Episode 16

SITDOWN! ALP National Conference, Barnaby yelling at dogs, Pauline's gaffs

25 July 202655 min

Show notes

Peter is live from the Labor National Conference in Adelaide. The backdrop for discussions on various policy issues.

We discuss various issues including the role of the Labour Party, the impact of One Nation, and the significance of the AUKUS alliance. We also touch on the gas export tax, Palestine, and voluntary assisted dying. We also explore Barnaby and his on-air dog yelling, Pauline and her gaffs, and our predictions for the week.

Chapters

  • 00:00 Setting the Stage in Adelaide
  • 00:26 The Role of the Labour Party
  • 00:55 The Impact of One Nation
  • 01:24 The AUKUS Alliance
  • 02:02 The Gas Export Tax
  • 02:39 Palestine and Voluntary Assisted Dying
  • 03:08 Cost of Living and Housing Affordability
  • 03:38 Labour's Institutional Dynamics
  • 05:19 The Role of Unions
  • 06:11 Labour's Policy Agenda
  • 07:20 The Lack of Major Contentious Debates
  • 08:12 The Future of the Labour Party
  • 09:09 The Conclusion of the Conference
  • 14:10 Labor Conference and Policy Development
  • 15:03 Political Figures and Gaffes
  • 26:21 Billionaires and Athlete Support
  • 34:36 Outdoor Media and Political Advertising

    Ticket's to Burning Platforms Live in Parramatta on Tuesday 28 July: https://events.humanitix.com/burning-platforms-believe-it-or-not-navigating-the-misinformation-age

Full transcript

Read itHide it

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.

Peter LewisWelcome to What's Your Poison, the show where people who disagree on just about everything agree it's best to do so over a drink. My name's Peter Lewis. I am the principal at the Progressive Strategy Shop Essential. Joining you today here from the National Conference in Adelaide and joining my special friend, my evil twin, General Strategics, Dame Damjanowski. Dame, how are you? And what's your poison?

Damian Damjanovskiexcellent, Mr. Lewis. My poison this week is a beautiful drop. An Olive and Armand Rukia from Croatia that was recently

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskigifted to me by none other than the lovely Giselle Captarian. And can ten out of ten recommend? but more importantly, Mr. Lewis, you're in Adelaide at in the heart of the beast, the Labour Conference. The once in a triennial event. firstly I want to ask what's your poison, but then I'm gonna we're gonna dig into this deep this week, I have a

Peter LewisYeah.

Damian Damjanovskifeeling.

Peter LewisYeah. So I'm in a little pod in the convention center 'cause the hotel room is smacking out on me. So I'm opening my poison, which is of course a Cooper's Green purchased on

Damian DamjanovskiNaturally.

Peter Lewisthe main road. You know, th there was a time when the Cooper's Green was the most exotic beer you could get in Australia because it had little bits of you know,

Damian DamjanovskiSediment.

Peter Lewisin the bottom and now it's just all the craft and this has become almost like Carlton. But anyway. I l I love I love Coopers. I love Adelaide. the only city in Australia

Damian DamjanovskiIs that the beer you're meant to roll on the counter?

Peter Lewissorry?

Damian DamjanovskiIs that the beer you used to have to roll on the counter to like even out the sediment from the bottom?

Peter LewisYeah, and indeed I probably shouldn't have should have done that already, but I did take the lid off earlier and it would have just caused grief.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter LewisI like Adelaide. I don't know if you spent much time here. It's the only city in Australia built off the plan. There were no convicts. and there's something about the whole place that makes sense. You've got your terraces, you've got your parks, and you've got a whole bunch of really interesting stuff that goes on around the precinct. Last night was both the the conference and all the faction dinners was on, but also Collingwood was playing Adelaide at the Adelaide Oval and the crossover there was of course, you know, a bit a lot of the corporate sponsors of the conference, including Santos, had boxes and a lot of the journalists ended up at the footy, not not naming names

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Peter Lewisobviously. But yeah, City of Churches,

Damian DamjanovskiSo it's been a good week.

Peter Lewislike it's good place to be. Are you are you an Adelaide fan?

Damian DamjanovskiI'm a huge so my dad lives in Adelaide on the South Terrace side. And I'm I've actually always been a huge Adelaide fan. This there's a good vibe to the the city that I quite enjoy. And it hits that beautiful Australian sweet spot between it's bigger than a town, but smaller than a city. And I think that's exactly what Australia

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskidoes well. We're not great at the big cities, and small towns can sometimes feel a bit depressing. And Adelaide just has that little in-between territory that I that I quite enjoy. But I must imagine this week. With the entire Labour Party faithful.

Peter LewisI was just gonna say before we get there, even the even the liberals are progressive in South Australia, apart from Alex Antic. Yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiWell, we're busy building submarines and ships and other defense things down there. So we're all the liberals are happy down there. I I was gonna ask you before we dig into this, for for people who don't know, myself included, what is a labor, an ALP national conference? What are these things? What's the point of them?

Peter LewisYeah. Well, you know, the Labour Party is a a creature of a long and rich history. The union movement established the party and that institutional democracy meets the branch democracy and once every term there is a national conference where a platform gets endorsed. Now the platform doesn't bind the government but it guides the government. There is a big policy formulation process. People get elected to policy co committees and, you know, in a in an area that is of input like that that is of relevance to a particular union. For instance, you know, on a manufacturing policy, the manufacturing unions will have a say in it, alongside branch representatives from all the different electoral councils. I think Labour still claims 50,000 members. I don't know if you can trust anyone's actual membership numbers and they're all a bit murky. But It is an expression of party democracy. And normally there will be one big issue that defines a conference. And we can talk about that later. But you know, I I've been going to conferences since I was a wee slip of an industrial reporter on the Daily Telegraph in 1995, where it was held in Hobart and it was the last days of the Keating government and the unions were really pushing back on this exotic beast called enterprise bargaining that they absolutely hated. But You know, Hobart was the the home base for National Conference for a long time. And you used to have to walk through the poker machines in the casino to get into the conference center. It was just wild. This is a lot tamer, I've got to say.

