Episode 15
In-depth on AI after Albo's speech
With Lizzie O'Shea
Show notes
Guest: Lizzie O'Shea - Lawyer and Author.
This week's conversation we really focus on AI, Data Centres, digital rights, technology, and government policy. We explore the complexities of AI, the role of digital rights, and the impact of technology on society. We debate the challenges of centralising policy-making and the commercialisation of technology, the need for a nuanced approach to AI and the importance of considering the diverse applications and implications of tech. Also be sure to listen and subscribe to Burning Platforms
Chapters
- 00:00 Introduction and AI Developments
- 00:50 Choice of Poison and Prime Minister's Speech
- 02:28 Guest Introduction and Digital Rights Watch
- 06:16 AI Regulation and Libertarian Perspectives
- 11:15 Context Collapse and Universal Room
- 12:15 Flattening of Society and Uni Context
- 20:48 AI and Lazy Tendencies
- 26:06 Prime Minister's Speech and AI Policy
- 30:27 The Albo Speech and AI Governance
- 32:21 The Role of AI in Society and Governance
- 53:01 The Chinese Approach to AI
Full transcript
Read itHide it
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.
Damian DamjanovskiWelcome to What's Your Poison, the show where people who disagree agree that it is better to do so over a drink. My name is Damir Damianovsky. I am one of the partners at General Strategic. And as I am every week, I am joined by my evil twin, Mr. Peter Lewis. Peter, lovely to see you at the end of yet another week. How's your week been and what is your poison?
Peter LewisSo hi Dame. It's been quite a week. It was like Hollywood for people who care about AI this week. The PM had his his big speech at the Sydney University, which I attended, and it was the good and the great of people either trying to make money out of AI or people who are trying to work out how to make the whole thing work, probably 50-50 between both. but a really significant moment, I think, in the way that where I'm confronting whatever this thing is and we'll kick that around in a second. But my poison is a Guinness Extra Stout. It's a little bit cool down here on the coast. so I've got a a dark beer. and it's warming the cockles. Yeah. Although I don't have that proper glass. I need to get that. what about you? What was your week? And what's your poison?
Damian DamjanovskiSo you're splitting the G as the kids say. Love a. it was a good week. It was just a work field week. Obviously, I was keeping track of all the AI developments and Prime Minister Albanese's what I would consider uninspiring speech at Sydney University, but we'll get into that in a minute. I have decided for my poison this week, however, to revisit my teenage years. I don't know if you you enjoyed these in your earlier years, Mr. Lewis, but now that it comes in a can, the double vodka cruiser raspri. Which I think has gotten me into more trouble than any other beverage imaginable. It is a sugar hit with a six point out eight percent vodka hit in it. and it's just joy. It's just an alcoholic zuper duper essentially. So
Peter LewisHmm. Let me tell you, I've never been on a cruiser. I've never drunk a cruiser. I've never seen a movie that Tom Cruise has been in. So I'm an anti-cruiser. so.
Damian DamjanovskiTell me about your guest this week. We've got a fascinating guest this week.
Peter LewisYeah, it's a perfect week to have Lizzie O'Shea, who's a good friend of mine. She's a lawyer, an author, an advocate, activist, the founder and chair of Digital Rights Watch, my partner in crime on my other podcast, Burning Platforms, and someone who can't think of a better way of spending a Friday afternoon than two of me. arguing over a drink. So Lizzie, Dame's kind of like a bad version of Dan. So I'm sure you guys are gonna hit it off just well. so welcome. And what's your poison?
LizzieThank thanks for having me. I'll say that with an question mark at the end of the thanks. no, it's good to be here on a crossover episode. I my poison today, I'm here to normalise not drinking on a Friday afternoon. So I'm actually drinking a raspberry flavoured mineral water. there are other reasons I'm currently it's enforced the brothers. I I do think there's some utility in thinking that drinking is not the only way to socialise. in Australia, even though everybody seems to
Peter LewisYes, it's in forced sobriety, isn't it, at the moment for you, Lizzie?
Lizziethink that it is. But yeah, I'm pregnant. So that's part of the problem, I suppose, with drinking. but I haven't got too much
Peter LewisPeople just judge if you drink too many, don't they?
LizzieYeah, it's yeah. Anyway, it's actually
Damian DamjanovskiTo to borrow the wise words of Tim Wilson, it's not my pro it's not my fault you're pregnant. Like it's I'm not to blame for you being pregnant, it's your own it's your own damn fault.
LizzieThat's correct. It's definitely not either of your faults that I'm pregnant and it's certainly not Tim Wilson's fault either.
Peter LewisYeah.
Lizzieyeah, I definitely brought this on myself. So I'm just getting through it. But yeah, pregnancy's not particularly fun, but I've only got a good three and a bit months to go. So yeah, but it's been a it's been a big week, obviously. If you're interested in AI, we've been following that at Digital Rights Watch and there's lots to talk about, which I suppose is what we're here to do now.
Damian DamjanovskiSo so Lizzie, tell me a little bit about Digital Rights Watch and kind of w where it came from and w what its mission is. Like what what is a digital's right d what is digital rights watch for people who who may not have heard of it and may not be particularly in depth in this space?
LizzieMm. Great. Yeah, so Digital Rights Watch is a civil society organization. We campaign for freedom, fairness, and fundamental rights for people who engage in the online world. So generally what we try to do is bring a human rights approach to technology policy making. We do that through campaigning, through writing submissions, through all sorts of other activities in partnership with other civil society organizations. generally our focus has been directing that advocacy towards large tech companies who hold considerable power and finding ways to
Damian DamjanovskiAnd through alliteration.
Lizzieattack that and decentralize that power in favor of everyday people, but also as against government. So we came about really as a result of, we've been around for about 10 years, as a result of trying to organize some advocacy to protect privacy, particularly against national security legislation, which, you know, at least 10 years ago, Australia was very active in legislating around national security. I think we passed over a hundred bills in the 15 or so years after 9-11. And you know, there was a a a big push in part because Australia doesn't have a Human Rights Act. We're the only liberal democracy that doesn't. And so there's not this regime or this culture of protecting rights. There's less of that now these days, although we do do work on national security and defending privacy, but we often do it in relation to online safety, trying to have a a human rights compliant approach to online safety. that protects rights like privacy, like freedom of expression, as well as you know, public participation and and being able to be in some of these online spaces safely. Also, obviously we're at campaigning for privacy reform because we're concerned about data extractive business models that give rise to all sorts of negative consequences in our online life. And obviously then also what we're going to talk about, I'm sure, today more is AI regulation, which in the last few years of course has been growing in its intensity as a field of policy making. and w we've been campaigning on on some of those issues to try and make sure that harms are elevated, companies are held accountable.
Peter LewisSo a lot of this stuff I would imagine a libertarian like you, Dame, would be all up for privacy, not having the government monitoring you. Like it it's not a left right thing here.
Damian DamjanovskiIt's a i i i I mean, I don't think it is a left-right thing. It depends on how you view it from a libertarian perspective, not that I'm pa painting myself as a libertarian. I would argue it depends on whether or not the service that a person is engaging with is something they're voluntarily doing with their eyes open as to what they're giving up in exchange for that service that's usually provided free or at low cost. Or whether it's a service they don't have a choice on, such as interacting with government through digital services. I think they're not it's not fair to necessarily equate them because people should have some responsibility and take some responsibility for what they use and how they use it. They're we we we can't be treated with with, you know, kid gloves on everything to be like, well, I use this thing, but the thing did that thing to me that I knew it was gonna do because it was free, so I need someone to come intervene and stand up for me.
