Episode 14

Telstra can't tell the time, the PM can't read a room

With Amelia Metcalf

10 July 20261 hr 1 min

Show notes

Telstra OUT! We cover telecommunications, political media, and Telstra network outage(s), the impact, the fallout, the causes, the handling of it. What does this mean for Australian businesses, data centers, AI regulation, and the impacts on society. We then move onto the complexities of regulating AI and the importance of understanding the practicalities of implementing such regulations.

Chapters

  • 00:00 Introduction and Poison of the Week
  • 02:12 Guest Introduction and Telecom Discussion
  • 12:35 Political Media and Statements
  • 23:22 Telstra Outage and Network Redundancy
  • 30:59 Challenges in the Telecommunications Industry
  • 36:18 Data Centers and Social License
  • 48:23 Regulating AI and Practicalities
  • 53:25 Impact of AI on Society and Economy

Full transcript

Read itHide it

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.

Damian DamjanovskiWelcome to What's Your Poison, the show where people who disagree on everything agree it's best to do so over a drink. My name's Peter Lewis. I'm the principal of the Progressive Strategy Shop Essential. Joining me, my evil twin, former Morrison Whisperer and now principal at General Strategic, Dame Dabdanowski. Dame, hello. How are you? How's it going? How's your week? I've had a pretty good week, other than not being able to communicate with my loved ones for a short period there, Peter. Did they survive? They did survive. Thankfully I had an optus sim to get me through it, so it wasn't too bad. What's your poison this week, mate? I as always have a little cider as a backup drink, but I've been told that you've got a little something something for us this week. So I'm very excited for a poison that I'm not expecting. Yeah, yeah. Well, I always come here empty handed to the beautiful general strategic offices. So I did go to the bottle shop round the corner and did the Homer Simpson ask for the second least expensive bread, which is That's actually the marketing strategy for Yellowtail. but it's also do you know that they they they gain the system? The Homer Simpson brand, they pump up the price of the second least expensive because they know that's the one. They they're the one you're gonna go for. Yeah, it's like it's actually the same price. The second least expensive from the bottle shop round the road was the Capaso Toscano Sangiov Sangiovese, which is actually my favourite red anyway. So I mean, that sounds very Italian. It does. Exotic man like yourself. So I've had a good week. I have had drinks this week with a green A teal, a red, and now I've got a couple of blues, so it's fantastic. So you want to eat It's very tripartisan of you. Yeah, I know. I I just like my colours. so introduce me to the guest you've brought along from Blue Team. Absolutely. So from Blue Team, I've brought along Amelia Metcalf this week, one of my favorite people from Blue Team. So Amelia and I worked together while we were in office. Amelia worked for the honourable Paul Fletcher in the communications portfolio. Fair to say he was honourable. He he still continues to be honourable, the man's still around. He retains the odds. He retains the odds. And Amelia now runs her own shop called Burke Street Advisory and has some very esteemed clients who there's no need to mention on this show. but we thought given Amelia's incredible experience in the telecom space and given the events of this week, it might be interesting to get Amelia's thoughts and dissections on the role of telecommunications in a modern country like Australia this day and age. Amelia, welcome along. Thank you for having me. What's your poison? well I think I'm drinking a gin and tonic. that I will definitely have some of that red. I I I don't mind that kind of lighter red. So, first question. how's it selling yourself as someone with ties into the Liberal Party at the moment? Is that i is it a buyer's market or a seller's market or how's business? Look, it's a fair question and Look, unlike some of other people in this industry, I actually have a fairly extensive background in policy before I came into politics. I was a federal public servant for ten years. actually working in the comms department. Yeah, right. Yes, we will. and I also spent some time working at the National Broadband Network. So I had a bit of time outside of politics, and that has definitely come in useful. I think for a lot of my clients, you know, everyone wants a meeting with the minister, but there's actually a lot of, you know, work that goes on at the departmental level and understanding, you know, how public servants think and how they form policy is actually very important. So that's been valuable. Also, I'm interested in everyone's origin stories, but so how did you come to be on Team Blue. Like what's your what's your origin story? I'm probably a different to a lot of, you know, I definitely wasn't a young liberal. I didn't I wasn't in university politics. Please don't point to me when you say yes. no, it's in general, it's I'm gesturing generally in that direction rather to you. you're you definitely weren't a young liberal, I can tell. You're too you're too cool. You're too old. Never went to university. You're too cool, yeah. I wasn't involved in university politics at all. I kind of did my degree and would Well, I was also working full time at that point. I went up the hill when I was about 36, actually. When I was working at NBN, the senior advisor to the comms minister at that time, he got promoted to that would have been twenty start at start of twenty eighteen. Fifefield? Yes, that's correct. Good guess. Have you Mitch Fifeeld? No. A genuinely lovely human. Like it's hard to say of a politician these days, but a genuinely lovely human. So he's chief his senior telco advisor got promoted into hi being his chief of staff and he called me and we had dealt with each other both when I was at the comms department and also when I was at MBN and he said, why don't you come up and fill the senior telco spot? and I actually didn't realise kind of what working in parliament involved. I didn't understand how legislation got passed. I had no idea that I was being born into a cabinet minister's office. Like I wasn't that type of political. I'd always voted liberal just as a result of my family and my parents, but I wasn't like involved in the party political stuff. And actually I was telling a story earlier today. In my first week, we had a call into the office from a backbencher who had a telco issue, and it came into the office manager and she transferred it to me. and it was a member for McKella, Jason Falinsky, and the office manager said Falinsky's on the phone and I turned to one of the other advisors and said, What's a Falinsky? Sounds like the acronym of a government department. And they were like, It's Jason Falinsky and the member of Mikela and I was like, okay, great. Nobody ever wants to hear Falinsky's on the phone. To be fair, most people are asking that question now as well. Like so small. I mean within my first three. I love you, Jason. With yeah. Within my first three to six months I learned very quickly how legislation gets fast, who all the backbenches are, how much power they have. And what a Falinsky is. Well, I relearned very quick quickly what a Falinsky was. So yes, it was a steep learning curve. And so but you're you're more involved in the party now. Yeah, so I member of the party, and I spent nearly five years at Parliament House. So started with Mitch and then worked for Paul Fletcher for three years. So definitely got very up to speed on all of the political side of things. It's somebody watching from the cheap seats. I just want to know from somebody, and you might know too, don't it? What the hell's happening with ICAC and the New South Wales Libs and what's that gonna do to the state election? look, I don't I'm