Damian DamjanovskiSo so does it always move around?

Peter LewisSo well, they have the so it's sort of through the nineties, I reckon, Hobart did it up until, you know, probably me I remember Canberra then having it when Simon Cream was leader. So it's about 2003, maybe. And then last time it was in Brisbane, this time it's in South

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Peter LewisAustralia. So there's there's there's the room where there is the I think there's 300 elected delegates who vote on various things, although as I will explain later, there have been very few votes. there's behind the stage, which is where the factional power brokers and the party officials and the representatives of ministers will negotiate. either amendments to the platforms because while it's not binding, there is a desire for alignment. And then there's the fringe festival where all the the sort of activists are sort of putting on talks and discussions. And it's a,

Damian DamjanovskiTheir own.

Peter Lewisyou know, it like yes, it's a conference at the Adelaide Convention Center. And yes, there's all the things that everyone sees every time they go, but there is a degree of, you know, life and it's a way of people there's 300 delegates for probably a thousand people here. So, you know, good people, good times.

Damian DamjanovskiAnd and now my understanding is with with Tony Burke this is basically a music festival for Labour nerds. 'Cause I I assume other than the three hundred yeah.

Peter LewisWell, anyone that's paying a hundred dollars to p anyone paying a hundred dollars to see Tony Burke play guitar, probably doesn't value their money as much as we do. But yeah. No, a hund

Damian DamjanovskiI think it was a a thousand dollars for lobbyists, wasn't it? Like the

Peter Lewisno, it was a hundred, I think. But, you know, to to be fair, you know, it wasn't just

Damian DamjanovskiOr for a good cause, or for a good cause.

Peter Lewishim. I think he had, you know, was it her name Libby Croaker sort of on backup vocals. There's a few other sort of people that were sort of in the bed. I was not there for that. I came in

Damian DamjanovskiNo, you didn't make it.

Peter Lewisthe day after I missed that, but was in there last night for a a few events.

Damian DamjanovskiSo so obviously party faithful can shop, but you've actually got delegates that have been appointed. They all come in, they vote on policy and they vote on positions, and it's meant to form the the view of government. What firstly were the contentious things this year? Because I guess in the mind of a non labor person or an average voter, there's a a

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskihuge number of things in terms of what they believe are the most important issues or the things they want government to do.

Peter LewisMm.

Damian DamjanovskiIs that what's kind of coming up in this conference

Peter LewisYes.

Damian Damjanovskior is it a different thing?

Peter LewisSo they have chapters of the report and there'll be different issues coming in. So I guess the three where there were there has been work to, let's say, manage friction, have been the gas tax, where there's been obviously quite a vigorous public campaign from progressive forces and social media influencers and elements of the party to revise that. I That was managed out of debate on the floor. There's been the the approach to AI, which we could maybe talk about a bit later. But, you know, that was really, you know, part of Albo's speech that we spoke about with Lizzie last week was really

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Peter Lewisputting that to bed. and then there's AUKUS and Palestine and the international issues, which it's it been interesting. So there that debate or that the the the international report is up tomorrow. So I you know, which is Saturday morning, we're recording this Friday afternoon. So that's where there's been the most colour and movement. There's been high level security here. There was a Palestinian pro protest this morning. There was an AUKUS rally. The numbers weren't they were in the probably around a hundred. It wasn't thousands or anything. and there are unions who would be if the if if if the issue really came to a head would I think push back on where Labor's position is. But the trick of running the conference, which is really the job of the National Secretary, Paul Erickson and the the parliamentary team, is to to to take the rough edges out so that and and we can again talk about this later whether this is a good thing or a bad thing, but to to sort of take the the friction out of it and come up with effectively negotiated positions that give people enough room.

Damian DamjanovskiLike a unified party platform.

Peter LewisYeah. And you know, this is interesting too, and I this is I guess this is a chauffeur nerd, so we can go one level in. Traditionally there was one big iconic shift at a national conference. So when Labour privatised Qantas, or when they the the when they opened up nuclear mining with the two this is back in the Hawke era, or gay marriage position. These are all like th they were the one big iconic

Damian DamjanovskiBig iconic things.

Peter Lewisso today there is only and that would be where it comes down to a vote and it would be You know, traditionally the right and the left were the right having the numbers, which was why we've got a privatized Commonwealth Bank now. the the only vote that's been contested to date has been voluntary assisted dying. which so

Damian DamjanovskiReally?

Peter Lewisthe only vote has actually been on death. and that and and again, you know, for people that don't know Labour history, like Those are the issues that often split because there is still that really strong Catholic base in the ALP. So issues around, say, that are more more likely to draw out the conscience vote is things around either, you know, abortion or marriage equality. And most

Damian DamjanovskiYouth and Asia or

Peter Lewisof those have moved on, but the euthanasia is still kind of like it's a relatively fresh concept. And I it I think it was just to get I think it's been voted up inside the platform and it wasn't it was A vote that was decided on the voices, so it wasn't like it needed they didn't sort of force sort of specific hands, but that's been the only one where it's gone to the floor and there's actually been

Damian DamjanovskiMm. And

Peter Lewisa conflict.

Damian Damjanovskido do what's the union presence like of this kind of event? Like do unions play a role in it? Do they are they completely sit like they're not invited to the event? It's I've always curious, like how do they participate?

