Episode 13

Shopping Trolleys and Selling Anger

With Ed Coper

5 July 20261 hr 5 min

Show notes

Guest: Ed Coper

We discuss the impact of social media algorithms on political discourse and public opinion. The role of anger and outrage in shaping online content and the need for algorithmic reform, including the challenges of educating people on information literacy and the ethical implications of AI-generated content. We talk about Ed's new book 'Angertainment'. And of course the critical analogy of supermarket shopping trolley return behaviour as a way to draw parallels with political voting patterns.

Chapters

  • 00:00 Introduction and Poison Sharing
  • 05:35 The Role of Anger in Politics
  • 32:14 Algorithmic Impact on Creators and Users
  • 58:18 The Parallels Between Voting Behavior and Supermarket Shopping

Full transcript

Read itHide it

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.

Damian DamjanovskiWelcome to What's Your Poison, the show where people who rarely agree over anything agree that it's better to do so over a drink. My name is Dament Domyanovsky. I'm a principal at General Strategic, and I'm joined as I am every week by my evil twin, Mr. Peter Lewis, who is principal over at Essential Media, Australia's most or one of the most progressive advocacy and campaign agencies. Well, I think given Who's on the coach today? Maybe one of one of three, I won't claim controversy already. I know that's to throw it out there. Most progressive or most agency? Most agency. Very agency. Peter, tell us about our poison. We're all sharing a poison this week. Well, we're sharing a poison this week. We have got the blasphemy ⁓ gin from Archie Rose that you've broken out in the ⁓ general strategic rooms. ⁓ so yeah, I'm doubting it. I'm introducing my very old friend, ⁓ Ed Coper, who's I I I think he's Australia's number one pod tart at the moment. You've been on just about every podcast in Australia's. Also media tart. I I I don't discriminate just with podcasts. I also do broadcast, narrow cast, sideways cast, any kind of, you know. Fantastic. But Ed, ⁓ thanks for joining us. You've got a book out. You can show it to the camera if you want. Angertainment. ⁓ we're gonna talk about that in the practice of politics this week. But before we get into that, Darma, how was your week? It wasn't too bad actually. It was so this was the last week, obviously before the winter break. So Parliament goes on a break for way too many weeks. They get more holidays than you know, primary school teachers. ⁓ you're pulling hands and cause you Well, yeah, so so ⁓ last night was the midwinter ball, which is, you know, ⁓ don't know what to say a premier event, but it's a fancy event put on for media and politicians in the Great Hall in Canberra. Sometimes you expect that ⁓ the last week before winter break is going to be particularly action packed because then everything's got time to like settle and die down. But this one seemed like it it wasn't that action packed or interesting if I'm honest. I haven't really been watching. I did notice that ⁓ and I love them dearly, the creators were down there making the case, ⁓ as I predicted last week, ⁓ over ⁓ AI and ⁓ their intellectual property. Although I did note that every year they tend to have their lobbying day in Canberra, the day of the midwinter balls. It just been cost effective. No, how's your week been? Anything particularly interesting? So catch your eye? Well, we had our ⁓ a big day yesterday. We had our lunch for Essentials 30th anniversary 30 years ago. Baseltoff. Yeah, I know. Tony Douglas actually set it up. I I I came in after a couple of years, but I am old, that is true. And then ⁓ I was I I got invited to a very Interesting little event down ⁓ at Walsh Bay last night. Chris Brown put it on. It's called the Sydney Table. We were talking about data centers and I was there to throw bombs and I did. So that was fun too. So good week all round and now Do imagine there's any photos that are gonna come out from that in the papers or no, no, no, because it was all Chatham House. So it was all good fun. But ⁓ we did then follow it through with a podcast. Everyone's got a podcast. So he's got a podcast. So that'll be out in a week or two too. So we can share that around too do you think the audience is just podcasters listening to other podcasts. I feel like it's becoming like that. ⁓ but anyway, here we are. We've got a few more than that, you know, as they say. Like and like share and subscribe. Or sponsor. ⁓ sorry to throw you you know, ⁓ to myself ⁓ in amongst your podcasts, but we'll just put in a plug for the book. ⁓ the chapter about the create economy ⁓ is actually entitled This should be a podcast. Because I don't I think writing books is quite quaint these days. So thanks for having me on yours in the absence of having one myself. But ⁓ maybe you should. ⁓ but bring you in, like it's not just about us. ⁓ so I met you years ago when you were working at Get Art, you went and worked in the States, I think, with some of the early ⁓ social media plays over there. ⁓ you've come back to Australia very successfully. marshaling the first wave of teals that these guys hate like nothing else on earth. So, you know, refle before we get into this book, reflecting on the journey. So you're you're a few years younger than me, probably about the same age as Dame. ⁓ politics has changed a lot. ⁓ I feel like anger's always been part of the game just framing up your book. But but what has changed over the years? ⁓ well where to begin? I really cut my teeth in politics doing what I assumed everyone else was doing at the time, ⁓ which was sending mass-forwarded emails and asking everyone for a little bit of money ⁓ to to have a sum total greater than its parts. And unbeknownst to me, Nobody else was doing it at the time and I seemed really prescient ahead of ahead of the curve. And then that's even before social media came along. I so so I then spent subsequent years convincing, you know, the Australian Labour Party they should have ⁓ something called a Facebook page, you know, and all these radical ideas. But ⁓ so being I I've seen the whole evolution of of politics in the internet. and we were full of hubris in the early days that conservatives would never be successful on the internet because the internet was a positive media a progressive medium. Yes, that this was a a uniquely progressive medium and it was going to take over and and good night conservative politics who who would never thrive in this ecosystem. And now that seems really quaint because ⁓ it's the far right populists who actually are very good at interneting these days and putting all the progressives to shame. So really this podcast is a story of how wrong I've been in my career. And and we'll we'll get to that in excruciating detail. ⁓ tell me more about so you built GetUp or you helped build GetUp from the Helped build getup, obviously, cast of of of others as well, but I was very lucky with the timing to be right there at the ground floor. And ⁓ the the most significant thing that happened in my career ⁓ had nothing to do with, which is Barack Obama won ⁓ in 2008 using the same kind of internet and politics playbook. And all of a sudden what had been an obscure experimental thing. was the flavor of the month globally. So And and this is one of those things that people forget because Obama's often credited with running like the first social media campaign when everyone in Australia knows Kevin O seven actually ran what I would consider the first western country mass social media camp like pioneered a lot of those techniques that then the Obama administration. So Kevin O seven was old style media branding, the ⁓ was the lake great Neil Lawrence. It was an advantage advertising bit. It was a good digital bit, but it was also being run when the unions were running rights at work. ⁓ that yeah. But that's multiproduct. It was it was air war, ground war. It was it was grassroots, connect hyper connected and filled with the warm fuzzies of of being part of something. And I actually do think it was actually the ACTU and R your rights at work who drove that more. But Kevin O seven gave it a wonderful brand. Yeah. ⁓ Twenty ten years and all the unions that I've done. 2010, I don't think a great deal changed. Twenty th by twenty thirteen I had convinced