Episode 18

Hacks are from Mars, Wonks are from Venus. Staffers v Bureaucrats

With Caroline Croser-Barlow & Danielle Elston

7 August 20261 hr 2 min

Show notes

Guests: Danielle Elston & Caroline Croser-Barlow from the Westminster Tradition podcast.

We cover a range of topics, including the Canberra experience, the role of Parliament, the naming of Canberra, whiskey and beer, the Westminster Tradition Podcast, perspectives on staffers and bureaucrats, the role of lobbyists and advocacy, perceptions of the bureaucracy, the impact of COVID on bureaucracy, and understanding public acceptance.

Chapters

  • 00:00 Introduction to What's Your Poison
  • 01:03 The Canberra Experience
  • 02:14 The Role of Parliament in Canberra
  • 03:29 The Naming of Canberra
  • 04:06 Discussion on Whiskey and Beer
  • 04:38 Reflection on Guardian Essential Report
  • 05:01 Introduction of Guests and Their Poison
  • 07:23 Westminster Tradition Podcast and Public Service
  • 09:40 Perspectives on Staffers and Bureaucrats
  • 24:30 The Role of Lobbyists and Advocacy
  • 26:24 Perceptions of the Bureaucracy
  • 29:04 The Impact of COVID on Bureaucracy
  • 33:53 Understanding Public Acceptance
  • 34:22 The Limitations of Bureaucracy
  • 35:19 Government Decision Making During COVID
  • 42:21 Trust in Government and Public Sector
  • 46:35 The Role of Public Servants and Consultants
  • 56:06 Technology and Public Sector Efficiency

You can listen and subscribe to the Westminster Tradition podcast here:

https://thewestminstertradition.buzzsprout.com/

Full transcript

Read itHide it

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.

Peter LewisI didn't get a countdown, but it looks like it's recording. Okay. Welcome to What's Your Poison, the show, where people who disagree on just about everything agree it's best to do so over a drink. My name's Peter Lewis. I'm the principal of the Progressive Strategy Shop Essential. Joining me is my evil twin, General Strategics ⁓ partner, a man who always believes that right is might. Dame Damjanowski, g'day, mate. Happy Friday. How's your week and what's your poison?

Damian DamjanovskiHow are you, Peter? Happy Friday. ⁓ it was a great week, other than having to make a a quick jaunt down to our nation's bush capital, ⁓ Canberra, which I had to do for a couple of days. But thankfully I'm back here in God's country, which is Sydney, or as Paul Keating used to say, if you're not in Sydney, you're just camping out. And am deeply enjoying a Lorraine Tasmanian single malt whiskey this week that I cannot recommend highly enough. Our southern state, though being well overrepresented in the Senate, does do a really good job.

Peter LewisMm lovely.

Damian DamjanovskiOf whiskey.

Peter LewisCanberra is interesting when Parliament's not sitting, it's a different world. It's like tumbleweeds through the realm, isn't it?

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, so ⁓ for for those who listen to the show and don't spend an inordinate amount of time in Canberra like we do, Parliament has what we call sitting weeks, so anywhere between fifteen to twenty weeks of the year. your elected and well paid representatives are ⁓ instructed to go down to Canberra to debate and and watch question time and all the things you see on the television. The rest of the time they're in what's called their electorate offices, which is in whatever electorate they're in. Or if the set they're a senator, they're you know on Sky News or the ABC and hanging out the front of those places. So

Peter LewisPennsylvania, yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiDuring those sitting weeks, Canberra is like a school camp that you wish you didn't have to keep going to. You see the same people, you hang out at the same restaurants, you have the same conversations over and over again, and then everyone disbands to their respective corners of Australia. When camp isn't on, Canberra is just Canberra, which is a you know, essentially a public service town where the major the biggest employer is the public service. That is most of the industry. It's the the purpose that we flooded the estuary there to create Canberra in the first place. That wasn't our first choice. and I guess that brings us into who we might have as some really interesting guests this week, Peter.

Peter LewisYeah, we'll get there in a sec, but I I just I just reflect on that. It's really interesting. Canberra is a city whose design principle is a cul-de-sac as well. So everything goes into a dead end.

Damian DamjanovskiThe so the ⁓ the most interesting thing I found out about Canberra Peter Lewis is after talking with ⁓ one of Australia's most esteemed and hilarious historians, David Hunt, who has written a series of books, ⁓ Gert, True Gert and Gert Nation. If you haven't read them, ⁓ please go out and either listen to the audiobooks or buy the books. Professor Hunt does an incredible job of bringing to life the unbelievable and hilarious history of Australia to life. ⁓ Canberra, which was one of the nominated names for our new capital, ⁓ came from the indigenous term Negambra, which the white colonialists at the time believed meant ⁓ meeting place. ⁓ Which is one interpretation, ⁓ but the more common interpretation amongst the local people was Negambra, which is the origin word, actually means the point between two breasts because of Mount Aisley and Mount Black. So in actual fact Canberra is named Tits, ⁓ which is I thought was a very fascinating term for our nation's capital.

Peter LewisClevitage. Lovely. ⁓ I don't know where to go with that. ⁓ you're meant to ask me my point. I have double loaded, I've got a couple of South Coast ⁓ finest. The my first one is a Jarvis Bay Brewing Comp. I'm doing this because I think we are going to be having a pretty thirsty conversation this week.

Damian DamjanovskiWhat's your poison this week, Mr. Lewis?

danielle elston: Ha ha.

Peter LewisI've been actually the last couple of days working on what is gonna be my tenth anniversary column for Guardian, which I'm publishing next week. Ten years ago we started doing the Guardian Essential Report and I I thought I was going to go back and look at every article I'd done over ten years, but I've just been stuck in twenty sixteen and it was such an interesting year. Malcolm was in charge. Hansen had just returned to Parliament. ⁓ it was just before Trump came in. It's a really interesting moment in time. So I I'm sucking all that up while sucking up a Jarvis Bray bright idea expert. ⁓ And you are right. ⁓ We've got two really interesting guests, and they are the hosts of the Westminster Tradition Podcast. Two self-described recovering public servants, Carolyn Crossabalo and Danielle Elston. Welcome, ladies. And what's your poison? Carolyn first.

CCBLet me just say my eldest and most beloved daughter was born in Canberra, so I won't take any of that ⁓ down talk of Canberra, which is one of my favorite cities. ⁓

danielle elston: Thank God you've only got one daughter 'cause you just named one as your favourite, but

CCBI know, but we all know my son's my favourite. ⁓ no. ⁓ what's my poison? ⁓ so today I am drinking, ⁓ I should be, because I am now in the great state of South Australia. I should be drinking some of our beautiful wine, but I'm actually drinking, like, can you believe this is actually beer? And it comes in a giant bottle and it's called Malt Donkey. And my husband works for this crazy company that's doing like bespoke ales with barley and whatever. So I am drinking that. Although you'll see my glass is half empty because I just

Peter LewisMm-hmm.

CCBthrew half of it across my desk. So I'm having one of those days.

Peter LewisThat's not normally, but that's a great question. Is it half empty or half full just there? ⁓ so like every middle aged man either is a craft brewer or has a podcast. So you've got, you know, all these things going on in your life. ⁓ and Danielle, what's your poison?

