Episode 20

The hangover - Sydney Swans anatomy of a crisis

With Elizabeth Lukin

23 August 20261 hr 9 min

Show notes

This week we sit down with Elizabeth Lukin, ex-AFL GM Corporate Affairs and Comms, who arrives with an alcohol-free drink and many good stories. We unpack the Sydney Swans scandal, how it's being handled, the culture of sports, the AFL, and the Swans.

Francis Leach also joins us as we get into male entitlement and misogyny in sport, how much of the pile-on is genuine accountability versus media sanctimony chasing clicks, the manosphere's grip on young athletes, and the partners who cop the social media fallout. We also ask what would real change at the AFL actually take, beyond just managing the headlines?

Chapters

  • 00:00 Introduction and Guest Introduction
  • 02:01 Career Journey and AFL Experience
  • 03:19 Scandal and Culture in Sports
  • 32:37 Male Entitlement and Misogyny in Sports
  • 34:20 The Impact of Sanctimony and Media Sensationalism
  • 37:07 The AFL Landscape and Public Perception
  • 48:00 Rebuilding and Brand Damage
  • 49:54 Media's Handling of Serious Issues
  • 50:35 Impact of the Attention Economy
  • 55:22 Influence of the Manosphere on Young Athletes
  • 58:07 Role of Masculinity in Sports Culture

Full transcript

Read itHide it

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.

Peter LewisWelcome to What's Your Poison, the show where people who disagree about just about everything agree it's best to do so over a drink. My name's Peter Lewis. I'm the principal of the progressive strategy shop Essential, and joining me as always is my evil twin, General Strategics, Dame Damdanowski. How are you, Darmay? And what's your poison for the week?

Damian Damjanovskivery good. And all the better for seeing you, Mr. Lewis. Another week down, thankfully. We are almost at the tail end of winter and about to get into a very, very rough El Nino season, or so the wonks at the Bureau of Meteorology tell us. So I'm already getting started with more of my fan favorite, the hard solo as I like to call it. what's your poison this week? And who is our interesting guest, Mr. Lewis? And of course, how has your week been as well? You're you're looking

Peter LewisWell, we will get to. Well, firstly, I'm

Damian Damjanovskivery incognito.

Peter LewisI'm dressed happy because it's been an awful, awful week. So this is what I wore to a Cuban night club party last Saturday night, which I think is my new look. Joyous celebration from my mate Aya Larkin of Skunk Hour Fame. I can't remember much about Sunday apart from watching the swans play terribly. And then on Monday it was like waking up to a particularly dystopian version of the hangover. As my team of 30 years has totally imploded. So I'm dressing happy but feeling very sad. And I just want things to go back a week. But I'm cracking Estella

ElizabethYeah.

Peter Lewisbecause I think we are all in a Stanley Kowowski moment and I look forward to letting it all out with you today in what might become a therapy session. But to help me is our guest this week, who is my professional big sister. The woman who dragged me from the junior leagues to the heights of EMC twenty-five years ago, I think. Liz and had a fantastic career, the first female head of corporate communications for the AFL, a woman who built her career on shouting sense into men with too much power. And a fantastic guest for us this week, Elizabeth Lucan. Welcome, Liz, and what's your poison?

ElizabethPeter and Damien, thank you for that fabulous welcome. And it is true I am his big sister, work sister, which I'm very proud of. Now my poison is 'cause I'm a woman of a certain age, I hate to tell you that it's an alcohol free, but haven't alcohol free beers got really good lately. So anyway.

Peter LewisYeah, I know it's it's been a good step forward in in humanity. So

ElizabethIt has. And I I I love wine. But the older I get, the less wine loves me. So I'm down to non alcoholic beer. And Pete, can I just say something else while I'm on age, right? Which is, you know, I'm a woman of a certain age, so I've been through menopause and I've had quite a lot of the symptoms. And now I feel like today is my first day of actually enjoying male menopause, which is going on a podcast. Because honestly,

Damian DamjanovskiI'm

Peter LewisHa ha ha.

Elizabethit is like we have a government. for women's pain, right? We need a government inquiry into male menopause because this this symptom kind of going on a podcast, having a podcast, being a podcaster, wow.

