Episode 17

Vic's new Premier, future of the Liberal Party, the Beattie Gambit

With Keith Wolahan

31 July 20261 hr 10 min

Show notes

Guest - Keith Wolahan (former MP, Menzies)

This episode we deep dive into Victorian politics, the future of the Liberal party, the the evolution of political messaging, the impact of historical political strategies, and the role of values in political identity.

You can read Keith's article here:
https://inflectionpoints.work/articles/liberal-foundations

Chapters

  • 00:00 Setting the Scene: Happy Friday, Peter
  • 02:34 Introducing Keith Wolahan
  • 37:03 The Evolution of Political Messaging
  • 41:01 The Impact of Historical Political Strategies
  • 45:19 The Role of Values in Political Identity
  • 46:51 Modernising Political Infrastructure
  • 51:02 The Influence of Digital Technology on Politics
  • 55:01 The Changing Dynamics of Political Alliances
  • 01:01:45 Reforming Parliamentary Practices
  • 01:06:52 The Future of Infrastructure Projects

01:08:17 Predictions and Speculations

Full transcript

Read itHide it

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.

Damian DamjanovskiWelcome to What's Your Poison, the show where people who rarely agree on anything agree that it's better to do so over a drink. My name is Damir Damianovsky. I'm a director here at General Strategic. And joining me as he is every week is Peter Lewis from Essential Media.

Peter LewisYeah.

Damian DamjanovskiHappy Friday, Peter. What's your poison for this week? And how has your week been?

Peter Lewispretty hectic week. We had a a live show of Burning Platforms, my other podcast out at Parramatta on Tuesday night. Thanks to you and Jules for coming out and being a part of it. It was one of the events that McKinnon's putting on as part of their democracy counts campaign, which is trying to get people thinking about how to play the game better, which is actually what this show's all about, as well as you know. Tonight tonight I am prepping for dark beer night at the Petershambolo. So I've got myself a dark beer, the Kostritzer Schwarzbier, and I am having it in my late father Kev's pewter. So there you go. it's my every month or so I have one for Keb. Good week.

Damian DamjanovskiCheers to Kev.

Peter LewisYeah. another Keb over my back shoulder, by the way. I pulled that one out.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, tell me about what is Kevin up to these days? Kevin Rudd, that is.

Peter LewisI think he's in a very important think tank. Keith might know more when we we bring him in. But this is part of my collection of election posters from my era of working at number at Sussex Street in the city. And every election there was always these leftover. I've got some very random ones, but got a beautiful Kevin collection as well. So I thought I'd bring it out for the show today. What's your poison and how was your week though, Dame?

Damian DamjanovskiIt's been a good week. It was lovely to see you out in Parramatta. Parramatta's my old stomping ground, as you know. I I grew up out there. So it was always it's good to see the city of Parramatta has really kind of come into its own as Sydney's multicultural center. But all the big news this week has really been about what's happening down south in Victoria. So

Peter LewisSouth of the border.

Damian DamjanovskiI thought in honor of Jacinta Allen, I would drink the only beverage that makes sense in Jacinta's honor, which is Mel Melbourne bitter.

Peter LewisHemlock?

Damian DamjanovskiSo I'm going to crack open a Melbourne

Peter LewisGood.

Damian Damjanovskibitter for Jacinta Allen because I feel like that's what she is. and this week I'm very excited. We have a great guest to talk to us about all things Victoria, all things Liberal Party, all things politics. And that's the one and only Keith Wallaham. So Keith is a I'll I'll let him talk a little bit about his history, but he's now a practicing barrister in commercial and public law. He served as a federal member for the seat of Menzies, which is a federal seat, obviously. And he took over from Kevin Andrews after Kevin left the parliament, previously the grandfather of the House. Keith then in the most recent election, the twenty twenty five election, lost the seat to a Labour candidate who's now the sitting MP. And it's the first time Menzies has ever gone to Labour. And that's partly a result of a redistribution, which changed the calculus of the seat, but also a continued massive swing against the Liberal Party across the board in

Peter LewisA good trademan doesn't blame his tools, Damo.

Damian DamjanovskiAll right, well, look, it was Keith who lost the seat. He ran a terrible campaign. I don't think he's a particularly state. No, Keith is genuinely,

Peter LewisHa ha ha.

Damian Damjanovskibecause I know he won't say this about himself. Keith is one of the most impressive people we've had in Parliament, especially from a coalition perspective. And I think I've always respected and admired Keith because he's one of those people who truly lives up to what you would consider classic liberal values. And I th when he lost his seat, I genuinely thought it was one of the worst things. And worst losses for the coalition that we've seen over the past ten years is losing someone like the talent of Keith Wallahan in there. That said, and sorry for a very l lengthy stop introduction. Keith, thank you for joining us this week. What's your poison? And tell us a little bit about your journey.

Keith WolahanThank you. it's great to be here with both of you. my poison these days is really coffee, far too much coffee, which I think is fair to say is the the steak poison of Victoria these days. So I d do enjoy coffee. part of that is my my wife doesn't drink and I as a parliamentarian I drive everywhere and it was just easier not to drink. Yeah. I'm betraying my Irish roots though.

Peter LewisThere's no judgment, Keith. It's okay. We're we're not we we are indulgers.

Keith WolahanYeah.

Peter LewisI did a bit of research 'cause we haven't met before, so lovely to meet you. one of my good mates lives in your seat or your former seat, Menzies, who would never ever vote for you, but he did say that he thought the campaign that you ran was one of the most civil, respectful and with two good candidates representations of democracy he'd seen. So I guess do you regret that?

Keith WolahanI I don't and and th the loss is fully on me. I I've I don't blame other people or institutions for for the loss, so it's always on me. But but but that's it. I I'm still I look back on the campaign and there are national forces and things that you can't do much about. You can only concentrate on your local campaign. but for a metropolitan liberal seat, I'm still proud of the the results. Like even with all of the headwinds. against the campaign, it was still only a a point six percent swing, whereas the national swing was three point six. So if you're gonna benchmark how the campaign went, I

Peter LewisMm.

Keith WolahanI think that's a fair benchmark. And then if you look at the the swing that liberals had in metropolitan seats, it was even higher than three point six. So

Peter LewisMm.

Keith WolahanI don't know if I had more people, more money or a time machine, what I would do differently. but it's

Peter LewisYou

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Peter Lewiswere carrying a lot of baggage that wasn't your own as well, to be fair. I think you were you were in one of those seats that

Damian DamjanovskiAnd

Peter Lewiswas carrying the cost of a strategy to amplify the immigration issues, some of the things that we'll talk about later. So I I I

Damian DamjanovskiAnd

Peter Lewisfeel like you were carrying a pretty bad product, you know, to that particular

Keith WolahanIt w look, it was

Peter Lewiselection.

Keith Wolahanit was one factor amongst many, but I I spent a fair bit of time not only looking at my own seat but the Liberal Party more broadly. And I think if you look back on that that time, when you look at the the correlating factors with the the bigger swings, what stood out more than any was the those who had a higher education debt. So I think as a singular policy campaign pitch, leaving aside the merits and there's There's definitely

Peter LewisMm.

Keith Wolahanissues with the long-term affordability of running campaigns like that. But as a as as an issue in in an election, it definitely swung a lot of votes. And so I

Peter LewisMm.

Keith Wolahanremember seeing a heat map of the people who had the largest, highest education debt in the electorate and then the largest swings, and they directly correlated.

Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm. Now, now Keith, we we will dig in a bit more into the the future and the party and and what's happening in Victoria. But before we touch on that, I'll just I'd love to kind of hear in your words the story of kind of how you got into this, because a lot of people who listen to our show aren't necessarily political insiders and they are always fascinated by how people get into politics. And you obviously came here as a kid from Ireland. You've you know you're you you're in law, you've served Australia in the defense force. Tell us a little bit about your story and how you got to being an MP, like that journey.