CCBWe're covering all the faces.

danielle elston: I'm on a ⁓ Scotch and Diet Coke, ⁓ which is usually how I finish the week. My old man I was gonna say it was his Friday five o'clock drink, but it was more his kind of Friday midday drink. So, you know. and we did lots of work together. ⁓ own y s yes. So a Scotch and a di a Scotch and Diet Coke was this was the starting drink. The starting drink. ⁓ and he's been dead for seven years, but I am still ⁓ I still find myself on Fridays at five o'clock having a ⁓

Damian DamjanovskiYour old man was a diet coke drinker?

danielle elston: Scotch and Diet Coke with Dad. And you can't use anything else. You can't you you can't you can't have a Pepsi. You can't have Coke. You've like it's gotta be Diet No, it's gotta be Diet Coke. ⁓

Damian Damjanovski⁓ in his honor slunge.

Peter LewisHis his his to dad. What was his name?

CCBQuick zero.

Peter LewisSo was your dad a I I ⁓ y did you take on the family business? Was he a public servant as well, your dad? Or what was his

Damian Damjanovski⁓ I'm all about Coke Red.

danielle elston: No, he did economic development in for ⁓ in native title. ⁓ so on the Cape in Cape York.

Peter LewisIt's to him. ⁓ so give us the origin story of Westminster Tricia. Maybe if each of you could just give me a summary of your LinkedIn profile and your hero public sector moment, and then we'll get into what you guys are trying to achieve with Westminster Tradition.

CCBI'll go first, D. ⁓ so I am, as you say, a recovering public servant. Started life in Canberra, working in defense. spent a bit of time in the Middle East as a civilian ⁓ policy advisor over there. And then ⁓ typical Canberra story, had our baby realize that like there was no family help ⁓ so far away. And so we moved back to Adelaide, ⁓ where I've been working in the South Australian government ⁓ for a long time until recently I got out. I don't know what my stellar moment is. I I did. I did get to work for Julia Gillard on the SA Royal Commission into Early Childhood Education and Care. And then ⁓ that made it really hard to go back to working for all the boys. So I left and I came ⁓ to be what I am now, which is I head up a think tank.

Peter Lewisthe front project, which is ⁓ still pushing on the early learning. Fantastic. What about you, Danielle?

CCBThat's right. We sound like we smuggle drugs, but actually we look about early learning, the front project.

Peter LewisYou certainly do. You d you sound anything except early learning to be fair, but yeah. Danielle?

danielle elston: I started out as a Commonwealth public servant in like the early years of the Howard government, which is a bit terrifying, and lasted about a year, maybe two, because I was very frustrated at how slow it was and probably really precocious and annoying to everybody else. And then I went and did a few years in NGOs in health lobbies and then ran my own business working with NGOs in health and disability on strategy and comms and policy and advocacy. ⁓ a bit like Caroline, I then discovered that. it was fine to bounce around to three states in a day when you didn't have a like two year old, but it becomes a little bit the national work is really hard when you have tiny, tiny kids. So I went into the South Australian government and did fifteen years of ⁓ all sorts of all sorts of different things for them. And these days I run good government advisory where we work with governments and public sector kind of organisations, help them do shit well and better and faster.

Peter LewisAnd off the side of your desk you've started this podcast. So what's the shtick? I've listened to a few episodes. It's terrific, but it's public servants talking, public servants, yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiGreat podcast.

danielle elston: I've got a few ministers. Thanks very much. It's a it's a it's a text chain that the other members of the text chain basically halfway through the RoboDebt Royal Commission hearing said, either you write a PhD or you start a podcast, but we're kind of bored and want to get out of your like group text now, you two. and it was going to just be there was no plan, there was no grand vision. It was going to be about we w we watched the Robo debt royal commission each day and you could be like, I've been in a meeting like that, I've experienced that. No, it didn't lead to catastrophic outcomes but

Peter LewisYeah.

danielle elston: it was eerily familiar, like leaving meetings and thinking the other agency was gonna pay for it and all of these things. So we did six episodes, three and a half, three, I don't know, years ago, quite a while ago. and it just kind of took off and I reckon it took off because it's very hard for public servants to talk about what it is that we do. There are millions of us. ⁓ most of it like the when

CCBAbout three and a half years ago. Yeah. Mm-hmm.

danielle elston: Bless our institutions and I work with lots of them, but when we do public things like the Iran Sogs and Euripas, it's very hard for current public servants to say this is how we do the work, this is all the things that happen. ⁓ for good reason. And so I think I think it took off because everyone can find themselves. I hear their they're here, their own job in it. And and they there's nowhere else, I suppose, like that to have those conversations. What do you what what on earth do you think people why do people listen to this, Caroline?

CCBYeah, 'cause like they don't all have the text chain. Isn't that the answer? Like they all want to talk about their work, but it's like deeply awkward and weird and hard to find a place where people are talking about public service work and so they come to the pod.

danielle elston: Yeah.

Peter LewisYeah. You've listened to a few episodes, Darmo. What what do you reckon ⁓ about that?

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, I look I I I found it very interesting because obviously and and and I know we'll get into this. So I I'd love to talk about perspectives from a staffing perspective versus a public servants perspective. Again, for those of our listeners who aren't in this space, there are kind of two broad categories of people. So you've got your elected representatives, that's your MPs, senators, everyone who you actually vote for, and they go in and they've got a limited term. They are able to appoint what we call a staffer. So that is their personal staff. staff. So if they're a backbencher or an opposition or in government, they get allotted a certain amount of staff who are paid, I would say, a reasonable amount of money to basically serve their minister directly or their MP. There's no real qualifications. Like the the yeah. Yeah, for look, for a lot of people it's the most money they will ever earn in their life. And even then it's it's essentially charity work. That aside,

Peter LewisGiven there's no real qualifications, I reckon they've most of them put one lotto, but yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiSo the staffers are there from what we'd call a political sp perspective. They are serving their extension of that elected representative. And then underneath all of that, there's obviously the departments who are designed ⁓ to w

Peter LewisUnder or about

Damian DamjanovskiTheoretically it should be under. So the departments is the what we call bureaucrats, public servants, civil servants, whatever moniker you want to give it. These are the people who sit in agencies and departments that outlive any singular government and are organized in a variety of ways, depending on the government of the day. And their job is essentially to execute the policy and will of the parliament, the government of the day, as well as ensure that the ongoing instrument of government continues to function regardless of politics. So theoretically it's meant to be a political, it is a servant of the public essentially. So it's just important to make that distinction for our listeners who don't necessarily know that distinction.

Peter LewisWell, that at least is the Westminster tradition, kaboom. ⁓ but the elephant in the room, though, I think is that our folks, the ⁓ hacks and staffers, don't care much for you folks, the pen pushing cardigan wearing. And I feel like the

Damian DamjanovskiOr the Washminster one as it would be for us.

Peter LewisI feel like the the ⁓ sentiment might be mutual. So I do feel like this is a good discussion to have. Like, you know, they're different universes with different objectives and different reward systems. So ⁓ ladies, ⁓ what do you think of staffers? What do you think of hacks?