the Labour Party to have an email address. ⁓ and that was really the first one where where they started thinking about that as part of the campaign machinery. And since then it's it's gone from strength to strength. Obviously, 2010 wasn't a great campaign. Yeah, and so 2013 was when ⁓ Kevin had just ⁓ taken back ⁓ from Julia ⁓ weeks before the campaign. Correct. So that was a very strange that was the twenty thirteen And so that's interesting, just on that line. So Abbott did not have a digital campaign, did he? That was just old media blowing labor out of the water. Yeah. So really was antithetical to I'm no tech head. Yeah, yeah. Antithetical to the internet and social media and how those things work. So so you did all this stuff and then You somehow ended up in the T like w working with it. Did Zali just call up at some point and was like, hey, get me Ed? I just ⁓ really interested in colours. And I was shopping round and you know the red wasn't looking so good on you. No, I I ⁓ thanks to thanks Obama, as the Republicans say, I then went and lived in the States for ⁓ for the next decade or so and randomly came back ⁓ to Australia just ⁓ During the pandemic in 2020 and ⁓ was looking for things to do. ⁓ and I connected with my my now colleague Anthony Reed, who had run Karen Phelps's 2018 campaign. ⁓ and OGTL. And then Zali Siegel's 2019 campaign. Sorry, Tony Abbott. and and we were of a mind at the time that there was probably about half a dozen seats that looked like Waringa and Wentworth. ⁓ and so then set about working on the strategy, you know, for Climate 200 and others. And then once there were campaigns in those seats, ⁓ teaching politics to people who had been successful in, you know, their own ⁓ their own careers, but ⁓ had the intellectual humility to say, I might be able to run a fashion label, but I don't know how to run a campaign. Let's get the professionals in. So we could just, you know. How did you find that? Like difference between working with Labour, which at that point was a very old machine that, you know, yeah, yes, it was getting with the times, but that versus getting to like because it's rare that you get to start on fresh ground. It was a a a wonderfully rewarding experience because legacy politics, this is not a part of a problem of any party, as you both would know, is risk averse. When you are in insurgent campaign starting from scratch. You you have to do things differently. And I was so lucky to be given the opportunity to have a carp launch. How would you run a campaign? Yeah. And we managed to do that. And lo and behold, they were successful beyond anyone's, you know, predictions. So it was a very rewarding and gratifying experience that actually if you get the campaign part right in politics, it works. What were you doing different than a major party? What so what what what we Without giving all your tricks away, but like this is And for the low low price of ninety-nine ninety nine, I'll come and tell you what to do for your campaign. No, th there there ⁓ some of it was retail politics, which you lose with a big federal party structure. You you can't do retail politics effectively times 150, you know, from a from a central campaign, you know, that you rely on the candidate. these all had amazing candidates and you knew that and I have worked on other campaigns, I will not name names and date I've worked on campaigns around the world. ⁓ Where you want to prevent the candidate from meeting any any voters. We were lucky, these are all ones where if you said, hey, if you just had a hundred thousand handshakes over the course of the campaign, you would actually halfway there. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly. ⁓ so it was about that ri and by retail politics, I just mean, you know, getting out, pounding the pavement, pressing the flesh, talking to constituents and being receptive to to them. ⁓ we were obviously helped by the external factors of the Morrison government. ⁓ and the liberal brand at the time, especially on climate change. So you knew how to what messages to lean into. But then the machinery was a digital first strategy. And that's the part that I'd been banging that drum ⁓ you know, for the the major parties for for many years by that stage. And it's always hard to divorce yourself from the old notions of how marketing should be done. Every corporate marketer gets it now, but politics is a bit slow to catch up. That's the bit that we were giving carte blanche to say, Well, you know, run this advertising and marketing program as you would a ⁓ any brand in twenty twenty two or twenty twenty one. ⁓ and we s we we saw the you know the ROI on being able to do And I have to admit, like ⁓ obviously I'm I'm not a teal sympathetic, but you know, working in this field we we subscribe to all the email lists and see how everyone does their thing. The the email campaign specifically and the digital campaign from the Teals is astoundingly good. And every time I get an email, I'm shocked at how well it's been structured to feel personal, to have a and authentic. Authentic. Yeah. To have the asks, you know, subtly put in there. Pre-campaign, I think ⁓ it's Byron Faye. Byron Faye was running these, you know, polling workshops where He was basically doing an open Zoom for anyone to be able to join and they would talk through their polling numbers. Now, if you talk to a traditional political party and said, hey, we're gonna talk to everybody. And the thing is, like, they weren't like real polling numbers. Like they were, but they wasn't like all the gory detail. But it's embedding a message to the It's embedding inside some reasons. But the thing is you'd look at it and I'd be looking at the other participants, and there would be eighty, ninety, a hundred people on these Zoom calls that were all generally wealthy, older, and were interested because they didn't have an on-ramp into politics, a true on-ramp, up until these teal campaigns came in and went, Hey, you're in the tent, we'll share everything we know, we're all part of this together. Which makes me wonder, and I'm curious on your thoughts, is is making a political community strong like is this like a terrible move for the Teal movement? Well, yeah, I I was really reminded of like ⁓ you know, the mature age student at university. Yeah. Y you know, and and it actually turns out you're you're twenty one and And then there's you know, this this middle aged woman there or something. And then it turns out you actually become best mates with them because they know they want to be there. They they're intellectually humble and they ⁓ y you know, just have this wonderful approach to is it was a bit like that for for this. Where you had all of these ⁓ these people, largely as with all politics, ⁓ you know, boomers or retirees. Are all incredibly attractive. Yeah. ⁓ no, they ⁓ they wanted to learn politics and approached it with ⁓ a lens other than ⁓ a lot of the you know young volunteers for the major parties are like I'm I I want a career in politics, you you know, I'm here for for other reasons. ⁓ and that makes a difference too. And the when I say retail politics, it's also about, you know, you as a volunteer talking to your friends and family, having those conversations, wearing a t-shirt and getting asked questions and having the answers. And You know, a across all of this, the superpower of of those campaigns and those teals, and you picked up on it on the emails too, is authenticity. ⁓ it turns out without getting ahead of ourselves on angertainment, turns out authenticity is wonderfully effective on social media, it's wonderfully effective with the voters, and ⁓ you don't have to be like a fire brand to get, you know, to to to cut through if you seem like you're being legit, you know. It's refreshing. But I would so So I watched the teal campaign, like we were working for Labour. So we were one step removed and saying, Go, you good thing, because you got you made the the math a lot easier and ⁓ And destroyed the Liberal Party. Well yeah, but I I do think the interesting response to made you win. No, no. But I do think the intr interesting response to ⁓ your your your great emails was you got your boss to crash tackle a young child ⁓ as that ⁓ but anyway. When it went viral. It went fire. Look, ⁓ you know, and you fly on the wall in the