. Eventually it'll happen.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: So there's, so I think we, there's those factors. What I think about with a fourth term is that the alternative, like there's a lot of these conversations about rejuvenation in democracy and all that kind of stuff. It's okay from the cheap seats, do you know what I mean? When you're in a privileged position where you kind of get by if it's labor or liberal and you're kind of, you know what I mean? You're kind of middle-class enough that you're going to be okay either way. Let's be clear about what the consequences could be of a liberal government in this state that's being propped up by one nation. Do know what I mean? Like what that can mean for workers and what that can mean for, I know you've already taken a swipe at it, but like our renewable energy projects that are underway, 2000 apprentices that are gonna come on board in the state energy corporation and all this kind of stuff. like, I know that we're like democracy needs a little bit of rejuvenation. but also there's some great risks, like workers know what's at risk under a liberal one nation coalition government if they get up in Victoria. So I'm gonna get out there and do everything that I need to do to make that happen. also the opposition, like they are so split, right? Like the Libs is, half of the team is.
Peter LewisGo four more turns, four more turns.
Damian DamjanovskiI think ⁓ I think
Danae Bosler, VTHC: shifting far right, they've got people quitting the libs to go and help One Nation and join One Nation and then the other half of the team are fresh. You know, not a whole lot of experience in governing. Not even close.
Peter LewisMm.
Damian DamjanovskiFe I feel I feel like the Labour Party's in this perpetual, you know, Batman dark night quote of you either die a hero or live long enough to see yourself become the villain that whenever they get into power they very quickly kind of get to this like, ⁓ crap, we're the bad guys now. isn't the fact that isn't the fact that like increasingly people are, you know, polling one nation, voting one nation
Peter LewisYou
Danae Bosler, VTHC: There's always another eminy. There's always another eminy in me.
Peter LewisThe pink one.
Damian Damjanovskivoting for these ⁓ as you describe them, kind of further right candidates, isn't that evidence of the fact that ⁓ Australia is probably a bit more of a right wing country than a lot of people like to admit? It's a more conservative country than most people will admit.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: I don't know, Peter, do you want to take the first swipe at that?
Peter LewisI think it's interesting that if you look at the numbers nationally, we have had more conservative governments than progressive. But I also think that in the global framework, we've been a progressive open society up till now. I think I've always had fights with the other side and I am of my tribe, but it hasn't been existential. I don't think we're becoming a right-wing nation. I think we're actually becoming a nation that wants government to do more for ordinary people, which feels to me more like wanting to become a left-wing nation. So, but I also don't know if those binaries exist so much anymore. It's like, I still think at the inside outside frame is much more interesting. Why? mean, here in the inherent contradiction of a party of workers being inside. And I think that's the actual really difficult part.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, the in I I agree with you on the inside outside framing. I'll ⁓ I'll ask you this, ⁓ just to slightly change tack unless ⁓ Dana you wanted to chip in on that, you're very welcome to.
Peter LewisShe threw it to me.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: I did. I'm, I'm pathetically hopeful and I loved it.
Peter Lewis⁓ nice.
Damian DamjanovskiI I don't think it's not hope. I I think you you you've automatically painted being conservative as being hopeless by by definition.
Peter LewisBecause Dame is one of the most optimistic people I know it's just a different sort of optimism.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiBut d but I'm just let's not forget that it was Conservative Prime Ministers who got rid of the White Australia policy here in Australia. Like we've passed the Conservative governments have done a lot for this country. Progress is not exclusively the field of the left wing. The difference is that conservatives want considered progress rather than blind forward progress. That's the p conservative view on it.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Hmm.
Peter LewisUp until about 1996, I reckon, when they let it rip. That's my, yeah. Anyway, I wanted to move on. No, we're not going to talk tax once because I want you to talk, are you going to talk about Carl? Cause I was going to throw to you.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiLet's not get into tax changes that were very critical that happened around then. Speaking of insider outsider, well, I thought as an outsider, our our our guess our now friend, because he's a he's a podcaster now, he's not a broadcaster anymore. Karl Stefanovic ⁓ has officially left the Channel Nine Stable and is a full time podcaster. Have any of you either of listened to his podcast?