CCBI ⁓ there's something when you were saying before about they're very well paid. Like it's so interesting to me because actually they look to me like they work really, really hard and often they're not as well paid as the public servants that they're working with. But then I'm like, ⁓ but I think of them as children. So like that's the other side. So I think it's like, well, if I was really gonna lean into the stereotype, it's the children. Yeah.

Damian Damjanovski⁓ yeah. Yeah. A and look good.

Peter Lewisentry level jobs, no qualifications. Yeah.

danielle elston: ⁓ entry level and like people refer to them as short pants 'cause you know that that thing of like you where you're allowed to wear long pants and so lots of public servants will be like, ⁓ short pants called me and they're looking for such and such.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah yeah.

Peter LewisHa ha ha.

Damian DamjanovskiThat's an that's an amazing game. ⁓

CCBI wish to say no one has ever said that in my presence, didn't you?

Peter LewisWell, I think Danielle can go wild.

Damian DamjanovskiI ⁓ can I just can I just clarify one point because I I just don't want to be taken out of context. While I think a lot of staffers are I I am. I I look I wear shorts as I need to and when I need to, but I have beautiful calves and legs, so I'm allowed to. ⁓ I do believe that a lot of staffers are overpaid, especially for the qualifications. And and I would add to that that I believe public servants, especially in Australia, are grossly overpaid.

CCBYou're wearing long pants.

Peter LewisYeah.

Damian Damjanovskifor their function. So it's not that staffers are overpaid, are underpaid and and public servants are paid correctly. I think that public servants are grossly overpaid and staffers are mildly overpaid. That's my only framing on that. Sorry. Please continue.

Peter LewisBut government department heads earn significantly more than the PM, don't they?

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, though they'll be earning a million bucks a year. A lot of them w

danielle elston: Yeah. Can also you you are also talking about this tiny coterie of public servants. We have to also remember that we have public sector employees and that the person standing at Centrelink all day or on the phones and they are public servants, like nurses, doctors, teachers, like there's lots of there's lots of public servants in this country. There's a small coterie of them that are directly responsible to working with the minister to design a system that is where we'll put the next school or we'll do the next thing. But the bulk of public servants work with public and deliver a service. There's a small group of them that support that by designing the system that the service lives in and helps make those decisions. But

Peter LewisBut there's also a porous nature as well, isn't it? So there most political officers will have some public servants that are seconded in as experts. And there'll also be any smart staffer is looking for the exit into a a job in the public sector which is significant rungs above their capability, which seems to be a a ⁓ a a skill set that many people I know have.

danielle elston: Yeah. MLOs and DLOs.

Damian DamjanovskiOr into corporate affairs and lobbying, which is even better paid. So

Peter Lewis⁓ yeah. That's the only other one.

danielle elston: Yeah. Yeah. And I think I think staffers I I would have once said that staffers made terrible bureaucrats. I ⁓ eat my words probably in the last ten or fifteen years. I think I think there are it depends on what staffers are attracted to. Like staffers are starters, not finishers as a general rule. So they're they identify the opportunity and see when something becomes urgent and think everything is urgent when most things actually are not urgent. And in fact that is just running a government guy's just calm down for a minute. ⁓ They understand where like the government wants to go, but the public servant has to turn that into something. So they have to turn that grand idea from that person who ran into you at that barbecue at that street corner meeting has to be turned into some kind of appropriation budget legislation, a system, like a thing. And so staffers operate in that big picture and bureaucrats often live in the implementation and the detail of that. And that yet there are some staffers who I think unnaturally. Like they w once they get through that, they're like, I wanna see this through. Like I don't want to just announce it. I want to go and be a bureaucrat where we actually get to like turn it on, find out what works and what doesn't, like to like to actually run it as opposed to just have the idea about it.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah. And I was just gonna say ⁓

Peter LewisRight. Do you go down?

Damian DamjanovskiIt it's fair to say that staffers and bureaucrats have not only different incentives but work on different timescales, right? The old expression is that politics moves fast and government moves slow. The system is intentionally designed like that, right? It's a check and balance. So the the political system is there to keep bureaucrats on their toes and in check, and the bureaucratic system is there to ensure that politics ⁓ and government isn't entirely short term incentivized. So these two things are counterbalances of what is, ⁓ I would argue in Australia that Washminster system. The most sophisticated and so far the best functioning political system we've seen anywhere in the world, right? So ⁓ I I genuinely believe that Australia has the best balance system in the world, with the only exception being that maybe we should move to a mixed member proportional system, but that's a whole nother discussion for a whole nother day. I would love to get back to before we go any further, how you guys view staffers now that I've done that full explanation, other than being the the short pants folk. ⁓

Peter LewisMm-hmm. Short pants.

Damian Damjanovski⁓ what's the view from inside the bureaucratic tent or the inside the bureaucratic palace of staffers? Like you go through a fair few staffers, I'm assuming, through your bureaucratic lifetime. So how how do you guys see them?

CCBYeah. Yeah. It's kind of like you come across a snake in the long grass and you act carefully, right? Like you don't startle them, like it's like you go really still and you don't move too quickly because you might get bitten. But also you have to like kind of have a good strategy around you. So most people approach staffers pretty carefully and then there's like a pretty good taxonomy of ⁓

Damian DamjanovskiRight.

CCBOf good ideas bunnies who you know, like you just kind of want to avoid because they're just gonna set you off on a whole other thing that like their minister actually isn't interested in, their chief of staff doesn't realize they're hassling you about. Like, so there's kind of the good ideas wonks, and you just you want to kind of play a bit of triage on them. Then there's the ones who are like the really scary ones, because actually they're not in any way interested in the public service and they're doing the like political bidding of their masters and they're like

Peter LewisOkay.

CCBthe dark arts ones. They're the ones you never want to get the call from because they're the ones who ask you to do something that you're like, ⁓ God, I don't quite know how to manage this. they're the two. And then there's the really good ones, right? Like the good ones who are like, I am here to deliver a thing and like I love the mission of the thing we're on. Like and I'm how can we get this thing done? And they're in touch with the people And they're much less kind of bureaucratic about like what are the process steps. They're like, surely we can like make a good thing happen.

Peter LewisCan you pick like a lot of staffers end up becoming MPs, become ministers, like on both sides, it's like a part of the apprentice. Can you pick the good ones when at the beginning, or does it take a while, Danielle, to get get a vibe on staffers?

danielle elston: ⁓ no, 'cause they tell you who they are like bureaucrats won't tell you who they are, right? 'Cause we're a little bit blonde mongy and that's part of the job. Whereas a staffer will tell you the first time, like they'll tell you everything. Whether they say so directly or whether it's through how they kind of operate, you will immediately know kind of what their cut of their jib is because they will kind of tell you and and I I I love staffers, but I also think we'll get to a bit later as to whether bureaucrats should be more political. And by that I don't mean capital P political, but around understanding the role of a ⁓ of an office and and and the parliament better. But so I I I I I have always always that's a stretch, but ⁓ I enjoy working with staffers. I think though it's a not regulated system, right? So staffers will speak as though they are speaking for a minister. Frequently later you untangle the fact that they are in fact not speaking to a minister and you've lost whole chunks of your life.