LizzieCan I just ask though, there's one other thing that I thought I'd just raise with you. So my the other laugh that I've got is that I'm actually a class actions lawyer and I end up suing a lot of large technology companies, for example. So, you know, one of those matters concerns suing Google and Apple for anti-competitive behavior. And one of the things I think that the right often does agree with in relation to the technology sector is that the system of markets doesn't really operate in the way that it should because there's this this tendency towards monopolization. These companies are so large and they acquire their competitors, they acquire anyone who who might have a product that they want rather than develop it in-house. That's often been a a mode of operating. And there are two kind of schools of thought, I think, when it comes to people who are really committed to market capitalism. Some people think that that kind of competition element is critically important for its functionality. But you know the Peter Teals of the world do do not do not believe in competitive capitalism. He thinks Competition's kind of for losers. I think that's a direct quote, but I'm sure you'll sue me if I'm wrong. I do wonder what you think about that.
Damian DamjanovskiHm. It's it's it's No, on it's a great question. So I'm I I'm not I'm I'm not aware of the the class action lawsuit. So what was the what was the anti competitive behavior that
LizzieSo it concerned the provision of services in the app stores. So it came out of Epic Games. If anyone's a gamer who's listening to the show, they'll they'll know Epic Games. Exactly. So Epic was deplatformed. They they claim that that fees charged by both Ga Apple and Google relating to app stores. Exactly. And so that's gone to judgment in Australia. I mean there'll there's bits and pieces on appeal. It's it's a it's a large and complex piece of litigation.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. So this is the fortn the fortnight issue. Yeah. We're exorbitant. Yeah.
LizzieBut some of those questions I think are a concern for the right. Like centralization of technology power is, according to some right wing ideologies, not a good thing for the economy or society. Right. And I think that's the other place where we often find common cause with conservatives and the like who, you know, even yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. I think so I would never call myself a classical like sorry, like a conservative in the entirely classical sense. I'm probably a weird blend of progressive on some issues, conservative on others, libertarian on others. My my confused or yeah. J I I think I I won't harp on this for too long.
Peter LewisConfused. No overriding worldview.
LizzieHa ha
Damian DamjanovskiBut ultimately, th these market dynamics and these monopolizations don't kind of happen in a vacuum where these big companies are just becoming monopolies out of anywhere. Google became what Google is because they genuinely offered a better product and service and invested in good products and services. Apple charges a premium and charges for managing the App Store and takes a cut on it so that it can ensure that if something goes wrong, it can issue a refund, that there's, you know, correct procedures in place, and because they manage the whole app store. And anyone who's used Android and it's like you know, free-for-all bizarre style app store versus Apple's cathedral-walled garden approach knows the difference between those two. And I don't think it's fair that when, you know, these people develop really good products and the entire market goes, we love that product, we're all gonna buy that product. No one's forcing you to. There's plenty of competitors out there. If you're choosing not to use it and we all choose that, yep, that's the product we want to use, then why shouldn't they get be rewarded for it? Why should they then be penalized for creating good products that people want to use. So that that's where I I'm not sure I I do. But again, I could be flattening the issue, which I know Mr. Lewis, both curious on your perspective on this, but obviously you sent me quite an interesting article about this whole I don't want to do the reveal too quickly, but this idea of a a uni, a uni context, which kind of ties into this in an interesting way.
Peter LewisMm. Yeah, neat segue there. So it's the notion of flattening. So there's been this notion around for a while called context collapse, which is the idea of flattening culture that you see. Like why does every cafe look the same? Why is everyone listening to the same music? Why do all sports teams like the global sports, another example? but the piece I sent you was A guy, Derek Thompson, who's a journo, who actually wrote the book Abundance with Ezra Klein, that I kind of loved before I hated. but he had did an interview with a philosopher this week called Agnes Collard, and it was really interesting. So the idea of the uni context, which is not just the flattening of culture, but the flattening of norms and behaviors and everything, because we are now living in what she calls a universal room. So the big shift is from This idea that you had different identities and different context to your life as someone in the community, someone in the workplace, someone in their family or in their church. It's all the one big thing now, but it's also global. And so it just changes the way that we make sense of the world. And it I don't know. I sent it to you and you sent me back a note saying I read this article at 2:30 in the morning while I was in the middle of the night. sleeplessness, it blew my mind. What did it do to you?
Damian DamjanovskiFor it was I found it really fascinating because I I harp on about this kind of flattening of society and this kind of erring towards the middle. And I obviously look at it through the lens of government is amplifying that approach by basically trying to rough like take off all the rough edges of society and ensure we are all as close to the center as we possibly can be, because you know, we'll we'll all be safer and more joyful if we are all Nine to five bureaucrats who pay a median amount of tax, live in a median-sized house, use a median amount of social media, and contribute in a median way before we die, right? Like to me, it's a world that basically the economists and accountants have won. Right? It's like we've decided that the economists and accountants are right. Every single pub needs to be a Justin Hems venue. Yeah, it's like everything needs to be a Hems venue, and we are all in an endless Westfield, right? It's it's a
Peter LewisMm. Measurement is God. Yeah.
LizzieMm.
Damian Damjanovskibringing to life of that wonderful Pixar movie Wally, where we all just become these kind of fat consumers who go into whatever the latest trend is. And it's always bothered me and I'm not sure I can fully articulate why, but that article I think helped me to adopt some language that puts a name to some of the things I feel about this.
Peter LewisLizzie will tell you I'm a bit of an intellectual tart, so I get onto an idea and just sort of go in deep. and this one has really got me. So what it says to me is that it's so but part of the theory is that because everything's the one context, you've got to group to make sense of the world, you group group into identity. so you you can measure things, you can understand things because otherwise it's all too overwhelming. Whereas in the past where you had before, when you had multiple contexts, it was more nuanced and it was all based around a relationship. It's almost the the the triumph of qual over quant. So you make sense of the world by measuring, putting it in a box, building, you know, a persona around it, rather than being open to divergent. Yeah, yeah. And and that that real idea of friction. And so I thought it was interesting also in politics, because I I feel this that quant that the numbers are much more important than the qual, but the truth actually lies in the qual. So and and the w the last bit I'll say to you just to bounce yeah. Sorry, go on.
Damian DamjanovskiDivergent thoughts, views, opinions there. Yeah yeah. And and just to just for for any listeners sorry, just Peter Lewis said qual over quant, and I think what you meant to say is the triumph of quant over qual, just for point of clarity.
Peter LewisYeah, but I I'm but my pony is qual, like, which is it it in practice it means listening to people, understanding how they work rather than just looking at the abstraction. So it's going in deeper. But the other bit, Dame, that I thought was interesting in there was the idea not just of the flattening of culture, but the flattening of strategy. So everyone and they they use the example in a sports team, if you if you everyone is being based on their stats and the strategies to preference the stats become king. Whereas
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisin a divergence you used to have outliers who change change the game, for instance. So I think that's interesting in politics as well. And the I I it doesn't give here you go.