meeting, you know, God, you know, look, just go and tackle the kids. And they're saying you're not getting your hands dirty here. You know, not saying you have to do it, but if you see a small child, if you see an opportunity, put off the shoulder, go. You you don't hold a hose, but can you tackle a child? Anyway, no, but what I was gonna say, Ed, back into your book, like it it was an interesting campaign because it was like about this the teals of the heart. But it was actually an angry campaign. It was like We've had enough on climate, we've had enough on gender, we've had enough on integrity. So you actually were using the tools that you write about in this book in that campaign. And maybe let's go into that book a bit. So how much of this is actually, you know, a mere culpa as well? Because you've been good at this stuff. And you know, we all know anger is the lifebud of politics. I've I come out of the union movement where anger, hope, action is the mantra. Yeah. Like you guys weren't winning by playing nice. Yeah, and and you know, for any Listeners who who haven't ⁓ read the book, it's about the dangers of angry internet mobs. What do I do for a day job? I create angry internet mobs, right? About in in politics. And and you're absolutely right. Anger is really important. And outrage is really important. Moral outrage is really important. That's why we've had it for millions of years. Social change is every every progress we have made in society has not come politely, it's come through anger and collective anger and outrage. And That's really important. That makes it even more important that we understand how these social media outrage networks work. Because what we have lost in the way that they work these days, the how they've worked in human history, is the ability to turn to determine, am I angry at the right thing to the right degree for the right reasons? Because am I just being pushed? Or am I being manipulated? And and we should view it for the through the lens of a scam. Right. Like we all are familiar now. We have some literacy with social media and ⁓ internet scams. ⁓ and and we know that the goal when ⁓ assessing am I being scammed is to take a step back and look at the, you know, is this ⁓ is this trying to get a reaction out of me that is not legitimate? It's kind of the same with outrage. We just need to learn those tools again so that we can maintain the anger at the right things. ⁓ And ⁓ maintain my ability to create angry internet mobs about all the woke lefty things that we need to fix in society. ⁓ so this is not about saying we shouldn't have anger, and it's not about saying we shouldn't have mobs, and it's not about saying we shouldn't have social media angry mobs. It's about losing that connection between information and and our reaction, like legitimate quality information about about ⁓ ⁓ the world and our action loses our ability to be outraged at the right things to the right degree for the right reasons. It's almost anger by default diminishes righteous anger that can be harnessed for the right reasons. Yeah let's use sugar as a metaphor, right? If I am a if I am an Olympic sprinter, right? I want a short-term burst of energy right before my race. The worst thing for me to do is to eat Fruit loops that morning and then sh constant handfuls of sugar all day. Because by the time it comes for me to use my sugar energy, I'm exhausted. That's why I wasn't an early at the end. So I'm I'm actually glad you brought this up. So I I really enjoyed your book. Thank you. I ⁓ obviously found myself outraged in parts of it because I was like, who's with me or at me? Both. So like I was outraged with you in some parts, but then I was like, This get up guy who's basically been using this angertainment to, you know, make you push his left wing woke agenda is lecturing me on the outrage of the right. So so I had a bit of a healthy bit of both. The end bit is where I I think I genuinely disagree, which I want to unpack that a little bit. So for people who haven't read the book, the the end, the if I can summarize and please correct me here is you kind of bring it down to the remedy to the scourge of algorithms and this horrid anger diet we're all on is that we better understand, that we're better educated on discourse and all and information and information welfare and all this kind of thing. And it was a really it was really dispiriting for me because following your analogy, these algorithms are basically going, rather than you going to your fridge and deciding what food you get, you open your fridge and It gives you a thing. And if you like the thing and go back to the fridge within a short period of time, it gives you that thing again. And it will keep giving you the thing, right? And so for most people, like any human, because we're, you know, wired sacks of meat and chemicals trying to make our way in the world, what happens is if it's salts, fats, or sugars, we will eat it and we will go back for more. And so it learns that we like salts, fats, and sugars, and we keep doing that. And the antidote as you've prescribed it is. Just don't eat that stuff and think about what you're eating. And I go, in a world where we literally can't do that from an obesity perspective, the fat guy says, from an obesity perspective, where when we do have choice, we can't even control ourselves. I don't think it's a reasonable pathway to ask that people start educating themselves on their information diets, if we can call it that, and how they actually dis how they understand what the objective is, who the actors are in information. Like that, it's just too much to ask of people. So the good news is you're half right. Okay. So there That's the that's the benchmark I call myself to. And 51% are fast now. Thing of not saying you're half wrong. the the problem is there's no there's no silver bullet. And so we actually need a few parallel solutions at the same time. Now, obviously, and Peter will agree with me wholeheartedly, number one, far and away, we have to change. platforms and we have to change those algorithms. And that is, to your point, saying we cannot have the fridge serve up the unhealthy crap all the time. ⁓ That is the by far and away the most important thing we can do. The other solutions are around what can we do in the meantime? Because that that also wouldn't be serving the readers and society if I just said, fix the algorithms of which there is limited political capital to do so and an incredibly hard journey ahead that Multiple regulatory ⁓ attempts have failed at. So that would be a disservice to say that's the only solution because we have to live with the platforms as they are in their current form, at least hopefully temporarily, until we can do that. So there are a couple of really important ways that we need to do that. ⁓ and the first is exactly what you described. We need a form of systems literacy that says when I am getting served as a user. When I'm getting served information on social media, do not fall for it hook, line, and sinker. ⁓ if we have that education, study after study shows that when you teach people to recognize the signs of rage bait or misinformation or any of those those other things, we're actually pretty good at doing it. But we are we we do not have that embedded into our curricula at the moment. And perish the thought if you're a young person coming into the world with all this AI slop and rage bait. What are you what are we going to do for that young person so that they can actually have that education to understand when you see information, it has come to you from a circuitous route from nefarious actors. That's the education part. Now, the third part, which is also equally important, is if you have good ideas, and now maybe my good ideas are different from your good ideas, but the beauty of living in a democracy. Is we both want a world where those ideas are contested on their merits and and the the good ones win. If we want that, we also have to change the way that we are promoting our ideas in the world that that takes this into account and and the systems of information into account. Because my main concern could be summarized by saying, in this world, can we have nice things anymore? Can you and I even have a polite policy discussion on something we disagree in? In the world that is governed by