Peter LewisHoly. I've seen the snippets where he's just trying to beat the man in the t-shirt. ⁓
Damian DamjanovskiMy my favorite summary of his podcast, I can't remember where I read it, but was calling it Joe Bogan, the Joe Bogan podcast. And I thought it was just such a wonderful encapsulation.
Peter LewisYeah, I just see him as the ultimate grifter who, you know, went through the nine factory good looking guy. ⁓ I don't know what he's whether his family got him in there he got in there on its merits it's interesting him and his brother both got in there. ⁓ makes really good money being the face of an advertorial on morning television and now he's worked out he can personalize his celebrity rather than having to do it through a media company. So I don't look I don't think his podcast is like ours, Namo. He's got money behind him, like he's bought the network, like we're starting out just and he's got a totally different model right he knows.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Hmm.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. And it he's got a funded business that has V C funding and
Peter LewisHe's got a fund of business and his model is anger and outrage, which is kind of the opposite of what we're trying to do here as well. And we don't have any sugar daddies pushing for unity across the aisle. If you're interested, please. Yeah, yeah, exactly. ⁓ Yeah, we'll be up for the McKinney political prize next year. But ⁓ I just think it's like he is, he,
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiNot yet. Mr Forrest, ⁓ I'm happy to pass on my pay ID details.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Get in touch.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Hmm.
Peter LewisIt is not about ideas, it's not about freedom of speech, as he's saying, although I'll be interested in your thoughts on that. It's a shill. It's about finding a way to amplify himself without having the pre-made networks of legacy media to make a buck.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Mm-mm.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, it's it's taking the bumpers off the bowling lane for him, right? He can say whatever the hell he wants and cause as much outrage. The the freedom of speech thing is nuts because he th the government is not trying to stop his political free speech. Like he he was an Atwheel employee of a company, he has a contract in place. So I don't buy into that. I do find it he is definitely tapping into a vein that exists in Australia. ⁓ which is kind of why I was asking about the, you know, are we creeping further and further to the right?
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah. Yeah.
Peter LewisYes, sir.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiBecause that is a very rich vein that he and Pauline Hansen and the ⁓ Please Explain cartoons, and there's a lot of groups tapping into this vein. And from everything I've seen in the in the polling, that vein is growing and the progressive vein is rapidly shrinking. And that's that's my question to both of you is why do we think that is? ⁓ I mean, you know, we've we've had at a federal level. Four and a half years of, you know, progressive government that at the moment the verdict is haven't done much for me.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: the topic of Carl, I don't know, Peter, if you want to go first on the topic of Carl, I just think it's just a money-making machine. It's a money-making tactic. that's, it's, he's gone out. If you're gonna leave one tent to set up your own tent, you do it in absolute fireworks and he's done a great job of it, right? Like we're all talking about it on a Friday afternoon. So he's nailed it ⁓ in that sense. And I think it's one of those things nowadays, which I blame the internet, like Peter, I blame the internet for this.
Peter LewisYou have a screen first.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: is this notion of free speech now. Yes, are all entitled to freedom of expression. We're all entitled to free speech. We're not entitled or guaranteed to a platform on which to share it. And that's what people are obviously, you know, yelling, yelling about. And the internet makes everyone think that they are entitled to a platform on which to share, on which to share racism and sexism and misogyny and all the other things that that people are sharing on the internet as well, too. So. Over to you, Peter, and then I'll keep unpacking.
Peter LewisYeah, I've always had a problem with this notion of pure freedom of speech. It also carries responsibilities and some of those are norms, some of those are rules and some of those are laws. And I think it's been very, I feel the right often take something where there's an attempt to set up norms and then say, you're like, you can set rules of engagement. Last year there were these, ⁓
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah.
Peter Lewismisinformation laws that got rolled on the basis that it was an impingement on free speech. What it was trying to do was force the social media companies to set up risk management frameworks. It was really about ⁓ platform accountability ⁓ to ensure that things that were dangerous were not going to spread. ⁓ And I feel like we're a bit like so he's basically I think saying that I've lost my freedom of speech because I'm being told I can't platform a guy in Australia who ⁓ I can do it, but I can't do it under the imprimatur of ⁓ the Nine Network, who both Labour and Liberal governments had said, you can't come into Australia because you're spreading theories that are going to drive hate and division. ⁓ So again, he is a grifter, but he's also basing it on this. He's trying to create himself as ⁓ a saviour of freedom of speech, and I just don't see it. I also am interested in I don't know all the money behind him. I did a bit of research on the internet and he's being sponsored by a gambling company. He's got a bit of money from some sponsors. I'll be like, there is a lot of money coming to Australia on One Nation. And if you were setting up an infrastructure to start spreading out things the way they've been doing in the States, like it would make sense that a guy like Carl would be part of it.