Keith WolahanYeah, just a a very quick log cabin story. I wasn't born in Australia, came out here at the at the you know, at the start of grade six, and then got to go into high school and had some teachers at a great public school who really made me interested in politics and the news. It sounded like a I don't know, like a soap opera that I started to learn the characters and read the newspaper every day and just Just loved it. I I just was a news junkie and and then became a politics junkie in university, but was drawn to liberal values through the Liberal Club at Melbourne Uni and then the Liberal Party. So that was really my intro to the Liberal Party. a career in the army, a career in law. I I really loved both and I'm now back as a barrister. but I think that what drew me to the army is probably the same thing that drew me to politics, which was A combined sense of service, of giving back, but but also a selfish desire for curiosity. I I I've always been curious as to what's behind the curtain of an institution,

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Keith Wolahanparticularly an institution that has a huge sway over people's lives. And and that combination of service and curiosity has sort of taken me in many different twists and turns. but I'm find myself now back as a barrister and yeah, involved in a some really interesting cases and we'll see what the future holds in terms of politics for me.

Damian DamjanovskiThat's awesome. And s service is obviously one of the the most honorable reasons to get into politics, I think, these days. We see a lot of people who got into politics very early and just kind of that has been the entirety of their career. and there's an

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskiargument to be made that that's not necessarily having the majority of our parliament made up by career politicians is not necessarily a good thing for our democracy or for constituents. So it's it's always refreshing when people have the call to service and that serves separate to their kind of career and other vocations that they do in their lifetime.

Keith WolahanAnd I think it's going to matter more and more. I I I think the uncertainty that has always existed in politics is now being magnified. if if someone is listening or watching this who's interested in politics, the the cost benefit of walking away from another career to do it is higher than it's ever been, particularly

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Keith Wolahanif you're going to serve in a House seat, whether it's state or federal, there's probably the last bit of certainty you're going to get is number one on a Senate or upper house ticket. but but really you've got to be a creature of a political party to, you know, to secure one of those and they're very rare. so it's it's an it's more uncertain than ever. So I I think you want people of competence and character to be involved in politics, but I think they need to be more first and foremost, risk takers now because

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Keith Wolahanand and to take that risk you need to have to be driven by that sense of service. Because otherwise why would you walk away from something else that you're good at and is paying your bills?

Peter LewisSo Keith, you were there for a good time rather than a long time. what was the experience like? And I'm particularly interested in this the the the relationships you made across the aisle and your general impression of what it was like to go into that world of many people that had been building their whole career to be there and very, you know, professional and assured, often had worked in ministers' offices and then were in the main roles themselves. But what was the experience like for you?

Keith WolahanIt overwhelmingly it was a rewarding one and th that is my interaction with people on my own side, on on the other side and on the crossbench. I think there are there is still a carryover in that place, at least last term of parliament, where I think there still is a sense from some that it's a career and there was a, you know, do your time before you can have a meaningful impact. And and I didn't feel that way from the get-go because I I was in a seat that was highly marginal from the very start. So I had this sense that this could be temporary from the first day. So I had this itch to contribute as much as I could in you know, in the possibility or probability that it was only for that one term. And and sometimes some people you get the sense they think, you know, know your place or maybe, you know, do more media next term or, you know, contribute in something. you know, more substantial in a few years and and I felt impatient for that, n not for a sense of advancement, but because we're we're not here for a long time.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, and you should feel that you're like every politician should feel that their time is limited. I think that's a very healthy way to approach it rather than the idea that you're going to be there for thirty years and one day you'll get around to it. 'Cause I think you're right there. I think that era is now come to a close.

Peter LewisYou're talking about our Prime Minister there, Damier.

Damian DamjanovskiWell, I mean, you know, the thing is, I think mediocrity takes time to foment. And I think we we've seen and I don't just mean Alba, obviously, there's there's quite a few politicians who've been there for a long time. And as a as a voter, you can feel the mediocrity of them Having been there for thirty years.

Peter LewisIt's nothing like the states where you've got all these elder people in their seventies and eighties because

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter Lewisthe seats are never contested either. Like it's really weird how that system's aging. But hey, Keith, what

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter Lewiswould have been on your highlight reel of your time? Like what are the things that you were really that we might not know about that you were really happy having either been involved with or achieved?

Keith WolahanYeah, the the committee work, it's it doesn't make the press very often. But like I I you know, thanks to Julian Lisa, who was the shadow attorney general, he he he gave me a lot of leeway to lead the coalition voice on two committees. One was on the National Anti Corruption Commission. And you would think that in opposition you you don't have much to do, but thanks to the late Senator Linda who sorry the the Linda yeah who was there and

Peter LewisLinda White, yeah, fantastic woman, yeah.

Keith Wolahanand she I worked with her very closely where I actually got to help with some of the provisions within the act and help draft it and I never thought you could do that from opposition

Peter LewisShe was the union organizer, you see, she got you to work, yeah.

Keith Wolahanand and I re and the other one was a an another late labor member which was the national you know the Murphy Report Peter Murphy and working on that so They were two committees that made me realize even in opposition, you can do a lot through the committee process. If you approach it in good faith, and that doesn't

Peter LewisMm.

Keith Wolahanmean you don't hold witnesses, hold their feet to the fire and push hard for things to be done, but but also you you have to look back to your own party and say, Well, I've got to bring my own party with me. And so stand up in the party room and you know, within the bounds of what you're allowed to say for in confidentiality reasons. Tell them where you're going and why you're going in that direction. And so those committees I I really enjoyed and didn't really make the press much, but but I was very grateful for that opportunity. Then the third one was the voice referendum. So there was the national debate about the voice, but then there was the

Peter LewisMm.

Keith Wolahancommittee work. We didn't have a constitutional convention. The substitute we had for that was that committee, and I was the the deputy of that committee and and you know found that very interesting.

Peter LewisWhat was your journey on voice? Where did you land?

Keith WolahanI was always against it. Yeah, I always against it. for primarily for constitutional reasons. I I'm a big fan of our Commonwealth Constitution. It's a boring document, but it served us very well. And so any change I I always approach with skepticism and and and I thought that particular model had high risk, particularly in the voice to the executive.

Damian DamjanovskiNow the thank you for that, Keith. I do want to ask, because obviously you are a and we c we'll forgive you for this, but you're a Victorian through and through.

Keith WolahanHm.

Damian Damjanovskiso so you live in our great southern state. and I think we we do really want to dig into from your view what the hell happened this week in Victoria. So Peter, as you know, and you can maybe talk to this from a Labour perspective in a little more detail. Old mate Jacinta is out. we've got this new guy, Ben Carroll. the the meme, and I think most Australians know him now purely through Batuda posts about the fact that he looks like a lesbian. That's pretty much what most people know about Ben Carroll at this point. That's that's the extent to it. He seems like he has that middle ground, middle manager, won't annoy anyone vibe to him. but the first thing he did is obviously roll commission into the big build, announcing cutbacks on the suburban rail loop. Like he he's trying to make a big impact. Peter, any inside info, and then Keith. What's your view on this?

Peter LewisOkay, so I think Jacintra Allen got beaten by mathematics. I think the view had formed that I think she was about net negative forty on personal approval and the the primary was about twenty three. So when that when that

Damian DamjanovskiSorry, d is that is that particularly bad for Victoria or

Peter LewisYeah, yeah. Like it's it's it's as bad as the it's change of government numbers. People see the writing on the wall. It's not unusual to people to to make the calls, you know, in very close to an election if it thinks it can't get any worse. Think of Rud Gillard, think of you know, and it it's interesting, very rarely is it a successful move. Oppositions up often do it. Like regularly the state opposition in New South Wales will shift a leader out three months before the election because the numbers just aren't there. So I think she fell to Mathematics based on the fact the government's been in for a hell of a long time. Like this would be their fourth term, but there was also three terms of Labour and then only one term of the Lib. So like Labour's been in there a long time. So they're carrying lots and lots of baggage. So the mathematics

Damian DamjanovskiI think

Peter Lewisgotter

Damian Damjanovskithe Liberals have only had a couple of years in the past thirty in Victoria, is that right? Four years one term, four years in the last thirty.