Peter LewisNo, no, no. So so Dharma, there's two sorts of unions. There's affiliated unions and unaffiliated unions. So for instance, most of the public sector unions, which are now some of the largest in the nation, like the teachers union and the nurses union, aren't Labour party affiliates for the very good reason that then if you are representing your members and your party is in power, you're kind of like You know, repr yeah, yeah, you're representing the worker and the boss and you can't have it both ways. so there is so unions back in the early two thousands, the union that it used to be sixty-forty unions, and I'm gonna get the numbers wrong now and I should have done the research, but it's more fifty-fifty. So you've either got union pro delegates who are part of that voting on the floor. and representatives of each federal electoral council, which are sort of voted by individual branches, which is effectively one for each electorate. So the unions still have the influence in their control of the factional votes. and it's always been the case if the unions were to unite as an industrial base, they can actually move the party, but because there are some left wing and some right wing unions, they tend to then cancel each other out and traditionally right would win. Now the difference again now is that because of the last election, the actual numbers in the caucus is much more, you

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Peter Lewisknow, balanced and there's a the the left has actually got a lot more power and obviously can tr the PMs of traditionally of the left faction and most of the key party officials are as well. So it's a it's a different dynamic. But I think the interesting thing is from you know Particularly the PM who would have spent many conferences whipping up mischief and then negotiating deals. He is maintaining power by taking as much friction out of the event as he possibly can. And again, there's two thoughts on that. Is this a good thing for d just the party i i is the best thing for the party, with the exception of Ed Husick, who is kind of a bit of a lone wolf who's got nothing to lose and has been sort of

Damian DamjanovskiYeah. We'll we'll get to Ed.

Peter Lewispublicly criticizing The lack of dissent in the party. I think most people, when you look at the electoral math at the moment and the the thumping majority are saying, Well, I'm happy for a boring conference if Labour's in such a commanding position and it and it's seen to be delivering on things, particularly around, you know, workplace laws and particularly around the energy transition. So, you know, it's

Damian DamjanovskiD do you think do you think Ed's wrong then in his so so for those who don't know, we see Ed Husick, former minister, now a backbencher in the Labour Party, has kind of basically basically gone completely rogue to a large degree and said, Look, the Labour Party's bit

Peter LewisI got nothing to lose.

Damian Damjanovskihe's he's the Labour Party's become allergic to any form of dissent. There's no real space for disagreement, and he's kind of inviting the question, what's the point of a conference? When no one's actually contesting anything into and to your point, Peter, if the only thing that's really come to a vote is, you know, voluntary assistant dying and there's no signature pieces coming from a side of politics where where this kind of mass conference doesn't really exist, is there

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskia point to doing it if there isn't any dissent, if there's no space for discussion? Like is it is it serving any purpose? And if so, what is the purpose?

Peter LewisWell but but I so so two things there. Each bit of the platform has gone through a ru a a a policy committee. So I think there's nine chapters on different issues. And so then again, the both the institution the the institutional players and the factions appoint people to those policy commission committees and they develop the the policies that make the platform. So if it was did nothing but rubber stamp, that's still a body of work that Labour would argue keeps the party relevant. and it's, you know, I wouldn't say it's a people's assembly, but there is a degree of democratic, inst institutionally democratic input into the development of those policies. The second thing is then on the floor, amendments to those policies can be moved. And there have been amendments moved. For instance, the ETU has a position supporting greater sovereignty in the renewable energy sector. that amendment I think was successfully moved. again, the other weird thing about it, you don't spend your time sitting on the floor. It's more like you're buzzing around trying to take everything in. And I've been

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Peter Lewisdoing quite a few events down at French. So I I'd I I encourage anyone listening to this to to to fact check anything I anything I say today. But I think that

Damian DamjanovskiAs we encourage everyone every week.

Peter Lewisbut the vibe is this. There's been a process to get the platform up that informs but doesn't bind Labour policy. There is a process for amendments that is an expression of a democratic party. I'm interested in hearing from you because I feel like I'm dominating this this particular episode of What's Your Poison, Dharmay. How is that different to how the coalition develops its policy and positions. Is is it just Sky After Dark is their policy committee or is there more nuance to that?

Damian DamjanovskiNo. No more than the Guardian is for the for the Labour Party, I'd say. So I the the Liberal Party obviously has a a federal council.

Peter LewisI'd be far more influential if it was.

Damian DamjanovskiThe Liberal Party has a federal council, which I think has about just over a dozen delegates from each of the state or territories, and includes basically leaders from the the federal party. So it it's almost like the committee bit of the Labour conference without the conference bit. w which naturally does beg the question, does it get the same level of input and scrutiny that you would get from a a you know a conference with five hundred delegates turning up? I I'm not

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskisaying that one system or or one method is better or worse, but I've always been fascinated by the labor, the labor convention because it seems like sorry, is it a conference or a convention? What's the official terminology for it?

Peter LewisOur one or your one?

Damian DamjanovskiYour one.

Peter Lewisit's a conference. Yeah. Yeah. ALP National Conference. Yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiConference. So the Labour Conference. I I I find it fascinating that everyone descends because again, from the outside, the impression is that there's, you know, there's lazy Susans in closed rooms where people are arguing at each other about who's to blame and and what the tax rate should be and and what they're going to hit the liberals on next. so it sounds to a large degree like they're not too dissimilar, other than the conference component of it. We we we don't do the big conference.

Peter LewisWe don't have lazy Susans though.

Damian DamjanovskiWow. Unless someone's donating. So was was there any domination or discussion of Pauline Hansen and One Nation, like in the corridors outside of the official program? Does Pauline Hansen the One Nation rise? Is it on people's minds or?

Peter LewisI've just been told I can't drink in here. Okay. Do you wanna take it off me or there's a bit of love. We can either edit out, it's fine, mate. Apparently it's not licensed premises, the Adelaide Convention Centre, even though further down. So the guy the the security guy has actually taken my half Cooper's Green and taken it away from me. So I'm g I I I think my performance may drop very substantially now. But anyway, in the spirit.

Damian DamjanovskiNo, that's right. I'm so sorry that you you had a a a Karen come up to you to take your South Australian beer. It feels like a feels like a very un Australian thing

Peter LewisI know, it feels like unpatriotic

Damian Damjanovskito do.

Peter LewisYeah, yeah. So so I think that is so it is an interest

Damian DamjanovskiThis is where the the little brown paper bag comes into play, by the way.