Damian Damjanovskiyeah. And I well I mean it rises populism. Lizzie, your thoughts on this before we
LizzieCan I s I struggle to get past with Agnes Cullard, I struggled to get past that twenty twenty three New Yorker article. I don't know whether either of you two have re read it, but sh it was it went viral for a while 'cause she just seems like
Peter LewisThis is what normally happens with my big ideas as well. Lizzie puts a pin in them because they're
Lizzieshe's just got she's she seems like a slightly irritating person, I have to say. Like so the New Yorker article, you can read it if you want, but it involves how she's separated from her husband and took up with a grad student who now lives with them and raises the kid together. And like she was dragged online. I know, it feels r it feels wrong to raise this, but it feels wrong to ignore it because I I bring it I just bring it in terms of my understanding of who she is. Anyway, like I think there's probably something to be said about
Peter LewisI think you're playing the woman, not the idea here, Lizzie.
Lizziephilosophers being all a bit eccentric in their own funny way. So I'm not I don't mean to be totally distracting on it. I do think there's a book, like I read a book from when I was at Columbia, there was a law prof called Bernard Harcourt. He's still there, right? But he he wrote a really good book in 2015 called Exposed and Desire and Disobedience in the digital age. And he sort of talked about this then in twenty fifteen about how it's very difficult To have an identity online that doesn't collapse all of your identities into a single version of yourself. So you guys think about it in terms of research. I think about it as how you appear in the online world. And like I think it was my sister said to me, she did she very early was like, I can't be on Facebook because what can you post on Facebook that absolutely everybody you know you think you would want them to see? Someone is gonna think that's stupid or irrelevant or overly serious, overly earnest, right? And so your whole way of engaging with the online world is through this single contextless identity, right? And then when you're scrolling some of these feeds, you see all this material. You see like a fitness influencer, you see animal rescue, you see children dying in Gaza, like all in the same feed. None of it is contextualized.
Peter LewisContextualized.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd and and hang on it, to to be fair to the tech giants, like for more than half of its lifetime, Facebook very distinctly had a set of tools to allow people to differentiate. These are my work people, these are my close family. And it's just it's one of those things but nobody u nobody used any of these features, right? It's and and yeah.
Peter LewisYeah, that was the good old days.
LizzieWell and they they actively collapsed it. So they they made a decision to collapse it together. And I remember being in a I went to a consultation once with them at a an international internet governance forum and I said, Why would you collapse all accounts into a single format? And they said to me, the users have asked us for it. And I I just knew that wasn't true, right? Like so they have a way of of structuring your identity that doesn't suit you necessarily, it doesn't give you choice. but it does mean it's harder to kind of live a more complex, diverse, distinctive life and And for all and and it it it takes other forms, right? Like some of the cancel culture stuff that lots of people don't like, being able to identify somebody in all their different contexts is made possible through that format too. So it becomes this you cannot say anything that that might be offensive in some other context. That's right.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Which means you err towards the middle and and and l so Lizzie, do you long for the days of the fa the MySpace top eight friends where you could be very explicit about the people th as they were file ranked in your life?
LizzieI long for the days in which my cultural consumption wasn't categorized by strong female lead. Do you know what I mean? Like I I long for the days where you would encounter different kinds of personalities of people that you used to do in lots of different environments. Some of them were online, some of them are offline. And the other thing I I feel really sad about is that there's this huge imp push to find it much more convenient to engage with a frictionless system of online research. things that you might otherwise have normally gotten from friends. So if you want to work out what to listen to next, what to read next, where to go on your next holiday and plan an itinerary, you don't call your friends and talk about it. You're encouraged to type that into an AI interface and get it get a result back, right? And that to me is very sad.
Damian DamjanovskiBut but but this is but but again, I I I totally get what you're saying, but this is all a reflection of human b like humans are fundamentally lazy. The reason we invented agriculture and animal husbandry was because we didn't want to have to keep going out and finding one or two carrots or going out on an expedition to get one antelope. We are a lazy species who will always prioritize convenience over the hard thing. And that's what's got us to where we are today.
Peter LewisDo you reckon you're building your view of humanity based on your own lived experience there, Darwin? 'Cause I don't know if history is a story of laziness, is it?
LizzieI mean
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. It is. W w wh why did we do agriculture? Because we were like, you know what, this is like the the advent of agriculture was we didn't want to have to keep going out and like hunting for food. We w it can be. Not always, but it can be.
LizzieDo you think efficiency is lazy? I agree, but like there's also like kind of diverse ways of thinking, innovation, like all of the social research will tell you diverse ways of thinking give rise to better results, right? Like across lots of experiments. So how do you cultivate that?
Damian DamjanovskiSure. But but but if humans weren't if we
Peter LewisAnd that kind of goes back
Damian Damjanovskiweren't
Peter Lewisto the uni that goes back to the uni context and maybe a jump off because I think I think where it lands is that categorizing everything and trying to have this universal truth is really what the hyperscalers are trying to do with AI and the large language models. So maybe just to end this bit up, Samai, so is then AI the triumph of our lazy tendencies and what are, you know, and then what is the cholesterol?
LizzieRight.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Yeah, yeah. So I like like absolutely so I I want to throw to Lizzie. My my only comment on this is yes and no, that like every tool, there will be a distribution bell curve where the vast majority of people in the middle will err towards whatever the laziest option is because they're human and because like most people, they're worried about paying their mortgage, feeding their kids, living about their life.
Peter Lewisyou know, feedback loop gonna do there. And scrawling slop.
Damian DamjanovskiScrolling slop, right? Again, like e if people weren't lazy, dentists wouldn't exist. Do you know what I mean? Like, if people weren't lazy, dentistry would not exist as a profession. We'd all do the things that we all know and have known for 50 dec five decades that we need to do, and there'd be like one dentist for every hundred thousand people. We don't. And the same thing with these AI tools is the vast majority of people will use them in a lazy way, exactly like Lizzie says, where they will go.
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian DamjanovskiWhat should I listen to next? What should I cook for dinner? That's not necessarily what the tool is there for, but if that's how people choose to use it, well, they're free citizens. Let them choose to use it that way.
Peter LewisGuns don't kill ducks, ducks kill ducks.
Damian DamjanovskiNo guns can guns can kill ducks, that's for sure, but ducks also kill ducks. Both of those things are true.
LizzieWhat's the document for here? Sorry, I'm not
Peter LewisI don't know. I I feel like Dame's blaming the victims, saying we give them these really dumb tools, we induce them to use them and that shows they're lazy.
Damian DamjanovskiNo, we give them incredible tools, Peter. But but but Peter, we give them these incredible tools. We give them 15 years of development. It is an incredible tool. All of these models are incredible tools that literally trillions of dollars, an incredible amount of research and thought has gone into. Hang on, hang on. All of this technology has gone into figuring out how to turn sequences of words into numbers that then computers can process on your little laptop. Like it is an incredible hang on.
Peter LewisClaw's not an incredible tool. Like, it's not I told ya he was the bad Dan Lizzie. Yeah. But why is that good?
Damian DamjanovskiBecause it's an incredible feat of technology and then people use it to ask really dumb questions and go, what should I cook for dinner? And it's like, can you use the tool for that? Absolutely. I could also use depleted uranium to heat up my food. Should I? No. But it's there and it's always warm. And you know, I guess it's got a few bad side products, but I that it's so much quicker than the oven and I don't have to think about it. And so is the tool to blame for that?