Peter LewisOne term. Ted Bailey, that's it. So since Kennet, one term in twenty eight years. So it's

Keith WolahanYeah.

Peter Lewisand there's issues I think that we can talk about around how does that create a gov like an opposition that's ready to govern. But so I think they've said, gotta try something different. Here's the other guy. for background he's ex he worked for Bracks, he worked for Conroy, he's linked to Miles and the Shoppies and that sort of part. So it's gone back from the left to the right. I think what he is trying to do though is what I call the beattie gambit. So Peter Beattie, Peter

Damian DamjanovskiWhat's the beat again bit?

Peter LewisBeattie was a premier of Queensland in the early 2000s. Corruption's running ripe while he is in power and he does this amazing shtick where he goes to elections saying, this is outrageous. It's happened under my watch and I'm the only man to fix it. And he just managed to Turn it from being defending the corruption or whatever is going on to saying, yep, it's there. What are we going to do about it? And so the the the accepted reality was that the CFMEU and the big build and the alleg the allegations and the push for a Royal Commission would totally destroy Labour. The bet is that that will all come out now through the Royal Commission is called, but because he's a bit distanced, he can go, yep, and who do you think's gonna fix it? Me? or the people that have only had one term in 30 years. So I think it's actually, I I hadn't heard him described as a lesbian. I'd heard him described as a wet lettuce, but there might be one world where a stable wet lettuce beats something that looks unstable. So that anyway, that's the logic bet behind doing it. Like I say, history

Damian DamjanovskiHmm.

Peter Lewissuggests it won't be successful because very rarely delay leadership changes. I think you guys and Scott Morrison was probably one of the few that actually executed.

Damian DamjanovskiKate?

Keith WolahanWell, I I think Battuta often nails it, and that can be they can also be quite cruel. I thought a better one they did was where they had that famous picture of Stalin and Trotsky where he removes them from the image. And so when when Ben Carroll said,

Peter LewisYeah.

Keith WolahanI'm not Daniel Andrews, I'm not Jacinta Allen, suddenly there was Ben Carroll sitting there with both of those images have disappeared from the edge of the water. I that there is a there is a question that people in the Liberal Party have and they they don't often say it out loud is that is our politics at a state level similar to some of the states in the United States in that if if if I was in the Republican Party in the United States, w w would I bother campaigning in Boston and San Francisco and New York and Los Angeles? Now, I I don't believe that that applies in a compulsory voting democracy here. But when your party has only won one term out of 28 years, there is a a real question where, you know, what does it take for the cycle to turn? That said, it really feels like for the first time in a quarter of a century that that that cycle has reached that point, that the corruption and the allegations of the corruption have reached school drop off conversations, people at the footy are talking about it. I mean, social media has blown up. Dave Hughes is obviously on in everyone's mind, but

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Keith Wolahanhe's he's not a natural liberal. And you know, w you could probably count him as a labor man at some

Peter LewisAnd is Beck Judd in there too, someone was saying? Like is she part of the

Keith WolahanYes. Beckjad sort of came to the party a bit you know a few years ago on crime. Yeah,

Peter LewisCame to the brown lows, we like to say, but yes.

Keith Wolahanthat's right. but but this stuff matters because w when when people aren't consuming news in you know conventional ways or there isn't a newspaper on the dining table, what your friends and social media feed says, you know, it has an impact and and you can't help but feel it and see it in Melbourne. Melbourne is You know, most of the seats in Victoria in the Victorian Parliament. And when you go through Melbourne, the big build, it's become a scar on the landscape because it

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Keith Wolahansome of these projects are going years over time. There's a lot of graffiti and rubbish associated with them, huge amounts of delay. And one of the problems is they're trying to retrofit all of this infrastructure on top of where people live. And that's probably an indictment on poor planning from previous generations.

Peter LewisWas it a good strategy originally to pump a lot of money post I I think it was sort of out of the back of COVID the idea was we'd sort of stimulate the economy through big infrastructure projects? Was it was the problem in the conception or the execution, do you reckon?

Keith WolahanI think it was the execution. And and a good contrast is Israel did a huge amount of construction, but they built it during COVID. So a lot of people came out of lockdowns. There's the new freeway, there's the new tunnel, there's a new road. We we started that construction when people were just coming out of one of the longest lockdowns. So it became a hindrance and an inconvenience. And then when you add on top of that, the the cost blowouts in every project, there's you could fairly say there's a 30%. premium on every kilometer of road or tunnel or bridge in

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Keith Wolahanthis state compared to others. And and people know that. There's a lot of zeros at the end of 15 billion. But when you break that down for every man, woman and child in Victoria, it's it's it's a lot of money that they feel like being spent on

Damian DamjanovskiHuge amount of money.

Keith Wolahanother things.

Damian DamjanovskiAnd I think you're absolutely right. The white elephant that is the big build, they, you know, with good intentions, put up all the cladding with the big, beautiful posters on it. You know, this is all part of the big build. And when that's fresh, it looks great. But the longer it takes, the more it becomes dilapidated.

Peter LewisI think it was the last campaign, yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiThat now becomes a lightning rod for every issue that people have because they go. There's that big build going nowhere. It's branded. The cladding is all colorfully drawn up with big build, but now it's got graffiti on it, garbage out the front, the homeless man sleeping at the front, the

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskisix stores felice either side of it. And then the the vibe of it absolutely changes.

Peter LewisSo it's like the opposite of the level crossings. So Andrew's sort of in his first term built all these level crossings to to get the rail network working and it was a it was a physical manifestation of a government doing things. Whereas I think what Key's saying is people are recognising that this is a ph physical manifestation of government not doing things. Is that a fair read? Yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiExactly. And and I think that there's a wonderful point of comparison as well for a lot of people, especially in Victoria, which is a lot of the New South Wales construction, which was started before COVID but continued through COVID and finished up afterwards, basically started opening up after COVID, similar to what happened in Israel. So people came out of COVID in New South Wales and suddenly there was new underground tunnels, there were spaghetti interchanges, metro lines with these big, beautiful sandstone underground stations had opened. And it felt like the state and the city of Sydney, especially, had jumped, leaped forward into this is a whole new era for Sydney. And meanwhile in Melbourne.

Peter LewisOur lockdown wasn't as brutal as the Victorians as well though. Like it went it went long and hard down there.

Damian Damjanovskiwe had Berry Jiclian, you we had a good we a good premier.

Peter LewisYeah, yeah. Not that's not what ICAC thought. anyway, speaking of that, like let's not even go there this week. Although I did think it was really interesting, in the ICAC evidence this week, there was some reclusive liberal donor who just who reckons Scott Morrison was too woke. Like

Damian DamjanovskiI don't know how much of a recluse he was, but

Peter LewisJust is is that a fair i

Damian Damjanovskiyeah.

Peter Lewisis that a fair analysis, Keith? Was Morrison too woke?

Keith WolahanI think that's that's one of those words that's thrown around a lot, particularly

Peter LewisHa ha ha.

Keith Wolahaninternally to Liberal Party, but it means many different things to different people. and y and I think you have to press them on what do you really mean?

Peter LewisI don't know what it means. Yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah. how are you seeing the chances and I mean obviously w you know, without going too in depth on it, do you think the Liberal Party in Victoria like they they seem to be mounting a good attack and a good game? Obviously they're still trying to fight off Pauline Hansen and One Nation down there and all the other threats, but how would you evaluate the the Liberal Party's campaign as it is so far for the state election?