Peter Lewisso a lot of the discussion outside One Nation is framing it. and I think there is a s a degree of this is all very good and we are smashing the libs, which demonstrably I think we can all agree they are at the moment, but there is this new factor in it and people aren't quite sure what's happening. I was talking to my very old friend Artie Roris, who runs the South Coast Labour Council, and he was saying that, you know, in their area, like that there was a meeting to set up a branch in Dapto, and sixty people turned up and they were basically people that have been targeted off petitions against renewables and against the voice.

Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.

Peter LewisAnd so there is the start of, okay, there's something new happening here. And I'd I you know, you'd be crazy not to have it on, but I still think it's almost like it's still a watch and brief sort of thing to me. the polling

Damian DamjanovskiSo Labour's still viewing this through the lens of, well, they're they're they're taking from the Liberal Party there's nothing for us to act on yet. Let's see how this plays

Peter LewisNo.

Damian Damjanovskiout.

Peter LewisI I still I think there is a recognition that this is a vote against insider politics. So what you're really seeing I I think and I think this is where things are interesting. In a world where it was just the Libs and the Greens, Labour would just be consolidating power and you'd you'd be reading this conference as really a consolidation of power. But I think the extra element here is that they recognise that they need to be seen to be using power to change things and not just to be defending a status quo that more and more people are turning against. Now, again, this will be embedded in little bits of policy, for instance, workers' rights around AI, which I think the the the fear of one nation I think is really driving a lot of now the movements on regulation of AI. I don't know if you saw this week the Victorian government has bought in some regulation and people are telling me they they clearly said that politically they are gonna go AI as sort of almost retail politics in the lead up to the next election. To give people a reason to sort of say this government isn't just the status quo. So I think that's interesting as well. So I think they're they're obviously not in the room. I think there's been real discipline. I don't think ABO actually mentioned Pauline Hansen in his speech. again, fact check listeners, because I wasn't there.

Damian DamjanovskiNo, but I think well, I s so Kate Ellis is returning as the incoming party president and she's obviously a former Rudd Gillard minister.

Peter LewisYeah.

Damian Damjanovskiand in her speech, she's specifically named Hanson and basically started talking up this plan to fight populists and and naming Hansen as the the the populist that she's basically

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskidoing there. So do it it's kinda like what's the play there by by putting Kate in that position and having her talk it up rather

Peter LewisYeah.

Damian Damjanovskithan elbow.

Peter LewisYeah, so that's interesting. So I did a forum with Kate last night, in sort of politics in the pub style with a couple of first term MPs, including a guy we've got to get on here at some stage, Matt Smith, the former Cairns Taipan, seven foot tall basketballer

Damian Damjanovskiyes. Yeah.

Peter Lewiswho's an absolute ripper. but you know, and Kate.

Damian DamjanovskiHe's the only one that's taller than Repicoli, is that right?

Peter Lewismate, I'll I'll send you a photo later because I took a I had to stand on the stage to sort of be shoulder to shoulder. so I think her her position is that the challenge for Labour is not just you can't fight one nation just by using angry memes and engaging in that style of politics. It's actually to rebuild branches. And I think part of her sort of role and she's look, she's she's passed, she's had her political career and she was really upfront. I don't want to go back into politics, but I've been asked to help the party and this is a way I can, particularly focusing on sort of giving w working with MPs to re-engage branches. because if you can get stuff happening in a local community, your chances of sort of not leaving that void that Artie's talking about in Dapto sort of increases. So the best way institutionally to fight an institutional incursion is to solidify your own footprint. And, you know, the reality is a lot of branches are pretty sort of you know, comatose because, you know, in in safe seats there's never really been that that imperative and like people use it as a place to sort of consolidate and hold power but when contests happen, like there's much more to play with.

Damian DamjanovskiSo so let me ask you, just drawing back for a second about some of the the bigger th No, that's but I I

Peter LewisI feel like this is Peter Lewis interviewed by Darmo this week, but let's keep going 'cause

Damian Damjanovskithink this is fascinating. I think a lot a lot of people won't know what the inside of a Labour conference looks like. And look personally I find it fascinating because I've never seen the inside of one and doubt I ever will. So I'm just gonna There it is.

Peter LewisYou really should come next time. Like they they they allow people to buy their w the you know, business observers are there too and like the top end of town's definitely here. Yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiBusiness observer. so obviously there's a a few big ticket items that I've been reading about. Number one, discussion about the gas export tax. So, like you said, this was the campaign

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskithat's been primarily driven by David Pocock, together with Conrad from Punter's Politics, the the Australia Institute and a few others basically saying that we need higher gas export taxes on offshore gas, which is the purview of the federal government, not onshore gas. AUKUS seems to be playing quite heavily. I'm I'm still trying to understand where Labour sits on AUKUS. Some seem to think it's a bad thing, some seem to think it's a good thing, some in between. And obviously the the Gaza Palestine question I think keeps coming back up at this conference and to caucus as well, because a lot of Labour seats are in heavily in in electorates and populations that have a heavy Middle Eastern population. so it seems to be a like a live burning question for a lot of them. So I might start with just like what's the conversation happening there around the gas export tax? Is this a real thing or is this just something that Alba needs to keep swatting away?

Peter LewisHmm. So the the So all these issues have have not had big coverage on the conference floor with impassioned debates. What's happening is in the fringe, which is the the other part of the convention where there's three halls where different groups run discussions on the hour. There's been discussion the Australia Institute's got a stall down, they've been running a thing on on the gas tax. Labour Against War ran a very well populated forum. last night. It's interesting in the fringe there is both a labor for I think I think it might be Labour for Israel or and there's a Palestina. They've both got their both got their stalls and their

Damian DamjanovskiWhich one has the better spread?

Peter LewisI I think the Palestinian one's more colourful. and probably a few more people there. But again the notion of so there's the management of the conference in one room. which is I wouldn't say it's tight, but it's ordered. And then there's the flourishing of internal democracy in the other part of the convention center. So the two and you know, the two sort of both have a role in the party. And, you know, again, it depends, you know, I guess how you look at the way power is managed, whether that is a good, good model or not.

Damian DamjanovskiSo I guess from the outside looking in, my observation would be what seems to be taking

Peter LewisIt's boring.