Peter LewisMm.

danielle elston: Because they don't have any way of internally managing an office. ⁓ They will have different motivations. ⁓ Like bureaucrats can think of staffers as impatient and thinking that they staffers often think that once you've announced something it exists and you frequently have to go and say, no, just because you said it exists doesn't mean I've made it exist yet. There's like something has to happen after that. ⁓ and they occasionally, I think, mistake like proximity to power.

Peter LewisYeah.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

danielle elston: for expertise and they're not the same thing. I also think though that like the things staffers often think about bureaucrats, slow, process driven, use too many words, is also true and that it's a real question of everyone needing to adjust their approach to get like get better outcomes happening.

Peter LewisSo before I go to Dame on his perceptions of ⁓ b the bureaucracy, particularly in the context of COVID where you were in with the PMO, which I know was sort of defining moment for the nation. So I I was I was I had a couple of years as a staffer for a a minister in the first term at the car government, the great late Jeff Shaw. ⁓ I was hopeless at it.

Damian DamjanovskiTraumatic. Yeah.

Peter LewisI wrote a piece afterwards that I called The Fear Factory. I just think being a staffer was just ⁓ you you're given this role with power, you are given no tools, it is all like swirling around and you are just panicking every day. And you bluff it, you get a cabinet paper you don't like and you change the the costings and you the numbers don't add up to eight. All that sort of stuff goes on. And I found working with the bureaucracy the most sane part of my existence because they would actually say, no, calm down. This is all we we had law and order, right? And so every other day the Premier was making this big, big claim for a tough new law. And there was this unit inside the New South Wales AGs, which is basically set up just to deal with the Premier's big announcements and wind them back and everything. It was so brilliant. So I I had a really good experience in the New South Wales AGs in late nineties. But that that's the last thing I've had to really do with the public sector, except occasionally not getting contracts from them over the last twenty years.

Damian DamjanovskiDo do you think and this is more for for Danielle ⁓ and Caroline, do you do you think bureaucrats view 'cause as we mentioned earlier, a lot of staffers some staffers leave to then become bureaucrats, some staffers leave to then ⁓ become lobbyists or, you know, basically what we Peter and I do. ⁓ is there a bureaucratic view on lobbyists? I just have to ask before we go

Peter LewisGood. Mm.

Damian Damjanovskiinto the the view of bureaucrats. Is there a view within the bureaucracy of what we call that bigamorphous blob that is lobbying and advocacy and all that?

danielle elston: It's wildly misunderstood by a lot of the bureaucracy, I think. I mean, I did an exercise when I was training in New South Wales a couple of weeks ago where I got them to work up their hypothetical advice and then gave them a fake minister's diary to point out all the other pieces of information and inputs the minister would get while you were drafting that. And when your thing landed in the minister's office, the minister has then met with the lobbyist, but also a researcher and a think tank and a this and a that and someone on a street corner. And public servants do struggle to understand how it is they drafted something up and what all the other bits of information. When it comes to actual lobbyists on a lobbyist register, most public servants would be, Well, don't make eye contact, don't answer the phone, don't have anything to do and pray God, I hope they don't call my minister. Caroline, is that far off?

CCBA hundred percent. Like most most public servants would hope they don't ever have to meet with a lobbyist, right? Like actually you tend ⁓ yeah, yeah. A hundred percent right. Like that's what the big guys have paid the big bucks for is they're the ones who have to sit in the room with the lobbyists and kind of manage the kind of challenge of how one one kind of navigates that question. It's a really ⁓ it's confronting for public servants.

Damian Damjanovski⁓ wow.

danielle elston: Got it.

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Peter LewisBut but is it like, you know, I I'm a big believer in countervailing power, that sense that you get the best decisions when there's friction in the system. And, you know, in a way, what you know, a lobbyist or an advocate does is sort of harness some counterpoints. And if you get the balance right, and it feels to me that often the ⁓ the the the public service wants to drive the process rather than allow it to be driven, like I don't know, to The difference between driving a process and sort of being a stabilizing force, I guess. Anyway, ⁓ Dame, what's your perception of the bureaucracy having lived through some crazy madcap years with the Prime Minister of Australia?

Damian DamjanovskiMm. Yes. Having lived through some tumultuous times. All right, strap in guys. Like we we're gonna be here. ⁓ so I'll give you my honest opinion. I'll give the preamble that I probably ⁓ as we've discussed before, I didn't follow the path of what one might call a typical staffer. So I was plucked from the outside world to be a staffer for the first time in my career in something called the PMO. Which was a a deep honor to get to serve in a Prime Ministerial office, regardless of who the Prime Minister of the day is. When you get that call and someone says, Hey, would you like to serve the Prime Minister? You say yes. You don't you don't ask questions, you say yes, absolutely. I've never been a member of a political party, but my personal views, as everyone who listens to our show knows, ⁓ on the center right on some issues, to the libertarian on other issues, to the center, to the center left on some issues. So I'm a mixed bag. Understanding the relationship between staffing and bureaucrats as what I would call an outsider going into the system was the most bizarre cluster F I had ever experienced in my life. About how these two forces seemed to constantly buttheads. And before COVID hit, obviously we were dealing with bushfires, we were trying to get all kinds of, you know, environmental efforts off the ground, economic efforts, this, that, and the other, all the all the different policy ideas that had happened previous to Morrison during the Turnbull era. ⁓ during the Morrison era, one of my proudest achievements before COVID hit was the fact that I managed to help the bureaucracy get the Australasian recycling labeling scheme off the ground, which I know it seems like nothing, but to me it had been st it had been stuck in this bureaucratic. No, no, but but it it had been st and again, I'd I'd come out of a combination of I'd done big corporates, I'd done small like consultancies, I'd done advertising land, I'd done finance. So I had a zigzag career and trying to understand why.

CCBNo, that's a big deal.

danielle elston: ⁓ that's big.

Peter LewisLook at these two. They're going, Wow, you did that?

CCBWe're like we see that. We see you.

Damian Damjanovskipolitics thought everything was so urgent and why bureaucrats thought everything was so slow was so bizarre to me because I was like, guys, there's a there's literally a middle ground here, which is like we can get stuff done at pace without rushing it. Like like how literally the rest of the world works. Like just let's find that middle ground. ⁓ and then COVID hit and I'll say this and I I hope we can unpack it together, which is I love the bureaucracy and I loathe the bureaucracy simultaneously because some of the smartest and most interesting and most dedicated people I've met have been bureaucrats. And at the same time some of the laziest, most wasteful and just absolute barnacles of society I've met have been bureaucrats. And what happened during COVID when the shit hit the fan and we all needed to swim in the same direction is that distinction became so blindingly clear. And we had to go through this completely the word we don't use anymore, unprecedented times. ⁓ where we all collectively, liberal, labor, crossbenches, bureaucrats, staffers, everyone had to get together to go, we have a big problem. We all know who the enemy is. We all know what we need to do. Let's all get on with it. ⁓ and it was really clear and apparent who was a drag and who helped the boat go faster to get to where we wanted to go. And my biggest sorry, go on.