Keith WolahanSo far it's going well and and a key part of that is Jess Wilson. when you're in opposition, all attention, almost all of it goes on the leader and the only time it goes off the leader is if there's disunity, bar a few hiccups, that they're they're they're a very united team. And Jess is sh I think she comes across in the person that I really know, which is a genuine, sincere person who's in politics for the right reasons, which is t to make a difference. so I I think so far so good. but when you look at the sixteen seats that need to swing, some of them are on, you know, eight percent two-party preferred. So that that's a big ask. And and some of those seats I know very well. you know, when you go door knocking in a lot of those seats, w what what what is a factor in politics here? Is there's very few families that don't have someone who has an economic interest in the state. And you know, whether that's through p particular jobs or a connection through the big build. or other areas. Now that doesn't mean they're locked on Labour voters, but but it means that the the the Liberal Party has to reach into constituencies that wouldn't naturally be liberal constituencies. And I think Jess is not taking anything for granted and is pitching to people that Labour might have taken for granted, to to teachers, to nurses, to people who might even be in a union. They they

Peter LewisYeah, well the teachers are at at war at the moment with the government, aren't they? And that was Ben Carroll as the education minister too.

Keith WolahanTh they are. And s and so I think, you know, Jess's task, which I think she takes seriously, is to to look for new liberal ground. And and I think that generally is the lesson for the Liberal Party more broadly. You have you have to look for a new generation. It can't just be asset rich people over a certain age. You have to reach out to young people, people who might work in the public service, people who have only migrated recently. And you cannot assume that there's any knowledge of your core equities, particularly on the economy, you have to

Peter LewisSo

Keith Wolahanrebuild those.

Peter Lewiswhat so you said eighteen seats you need?

Keith WolahanSixteen.

Peter LewisSixteen. Can you do you know where those seats are or is it still a bit hypothetical? Like where are the areas? I know that East Melbourne

Keith WolahanYeah.

Peter Lewishas been was a bit that that that should be reachable.

Keith WolahanSo two yeah, out out of out of the sixteen, two thirds of them are metropolitan seats and about one third are regional outer suburbs. So it's not wholly a metropolitan task. It's it's rural and regional as well.

Peter LewisMm.

Keith WolahanI I think there's there's a lot that are in the eastern suburbs of Melbourne. There's quite a lot of those seats have a

Peter LewisAre they the ones that vote teal federally now?

Keith WolahanNot really. I I think more of them I think the teal state seats have stayed liberal. So when you look at Goldstein or Kuyong, which are the two teal seats in well, one's not in Tim has one Goldstein back, but on a very tight margin, the state seats are still liberal. So within Kuyong, which Josh lost to Monique Ryan, you've that's where Jess is. In Kew, you've got John Pasudo in Hawthorne, and then you have Michael O'Brien who's retiring in Mulvern. So even though it's teal federally, it's wall-to-wall liberal on a state level. And and and there's various reasons for that. You know, one of them is the various donation laws and what that means for running an independent campaign.

Peter LewisAre the teals having a look at any of the seats, do you know, or you're not getting

Keith WolahanThey are. They so they're running in all of those seats again, but then also expanding into others. I I saw recently they're calling the voices of candidates. there's one of them running in Ringwood, which is, you know, further out to the east. there's a retiring member there in Will Fowles, who was the Labour Party, but but is you know.

Peter LewisEssential alumni just quietly. Colourful character.

Keith Wolahanno, he is, and and you know, he is. And but but he's announced that he's not running. So I think that's they see that as an opportunity. but I think the teal the teal teals are really going to concentrate on those seats probably more within Kuyong and and Goldstein. But when you go back to the 16 seats, they're predominantly labor liberal contests. they're very

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Keith Wolahanmulticultural seats, particularly Chinese diaspora to the east in Melbourne and then in Indian to the north, the west and the southeast. but those communities again. There is a feeling that Labour has taken them for granted. They're high percentages of entrepreneurs and small business

Peter LewisMm.

Keith Wolahanowners who are really struggling in this state. And so if if the Liberal Party can

Peter LewisAnd is your thesis they won't be vulnerable to one nation because they're more multicultural or you're not taking

Keith WolahanI don't think you can take that for granted. some of the outer suburban seats like out in Melton and other places, even with a very high migrant population, One Nation's polling very high. But

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Keith Wolahanas you get closer to the C B D, I I that w those One Nation figures drop right off. So they become

Peter LewisMm.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Keith Wolahanmajor party contests.

Damian DamjanovskiSo, Keith, if it's all right, I might I might use this as a point to pivot a little bit. And I I would really like to talk about an incredible, what I'm gonna title an incredible article you penned called Liberal Foundations. so for for some of our listeners who may not have read it, Keith, you penned an article called Liberal Foundations on an online publication called Inflection Points. and it had a lot to it, but It had a basic central argument, which is that this that the Liberal Party and the idea of the liberal conservative in Australia needs to do some serious soul searching if it ever wants to be a party of government again. and I'm not doing the article justice, but I'm gonna summarize some of the main points that I took out of it that I absolutely loved. One was that some of the failures that are happening aren't Cyclical. These aren't things that all, you know, voters will eventually just come back to the party, but rather these are actual structural issues that the party absolutely has to address, everything from the changes in migration, home ownership patterns, education levels, the the generational changes, the fact that the party essentially holds almost no metropolitan seats in Australia at a federal level anymore. The the the metro city center, the cities have abandoned the party by and large. And you make the very good argument that you you essentially can't govern in Australia without the cities. Like it's not mathematically possible. there's so much to it. I I want to tell you firstly that I both admire the article, but I also want to let you know how deeply annoyed I was by it. And I'm gonna tell you why. And that's because I sat there reading the article and going, everything in here is absolutely right. And I'm annoyed that I didn't think to write it first and that no one else has thought to write it until Keith came along, sat down, and penned this thing in one beautiful hit. so that's my my backhanded way of saying my deep admiration for for what you put down. Peter, first your thoughts now that you you've you've read it quite recently, obviously, not being a a

Peter LewisYeah.

Damian Damjanovskicoalition man. What were your thoughts having read Keith's piece?

Peter LewisYeah, I thoug I one one of the things I took away was your your recounting of Texter coming up with the personas for the nineties, which were Phil and Jenny, and they were like the persona that politics was driven towards, which was people without a tertiary education. It was probably a small business or a trade. This was Howard's tradies. And you base you know, Howard succeeded in building a new constituents for the Liberal Party out of that that focus and that insight. And you do make the point that Phil and Jenny are getting on now and their kids went to uni and they've got a different set of challenges, including housing. I and I and I thought that you landed that provocation really well. My question is, liberals tend to do well when people think the status quo is worth protecting and I feel like you you're kicking even more against the breeze than Labour is at the moment of nailing a proposition that says we've got to hold something in the middle. I think it's a very hard place to be. So I don't know if you want to respond or yes and that. But yeah. I I enjoyed it and I thought it was deep thinking as well. I saw eco okay, Damos on that.

Keith WolahanNo, no, thank you for your kind words. I I guess it's it's start one of my passions in in life was always public speaking at high school, even in the military, that the part that I enjoyed often was giving orders, you know, in Afghanistan. I felt like words were bullets. and the first one of the most important questions you should ask before giving a speech is or in advocacy is who's in the room? If I'm going to walk into a hall and convince people to my idea, my argument, or my case as a barrister. Who who am I talking to? Now that doesn't mean you change what you stand for or what you're trying to achieve, but it frames everything in what you say and what you do next. And the sense that I got from the Liberal Party is that we haven't asked that question. And there are a lot of assumptions that are there in politics. There's there's a lot of templating for campaigns. There's a lot of reflection to the good old days of the Howard

Peter LewisMm.