social media information. And I think most people who are on social media would agree that's really hard to do, if not impossible. And that's the interesting bit, isn't it? That it's fine to call out the problem and your acrostic be nice is a really compelling sticky idea. Sticky note. But to actually travel like so if anger is what travels. How can you make civility something that people you know, we're trying to do it here a little bit, but how you know, apart from two guys drinking with some with somebody else, ⁓ how do you actually make that work? And and like are you thinking about that in your practice? And you know, and then and again, in your political work, what's the opportunity cost of trying to do it better and differently? Yeah, I think anyone who's spent a long time in politics realizes that you're actually friends with people across the aisle. And it's really the political novice who thinks that that your political opponent is your enemy in life and they're an avatar. I discovered this last year at the age of fifty nine. There you go. But maybe it was you two coming together. ⁓ the the problem is ⁓ when we migrate all of our political discourse onto social media, we migrate it onto platforms where you don't see each other as another person. You see them in your tribal ⁓ jersey ⁓ just as an avatar for your opinion. And On top of that, it's an environment where if I insult the other person, I get rewarded in in terms of engagement and likes and shares and you know cutbacks and search tax. So so all the incentives are wrong for for that type of civility when we have the conversation on social media. Easiest solution, have those conversations outside of social media. Now, to our earlier point, that's not realistic either. So yes, we need to do that, but we also need to fix the social media part of it. I mean, it's not really to do that because Albo's cost of living crisis means we can't all go for a beer. ⁓ that's a little joke. That's a little joke. Since he took forty seven percent of your company, things have been. I mean, like he's he's here as a part anyway. So two things. One Is he here? I'm gonna again just gently push back on this idea that we need to rethink the algorithms. Now, I'm not a fan of the algorithms. I think the algorithms bring out the worst of us because they give us the sugar hit because we ask for the sugar hit. What I do think is that an education like education won't work because we've been trying this since the days of old fat norm, you know, life be in it, be healthy. We've been trying to educate people on their actual diet so that it works. Have you met have you met a young person these days? Yeah. They got washboard abs and and that's got nothing to do with norm. What did they what did that have to do with? That actually had to do with the algorithm forcing them to feel peer pressure to look a certain way. And the cost of alcohol going so high that they started rejecting it in exchange for recreational drugs. Anyway, that aside, my point here is: I don't think it's just as a thought experiment, I don't think the algorithms need to change. But what's always made sense to me, and I genuinely can't remember who suggested this idea, and I feel really bad because I've parroted it so many times and I can't credit it, is the default position on social media. Should be that you are given a non-algorithmic feed. You should be given a chronological feed, but you always have the option to opt into the algorithm for whatever benefit that social platform wants to give you. So Facebook wants to give you better access, this, that, and the other by opting into the algorithm. If you choose to engage with the all-sugar diet, the government is not there to stop you because you are a free citizen and you should have that choice. But your default setting, when you Go into a platform and you go, I am here for the purposes of engaging with my friends, my family, this, that, and the other, should never be algorithmic. So changing the posture of social media to go, we are not going to touch your algorithms. We're not going to ask you to change them. We're not going to ask you to reveal them. However, to operate in Australia, the default position for a user must be you are opted out of the algorithm unless you opt in for some reason and there must be a clear pathway to opt out. Doesn't that seem like a rational I don't I don't want to be the advocate for Mark Zuckerberg here, but I'm giving you a free service and I make my money out of my algorithm. So I the corollary of that would be you have to pay to use the platform and you get it free if you have served ads. Google still serves you ads if you're not logged in. It just serves you less accurate ads, right? So if Google wants to provide you as somebody that like this guy spends a lot of your time serving stuff up on these platforms, that's not as good a deal though, is it? Well look, the let's do a little tour through the algorithmic history here. The reason they exist is that a chronological feed is really shitty experience. Especially when you have a lot of friends. Yeah, because it it worked well when you only knew twelve people on Facebook. But it became too fast. Exactly, exactly. And so we have to ask ourselves, ⁓ you know, and I'm not one of these people who say social media bad, delete the apps. ⁓ There is incredible good that comes from it. Especially if you are some marginalized youth, ⁓ you're a young gay kid in a country town who can't find, you know, like-minded people. You you can find your tribe on on social media and find really useful advice. And it's count countless examples of the benefits of it. The problem arose when the decision was made that ⁓ keeping your attention for as long as possible was the most ⁓ valuable thing for advertisers. Yeah. And unfortunately, that's where the human ⁓ emotional system comes into it and we pay more attention to things that are threatening, cause fear, cause anger. Or a catchy jingles. But we can't seem to crack the social media code for catchy jingles. You can do the really good emotions too. My social media feed for the last couple of weeks has been filled with my FOMO of all this euphoria in New York with the Knicks winning the N w winning the NBA championship. ⁓ Very viral, very engaging. My algorithm decided that this should be a constant torrent of this kind of joyful content. So other motions do work too. The idea that we can opt out or opt-in is one of the policy solutions on the table. I'll shout out the Fix Our Feeds campaign that Chanel Contos and Teachers Consent is running. ⁓ but there's also the idea of choice about what your algorithm preferences. So not just opting in and opting out, but being able to say, I am interested in, you know, the NBA politics and, you know, et cetera, and giving you some a choice over it because all of the issues on social media boil down to the fact that we have two modes of cognition: one when our brain is in gear, and one when we are gut-driven by our prehistoric lizard brain. And unfortunately, social media thrives in our lizard brain, and all you have to do is put your brain in gear. Choosing the topics that you want to see in an algorithm, which some of the platforms are are getting to this point too, puts your rational brain in charge. And then you can say, actually, no computer, I do not like that political rage bait or that y you know, less Candace Owens and and and more but ⁓ y you know, what's your poison podcast? Because it'll be tagged as politics at some point. So there's been this ⁓ And I've been someone that said algorithm bad, it's manipulative. And talking to younger people in my team, they go, ⁓ I actually love my algorithm. I just want a better algorithm, not a shit algorithm. And they're getting better at training it themselves. