Episode 19
Politico comes to Australia. How about them melons!
With Ryan Heath
Show notes
With guest Ryan Heath - Editor of Politico Australia.
We cover the week, Ryans story and the changing Australian political landscape. We explore the media's approach to reporting political events and the role of Politico in filling the gaps in political reporting. We also talk political media tactics, diplomatic incidents, party politics, and the impact of populism on political parties.
Full transcript
Read itHide it
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.
Damian DamjanovskiWelcome to What's Your Poison, the show where people who rarely agree on anything agree that it's better to do so over a drink. My name is Damir Damianovsky. I'm a principal here at General Strategic, and I'm joined as I am every week by my evil twin, Peter Lewis, from Essential Media. Peter, how has your week been? What have you been up to and what is your poison?
Peter LewisSo busy week. spent a couple of days in Canberra, a couple of days in Melbourne, just back home today. Canberra was fantastic. highlight Monday night, the 40th anniversary of dot AU. And there was a retro event at Old Parliament House, Pac-Man, Space Invaders out, remembering the way the internet was when it was a lovely place to be.
Damian DamjanovskiGood old days.
Peter Lewisour guest was actually there as well, so we might even talk a bit about that later.
RyanI hear there was a good moderator at the event.
Peter LewisThere was a fantastic moderator full of verb and a lan, but you haven't been introduced yet, Ryan. So hold your horses. My poison, I've gone box. So I got home and didn't have any alcohol, but my daughter had left a box of Watergrove Sablanc in the fridge. Now, I'm kind of proud because I was a boxer growing up. My parents were dedicated boxers and my daughter's boxing. So it feels like third generation box. It's it's kidding itself that it's better than bottled wine and more environmentally sound. Packaging is no less than 85% lighter than glass. So I'm gonna give it a try and hopefully it lives up to my memory of a boxed wine. yeah. And it, you know, it's it's
Damian DamjanovskiBeautiful sound coming through there.
Peter Lewisit's like the instant coffee of wine when you don't. You're doing it for a reason to ra rather than, you know, for the palate or the smell. But this will do fine on a on a Friday afternoon.
Damian DamjanovskiThat that that looks to life. When you know, I do hope for because I'm a box box wine fan. I've always have been growing up
Peter LewisHero Boxer.
Damian Damjanovskigrowing up in Western Sydney, in an ethnic family, there were always many boxes of wine. And I I pray for the days when a similar walks around their fine restaurant with a little box and and you know, p pause your glass that way rather than the fancy bottle technique.
Peter Lewisit's good and it's good to know that the casks are coming back into some sort of fashion, at least with the younger generation and all all strength to them. So what about you? What's your week? Why are you wearing meta glasses and what's your poison?
Damian DamjanovskiI'll start with the glasses. So, Peter, as you know, and some of our listeners, but not all will know, is I have a a weird condition called photophobia, where my eyes get all funny sometimes from light, which means I have to wear my prescription sunglasses when it flares up particularly badly. And today is unfortunately one of those days, despite being a recording day for us. So I have to wear my glasses so that I don't A get a migraine. And B, don't sit here with you know hugely teary eyes that just don't stop pouring water everywhere. So I apologize for that. But my poison this week is a beautiful Tasmanian remnant, which is a lovely dram of single malt whiskey. This specific one is the black spot. So slange to everyone. and
Peter LewisHope it's hitting the black spot.
Damian Damjanovskiyeah, it's it's doing all right if I'm honest. And my week has been. Not too bad, if I'm honest. I've I've had quite a nice, good working week, nothing particularly eventful, sadly. And I didn't make it down to Canberra this week for the first sitting week post the winter break, but I'm excited by everything that has been going on in Canberra. And I think that might be a really good segue for Peter. Please introduce us to our wonderful guest this week, who knows everything in Canberra to the point where he's not only in Canberra, he's in the belly of the beast and the worst part. Belly of the beast, the Senate. Peter, who have we got this week?
Peter LewisSo I brought along Ryan Heath, who is come back to Australia after many years abroad to establish Politico Australia. I think it's this week the the the the launch, but Ryan will tell us more about that in a sec. I knew Ryan first when he was a young whippersnapper many years ago. He was National Union of Students president, I think. He wrote a terrific book about being young, like generational politics. And then he went off into the world and I haven't really seen him for 20 odd years, but it's great to have you in the room, Ryan. So welcome to what's your poison and to state the obvious, what's your poison?
RyanHi guys, hi everyone. I am drinking prime ginnister gin and tonic, fever tree tonic, of course, because anything else is a crime. and unlike Christopher Pine, I've put my own citrus in my gin. But I'm I'm a boxer too. I grew up on the box wine. My mother wasn't feeding it to me, but I used to take the little pillows that the wine came in, like the little bags. I'd blow them up and then I'd watch the one day cricket, you know, the old Benson and Hedges World Cup, the one day cricket matches at night after dinner, resting on mum's used box wine pillows. Mm-hmm.
Peter LewisAs a pillow. Terrific.
Damian DamjanovskiAmazing. And y you you guys know the the the correct term for the pillow, yes? The bladder. It is the wine the bladder.
RyanNo. Ooh, the blada.
Peter LewisLad the impal ya.
Damian Damjanovskiso Ryan, for for some of our audience who might not know, I'm gonna ask you to tell us a little bit about Politico, which
RyanMm-hmm.
Damian Damjanovskithe three of us know is one of the world's most esteemed political publications, and obviously has been absent from the Australian market other than occasionally Australian politics being tagged in the international politicos. What is Politico, what what is it doing that others don't? Like what what's its kind of
RyanHmm.
Damian Damjanovskireason for existence. And then maybe if you can tell us a little bit about your backstory and how you got to this point of being the the Austr you know, incoming Australian editor for Politico.
RyanYeah. so Politico's turning twenty in three months' time, and has been in Europe for eleven of those years now. And so it's basically the the insider's insider publication. And it becomes very interesting to lots of other people. But instead of treating politics as something you write about for everybody, we write about politics for the people who do politics, who live and breathe politics. And it's open to anyone else to read, but it's not written For the anyone else. It's written for the people who have to do this for a living. And that allows us to dig into some of the details and the juicy dynamics that, you know, might not be interesting or might go over the heads of other people who who don't have to sort of do this from dawn to dusk, or as is the case for politicos, often until midnight or later. So we got famous because we kind of pioneered the idea of newsletters. So delivering news to your inbox through newsletters. And that's the thing we're gonna start with in Canberra. You'll obviously always be able to read articles on our website and our app, but the thing that we are deliberately trying to get you addicted to starting on Monday, August 17, is something called the Canber Playbook. And that is a real mix of high and low. It will be big things that we expect to happen in the day ahead in Canberra. any kind of wrap-up or what's next, an analysis of the stuff that's been happening overnight. And what I call the kind of dessert to go with the vegetables, which is I found out today that the Speaker of the House and the President of the House were a bit upset that there weren't t-shirts about them in the parliamentary gift shop. They were just t-shirts saying, I'm gonna be prime minister when I grow up for the little kids who come to visit. So they've demanded that there be speaker and president t-shirts.
Peter LewisNobody says I wanna be president of the Senate when I grow up. Like
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. No one says, Yeah, I wanna be like Milton Dick. Yeah.
RyanBut also guys, you're following the protocol because the other thing I've heard is that the President of the Senate doesn't want to be addressed in any way as Madam President, and she's written to the departmental secretaries to make it clear that she won't be accepting correspondence if she's addressed as Madam President. so we're gonna go all into the nitty-gritty of all these sort of little details about how this works.