not across all of the detail. What I will say is apparently the hearings are gonna be held in September and October, which is horrific timing for Kelly Sloan, because as you know, the election is in March next year. I think it'll be a massive distraction from her campaign. Are you a are you a fan, sorry to interrupt, but are you a fan of ICAC hearings being publicly broadcast? Yeah, so I've had a few union clients and I helped New South Wales branch through an ICAC inquiry as well. And it is very public, it's very brutal. like I I support that level of scrutiny. I think the New South Wales is better than the federal model where it's all happening behind closed doors. I think the threshold for things going public needs to be thought through because allegations can ruin a career. Yeah. And like to be fair, these are alleg I I I think there's been an investigation that's warranted an inquiry. So it's beyond the allegation. But often you'll have these huge trials and at the end of it, yes, there's no charges laid, but careers are in tatters. And like good people can end up We lost Gladys as a result. Well, yeah, and lost lost multiple liberals. We've lost multiple liberals. And and I asked and Labour and Ps tend to end up in jail rather than through the ICAC. So it's more the criminal courts for for New South Wales Labour. corruption, right. so I I think what's interesting here, and for people who don't know, the these ICACs, so these anti corruption commissions that exist in every state now at a federal level through the the NAC. Yeah. The terribly named Knack. They always have the option or when they set up the charter to determine whether or not they are something that is live streamed to the people, i.e., it's a it's basically an open hearing where to some degree it can very easily descend into a witch hunt. But simultaneously there's a there's a good argument to be made for its transparency, it's putting politicians to account. But that also assumes that there's no agendas or there's no unintended consequences of, as you said, putting these people Up on the stand with an allegation that's potentially unproven. Is there a halfway point between having it behind closed doors and having it live streamed to everyone as it's happening? It's a good question. So the the the idea of the ICAC was to set up a process that would increase faith in government. Now the question is, is the way they're running their inquiries increasing faith or undermining faith? And you know, I think For the Liberal Party, they they set up I was back as a law student, I think they set up the ICAC in about ninety one. Like huge mistake. Nick Greiner lost his position to the ICAC. Barry O'Farrell lost his position. Gladys. because if you shine a light on the way politics is done, I and and so I have got a degree of sympathy. And then, you know, I I was supporting Kayla Manane, who was a young woman running ALP head office for a while. And she just got totally brutalized by it. And I think there is real corruption which ends up in the criminal and then there's bad bookkeeping and there's bad practices and there's things like so I And and let's be honest. I'm not saying wind it down, but I am sa and I'm also saying I think it's gonna totally ruin your guys' campaign. You're saying too much transparency is a bad thing. Well, let's be honest, like it with the exception of needed transparency. But with the exception of maybe sport No other career or vocation in Australia, let alone the world, has the level of microscopic scrutiny that politics does, right? The media is embedded with you day in, day out. They're looking for a scoop, they're looking for a story. You have all these commissions that will analyze every move you've made, how you made it, when you made the decision, who was involved, what was disclosed. An average person doing their job to a competent level. would never put up with this level of scrutiny. And to be fair, in most jobs, if you were put under this level of scrutiny, we will find a a way in which you cocked up according to the standard. So while I agree that yes, we should hold politicians to a high standard, doing it in this live way does also feel a little bit performative rather than what it's trying to do, which is instill confidence in the system. Although I would say I think the model they've set up federally is too far the other way, where there's nothing to see here move on and you're not really hearing anything And and you don't understand why the decisions were made, how they were made, what was actually looked over, all that kind of thing. I think most states have I c like I think it has cleaned up the way politics is done in the States. I just think there have been you know, I don't know. Yeah, we don't seem to apply it to local councils. Yeah. The most corrupt of them all. Where would Salim Mahaja be today if we had interrupt ICACs for for local council levels. anyway. Look, there's been a lot happening this week. I I I I thought we'd cover off a few things with Amelia, like firstly, Albow's brush with the Bogan fear. with the what are we calling it? The the bush deep. Like it should have been a warning. We might have a bit of a discussion about the the Telstra outta outage that you averted to earlier. and maybe also a bit about Where Labour's taking the AI debate with a big speech next week. But let's start with. So Albo gets approached to do a podcast with it's she's almost satire. Like I I watched it and it's almost like Norman Gunstan that of my generation. It's she's not a real thing. It's not like she's sitting down with Abby Chatfield, which he did very effectively in the last election, talking about life. This was satire. In the lodge, but he played around with along with it, and then it was like, I I think we've gone too far here. What's your take on it? Honestly, I can understand how a media advisor in Albo's office would have looked at the podcast and go gone, everyone here understands this is satirical. They're gonna ask satirical questions, they're gonna ask some risque questions. Albo just needs to play to the podcast and its audience, and he'll be okay. Because why would anyone else be listening now? This is a interesting question that we've discussed often, which is the nature of media and the nature of how we perceive and frame a politician is changing, right? Gone are the days, whether we like it or not, of the statesman at a distance who retains a certain level of prestige and a certain air of statesman conduct, and now we want our politicians to be hugely relatable, just like us, fault you know, flawed like us. We we the Hawk era onwards has turned into We kind of want a bit of a bloke or a lady who we would enjoy having a beer with. That doesn't explain the Howard era, sorry, Doug. Well, I mean you might not want to have a beer with Howard, but the fact that my Australian track circuit is. There's a lot of people out there, Mr. Lewis, who would love to have a probably a wine with Mr. Howard or a l lovely cup of tea with Mr. Howard. And that's the point is we want people who don't who feel like they're at the same level as us. They're not above us in any way, which is I think why Turnbull both energized one part of the cohort, but then really got everyone else offside because there's a lot of people out there who really would not want to have a beer with Mal or a Chardonnay with Malcolm Turnbull outside of a very few cohorts, right? So we we have this weird thing now where we want to kind of be relatable. But if they're too relatable, then we go the other way and we go, well, we don't want our PM to be saying that it's going to shag Kylie Minogue because who wants that visual? Like That's not something you want stuck in your head. That wasn't even the worst of it. What did what have you heard any of it or have just watched the collateral damage? look, I've I've seen clips online. Look, was I personally offended by it? No. Did I think it