Peter LewisSo I unpack that though. What w tell me how it felt when it was working as opposed to when it wasn't working. Like what was

Damian DamjanovskiWhen it was working, it was a combination of ⁓ the staffing side of stuff, which is people whose view of the universe is yes, this is a good idea, but The good idea has to be sold to the Australian people, which which bureaucrats, it feels like they don't have that lens on constantly, right? Bureaucrats go, well, whatever we say, that's what's gonna happen. Because, you know, what? We're the tax office. So what are you gonna do? ⁓ or we're the health office, so they're gonna listen to us because we're the Department of Health. Meanwhile, the pu the political lens goes, No, no, no. Our jobs expire every three years unless it's renewed.

CCBTotally.

Damian DamjanovskiWe don't have guaranteed tenure. So we have to make sure that fifty percent plus one of the people go, Yeah, that's a good idea. And guess what? The majority of the time people don't floss their fucking teeth. People don't avoid sugary foods. People do smoke darries and drink alcohol and do things that are bad for ⁓ because humans are irrational actors. And bureaucrats often act like, especially poor g bureaucrats, like the system is rational actors who are all walking around together in harmony going, If we all do the rational thing, everything will be great. The reality is so much messier. And the role of the political staffer is to Sorry.

Peter LewisSo just time out on this, do you guys agree with where Dame is going at the moment?

danielle elston: bits of it. I think that I think in an effort to I think in an effort to be apolitical, we've really like I completely agree with you, so that connection to the public. So you're talking about selling it to the public and and that and I don't think that's necessarily the sales piece of it. But I do think No. Yeah. I do think that ⁓ what will the public think is not is not factored into your top ten thinking. And there's I think it's just about

Peter LewisSorry, mate. I'm just we'll come back. Well, during COVID it's not a sales piece for a vote, it's a sales piece for compliance, right? It's just

danielle elston: I think part of it is bureau the bureaucracy has to get so much better at capital KP politics versus kind of living in the world. Like the public is we we serve the public. The public vote. They are not scary. The fact they vote isn't scary. ⁓ who they vote for is also not scary. But we have to be much more across what is what what their view is. ⁓ and I don't mean getting you, Peter, to tell us the numbers in a kind of I don't want I do not want agencies running around f focused group testing. what people think of bureaucracy. ⁓ I just I just I think there's a and I want to get to Caroline, but I think there's also a difference between the Australian government and the state government. State governments are much closer to the action. ⁓ like you as a bureaucrat, you have to speak to the parent of the kid in the school. Like there's no like yes, there's someone going off and doing Australian government, whatever we call it in our national cabinet meetings and they write papers. But if you are in an education department, if you're in an environment department, you have to actually talk to the guy who tripped over and broke his leg in the national park.

Damian DamjanovskiAgree, agree.

danielle elston: Like, cause we didn't maintain the path properly. So you're a lot you are like there is a there is a difference between the type of people attracted to that type of work. ⁓ and I do think it is challenging if you operate in a very my whole job is to produce pieces of paper and you don't can't see the through line to a service to the public. It is it is hard to maintain an understanding of I don't say public trends, because that makes again it sound like I want a focus group, but just understanding what the fuck's going on out there, right? Like not everyone has a car.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

danielle elston: Not everyone has this. ⁓ there's a whole series of things that when we design things are often not in mind. And I bang on a lot about that, don't I, Carol?

CCBPerfectly so.

danielle elston: What do you think though, Caroline?

CCBLike I completely agree that the best that things work best when ⁓ political staffers are making sure that bureaucrats are thinking about those questions of public public acceptance and public acceptability. I think the idea that only bureaucrats walk around with a strange sense of who people are in the world and that political staffers don't sometimes bring into the world a naive sense of human agencies like

Damian Damjanovski⁓ the no no the political staffers are just as guilty of this. Yeah.

CCBPossibly having watched Benedict Cummings in the you know, in in ⁓ number ten. I kind of think there's a it goes both ways. But like I agree, it's a really useful thing to bring. Yeah, bring it.

Damian DamjanovskiNo, of course. Yeah. ⁓

Peter LewisBack to your therapy session on the covet though, Damien. I I feel like I I c I cut you off for a f a quick bit of feedback from the audience.

Damian DamjanovskiNo, no, I I was just gonna say that obviously during Covid we we experienced ⁓ I I would argue we saw the best of the bureaucracy and the worst of the bureaucracy simultaneously and at a and at speed.

Peter LewisSo what was the bad bit? Like tell me the bad bits.

Damian Damjanovski⁓ the the the the bad bit of bureaucracy is ultimately the inability to make a decision, right? So i and and this is the I think the the original sin of all bureaucrats is the inability to make a decision without either consensus or some form of third party validation of that decision, whether that's research or an external consultant or a minister or someone above them saying yes, this is a good decision. Bureaucrats are ultimately people who, in in my view, ⁓ need Steering committees in order to make a decision, and that is the process that slows it down. And it makes this assumption that a consensus decision is somehow better than a singular decision. And politics is guilty of the opposite, which is what we now call the captain's pick, where individuals make decisions and go, well, this is my decision, and we're just going for it, which can be just as wrong. And like I mentioned earlier, I think usually the truth lies between the two. But specifically during COVID, a lot of what people now ascribe to are well, we were really slow at doing X, Y, and Z because of the fact that, you know, politicians couldn't make decisions about what vaccine or what we should do. It's like, no, no. Like of course politicians didn't because they didn't want to wear it. But what happened was a whole bunch of doctors got together into a committee that we called a target, if anybody remembered that, and went, All right. What do we think the best way to attack COVID is? And what happens is if you put ten doctors and doctor bureaucrats in a room together, is none of them can agree on anything. So they just go to the lowest common denominator decision.

CCBHave you read the ⁓ so Stephen Hamilton and Richard Holden wrote that great book, Australia's Pandemic Exceptionalism? And like, so and it's it is a book about kind of how did we do so well in the crisis response? Like, how did your government do so well in the crisis response of kind of crushing the curve? And then do so bloody terribly and losing the race of the vaccine. And their argument about it is not that it was a bunch of doctors in a room. They're like fundamentally the health department was operating on the wrong heuristic, right? Like the heuristic should have been what is the big cost we're trying to avoid. The big cost we're trying to avoid is ongoing prolact ⁓ prolonged lockdowns. And so to avoid that, we should spend heaps of money buying lots of different kinds of vaccines, even though it might be a bit wasteful, right? And instead they were operating according to their like business as usual heuristic, which is, I should not spend a single penny more than I can possibly do. So I'm gonna scrimp and save and go and do. But can I just say to you, Dubate, the reason why they have that heuristic is because

Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Exactly right. ⁓

CCBYears and years of governments telling bureaucrats that the only thing they should do is be really, really efficient with dollars and any wastage is bad. So like I think there's a cycle there.

Damian DamjanovskiTotally. And and

danielle elston: And so so a lot of the things you're describing at are signals that are sent down from ministers. Like firstly, Atagi existed before COVID and existed after COVID. So it it exists forever. But like ministers do not like bureaucrats bringing them the answer and the solution and saying we've decided to do X if everybody doesn't like it. They are quite people pleasy, right? They are not very good at you saying the best decision, the most effective, the most of this is this one.

Damian DamjanovskiAbsolutely. pushback.

danielle elston: And that's what we're gonna do. And then they say, hang on a second, aren't seven people gonna be really angry about that? And you say, Yes, but here is your argument as to why it's the best thing. And they send you back to the table. They're nah nah nah nah nah. I can't front those seven people and the fact they don't like this decision. Give me a decision that no one hates. And you go, mate, that's not that's not very viable.