Damian DamjanovskiSo it's I I love this, Ryan. So it's not just the dry political machinations, but it's a little bit of the I'm gonna say and I don't mean this in a demeaning way, but a little bit of the gossip and also
RyanYep. Yep.
Damian Damjanovskia little bit of the the quirkiness and insanity that is Canberra. 'Cause again, for a lot of people on the outside, you you see places places like Canberra and Parliament House, and you go, that's a a big official institution and a big bunker and The realization that inside that building is a couple of thousand people who are, you know, often don't know really what they're doing. They're trying to make heads or tails of the whole thing. They're sax of meat and chemicals like the rest of us, trying to understand the universe. Like that that's an interesting realization. I think that's an interesting take on it. So I'm I'm personally very excited to subscribe to the Canberra Playbook. How did you get to this? What what have you been doing since you were the young whipperslapper with Peter Lewis?
Ryanlong and winding road, but I always love Peter 'cause he was one of the creative ones sort of in that broader labor movement. So I don't know. I don't want to say you were my spirit animal, Peter, but I saw you back then and that was why we orbited each other for a while. Yeah. and
Peter LewisPoor bugger. Yeah, yeah. That was in the days of workers online, I think, which was still the most fun I ever had, I reckon. Yeah.
RyanYes. Yeah. Literally in the twentieth century at one point and then then in the
Peter LewisYeah.
Ryanearly years of this century. and I don't know, it's a bit of a weird full circle for me. Like the first political thing I ever did was I was a member of John Howard's National Youth Roundtable, which was this random youth advisory body. And so pretty much twenty eight years ago, I was in this building
Peter LewisCan I just say that youth round tables, the people that put their hands up are the last people you want representing youth, but you're an exception, I'm sure.
RyanWell, don't tell Andrew Charlton, because he was on it. So was Kelly O'Dwyer.
Peter Lewismy goodness.
RyanAnd anyway, there's a national youth parliament starting on Monday, the first ever one. And I was just like, my god, like I came here, squatted out in tech's office
Damian DamjanovskiThis is full circle moment.
Ryantwenty eight years ago for that round table, and now I'm squatting in the Senate staff lounge trying to set up a media outlet twenty eight years later while this parliament gets going.
Peter LewisSo you are having
Damian DamjanovskiThat's incredible.
Peter Lewisa few swings and roundabouts getting space in Parliament. What's going on there?
RyanYeah. all right, yeah. We'll we'll I'll get back to the original story, Dame. but we we do not have an office. We're homeless in Parliament because the Department department of Parliamentary Services, which is that category of people Darme loves, the public servants, like we heard all about
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Ryanthat in the last episode. they do not see fit to engage in a discussion with us about how we could sublease from another sort of publication that's in the press gallery. there are four empty offices that overlook the Senate and they're a bit a bit controversial because they're heritage listed offices, and the both the usher and the president of the Senate, that sort of orbit and the department, the bureaucrats, don't want us to touch those empt empty offices because of all these complications around the heritage. and yeah, it's just a bit of a mess. And and they won't take meetings with us. so we're in a world where, you know, you can be a billion dollar media company and you've got to hang out and the stuff lunch. Yep. Yep.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. But you but you guys have your press credentials, so you're entitled to be basically anywhere in the building. So again, not not to harp on, and there's no bureaucrats here to defend themselves, but let's be honest, there's no bureaucrats to hold themselves accountable either. So they would rather you just hover around the building willy-nilly conducting business than give you
RyanMm-hmm.
Damian Damjanovskia proper place of work because of some imagined rule, some imagined slight
RyanYeah. Well, there are people who are doing subleases in up in the press gallery, including Michelle Grattan, the doyen of the whole gallery, including
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Yeah.
Ryana podcast studio that kind of exists to sort of facilitate politicians having their podcasts. so there are lots of people subleasing up there, but the official rule is no, you can't sublease and we'll kick you out and chase you out of the building if you try and do it. So we're just gonna run in circles.
Peter LewisAlthough I wonder and and let's get back to your series, but I just do wonder whether yes, you want a home, but actually just hovering, it's probably a better way of getting getting the news. 'Cause I I do feel like there there is a sense a lot of people
RyanYeah. It's a good little under under story.
Peter Lewisget institutionalized in that gallery and they work in the office and people come and see them, but they miss a bit of the dynamic. So who knows?
RyanYeah. Well it's a it's it's a bit like my shadow situation here on this podcast. I'm kind of like half in the shadow, half in the light. I can move around
Damian DamjanovskiAlthough to be honest, Ryan, in my time in that building, even though we had an office inside the Min Wing, my office was in the members' courtyard with a cigarette, and that was a fantastic office because Parliament House has some of the finest grass in this country by a long shot.
Peter LewisSo that's what you were smoking in parliament?
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, the the the the parliamentary grass. No. So again, if you if you ever get the opportunity to go down and and kind of Put your take your feet out of your shoes and socks and enjoy the grass that's in the Senate courtyard and the Parliament and the members' courtyard. It is a specifically bred hybrid grass that is made just for Parliament House. And there's like a team of God knows how many. No, but there's a there's a whole
Peter LewisThis is a politico yarn for sure, right?
RyanWell,
Damian Damjanovskiteam of botanists and arborists and all this kind of thing that, you know, 365 take care of Parliament House. So that grass is better tended to than any grass in the country. It's well drained, it's like It's looked after so well. It is better than any golf course and it's just beautiful. And no one enjoys it.
RyanOkay. I'm gonna do that. In honor of you, Dame,
Peter LewisExcept you. Yeah.
RyanI'm gonna do that. and also in honor of you, I'm gonna answer your question, which was like, How did
Damian DamjanovskiPlease do just just put your feet in it. Yes, please. Sorry.
RyanI get here? yeah.
Peter LewisThe rest of your life, yeah, sorry.
RyanSo I I did work for a a Labour senator for a year, and then it just kind of taught me that I didn't really want to be in frontline politics. So I ran away to England because I didn't speak any other languages, but I wanted to get out of the country. And I ended up as a as a public servant. and it was when Tony Blair was prime minister, and he really did encourage a lot of innovation and You know, when you're 24 and you've got big ideas and you're part of a system where they're saying have big ideas, that was actually a lot of fun. I loved it. I got to be near politics, but not actually practice the politics or have the hassle and the the scrutiny that comes with being a politician. and then I pretty randomly took a secondment to Brussels for a year because, in a pretty good preview of Brexit, absolutely nobody in Westminster wanted to do this one-year secondment. For what was a a very awesome speechwriter job at the European Commission in Brussels. They all thought it was like taking maternity leave or something, like it was gonna be some big pause or delay on their career if they went over to Brussels. And I was like, I'll do it. And I got paid some extra money. And it just turned out to be fantastic. I worked for a liberal commissioner over there, a Dutch woman who was known as the kind of like Dutch Margaret Thatcher, a woman called Nailey Cruz. And we did a lot of all the all the We we bayoured out bunch of banks unexpectedly and we did a lot of the scrutiny of the big tech companies. Like, you know how people do billion dollar fines against the big tech companies? We were pioneering that sort of accountability
Peter LewisHmm.
Ryanon those companies. yeah, and then I ended up working for a president, a bit like you, Dame. I got asked to go work for the president of the commission and I didn't really know him or like him, but you get asked by the president, you turn up. and he was a conservative from Portugal and he fired me about four months later, so that ended pretty quick.
Peter LewisYeah.
RyanAnyway, long story short, Politico
Damian DamjanovskiFantastic.