Keith Wolahanera. But but Have the people in that hall that I'm trying to convince, have they moved on? Are there different people in that room? And if so, I the onus is on me to find out who they are. And what jumped out at me was just the the collapse of the vote for the center right in the cities and why that matters. If you go to the US Congress, it's a majority rural and regional Congress at 57%. So you can win and command a majority of that house and the presidency. And pay off a lot of the cities if you're on the center right. You can't on the center left, but you can on the center right. When you come to us, it's flipped, as opposed

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Keith Wolahanto 57% is the number for us from metropolitan seats. So out of 150 seats, 88 are metropolitan. So our democracy is one of the most urbanized on earth, despite being this huge continent. We're actually concentrated in a few cities. And when you look at cities in peer democracies, the center right. Either give up or don't do very well. So the task for the center right here is to win in a political climate and market that our peers don't bother in. And so the task that we have is is quite unique. And then so the paper was about saying, well, who is it that lives in a metropolitan area and why is it that they lean more left than right? And there were three factors that really jumped out. And I did a lot of work with a demographer, Toby Woodridge. And and they were on your your heritage as a migrant,

Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.

Keith Wolahanyour education, and and then home ownership. So those were the three that that dominate. There's many others, but but they're the three structural forces that have changed significantly in these seats. And and I think the Liberal Party needs to A understand that and then B you know double down on its values to a new audience. And The onus is on the Liberal Party to make that case. Because particularly if you're a migrant, you you haven't sat around a family gathering where, you know, granddad talked about Robert Menzies or dad talked about John Howard. I don't

Damian DamjanovskiNo, you don't know who these people are.

Keith Wolahanknow who they are. And you certainly, you know, you're unlikely to have a mainstream news channel on in the background hearing points.

Damian Damjanovskiyou got SPS.

Keith WolahanMaybe, and that's some families, like even, you know, we're we're a political family and and we read the news, but There's many days when I I won't have the seven o'clock news on or the six o'clock news on. And so my children don't get it like I did. I I have to remind myself of that. And so so the core equities that the Liberal Party has banked on on the economy on national security, they don't mean much to new audiences.

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Keith WolahanSo we need to rebuild those. And it's a uniquely Australian task that, you know, there's there's no one overseas that has the template to do it. But if you don't do it, you you're out of power. Permanently. Yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiPotentially forever.

Peter LewisHow how how damaging do you think the dominant so two things have really, I think, knocked your party off course. you had two long period you had a long period of power under Howard, then Labour was a bit of a shit show, and then you guys weren't much better. and in that period, politics got louder, it got more divisive. I think particularly under Abbott, the politics of opposition and that sort of deep embeddement with that sky in infrastructure, that kind of the the Fox News version in Australia. And then it's kind of been the cheer squad that's driven people away from that core you're talking about, but now it's splitting into another party. And that that sort of that shift to the right seems like It's gonna be really hard for you to reverse and hold on to, particularly as you lose more and more seats. So one of the ways I've been thinking about it is with the teals, you lost your left wing, you risk losing your right wing and then what is left, 'cause you've really got to rebuild from there, don't you?

Keith WolahanI was thinking I'm been doing some work with, you know, McKinnon, you know, who are a nonpartisan organization and yeah, they are

Peter LewisHmm. Good people, yeah.

Keith Wolahanand and and they're trying to turn their mind to how to attract quality people of competence and character to any side of politics. And and I was thinking what w if you were speaking to someone who was of competence and character and you wanted them to be involved in politics, a year ago on the center art I would have said, head out to the regions because tha that's that's where The more long-term prospects for you will be. But then now when you look at the One Nation primary, which is highest in the regions, there's nowhere that's safe. And if anything,

Peter LewisYeah, yeah.

Keith Wolahanthere's you know, the the last little bit of ground that you could do is maybe the outer suburbs or you know, seats like like mine. But there's no safe area for people of competence and character to go to. And and I I think those three reasons, those three you know, demographic reasons of heritage. education and home ownership. Th those factors are a bit different in the regions. However, I I think your point about, you know, how media has changed and you know, I I regularly appear on Sky. I was on it today, I'm on every Friday or it's now News twenty four. But but it beams free into the regions, but you gotta pay for it in metro regions.

Peter LewisDo you have the lefty seat on Sky, do you, Keith? Like just so the the counterbalance?

Keith WolahanNo, no, I d well d to to be fair to them, I I I I don't see it that way, but but th this yeah, I think News twenty four is quite different during the day or or in the evening, but but but I mean that the former chair the current chair of the agency was on. Yeah, no, I I have.

Peter LewisHave you ventured in there after dark yet or have you s kept your distance from poor Murray?

Keith WolahanI have, yeah, but but I do remember I remember one coalition regional member got a bit shitty at me for going on Sky so much and they said, you know, people in your seat don't watch it, but people in mine do

Peter LewisYou're not a you're not a good look for my people, Kate.

Keith WolahanWell, no more that I was taking a spot they could take. So I you know, I I didn't realise what they were saying. They said it in a more subtle way. And then I thought,

Peter LewisIt's like a psyops. They're they're they're beaming a a paid service free into the regions. But I don't the point being, it amplifies you, but I don't know if in the long run it does you good.

Keith WolahanWell, I I think I

Damian DamjanovskiWell sorry.

Keith Wolahanthink part of it was a lot of, you know, all of these leadership battles over many, you know, the the last fifteen years in Parliament on both sides, but particularly Liberal Party, it's fed into this internal fights have you know, th they've played out on News Twenty Sky and then News Twenty Four. But but I think people often miss the, you know, which side of the party someone's talking about and they just hear constant criticism of the Liberal Party and they feel, well, you know, you you're no good or, you know, you're too woke or whatever, and and I'll go somewhere else. I think another part of it is when they look at the states and then the the loss that was last year, I think there's some people that say, Well, you're not an election winning machine anymore. I I don't trust that you can win, even though I might want you to, but I'm gonna look to other parties who might be more competitive.

Damian DamjanovskiKeith, I just wanted to ask you, because I after reading your article, I spent a lot of time thinking about this. Because again, it was, it wasn't just erudite, it was really well structured. You can tell you're a barrister and that you enjoy debating and speaking. I did some deep diving into the party and the history. And I have a theory that I want to put to you that I've been working on and expanding on. But I genuinely think if you look back to the history of how Menzies founded the party, it was. While it's a big tent, what's classically called a big tent party, right? Where a whole bunch of views come together and we go, hey, we we accept multiple points of view. It was founded and basically spent the majority of its history being an anti-communism party. So from when Menzi is founded, it was a we are against something rather than this is what we are absolutely for. So the the primary driver of the party for a long time was what we stand against, which was totally fine. It it worked.

Peter LewisBear in mind Labour was split over communism as well, which is why they're in power for twenty odd years, yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiSure, but but it was but Labour was seen by the Australian people to be the, you know, a beachhead of communism into Australia.

Peter LewisHm.

Damian DamjanovskiMen's is one off the back of that, longest serving PM, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. Then we get to the kind of Hawk Keating era. Communism collapses all over the world, more or less, and we we kind of bring an end to the communist experiment. Australia goes through a recession under Keating, and in comes Howard with A combination of a couple of things. One is basically going, hang on, we can we should focus on the economy. So he his kind of main thing is the economy at that point through tax reform and a few other measures. Simultaneous to that, we start importing American-style wedge politics into Australia for the first time. So that Reagan wedge tactic started

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskigetting imported from that first Howard victory for the first time. And we've

Peter LewisYou guys were good at that, yeah.

Damian Damjanovskivery good at it. And we've we we'd never Australia had never really done that to the level that they had started doing it under Howard.

Peter LewisMm-hmm.

Damian DamjanovskiHoward wins off the back of a combination of really good wedge politics and a growth economy that is just too strong. Nobody wants to mess with that.

Peter LewisUnlocked by the economic reforms of the previous Hawkeyan governments, yes. But

Damian DamjanovskiYep, absolutely. So the Hawk Keating reforms helped to put the sales

Peter LewisWhich to be fair were bipartisan, yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiYep. All the way through. Up until basically people just felt the need for change under Howard. And they moved to Howard Light, which was the man over your right shoulder, Peter Lewis, which is K-Rod. K-Rod, Gillard,

Peter LewisKevin I seven.