Damian Damjanovskiup a lot of air is issues like AUKUS and gas export and Palestine, Gaza, and all that kind of stuff. What I haven't heard a lot about, and maybe it's different on the floor there, is what are we doing about cost of living? Cause I would argue that for most Australians, that

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskiis still the big issue is what are we doing about cost of living? What are we doing about inflation? What are we doing about housing and immigration?

Peter LewisAnd probably immigration as well, yeah. Hm.

Damian DamjanovskiAnd watching all the coverage and all the the releases that are coming out of the labor conference. It's the one thing I haven't heard anything about is here's what we're going to do to really tackle the housing crisis or to step it up a gear. Here's how we're going to make sure that Aussies aren't paying as much for X, Y, and Z goods because inflation's eating away at their

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskiat their income. Like, is that Is it a topic of conversation or is it

Peter LewisWell So it was interesting. The the the s the the the element of Albo's speech they obviously put in there and dropped to get coverage was actually supporting more people th to to sort of get training and get into the workforce in sort of areas like allied health. and I thought that was interesting. The growing caring economy, the increasing need to get skilled migrants to fill some of those positions in places like aged care and early learning and stuff. So it that was kind of like a policy intervention that's that sort of ticks an education box, probably ticks an immigration box, and then sort of by corollary ticks a housing box and a cost of living box as well. So it was an interesting little one that had a bit of something for everyone.

Damian DamjanovskiWell.

Peter Lewisbut you know, this is not again, the platform guides the government's policy. So this is not where you are coming up with retail politics or what is your tax cons like, you know, what is your pre-budget tax splurge. That is not the role

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter Lewisof a comp the last, you know, just one more little bit of history, because I was involved in this and it was probably the last time a conference did anything of huge significance. It was New South Wales ALP conference back in about 2013 where the Premier got rolled on privatizing the power industry. now that and I'm probably getting my years wrong was about twenty ten actually, just before they all went a cropper. So that was the last time there was real institutional pushback. And again, so it's again, I think that the journos come here and they want to A, find a fight to cover. They haven't been given that. They want a big grand narrative. Again, holding power from a position of dominance politically is probably not the most ex it's not going to win you a Walkley Award, right? So there's It it it's hard to find it. I I still, you know, personally I think that, you know, the government has still not explained quite what the long term plan with AUKUS is, particularly Pillar Two. That's probably a discussion for another day. But you know, that that what that has not been debated in great detail on the conference floor.

Damian DamjanovskiD do you do you not think that this all signals, and again, not trying to be disparaging about the event at all, but like, does this not signal either that the government feels like they've got this when it comes to housing and cost of living, or that they don't want to talk about it? Cause again, from a from a punter perspective, you look at it and you go, Isn't shouldn't that be the number one, two, and three thing you're talking about? Unless you genuinely think, as in the Labour

Peter LewisMm.

Damian DamjanovskiParty genuinely thinks. That they've they they're doing everything they can on the twin pillars of housing affordability and cost of living crisis.

Peter LewisYeah, but you know, they're not magic wand things, you know, and yeah, I'm not gonna prosecute Labour's housing agenda, but Claire O'Neill, and before her Jason Clare have put in a bunch of measures that they are rolling out. Their big problem is actually the delivery, not the policy line, right? the other big thing and there and there are a lot of Yeah,

Damian DamjanovskiGet this is getting enough like people into the trades and

Peter Lewisand that doesn't happen overnight. And then if you bring more in you've got to increase immigration, which ends up putting more pressure, yada yada and the circle goes around. you know, the big investments in TAFE, you know, which were done at a state level, really critical in that as well. Probably there's movements, you know, in New South Wales to move into prefab modular, which will speed things up as well. But these are all sort of long term. And then on cost of living, you know, we've been talking about this since the, you know, the the beginning of the war in Iraq. Like, you know, but the co

Damian DamjanovskiSince COVID.

Peter Lewisyeah, but but particularly like we still those Your prediction the Straits would be open probably from three months ago, we're still waiting for that. But that is the the slow ticking time bomb on the economy that the government has no control over really. So yeah, lots going on there.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah. So j just to be fair, by the way, I my prediction that oil would Brent crude oil would go over a hundred US a barrel did come true today. So it's it's not it's not entirely

Peter Lewisyeah. No, you're no, it's more no, I was talking more about your prediction from a few shows ago that the straits would be open and things would be tickety boo. Yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiI really that w I think that was a very, very hopeful prediction and I'm sad that hasn't come true. And instead, if you're driving a combustion engine vehicle, I think you're gonna be in a fair, fair bit of pain. So what's left on the agenda? So you said tomorrow's the last is that the last day of the conference or?

Peter LewisYeah, so well I'm actually doing a thing tonight, launching Fair AI, which is the other thing that's come through, which is an initiative to sort so rather and I think Labour's got a tradition of having not you know, they've got this organization lean, which has always run a pro environment line inside like so to push more pressure on stronger environment laws and climate laws inside the party. And so the idea of Fair AI, which is gonna be a initiative of the Chifly, which is the the in-house think tank. We're launching that tonight to try to get members into A, being literate about the challenges, but also providing not ensuring that when the inevitable backlash against AI comes, it's not happening outside the party, but it's also being understood and prosecuted inside the party as well. So

Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.

Peter LewisThat's happening tonight. Then there's the conference dinner, which will be, you know, rubber chicken and inspiring speech, I'm assuming, from the Prime Minister. And then tomorrow it goes to about lunchtime and obviously most, you know, of the the delegates will be turning up with sore heads and you know, that's where and that's Well, yes.

Damian DamjanovskiDeep hangovers. If they haven't had their beer taken from from by overzealous staffers of convention centers.

Peter LewisI I'm still quite I'm still quite outraged by this, yeah. Anyway, that's that's national conference, I'm sure. Anyone that's here

Damian DamjanovskiMurphy, sit down.

Peter Lewisis sit down It's a dog.

Damian Damjanovskinever obviously say that to Murphy.