Peter LewisThat's vanilla. Everything becomes vanilla. Like if everything

danielle elston: And then everything becomes vanilla. But that's from ministers. Yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiAnd that's it. E i everything much like in Australia in general, we ⁓ we all end up erring towards the median or the average because that that's what the system is designed to do, right? And and I'm not ⁓ I'm not rallying against that necessarily.

CCBWhat's like

Damian DamjanovskiBut I think the COVID experience was one where it became really clear what the limitations of that are. ⁓ and and Caroline, I totally agree with you that th like in a nutshell, yes, that's that's exactly what what did happen. Did Australia have an exceptional COVID response? That's a that's a whole other that's a whole other podcast episode and a whole other thing. I I'd argue that in some regards we absolutely did. And and I, you know, ⁓ I still hold myself to the fact that I got to be part of that. But

CCBYeah.

Damian DamjanovskiThere were a whole other way, ⁓ a whole bunch of other ways around the world that people ⁓ responded to COVID that had similar ⁓ effects and and similar results as we did without necessarily the economic or potentially the social outcomes that we did, because they had better decision making happening up front.

Peter LewisSo

CCB⁓ do you think better decision making? Sorry, Peter, but like I think this is really interesting, right? Because I think one of the big mistakes people make in public policy, both from staffers and from bureaucrats, is the idea that there was a right and knowable answer in advance. Like if we just had better decision making, that's what I reckon, right? And it turned out that the thing the Swedes did was kind of or whichever country you're thinking about. Like it turns out that worked out okay, but like

Peter LewisYeah.

Damian DamjanovskiThere isn't. There isn't. Yeah. Yeah. Sweden, yeah yeah.

CCBNo one knew in advance whether that would work out okay and we could see other things happening. So it's like to me the test is not post facto, could we have chosen differently? But looking forward, did we have the right information? Were we trying to make it on the right set of values? Did we bring people in in the right way? And and I think like Australia did an extraordinary job of that. Yeah, exactly.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah. And and what's our risk tolerance? Yeah, we did we we did all right, right? And and the the only thing I I I'd I'd pick apart on what you said that that is a I don't want to say a pet peeve of mine, but is an area that I I discuss ad nauseum with people who are you know, people who have I've captured in a conversation usually is ⁓ for our poor listeners right now, is

CCBYeah.

Damian DamjanovskiYou you you both mentioned the idea of this is a trained behaviour of bureaucrats where over years and years they're taught that they need to save their pennies. I agree, but I also think that's why personally I believe that you should have a lifetime limit of how many years you are allowed to serve in the public service in a bureaucratic role. And if you reach that limit, well done. You've you've you've done your service to Australia, off you go to the private sector to do a real job. Yeah. Off you go, you can do something else, but

Peter LewisGo up to the corporate sector and sell your wares. ⁓ we're gonna talk about consultants in a sec, but can I just I might just change it up a bit 'cause we could spend the rest of the show talking. It's fascinating. ⁓ so my heroic my heroic

CCBYeah.

Damian DamjanovskiBy the way, I I apply the same rule to staffers. I I actually think staffers should only be allowed to serve a certain amount of years in staffing. I think entrenchment and tenure are two of the worst things you can possibly have in any job occupation. But sorry, Peter. Didn't mean to cut you off.

Peter LewisYeah yeah yeah.

CCBYeah, but they only ever do.

danielle elston: I'm not entirely sure that once you develop a lifetime of skill of delivering public value it translates easily into profit, but

Peter LewisSo I hope not. ⁓ my my heroic contribu my heroic contribution to the pandemic was to run the Guardian Essential report from my attic while you guys are running the country.

Damian DamjanovskiSure it does. There's gotta be a way.

Peter LewisAnd what was really interesting was trusting government surged, like across both federal and state. And regardless of what was going on under the surface, Darmate, like, you know, people wished the government well. My side of politics wished it well. Albo stayed out of playing silly buggers on the politics, which was, I think, the secret to his later success. And trust in government surged up into the 70s and 80s. But we're at a moment now where it's lower than when it started off. ⁓ and I'm interested in your guys.

CCBAgreed.

Peter LewisReflections on the extent to which often this is seen as a rejection of politics, but I feel it's also a rejection of government and the way government operates. So that to me, ⁓ the the rise of populism in the states and then the rise of one nation is like a pox on both our houses in a way. so I'm interested in ⁓ where you guys, Carolyn and Danielle, see the public sector at the moment. We've come out the other end, there's always this push. for efficiency. There has been, as you as you started your podcast, the Robo Debt Royal Commission, which really undermined faith in the government ⁓ using new technologies. So where like what's the state of the sector, like the public sector at the moment, and ⁓ what needs to happen to rebuild those sort of levels of trust subject to another lab leak or a wet market or whatever it was. Thank you, Anthony Fauci.

danielle elston: C C B or No? ⁓ I think there's there's a there's about five things in there. The trusting government piece, I have been banging on about a lot in the last six months because I don't think public servants think it's about them. I think they see minister in a sex scandal or bang frog march to ICAC, and then they see trusting government figures and they're like, ⁓ they hate politicians. So do we. Like, that works out fine. ⁓

CCBNo.

Peter LewisGone. Yeah. Those guys. Yeah.

danielle elston: All the evidence we have, and McKinnon has a excellent piece out that I'll send through if you guys have some show notes, ⁓ that just gives me like data to prove that I was right to start off with, which is always really satisfying, which is people's trust in government is about how they experience government. It is literally I don't trust government anymore because I tried to get it in my age care package and by the time I got it my parents were dead. ⁓ there the reason their trust in government drops is literally a transactional mm like relationship with service and it's not exclusive to that, but I think there is something. So I think so my second part of when you said one of the things they have to change is that we do need to connect the public service back closer to like the way to get into the public service is to get a degree. so we're immediately cutting out whole sections of people who should be in the public service. It used to be

Peter LewisMm. That's nice to you, man.

danielle elston: There are excellent secretaries who left year 10, went into traineeships in the public service and were bloody excellent public servants. There are no roads like that in anymore. And so the voices, and I don't mean how many women in leadership and how many people of this background. It's just a straight up like if you already have to have had your first or second degree to well, then we've already cut a whole huge chunk of people who should be in the public service out of it again. There's a lot of things I think that need to change in the

Peter LewisEven

CCBClass.

Peter LewisD A I

danielle elston: public service part of it is being able to talk about it. ⁓ we send people in, it's a very like that the closed part of it doesn't help you grow just your skills and your capability. And that politics isn't like a contaminant. It's it is the soup we sweep. Like it is it's what what we're in and you do need to like it's it is something you need to understand. And I don't mean be a part of because there's a difference between understanding it and participating in it. But understanding like this idea I run it, I do

Peter LewisMm. Yeah.

danielle elston: When I do managers training and the whole room says, ⁓ well, we don't watch any media. I just, you know, I get my stuff what as though that's a choice not to know how the things you are deciding are playing out is for me just like big changes that need to happen. ⁓ that that this neutrality doesn't mean naivety. Like that's not the same thing. Being neutral is essential. Being naive to trust in government, even just like people who like

Peter LewisYeah. Mm.

danielle elston: haven't Googled their own minister, don't know that they were previously in the private sector or worked for a union or that level of naivety is not neutrality. It's it's just not understanding both the public and the operating environment and the authorising environment.