was weird? Yes. I thought I thought some of the shagging after the rabbit ocean. Yeah, I thought I thought some of I thought some of their comments were ill judged, but whatever, you know, sometimes you're in an interview and you say things you don't mean. What I will say is that if Scott Morrison had made those comments, the outrage would have been deafening. Agree. I agree. And the outrage that would have occurred There would have been a movement. Yes, that's that's right. so I do think a little bit of it is hypocrisy. from As a woman Libit working in the government when, you know, it was a gender there was Yes, yes. How did you feel at the time like How much of it was fair call and how much of it were I mean, we we did kind of get to the point where every time Scott opened his mouth the outrage was just whatever he did or said. Like I think Yeah, that's right. We we actually got to the point where no matter what he did or said, the the outrage was just at high volume. Like and I think that was part of the political cycle and also some of the other things that were going on at the time. Yeah. as I'm sure you're aware. Whereas Kevin Rudd gets busted going to scores and it kind of humanizes him. Yeah. Look, like I just think like if you're gonna have outrage, look, I don't personally care. Like I thought they were weird comments, but I I'm not personally offended by them. I do think if you're gonna get outraged by something like that, the outrage should retain regardless of who says it. And and I don't think that that You want equitable outrage. This is a new thing that lives in equitable outrage. Look I mean I'm just saying, like if it offends you it should offend you regardless of who says it. That's that's all I'm saying. Yeah. Do you think it's about the office or the person? look look look I'm probably too old. I didn't know who was interviewing him. I don't know that podcast. I didn't know the interviewer. I thought she was just like some sort of cosplay Steve Irwin. I had no idea who she was. Like a lady and it was genuinely. What if Crocodile Dundee had a love child? So it was No offense to her, I have no idea who she is. I never listened to her podcast. so therefore I thought it was weird that she was actually invited into the lodge. I I'm I'm a bit older though and I have that kind of traditional media view, so you know, I maybe I'm the wrong person to ask. Except you're all we've got, so we have to ask. But like Darmay, like it's it feels to me still like politicians are learning pod as a second language, right? So we've taught them how to do media where you'd say a whole lot of stuff but you know that er anything could be grabbed up into everything could be taken out of context. We've created robots and we've created people that play, you know, risk-averse communications, delivering a core message because they know that's going to reach the public. This is a totally different game where you're going in there and you're having a full conversation and then but then there's also this sense that anything can be packaged up and taken out. And and and the addition to this is obviously when when politicians do this through their own social media channels, right? They have the ability to put something out through social media, realize it's a misstep because they get early signals through comments, this, that, and the other. And then remove it. Now with a podcast. Well they well but the thing is they don't do those missteps anymore, right? Because they get the early signals, they take it off, they're not look me, look at me. So when th they don't have control of the channel because it's someone else's podcast, that person has an interest in getting the largest number of eyeballs possible. So of course if there's something salacious, angry, to Ed's Ed's point from last week, anything that might trigger a bit of anger in people, they know that the algorithm will reward them. So they'll happily promote that little bit. Now that's the Faustian pact. You are by going in there, you are a tra your transaction for your engagement slash humiliation is distribution. And if you can make it work and like we did groups during the last election where Alba was really benefiting off Abby Chatford, there were lots of people saying lots of women in Labour green seats, particularly, who was and and Abby was a Green, she was partisan green. But it was working for Albo because people thought, he's okay, he's talking to Abbott. I find that genuinely and I asked because obviously she's quite very green. Yeah, yeah. But it worked in those contests. Now this is different. And I you know, so what should he like? So A should he have in bought a cosplay Bogan Bush Queen into the lodge, maybe? Was the distribution worth it? I do think that, you know, the Shag Kylie thing, he He could have gone another tack which was just to break down the wall and said, You know what happens when I say something like this, it's gonna go off everywhere because people listen to you. So I'm not and it's a disrespect to her anyway. I love Kylie, but I'm not gonna talk about shagging her. Go and watch her Netflix series. Like he could have got a rap There's so many ways to put off. Like, is it only well for him to do that type of media? And then the second bit is like media training and like should he have answered the question to begin with, regardless of who's asking it. And so I would say on the first one, I think he should be doing podcasts like I think all politicians should be doing more of these not just podcasts, but more of this content that because he teaches them to talk to people. Exactly. Like so it moves them away from, as you said, the robotic talking points, which is why we're seeing the rise of things like Pauline Hansen and One Nation, where people are going, I'm tired of the stock standard political establishment where This guy refuses or this guy girl refuses to answer a question because she's always going back to her talking points and kind of forces them into a normal human conversation. But I do agree with that. But there's a reason they have talking points. There's a reason they have talking points. And so I think maybe the media training and the way they're trained for these things maybe needs to be updated to go, look, you're gonna be asked some real left of field questions. So let's practice a little bit. How do you deflect a question where someone asks you, hey, between Kim Jong Stalin and this guy and Paul Pot, who's the best dictator? Like how do you deflect that? Do you remember two cycles ago? There's no no Shad Mary Kill between those. Do you remember when Albo was getting in the twenty two election? Like he was they were just asking him economic numbers every day. It was just like a human punch. He's like, I don't know. I think they asked him the interest rate. But do you know who g who he ca you know who came to his rescue? It was Adam Bannt when he did the press club. And someone said what's the network. He said, Google it mate. And like you can actually think this through and divert it in the culture. And it kind of stopped the What's refer reframing the question though? Exactly. So Adam Bad did nothing else for politics. Google it mate. And he did genuinely. He has done nothing else for politics. We can all agree on that. Don't be harsh. He's now running ACF. All the best, Adam, because you know, Labour lawyers who go into politics tend to be good people. I'm just saying. So I think ultimately Most of this will blow over. I don't think it's gonna be a particularly damning thing. Did that do its job? Yeah, I d I don't know that he did. Well, yeah. Was it unreserved? 