Peter LewisI thought that was so I know I

Damian DamjanovskiAnnaby Joyce.

Peter LewisI was watching it live and I just said that is going to go places that very few 730 interviews go and it was just that red-faced, unhinged Barnaby that we know and love. But that was so unfiltered, wasn't it? And I get that's how country

Damian DamjanovskiIt's

Peter Lewispeople talk to their dogs. But it's

Damian Damjanovskiyeah.

Peter Lewisnot how you talk to Murphy, is it?

Damian DamjanovskiNo, I I would never talk to Murphy like that, but he's not a country dog. But I mean, what I found most fascinating about this in the first instance, definitely not,

Peter LewisI reckon Murphy's a teal just quietly. Murphy is gonna end up a teal.

Damian Damjanovskidefinitely not, is the amount of people I heard ask me whether or not it was a planned bit, whether Barnaby did it as a bit of a planned stunt to avoid answering the question, is just an interesting reflection on how people view the machinations of some of these retail political

Peter LewisThe Cynest is yeah.

Damian Damjanovskioperators. But Barnaby is so wonderfully unashamed in being himself and just the following few days there was no like, I'm sorry for yelling at my dog because I was stressed or he was he basically just s stood by his guns and went, Well look, I'm from the country and that's how we talk to dogs. Right.

Peter LewisMm.

Damian DamjanovskiAnd I think what's wonderful about that is That kind of authentic, whether you call it retail politics or just Barnaby being Barnaby and Pauline being Pauline is increasingly resonating with people because yes, it's funny, but also people see that and go, he's just a nor he's just a normal, slightly unhinged human being. And I like that about him.

Peter LewisBut I think there was also Yeah I also think, you know, there's that scenario you've had a really bad day at the office and you go home and kick the dog. Like I wouldn't put it past Barnaby. I'm not I I don't want us So he that was a really tough interview where he was really being called on to which he rarely has to. He's always been the loose canon. He was being called on to justify his leader's

Damian DamjanovskiTo justify polling.

Peter Lewisloose cannonness. And you know, Sarah Ferguson as she does was going him, you know, pretty hard and pretty below the belt. And then I just I felt the dog was irritating him, but I think it bought out. And I I think that moment where it's just so much emotion like that, sit down. And then I thought the the the beautiful bit was the next bit where he kind of captures himself, looks at the camera and sort of goes, It's a dog, and sort of giggles

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter Lewisa little bit. And I feel like the meme is not actually the sit down. The meme is actually the it's a dog, which is actually

Damian DamjanovskiIt's the it's a dog.

Peter Lewiswhere he's ended up. He has got a dog of a job in a dog of a party that is not properly trained, that yelps everywhere. Like you can see where, you know, like he he the dog that he was kicking or shouting at was not whatever his dog's name is. It was the one nation and the choices he's made in recent times.

Damian DamjanovskiSo so you think the the dog in Barnaby's head is an allegory for his joining Pauling Hansen's One Nation and how he's feeling about

Peter LewisI don't Yeah.

Damian Damjanovskithe party or?

Peter LewisI'm not sure if Barnaby deals in allegories or metaphors or if he's a straight up and down Riverview Well, you know, he d he did he

Damian DamjanovskiHe's a very erudite man. He's a very erudite man.

Peter Lewiswas educated by the Jesuits alongside Tony Abbott at Riverview College on the Sydneys at Leafy North Shore, which is a bit of his origin story that isn't told very w very often.

Damian DamjanovskiNo, no, it doesn't fit the narrative. So obviously the the the thing he was justifying is Pauline this week, in another Pauline moment, you know, as she talks through her lengthy verbal monologue of things, made the statement that obviously domestic violence kind of runs both ways, and that if you're the subject of domestic violence, you should just leave as though that's an option

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskifor everyone. How many of these gaffs you reckon? And let's not be shy about it. Like that is a gaff. Like, that's not something that while maybe in the detail you could eventually post-rationalize a justification for saying something like that, it it's not something that any trained politician, let alone someone who's been a politician as long as Pauline has, should be able to make so readily. How many of these comments do you think she can get away with before? It starts doing serious impact, both it at the polls, but more importantly, to the people she's managed to recruit around her. Because there's only so many times you can do that. And it definitely doesn't bode well with

Peter LewisSo yeah.

Damian Damjanovskiconservative women, that's for sure.

Peter LewisAbsolutely. And look, I think the dynamics in the last few weeks have changed a bit for One Nation. I'm not I'm not ready to call it, but I think since the National Press Club, where there was more scrutiny on policy, the numbers have sort of tapered off. Like the the rise has definitely plateaued. I think she is now being held with more accountability. to what she is saying because she is putting herself out not as just a disruptor but a potential leader.

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Peter LewisAnd she's and she's embraced that and said, I I can lead the country and everything. And, you know, so I think the rules where the things that she has said in the past have been consequence free. And the way that she goes about her business, everything from the sinecure for her daughter in New South

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Peter LewisWales to allow her to campaign in Tassie for a Senate seat to you know, her increasingly budding, I don't know what's the what's the sister version of a bromance with Gina Reinhardt where she's, you know, besting it at, you know, fashion shows in was it Milan or something, you know, or Sicily was it? I don't know.

Damian DamjanovskiYes. The Dolce and Gabbana show, whatever it was.

Peter LewisYeah. Like like that that is indulgent. And anyone that's a professional politician would say, do not do that stuff because it sends a message to punters that you're out of touch with them. And I think You know, what's Pauline Hansen's policies gonna do that is gonna make your life better and you don't prosecute that case, you know, pull side with the Uber rich. And so I do think that the the consequence free politics of Hansen that has had thirty years of, you know, the noise is rewarded with amplification. Now the noise is being rewarded with accountability and I think that creates a different dynamic, don't you reckon?