Peter LewisBe ye not allowed to Is he?
LizzieI think you're very you're contextless about how tools are created though, Dame, right? Because then they don't come out of nowhere. There's a whole process by which these products are created for human consumption. There's a design element and a decision, right? So they're they're trying to commodify your experience for their benefit. They're not trying to give you a tool that is useful. Their objective is not to make you a better person. It is to make money off you. So they do that by picking. We've accepted
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, absolutely.
LizzieI mean, some of us have accepted that that's a legitimate way to create technology and it's the best way to create some people think it's the best way to create technology. I don't agree. Some of the greatest innovations of technology have come through people doing things not for profit at all, right? And so it's just not that there's a universal the Linux open source kernel that is the the kernel of supercomputers that is the basis for Android operating systems, it its foundations are in open source
Damian DamjanovskiG give us a couple of examples of Lizzie, so we can we can discuss with examples.
LizzieSoftware development, right? So, I mean, there's there's a million examples, right? But the the point is that assuming the commodification of technology produces good outcomes for humans, for whom this was pushed upon, or that it's the best way to d design technology, both of them are false, in my view. And to think like that misses the opportunities of humanity at its best. when we don't allow mega corporations just to exploit us for profit. So that's the world I want to build where we have the opportunity to explore alternatives.
Damian DamjanovskiSure. But but but just to build on that analogy, and Linux is a great example of it, Linus as a researcher, developed Linux as an open source technology, but didn't distribute it. The same way that the Transformer white papers were developed as an open source white paper. Red Hat and others who are commercial organizations then turned that into a tool that put it on millions of devices, the same way OpenAI and Anthropic and Google and everyone else turned the Transformer white papers into functional LLM products. Having the idea and going, this is a cool thing.
LizzieSure.
Damian DamjanovskiIs not the same as going, this is a commercial product that now needs to be able to make money. And to make money, you have to cater to obviously a large market where you gotta go by the bell curve and go, there's a lot of people who are gonna use this for silly stuff. There's some people gonna use it for amazing stuff, and there's gonna be some people who use it for really, really bad stuff. So, how do we protect against the bad stuff, enable the amazing stuff, and cater to the middle where they just wanna use it to know what's for dinner?
Peter LewisYou you've basically just given Albo's boring speech this week, Darmay. Like I know you said it was boring, but that was actually in a nutshell what the Prime Minister got up for his first first speech at his old arma matter, a very important event for him. And he basically said, I'm not an AI, but on the one hand.
LizzieHa ha
Damian DamjanovskiHa ha ha. Three hundred meters from where we grew up in housing commission.
LizzieYeah.
Peter LewisBut on the other hand, and everyone said, yes, we agreed there is a one hand and the other hand. It was actually quite an interesting moment in that the Prime Minister got up and said this is complicated and Prime Ministers never get up and say that. Sorry, I'm just intervening in your trip down Linux to get to the eight pre PM speech before it's too late.
LizzieYeah.
Damian DamjanovskiThe the And and no, it's th that's alright. Look, there there's probably a fair bit of our audience who are huge Lin Linux fans, so you know, sho shout out to all the nerds out there. Yeah. I'll put on a bulletin board somewhere. I I do think the speech was boring, but not because it was a a dull speech, which it was. It was this sudden realization by Albert, like it was a call to arms if you listen to his language about, you know.
Peter LewisJust cut that little bit up and put it on LinkedIn. You know, that's all you need. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiWe created Medicare and we're gonna create like and what people need to remember is this technology is almost fifteen years old, like 10 years old from Transformers at this point, right? 15 to 10 years old, depending on what point you start thinking about the modern version of what we now call AI. This is not a thing that turned up yesterday, but the government's acting as if it's coming, which is this crazy reframing of like, we need to do all this stuff now so we can be prepared for AI. It's like, guys, we The train left a long time ago. What you're seeing is like the fourth train coming up the road now. Like we have we are well past that. Australia hasn't even remotely invested.
Peter LewisYeah, all the big decisions were made when the Morrison government was in power, you're saying, like which was no decisions.
Damian Damjanovskiw no, well before then. No, well, well before then, to be honest. Like well before then. Like it would have been like 2017 is when a lot of these decisions should have been made. Yeah, yeah. But Turnbull Turnbull is when these decisions yeah, yeah, of course, yeah. For that and not having a fiber optic MBN. Here we still are. The greatest infrastructure this country should have had, which is an all fiber internet, we still don't have. Right? And again, I'm not I'm not I'm not one team enough to say that we did it right.
Peter LewisThat's right. You only had three years in power, yeah. so you're blaming Turnbull. You're blaming Turnbull.
LizzieMm.
Damian DamjanovskiYou you're doing it wrong. It's we did it wrong. Like I I'm a Australian man.
Peter LewisWere you a turnball man? So you're not a turnful man.
Damian DamjanovskiJust an Australian man.
Peter LewisWhat did you make of this fetch, Lizzie?
LizzieI find it so funny talking to people about this speech because it's a bit like like an inkblot test or it's like when I I'd I hadn't seen the Barbie movie and I go, What do people think of the Barbie movie? Some once someone said to me, it's it's you know, it's an ad for a commercial product. Someone else said to me, it's a movie about slavery. someone else said to me it's a woman a movie about feminism. And I was like, What is this movie about? And I feel the same I mean, it turns out it was about all those things, but I feel like it's the same with this speech. Like I talked to one person who's like, That is a we're open for business speech. I talked to somebody else going, Wow, he's really standing behind copyright and protecting artists. And then I talked to you guys and he's like, that was nothing burger. And I was like, what is it? Like on one level, I think I don't I I'm fine with the idea of an office of AI because there are a lot of people making policy about AI across a lot of ministries. There's some utility in it being centralized. That may be a good decision. Let's see, right? And I also think some of the talk around the risks is kind of novel language. Like one of the things that I talk about
Peter LewisMm.
Damian DamjanovskiMm.
LizzieIn relation to speech is when when we talk about AI, people can be thinking of a weapon system. They can be thinking of a tool they use at work for productivity. They can be thinking about a chatbot that their kid spends ages on that they're worried about. Those things are all AI. And so when the government says, it's this productivity benefit, maybe they're thinking about the chatbot. And when they say, it's something really dangerous, they might be thinking about something that helps them plan an itinerary, right? Like so there's this real chaos around how you talk about it.
Peter LewisMm.
LizzieAnd I was relieved to see an acknowledgement that there's risks and harms we have to manage, because too often that's not been part of the productivity discussion. And then I'm sort of relieved to see a plan for centralization of policymaking. I mean, I think every tech company now is planning how they're gonna lobby to the PM Direct and how they're going to position themselves in relation to data centers, because that's the other big thing that came out of the
Peter LewisHmm. Mm.
Lizzieof the speech. We're we're fast tracking you know, creation of this infrastructure. So the industry is going to be mobilizing, I think, to kind of work out how they can influence that process of policy making, which causes me concern. but yeah, it's it's sort of hard to remove everything at once.
Damian DamjanovskiThis is Yeah.