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And so this sort of idea it's a weird world where where you sort of you you you express yourself through your algorithm. But my my question on the back of this, obviously you've written this book over what, twelve, eighteen months is normally the how long it takes to gestate one of these. And the The the rise of AI generated content and slop is probably intensified from the time you start it to the time you end it. So how does that change your analysis or reinforce your your views? Well, I think the the ⁓ we've been discussing this from the point of view of the user and how the algorithm affects the user. I think we also need to look at how the algorithm fit affects the creator. ⁓ Because I think that's where it's more interesting. Because we can all, you know, try to ⁓ get control of our own feeds and pay attention to things that that we want to pay attention to. But the incentive system as it exists for the algorithm will determine what creators go out and create. You know, what can be monetized, what will get engagement. ⁓ that is an algorithmic decision, and that determines if I am a grievance grifter who wants to go and you know get clicks, or if I'm just someone who wants my post to get noticed, my the creator is also just a brief shell host who wants to make a bit more money. Just asking questions, mate. But that also depends on how you want to make money out of it as well. True. That's a that's a huge Exactly, but there are many ways to skin that cat. And and they all come back to ⁓ if the algorithms hypothetically change tomorrow to say that anything That builds political c consensus between ⁓ echo chambers will be number one in the algorithm. I can guarantee you all of the creators would go out and create that content. Right. That my point is that the the tail wags the dog there. So to your question around AI, this is this is what has ⁓ been supercharged recently: is the ability for content to be created that then pleases the algorithm has grown exponentially. And ⁓ obviously ⁓ There's a couple of things are going to happen. I'm hop I'm actually hopeful about one of them. I'm hopeful that the rise in AI AI slop means people start demanding better platforms and they have a worse time online. And the platforms actually have to catch up and make it more human because they might lose people's attention. And how many people have you heard anecdotally saying, ⁓ yeah, I I stopped looking at, you know, Twitter, now X. You know, because it was all slop. Or stop looking. Which is increasingly, you know, AI slop as well, ⁓ as well as humble brags, myself not you know not accepted from that. ⁓ people will switch off in droves. Yeah, yeah. ⁓ and then and then the other impact is young people ⁓ will grow up in a world where they don't trust any information. Because why would you? Why would you? And and and it was interesting, Canberra Uni put out their media report the other day and young people more young people have Paying for news, which is interesting signal. Well, because and again, probably the result of ⁓ them not ha being catered to by ⁓ you know, legacy media institutions, but also the idea that you have this parasocial relationship with people you follow that should be monetized is a really direct route for young people. So they look at that and they say, Yeah, I will pay for that person's content, I will support that person. 'Cause they're my news source. It's an individual with personality. And then they form my truth and this is my truth versus your truth. And then you've got to find butt then you gotta find common ground. You've got to find people that are trusted. We rely on on the creator, you know, holding up their own ethical standards of journalism. And that's a fraught thing to do. So I'm gonna ask you this first, Peter. Do you I don't know if we've ever talked about the shopping trolley theory. I suspect we haven't, but give it to me. So I it's a dance move, right? It is. So it's not. I firmly believe that you can determine the health of a society by how many abandoned shopping carts there are in a car park. Because if you watch a person and watch them take their trolley cart for any American listeners, from the shop to their car. American listeners. We do have some American listeners weird. All Well, howdy y'all. From the shops to their car, they load their shopping into their car. Assume there's no one else around and no cameras. What do they do with their trolley? Do they leave it abandoned recklessly? Do they leave it abandoned but not in a trolley bay? Do they return it to the trolley bay that is not conveniently located? Or do they return it and also collect any other trolleys on the way and return it to the card? Now, controversial as it may sound, I genuinely believe. That anyone who does not return their shopping trolley to the bay should face severe consequences. Isn't that why they put the two dollar thing in? Aldi does, but that's a that's a very German solution to the problem. I'm thinking that you were one of the people to so I get a lot of internet hate ⁓ and have for many years. You you know Peter and I have you we we worked on a campaign to bring David Hicks home from Guantanamo back then. Death threats every day. It was wonderful. I have never gotten as much internet hate. Than the time when I admitted on morning television that I put it into the d I don't take it all the way back to its thing. I I'm in the middle ground. I put it somewhere inoffensive out of the way. If I was a dictator, I would genuinely put it in I'm wondering if you were one of the people to put you to death over there. No, no, I would. Because I'm like, there is no reason for you not nothing in your life is that important that you had enough time to load your car but not return your trolley. It is just a selfish And disobedient access. Why are we talking at what I think we have a wonderful lens to view ⁓ cultural relativity? I'm sure the Japanese all put it back in the back. So what's Li Liberals sell it on the open market? No, liberals say that you have personal freedom to do what you want with the trolley. Labor says everyone should take it to But you have personal responsibility to return the trolley. Labour says we're gonna hire two security guards to watch everyone putting their trolley away, and then we're gonna hire a supervisor to watch the supervi to watch the supervisors and they're all gonna be unionized. One nation says they all used to put it back in the bay in the good old days. No, one nation would say that it's only the immigrants who don't put their trolleys away. ⁓ and the teals get it home delivered. So amazing. So I I love this. I I I love this, I love this metaphor. It is a crazy good metaphor. And I don't know if you've ever done it, and it's a really creepy thing to do, but If you are in a shopping center, just sit in your car and just watch and watch what people do with their trolleys. And if they don't notice anyone else is around, you'll get a mix of people who kind of sheepishly go, ⁓ I can't be bothered putting it back. And then the ones who try to jam the wrong size trolley into the wrong thing because they just don't want to walk the extra 10 meters. So let let's extend the metaphor to social media and the social media algorithms. They they've gone one step further and said, All right, people, go for your life, do whatever you want, but. If you put rockets on yours and deck it out in like s you know sparkly things, or if you can get into a fight with someone else, like a punch up over it, that's gonna be really good as well. Or maybe one of you wants to like smash them into e each other as hard as you can and and how much damage to a car could we cause with a shopping trolley? Let's find out. You know, that's the incentive structure there. So I think the the the the solution At the heart of your what I'm hearing you say is that at the heart of a successful society is is a desire ⁓ to do the right thing by people you've never even met before. Because you are because you live in a society. And I think that's great. And I'm one ⁓ it's wonderful to hear you are in fact a social democrat. and so if if you want to create a system where everyone is doing the right thing in a shopping center car park, ⁓ What incentives would you give them? And you've you've raised a couple of And I think this is where not only we disagree, but where Peter and I disagree is I don't believe in the idea of incentivizing or financially creating these, you know, surveillance systems, this, that, and the other to do it. I think you should have a moral obligation. You should feel your moral obligation to return the that's why my algorithm is an American actual Instagram account called Cartnarks. Who literally follows people around who don't return their thing and puts a magnetic sticker on their car. Have you seen cart golf