'Cause it was issued by writing and he didn't stand up and take any questions on it. So I don't know. Not a good enough apology for you. Well, I I I got offended by it. I d I didn't I actually didn't think he needed to apologize. So but I do think if you are gonna apologize, like do it fully. That you know the only thing I would add is I I do actually deeply agree with Amelia that He didn't need to apologize for it because it was clear like and and the big issue here is that if Albo goes to a pub or any politician goes to a pub and has a town hall session and says some off the cuff remarks in a to try and be more relatable, the remarks happen, we all move along. When it's in a podcast or a format where people can go back, replay it, amplify it, it's a different game. And that's a bit unfortunate. But that's what modern media is, right? That that it unfortunately that's just the facts of the what it is now. But I do think the media need to potentially have a look at how they treat coal conservative politicians on these questions versus how they treat Labour and Greens politicians on the same thing, because I don't think the treatment is necessarily one for one. And there is something to be examined there about Justice for right wingers. Well yes, absolutely. I would also ask like what encouraged Al Wedding Fit out the statement where he said he apologizes Unequivocally. Like what happened that day that he felt like he needed to put that out? Well, it wasn't the Wednesday because if he'd put it out on the Wednesday on Telstra, no one would have been anyway. So what happened? So there was this I kind of started I my my I'm on Telstra and all of a sudden things weren't working. I think it was pretty early in the morning. I was just trying to check my Slack and everything before I I got about my day and I texted the guy on the help desk and said what's going on. He said, the whole nation. Something, something, Telstra. And so I tried to look it on my training. Trains aren't running. So what happened? Like, you know, what actually happened? Like what went wrong? Like what was the glitch? So my understanding is the glitch was basically a time synchronization issue between some of the backend servers at Telstra. Yep. for the less technically minded, basically me. Every computer and every device has to have some idea of what the time is. Not for any other reason that other than most computers and systems now run on security layers and have security certificates to ensure that things are what they say they are, that they are secure systems. And those certificates require an accurate timekeeping to know that the certificate is valid, that it's within its validity period, all this kind of thing. So if one device or one system is in a different time, whether that's a different date, year, time zone, whatever it is, it throws that off. And the rest of the system goes, well, I don't recognize you, I don't think you're secure. Because you think it's two thousand and six and I know it's twenty twenty six. Unless you're in the Liberal Party. But is that that's Y two K bug? Kind of white. It's not dissimilar, right? But like people underestimate how vital time synchronization is to all modern infrastructure. Right. But I also heard that there's two other bits going on. So the GPS actually relies on time as well as space. Absolutely. So th so GPS is But also your your device figuring out what the delay is between three different signals. Yeah. And every day the system loses like a microsecond, which is where the And so all of a sudden, is that kind of right? Like you know about this. You used to work for a comms minister. I actually work for two. What what I what I would say to you is like, yeah, obviously there's been an outage and and Damien's given a good explanation of the issue. Yeah it was, yeah. Yeah. What I would say, and I don't think people will like this, a couple weeks after I started working for Mitch Fryfield, there was a Telstra, severe Telstra outage because there was a lightning strike on one of the key cables between New South Wales and Victoria and it also affected Triple Zero. In the last few years we've seen Optus and Tolstra sulfur outages. I know people don't like to hear this, but networks are not fail proof. Like they will go down. They work most of the time, but there are things, you know, the time issue, the lightning strike issue, cyber attacks, like things happen that mean that our telco net networks will go down. And I think like in this instance you saw things like Victoria Rail stop working. Victoria Rail needs to make sure they have a redundancy so that their network keeps working. Like that's crazy. I'm not I'm not blaming anyone. What I'm what I'm saying is networks have gone down and they will continue to go down. And I I think we're gonna talk about data centers later. You know, we're gonna move from just tolco networks into things like data centers that r essentially will be running our entire economy. We need to have redundancy. And especially if you're a like a transport network like that, you are gonna have to make sure that you have redundancy in place. Because and then and look Telstra's had a real kicking this week and I'm not defending them at all. What I am saying is that These outages will continue to happen. And and look, I'm not I will defend Telstra and I'm you know, I've no commercial affiliation with Telstra other than I do have a Telstra phone, but also have an Optus phone. So I was fine during the outage. What I will say is, Peter, if you lose your laptop and you didn't have a backup of your hard drive, I don't think What am I meant to back up my hard sh so I I don't Do you know where your laptop is right now? Yes. Somewhere somewhere. So I don't think that half of the a reasonable person is quite would go, you know what? Apple is entirely to or whoever your laptop's from, your laptop provider is entirely to blame for the fact that you didn't back up your laptop, right? Or with your iPhone or whatever it is, right? That every punter who's ever lost a phone with photos of it that didn't back it up to the cloud or this, that, and the other, understands the idea that you need redundancies. Now, in Australia, a lot of our back-end providers like payment providers, rail networks, this, that, and the other went, well, you know what? We'll pay for one telecoms provider like Telstra. We don't need a redundancy, we're good. And then suddenly, to Amelia's point, these things are not foolproof. It'd be idiotic to expect them to be foolproof. One goes down and they go, well, the whole rail network came down because we didn't plan a redundancy. We're gonna sue Telstra and hang on a minute. Where's your redundancy point? I pay for my iCloud backup every month. Seeing Jacinta Allen come out and kick Tolstra about that was crazy. Like she is responsible for the transport network in Victoria. There should be a redundancy in place. That's not Tol Tolstra's not responsible for transport in Victoria. What was your take on the the Liberal Party's response, which is a mixture of the Chinese did it and I'm gonna dial triple O to show you how bad it is? Like which of those would have been your advice to So look I think look, my my general advice regardless of party is not to make assumptions about something until you have the facts on what's happened. And I think you can say things like, I'm being briefed by Tolstra as to what's actually occurred. you know, I won't make comments. And not to make triple O calls if you're not in an emergency. Let's just establish that. So what I what I would say is I think there's been a bit of commentary this week from the coalition kicking Tolstra again. Telstra's obviously a private company, they run a private network, they're that publicly listed on the ASA. The bit that the government is responsible for and pays for is triple zero. And that is extremely critical because obviously if you call Triple Zero, you're in distress and you need help. most people. Unless you're Sarah Henderson. You could argue she's in distress. It would have been a good start. No, she I think I believe it was done privately and then spoken about on Sky and T G B. so look, I do think like s leaving aside what I said about redundancy