Peter LewisCan I just say to both your points? So I think in Albo's head, and that this is his Hawk Kedding moment, that this change is coming, I can't stop it. which I I think is still open to debate, but they've made the decision there is benefit if they do it right and they can't stop it. but also, Lizzie, I was just thinking about this over the last day. I think what he's done is what I sort of say. Everyone should do, which is start with the points we all agree on, and then we can interrogate the friction without everyone hating on each other. So he gave this speech where he gave the bit for everyone to say, this is the moment wherein it's complicated, there are benefits, there are risks, and I'm gonna take responsibility. That I th I think that's all it was, and now the hard work begins. But I do think I'll give credit to them for that, that they've said.
Damian DamjanovskiMm.
Peter LewisLet's get everyone on the same page. Let's take responsibility. And now there's a lot of stuff that you need to think through. And that's going to be the real test to the government because he's put his hand up to do it.
Damian DamjanovskiSee, I'd argue that this is another one of those moments where not only is this and previous governments behind severely and somehow think that you know what, this problem needs more bureaucrats. That's who's gonna solve the complex issues. Well, that's that's the only thing he announced. The only thing he announced was an office of AI.
Peter LewisBut that's not what he was saying. He was just saying he was actually less he was actually saying less bureaucrats because the like I think I don't know, tell me if you disagree with me on this. my criticism of the sh the pivot in the Albanese government from the Ed Husick push to get an AI act up, turning that into no, we will just deal with it as things emerge. I think they've worked out they've overcorrected. And you can argue whether or not a piece of legislation will be enough to get our act together, but it is a really good organizing principle because everything rises to the surface and you've got to deal with it. But where they've ended up is nothing's really happening. There's bits happening in AGs, bits happening in comms, bits happening in Treasury. And so someone needs to pull it all together. And so I think that like what would you have done differently if if you'd won the last two elections with the great Scott Morrison? What would you be doing now different to this?
Damian DamjanovskiIf I were advising any prime minister right now on AI, my one, two, and three priorities would be number one, how do we ensure that we have sovereign AI capability that is not just us borrowing or distilling or utilizing and fine-tuning someone else's model, but have our Australian capability that is close to on par with the frontier models? And then secondly, How do we reduce the energy requirements of running these frontier models so that we don't necessarily need the level of infrastructure at today's levels? Like they're the two races you'd want to be racing right now, which is a bit of the American race and a bit of the Chinese race. If you can combine those two things together, and you know what? And I know Albo talks about, we need to make a great path for investment in Australian AI from overseas investors. We don't need overseas investors. We've got a lot of Australian investors. We've got a lot we trillions sitting in super. We just need to invest it in the right stuff. We should be investing in our own capability. But if there's not a legislative environment where local people like innovators here can actually profit from innovating, they're gonna go to the US, they're gonna go to China, they're gonna go to France.
Peter LewisThey can't go to the US anymore 'cause th they've outw lived their welcome there.
Damian DamjanovskiWow, th there's other countries they can go to. There's plenty of countries who are investing heavily in AI. We're one of the only ones who is still talking about how do we create the regulatory environment to encourage investment from other third parties. Like we are n we are nowhere near this party. We are so far behind on it. And this announcement means we're
Peter LewisThat's not the mail you get though. That's not the mail you get. That they that hyperscalers need a stable democracy with renewable energy to run their their training models. And there aren't many you know, there's potentially Norway with wind, there's potentially Canada, and there's us. They're the only three that seem to be in the game.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. And I I'm curious for Liz's perspective, and the only thing I'll add is this is the I think this is similar to what we did with nuclear energy, where we said, No, we need to slow it down. We're not gonna touch this, we're gonna block it down. and we go f thirty, forty, fifty years later and we miss the train on it. But Lizzie, you're very curious for your much more learned thoughts on this.
LizzieI mean, I've got a lot of views about nuclear as well. I'm not sure we missed the train, I have to tell you. I th I don't think that's Yeah, like we applied the rev the revolutionary break, right? Like to borrow a Marx Walter Benjamin intersection there. But maybe that's not Dame's field of philosophy. But what I was gonna say was I don't see this friction as being necessarily a problem. Like I don't, I don't
Peter LewisOr avoided the avoided okay.
LizzieLike the the reality is, I mean you've you've I'm sure you've talked about this on the show before, but Australians are the least optimistic about AI, right? We have very low rates of trust. We use it a lot, but we don't particularly like it. So how do you get the benefit out of this technology in circumstances like that? I think you have to instill a program of trust, of confidence that it's properly regulated, because otherwise you don't get take up and use. I don't think anybody wants Australia to be a big humming data center for the world, much in the same way that Australians don't want To be the nuclear waste dump of the world. Do you know what I mean? So I think there's a there's something to be said for a more reflective, slow approach. I don't think it's necessarily a failure. and in fact, it may pay dividends in the long run because it it enables trust. Like most of the polling suggests, if you look at the United States, people do not want to reproduce what is going on over there here. And that includes things like Colossus, you know, the largest data center in the US, which is owned by. Elon Musk's corporation, which is rented by Anthropic for over a billion.
Peter LewisThat's not a negative for Darma. He hung out with him at the Byron Bay Music Festival, so Splendor.
LizzieTo Elon or somebody else? Okay,
Damian DamjanovskiSplendor. Elon. I hung out with him. I said hello.
Lizziewell Okay, as long as you as long as you didn't take whatever it was offering, because I'm not sure the ketamine's assisted Elon's thinking capacity. But the the point I'm making is they rent they pay at one and a quarter billion dollars a month to rent capacity from Colossus. It's a disgusting data center that is using fossil fuels despite promises that it wouldn't it's ruining the local community's quality of life, water supply, all this stuff. I th I think people don't think that's a good model, right? So we're gonna have to do work to bring them along on the journey if we wanna do use this tech and make the most of it. So you can't, there's no shortcuts to that by saying just trust us. This is great, and you'll love it in the end, because that does not work. I think that is the foundation for mistrust in both government and also the tech and the industry.
Damian DamjanovskiIt's a good point. It's but but Lizzie, just to ask you on that one. So, I mean, Australia's ranked the number one user by anthropic in the world per capita, right? So their data, and I'm not talking about polling job, I'm talking their actual corporate data, says that Australia, regardless of how people say they feel, is top of the pops for usage of these AI systems. We we are huge adopters of this overseas tech. We have no influence on it. When Fable got switched off, the new anthropic model. Well we were just left in the dark with, I think, an hour's notice or two hours' notice or something. So should we not have some level of control, input, sovereignty over these kind like, is that not important? And my second part to that question I'd love to not debate, 'cause we're we're never in in this show here trying to necessarily convince one another, but always to kind of express opinions, is I I get that people get scared about data centers because they sound scary and they look scary. They you know They don't have a dark harm. Anyone who's actually gone to a data center goes, okay, it's just like every other warehouse building. Some are bigger, some are smaller, whatever. But when you have data centers, which is not just computing AI, but doing a lot of stuff, there's other things that you're no longer doing because that data center's allowing a thing to happen. So for example, in the world of AI, if the data center means that you can use AI to ask and get a reasonable response on a medical question. You may not have gone to the GP and gotten your question that way, which means A, you would have saved money, B, you didn't have to drive over to the G. Like, there are second and third order consequences where it's unfair to just purely measure the societal and carbon footprint impact of a data center and go, well, that's purely bad, and not take into consideration, well, hang on a minute. What is the other activities in second and third order that are now being abated by the fact that people are using these tools?