too, where you like that you it's like you you see how close you can get it back into the bay from far out far away? No, but I need to I need to tweak my algorithm now. So so currently the incentive structure, if we talk about social media, is we're gonna pay you if you do the wrong thing with your shopping trolley. Yeah. Now one easy fix would be we're gonna pay you if you do the right thing. That's the monetization solution of like stop monetizing the shit things and start monetizing the the the quality or the helpful things. ⁓ the other is you know saying to everyone like, hey, we actually when you leave your shopping trolley in the wrong place, ⁓ someone might not be able to park then. And it might be an old lady who has to walk further to get to the shop. So you know, that's the social responsibility ⁓ part. and it in reality, a perfect shopping center car park would have elements of all of these solutions. So just just to move it out of the abstract of shopping trolleys, though I would happily talk about shopping trolleys for hours, political lens. Who is doing this angertainment, rage fading stuff well? Who's not doing it well? How's it working at the moment in the current climate? Yeah. Well, you can ask exactly the same question a different way by saying who is doing well in politics globally right now? ⁓ and that's obvious. In the US, and and maybe we can talk about maybe is this changing? Maybe have the winds you know shifted. ⁓ in the US, MAGA is in complete control. In the UK, Nigel Farage and Reform have ⁓ preferred prime minister would win an election if it were held today. In Australia, Pauline Hansen is preferred prime minister. Wouldn't win ⁓ an an election if held today, but un Let's just put it this way. Colleen Hansen's been saying the same thing since 1996. How is she going in 2026? Right? Something has changed. And my contention is that there's nothing actually inherent to political ideology that makes one side better suited to angertainment than the other. It's just that one side has cottoned on to the power of angertainment much more quickly than the other. And those are the people who are doing very well. So could I again? politely disagree with you. That's that's what we're here to do. You could impolitely disagree. That's also I wouldn't I wouldn't dare. But so I look at things like David Pocock and ⁓ punter politics as an amazing example of angertainment, right? Because they collapse complex taxation and resourcing and beer excise issues down into these very simple sloganistic you pay more in beer tax than a gas company pays in tax and go put it out there. They get their hundreds of thousands of views. They go into a Senate estimates wearing a t-shirt. They get job done. Their followership from everyone else being outraged going like, I don't want to pay more for beer than a gas company page in tax. They get their YouTube advertising dollars. They're they're doing it well. I don't I I wouldn't I'm sorry, I I guess what I'm trying to contend here is I don't think right now in Australia this is exclusively the air the domain of the crazy right wing. I think that there is a very left wing bent to angertainment that's being deployed much the same way. The handbrake on this is that when you're in power, you're using the information ecosystem differently. You're trying to give people a sense that you're in control of the situation. And I w I was interesting actually watching some of the ⁓ comms that Mandami's putting out in New York, not just about the Knicks, but even this little small business video he did, which was funny and engaging and it was different. But I think the the challenge for Labour, you can't be angry and empower. So you can get angry at the people opposing you. And I think, you know, Alba did that very well with the Greens last term. And ⁓ but w when it got to the election, it was more about just don't get angry with them, just ignore them. so but as outsiders it's easy to get angry. But Pocock's not in power. Let's an insurgent. Let's take it back a step because we haven't defined angertainment. Yeah, true. So so my definition would be ⁓ this formula where you incite people's emotion and do it in a in an attention grabbing way, you win ⁓ power through their attention. That is not always illegitimate. ⁓ I I wouldn't say that that David Pocock really what he does is engagement because he's not actually doing a stunt-based, gimmicky, you know, I'm inciting your emotion with an attention-grabbing thing. I Punch's politics, I think you could much more accurately say he's he's doing that. It's very entertaining. That's okay. It's okay. Mamdani is very entertaining. That's okay as well. We're not criticizing this model of politics for its ability to do good comms, right? To do To to wrap a message or an important issue in a in a p bit of content that that gets noticed. That's not the contention here. The contention is when people do it for the sole purpose of getting that attention and they manipulate your attention in doing so. So if Pauline Hansen was out there saying, I have ⁓ a very ⁓ important policy position that we should ban the burqa in ⁓ parliament. And I am going to make you care about my important policy position by wearing a burqa into the Senate chamber, then that is a legitimate way to get us to care about her policy platform. But she ain't doing that. She doesn't give a shit about the policy of banning a burqa and that. She is doing it for the attention and the attention alone. How how would you not argue the same f ⁓ David Pocock? Sorry, you I don't say you're touching on a nerve, but ⁓ there's this thing where I think if you're it Do you think Aragama is the only man in Australia who doesn't Have a thing for David Pocock. It's one of those things where I'm like, I feel like when this kind of content or message comes from the right, it's tarred with the angry brush. And if it comes from the left, it's tarred with a rightful brush. I would argue that Pocock and Hansen, both of whom are senators, right? ⁓ essentially on the same term, are kind of doing the same thing, which is reinforcing their own personal brand so that when it comes time for re-election, They can get re elected. I don't think so. I and I think we could you could have that argument very legitimately with you had you picked a different example than David Pocock. I think you've picked the most earnest, genuine person in Australian politics, probably to a fault, right? But earnest if you can find if you agree with no, I don't think anyone who disagrees with David Pocock would would would reliably contend that he doesn't actually think what he's saying. So you think Pauline Hansen doesn't think Definitely. Definitely. That her motives are entirely different. And you let's look at an easier example is Trump, right? Do you think Trump is motivated by a coherent policy agenda and an ideology that he is trying to push in the world? Of course not. Nobody, no, not even Trump would say that, right? He is motivated by ⁓ power through attention. And the the problem that we have with that is the thumb is on the scale of social media for people like him. Now, David Pocock does does a really good job of getting his message out there using the social media incentives. And in order to do so, he wraps it in in a compelling and in in entertaining and authentic way. But by no means is he doing it for the attention that it gets. He is doing it for ⁓ the his ability to communicate something that he is passionate about and something that he is rallying support around that. I don't think the same is true of Pauline Hansen. I don't think that she is out there saying, I I I have a very specific ⁓ policy vision about burkers in parliament and I and I will I'm also a good communicator, so therefore I'm gonna wrap it in some really social media friendly content. She's trying to win social media and she knows that the burker is a good issue for her to do it. And that is the big difference. The craft is before the hook. To your point, she's been saying the same thing for twenty years. I don't think Pauline Hansen's rise over the last six months has been because she wore a Bork Berkram. No, I it's a lot more going on. Using it as an example. But I but I also just to move it on a little bit. So the the line between Trump and Hansen, though, I think, for our