Damian DamjanovskiDo you do you think I you know, he's doing five shows a week at the moment, right? So it's prolific. But he's gonna not just run out of people, he's gonna start having to Well, he's gonna have to start talking to the same people
Peter Lewisrun out of crazy people to talk to. The point at which we're on there means that he's really on the skids.
Damian DamjanovskiWell, i it's this whole thing of at some point the controversy, the shock factor starts to wear off and it starts to become same same, right? Like South Park went from being like crazy controversial in its first two, three seasons to we forgot about it for for ten seasons or so. Like th it's the natural order of things. We then exactly we we acclimate to these kinds of things. How long till Carl hits this? Like how long can you keep that up?
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Mm.
Peter LewisSo, thank until Donald Trump and his tiny dick came back on. What day is it? Maybe next Wednesday.
Damian DamjanovskiDana, you were gonna say something. Yeah.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah, he'll have to pace the content. That's what Joe Rogan kind of did. You know, he paced the content and he'd mix it up with these random sessions about, you know, smoking pot to help you sleep better or whatever. Do know what I mean? So he'll he'll call. We'll have to.
Damian DamjanovskiMm. Which brings us on to this week's sponsor, medicinal calum cannabit. No, kidding.
Peter LewisBut like, least, like, no, if you'd like to, yeah, what is, what do they say? Like and share? never get it. Yeah. ⁓ we're almost at the time for kiss of death, I reckon. ⁓ so, don't know, we, ⁓ we started this as predictions of the week and we always get it wrong. So now we're just calling it kiss of death. So sometimes we talk about what we actually think is going to happen.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: You guys have sponsors? I didn't think you guys.
Damian DamjanovskiI wish. Yeah, like and share. Just s s send us some money, pay ID, whatever. Yeah.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah.
Peter LewisAnd now we're starting to think about things we really don't want to happen. And we predict those that happen because we always get it wrong. It's the best way of stopping it happening. So take your pick. Do you have a kiss of death for the weekend?
Danae Bosler, VTHC: So my kiss of death for the week ahead and I don't know, and because you told me this beforehand, I don't know if I'm meant to reverse engineer it. And so if I want, that's the outcome that I want, so I need to reverse engineer it. But there is a chance that the USA will play Iran in the World Cup. There's a chance of that next week. And.
Peter Lewiswhatever you want.
Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm. And you're anticipating Israel's gonna get in between on the field or
Peter LewisAmpah, Israeli ampah.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: And that could be, I am actually genuinely anxious about what that could mean for world politics and peace and hope. If we have a soccer match, could it be the soccer match to decide all soccer matches? So I'm not gonna call a winner or a loser in that one, but I'm just calling that that is gonna happen next week.
Peter LewisAnd what about you, Damme? Good call.
Damian Damjanovski⁓ so next week I believe is the last sitting week of before winter. And I'm
Peter LewisI believe you are right.
Damian DamjanovskiI'm expecting that Labour might introduce a guillotine bill that includes some hairy measures in it. I'm not going to say what I think they might be, but I'm going to earmark that there's going to be an interesting guillotine bill potentially brought in at the end of next week. For those who don't know, a guillotine bill is basically a time-sensitive bill that the government introduces that has to be voted on in the Senate before the end of ⁓ before the Senate rises.
Peter LewisRight side.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Hmm.
Damian Damjanovski⁓ and it's basically a way to shuffle through legislation before they all go on a winter break.