Damian DamjanovskiWell, I think I do think you're right on this. I'm I'm not sure how much the policy, the lack of policy matter. So if you imagine Pauline's Hansen's got kind of two groups of support in my head. One is the the diehard Pauline Hansen One Nationers, which is generally hard right, and have been with Pauline Hansen for a long time, roughly about, you know, anywhere between six to ten percent, depending on whose mathematics you use. And then

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskithere's the people who are kind of Pauline curious or as you call them, Peter, the outsiders who look at Pauline and go, well, she's not like the rest of them, so maybe it's time to give her a shot. I think she's grown her base a little bit and then gained a lot of the outsiders. I think what's at risk when she does a lot of these gaffes is those outsiders, because they're the ones who will look at things like her views on domestic violence or some of these gaffs and they start to go, that's a bit that's a bit untenable. And then they justify why they're moving away from Pauline by going, but she doesn't really have detailed policy positions. That's why I'm potentially rethinking my support for for One Nation. I I

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskiagree with you. I think it's plateaued. I just don't know how much or when that support will start to dip. I think it's still a few gaffes away. And I think before the end of the year we'll might see one or two more of them. That said, whether or not she can recruit a few new members to help like a few new candidates and star people to kind of help correct

Peter LewisWell,

Damian Damjanovskifor that.

Peter Lewisthey're running the Victorian election, which is only it's few I think it's three or four months away. They still haven't got a

Damian DamjanovskiTwo months. Yeah, three months away.

Peter Lewisn they still haven't got a leader or a nominated candidate and they're ahead in the polls like WTF, you know, what do you do with that? Damn, the other thing that I have noticed though, in the last couple of weeks is the Libs seem to have landed on a strategy now to attack and differentiate rather than try to amplify and copy and I think that's been really interesting. I don't know if it's if you can cast any light on the thinking behind that, but I I do I have noticed a change up in the last sort of yeah, again, probably since the press club, but particularly with Taylor.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, and look I and and I I can only speculate rather than speak to any insider knowledge, but I think you're you're absolutely right. I I wouldn't so go I wouldn't be so generous as to say they have crafted

Peter LewisIt's

Damian Damjanovskia new strategy so much as fallen into one. which was I think Angus's budget and reply obviously had a few like didn't shotgun, but it took a few different directions. then as they saw the initial reactions to some of those directions. It kind of narrowed in with Tim Wilson's press club speech really on, you know, the economy, small business, supporting small business, which is where the Liberal Party does well. This is one of the equities of the coalition in general, is support for small businesses, smaller government, fewer taxes. And they're just hammering that home. So it's one of these things that I think they've they've stumbled into remembering what made the coalition successful in the past. a as though they've had amnesia over the past

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskithree years and gone, yeah, that's right. That you know, having all these identity politics fights doesn't actually get us anywhere. But when we talk about the economy,

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskipeople might actually vote for us. So you you gotta hand credit where it's due. They they they've remembered what works. So I I would say yes, they they've found a good position yet again. hopefully they can maintain it without accidentally slipping into more identity politics discussions or falling into the populist trap of just bashing immigrants and hoping that that somehow magically wins votes because as you and I both know, a large a large part of the voting cohort for the Liberal Party is immigrants. and a lot of them is recent immigrants, especially from both South and the eastern parts of Asia. and they don't like it when parties tell them that they're basically, you know, they're they're They're essentially unwelcome guests in the country. So

Peter LewisMm.

Damian DamjanovskiI don't know how far they'll go. But the I think the last thing I wanted to to chat about before we let you go, given that I know you have another engagement to go to, is the swimmers at the Commonwealth Games being banned from thanking their patron Saint Gina Reinhardt, the fine Ms. Gina Reinhardt. What what have you have you heard about this or?

Peter LewisYeah, so she's yeah, yeah, yeah. So she's basically offered, I think it's twenty grand a medal, is it? I don't know if she's graduating gold, silver and yeah they are. Here we go. twenty for gold,

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, so it's twenty for a twenty for a gold.

Peter Lewisfifteen silver, ten bronze, and thirty grand for a world record. it it is interesting thinking through whether this corporate support maybe we change up the national anthems. I don't know if our billionaires need to given that billionaires are now sort of more carry more wealth than many sovereign states, whether we get in a world where y each billionaire has their own anthem, Darmay. And I don't know if it was Gina what it's going to be, but given f her her love of the slouch hat and the Bush conference, it's probably going to be something pretty bad by Troy Casadaly or John Williamson or something that they can go on their their podiums and salute the great Gina for her mag municipants. and whether also Paul Lee and would then be given the the the job of sort of putting the metals round the neck, maybe that's the next

Damian DamjanovskiBut

Peter Lewispart.

Damian Damjanovskibut you you gotta admit, most of our athletes aren't some of them aren't paid anything. and most of them are not given any kind of remuneration for what is often years of training and sacrifice. The idea of wealthy people being patrons for sports and the arts, this is not a new concept. This goes back to

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskibefore the ages of the Medici and the Renaissance, all the way back to ancient times when throughout history

Peter LewisAnd it was interesting. The Medishis were effectively the state. Like they they w they they were the state.

Damian DamjanovskiThey were, but but they weren't the only ones. The point is, throughout history, whenever there has been any kind of structure that allowed for some part of the population to accumulate wealth faster than others, it has been almost a responsibility of the wealthy class to be patrons for our sports, arts, and other pursuits. What's wrong with that as a model? Why do we look down on it now and go, nah, you shouldn't do that? The taxpayer should foot the bill. Because we know the taxpayer won't foot the bill. Taxpayers not gonna give swimmers twenty grand for

Peter Lewisto be fair, this

Damian Damjanovskia gold medal. They'll they'll give him an institute to train in, but they won't reward them for success.

Peter LewisElite athletes are incredibly well supported by the taxpayer, particularly, you know, in those Olympic medal winning sports through the Institute of Sports and and state based ones. So I yeah, my thing with

Damian DamjanovskiWhy not give him another twenty grand?