Ryandecides it's coming to town in twenty fourteen and I begged, borrowed, and stealed access to Politico to get myself a job. And we founded Politico. We brought Politico outside of America for the first time. And this same newsletter I'm doing here in Canberra, we built that in Brussels and and made that something people in all the European capitals had to read. And got married to an American, moved to America, and ended up at a AI startup because It just became super clear to me AI is gonna change everything. I didn't know exactly how, but you know, I was very confident it was the biggest, most horizontal change any of us are gonna experience. And I wanted to get into the guts of it. So I went and worked at an AI startup until last year.
Damian DamjanovskiWow, that's that's quite a journey and a very
Peter LewisIt's a journey, yeah.
RyanYeah.
Damian Damjanovskifascinating one. I I I kinda wanna ask you a little bit about two things. One, America and living over there, and I'm sure as a political tragic, you would have spent a lot of time observing the American system compared to both the Australian and the British systems and your observations on
Peter LewisThe European. Yeah.
Damian Damjanovskithat. And then I'm gonna ask you a little bit about the Australian political media landscape. So maybe l let's start with America. What what's From an Australian perspective, a lot of our listeners probably would listen into this and go, like Austral America's a basket case at the moment. Things are going crazy. Trump, trump, trump, trump, trump. Love him, hate him, whatever. It's a bit weird at the moment. Your observations on the what's happening?
RyanYeah, I think it's in the weird zone, not the basket case zone. and you know, I was talking to Dom Peritette, the former New South Wales premier the other day, who's now with BHP, and he was just like, you know, like there's a Trump derangement syndrome in the Australian media and the way the sort of filtered lens Australians get about America. But it's not based on nothing. Like there is some kind of deep unease in the country and whether you are uneasy at the Mamdanification of New York or at the kind of sort of real wrecking ball that Trump and his allies take to a bunch of institutions. You know, this is not a country that's at ease with itself. And I come up with the most random examples. Like it is, it is a country where like nobody will respect a traffic light as a pedestrian or a biker. Like people just walk wherever the hell they want now. It costs $15 to buy two liters of milk at the supermarket, like next to my house in New York. And I'm not talking about like some fancy milk or some fancy supermarket. Like that's just what milk costs. unless you're gonna go buy the absolute dregs. And, you know, and then you're if you live in that country, you're empowered by a president who doesn't think rules apply to anything. And so that is why things are just going off in a bunch of different directions. There's a culture of the rules don't apply anymore. And a little bit of these kind of like last days of Rome, where like, I don't know, half my half my Instagram feed is kind of the fabulous gaze of New York just going and living life like it's an endless party. Because they don't
Damian DamjanovskiMm.
RyanAbout politics, they don't want to talk about any of that difficult stuff. And it's you know, it's a pretty wild place. And you throw in three hundred million guns, it's bit combustible.
Peter LewisSo I'm interested, Ryan, in the the mutually dependent feedback loop between media and Trump. So Trump drives clicks, clicks drive Trump. Round
RyanYeah. Yeah.
Peter Lewisand round and round it goes. and there's a certain sort of media that trades off this. So just talking about even your model of politico in Australia, finding,
RyanMm-hmm.
Peter Lewisyou know, the sugary stuff, that's all part of what's knocked things off kilture, isn't it? Yes, there's the economic stuff underneath, which is undermining faith in the system. But the sideshow is creating this sort of mutual dependence on weird and wacky. And I just don't know if it's a r fair representation of the world, and particularly whether we want to bring that into the way that we think about politics in Australia. So there's a provocation
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisor a question.
RyanYeah, there's multiple things going on here. And I think we can connect it back to Pauline Hansen and the attention economy that she's driving or a part of in Australia, so that people feel like it's close to home. you know, Pauline Hansen and Barnaby Joyce are just more interesting than a lot of other Australian politicians, and that is factual about Trump too. And that doesn't make it great necessarily, but they they they know how to project a level of unfiltered behavior that people can kind of respond to. So th there is a reason why people are are are attracted to those antics and those performances.
Peter LewisBut look what happens to Andrew Bragg when he tries to be interesting. Like he gets slapped down. or and we'll talk about Albo later when he goes on a po Yeah, yeah. But there is that
RyanAnd he kind of got attacked by Labour as well. Labor went hardcore at him about Andrew Bragg's big day out. And I was like, this is really mean. Like the guy came up with a bunch of interesting ideas. Like they're obviously not all road tested, but let's talk about the ideas. Yeah, exactly.
Peter LewisLet's discuss the ideas, not the guy, right? Yeah.
RyanI didn't think that was fair. and I mean I can see why Angus Taylor might be annoyed at it, but also, you know, like have some ideas of your own if you don't like Andrew Bragg's, what you might
Peter LewisBut but to your point on One Nation, before we get back to the States, like One Nation can do that 'cause they're an insurgent. So the media landscape incur like it it works for an insurgent. Whereas when you're a a party with structures and it it's harder to do that. It's harder to go road.
RyanYeah, yeah, yeah, that's fair. but like there are other drivers of the issues in America where it's the twenty-four hour news cycle. So this does get to the heart of the business model. And I think the idea that you've got to deliver people news twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week, is more of a problem than the idea that people are chasing clicks. Because you have to manufacture news if you have to artificially fill 24 hours of airtime or or endless digital space, let's say. And You know, I just don't think that's always justified. So that becomes a big problem. Our business model is a little bit different. Like we we really just don't depend on clip.
Peter LewisYeah, explain that 'cause I didn't get it 'til I spoke to you over in Adelaide. Yeah.
RyanYeah, yeah. So in many ways we're a B2B company. So we rely on relatively high-end subscriptions, so enterprise level subscriptions, where your company or your government department buys a group subscription to Politico. And that that costs a lot of money. Like you're you're almost certainly paying ten thousand dollars an up for a Politico subscription. But that's for Yeah.
Peter LewisBack to the thin review seems cheap.
RyanBut that's for very granular policy reporting about the guts of politics and policy. We don't charge for any of the the the politics reporting. Like we need
Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.
Ryana a window to display what we can do. And we think we've got a role in democracy where we would never put everything behind the paywall. But because we're not trying to get 10 million people reading each story on our website, we don't have to have rage generating headlines. We don't have to do that thing where the story doesn't match sort of the the thing you got tweeted. we we can actually just serve you what we think is the real details. And also because we're going for this niche audience, we can't afford to piss off half of that audience. Like we have to be nonpartisan. We have to keep everyone in the tent and be a kind of trusted convening space. Because if we just did the thing of chasing the left or the right, like we we
Peter LewisMm.
Ryanliterally wouldn't make money. We couldn't make money.
Peter LewisSo this is really interesting. So you've basically got gossip and depth. And then the
RyanAnd he
Peter Lewisbit in between, which is process, you say, Well, that's for other people. That's that's what the traditional media mastheads do. Is that fair or
RyanYeah, th yeah. I mean it's pretty close. Yep.
Damian DamjanovskiSo so let me ask you this because I I'm fascinated by this. So in the press gallery, which is, you know,
RyanMm-hmm.
Damian Damjanovskiwhat we call the collection of, you know, news organizations that sit in Cambert Parliament House and and follow all the events that are happening there, Australia, you would argue on the one hand, isn't poorly represented. You've got the the Herald and the Age, you've got the AFR, you've got news dot com dot AU, the Oz, you've got the Daily Tele Herald Sun, Capital Brief. News twenty-four, the ABC, who am I missing? Like we've we've it Yeah, you the City
RyanYeah, you you covered a lot of it. You got the city papers,
Damian DamjanovskiPapers, the Canberra Times, the Conversation, like the New Daily, like there's so
RyanYou are an S B S A P
Damian Damjanovskimany of in there. What is it that's in your view, what's missing from the way these organizations are reporting Canberra and
Peter LewisQuestion.