LizzieYeah, how you measure stuff to return to where we started is quite important if you think measuring stuff is really important because there's third order production issues associated with large language models or generative AI products, including data extraction, data labeling, which is largely ignored by the industry, which is often done in conditions of tantamount to slavery, for example. Like if you if you read any accounts of it, just horrific human consequences.
Damian DamjanovskiThe somewhere in Africa in a you know, bat battery yeah.
Lizziei in Latin America in all sorts of places. And in fact quite predatory. Like as in these companies will look for places of economic crisis and then set up shop and offer jobs doing data labeling and cleaning. Sorry, my cat who's got his own opinions about this about this pr this this NATO. So you know
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. That's all right. Clearly. But you know, the this is this is also how
Peter LewisJust her?
Damian Damjanovskiwe get chocolate and coffee and we we don't seem to have minded for the past five hundred years.
LizzieAll all true, right? So how you measure this stuff is quite important. And I don't think we should necessarily accept the industry's figures on that. I think there's a real role for government to play in offering measurement tools or whatever for assessing some of these opportunities in a realistic manner. And so that's that's also what I'm arguing for. Like fast tracking this process, making a bunch of policy decisions behind closed doors does not necessarily guarantee good policy. does not invite the public in and take them on a journey as to why this might be needed. And that I think you can pay a price for that. New York has just announced the state of New York's just announced a moratorium on data center construction. They don't want them. So like do is that what is that what we're gonna head for if we don't do this work of public consultation first?
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter LewisSo kind of back to the ALBO speech, like the politics of this is pretty wicked. the politics of being seen to be pushing new developments around data centers is hard. The politics of explaining why you're gonna put more burden on the energy grid is hard. And then the other hard bit that we haven't kind of got to yet is that the most culturally literate people in the country. performers and media feel deeply aggrieved that the whole show is being run on the theft of their labor, which again, if we if we're getting it down into second and third level level layers, that is actually the pushback on copyright, that this technology has stolen our work and now it's being used to give people the tools to do it in a shittier way because people, as you say, dumb are lazy. in a way that obliterates all that creative work. So you can see why this is a really and Australia's got better copyright laws than most. And I'm sure Lizzie will also not carry a torch for copyright because it's not the best hill to die on. But that's the hill where a lot of these negotiations are going to be played. And God love the creators, they push back hard. And it also means now there's a leverage point for the government around copyright in terms of setting the terms on which these companies will operate in Australia.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd Peter, it may or may not shock you to know this, and it's a wonderful segue into my second what's your poison drink for the week. I I actually agree with you here, and I I'm gonna explain why, but to show how I agreed with you, I would like to let you know that I'm drinking a silky red blend called Cali by Snoop.
Peter LewisStout.
Damian DamjanovskiWho knew that Snoop Dogg had an Australian silky red blend wine? And I tell you what, it's not terrible. It's it's it's it's perfectly drinkable. So so I I actually agree with you so far as if a any AI, and it's not just AI, but any tech or media company wants to use creative copyrighted materials to train on.
Peter LewisI think That's gonna be ironic. That is gonna be ironic.
Damian DamjanovskiThey should have to pay a fee to train on it. The creator should have the option to not have their work trained on. And they should be able to track whether or not it was trained on it and what it got extracted from it. And there should be a reasonably simple system to do that that isn't automatically weighted towards the larger copyright holders like big record labels, but should be able to extend to large and small creators, writers, all that kind of thing. That to me seems perfectly reasonable.
LizzieYou do need Yeah. You do need a kind of big government to do that, I reckon, don't I? Just for the record. Because what you're talking about sort of sounds a bit like because say something like the public lending right is is kind of like that. Like I'm I'm gonna butcher it, I'm sure somebody who's an expert in copyright will tell you so
Damian DamjanovskiW why is that?
LizzieAfter you publish this. But essentially, like if my book gets borrowed from the library a certain number of times, I get paid a sum of money that is reflective of that, right? So you've got the infrastructure to be able to do that collection, that distribution. It's frictionless for me because I've just registered my book, right? And so you do need people advocating, you know, not just the the big four, big three, big two, eventually publishing houses, right? But actually for individual creators to have access to that that kind of compensation does require.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Yeah. Highly.
Lizziegovernment to do that work. It's a it's a state enforced monopoly over a product. So I'm just I'm just explaining to you for someone who maybe doesn't like government interfering into the market, you're asking for
Damian DamjanovskiI don't know. Yeah. Well I I think there's peak b I think there's peak bodies who do this well and do it a lot more efficiently than government does. And I'd argue that if on the one side
LizzieNo, but but the law requires the creation of a monopoly.
Peter LewisThere's peak bodies, there's international rights holders, and then there's individual performers as well. And I think part of the challenge the government's got as well is that, as I said before, this is not just intellectual for creators, it's emotional. And there's been that so what is the reparations for the theft? Like because there the the the companies are up front, they've stolen the stuff to train their models. Then there is the compensation of whether or not you want to opt in, but that's chicken feed.
LizzieMm.
Peter LewisLike it's like little bits, micro payments. And then there's what is the wealth out of this? But you're group you're building good models off the back of good culture. So what is the ongoing model to fund culture out of all this? Like it's a lot more than just a compensation or licensing deal, don't you? Like
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, but ar arguing whether or not they're paying versus how much
LizzieOr journalism.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, but Baslo Baz Lerman doesn't pay ongoing royalties to the estate of William Shakespeare because he readapted Romeo and Juliet. Yes, he was inspired by it, but he made money off it in a different way. Should he pay for Romeo and Juliet royalties? No no no, you're you're but you're assuming it is because the actor.
Peter LewisBut that's different to a machine taking bouncing off the culture. Like this this trope that every bit every creator builds off culture and therefore it's not worth anything. Like that's that doesn't stand up. This is different. Like
Damian DamjanovskiBut the machine doesn't build without a human actor asking it to do a thing. The machine Yeah.
Peter LewisPutting something in the prompt, write me write me a book in the style of Lizzie O'Shea. Like yeah, like no.
LizzieI don't think everyone anyone's entered that prompt, I have to say, but what
Damian DamjanovskiHa ha ha ha.
Lizziewhat what I would say is I don't I don't know. Look, I I feel like I'm gonna do a Bernie Sanders thing. I think we can all agree that we want artists to be able to produce work and get get paid for it, right? I think we can all agree that we need high quality news content because none of these generative models will work without proper news content generated by quality journalism. outfits by people who are paid to do the job properly because otherwise it's just becomes an engine of miss and disinformation. So how do we pay those people? How do we subsidize that? Maybe it's through a system of transfers, maybe it's a system of pricing it according to a market. But maybe also we should think about other ways to compensate people to free them up to do this kind of work and there's lots of other creative options for doing that. But you do have to find a way to subsidize it because if you don't it be we become worse, right? I think a society without people who create art is worse. I think a society without quality journalism is worse. Let's find a way to fund it. The market might not be the only way to do it.
Peter LewisWould you do you care
Damian DamjanovskiBut
Peter Lewisif would you listen to AI generated music? Do you care about that, Dani?
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, I I do. I have. I've created AI generated music. It's fantastic. It's a it's a tool set that allows me to express a thing where I might not have the technical ability to create that thing.