Peter Lewisbut my thing with BNS is pay your taxes and then there's more in the pie to to offer institutional support. elite athletes, I've always had an issue with them. We grow Like and it is is it's the same with culture. So stay with me for this with a sec. So there are lots of people that want a career in the arts, there's lots of people that want a career in sport. Small numbers succeed. Most of them are supported first by community, by their parents, then by programs that are funded by taxpayers. And then the ones that get to the top and win a medal or a contract in a in America and pop off and make amazing amounts of money. then work out ways of minimising the tax going back to the taxpayer, setting up like I I think the one thing we could do to equalize you know, the the wealth generated in sport was to sort of a shame the very successful to putting their money back into those sports by paying their taxes and also recognize that as a society where you grow people that excel, it's a collective pursuit.

Damian DamjanovskiSure. But just to add to that as a slight point of contention, while while I totally agree with you, big corporations who skirt their taxes, and most of them tend to be foreign-owned corporations, are are doing an ill justice by all of us. Gina and Hancock Prospecting are one of the largest taxpayers in Australia. They're an Australian-based company. They paid, I don't know, a couple of billion dollars at least in tax over last financial. And just disclaimer, I have no Not paid in any way by Gina or Hancock prospecting on anything, but they are large taxpayers. Like our mining companies are genuinely some of our largest taxpayers in the country. So she's paying her fair share, but then on top of that, giving some of our athletes a an extra little, hey, if you do really well, here's a bit of a bonus. And I just, I, I find it hard to see what's wrong with that. We shouldn't we should be applauding people like Gina being like, hey, if our Billionaires want to do that. If Mike Cannon Brooks wants to go, you know what, I'll also chip in 20 grand if you win a gold medal at the swimming. Why shouldn't we encourage that? That's my only point on that.

Peter LewisYeah. Yeah. I'm happy for her to throw her money anywhere she wants. I'm not I'm not a fan of billionaires. I feel I think I said it the other week every ever

Damian DamjanovskiYou've a you have a philosophical opposition to billionaires, I get that.

Peter LewisEvery billionaire is a policy failure. If there if someone is a billionaire, inevitably something's gone wrong for the rest of us. And that, you know, hyper concentration of wealth, particularly someone like, you know, Gina Reinhardt, who inherited her wealth from her father's prospecting on Indigenous lands before Indigenous people had any rights. You know, there there is a bigger story to be had that maybe somebody maybe one day has with Gina, her flirty.

Damian DamjanovskiWe we I think we're happy to unpack this.

Peter Lewisher flirting with, you know, the the craziness of the Trump world, I don't think aug as well. She's not my chosen billionaire. she's obviously Pauline's. I think ultimately that's the poison chalice. She'll Hansen will be incredibly well funded through that association. But also I think, you know, there will be It it won't be sort of money for nothing and there will be an expectation of certain policies that should heaven help us, Hansen ever has any opportunity to shape the nation, won't be good for any of us.

Damian DamjanovskiI I genuinely look forward to a session in the near future where we unpack our favorite billionaires and the pros and cons of each of them. maybe maybe Gina and Pauline are evil twins, who knows? But on that note, have you got any predictions for the the week coming, assuming that other than your hangover?

Peter Lewisthe kiss of death. So my kiss of death is actually also an ad. So but people who listen to What's Your Poison and thank you, we've got a growing audience. You are now outstripping my other podcast burning platforms, which is just on tech. But we are doing a live event next Tuesday evening. If you're in the Paramatta area, we're putting on again, it's not That's different to what's you're putting. We're putting on drinks at five o'clock. We're doing a public forum with support of the McKinnon Foundation's Democracy Counts campaign around mis and disinformation. Hamish McDonald, who did the series matter of facts, will be one of the panelists and will be having some interactivity. I even believe that you may be coming, Dame. So if there are any

Damian DamjanovskiI will definitely be there.

Peter Lewiswhat's your poison fans in the Parramatta region, which is a pretty small fenn diagram? You are welcome to join us and meet us in real life.

Damian Damjanovskiabsolutely. And I'll

Peter LewisWhat about you? What's what's your what's your kiss of death? Mine's mine's sort of clearly gonna come true.

Damian DamjanovskiMy case of death relates to a s a small thing that happened as part of the labor conference, which is a the Adelaide Airport took down a piece of advertising. and I think it was from like I I I can't remember the details if it was, but it was someone in the water Murray Darling. They're basically advocating for changes to that how the Murray Darling Water Authority allocated water, this, that, and the other. but they took it down as being quite as being too controversial. And I think that's quite interesting because obviously a lot of outdoor like outdoor companies usually take money from whoever it is as long as it's correctly authorized. It's not necessary for an outdoor company to necessarily pass judgment on the content itself as long as it meets the ad standards.

Peter LewisWe've never been a we've never been able to get political billboards up in airports. It's the one place it's really, really hard. They've got their own I think particularly since they've all been privatised, they have much tighter guidelines than anywhere else. So doesn't s a doesn't surprise me.

Damian DamjanovskiI think I think over the next week this will become a a bigger story and whether the Outdoor Media Association or some of these bigger companies get involved in it, I think watch this space because I think there's an

Peter LewisHmm. Alright.

Damian Damjanovskiunresolved question there about what role do they all play in determining what can and can't go up. Are they allowed to take sides? Should they be allowed to, etcetera?

Peter LewisMm. So from rent this space we're gonna go to watch this space. Yeah. On the I don't

Damian DamjanovskiWatch this space. Mr

Peter Lewisknow who's gonna close it up. You close it up. I'm tired.

Damian DamjanovskiAll right, I'll close it up just so that you can get back to your conference. Mr. Laws, thank you for joining me this week as we do every week. I'm really glad that you're having an amazing time down there at the Labor Conference. I look forward to the session on Tuesday night for burning platforms. As you said, if anyone's in Parramatta, come along. I think you've got an eventbrite link or a

Peter LewisAt the five. Yeah, we might chuck it in the show notes if we can do that in the YouTube. Is that okay if I flick that through to you? Awesome.

Damian DamjanovskiYep. Absolutely. otherwise I will see you next Friday for another week of discussion. If you have enjoyed the show, please like, share, and subscribe. And as always, we look forward to seeing you next week. Thank you for joining us.

Peter LewisHere we go.