Peter LewisAs we learnt this week, it is probably th the safest place for men of a certain disposition to be. Before we go

ElizabethReally?

Damian DamjanovskiVintage.

Peter Lewisinto my trauma of the week, just share

ElizabethYeah, yeah.

Peter Lewiswith Dame a bit of your journey because it's it's fascinating. You you started your career working as a nurse, then you learned how to

ElizabethYeah. Yeah.

Peter Lewisshout sense into people with too much power. We ran essential for over a decade, and then you ended

ElizabethYeah. Yeah.

Peter Lewisup in the center of this.

ElizabethYeah.

Peter LewisAmazing organisation which is really part of so Australia's social infrastructure, the AFL.

ElizabethLook, I was one of those people who left school and went and did nursing straight out of school, so straight into a hospital in the Marta Hospital in 1980. And I like to say to people all these years later, I'm still cleaning up people's shit. I just get paid a lot more money for it. I did my nursing training and then I worked in unions in WA, came to Victoria, worked at the Nurses Union. then helped start Essential Media Communications. So I think I became the third owner in the year of the MUA dispute or in the lead up to the MUA dispute.

Peter LewisAnd kind of out all that Kennett disruption down there as well. We had all those unions. But then we also

ElizabethYeah, that's right. Yeah.

Peter Lewishad the AFL as a retainer early.

ElizabethWell, we did because somebody I knew, knew somebody quite high up at the AFL who said to my friend, know, we're doing our media really badly. I'd like to get the people who've done the MUA dispute. And my friend said, I know who that person is. Now, I actually grew up in Queensland. So I came from rugby league territory. So I... didn't know anything about the AFL, but yeah, we got that contract early on and that was under Wayne Jackson. So I've worked, you know, more than 20 years for three different CEOs, three different chairs. And I kind of was an ex-journal consultant for a long time. And so the AFL would also put me in or recommend me to clubs. So I went in and out doing kind of crisis management in 40. And Pete, you'll remember,

Peter LewisAnd how as far as crises go, what's this shitstorm? Where where do you reckon that fits? Without going too deep, just a top line.

ElizabethThis one. This one.

Peter LewisYeah.

ElizabethLook, I think because it's, we're going to talk about Just Footy now, the

Peter LewisMm. Mm.

Elizabethimpact on Just Footy, but I think five football players being wiped out on the eve of the final series is the biggest since Essendon where, you know, kind of half the team got wiped out by a water decision.

Peter LewisDo you know about that one, Darmay? They were they were pumping them up with horse steroids.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, right. And and sorry, y is that is that illegal? Is that against the rules? You can't give horse steroids under normal circum okay. So Liz, can can I can I back to basics just as an outsider? So

Elizabeththat would be alleged and that would be probably... It wasn't horse steroids, no. There was a drug scandal. You can go and kind of read about it. Yes, please. Yeah.

Peter LewisAlleged. There's gonna be lots of alleged today, by the way. Yeah.

Damian Damjanovskias many of our listeners know, and anyone who's met me for more than five minutes knows, is I'm not a sports guy. It's just never been my thing, right? I enjoy the tennis. Other than that, I'm not really

ElizabethYes. Yeah.

Damian Damjanovskiinto sports, but I can absolutely appreciate it. And love how institutional sports are to the Australian psyche and Australians in general.

ElizabethYeah, yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiHaving worked in politics, the the thing that always astounded me about politics is there's only two professions from what I can see in this world where the media is embedded as part of the profession, and

ElizabethYeah.

Damian Damjanovskithat is politics and sports. They're the only two professions where essentially the media has an all-access pass and While everyone else is out there trying to get their name in the newspaper, politics and sports are kind of the only two real reasons anyone picks up the newspaper, right? So you having done communications and crisis management for the AFL, I've got so many questions.

ElizabethYeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Damian Damjanovskibut just just your kind of thoughts and reflections on being in that role in a profession where basically you're having to keep Jonos at bay most of the time. Like that is a job where you you don't need a PR agency to manage that for you. You need you're there. You're at the forefront.