Damian Damjanovskiand why is politico gonna fill that gap? Like what's the thing that you're going that you guys at Politico went, Yeah, obviously we need to be in Australia because no one's doing this.
RyanYeah. I I think people are way too obsessed with the immediate horse race questions. There's not enough context being applied. There's not enough follow-up. And often journalists get criticized for not doing the follow-up questions in the interview. Like I think it's more important to do the follow-up questions the day after and the week after and to be able to circle back to things. And what's really nice about a newsletter format is it's so flexible. Like I don't have to wait until I have an entire story ready to tell you something important. And if one extra thing occurs next week or four days later, I can just add a line to the newsletter telling you that's happened or why I think that's important or why I think it means something else is going to happen tomorrow. I don't have to
Peter LewisYeah.
Ryando a live blog that just disappears sort of off the face of the earth five minutes later. And I don't have to wait until I have enough for a thousand words of a very sort of ego stroking, throat clearing article. I can choose whatever level of information I need is going to get you the thing that you can use to make a better decision or take action on. And so
Peter LewisMm.
RyanI think that's, you know, aside from wanting it to be fun and relevant, like where the relevance comes from is people being able to take action after reading something that we've put in our newsletter. Like this should make your day easier. And if it's not, then we're not doing your job. We're just doing something that's interesting. And you could read that on the weekend. Like we want you to read it in the morning and then be better at your jobs because you read.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. And no doubt you're gonna get some good gossip sitting in the Senate dining room rather than in the press gallery. So
RyanYeah.
Damian Damjanovskithat that's really good. Do do you think there's a like have you noticed a massive difference? Cause I'm just working on one thing you touched on there, which is Australian
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskinews outlets definitely have a way of reporting Australian politics that I don't think you necessarily see in other parts of the world. That's my observation. but I'm curious on your thoughts is Is Australian media parti does it have its own particular quirks about how it reports on the political establishment compared to other places that you've seen?
Ryantricky. I mean, I I feel like I have a bit of a blind spot here because I haven't been back for long enough.
Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.
Ryanthere is a bit of a literal pack mentality and a bit of a narcissism in the small differences between how the pack sorts itself and presents itself. so one of the things that I told our team, and we we're starting with a team of three on Monday, and the fourth person just has been held up from the Finn review, he's on on a long notice period.
Peter LewisIncluding my old friend Paul Carp from Guardian, which is a great signing.
RyanWell yeah, he's the one that's being held up
Peter Lewisright.
RyanYeah. So he'll join us in September. So we're r a relatively small team. We can't be everywhere at once. And what I've told them is I don't ever want you chasing twenty other people into a courtyard for a press conference. You know, one, we want to elevate other people's good journalism. So if twenty people are already going there and reporting on it, let's take the best work that came out of that group of twenty and link to that and credit that in the newsletter the next morning if it matters. And probably None of it matters. Because if you're all being herded together to be read out talking points, well, someone else can read that somewhere else. Like we don't want to just aggregate stuff that AI can aggregate or that you can get in 20 other places. We want to go somewhere where other people are not. so for us it's about not being afraid to go niche and going to whatever patch of the beautiful grass in Parliament House no one else is standing on
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Ryanand and not being worried that. We might be missing the biggest story of the day or the year because we were
Peter LewisHmm. So much of the daily news cycle is driven by the fear of missing out, and then the other one is the perse perverse incentive of being first, which normally means you've just been given a drop and it's uncritical reporting.
RyanAnd because of business models, a lot of people here are not looking the fear of missing out, they're not looking at most of the town. Like there
Peter LewisMm.
Ryanare hundreds of billions of dollars a year being spent by government departments within two kilometers of Parliament House and virtually nobody writes about it. It's
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Ryanin my opinion, that's insane.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, literally the only publication you can get some of that information is the Mandarin, which is a subscription only and it's
Peter LewisMm-hmm.
Damian Damjanovskibasically a publication designed exclusively for bureaucrats. So do you and again curious for your thoughts on this, because I think when we were in government, one of the things that it always felt like was that Australian media outlets love the gotcha. Like they're very kind of almost adolescent in their approach. approach to trying to catch politicians in like, you know, whether it's a verbal stuff up. And we're seeing this at the moment with Mellingate, which is why, and we'll dig into that in a bit, but that's what we're seeing is like this very kind of adolescent approach to how we treat our politicians rather than substance based. What what's your views on that?
RyanYeah, and some of that can get too worthy. It can be people who just wish everyone else read the same sort of policy white papers that that they did. And I I don't want to become that sort of person that becomes too intellectual and tells people everyone has to read a long book at night in order to enjoy themselves. But it it is absolutely true and the Mellingate stuff sort of highlights that. It's it's not even a gate. Like it might be a mellodrama.
Peter LewisHa.
RyanIt does not rise beyond melodrama in my mind. There's no gay.
Damian DamjanovskiA melan trauma. A melancholy, as Peter Lewis calls it.
Peter LewisYeah. and I but
RyanYeah, yeah, yeah.
Peter LewisI I think if you unpack that and which was before we get to Mellingate, just the ongoing and sometimes inexplicable influence of the Murdoch media still within the gallery. So like that that story was kicked off by a former Japanese ambassador on the front page of the Oz. Like I I don't know how many former Japanese ambassadors. Yeah.
RyanMm. Yeah. Who's known to have big ripes against the government? It's not it's not even neutral.
Peter Lewisand so no, no, no, no,
Damian Damjanovskipain. Is this this
Peter Lewisno, let's Just just hear me out for a sec. So I because I think there's been this thing for a long time that the Murdoch Media sets the agenda. It used to the Australian sets the agenda. Inexplicably, the ABC often runs off the back of whatever News Limited's running. But it feels to me this one in particular has been totally confected by news, who are a right of center outlet, arguably beyond right of center. you know, clutching their pearls on an issue that would normally be something that's prosecuted on the left as a woke sort of he's gone outside his lane on gender, but it's being prosecuted by our friends at News Limited. So
RyanI they find it delicious. Like, I if I were Penny Wong or Katie Gallagher or Tanya Plivosek having to stand up and defend this, I'd feel pretty humiliated and embarrassed because it's just a bit silly that this ever happened in the first place. But the idea that people in Japan are quaking in their boots or trying to withdraw trade or anything like that, like it that's just not true. And the only reason it's gaining attention in Japan, which is allegedly the problem that is being addressed by the opposition is because the opposition is insisting Japanese people address it. So they're creating the problem they're accusing the Prime Minister of having generated. So it I don't know, like I I my
Peter LewisSo how would you cover it, Ryan? If you if you were up and running, how would you be covering that story next week?
RyanYeah. We we we we did dummy runs this week, so we went through it. so obviously we would have mentioned it. We would have said this is getting too much
Peter LewisCrazy.
Ryanattention, and the playbook challenge we would have issued to the opposition is how is this winning back voters who have defected to one nation? Your primary challenge at the moment is to win back voters who have defected to one nation. And yes, your job is also to make the prime minister look stupid or incompetent. But in the process of doing that, you should not make yourself look stupid and unc uncomp incompetent and too attached to one thing. So I I think they've overregged it and I don't think they're achieving their main goal in over.