in networks, I do think if people call Triple Zero, they should know they should feel assured that if they call that number that help will be coming. So I do think that is the bit where the government is liable, regardless of who's in power. And that that definitely needs to be foolproof because people need to know that if they're in distress that there will be help coming. So I've got a weird bit of backstory in this in that we've been doing work for the consumer group, A CAN. And it's been a I've been mentioned. Tell us what A CAN is. So A CAN is like it's it's funded by the TOLCOS. It's a consumer advocacy. I think it's Australian consumer that bla blah. Carol Bennett runs it who is Fierce woman who used to come out of the anti-gambling lobby and she's come into this world. we've had this bizarre thing going on. With that they commissioned us to do a poll of consumers on their attitudes towards triple zero. And we we asked this question, which was have you or a family member had their calls to triple O interrupted because of an outage? And we got like 10%. And they put it out and everyone went, And and the industry went, there is no way that is right. We're gonna shoot the messenger. And then we did a second poll that was eight percent. So it's all within the margin of error, but it doesn't necessarily mean everyone's had those number of outage because they're saying that's just impossible. But I've never in my 25 years of polling, I've never seen an industry go so hard at the messenger. So we've had legal notes through ACMA who never do anything from in their real job, look like holding the media to account. Asking us to prove our methodology. We've had to do all these meetings. Carol's been hauled over the coals and Senate. And So can I just Yeah, they're very, very sensitive is what I'm saying about public. So can I give you my like Telco version of that? So when you know about our poll, do you? No, I don't. But I know a little bit about com. So when you call Triple Zero, what happens is your call goes into Telstra because they're ri they've they've got the Commonwealth contract for Triple Zero and they'll say to you fire police or ambulance. And you'll tell them which one you need and then they will direct you and they will know where you are geographically. And so if you live in Victoria and you say fire, they will put you through to the fire service in Victoria. So that's the first level. Yep. And when you have a triple zero outage, that's what you're not getting through to. but there are also state issues and Victoria is an excellent example. they have not staffed their triple zero call centres to take the calls from Tolstras. Is that Kenneth Era cuts or? More recent. No, it's it's actually in the last few years, under Dan Andrews and just but that's not Tolstra anymore at that point. That's the mistake. So that's so that's so Tolstra is getting a call and saying, Victoria let's say Victoria ambulance and there's no one on the other end to take the call from Tolstra. And so what Tolstra has to do is keep them on hold until there's someone to pick up. And when I worked with Hall actually there were some really horrible stories about People you know, I remember one woman, her husband had died and she called Triple Zero and Tulsa wanted to put her through to Victoria Ambulance and they had to keep her on hold for forty minutes or she was crying with her dead husband next to her, trying to get it through to Victoria Ambulance, but there was no one on the end to pick up. So I d I do I think I do think when you talk about outages for Triple Zero, like you have to. Yeah. The other thing that I've been told, again, I'm interested in your take on this that there was a proposal to move triple O into the national emergency framework and out of comms. Yeah. And I think both side like your government didn't didn't approve that. Like what was the logic in not going down that path? Yeah. So at the moment it sits under the comms portfolio. So that's which is the weirdest portfolio. Like Anakin like I'm interested. Like it's a double like Annika Wells has got sports gambling, she's got online harms and she's got triple O. Like it's very disparate and you guys had it as well. Like is that The right. so Paul Paul didn't Paul and Mitch didn't have comms. Paul had urban infrastructure and arts and Mitch had arts. Attica previously had comms, and then she also got given com like sorry, she previously had sport and then got given comms. What I will say is that comms industry, the telco industry has more work to do now with this minister. Yeah. they previously had Michelle Rowland. Yeah. And before that, Paul Fletcher. And both of those had come out of the telecommunications industry. And they were both they were both lawyers out of Telco. And and Michelle had also been opposition for six years comms minister and then became consistent. So she had had a you know many, many, many years in that industry. And Paul also had been an advisor in comms and also worked at Optus. So I I do think the industry was very lucky to have somebody they were dealing in both of them, Roland and Fletcher, who really deeply understood the industry, had good contacts, and they now have a minister who doesn't have that background. And I'm not saying that's a bad thing, but I do think it's a bit more of a challenge for them because telco is very complicated. I'm not Pretending that I'm any type of expert, even though I've worked for ministers. You just ran the policy for the country because I don't know much about art, but I know what I like. I had very I had very clever people I could call up and they would explain the issue to me in a way that I understood. and I was very lucky to deal with those smart people. But I do think the industry has a challenge. And if you watch Annika's press conference earlier this week, she twice said, this is the least trusted industry in Australia. she was But the most dependent on. Like, but gotta ask you this why didn't you bring Triple O, if that's so important, into national emergency frameworks? Why did you keep it in comps? because we because I mean look I I didn't make that decision. But at a high level I would say because it's a comms network and it should be run by Tolco people rather than being moved into a national security or emergency emergency. Well that will change the nature of the the triple A responses and framework. It is like You could make the argument that it would become more bureaucratic and and the service itself would be worse. But I I just want to move on from this one sec. Annika obviously did her sorry, Minister Wells did her press conference fine. Do we think it was justified for the CEO to have to fly back from her annual leave and face this press conference today where she was raked over the coals by the media for something essentially she had no control over. There was nothing nothing she could have done about it. Was that the right response from Telstra? Again, it's kind of you set the standard, you need the leader to take responsibility. You know what it was like when something bad happens and your boss is overseas. You've got to get them back, otherwise They're lying on a beach playing a ukulele in Hawaii. So it it's a purely an optics thing, right? It's nobody wants to see the CEO on break while people are potentially dying from triple O allertages. I think I think that's right. And I think that's reasonable. Like these people are paid like A lot of money. Whoa. Like what, five, six mil? I think yeah, well I don't know. And then of course she comes back into it, has the day, and then it's like, so are you gonna give up your bonus because yeah, as Amelia said, something happened that I like that gone are the days where CEOs would resign when things happened. And now at most it's a will you give up your bonus? Would you? What, resign? Yeah. You're never faced material. You're post-material. I'm postmaterial. I I would like to