CCBHm.

Peter LewisMm. Yours, yeah. Carolyn, I think we we talk a lot about democracy and I think there's a tension between the practice of democracy, which is that collaboration between elected reps and the public sector, and the contest of democracy, which is, you know, the cage fight. And I I I'm interested in your thoughts on how those two things interact as well.

Damian DamjanovskiDon't you th

CCBLike I kind of am really taken by that idea that we are no longer caught in a trap between the left and right. We're caught in a trap between the top and bottom. And like the public service is viewed as elite in the way that Danielle was just talking about and out of touch with what's happening on the ground. And like so it's actually it's about elite consensus against kind of lived experience of ordinary people who are very angry at their public ⁓ their political parties and their public services.

Peter LewisMm

CCBSo that's kind of my first reflection. I think Dame was about to jump in, ⁓ 'cause I have something else to riff on, but I reckon go that way first.

Damian DamjanovskiNo, no, you're you're you're saying exactly like exactly what I was going to touch on as well, which is I I I do think that people like the majority of people from all the polling I've seen is that e all the polling I've seen is that people do view the bureaucracy as being ⁓ essentially the political part of the political elite these days. And I would agree with most people that I think most bureaucrats are disconnected from the plight of the average Australian.

Peter Lewis⁓ we want to get it You guys have done podcasts before you can take it anyway. Before I go to Carolyn, can I just say one more thing, which jumping off Danielle and then I'll give you the floor. So for years and years we did ⁓ focus group research for the Public Service Association in New South Wales. And every year it would come back and they go, Nah, they still think you're cardigan-wearing beige people. And then Victor Dominello from the Coalition Side of Politics created Service New South Wales and change and changed the whole model of service delivery using

CCBAnd so what ⁓ Mm, very sexy.

danielle elston: ⁓

Peter Lewistechnology but not replacing people but just triaging and then a really good customer experience. And all of a sudden no one thought public servants were wearing cardings anymore. It's like they're they're a service organization. They do really good stuff. It was so interesting. So back to you Carolyn.

CCBYeah, and I think Danielle's point that like government trust in government will grow when experiences with government are better. But I think the kind of thing I want to just add to that is, and this is where Danielle and I always disagree, like, I think one of the challenges is we've kind of got into a candy vending machine version of government where people think government can give you everything. And like one of the challenges that we're gonna have to say is actually like. One of the reasons why people aren't getting aged care packages is because we can't afford to give as many. And so we implicitly ration through long cues, right? Like so I just think there's something for me about we need to get better at our transactions and we also need to be more honest about the limits of what government will be able to give you and then be more humble about kind of how government creates partnerships. But really what I wanted to say was about RoboDep, because the thing about Robodep, right, is it's

Peter LewisMm.

CCBThe reason why it pisses people off is like A, obviously terrible things to to really vulnerable people, but B, no one got punished for it. And that's the part, right? It's like that the the system the system of kind of the legal system, which operated perfectly appropriately. And like we had our we had the ICAC commissioner onto our podcast to talk about it and like.

Peter LewisMm.

CCBThere is nothing wrong, like the process that was taken to look at the people who thought up and designed and implemented ⁓ Robodet, and they all got all their procedural fairness, like that's all entirely appropriate. And we had an administrative system that shook people down with speculative invoicing, and it was like 400,000 people didn't get that. And I think that to me captures this question of the top and the bottom, right? Like that there's a rule.

Peter LewisWho should have gone down for that though? Who who would you have? Not Dame's boss.

CCB⁓ the public servants, a hundred percent the public servants. Catherine Campbell, like she can sue me for this. ⁓

Damian DamjanovskiNo, he wasn't the one who

CCBNo, I don't think I don't I genuinely don't think Yep.

danielle elston: No, I mean there's a whole piece there around over-responsiveness. There's a whole piece there that leads to this back to the original part of this conversation, which is when you listen to that evidence, they heard their minister on radio. He said he wanted to be a tough cop on the welfare beat. The government had sent another silly signal, which was you can't have anything new unless you can save the money, which is something stupid that governments say to public servants when you're like, Well, we've actually got to wait that it can be cost neutral, but not in this silly framework you've done. So they're like, two things. Well, he said on radio to a particular demographic he wanted to be a tough cup tough cop on the welfare bait. That is not an instruction to the public service. That is talk back radio. Bureaucrats can be over-responsive to signals that are not for them. That was a signal for someone listening to the radio in Sydney. It was not a signal for the public servants and and there can be an over-responsiveness. And part of that, Peter, is because you like, ⁓ it was a total world of panic all the time. Yes. Imagine being a like career public servant and like you finish and someone else comes like, ⁓ God, this one's gonna start panicking too, like the arm flapping and the everything's an emergency. Is that in order to calm down the political office, public servants are like, All right, I'm gonna read the signals and try and get them something quickly and early to to basically like lower the what's happening, what's happening. And it creates perverse it c pr creates really perverse outcomes.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter LewisBecause also I like politics would not have a monopoly on venal, ambitious people either. Like some of them would be in the public sector as well.

Damian DamjanovskiNo. And you know what, Scott Scott showed up to the to and answered the questions, right? A lot like he he wasn't he didn't shy away from actually turning up to those Royal Commissions and answering the questions like

CCBI mean, I wouldn't say answered the questions. He gave a lot of words in response to the questions, but but I agree. Like, I don't think. Yep. And it was a royal commission. But I think like one of the things that Danielle was kind of hinting at there is there's like, what did the public servants do? I genuinely think the public servants are the people who were in the wrong. And I think the political class was unaware or

Damian DamjanovskiJust reminder Caroline, Scott is a politician. From the remote.

CCB⁓ what's the phrase? Like negligent who didn't give a shit that the culture of fear that they created made it almost impossible at any point, once it was clear that something illegal was happening, ⁓ to say, ⁓ excuse me, Minister Tudge, we know this was done four ministers ago, but actually we think maybe you've all been lying to the people for the last six years that is also a function of the political class. So I don't think it's a corruption issue, but I do think it's like an accountability issue.

Peter LewisYeah.

Damian DamjanovskiIt's a i an accountability issue is a really good way to frame it, Caroline. I completely agree. And and ⁓ I we don't have enough ti Yeah. Yeah, and I don't I don't wanna I don't wanna get started at the

CCBAnd you lost an election, so accountability, right? Like that to me.

Peter LewisI want to ask you guys one more question. Yeah, because I I want one more question before we go to Kiss of Death, which I don't think we've even warned you guys about, but that's our prediction for the week ahead. So there's your warning. so RoboDead happened. Now we've got a couple of things that are moving in in government. One is The take up of AI, whatever that is, however that's going to be taken up. And the other is the the deliberate ⁓ decision to wind back drastically the NDIS. So if you are a public servant in the intersection of those two pieces, what have you learned from Robodet and how are you doing it differently this time?

CCBSo I

Peter LewisDanielle. Or Caroline. Whoever wants it.

danielle elston: ⁓ I think Caroline probably needs to go first. No, I d I d I d I disagree with the characterisation.