Damian DamjanovskiSo I I don't disagree with you, Ryan and Peter, I totally get where you're coming from, but I just want to break apart a couple of things there. Number one, I don't think it's for regardless of the outlet they chose, I don't think it's necessarily fair for us to try and discredit a a former diplomat who, you know, clearly does have a view on this thing. Like ultimately they're, you know, they're still a former diplomat, like they're to a, you know, to an allied country. Yeah.
Peter LewisFormer diplomat like how many former diplomats have a view that don't get on the front page of the Australian? But go on, please.
Damian DamjanovskiSo I think they're putting aside the Liberal Party response to this, which I agree is not only over-egged, but you know, Patterson asking for people to, you know, for the AFP to investigate. Well, like that that's starting to get into incompetence territory. Like that's Yeah. However, there
Peter LewisI'm waiting for them to do a like an action bring out your melons or something. Like what
Damian Damjanovskithere is a morsel of truth here that does deserve to be investigated. And I think I think it is right for the Murdoch media or the Oz specifically to investigate it, which is
Peter LewisWhat is the morsel? What is the morsel?
Damian Damjanovskiwe you know, we we don't treat a you know, a Labour Prime Minister making what was a essentially a sexualized remark about a foreign head of st hang on. We don't we we don't
Peter LewisI'll hear you out and then I will respond. Yeah.
Damian Damjanovskitreat it the same way we would have done a Conservative Prime Minister Also making a sexualized remark about a woman. We just don't. And and I think that's really clear. Like we dis we we dismiss it as a, it's not a big deal because there's other things that are more important that are going on. Totally true. But on the same token, if we have a higher standard for our elected representatives and our prime minister is make like regardless of what kind of podcast it was, like. He's a statesman. He's not meant to be making sexualized remarks about anyone, let alone about a foreign head of state. We would not accept it in other circumstances. Why, why would we let this prime minister get away with it? Like there is a case to be prosecuted there, but I think the Liberal Party completely missed the mark on what the case was to be prosecuted and just overstretched in the process. And to Ryan's point, made themselves look stupid in that process, which is the the doubt, the the silly component of it. So that I think that was where they really you know, they they really missed it. I mean, don't forget, like we th the Labour had a field day with like Tony just winking at a at a woman when he was running for Prime Minister. Like th this is not something
RyanWell also if they hadn't over egged it so much, Darmay, they could keep returning to it as a callback for months and months and months and gotten a
Damian DamjanovskiExactly.
Ryanlittle bit of mileage out of it. Now people are gonna be so sick of the concept of milling, they're just never gonna wanna hear about it again.
Damian DamjanovskiTh they'll Exactly. Like it's one of those things where because they over egged it, they've lost their tactical advantage, which goes to a bigger question from the Liberal Party perspective, which is the media tactics at the moment are appallingly bad. Like who is who's making these calls? Sorry, Peter, go on.
Peter LewisLet me go back because I got rudely interrupted by a plane going overhead. I think I dropped out for a couple of minutes. And I don't no so I don't know what Ryan just said, but I'm sure it was erudite and also incisive. I
RyanChecks in the mail.
Peter Lewishave watched the video as obsessively as I watched Barnaby's sit-down video. And this is what I will say in Albo's defense. He was asked to question what was the weirdest present that you've ever received, he said it was the melons. And I do think that is a weird thing to be given. So it was obviously what came into his mind. He did not open the Mel he he was not the instigator of Mellon Gate, the woman whose name I forget, who is a kind of comedian. Like so there's a question about,
RyanNikki Osborne.
Peter Lewisyeah. So she started going all Pamela Anderson him and he kind of went with it. he didn't say, don't be sexist, go away.
Damian DamjanovskiHang on.
Peter LewisHe kind of went with it. I don't think he initiated anything that was disrespectful of women. I think he just said there were two melons and let it go on. Now, I think though, I think where he gets into trouble is then denying that something's happened. It's a bit like when he fell off the stage at the minors union conference and then denied that he'd slipped off. the stage. Like I don't think there are any votes to be lost in going with a podcast like that and going with it. But the problem is he's denying something that happened happened. Like otherwise it would have just been Kevin Rudden's scores and everyone goes, okay, it makes him more human.
Damian DamjanovskiBut come on, like Peter, like he he didn't bring up the melons unknowingly. Like, firstly, you know, like when these gift
Peter LewisI don't
Damian Damjanovskiexchange, hang on, when these gift exchanges happen, the advancing team in the PM's office, which is a group of five or six people, and then the
RyanWhat did we give her? No one's talking about that.
Peter LewisBananas.
Damian Damjanovskithe advancing team of the Japanese PM, which would, you know, scores of a hundred people, actually discuss
Peter LewisMm.
Damian Damjanovskiwhat an appropriate equal value reciprocal gift is. He knew he was going to receive the melons. And he also knew the fact that receiving perfect fruit is one of a a very high stature gift from the Japanese. He brought it up in that podcast quite intentionally as a weird gift. And it is far f so all I'm saying here, Peter, is I think it's very
Peter LewisI I just d I'm not sure they prepped properly for that podcast. I I heard the the woman was actually on
Damian DamjanovskiThen that's a whole other issue.
Peter LewisMark Boris this week saying that every podcast she does that shag Mary Kill or whatever. So again, they should have seen it coming and been ready for that. So
Damian DamjanovskiI I think it was it was yeah, I think it was poor briefing, but I I'm I'm just gonna call out that I'm not I don't think it's I don't think this is a justifiable comment by Alba. Whether or not it's a big deal is a different question, but I think No, it's it's not, it's not. Of course, but
Peter LewisI don't think it's a diplomatic incident though. Like I think it's been totally blown up and ridiculously so. And people that think the political system is an indulgence that and and is being dr and and driving to look at, you know, the populist outsiders, it just adds grist to the mill on that, I reckon.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd again, look, I I I know our audience probably is so sick of hearing about Mell and Kate because of the fact they don't genuinely care about it. The the part as I said, the part that bothers me is not whether or not it was a diplomatic incident. It's the fact that the outside of the Oz, the rest of the media seems to not care about holding Albow to account on sexualized comments about a foreign, you know, head of state.
Ryanthink it's being noticed. Like just my vibe check
Peter LewisDior pardon.
Ryanaround the building is people are they're very much going, like, why do we have to write about this? But Albo, wow, he's really blowing up political capital that he had in spades. Like
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Ryanwhy is he
Peter LewisI also suspect the you know, your old boss got hit so hard on so much of this that there is a bit of equalising or evening up going on, Damien.
Damian DamjanovskiMaybe I I couldn't I couldn't say I'm not in any of those newsrooms and I'm not a journalist. I don't know how that part of it works. But I as a reader, I know that I go, Well, if this wasn't if this was a different PM, if this was Abbott, if this was someone from the Liberal Party, they would definitely be held to a different standard by a lot of these organisms. Like there would be nonstop Guardian articles about Tony Abbott winking, as there was, right? Like that that's the that's the bit that I go, that that's pretty, pretty annoying.
RyanWell there's I mean part of this is like yes n w one thing I always try and sort of remind people about when they complain about how news occurs or how journalists do things is like news is conflict d driven. People often want news to be more positive. And I'm like, Well, news isn't about positivity. It's about when people are clashing over something and giving
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Yeah.
Ryanyou the tools to decide which side you're on. but
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Rather than Alba has successful event. Great stuff, everyone.
RyanYeah.
Damian DamjanovskiRound of applause.
RyanYeah. But then also what's interesting is when people do something that is either completely against expectations or which reinforces something people were already thinking about them. And here
Peter LewisOkay.