Peter LewisThis is where I've chosen not to ask you. Our theme music's AI generated, isn't it? I've kind of yeah. I I I should not have even asked the question.
Damian DamjanovskiIt a hundred percent AI generated and it's a wonderful track. So it but I mean AI is paid to do the job. That's what tokens are, right? Is your reimbursing the AI in theory for the any
Peter LewisBut you're paying the token like twelve bucks or something. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiTwelve dollars per million, twenty five per million that's not the point. Th there's it's a different discussion whether or not it's being paid for and how much it's being paid. I don't think that artists need to be crazily compensated 'cause then we don't have struggling artists. Then we have wealthy artists, then wealthy artists never produce good art, right? We d we don't want that. We want to We which is our good which is our good well paid artists. We we that that's
LizzieI mean, that's frankly wrong, firstly, but also secondly struggle to produce good art. who's a well my God, there'd be there's dozens of them that you can identify immediately. Like people would say but but like people with big followings, like people would say Taylor Swift is well compensated and she makes good art. I I don't have a view on it, right? I don't have a view on Beyonce, I don't have a view on dozen of these people, but
Damian DamjanovskiDozens out of out of all
LizzieI think it's unfair to say that well compensated people don't produce good art. I also think it's terrible to say that you have to be struggling in order to produce great art 'cause it's wrong.
Damian DamjanovskiI think I I I I say that in jest, but I think the the counter to this, and Peter will know that I I harp on about this all the time, is I do see that AI and these tools are a tool of equality. So not every kid or adult growing up necessarily has the financial resources or socioeconomic upbringing to be able to afford to learn the piano, the guitar, producing this, that and the other, because they have to help their family out with this, that, the other, they gotta work three jobs, whatever it is. These tools are an equalizer, and that is actually a really important social job.
Lizziedamn mate. She'd be doing you should be doing marketing for these large tech bros that are all worth billions and billions of dollars about how they're bringing equality.
Damian DamjanovskiBut it is, but but li but Lizzie, think but Lizzie, think about your vocation, right? Of of the legal profession, which for a lot of people in Australia is just economically inaccessible. And a lot of people do not get legal help because it's inaccessible and legal aid is woefully underfunded and under-resourced. Why shouldn't people who have English as a second language, who have economic strife, who are socioeconomically worse off, why should they not have access to the top legal minds? Just as someone in the eastern suburbs who's had five generations of wealth because their family arrived at the right time have. Why would we rob them of that?
LizzieI mean, dame, you've described why I'm a class actions lawyer, because I'm at actually representing tens of thousands, sometimes millions of people who don't otherwise have access to the legal system, and I'm effectively trying to represent them in on a parity level with the the my opponents who are all extremely well resourced, right? So I agree with you. Access to justice is an issue. What I think we do need to think about in in in terms of AI particularly for legal services to the extent you want to talk about this is how you avoid a two tier system where we just have automated fake lawyers for people who are poor and really high quality legal services for everyone who's rich and we assume it's the same.
Damian DamjanovskiWhy can't the automated
Peter LewisWhich is also what they're doing in education, isn't it? Like AI tutors versus real tutors.
Damian Damjanovskibe quite quality? Hang on, hang on, why can't the automated be high quality?
LizzieIt Because that is not how the legal system works, right? The legal system is a human made rule system and it requires that engagement with courts, with defendants. It's not about a it's not always about a fact finding. It may be in some circumstances, but it's about negotiation with power through a human system. So you need people to do that work is what I would say. Anyway, that's a whole nother discussion.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Totally. So I I don't disagree with there, however, I'd say I no it's a great discussion and and we'll leave it for another time. But I would argue that what you've done is frame the current limitations of AI against the corpus of what is the legal profession. And I would argue that if we have this exact same conversation in one year, we'll be sh we'll potentially be shifting our positions a little bit because every field that AI is trained into i i it's self-improving by design. So its ability to negotiate right now is highly limited. In six to twelve months, that might not be the case, depending on how the technology is guided, right? So if the idea is that you can give the efficient lazy option to people to go, hey, you now have access to top quality lawyer, top quality doctor, this, that, and the other, I find it hard to argue personally against giving that capability to anyone and everyone to ensure that people do have a level playing field.
LizzieYeah, I mean I just query whether that's the outcome. Like I'm I'm I mean, this is a big discussion, right? 'Cause what do you do with a bunch of people who generate hundreds of pages of submissions and then appear self represented in the Supreme Court where judges spend twenty five, forty, fifty percent of their time dealing with self represented litigants who've used AI to generate submissions. That's a real problem for access to justice as well. Right? Like
Peter LewisMm.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, and I think what you end up doing is getting you know, a next generation of judges who understands how to use the tools to better parse the twenty to fifty self represent the system corrects itself, which is the beauty of it, right? And
Lizzieit look, I mean, anyway, there's a it's a big discussion that I think warrants a bit more attention than perhaps some the third drink of snoops red wine will will allow.
Damian DamjanovskiI agre agree, agree. Before we kind of tie off on this, because again, this is a topic that I think we could go into a lot of depth on, I wanted to chat about your view, Lizzie, on the Chinese approach to AI. Because everything we've talked about here and the Albanese approach and all this kind of stuff is focused on what's called the frontier model. For those who don't know, the frontier models are basically when you think of Anthropic, OpenAI, Google, Microsoft, they're the guys at the frontier who have the big data center. They've spent billions of dollars teaching this, you know, blob of AI a thing. And then you rent the ability to use that thing by punching in a prompt into your chat GPT. The Chinese approach, because the Chinese have looked at this and gone, well, we don't want the US to have a disproportionate technological advantage. The best thing we can do is not to compete with them on the technological advantage, is to make a close enough solution that is free to the world. And is essentially much more efficient in terms of the energy and processing requirements. So you can essentially pop it on your laptop or a you know, a piece of machinery that costs you two, three thousand or ten thousand dollars that you can plug into your home. And you get, in some cases, eighty-two, ninety-five percent of the measurable capacity, the measurable quality of a open AI or anthropic. but it's never left the internet. It's sitting there on your computer. And with those models, you can also do stuff that you probably should not be able to do. So Lizzie, I'm curious as to how this thinking fits into your view of how we're gonna govern AI when China's just going down a completely different track that is not governable, that none of these frameworks are gonna even touch on. What's the point?