CCBThink it's a fair, like, so I don't think it's a fair question. Yeah. Yeah. I think there are two things going on. There's like there's a very clear decision by the government to reduce expenditure on the NDIS and a range of kind of negotiations with states and territories around how one might do that through particular rule changes and whatever. And then there's kind of process changes that follow from that. That is a very challenging piece of public policy. And they're navigating that over there. There is also absolutely a question around how technology might be used as part of the functional assessment and and process that's happening there. I think like

Peter LewisBut how do you stop it becoming Robodet with those two things going on?

CCBWell, I mean, so we have a friend who always says like she was never interested in the legality of robo debt. She was interested in the immorality of robo debt. It's actually quite easy to stop it being robo debt. Like you make it legal, right? You actually read your act and you think about what the review rights are and you do that. That is what the public servants, I presume, are doing. Like they are actually considering whether or not, you know, in RoboDebt the illegality was averaging, right? So they will be doing the thinking about how do we make sure that the legislation lines up. And empowers the actions of the public servants. That's fundamentally an ethical question for the Parliament of Australia and not a question for the public servants. Like the Parliament of Australia is going to have to make choices about what legislation it passes and enables to happen. And it feels unfair to kind of pin that on the public servants, who are the ones who will then, I assume, do their very level best to make sure that what they are implementing is consistent with the legislation and You know, like that is a challenge. I'm not saying it's not, but it just feels I don't know. There's something icky about that question for me, Peter. Like if you don't like the policy, vote for a different government, right? Like that is that's a thing.

Peter LewisMm. I'm sorry. Hmm. Danielle, one last question for you on technological change. Is there is there in in the do you see in the future a public sector with fewer full-time staff, more people like you that are giving advice and helping them find their way through? Or like what's the right balance between people working in government and on government?

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

danielle elston: I'm anti consultants, which is a like pretty hilarious thing. Yeah, as a consultant. ⁓ as a busy mother. As a consultant, I ⁓ don't like consultants. ⁓ we we have to stop

Peter LewisAs a consultant. That's what some people call self loathing, Danielle.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

danielle elston: we have to stop being obsessed with the number of public servants. We create all these perverse incentives that like so that where we have a hiring freeze and then we want to lower consultants at the same time, we want to roll out seven things and no one's ever talking about what were what's the work and what's the resourcing. If you're in the private sector, it's what's

CCBYes. Yeah.

Peter LewisThe efficiency dividend is such a blunt instrument, right?

danielle elston: Well, it's just stupid. ⁓ like in the private sector it'll be what's the work that needs to happen, how much technology can I use and what resources do I need and then what's the profit margin? Whereas we go five percent off your off your FTE with no no f pre work to figure out and no frontline service cuts. ⁓ and and so the technology stuff, ⁓ they will be very anxious about

Damian DamjanovskiHm. Agree.

CCBYeah. Yeah. No frontline service cuts. Yep.

Peter LewisAnd bringing in an NDIS.

danielle elston: But ⁓ AI AI has an opportunity to do different things than I feel like government is looking at. Like there are huge parts of government that rewrites the same thing over and over again to meet the whims of some senior person who doesn't like the word stakeholder but prefers their commas to be not Oxford or whatever. We can set all of that up now so that all of that toing and froing is just dealt with by like automation. The challenge we have, and if you look at the post office in the UK, not just Robodare.

Damian DamjanovskiInsane.

danielle elston: is if you don't have a human stop button built into your automation, that is hugely risky for your service delivery. And that is where you get your big not just scandals, where you hurt where you harm people, where you harm your own citizens. And so the rise in the automation will still need to be balanced with like how can w how can things have a s like a human review component. So I think there's a lot of opportunity, but a opportunity for increased

Damian DamjanovskiYes.

Peter LewisMm.

danielle elston: technology, but we also don't have less public servants since we stopped having to have physical licenses and we moved from physical forms to digital ones. So I don't think like rolling out this stuff and maintaining it costs more than they ever budget for. ⁓ and the absence of wanting to pay whatever it costs, whatever those private sector companies that charge a fortune to give you the technology in the first place are charging. ⁓ so It is not a matter of roll out some more and have less public servants, AI can take over. I'd like to see AI ⁓ appear before estimates and determine exactly how it made the decisions to allocate its money.

Peter LewisI think it already is. ⁓ look, we could go all Joe Rogan on this and go for three and a half hours. ⁓ but I feel like we should s s try to land it. So our last segment of our show is Kiss of Death, which is the predictions of the week, which we rarely get right. Dame, have you got one? And then I'll go to ⁓ our Westminster traditionalists.

Damian DamjanovskiYep. Let's do it. I think my kiss of death for the week is actually ⁓ related to Tony Burke who pulled out of his National Press Club speech this week because he's got apparently some maybe or maybe not new immigration cuts to talk about. I think ⁓ the shit's gonna hit the fan on this one this week. I'm not sure how, but I have a feeling that this week ⁓ we're gonna discover a lot more about what those cuts actually are. What about you, Peter?

Peter LewisMm. I'll go to Carolyn and Danielle first and then close it out. So Danielle?

danielle elston: Mine's probably not this week, but the current hiring freezers of public servants around the country will lead to ⁓ additional contractors, consultants and labour hire and the total number of people who are working on things will actually not change.

Peter LewisBut their hourly rate will go up. ⁓ Carolyn?

CCBExactly right. I think we will keep worrying about what COVID means to the Victorian people for a while yet. Like I think there's like I read that Com Samaris piece about kind of this is part of what's happening in Labour in Victoria and just thinking about our conversation earlier, there's just something under the hood there that I'm still interested in and with the Operation Richmond stuff coming out about the firefighters union and Dan Andrews being back in the ⁓ in the news, I just think there's like more soul searching to do.

Peter LewisYeah. Yeah, we managed to get through a whole show without talking about ICAC, which was good. So my case of death is that there will be a bit of legislation that gets through Parliament next week on gambling. It's been totemic. ⁓ there is push and pull at the moment. Both the Libs and the Greens are saying it won't land. But I think Albo, if nothing else, is someone that lands the deal and I think that some I don't think they'll pull it. I think they need to land it and they will convince themselves that they've moved things forward, even though not as far as the great late ⁓ Peter Murphy would have wished. So You're back, Darmay. ⁓ on that note, ⁓ thanks for a great conversation, guys. ⁓ really fun. I feel like you've joined our expanding Marvel universe of people that we can disagree with respectfully. So it's great to have you part of it. ⁓

Damian DamjanovskiSorry. I I I I will say Danielle and Caroline, I was determined going into this that I would not like you, but I adore you both and thank you for a really fun, interesting, thoughtful conversation and a respectful one more than anything.

Peter LewisYeah.

CCBHa ha ha.

Peter LewisAnd ⁓ we we'll put a link to your podcast, obviously in our show notes and also up on the Burning Platform Substack and those links and the things that approved Danielle's right, we will put them up there as well. ⁓ so great conversation, guys. If you like these sorts of conversations, just like us and share us and do all those things that make the algorithm love us. ⁓ we'll talk again next week. Thank you all and ⁓ have a great weekend.

CCBYeah, ⁓ that back at you. It's a long list. Thanks a lot.