Ryanit's interesting because Albo was supposed to be the champion of women as a left winger, and now he's not doing that. And what's interesting
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. And
Ryanabout Abbott doing something is that you kind of expect it from him. And so now it's reinforcing this kind of idea that he was always going to do stuff like that.
Peter Lewis'Cause the worst
Damian DamjanovskiNo you're
Peter Lewisthing for a politician is to be seen to have double standards, right? Like the you know, that so yeah, get it. I also think
RyanIf you're from the establishment, but that rule doesn't apply to One Nation, to MAGA, to Nigel Farage, to Georgia Maloney, because they're seen as anti politicians. So
Damian DamjanovskiMm.
Peter LewisYeah.
Ryanthey're not held to the standard of a normal politician because all their other performances are about being a normal person who's sticking it to the system, et cetera.
Peter LewisCan I just say that and I'm interested in your reflections on this? So Trump, you know, everyone thought grabbing by the pussy would be the end of him and it had no impact whatsoever. Like, but it but then it wasn't. But then it wasn't. And
RyanMm. It nearly was. Got close to ending him. Yep. Yep.
Peter Lewisit's almost untouchable that whole thing. I could st I could stand in the middle of the street and shoot people, no one would care. Like, so where is what what are the things that lead to accountability and what just creates oxygen?
Ryanwell we're not gonna answer that in this podcast. That's that's another four hours of chat.
Damian DamjanovskiBut it it it sounds like
Peter LewisThat's more a philosophical question, isn't it? Yeah.
Damian Damjanovskibut it sounds a little bit like what Ryan's saying and what I'm hearing is like if you do want to enter politics in Australia these days, and this is for any of our listeners who have, you know, the the psychological condition that unfortunately makes them want to enter politics, if you do want to enter politics, start crazy, don't start normal and then go crazy. Like just start insane from the beginning and then you're good, because then you can
Peter LewisThe Barnaby Doctrine.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, the Barnaby doctrine,
RyanYeah. Cool.
Damian Damjanovskiit works.
RyanBut it's driving the other mainstream category of people in this building mad. Like I've had multiple conversations this week, not connected to this topic, but just people going like, How on earth do we fight the need to be viral in two seconds? Like they they don't understand how to make people engage without also sending you into in some productivity coma. So like there is a real lack of being able to be, you know, accessible and interesting. Somewhere in between the productivity coma and the I'm doing wacky crazy shit with my pets.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, I I I I saw I saw a Instagram reel of Ted O'Brien speaking Cantonese or some shit. And I was like, all right, if even Ted O'Brien at this point is attempting to get views, we've we have jumped the shark as as a nation. But I I a couple more questions for you, Ryan. I do realize we're kind of getting on with it. as a kind of re-entrant into the building, you get a kind of fresh perspective on obviously Pauline and Albow and how they're doing. I'm really interested on as a re entrant.
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian DamjanovskiHow you're feeling about the Liberal Party, Angus and his performance. Obviously some of his staff had a bit of a incident this week that we can talk about. Just your your general views on it, I'd love to hear.
Ryanit's funny. Like I'm one of those like when people ask me, What do you like as a journalist or how do you approach things? And I I'm a bit of a cuddly journalist sometimes. You know, I'm like Oprah when it comes to interviews. Like I just want you to be your best self and I'm sometimes even coaching you to like reflect on yourself and come up with a better answer. I'm not the attack dog sort of interviewer.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
RyanAnd then I'm just a total asshole in print. Like if if you've lost me, you've completely lost me and I'm gonna say exactly what I think. and so people find a bit of wicklash when they engage with me where they're often like, you're so nice in person because they've just been reading me up until now.
Damian DamjanovskiCudley that cuddly teddy bear had teeth.
RyanYeah, exactly, exactly. and so I am judging people in the building right now because I I have gone out of my way to engage with people and people are usually really nice in person, but I have I've personally written to everyone who's a departmental secretary or deputy secretary. I've reached out to all the officers of the MPs and the senators, and there's a very stark dividing line between people who like r recognize that you're doing that or people who actually look at their email inboxes or leave their staff
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Ryanmembers to do it and so on. And you can't reach total judgments by doing this. but the people who kind of like are c entirely disinterested in what Politico is or what it might do. Like I am keeping notes on you because I do think it says something about you that you don't have any clue what Politico is or you don't have any interest in finding
Peter LewisLack of curiosity.
Ryanout how you could use us. and then the people who do engage, I'm like, you're switched on. And It doesn't mean you need to know everything about politico, but you know, there are members of the cabinet who are a bit like, right, tell me more about your business model. How can we engage? You know, I think I'd like to do this with you. Does that work? You know, are you like other journalists? Like, tell us how it's different. Like they have honest, sincere conversations about how to have a productive conversation. And then there are people who are like too up their own asses to even realize that we're in the building. And, you know, and to bring it back to the Angus Taylor side of things, like,
Peter LewisYeah, I feel like this is a preface to Angus Taylor, but
Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.
RyanYou know, no, it's it's not specifically to Angus Taylor. where I'm I'm on all of their lists. I've been to the party room briefings and things like that. But it's also true that no one said, like, hey, why don't you come in and do a presentation about politico or anything like that? We haven't sort of had that level of engagement. but but I've had some good relations with a couple of people. I don't want to out them in particular. But, you know, like there are good people who
Damian DamjanovskiNo, you very you're very welcome to, but
Ryanare reaching out and they respond quickly when you have things. But there hasn't been any sense of like, yeah, well we need to get on top of this and And and make sure politico understands the opposition position. There's there'd be none of that.
Peter LewisSo you left a you left a
Damian DamjanovskiI think that might just be 'cause they don't have a position at the moment. That's a problem.
RyanMaybe.
Peter LewisBut you left Australia when Howard was still in power, did you? So
RyanYep, that's true.
Peter Lewislike I I'll I'll just push more on Dame's. Like, what is your view of where the right in Australia has gone? Like genuinely curious, yeah?
RyanInteresting. I'll reverse engineer the answer because I think they're dealing with a lack of investment in contrast to Alb ALBO. And it's a specific ALBO point here. So the left vote was splitting from the mid-2000s onwards. And ALBO was the epicenter of that because it was happening in Sydney and Grangle and those sort of
Peter LewisGrindler. Yeah.
Ryanin the city electorates. And it wasn't like he was automatically going to lose his seat, but Sort of people like he and Tanya Politusek were in danger at various moments and they had to confront that reality and they had to figure out what the fracturing of the left vote meant. They had to quarterise it, and then they had to find some way to not alienate everyone in that process. the liberals have never really had to manage that fracturing of the right vote, and they clearly don't have any answer for how to manage it. And so they're going through this pain that Albo went through sort of 15 years ago, and he's through the pain, and Labor's in a in a lucky nice spot now because they did manage to get rid of sort of the green wave that had had come in in those inner city seats. So he's sitting pretty and the liberals have just never had to do that hard thinking and they're paying
Peter LewisMm.
Ryanthe price for it now. You see it in all the clunky responses about coalition versus supply agreement versus finding some way to work together on legislation. Like the mathematics is obvious. Like the right is a larger block of votes than the left, but if they want to govern, they have to find some way to work together and The inability to have a smart conversation about that, you know, like it's a bit damning about their state of operation here.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. We we've discussed this on the podcast before, Ryan. You might you might not have heard it one of the past episodes, but the the fact that the the Big Tent Party in Australia was born as a as a protest party against communism and never really took the time to recalibrate its center after the fall of communism, but instead rode the wave of, you know, economic good fortunes during the nineties and then a dysfunctional Labour Party through the late early two thousands, like it's literally never seemed to have done the work of sitting down and going, what is our center of gravity? What are the things that the left and right can agree to within the Liberal Party? And how do we move forward with it? So I I completely agree with you. It's like it's literally just work that has not been done. And there hasn't been the people in place to drive
Peter Lewisbeen the previous
Damian Damjanovskithat work being done. We haven't had the I hate to say it, but there hasn't been the leadership in place whether it's from a elected officials or an organizational perspective to go, guys, we can't move forward until we answer these questions properly.