ElizabethLook, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Look, one of the big differences, well, talking about things on steroids, the media coverage of sport is so much bigger, is just, you know, it's just so much more intense and people really, really care. So I know the Canberra Press Gallery care about what politicians do. But does anybody else care? Not many other people.

Damian DamjanovskiThey they don't care about the politicians. They care about how it affects them. Like a punter

ElizabethThank

Damian Damjanovskicares about how the things politicians do affect them. But you're absolutely right. Sports is different. Sports people give their hearts to sports.

ElizabethNo, all sports are different. And, you know, so much we could unpack here, but I'll tell you something that Lindsay Tanner told me once. So he was the, you know, he's the finance minister during the GFC. So as, you know, global capitalism is shaking and they are facing into this terrible issue. And he was doing press conferences as the finance minister, right? Then he, when he retired from politics, he became the president of the Essendon Football Club. And he once said to me, like any press conference they held about anything, there would be just a sea of television cameras and so many journalists. And he said to me, nobody turned up this much when I was finance minister during the global financial crisis. So the interest is greater. The business is huge. The, you know, the kind of ownership by the public. is really big. But the other big thing about sport is that the media owns sport. the AFL has, we all know that kind of they, every four years, they, or five years, whatever, they have, whoever gets the broadcast rights. Now you tend to think about that as, they just sell the rights to the game. I think first job I did for AFL, as an external consultant was back in 2000 when they went from Channel 7 to Channel 9 and News Limited. So a long time ago. But what also gets, you know, it's more than just being entrenched and in the same house and having an all access pass. know, sport has got a responsibility to deliver for the people who are paying for that sport.

Damian DamjanovskiHm.

ElizabethAnd, you know, in more recent days, of course, we know who's paying for sport and that is the gambling agencies. You know, it's the media pays for sport. And so I was in the AFL during that fascinating period of time where they set up their own media outlet, AFL Media, it's been extremely successful. there's that added bit about, know, you are contractually, you have to deliver for the journo. So if you're a coach and you have a bad game, you don't get to say at the end of that game, I'm not talking to the fucking media, forget it. No, you sit there at the end of the game,

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Elizabethand you've got the sponsor's drink, you know, right there in front of you. And you've got to sit there and take all the questions from the journalists. So.

Damian DamjanovskiThat's the that's the Faustian bargain that they've kind of agreed to.

ElizabethYeah, yeah, yeah, which has got much voice, of course, under...

Peter LewisAnd it all works until it doesn't, doesn't it? And which sort of brings us I don't know if we want to go into this week. I feel like I want to get a few things off my chest as a fan because we always

ElizabethYes, we do.

Peter Lewistalk, no no, we always talk as professionals, but I feel like this is a rare occasion where I've got lived experience. Like I am I I literally wrote the book about being a Swans fan, The Convert of Fans Journey from League to AFL, which I wrote back in ninety eight.

ElizabethPete, before you go there, I

Peter LewisMm.

Elizabethjust want to tell Damien about what it's like listening to Talkback radio in Melbourne about the Swans, right? You

Damian DamjanovskiYes.

Peter LewisMm.

Elizabethmight say to me, Pete, and you are a lived experience true fan, you came from rugby league over to the Swans, but I've been listening to Talkback on one of the football stations down here, and these are the kinds of calls, Barbara, who's 92, rings up from her kitchen. and she's talking to Gerard Watley on SEN and she's saying, I have been a supporter and a member back to South Melbourne days, South Melbourne and then the Swans.

Peter LewisMm.

ElizabethAnd she was at the game and her sons are all S-ed and don't know how that happened, right? But her whole life, so the grief and trauma that you're feeling.

Peter LewisMm.

ElizabethI have listened to

Peter Lewisyeah, no, I'm not

Elizabethpeople crying on radio this week.

Peter LewisI'm with Barbara. So I'll take you through where I'm up to if you lie. Cause I feel like I've ended up where Barbara is, because I reckon Barbara's done with them. She brought me, you know, and full respect for staying this long. So, you know, it's been great being a Swans fan. Like so I I converted in ninety six. We made the grand final. I got to write a book about it. I've had a it's been a wonderful journey since, you know. you and I went to the two thousand and five grand final because you were working for the AFL and we got to watch Leaping Leo Barry take that

ElizabethYeah.