think I would. I don't know. I've never been put in that situation. I'd love to be called on to resign, I reckon. To like make the announcement. Tony Stark style, be no, I'm done. I want it like the pro only problem with having your own business, you can't be made redundant and go on gardening leave. Like, how We got kicked out by the Australian public, so we went on gardening leave. It was fantastic. yeah, well I got I got kicked out at the same time. Look, we suffered Italy was fantastic. Thank you to the Australian taxpayer before we move on. So one is Do you is there a world in which 'cause Telstra's made a big play of shifting to AI, cutting their workforce. I one theory put to me was, you know, this could have been a bit of vibe coding that sort of sent them astray. So a bit like AI slot isn't as good as real writing, vibe coding isn't as good as real coding. Hang on, so how are we getting to vibe coding from a Telstra interpretation? Because the glitch, like where did the glitch come from? I don't disagree with you. Just ask what is vibe coding? What is it? Vibecoding is getting AI getting Claude to write your code rather than all those kies that you've So instead of an engineer AI writes the code. Okay. So no, that's not why they added happen. And I I'm I'm gonna I'm gonna software fall. Yeah. So it could have been vibe coding. I I don't think so. I mean I I I don't know definitively. I think jumping to the conclusion that it's been vibe coded because there was a fault. Just putting it out there. I it's not look, conspiracy theories abound. I think We're after the clicks. I think to Amelia's point earlier is people should be aware of the fact that none of these systems are foolproof, that all of these systems have fault, that there is a high if not reasonable like there is a non zero chance that every system will go down. Whether it's your banking system, the NBN, Telstra, Optus, whatever. If you are that mission critical where an hour or ten of outage matters to you to the point where you cannot reasonably functional work without it, you should have a redundancy, right? Like I said, like I have an Optus sim as a backup that I instantly switched on. Why don't we apparently, and again this is through So what would you do about it? Hi Carol. most countries have a roaming function that you know, if one network goes down, you have an automatic roaming. Is that something that we're missing? And then the second corollary to that is if we hadn't privatized all our network and we had it under The one domain, then that would be built in. So Yeah, so mandatory roaming is something that the communications shadow minister Sarah Henderson has been calling for for a couple of years now. well I don't think I'm not sure that Laiva supports it. ACAN does though. And and and this is something that in a lot of Europe, like mandatory roaming is switched on by default. So in Europe if Yes, but that's a different That Europe is a different market. So the the competition regulator has looked into mandatory roaming twice now and decided that would actually lessen competition. And the reason is Is competition what we want or security of our network? Well, l let me just explain why they came to that conclusion, which is obviously Tolstra is our biggest network provider, particularly in the regions. If you allow their competitors to roam onto their networks from a competition perspective, why would they Why would they invest and allow that to occur if they if their competitors can use their networks? And why would their competitors build additional towers and areas where Telstra exists if they can just use Telstra's network? And then if we follow through from the outage perspective. So Telstra doesn't want the roaming cause Well that that that wasn't Telstra's view, that was the competition regulator's view. obviously Telstra Telstra would agree with it. So from a competition point of view, instead of having two providers we'd Not even have two protections. Why would you duplicate the like there was always that thing back to the p original sin of privatization. Like Lindsay Tanner always argued you should have kept the wires and the network in public hands and then had competition. But also just from a practical perspective, each mobile tower can only handle so many customers, right? And Tolstra has built the towers for their customers. If you load on Optus and T V G onto their towers, they will become unsustainable because that's how mobile networks work. Once you put too many people on it, they stop working. So that's also a problem. And Tolstra's not gonna pay to upgrade those towers for their competitors to kn roam onto them. I understand in theory why mandatory roaming is sounds like a good idea, but the practicalities of it actually make it very difficult and Tolstra as the biggest provider in the market is not gonna give a free platform to their competitors. So I d I do I'm not I'm not saying I'm against it, but I also do think the practicalities of how it would actually work need to be worked through. And if you think about it in emergency, let's say Optus and T V G's towers burn out and there's only Telstra left, if everyone in that entire area loads onto that tower, it will just stop working. And who gets priority? The Telstra customer, the T Optus customer well or if you're an emergency network and you're trying to communicate with an ambulance. Yeah. Do what I I know, I know it sounds really good, and I I'm not disagreeing with the concept. I'm just saying there are technical practicalities that actually need to be worked through. Thankfully, Elon's Starlink satellites will take care of all of this. And well, all AST Space and Oval. There are some competitors that will be. This was the last curve ball I was gonna throw in. So my sister out at Mudgy, hi Karen. she's just actually called Karen. Yeah. I enjoy that. Two R's. 'cause my parents couldn't spell. but she is out on a farm out of Mudgy and she's just been connected to Starlings. She's going this is it's phenomenal. So the evil tech overlord with the space junk, like does he make this whole conversation redundant and so that's a great question. And what what Elon is doing at the moment in Australia? So we know one of the clients for Am Amelia McNeil. No, I I actually I actually want I actually have one of his companions. Have you met Elon? No. Have you? Yeah, I met him at Splendor in the Grass while he was dating Amber Heard behind the stage at This is a crazy name drop. This is a crazy name drop. No, no, so it was one of those weird things where at the time I had donated some money to the Lismore flood relief effort and in exchange I got some free tickets to Splend in the Grass VIP area. I'm like, great, I'll go up. No one wanted to come with me, so I was there alone. At the time I was a teetotaler, so I didn't drink. What? So I was waiting in the you buried the lead here. No, I was a teetotaler. Who are you? And and so I had a cup of t I went to get a cup of tea. So I had to go to the bar and ask for a kettle so I could make a cup of tea because I as you do. The L C D sound system was playing and I wanted my nice cup of tea so I could be in the mosh pit and listen to L C D sound system. And to my left, there's this American sounding dude who was asking for some sparkling water for him and his missus. And I looked over. And obviously Elon wasn't at the status he is today. He was still the like Tesla guy and Teslas weren't really available in Australia. And looked over and I'm like, Hey, you're Elon Musk and he was like, Yeah, I am and he introduced me to him and the girl he was dating at the time, which turned out to be Ember Heard, who I still don't know who she is, but Johnny Deptas. Yeah, we had this like passing conversation. And so Was that it? Yeah, that was it. Hey, hey. Yeah. That is. Elon and Amber demo. Yeah. That's obviously not. Confidential. Anyway, back to it back to our question. So why is