Damian DamjanovskiK-Rod, complete disaster. People go, No, we don't want that kind of mess. Move back to Tony Abbott with this huge swing towards the Liberal Party. And then

Peter LewisMore wedging.

Damian DamjanovskiAnd then that huge margin just kept getting eaten away after ever at every subsequent election. And reading Keith's article, what I realized and reading through this history was after the fall of communism, the party never did the work that Keith basically outlined in here, which is go, what are our core values? What is the thing we actually stand for? Who do we stand for? And and why should people vote for and

Peter LewisHmm. So true. Because if you're on the side of business when there is no force on the left, you end up being seen as the cheerleader for the status quo. And I think that's where you guys ended up. in a world that doesn't deliver

Damian DamjanovskiWell, and and I think the the whole wedge politics thing, which which again,

Peter Lewisfor people anymore.

Damian Damjanovskiif you're on an upswing, wedge politics works well because you find who are the only people who matter in which seats that matter in order for us to get to fifty plus one. But then as that starts to erode, that stops being

Peter LewisHmm.

Damian Damjanovskinot only does it stop being effective, but it's slightly cancerous on the party because it means you no longer care about any specific values, you just care about the win. So Keith, sorry. This was a bit of a brain fart that I wanted to throw to you 'cause it was me kind of using your article for a jumping point and it just got me thinking in a thousand different directions. And I've been very excited to share this with you for your thoughts on it or your dismantling of as complete garbage.

Keith WolahanNo, no, I know. I I I think that's a g an important observation. and I think I think there are other changes coming though, where, you know, s someone will write an essay like I did in five years from now. And I think one of the things they'll do, they'll say, How did AI change politics? Like there's a lot of discussion about how it's going to change the economy and you know, the IMF is forecasting that thirty percent of service jobs are vulnerable. Like even if it's half of that, that's gonna have a a massive impact. particularly on metropolitan seats. And and so so th that's that's you know a future essay for someone else. But but these these changes really matter. And you can values are your foundations. And that's why I called the you know the essay liberal foundations, because you need to have foundations. But I think it's important we separate what is a foundation and what's furniture. And so if

Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.

Keith Wolahanif we all live in this house that is Australia or the Liberal Party, you know, the metaphor applies to both. We often have fights over things that shouldn't really matter. And th they're often superficial things like, you know, the the color of the drapes or, you know, the painting you hang on a wall or what sort of taps you use in the new kitchen. And reasonable people can disagree about those and we can have healthy debates. But there are some things that are so important that they hold up the house that if you neglect them or get them wrong, the whole thing comes crumbling down. And that applies as much for a political party as it does for a nation. And so What we need to do is to better distinguish the two. And and I like the the you know, the title of this What's Your Poison? I I'd like to think, you know, people can have these vigorous debates about what's furniture. But w when it when it comes to foundations, you know, we

Peter LewisSolid foundation friction creates positive energy, Keith.

Keith WolahanExactly. And and will you'll die on that hill, you'll cross the floor for those issues. And I think one of the things I I did find disappointing in political debate over the last few years is those get blurred and and you'll get people really agitated and upset about something that doesn't really matter and reasonable people can disagree. but but are not enough people are dying on the hills of foundations. But foundations

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Keith Wolahanget you so far, in the end, I think found values which really are foundations, they matter to people when you articulate it in a way we say who you fight for. And and and you mentioned that. And so who you fight for really is the manifestation of the values. And for the Liberal Party, for a long time it has been asset owners. The problem is a lot less people have assets, whether it's in housing or or shares, and and and they're getting older. it was small business owners, but a lot less people are in a small business than they used to be. so so finding out who they are i is a very important question for the Liberal Party and it can it's gonna continuously evolve.

Damian DamjanovskiIt's a it's a such an important question, Keith. And I I think we we've discussed this on this show before, and I I still haven't found the source of where I read this quote that has stuck with me as one of the most damning assessments of Australian life over the past twenty to thirty years, which is Australia's become a nation where you can no longer build a life, you can only inherit one. And that is probably the most damning Donald Horn, Don Horn-esque view of modern Australia I've ever heard. And it's something that no one seems to be really looking at how do we actually fix it. And I and I agree with you, Keith, that I feel like the Liberal Party as the party that we know that asset ownership is one of the key indicators of whether or not you'll vote for center right over center left. We should be doing everything in our power to ensure that people have the opportunity to attain and maintain assets over their lifetime. and it seems like that's not even remotely on the agenda because we're busy talking about everything but The core issue.

Peter LewisCan I just go back to your comment on AI? Because I find it really interesting and it does resonate, Kate. So I'm a progressive. I've always identified as a progressive without really questioning what it is. And I wrote a piece earlier this year where the rush into hyperscaling and you know moving fast on is I don't f I feel like I'm becoming a conservative around the best bit of conservatism of considered slow movement rather than you know, creative destruction. I think there is a realignment around what is going to be a really rapid technological change. I don't think it's washed out yet, but I think it would be a mistake for the Libs just to be seen as being with the big tech companies or saying that accepting there's going to be this trickle down economic benefit. So I think it's interesting you've identified that as a potential point of rethinking where values underpin a political position.

Damian DamjanovskiSo so hang on, Peter, if you're a patriotic progressive and Keith is a compassionate conservative, where where am I stuck?

Peter LewisYou're you're you're our little libertarian buddy. you know you're pretty libertarian. Yeah No no. You can't but you

Damian DamjanovskiI don't think I'm libertarian. I do I do like AI to run rampant. I'm I'm a big believer in the machines.

Keith WolahanI don't I don't think you can stop it anyway. I I I yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiYou can't.

Peter Lewisbut but you but with a conservative mindset you just basically are saying I do think there's a sense of you need to put some brakes on this and think it through clearly, rather than just have it roll over the top. So I don't know. I think it's maybe I don't I don't know. But I think it it's a different way of thinking about it for me anyway. Hey,

Damian DamjanovskiI I I

Peter Lewisbefore we finish, we do need to ask Keith about One Nation, because I don't think I think the elephant's been in the room. You know, particularly in Victoria, we're going to see whether the the Libs preference. have you got a view? Because I feel again there is a trap in chasing one nation to the right where you're particularly with your paper and, you know, the the position of being the people that can sort of hold the country together. There's a real tension there depending where you go.

Keith WolahanI think a more important question, and I'll answer it directly, but a more important question is

Peter LewisMm.

Keith Wolahanwhether you're going to be in a coalition or not. I I I think that's a more consequential one. I I think we twist ourselves in knots over who preferences who. And you know, anyone who picks up a how-to-vote card knows it's your choice. You can do whatever you want. And there's a lot of ill discipline in some parties, more on the right. Like when you look at the South Australian election, that the liberal and one nation votes sprayed all over the place. I I think there was only sixty percent discipline. Whereas when you look

Peter LewisMm.

Keith Wolahanat the Greens preference to the Labour Party, it's like eighty-five percent. So there's more discipline

Peter LewisMm.

Keith Wolahanon the left than the right. And so a a lot of parliamentarians

Peter LewisThat's all that's date control, okay.

Keith WolahanYeah, but a lot a lot that's right. But a lot of people on the right sort of they they don't really like answering that question because it's they feel like it doesn't matter as much. Feel like it doesn't matter. But but politics

Peter LewisBut that's going to be a real that's going to be a real discussion if in Victoria potentially, because the bit we didn't talk about on the map is the red wall of industrial seats that Labour's

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Keith WolahanMm.

Peter Lewisheld really since Brack's one, you know, Geelong, Bendigo and Ballarat. There is a scenario they become one nation seats, and then if that's balance of power, who's going to form an alliance? Or is there a world in which there is a stability pact between the major parties? I don't know.