Peter Lewisamazing mark. I I watched them when in 2012 in a pub in Windsor drinking, you know, Guinness in the middle of the mor like very early in the morning. And but Sydney have always been the good guys and we had the no dickheads policy. When when they booed Adam Goods, we were the ones that said, no, you don't do that. to people and I think the AFL's done a remarkable job up here too. Like my both my kids played the game. My daughter still does at uni. and quite a few of the squad now are local kids, including some of the ones that have been suspended. and you know but I do think so this is what I reckon like this is just where I'm at at the moment. Totally and all those caveats alleged, alleged alleged and First thoughts are with the women who have been subject to alleged alleged. allege,

ElizabethWell, we don't. Yeah.

Peter Lewisallege, allege. However, I reckon there's been something going on for a few years. And I reckon there's been this thing where this whole Blood's strong core has been the l losing two grand finals in the last four years by 10 goals. It was something going on. And I don't know. no, seriously. Am I allowed to say this,

ElizabethOkay, I'm sorry to laugh.

Peter Lewisbut you know, and this season, right? This I just set this up because it let

ElizabethYeah.

Peter Lewisthe let me get this. So then, you know, this year particularly, we're coming second and we've smashed all the easy sides and then we've been found wanting from the good sides. And I'd actually been dreading another grand final where we get there and lose by 10 goals. I've just lost the faith. And and so this is what happened on Sunday ARVO. The Swans narrowly beat the wooden spooners at the MCG to celebrate players allegedly got on the piss, allegedly stayed out till all hours. A lot of this is not even alleged anymore, but I will allege away. Allegedly did drugs, allegedly hide strippers, allegedly something went horribly wrong. But regardless of what, did or did not go wrong legally or allegedly, it was still horribly wrong. And you know, I've I don't know. Like I just think this talks to something beyond the crisis. And I've been spending time with other Swans fans. The guys that are running the Reddit are really being sensitive and responsible volunteers. Like I've got a shout out to them. but you know there's just something else. And when Fran Francis is joining us later and he's probably got some things to say, but I don't know, like it it's almost like it's hard to accept that what happened was a black swan event. I've

Elizabethyou

Peter Lewisnever seen anyone get sprung on the first time they've transgressed. It just does not ring true. So I don't

Elizabethset.

Peter Lewisknow. Here we are. it's so damaging to the club. I can see why Janice is gone. I'm gone. I don't care about I I don't know. I feel like I'm done. And it's just been so

ElizabethNo, no, Pete, Pete, no,

Peter LewisSuch a big wake.

Elizabethno. Well, you can't be a proper fan if you're going to walk away from your club and this happens. And the second thing I'd say is...

Peter LewisNo, but the co it just shows there's something broken in that culture and they've been living

ElizabethNo, no, no, no, it shows. So I've done footy for over 20 years. I have done, okay, I'll give the caveat that we're all giving and all of the football commentators

Peter LewisAlleged.

Elizabethhave learned this very recently. No, not that caveat, this caveat, right? There is an alleged victim at the center of this and that victim has a right to their own process and care and all that kind of stuff, right? all got to say that. And I can't tell you how fascinating it is to listen to the football, because I've done this for 20 years and to listen to all these male commentators say this, like, they've always thought this, this is a relatively new thing, right? There's a woman here and we better put her at the centre of our, like that is totally new. So I have dealt with these issues across a range of clubs. And I don't know how bad this issue is, but I've dealt with some really bad ones. And what, so there's a couple of things that are new about this, about the handling of this. One is, clubs have generally done everything they can to keep the good players on the park, right? So they'll say there's a police investigation and we can't possibly, know, anything we do might, you know, kind of interrupt an investigation or future legal cases. So out of due process and blah, blah. Swans could have done a whole lot of things to keep those players on the park. They could have. And a lot of clubs have done that in the past. So, so that is interesting to me. The other thing that's interesting to me though is the hysteria about this. Like as if blokes like...