LizzieWhat's the point of seeking to regulate? Is that your question? Because I think there's a different, like there's a lot of different ways you can think about the Chinese versus US approach to AI that are relevant to Australia. Like one of them, I mean, our friends at the Tech Policy Design Institute, or my friends at the Tech Policy Design Institute, have written have written an interesting article in foreign affairs a few months ago talking about exactly this issue and how Pacific Nations, who are some of our very important neighbours, Often want to use Chinese tools because the Chinese government does not impose the same restrictions that the US government does on buying into a single stack, on being dependent on US tech with US state decisions guiding how that will be available or not available according to their own interests. There's there's a real like kind of geopolitical international relations issue here that I think is not well understood in Australia, how the Chinese model might impact some of our close neighbours. There is then a question around. Safety, like is it is it i in the broader sense of the term, is it safer to have a system like in the United States where there's a small number of companies regulated by a state, versus in China where it's very heavily concentrated in terms of regulation and prohibition. So we've just seen China talk about banning companion apps, for example, because they think there's a problem with social cohesion, for want of a better term, around the use of these apps. Now in the United States, a lot of people are calling for something similar, especially in relation to children, because we've seen a spate of suicides, we've seen instances of addiction, all this kind of stuff. So similar human concerns, different regulatory approaches. query whether they're that different in the outcome, because I just think they're two ways of doing the same thing. We talked about App and Google earlier, and I sort of think it's similar, like open source or software products versus closed gardens. There's this, there's two different approaches. They've got international implications, they've got safety implications. I don't think any of that means we shouldn't try and do something about it in Australia. We should look at what we can leverage and and lean into that. I think the infrastructure question is one of those big key areas. There are other things. We've got consumer protection regimes that are strong and well established here. We've got competition laws, we've got like a range of different regulatory environments that I think Australians have come to expect from their products and it's the price of doing business here. That we can easily apply in this context and and we have well resourced regulators pro who are interested and capable in doing their jobs. So I don't think any of this is a lost cause. And I think it's probably what most Australians expect. And if and if their governments don't do it for them, then I think they'll pay a price.
Damian DamjanovskiBut but do you think and and Peter I'll I'll f flick to you for your thoughts on this, but is like you can't close Pandora's box on this because doesn't matter how much government regulation there is, if you can download a Chinese model, run it locally on your computer and it's effective and you can have it as a chat box do you know what I Like th this is the kind of like Netscape LimeWire era of doesn't matter what the government says
Peter LewisIt does actually circle back to our it circles back to our original conversation about the uni context. You can still set up your own norms and what is the right way of doing things and then build regulation off the back of that and then have a a notion of what is good because I think where you end up is a a very optimistic way sense of the notion of progress, but all this also at the same time a sense of nihilism. It's not worth trying because the other's the other side, if they are another side, are going to do bad things anyway. And I I think also that we get caught into this idea that we're on the side of the good guys. Like I'm I'm not convinced that the tech overlords that are turning America into a fascist state are actually our good faith partners in this endeavor. Not I'm not saying we should sign up to the PRC, but if you objectively look at the way that they are developing it, it it's kind of consistent with it's not going to override the rule of law because that's the vested interest of the state. it's it's going to use less energy. It's going to be you more div dispersed. I just don't think it's an an an obvious good guy, bad guy scenario here. And I just think that we've got to be able to think critically as a third like there there we have to think through a third way of doing this.
Damian DamjanovskiSo I look I I'm I'm I'm with you on this. Yeah. I I
LizzieMm.
Damian Damjanovskidon't disagree with you and I I'm reluctant to assign one side as a good guy, one side as a bad guy. I don't think that's the case. There are two very different approaches. I wouldn't start painting the tech bros of Silicon Valley as being kind of fascists quite yet, but the US I think we're gonna have to unpack that on a separate episode, but I think ultimately we do have to remember that the US, along with the UK and New Zealand and Canada, like
Peter LewisThey're kind of the worst people in history in my view.
Damian DamjanovskiThese people are well, yeah, these are our allies. These are these are people who we are tied to as countries closer than any other country.
Peter LewisColonial powers. We haven't even got into pillar two. Yeah.
LizzieNot great allies, I should say.
Damian DamjanovskiWe we'll have to unpack that on on another well, I mean, depends on depends on your view, I guess. Depends on how far back in history you go. but just as we're getting to the hour mark, and I know Lizzie, you do have to run off because you've got amazing work to do that isn't just shooting the breeze with us. I don't know if you know, but we do a what's your we do a kiss of death every week where we basically ask you to make a a prediction for the week that either you do want to come true or secretly hope won't actually come true.
LizzieHmm.
Damian DamjanovskiI'll start off with you, Mr. Lewis. What's your kiss of death for this week?
Peter LewisSo it's ALP National Conference in Adelaide next week, from Wednesday to Saturday. It's a lot bigger show than the Libs put on because there is real members and real institutional base. They come up with the platform. There's a bunch of fringe events. Lizzie and I are gonna be over there having fun. But my my prediction is actually this that when The 400 delegates and thousands of other people that will attend Adelaide, they will start with a communal prayer that thanks your friend Jane Hume, who you have said is the funniest person in Parliament, who yesterday got very hot and bothered about the fact that Labour was giving unions a right of veto on AI. And they will all say, thank you, Jane Hume, for taking all the heat out of our national conference, because that was exactly the message the government wanted to send to its membership base.
Damian DamjanovskiThat's a that's a very bold prediction, Lizzie. Do you have a kiss of death for the week?
Lizziemy god. I was thinking about this in the short notice that I was given to come up with something, which is approximately ten minutes. I I thought I'd come up the only thing I could predict happening was sort of what I foreshadowed before, which is that every technology company now is asking for a budget increase for their lobbying to go to talk to ALBO's office and plan out how they're gonna attack like the or what their approach is to the data center standards that will be introduced. and so
Peter LewisShould I
LizzieWell, the re the convenience of this prediction is that it's unverifiable, but I think we can all expect it's gonna happen. That that is their joke.
Peter LewisI reckon you're on a good I reckon you're on a good wicket there, Lizzie.
LizzieUntestable. That also makes it a good prediction.
Damian DamjanovskiGreat prediction. my kiss of death, I don't know if it'll happen this week. and obviously, I'm very bullish and progressive on data centers and AI, and I I always think that humanity is saved through technology. I I know it's a zigzag path, but I I have to believe that technology is ultimately our collective savior as a species. I have a feeling over the next few weeks or in the very near future, there will be some kind of criminal-level attack.
Peter LewisWhat about you?
Damian Damjanovskior attempt on a data centre in Sydney or in Melbourne.
Peter LewisWhich I may or may not be part of. I I don't know if I sent you the photo. On the on the way to the Albo Speech, just as a final thought, I don't know if we can put it up on the podcast, there was I was going through the tunnel underneath home building on the way to the Great Hall, which has always been the place where all the graffiti is, and just across the
Damian DamjanovskiThis is Peter Lewis graffiting outside an X DC, just saying you're all fascists. End the hyperscaling.
LizzieAnd he'll say, Dummy did it. That's what he'll say.
Peter LewisThe arch. It was just fuck AI. It was beautiful.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
LizzieGonna get an explicit writing for that.
Damian DamjanovskiThat is amazing.
Peter LewisI know, maybe beef it out.
Damian DamjanovskiPeter, as always, thank you very much. This has been a very fun and fascinating episode, really deep diving into AI and all this kind of stuff. Lizzie, thank you so much for A joining us last minute, but B, sharing all your wonderful insights and having a little bit of civilized and cultured debate with us, even though we don't necessarily see eye to eye on all things. And and I don't necessarily want us to, because that would just be unique.
Peter LewisBoring.
Damian DamjanovskiOur conversations. I would like us to keep disagreeing on this respectfully. if you are watching the show, please, if you don't subscribe already, please do. If you haven't watched Peter Lewis and Lizzie's other show, Burning Platforms, you can find it. We'll put a link up. You should absolutely listen into that because it's it's a great yarn to listen to as well. We thank you as we do every week for spending an hour with us. we hope you join us next week. We will have another fun, exciting show. Like, share, subscribe. Thank you very much, and we will see you again next week.
Peter LewisWe'll put a link, yeah. We'll put a link in the bottom, yeah.
LizzieMm. Thanks for having me.