our friend Elon So on Starlink, what Elon has done is launch lots and lots of satellites into low earth orbit. Yeah. And what that means is that he's able to provide coverage into remote areas, but there is a fixed satellite on the roof. Yeah. And that's amazing. It's a game changer, right? And it's definitely better than what NBN does. They've got a satellite much higher up in orbit. with a really long like extensive response time is really slow. But what Elon's current service requires is for you to have a fixed satellite on your roof. There are currently providers. sorry, they've also got message to mobile through Tolstra. There are providers which which within the next year or year and a half will enable you to call or text from your iPhone anywhere in the world. They have done tests in the middle of the ocean with no soul towers for you to receive an actual call through your iPhone with no additional upgrades or anything, no satellite phone. And what that means is within the next twenty-four months, which is crazy to me because I've worked in comms for many years, within the next twenty-four months, hopefully, there will be nowhere in the world that you go where you can't receive a text or a call. And you might think that's a good or bad thing. No, that's like an asking But that that would be an amazing redundancy when you have an outage from Tulstra from the terrestrial network or a bushfire or a full That's right. This satellite Connectivity will give you that redundancy that we were talking about. So do you want to live in a world where we rely on Darmay's mate from the Lismore Music Festival to Splendor in the Group? I'm not I'm not changing that. AST Space Mobile. Check ours. Check out. So I it's they're Amer they're American, but check out. So I Game Changer. I don't know about you, but I actually travel with a Starlink satellite in my car at all times. So I've in the boot of my car I carry a magnetic. I don't know about you, but that's what he does. Just at my eye. I I think redundancies are important. So I always have one of the Starlink mobile satellites. In case in case I'm somewhere where there's no mobile reception or Telstra. Between the city and Camperdown, there's a lot of potential black spots. There are but you we travel to Canberra often, we we go out of the out of the city quite frequently. And I gotta say, more than one occasion having the Starlink satellite has been an absolute game changer. 'Cause Three, four hundred megabits down and you know, ten megabits up in terms of speed through a satellite attached to the sunroof of the car while you're driving at 110 Ks an hour is a revolution. Like it is a genuine revolutionary thing. So we're we're 40 minutes into this discussion and we've been talking about telecommunication policy. I don't know what the stats are gonna tell us about this, Darmay, but maybe we'll move on. the the other thing I just wanted to pick your guys' brains on. So Albo's doing a big speech on AI. Next week. I think there's no secret now. In Sydney. This is the AI decid the Labour Party deciding that they want the final say on what AI is. My question was gonna be for both of you. If you were Albo, what because this is hard, right? I'd shag Kylie. Yeah, and may if you were Albo, how would you pitch this to the Australian public? Because we know Most people are really skeptical about AI. They think there's more risk than opportunity, including me. Yep. so what's your pitch, Mr. Albanese, and then Ms. So the only thing I'll add to that is Anthropic recently released their global usage statistics on their products, which is the clawed suite of products, and Australia ranked number one in the world. That's only you though. That's just me. I'm bringing the median up. So I Don't disagree with you that there's a lot of skepticism out around AI. However, it does appear that where the rubber meets the road, Australians are some of the highest users of artificial intelligence in the world, including the US. And I think when ALBO and the Labour Party start putting together what their policies are around AI, and let's be honest, they're not going to be progressive policies that look to how is AI going to be a productivity advantage and help Australia, they're probably going to be a handbreak on it. I think they need to be really careful about how hard they go on it, 'cause we might miss a huge economic opportunity because of the fact that the Labour government doesn't know how to deal with this yet. You're from the let it rip or we miss out on the parties. Not necessarily let it rip, but I don't think government is the right instrument to make good decisions about emerging tech and I don't think there's any historic tech overlords are better. No, I think the free market is a great instrument to determine. What how would how would you frame it up if you were advising the PM on how he pitches this out? I mean I first of all I don't think the PM would advise let me advise him. That's my first time. But if he you know, we're amongst friends. Second comment is I think the Labour government has been grappling with how to regulate I AI for a little while now, as you know. Ed Husick was minister. It's now Tim S and there's I think there's been a shift in approach. Are you a Husick woman or an ears woman? Neither. I'm a Husick guy. I have to stick with my Mar Mary Shag or what's the other Shag Mary Kilk. Shag Mary Date is the political thing. I can never marry a Labour man, so you know. It's a narrative I thought. Don't let the red jacket for you. I know you're looking very Charlotte Walker. so I think I think Labor has been grappling with how they regulate AI and I don't blame them because it's so fast moving that I do think putting an entirely you know, one of the questions they've had is do we use existing legislation or do do we put an entirely new AI Act down? And I think they've made the right decision for now, which is try and use existing legislation. They've set up an AI safety institute, which is kind of testing different models to see like what happens and and how they manage that. yeah, I mean I yeah. I'm re I'm really torn on this. So like I'm a Luddite, I wanna fight the machine, I wanna beat the machine, but I also wanna recognise that I probably need to shape shape it. I reckon what and I do not know 'cause it's really tight, like I've been reading around going, What's the announcements? I reckon they're gonna pitch this and I'm interested in what you guys think about it. I reckon he's gonna pitch this as his hawk heading moment where globalisation was coming. We can't stop it, but we can shape it and we'll shape it the Labour way. And what was interesting back in that was then Howard and the Libs basically were on board. And I I think if he can pull that off, I think there will still be points of friction, but that's what he's got to achieve next week. He's got to say we get that people don't 'cause there is real problems in both the social license in rolling out the data centres, the deals with the creatives and copyrights. Well I also I also think there's a But is that a is that a fair analysis of where I also I also think there's a massive conflict for Labour, which is they've had this net they've got this net zero target and now all of a sudden you've got data centres which have massive electricity and water representative. But they're promising to make it all renewable. Well so is Labour. Yeah, well they're they're believing so they're believing the harms. So let me ask you this. What do we feel needs to be regulated about AI? Like AI, in your view, what's the bits of AI that need to be regulated about? It should be harms, is my view, but Yeah, so th so this is let let me take a step so I think the big problem and I I think I mentioned last week I spent some time with Belinda Dennett from the data centers, who's got a really tough job, right? Data centers. My my thing to her is A data center is a black box and