Peter LewisBut two week like two weeks out from the finals, you're going out like it is no, that

ElizabethYeah, yeah, it's really stupid. It's real. Yep. Yep.

Peter Lewisis like everyone invests so much time and emotion into a team and that's the end product. That is a breakdown of culture. That is and I still reckon they're trying to quarterise it. I did not think Cox and

Elizabethyeah, it's a big... Yeah. No. No, don't. It's...

Peter LewisMills were convincing today at all.

ElizabethWell, there's a couple of things to say about kind of culture, right?

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

ElizabethAll of these young men, all of them grow up, you know, kind of... I just don't know how... It's going to sound like I'm defending them and I'm not defending them. What I'm interested in is the outrage about this issue. And here are the words that the footy commentators are using. Grubby. You know, people are a bit disgusted by this because of the reality of their golden boys have used strippers at three o'clock in the morning. I'm going to not talk about what might have happened there, right? Because we don't know what happened, but we do know that, that, you know, there's a few things there. And I just feel like, like, have people not been watching what's going on with, with kind of, you know,

Peter LewisI know and I'm interested

Elizabethmale violence against women, wait a minute, male violence against women, the sense of entitlement that men have. I'm not saying, you know, and of course, hashtag not all men, but holy hell, fellas. You know, it's like, do we, so I'm not saying swans people shouldn't be broken hearted. Okay. And, but can I just talk about the comms on this Pete, before I get into a feminist rant? Cause that might take us all down. The comms on this huge story Monday morning. there's like seven police officers at a hotel in Melbourne. It totally dominates, you know, the kind of the new cycle in Melbourne, like totally dominates. And then I kind of watch what must be quite difficult, right? Because nobody knows what's happened and still there's been no charges and the police are expected to investigate. So it is complex. So there are some people who want to race out and say, Swans did a terrible job. AFL hasn't come out, blah, blah, blah. These are actually complex with a whole lot of legal things at the heart of them. So.

Peter LewisBut to be honest, I don't think th the way you manage this issue has it it's the issue, not the issue management that's the issue. Sorry, that sounds ridiculous, but you know what I mean.

ElizabethNo, no, no, I know, I know, I I know. But OK, so can I speak in defense of the Swans? They send their CEO out on the front on the first day and then the next day they do well on by Wednesday they do something that I think did actually everybody goes, of course they needed to do that. Of course they should. Of course they should. But I actually think it's really remarkable what the Swans have done. They said we're torpedoing.

Peter LewisThat's 'cause they know how bad it is. Like they I I don't maybe they don't either I I just think this is you how long has it taken for Essendon to get back to being credible wooden spooners? Like a decade. Like I think this is cataclysmic for the club.

Elizabethno, no, no, I don't think so because your team and your club have kind of put a really big, like there's a whole lot of people at Essenton who still deny what happened, still deny what happened. Whereas your club is not a club.

Peter LewisAgain, I'd find it very hard to believe this is the only time this shit's gone down. Anyway, what do you how do you see from the cheap seats, Damon? Sorry, I'm being

Damian DamjanovskiSo I I'm just gonna ask a c I I well, look as an outsider I'm gonna ask a couple of questions 'cause so I thought that the AFL had like a three strikes in your out rule with drugs.

ElizabethThank

Damian DamjanovskiIs that not

Elizabethis that's illicit drugs. Like the AFL, like every other sport, Damien, is covered by ASADA, the rules of performance enhancing drugs and WADA, the World Anti-Doping Authority. Now, the AFL's three strike policy is really about, we're not allowed to use this term, but about party drugs. So, you know, they do a regime of testing that they've agreed with the players union. So they're actually quite forward thinking in this. very hard to convince anybody but they do a regime of testing way above water, soda and water.

Damian DamjanovskiRight.

ElizabethSo keep those two things separately. You know, the other difference about politics, Damien, if we can just talk about that right,

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, yeah.