RyanAnd it's really hard to do
Peter LewisMm.
Ryanit if you're down to nine thousand members in New South Wales. Like you're now fighting over scraps and bringing in the brethren or whoever to man the polling booths. And then like my God, you're just you're kind of like fighting over nothing, which makes it all the more sort of insane the level of energy that goes into the fight and all the less
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Ryanproductive what comes out of the fight.
Damian DamjanovskiI'm just gonna say I'm just gonna say allegedly bringing in the brethren for our own coverage. Thank you.
Peter Lewisthe one thing I would challenge you on is the notion that Labour is sitting pretty because their primary vote is low thirties now. I I I feel like while I think Swannee's said this before, that while their their their advantage is broad, it's not particularly deep. and
RyanMm-hmm.
Peter LewisI do think that that insider outsider analysis means that it's not that one nation is as as an immediate a threat, although I think it will play out in the Victorian elections that they will pick up some Labour seats in some of those industrial rural areas. So yeah, interesting because you were obviously your your your your origin story like mine is out of the Labour Party and the Labour movement. What's your impressions coming back to a government that looks very like on the surface very strong, obviously with a lot of people that you probably came up with as well. Like what what's your view on where labor is at the moment, right?
RyanIt's surprisingly mature in just its kind of like day to day outlook and rhythms is what I would say. Like
Peter LewisMm.
Ryanyou compare it to sort of the Rod Gillard folks, like that was really young laborization of government.
Peter LewisA second marriage. Second marriage.
RyanYeah, it just wasn't I mean that, you know, better forgotten. and these guys at the very least seem to be like, Okay, well we're not gonna lose our core, we're not stabbing each other in the face and we're kind of basically trying to do our jobs is the vibe
Peter LewisMm.
Ryanthat cross. And you can have all of your quibbles about is there enough debate within the party, the level of grassroots versus ministerial advisors versus unions and all of that. Like I'm not saying those elements couldn't be rejigged, but there's not some kind of like fundamental sort of insanity or or personalization of it all compared to the previous governments, is is what I would say. And then like when you look across broadly at the scene, like I grew up just near Coss Harbour. I've only ever been represented by a national party MP, or there was a liberal at the state level for a while. Andrew Fraser, the the president of the Nationals, was my MP. He gave me my Ducks Award at high school, actually. so I'm really
Peter LewisHumbleberg.
Ryanfamiliar with that national integration into community life and how things work in those areas. And if I were the nationals, I'd be worried about a total wipe out at the next election. Like I think one nation is gonna eat into liberals, take a couple of Labour Heartland seats in those sort of outer suburbs, but it's the national seats that they really stand the good chance of just taking. and you might be in a world where there is only an option for a liberal and one nation. It maybe it's not a coalition, but maybe they're the two that have to work together for there to be a right wing government. And then it's not a choice, it's just like, well, that's what it is. So either you go away and rebuild in the shadows and refuse to govern, or you have to try and work together
Damian DamjanovskiMm.
Ryanform of government and the national is
Peter LewisAnd and I
Ryannot there.
Peter Lewisand one more question on that. What do you reckon the right in Australia can learn from what Trump and populism have done to the Republican Party in America?
RyanI mean, the party structures are so different. And the lesson Trump takes from all of it is I was right. And so he was wrong to like accept the council of people who supposedly knew how government was run. Like in his opinion, like that's where we went astray and failed to achieve what we wanted to achieve in Trump won. And where we're getting what we want
Peter LewisMm
Ryanis we Asked for everything we wanted. We weren't afraid. We never backed down. We brought in the outsiders to shake things up. Like that's the lesson he takes from all of it. But if you're gonna do that as the liberals here, I'm not directly equating Andrew Hasty and Donald Trump, but but Angus Taylor is not the Trump option. Like the closest thing to it is Andrew Hasty. That's why One Nation sees him him as such a threat. That's why they're going
Damian DamjanovskiNo.
Ryanhardcore at him. Like they have their own personal gripes, some of them. About the Ben Robert Smith stuff and seeing Andrew Hasty as a traitor, but they also see Andrew Hasty as the one most like them in a policy perspective. That ability to see some of the economic nationalism arguments, the interventionist stuff for strategic industries with all the conservative social stuff, like the reason what they want to take him down is the reason the Republicans wanted to take down Kamala Harris. They see him as a future threat. So, you know, if the liberals wanna directly confront the
Peter LewisMm-hmm.
Ryansort of one nation anti-establishment insurgency. Then they should have gone for a hasty rather than a tailor.
Damian DamjanovskiHmm. That's actually a really interesting observation. So you do do you think the Liberal Party's position right now is their rock bottom, or would you argue that they might not have seen their rock bottom yet? You don't have to answer that.
RyanI think they might not think
Peter LewisYou don't have to explain.
Ryanthey're up bottom. And I think Victoria is the litmus test here, which is a lot of pressure to put on people who didn't ask for it. But, you know, if if the Liberals cannot cobble together a government in Victoria against what was the Jacinter Allen government and that mess down there, there are serious questions about their viability in general. And I don't think one nation is going to like quote unquote win or finish first necessarily, but for them to top the polls without a leader And candidates, like that says a lot about what Victorians think about the state of their politicians and so on. and it's going to be a real struggle for a Labour government to function, even if they do get across the line. So it's kind of like a bit of a mess in general down there. And it tells you a lot about some of the fault lines for the federal election. But like
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Ryanif Jess Wilson can't walk away as premier by Christmas, you know, like we're in serious, like, what is the point of the Liberal Party territory?
Damian Damjanovskithat's super fascinating, Ryan. I think where the lab the Liberal Party goes from here and how it affects our democracy is gonna be something that I'm sure people are gonna read about in Politico. for our listeners and anyone else, how do they how do they get the Canberra playbook? How do they get involved with politico? How do they start reading?
RyanYeah. Critical thing. You've got you've got to subscribe. I think a lot of people think they'll just go to the website and find a million Australia stories. We are part of five hundred and fifty global team of political reporters. So it's not all gonna be Australia stuff on politico.com. But if you Google Canberra Playbook or go to politico.com forward slash Canberra dash playbook, like you just need to give us your email address. And it will get delivered to your inbox five thirty every weekday morning. And we'll be out with our own podcast in October. So if you like to listen rather than read, we'll be there for you from October onwards.
Damian DamjanovskiSo politico.com forward slash cambra dash
Peter LewisWell stick in the play notes.
Damian Damjanovskiplaybook, which is a very memorable URL. Congratulations.
RyanHa camera playbook. You'll find us. If you type it in, you'll find us.
Peter LewisDot AU, what a beautiful thing. As we said on Monday night. We didn't even go back to that. But yeah, like
RyanYeah, there's no dot AU. I I'm I'm I'm contradicting the brand here, but I I w
Peter LewisMm.
RyanI was moderating those beautiful tech awards on Monday night and it was a great night.
Damian DamjanovskiAre you Peter Lewis, are you a dot com dot AU guy?