Keith WolahanWell, I I've I've said publicly and I'll say it here again, I I think the Liberal Party should rule out a coalition with one nation and and be firm on that. And then, you know, if the people in Victoria are a nationally elected parliament that that has many One Nation members will will, you know, so be it. But but that's up to them whether they guarantee supply or not. But but if if you're firm on you won't do a coalition and then you you follow through on that, I I think that's an important signal to send

Peter LewisMm.

Keith Wolahanto the electorate. And it's about self confidence as well. people are obviously frustrated with you know, Labour governments, but also with the Liberal Party. But at some point you have to say, you know, no, I you know, this is an eighty year old institution that has enduring values that still matter today, and I'm gonna fight for them. And part of fighting for them means I I'm gonna I'm gonna be very clear about how we are not one nation and one nation is not us.

Damian DamjanovskiWell, I think that I agree with you ki you I I was just gonna

Peter LewisBut it is a strateg you got it, Donna, sorry.

Damian Damjanovskisay I agree with Keith that I think that there's an element of giving up before game day if you

Keith WolahanMm.

Damian Damjanovskibasically go, Well, yes, we would entertain the notion of entering a coalition with one nation if it helps us kick out the Labour government. That that is basically resigning yourself well before game day and it sends entirely the wrong signal.

Peter LewisBut that is also say I know, that is saying we've got more in common with one nation than we do with Labour. And the reality is, as your experience showed, on day to day, there is more in common between those two parties than there are with a nativist, you know, destructionist party.

Damian DamjanovskiWell the the the quote from the Hamilton musical, right? If you stand for nothing, burr, what will you fall for? This is if we don't if we don't have values that we stand for and we go like, you know what, we're happy to make a coalition with anyone just to get into exactly.

Peter LewisAnd then and then you're just chasing votes. And it's a fool's game like we're seeing now in the UK, where you know, reform sets up and now there's a group to the right of reform. And

Keith WolahanRestore, yeah.

Peter Lewisand Farange is is I I had a look at this, I don't condone sports spending, but Lord Binface is at four dollars to knock Farange off in the seat that he's going. I I feel like it's

Damian DamjanovskiThat's not bad. I do condone gambling and I reckon I'd take those odds to be honest,

Keith WolahanHa ha.

Damian Damjanovskibecause Count Binface is you

Peter LewisHa ha ha.

Damian Damjanovskiknow, he's he's been at this for quite a while. Keith, we're we're we're we're not gonna end yet and we're not gonna end on a negative note. again, referring back to your liberal foundations, the other thing that really hit me, and anyone who knows me and has worked with me will know how long I've been banging this drum, is the need for the modernization of the organizational instruments of the Liberal Party. and when I read your Wonderfully penned piece. I felt like I'd met a kindred spirit who understands the importance of what we now call the tech stack within organizations. That is the infrastructure underneath the organization, not just the person on the core flute, not just the name on the how to vote card, but all the things that ensures that that person is there, that the membership is well communicated to. When we compare the how the Labour Party runs their campaign. How the Teals run their campaign and now how even Pauline is running campaigns to the liberal party machinery, they feel like they're in different centuries, let alone in different decades. Like the it's unbelievable levels of difference. And I was hoping we could unpack this a little bit because you you ran as an MP, you experienced all this stuff firsthand. Obviously, I don't want you to break any confidences, but how dire is this need for the party to let's call it modernize, improve? Get with the times, whatever it is.

Keith WolahanIt will continue to lose unless it fixes it. And it's not just at an organizational level, it's at a parliamentary level. And and part of it is, you know, we are, you know, in a G20 economy with enormous complexities. It is beyond the capabilities of any leader or federal director to to rub their tummy or look in the mirror and get it right. that that's not how you make decisions in a complex environment. In the end, there's a leader who makes a decision. But the decision-making process in the Liberal Party is flawed and it needs to be fixed. And it's something that money and talent can fix. when I looked at the last election, the Liberal Party outspent the Labour Party by $50 million, yet we got smashed. Part of that was because we spent it in a lot of the wrong places at an industrial scale. That's unforgivable. And we should self-reflect and fix that. And and And a good example would be say in like the the military, and you know, the military makes mistakes, but because the stakes are so high, it learns from those mistakes and fixes.

Damian DamjanovskiEvery mistake it learns from.

Keith WolahanAnd and use it, let's use the example of, you know, the the tier one special forces that in 2011 did that raid,

Peter LewisYeah.

Keith Wolahanthe Navy SEALs, SEAL Team Six against bin Laden. Now, people focus on the person

Peter LewisYeah.

Keith Wolahanwho pulled the trigger and the SEALs who landed the helicopters and went in, but but they were the point one percent of that mission. Most of it. was unseeing people who are doing the intelligence to make sure that they hit the right compound at the right time with the, you know, the right resources. And and so I I think in politics we we often focus on the person who's in front of the TV and and we trust their judgment and, you know, they understand Australians more than anyone else. But but we need to make sure that that work puts that person in the right seats in front of the right people with the right resources and the right Policy commitments that are consistent with values, but also appeal to people's genuine concerns rather than what

Damian DamjanovskiHmm.

Keith Wolahanyou think they might care about.

Damian DamjanovskiIt's the the the the machinery of politics. And and Peter, I'd love to obviously you Peter, you've front row seats inside the the Labour tent about how Labour updated and upgraded its machinery again without without revealing anything you can't reveal. how does it look on the Labour side of the fence? I mean, I know you guys are now implementing some real modern techniques compared to a liberal perspective.

Peter LewisYeah. But it's but also I just think Labour's got an infrastructure advantage with their institutional base to the union movement. So you you you kind of keep talking about getting their feedback loops going and knowing what's going on and knowing what's talking to people. When when you've got connections with nurses and teachers through, you know, the union movement, you you you you you've just got a better distribution network than you do. and, you know, on the ground, you know, traditionally it yeah, the the It's always assumed the Libs are buying the sort of volunteers, whereas there is this big volunteer network on the ground. So I think it just makes it a little bit harder. Like the one thing I'll say, and the choice for both major political parties is whether they build a digital infrastructure and then use it to weaponize conflict or to bring people in and have some better political you know, experience than just being angry and voting against someone. And I still think, you know. We're much better at making people vote against than vote for. And you know, if people like Keith can help your side of politics come up with that value proposition, I think it does make for better contests, you know? And I think that's good for democracy.

Damian DamjanovskiI agree and agree. And and look, we we've discussed this at ad nauseum, Peter, but I still continue to be deeply impressed by Byron at the team at Climate two hundred, not because of their policies or their candidates. I don't I don't hate them. Well like I I d I don't I have I have

Peter LewisNow you hate them, don't you? I thought you hated Tails. Do you hate Tails, Kate?

Damian Damjanovskino strong position towards the tears. Yeah.

Keith WolahanI d I'm not a hater. I I don't hate an if someone's winning I I I think it's the onus is on the loser to study them.

Peter LewisI know, you know. Admire that.

Damian DamjanovskiExactly. And and and Keith, studying the teals is so fascinating

Keith WolahanYeah.

Damian Damjanovskibecause you know, obviously we, you know, watch every side when an election happens and watching Byron and the team and how they engaged constituents and potential voters, the weekly Zoom calls with polling where you had 90 to 100 people.

Peter LewisBut they also unlocked the grey army of people between fifty five and seventy that have got time.

Damian DamjanovskiWhich is a huge army in Australia with a lot of money as well. And money is the the blood of a political campaign.

Peter LewisTime and energy and it but then they had a reason, like the they believe in climate action, they wanted integrity and respect for women. I don't think that's far away from where you'd sit, Keith, either. It's just they articulated it as a as a contra to the Liberal Party. And I think it did real long term brand damage there. Yeah. Yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiAnd they mobilized it, which is important. You need to be able to mobilize it. You need them to turn up to a kitchen session, to a door knock, to a polling booth. before we kind of wrap up and get to our kiss of death, which Keith is where we do our predictions, couple of real rapid fire questions I had for you. Do you mind if we just kind of throw them off and you can hit them up? Number one, should we expand the parliament?