Peter LewisSo my kiss of death, which I think is both a good and a bad thing at the same time. So I'm hedging my bets. There's been a lot of talk, July cabinet is going to make some really big decisions on AI. Cam Wilson at the ABC had a piece this week, was ⁓ allegation, was a whistleblower coming through David Pocock's office saying that they had written. to competing papers for cabinet ⁓ based on positions on AI, both of which will take away rights of creators in the interests of ⁓ the hyperscalers. I think things are going to really heat up. Albo today was saying he's going to do a big speech on AI in mid-July. So I think there's been this thing happening over the last couple of months. It's almost like this stalemate. So you've got the ⁓ Anthropics and the Open AI is saying we want to train data in Australia, which is a really big deal. like it's not just sort of retail AI, it's manufacturing AI. you've got Australia's got stronger copyright laws than most of the rest of the world. And this technology has been trained on the stolen work of writers and musicians. And they're saying you can't back down on copyright. But I think it's going to be coming to a head in the next couple of weeks. So I think things are going to really amplify on that. over the next seven days.
Damian DamjanovskiI think we might be on the same ticket here, Mr Lewis. That's that said, why do these copyright hold no one's buying their book. No one's listening to their music. Just let anthropics suck it up and do something with it. Far out. Like
Peter LewisMm. And I. Hold on,
Danae Bosler, VTHC: ⁓ you are poking the bear there. You know, yeah, that's...
Peter LewisYeah, build data centers and drain the environment and put workers out of.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: This is, this is Peter's favourite topic right now mate, you're poking the bear.
Damian DamjanovskiJust just you gotta keep going.
Peter Lewis⁓ you're totally. But anyway, he's doing it at the end of it. Like, this is what we do every week. We disagree over a drink with people we like who are sick and
Danae Bosler, VTHC: you
Damian DamjanovskiMm. Otherwise we're all just gonna be one giant teals party complaining about, you know, people from outside our suburb parking near the beach too long and why are all these people coming to my parks and my beaches? Like we can't we can't live in that country, surely guys, like
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Yeah. we didn't even talk about the... ⁓ We didn't even get to talk about the teals party, because I would have loved to hear your opinions about the teals. I have opinions too. Yeah, yeah.
Peter LewisThat's because it's only two people. It's not a party. Like if two people turn up to a party, it's a coffee. It's drinks. It's drinks. Next time, because we'll definitely have you back, hopefully, with someone that you can disagree with over a drink as well. Next time.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: And we didn't talk about it.
Damian DamjanovskiJust you should have called it the Karen's party, that's all that needed to be called.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: We didn't talk about it because it's irrelevant. It's irrelevant. ⁓
Damian DamjanovskiDan, I would definitely have you back if you're happy to be back on. ⁓ and then we can dissect the disgusting logo that the Caram Party have invented, which is a hand holding a heart holding a lump of something. I don't know if it's
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Absolutely.
Peter LewisIsn't it a red double or something? Is there a dub in there?
Damian DamjanovskiIt looks like somebody holding a worm with like a cancer on top of it. I I couldn't tell you what it is. It's it's bizarre.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: Do you know what? It looks like it's AI. That's what it does.
Peter LewisBy the way, how is your hand after the last one?
Damian DamjanovskiThankfully the third degree in burns have started to subside. I'm off the endone now, thankfully, so it really is. I'm just tempted to get a lifetime prescription. ⁓ Dad, I can I just say a huge thank you for joining us this week. This has been a very illuminating and fun conversation. Please you're welcome to come back anytime you like.
Peter LewisIt's the coming off that's worse than the going on, isn't it? Yeah.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: You
Damian DamjanovskiPeter, as always, it is a pleasure to chat to you every Friday and disagree over absolutely everything. We'll get to the bottom of who's going to pay for copyright holders, but I have a feeling it's going to be the Australian public, as always, who's going to be caused to foot the bill thanks to Labour policies. ⁓ if you like the podcast ⁓
Peter Lewis⁓ getting political in the outro, that is so against the spirit of this show. But anyway, just wish people a good weekend.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: ⁓ It is, it's rude, it's rude. Thank you for having me. I'd love to come back on. I hope I've shifted you a little bit closer to unionism, a little bit closer.
Damian DamjanovskiLet's have a great weekend. If you've enjoyed it, please like, subscribe. We'll get there. We will get there one step at a time. And you can take some pot shots at Sydney next time and talk about our horrible harbour and disgusting weather and ro roads that work and beautiful tunnels everywhere and all that kind of thing.
Peter LewisBad bitches. Shocks. ⁓ See you all.
Danae Bosler, VTHC: and tolls, road tolls to the roof. Thank you, see ya.
Damian DamjanovskiThanks everyone. Like, share, subscribe.