an avatar for everything that hasn't been resolved about AI. I think it's the harms, it's the scams, it's the concerns about jobs and it's the and it's the theft of the creator work. So those four bits sit there. Then you've got the existential risk. I was at an AI safety summit this week and I think I I'm not convinced that the technology is going to go so fast that we're gonna have paperclips taking over the world in the next couple of years. But I do think those you've gotta make people feel that this is safe because if you see a data centre and you see child abuse and companion bots is what's going on inside there, that it's gonna be really hard to run anyway. So I so I don't disagree, but can I just take it up one more level which is like with given where like I I think it was Sam Altman maybe it was anthropic said they wanna make Australia their second home and Sam Altman said Australia's a priority. The reason They're not just saying that because they want to build data centres here strategically and from a security perspective, like they also want to base data centres here because of our geographical location, also our It's a safe place. And there's this glorious dream that Twiggy builds all these training centres on renewables in the middle of the pill, we're sending stuff out. To Asia and it's kind of like an export of green energy. Like there is a there is a good story to tell there. Can I challenge you on some of this? So ch challenge me on all of it. That's what we're No, no, but but this is an important thing. So I think I don't know what your view of a data center is. I don't know if you've been inside a data center. That's and it's again that's not an accusation. So i it like it's a lot of server acts in a you know, big closed air conditioned room, right? But most modern life runs thanks to a data center. So everything we think of as a modern convenience from your Netflix to your banking, all that kind of stuff. And Belinda does a good job in explaining you're tearing things out of servers into Exactly. So that's part one. Part two is the kind of AI models that live in a data center are large commercial, what we call a frontier model. So when you think of open AI, Anthropic, you know, Google Gemini, these are frontier models where a large corporation, a hyperscaler as you love to call them, Is built this model for a mass market. This is not where child abuse material is coming from. This is not where scams hang on. These are not where scams are coming from. Those things come from what's called an obliterated model, which is someone somewhere, not saying always China, but eight times out of 10, China. Someone somewhere has taken one of these models, distilled it down into a version that runs on local hardware. So you can run it on. A Mac Mini, a piece of NVIDIA hardware in a closet somewhere, and on that device, all the safeguards have been removed, and that device can be used to create scam material, can be used to create child abuse material. The standards that OpenAI, Anthropic, and the other hyperscalers have, because they are a commercial accountable organization, are significantly higher than my mate Vlad, who's got an obliterated model sitting on a home piece of hardware somewhere and is not subject to the same standards that the people in the data center is. So I guess what I'm saying is my fear is labor's going to try and apply the standard of what they did with cigarettes, which is basically create a perverse market by punishing the wrong people for the wrong thing. The hyperscalers are the ones doing the right thing. We should be encouraging them to work within legislation that allows them to Make money, provide a good service, and continue to hold themselves to a high standard while finding ways to ensure that the bad models, which are people are using to run scams, don't find their way into the Australian market. And right now, it is so easy to get one of these models onto a piece of local hardware, your laptop, my laptop, that people should be scared of that, not what's happening in a data center. So two points there. Firstly, I am not surprised that you've got a dodgy guy called Vlad that's doing really weird things on the internet. Secondly But secondly, I am saying what the point I am making is that people see a data center and they see all those fears and that they they see all the issues that haven't been resolved around AI and they see the centre as the embodiment of that. So as I said to Belinda the other week, it's not your fault, but it's your problem. Yeah, absolutely. And and so that is the social license problem. And I I fear the data centers are just going, we'll give a bit of money for the community football club like any other development. It's gonna be okay. They need to do a lot more than that. And and look, let's be honest, data centers, number one thing they should do is spend a little bit of time investing on the exterior facade of data centers. Because if you've been past an XDC data centers, there's no reason to use that much grey paint on one building. Like put something else on it. Like just make it slightly more aesthetically attractive. Community art. Yeah, you put some commun like City of Sydney did this, right? You have to put up archive or artwork if you've got some kind of design contest. Have a design contest. I feel like we're at the point where we need to go have we told you about kiss of death, Amelia? So the kiss of death is our prediction of the week a ahead that normally doesn't come true. And so now there's kind of this Will I know we're doing something we wanna happen, we think will happen or we don't want to happen, because if you say it's gonna happen, chances are it won't happen. But you broke your streak. I did. I broke my streak. I predicted that OpenAI's GPT five point six would be out before the end of next week. And here we are, yesterday and this morning. So what's GPT five point six. So what's your kiss of death this week? Well I'm worried that now I'm gonna like either have to do something really, really good or I am gonna break my streak. Okay. Well come on. So I think I'm gonna move back to the Middle East. I'm gonna take another stab at the Middle East. They're gonna open the straight Super Moose. No, they're definitely not gonna open the Straight Super Moose. My guess is that the price of oil is gonna spike up again by the end of next week, over a hundred and ten US barrel. Like I think there's gonna be a significant spike on the price of oil as a result of the US activities in Iran. That's my kiss of kiss of death. What about yourself? I was in the same boat. I look, Jim Chalmers in his budget had a scenario, the bat the scary scenario where it goes up to two hundred dollars a barrel. Not impossible. Inflation goes to eight percent. Unemployment. Would that make you buy a Tesla out of curiosity? I bought a Chinese. You have a fridge, don't you? You drive a fridge. Yeah, I dri I drive a little BDO. Yeah, that's a fridge. Yeah. happy as. You would never buy another combustion engine? No, I don't think so, would you? I I did intentionally. Why? 'Cause I I w I like to hear an engine roar. Yeah. What about you? What's your kiss to death? I'm guessing that elbow won't go on another podcast in the next week. Very good, Amelia. Hey, thanks for being such a good sport. Lovely to meet you. Thank you for having Amelia, you're incredible. Thank you so much. You're always welcome back on the show. We loved hearing about everything to do with telecommunications, Telstra, data centers. More than ever wanted to know about more than we ever wanted to know about it. Only the nerds care about it. But that's the kind of people who listen to us. Welcome, nerds. as always, if you enjoy the show, like share and subscribe. If you have any feedback, please send it through to us. We appreciate your time as always. And we'll see you next week for another What's Your Poison. Thanks, guys. Thank you.