Peter LewisYeah. Like I'll I'll take a dot AU. I feel like it's a good identity. what y you go looking for the the prosaic, like Tabalu was really big for a while because it was dot T V. Like you're not patriotic
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewison your U URL.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. So so well w we are. thankfully Georgia, which is a a little country in the Caucasus, has two domain names, not just Georgia, but also Georgia South, which is. So the majority of our domains, with the exception of our generalstrategic.com, are actually.js, which worked out really, really well for us. So we we we like to keep it on brand. So most of our money goes over to South Georgia for w whatever they decide to spend it on.
RyanWell, we didn't go with dot com dot AU because we're moving to a single global system at Politico. And and and that's important because, you know, we really want Australians to be connected into those global conversations and we want to see our reporting as a bunch of connective tissue and and bridges. So we didn't want to just
Peter LewisMm.
Ryancreate a little Australia silo of talking to Australians.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
RyanAnd that that's
Peter Lewisbit
Ryanthe way the Guardian did it. We want to be like properly connected across the newsroom.
Peter LewisAnd and and particularly when you go deep into like you know, I spent Monday at the Tech Policy Design Institute talking about digital duty of care and the extent to which understanding what's happening in Australia is happening in other places, you you're totally right. And particularly for deep politics rather than the shy sideshow of politics, it it is really important to to to create some interconnective tissue.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. on that note, Mr. Lewis, we're I think we're reaching our kiss of death stage. Have
Peter LewisMm. Mmm.
Damian Damjanovskiyou got a kiss of death for the week ahead?
Peter LewisYeah, on Brandon on the discussion. So news media bargaining initiative is I think it was intro incentive, sorry, it was
Damian DamjanovskiIncentive, I think it is now. Yeah.
Peter Lewisintroduced I think this week or else next week. So my prediction around that is of because this is a very, very important piece of policy for an independent media that speaks the truth. My prediction is it will be heavily, heavily supported by all those media companies as the most important bit of pol public policy we are going to see this year. And we've seen this movie before. I was quite a a public supporter of the news media bargaining code, but my God, I've never had such a good run in the media as when I was coming out say the media should be given more money. There are some hairs on it as well that are worth watching and particularly maybe for you, Ryan, which is this the number of deals that need to be done for it to reach The the criteria. I think it's gone from six to eight, but there is a real concern that small media companies might be left in the shade. And there is also a bigger thing about how it's going to be forced, enforced anyway. So watch it, but probably watch it more deeply than just the headlines, because I think they will be overwhelmingly positive because we need an independent media. There you go.
Damian DamjanovskiVery good. Ryan, have you got a kiss to death for the week?
RyanThat the Department of Parliamentary Services is gonna realise actually it's so much better to give politico an office and we're gonna have our own space
Peter LewisThen have you winging.
Ryanby the end of the wing.
Damian Damjanovskiif you do get an office, I promise I'll be one of the first there with a cheese board branded politico for you guys to warm your house, so to speak. So I hope you're
RyanI I will bring the champagne and be a true champagne non socialist with you.
Damian DamjanovskiAmazing.
Peter Lewis'Cause you're not anymore.
Damian DamjanovskiMy kiss of death this week is a pet peeve, but one that I'm certain will actually happen. So as some of our listeners know, we w we're on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple Podcasts. on all of those platforms, as we're a young podcast, we promote our podcast to to expand our listenership and and make sure more people hear about us. Spotify and Apple Podcasts doesn't seem to have a problem. Every week, for some reason we're Without fail, YouTube either flags us as being shocking content or flags us as trying to sell political ads. Now, we went through the hoops of registering ourselves as a political entity because they believe that every time we say the words Anthony Albanese, Angus Taylor, whoever else, we're somehow endorsing these people and that we are, you know, a political advertiser, which any listener here will know we are not. But worst of all, the only way to appeal this process is through Google's absolutely terrifying dog shit garbage piece of AI customer support. I've talked about this on LinkedIn. I've tried to hit up the local MD of Google in Australia. I can't get through to anyone. Listeners, if you know someone who
Peter LewisIt's just so much.
Damian Damjanovskican help us out with the fact that YouTube seems to think that here we are selling propaganda when we are one of the few who are actually trying to do a political debate in a respectful way. please help us out, because my kiss of death is that yet again we are gonna get flagged as being something that we are
RyanYou and your human friction you're adding into the Google system, Dame. They by the way,
Peter LewisThey don't like it.
Ryanthey weren't able to tell the Senate inquiry this afternoon, or sorry, a parliamentary inquiry, how many accounts they've actually closed under the teen social media ban. It was a big hooha this afternoon. So there is there is a lot of not wanting to follow friction based processes in the company at the moment. That was my impression.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. So and you know, I'm I'm I'm usually a supporter of all things tech and digital, but the point at which you make it harder for us to actually buy your product, or give you money for that product, and you don't actually give a shit about helping anyone resolve it and you don't provide an escalation path for people to resolve it, then I'm happy to rally against you. So that's look, that's my kiss of death for the week. I'm I hope it doesn't come true.
Peter LewisWhat's the prediction that they'll actually listen to you or that it will still be it'll be groundhot it yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiNo, no, my my my prediction is that it will get banned yet again. Yeah. And and ironically, what happens with the ban is our our our you know promotion gets banned. So I then have to go through and repromote it and it repromotes. Fine. But then after four days, it just gets banned again. And then I have to just repromote it. So it's not like it's actually stopping us from promoting it. It's just providing this idiotic AI inconvenience for no reason other than no one at Google wants to fix the two pillars of their product, which is meant to be an advertising platform and now they're AI. It's literally the only two things Google actually makes money off. So if both of those products are dog shit and no one in the organization can even bother to send an email going, hey, so sorry, sometimes these things get caught up in the mechanism. Let's help you out, like what do you like why shouldn't we all rally for the fact that maybe you should pay tax on your revenue generated in Australia? And you should be held to a higher standard if you can't actually service your actual customers in this market. That's all I'm gonna say.
Peter LewisI've rarely seen you as passionate about anything, but that's a great way to end the show, don't we?
Damian DamjanovskiNo, ca 'cause you know what? It this is the shopping trolley thing, is like th there's a social contract here, which is if you're gonna exploit this market, fine, but serve your customers well. Your customer is not the viewer, your customer is the advertiser.
Peter LewisYeah. We want you to exploit us, Google. Let us let you exploit us. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiExploit me correctly. On that note, Ryan, thank you so much for joining us this week. Again, I apologize for the sunglasses. I realize it's a bit unorthodox. We are so excited to start reading the Canberra playbook here in Australia. I think it's going to be a great addition to the media landscape. We're excited to hopefully have you back on the show to talk about everything from AI to the gossip in the corridors of Canberra to how you're going to decorate your office when the Department of Parliamentary Services pulls their finger out and actually.
RyanIf it's the
Peter LewisI reckon it'll look w it'll look like
Ryanheritage office we won't be allowed to post it now and w
Peter Lewishis jumper. Watch out.
Damian DamjanovskiYou are welcome back on the show. Anytime you feel up for it, Ryan. Thank you again. Peter, as it is every week, deep pleasure to talk and disagree with you about all things politics, Australia. And it was it it was actually great to agree
Peter LewisIt was great boxing with you. I I did a lot of boxing actually.
Damian Damjanovskion the fact that we all love box wine. And I hope everyone starts carrying out a a little box of wine whenever they go out and about or just in the boot of their calf whenever they they feel like a drop. Thank you, everyone. look forward to seeing you again next week.
RyanThanks everyone.
Peter LewisAll right.