Keith Wolahanyes. I I I I think the parliament it, you know, because ultimately it will the seats will be too big. At the moment, the seats are the seat that I represented has 170,000 people, 120,000 voters.

Damian DamjanovskiJesus.

Keith WolahanYeah, it's massive. Like that's that's bigger than most seats in the House of Commons or other peer democracies. There's a point at which it has to be recalibrated to the population. So eventually we'll have to expand it. but when you do that, you really need, I think, bipartisan support to do it.

Damian DamjanovskiLove that. Number two, should there be a term limit for sitting MPs and Senators?

Keith Wolahanno, I think that's anti democratic.

Damian DamjanovskiFair enough. Number three, should donations be disclosed live?

Keith WolahanI think the timeframe should be shorter, but but you need some period to process them, just the administrative process. But I think it could be done a lot quicker.

Peter Lewisbefore the election day.

Damian DamjanovskiFourth and last one, should MP and ministerial diaries be made public within twenty four hours?

Keith Wolahansubject to national security constraints. I I don't I don't see the problem. I think that would be the exception. the the problem with all of these sort of things is though people go off grid, you know, like a a

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Keith Wolahanlot of the messages are done on WhatsApp and other things and that you can't FOI those. So I have a feeling diaries would suddenly be

Peter LewisDo you know

Keith Wolahanvery empty.

Peter Lewisdo you know my favorite

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter LewisTaiwanese politician Audrey Tang, who was the digital minister there and quite transformative, had this policy that she, whenever there was a meeting, she said, I'm gonna publish a transcript of the meeting at the end of the meeting, and you're welcome to redact anything you want. and so everything was effectively public unless the lobbyists wanted it out. And it she reckons it changed the dynamic totally. They could still they

Keith WolahanCan I say that was that was one thing but but that

Peter LewisThey could still black it out, yeah.

Keith Wolahanwas one thing I was pleasantly surprised at. I I I never came across, either myself personally or heard about it, where there was a a strings attached

Peter LewisMm.

Keith Wolahanpressure on either with a donation or a threat with someone. I I never heard that and and and I th you know, touch wood that's the way our democracy stays, but When I visited the US Congress, I I remember speaking to a first term member of Congress and we were sharing notes. And that person said that they're on the phones two days a week raising money. Now I I don't know. Now I don't know I don't know any

Peter LewisThat's why there's no place for you in the New South Wales Liberal Party, Keith.

Keith WolahanI don't know any Member of Parliament in Australia that does two days a week raising funds in Australia and and long may it stay that way.

Peter LewisNo, it's good it's good that we haven't got there here here.

Damian DamjanovskiPeter, it's time for our kiss of death. Keith, our kiss of death is basically our big prediction or small prediction

Peter LewisOkay.

Damian Damjanovskifor the week. You can either be predicting it because you want it to happen or predicting it because you don't want it, because we

Peter LewisOr because we always get it wrong.

Damian Damjanovskialways get it wrong. Peter, I've forgotten what your prediction was last week. I'm so sorry.

Peter LewisMe too, but it's been a long I predicted that we'd have a really good time on Tuesday night and we did. So that was that was a good prediction. So my predic my

Damian DamjanovskiWe did have a great time. So well done. Good prediction. Self serving, but good.

Peter Lewismy prediction this week is that Albo is gonna have some sleepless nights working out how to deal with the announcement by Hannah Ferguson that she's gonna run as an independent ingrained love. so Hannah is the head of Cheek Media, a former ETU organizer who built an empire based on political opinions and dildo sales, and she's popped off. She was part of Labour's influencer strategy, but she's gone rogue. influencers are becoming people that think they can also become politicians. Punter politics had a bit of a go at changing the gas policy. I feel like for him it's recognizing the steps are easier outside the dance. So Hannah has put her hand up. She wrote a piece in The Guardian about why she's taking Albo on, on all the progressive causes that Hot Albo years ago would have been all up for, homelessness,

Damian DamjanovskiOn Alba.

Peter LewisGaza. you've seen those photos. But so my mail is that Albo has ran run Grandler as his domain for close to 40 years. It's very unlikely that she'll do anything but take some votes off the greens, but you never know. But the hard thing is She's got such a high profile. She's an opinionated, progressive woman. And how Alba responds to that is going to be so challenging. We've seen him get it wrong with Grace Tame and then the thing with Kylie we were talking about a few weeks ago, both of which happened on podcasts, I might add. So I think I think I I think they'll be alert but not alarmed. But there is this risk that if you play it wrong, that will really get amplified quickly and really Due to

Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.

Peter LewisAlbo's vote with women, what ended up happening to Scott's vote with women before that election went south. So that's my prediction. He's not gonna

Damian DamjanovskiThat's an interesting kiss of death.

Peter Lewiss we'll have to we'll have to ask him whether he's gonna sleep or not, but I I feel like it's it's it's a bit of a a bit of a quantary for them at the moment.

Damian DamjanovskiKeith, have you got a kiss of death for the next week?

Keith WolahanI I think Ben Carroll will open the books on the suburban rail loop and be more shocked than he thought. And and and I think the temptation to either pause or cancel that project will be huge. But particularly w when I think the debt in Victoria, Victoria is very close to requiring federal bailout, like very close. and and I I think that There will be no other way for him. and that will have a huge consequence for the eastern suburb seats because that that's where round one is built. And I think people will then say, you know, you've been winning elections off the back of this project for many years and now it's over. Yeah. I I just and he'll he'll do it. He'll do it to save the furniture in the west and north, but it will I think it will cost them seats and east.

Peter LewisThe Beattie Gambit, the Beatty Gambit, he's gonna do it. He's gonna do the Beattie Gambit. They always do it. Only Beattie pulled it off.

Damian DamjanovskiBaby Gambit.

Keith WolahanIt'll cost them.

Damian DamjanovskiWell, that I think that happens when you've only got one house to contend with. My kiss of death, thank you, Keith. My kiss of death for the next week. So next week, I believe, is the last week of the winter break before Parliament comes back. my guess is, my prediction, my kiss of death is that we will, and I don't know who, but I think we might see a parli a federal parliamentary retirement or we'll we'll see maybe one defection, maybe one retirement before parliamentary.

Peter LewisWhich side?

Damian DamjanovskiParliament goes back to sitting. I have a feeling it will be on our side. That's my guess.

Peter LewisI wouldn't be surprised if Dreyfus goes at some point too.

Damian DamjanovskiI don't th do you think Dreyfus will go before the election?

Peter LewisHe's a good soldier, maybe not. Basing he needs a by election, right?

Damian DamjanovskiYeah. But I think there's g people on our side who don't really care about that and are just tired and just want to get out and want to get back to making money, paying the mortgage, and not not be that's it, not be on the sinking ship. So we're we're at an

Peter LewisDrinking beer on a Friday afternoon, talking trash rather than having to do real work. Yeah. I I I feel them.

Damian Damjanovskihour and ten minutes, Peter. This has been a really great chat. Keith, I cannot thank you enough for spending over an hour of your Friday afternoon talking with us. I personally have Deeply enjoyed it. I know so many of our listeners will deeply enjoy this deep dive, not just into Victoria, but into the future of the set center right politics in Australia. I hope you feel that you can come back anytime. Either you want to talk about stuff or there's something interesting that we can all talk about together. But I want to thank you deeply for joining us today.

Keith WolahanThank you for inviting me.

Damian Damjanovskianytime, Peter Lewis, we'll be back again next week. Same time, new person, or maybe just us, we'll see. Thanks everyone. If you haven't yet, please like, share, subscribe the podcast. We're available on YouTube, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Prime Podcasts, Deezer, I think at this point. and

Peter LewisWhat's data?

Damian Damjanovskiwe thank you all for your listenership. So we'll see you again next week. Thank you.

Peter LewisAll right.