side of politics, Ed, is that we've always matched the anger with anger. And I think one of the interesting provocations in your book that I took up this week was can you Do it differently because I think what we actually do by being angry about Hansen is create and and can can you disarm it through the through work the So this this notion that I sort of sort of took out of your book and more thinking, this notion of equanimity where you don't get angry back, you keep calm and you draw her out. And like we we the plateau in her numbers over the last couple of weeks have really been off the back of people engaging with her on her policies off the back of the National Press Club. And it's actually let me just use a good example to kind of illustrate this this point. is if we genuinely wanted to connect with Pauline Hanson and understand her and and change her mind on something, then we wouldn't shout at her on a podcast, which I I find really fun. we would understand where she's coming from. Right. And and and I am of a strong belief that you can find common ground with anyone. Yeah. Right. When I if I am getting a death threat from someone on social media, usually it's around some COVID conspiracy. You know, and let's find out what drives that concern, right? Let's find out what are you actually pissed off at? Do you, do you what where does this distrust in these institutions come from? And you know what? We probably might find some common ground. I am skeptical of big farmers' incentives. I that the you even though it leads me to different places. So there's there's the ability to do that. So I was encouraged. The piece of research that you did at Essential this week, for me, was the first time that ⁓ we've tested when the rubber hits the road and what is important to people. And Pauline Hansen at the Press Club had to put her ⁓ you know, positions out there on a bunch of things. And let you tell us what happened when. They were put in front of the Australian people. She couldn't get even ending multiculturalism, like it doesn't rate more than thirty percent with the general public and less than fifty percent with their own people. But stuff like privatizing the ABC or ⁓ you know, sh shutting down SBS, which I know is your your favorite dharma, like it's under 20%. And that's the general population, even amongst one nation voters, it's it's it's like low 20. So it and it I I think the truth in there is if you actually engage on the issues, like we still gotta work out a way of making those without anger, there's still friction there, but without anger, how you make them travel so people know that those those issues are there. But there is definitely something unlocked there that I don't think I've seen before. Just to be fair, like outside of like tax cuts and like things that affect me. No one likes anything. No one likes anything. You never get you never get anything that's ⁓ contrario actually. Well the only policy that everyone was in favour of was a Royal Commission into banking where they had like seventy five million dollars. Your shopping trolley execution squad banking. No, normally when you say do you think the government should do this, you do a whole lot of things, they go, Yep, yep, yep, yep, yep. What Hansen's doing, a lot of her policies are, you know, shut down, shut down, shut down. People don't want that. So it's this there's a contradiction there. This is also more gotta unpack the anger. 'Cause It's there's almost these different levels. Most p like the other thing we got was like she's reflecting a mood. People don't think government's working, but when you pick it down to the specific things that she wants to do, people aren't with that. So you've got to almost get past the anger to engage with the the points. People don't vote on policies. Well Correct. But 100% correct. Let's f we found something we agree on here. No, but What they vote on is built up from the policy. So, you know, you beat Bill Shorten. You say people don't vote on policy. You built beat Bill Shorten because you built a narrative based on policy. No, the feelings. Feelings. The feelings being and and the policy was the hook, but it was the policy feelings. The policy is the rationalization. This is it was the the policy weren't the feeling feelings. Jonathan Heights, the Jockey on the Elephant thing, right? Where and I I think Bill's a lovely guy and a lot of respect for Bill. But people just thought he was a bit weird. Like the people who were undecided voters thought he was just a bit freaking odd and Scott was less odd than yet. Because they didn't know him yet, right? They're just like there's something off about this guy. Which is very catchy. I had nothing to do with that, but very catchy. Worked really But no, it was I would I would argue that Shortens loss. I know we're digressing here. It's as close to Houston's. You put too much policy out. You're both right. You're both right. And and I'm I'm here. Sorry, I'll end on that. I thought we were here to yell at each other, but now I forgot we're on the agreement podcast. ⁓ you you're both right. The the the policy becomes the feelings hook. Right. But it is the ho it is the feelings, right? What I'm saying is rather than letting the feelings drive everything, build it back from the bottom. This is the probably the most important challenge for politics these days, right? Because we are governed by the difference between feelings and reality. So we what look what's happening in the economy, ⁓ and what's happening with the support for one nation is is people are driven by their feelings that they aren't doing well. A lot of people aren't doing well, but quite often the reality doesn't match that as well. And it doesn't matter. And and where where we have an advantage over grievance politicians is not on our policy solutions. It's just on the fact that we have solutions, not what the specific solutions are, right? So you're talking to the Labour side politics at the moment because that's kind of a relevant solution. Yeah, yeah. Well no I'm sure we we're it's there is a long way till the next election. I'm sure the Liberal Party will come up with a policy soon. The the the idea that one slide was all right. The idea that grievance politics and politicians can can get the levels of support that we're seeing for one nation here is not shocking. ⁓ the i i it is anemic, right? It it is not it it is not a long-term fuel for a political movement. It is a way to take baseball bats to the current political establishment. And we've seen that and and and Americans I think now can roundly agree that Trump is is a is a horrible mistake, even his supporters. ⁓ because I don't think they do agree because that's why they voted him in the second time. Like MA MAGA supporters the vast majority think that their response to Iran and as supporting Israel was the correct response. ⁓ so very good. They they they it's because it's anemic, right? Because it's grievance and and ⁓ People need ⁓ need substance and the feelings only last for so long. So I think it going back to Pauline Hansen here, we we where the government has made a mistake is when people have legitimate grievances, they've gone straight to the bit where they s where they explain how they've made their lives better. I know the list. The list of solutions. Here's all the the things we implemented last year. Grievance politicians don't have a monopoly on grievances, right? But the the thing is, and this is where I I don't understand what the answer is but they did have substance, right? So the US had Biden and they then rejected it. Here we've had four and a half years of Albanese and people it wasn't under Morrison that One Nation came to arise. It's been under Albanese. People are going, g they're giving the clear signal, you're not getting this right. You're screwing it up. We don't want this substance because this substance ain't working for us. There is one major party who's been responsible for the rise of one nation and it's not Albanese, right? The the all and correct me if I'm wrong, the support has come largely from the collapse in the Liberal and National Party vote. Yeah, it's support of one. Yes, there's yes, there's people who've come across from from Labour. But the idea of effective opposition in Australia is when you don't like the direction of the government, you you back the viable alternative. And in the absence of a viable alternative at the moment, they've gone for the next best thing. So yes, it is a form of grievance. ⁓ yes, it is all about the governing party, ⁓ and less about where that grievance go goes. I think the biggest mistake we make in Australian politics is that we assume people are much more political than they are. Yeah. You know, when when it comes time to the the, you know, the biggest ⁓ misconception I always see in politics is that ⁓ we should campaign assuming that people will go and consider the alternatives and and b back a policy, right? I'll I'll add I'll add to your little statement there. I think we overestimate people's political care factor and underestimate their intelligence. So we do these two things simultaneously we go, we're treating you as dumb because in actual fact you just don't care about politics. It's like you're not really unfortunately we found something we strongly agree on. We do over a hundred groups in the last campaign and my main take out was that people really value their vote. They take it really seriously, but they do it with low information. They get it and they they get it way better than they're going to credit for. Have we talked about I'm gonna give you one more analogy. have we ever talked about the supermarket analogy? We've just done the supermarket analyzing No, we're back in the store now. We're we're but we're not in the carpet. We're not in the carpet. We're doing retail like so one thing that I've always find fascinating, especially from our past lives, is like Why Australia has so many duopolies, right? We're a country of duopolies. We we barely tolerate a third option on anything. We like two solid options and like an underdog third option that no one pays attention to. And I did ⁓ in a past life, I did a lot of work for supermarkets for a certain German brand that came into the market and did a lot of research on little. Exactly the one. So what we found is like Australians vote the same way they go to supermarkets, right? Where you get about a quarter of people go, I'm a Kohl's person. I only shop at Kohl's. I do not shop at Woolies because the food is fresher, the prices are lower, the stores are laid out better. And I don't care, they use Palantir. And on the other side, you get a quarter of people going to Woolies, who use Quantum instead, and they go, I only shop at Woolies because the food is fresher, the prices are lower, and the stores are laid out so much better. You five to ten percent of people who go, Well, I normally shop at Kohl's unless like there's a really good reason not to. And you have 35% people who go, I don't think about it, but I always go to this supermarket. But they really don't care. Most of them decide on the day depending on what's convenient, what's nearby, what looks the store looks fresh or there's a special on, but they do not think about what supermarket they shop at until they are kind of forced to make the decision. And we roughly vote on the exact same percentage line. point where the insider outsider. So the major parties are about 53%. ⁓ the rest are going greens, teals, now one. So to me what it says is one of those supermarket chains has let its stores rot. It's closed down a lot of those stores. There's a bit of a gap in the market. And there's a lot of IGAs, superbarns, supermarts, friendly grocers. My my question is if you're Does one nation set up Audi or do they take over Woolyship? No, well the irony took over the Republican Party, which is how he out. One nation is the ethnic grosser, which is really problem for their brand because it is multicultural and not monocultural. But they were the they were the other choice in the ⁓ supermarket center like the five percent of the vote. And unf and now all of a sudden, it's a green percent of that's the grandstream. When we talk about this analogy When I've talked about nostalgia before, I usually bring up the fact that about ten percent of people will always go to Audi, not the supermarkets. And they're they're the they think that they're on the inside of something. They're like, no, no, you have to go to Audi. That's the best thing. But it's always been five to ten percent. Now, as people are hurting, previous everyone's gone, well, don't go to Audi, because it's a limited range. They've only got five products. And there's a whole bunch of junk that I've that's got nothing to do with me. I I don't need any camping gears. I don't need But all of a sudden in a cost of living crisis where the other supermarkets are falling apart, Audi is you go, ⁓ well actually they've got full stock of everything. They've got all the beef mints there at a reasonable price, they've got all the veggies, they're not short on peanut butter, this, that, and the other. Starts to look like an attractive option. They just don't have any candidates. Yeah, the the the problem with the Aldi analogy, if you're talking about one nation, is is one nation just has empty shelves. So people might go in there once. ⁓ thinking that they could beat the system and then find when they get home. They're promising to fill your shopping cars. I the thing they've got nothing for dinner. The thing is we like in theory, yes, but we don't know that until at least a full election cycle to see what comes out of it. And globally I I'm of the opinion that ⁓ you know, countries may flirt with these these populist alternatives. They will only ever last one term even if they're successful. If if for reform gets in in the UK It'll be a one-term disaster and it'll revert to the mean or some other sort of The historically populist parties do well for long periods of time. Is this my is this my ⁓ prediction? Yeah. I think we should actually move to kiss of the it's almost time for This is one of our kiss of death. We'll have to talk about the historical longevity of populist movements on the next podcast. Absolutely. You are always very welcome back, by the way, Ed, but give us your kiss of the death for the week. ⁓ I guess I'll have to stick with that one, you know, that that right wing populist governments Burn brightly for one term and people regret their choice as like a one-night stand. And if they ever get into power, I don't think they will in Australia, they may in the UK. i i it it will revert to the mean very quickly. Just look at Trump. Yeah. ⁓ kiss of Jeff. ⁓ ALP State Conference in New South Wales this weekend. ⁓ there is normally one sort of one one big showdown. This one's gonna be around gambling. ⁓ rules and reforms, particularly in New South Wales, where the pokey industries have basically w run the state for many, many years. ⁓ there will be a push from the left to change the policy and they will probably get it up at conference and the government will do nothing about it. Love that. ⁓ my kiss of death that I had been thinking about earlier in the week was going to be that Anthropic was going to re-release Clawed ⁓ Fable Five. Next week. And they did this morning. So lo and behold, so I'm not So is Klaus happy? Like is Klaus a better companion now that you've Yes, we'll we'll discuss that offline, but yes. ⁓ so instead I'm gonna pivot my kiss of death to say that within the next week we will see ⁓ OpenAI release its GPT five point six as the official competitor to Fable Five. Because Samaris will be so exciting. Ed, thank you so much for joining us. It has been a ⁓ Wonderful conversation. I hope you've enjoyed your time with us. Thank you for the coffee infused whiskey. ⁓ sorry for vacillating between disagreeing and agreeing. You know, it's not like I guess I I I read the clips from good. That's what good conversations are. ⁓ right. So we did that okay. Yeah, we did that correct. ⁓ you're always very welcome back on the podcast. I ⁓ I hope you find ⁓ another occasion. Doesn't have to be a new book, you can come in between books if you prefer. ⁓ if you're watching at home, please share the podcast with anyone that you think might find it interesting. Like, share, and subscribe. Send us your feedback. We've been getting lots of good feedback from people about what we're doing well and what we're doing terribly. So we're trying to implement that as fast as possible. And in the meantime, enjoy the rest of your week and thank you for joining us on What's Your Poison?