Elizabethis a lot of politicians can kind of live within the political bubble. And when you go into sport, you realise how, you know, the Swans have to put a team on the field on Sunday. They will have thousands of their fans there, cheering or booing. their women's team is playing beforehand. you kind of get every week, you get this kind of reminder, we should get a reminder about who you're there for and why you're there. And the interaction with the public is so much more constant than politics, right? So much more constant.

Damian DamjanovskiSo so so so just just going back to the drugs. So

ElizabethYeah.

Damian Damjanovskiparty drugs are not acceptable or are acceptable or slightly acceptable?

ElizabethI'd have to go and look at the rule books that I used to know, right, but cocaine and speed, no. No, no,

Peter LewisIsn't it a bit of a sh like don't ask? Because there's some that get out of your body really quickly before they can be tested that

ElizabethOn game day, please, if you've got any of your listeners or watchers, they'll correct us, don't worry. But on game day, cocaine speed is a performance enhancing drug. They do say that

Peter LewisBut after the game.

Elizabeththe reason why lot of sports people take cocaine is because it gets out of the system, it doesn't put on weight.

Damian DamjanovskiQuickly and yeah. Right. So it's so it's like slightly permissive as long as it's not on game day.

ElizabethWell, it's also legal, isn't it? Is it illegal? Yeah, yeah, sorry. I didn't mean it.

Damian DamjanovskiWell, i it is, but that the I guess that's what I'm asking is 'cause when I was I was trying to do some research beforehand and there was a my understanding

ElizabethYeah, yeah.

Damian Damjanovskiis that there was a three strikes rule up until recently, which was basically the sport deciding that it's okay for you to take illegal drugs twice. The third time though the third time then you're in

ElizabethYeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. No, no, no, no, no. No, it's no, no, no. That would be a whole other podcast, That would be a whole other podcast.

Damian Damjanovskitrouble. So I I I guess the other thing is to kind of like and obviously we're gonna say allegedly because An a an an a an allegation is not the same thing as an indictment. Like every Australian, you know, these players are entitled to, you know, a fair investigation, a fair hearing. We weren't there, we don't know what happened. The process should play out as it's meant to play out, which is

ElizabethYeah. Yeah.

Damian Damjanovskiby professional investigators and the judicial system, not by punters and definitely not by the media. So before we we color everyone, anyone with any kind of allegation.

ElizabethYeah, yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiBut the media attention on this has been, like, from a outside observer, just insane, like absolutely nuts level of attention on this. Is that part of the deal that these guys make when they take up these

ElizabethYeah.

Damian Damjanovskisports? Is it basically saying, hey, we we get you a twenty to thirty-year-old kid who can kick the ball really far? we're gonna pay you stupid amounts of money to kick the ball. but

ElizabethYeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

Damian Damjanovskion the flip side. You don't get to do any of these things because if you do, we're never gonna stop to like is that just is that that's the deal they make and they need to be aware of it? And if so, how do these institutions like the clubs and the sport more generally, how are they setting these kids up for success? Because I would be thinking, if I've got all these kids who win, lose or draw are all together and we've taken them to a different city on a camp, Wh where's the I don't want to adult supervision, but where's the people to make sure that they're blowing off steam in the right ways, that they're not going off the rails? Like, if that were my team, that would be my biggest concern being like these guys are pumped up with either the the high of a victory or the sorrow of a loss after a game or before a game. You know, they need a bit of they need a bit of tending to. Where where is all that in this sport?

ElizabethSo there's two things I'll say. One, I do want to talk about the deep. Did you say the Faustian pact? Let's talk about that. But the other thing I'd say is, and I've sat in rooms with football people, men, very senior levels of the game, when I've had to listen to this idea, when it's been really serious, you know, serious issues around sexual assault or sexual harassment. And I've had to correct a lot of men. in the time that I've been involved in football, which is, and I can hear a little bit of this in the current commentary, right? Which is like, what do you think was gonna happen at three o'clock in the morning after all this drinking and all this drug taking? And I've had to say to people in footy, know, I've got a lot of men in my life, including four brothers and the men that I have worked with and nowhere on the continuum of one beer to a hundred beers. would they suddenly fall off and start sexually harassing somebody or sexually assaulting someone? So I can't tell you how many times I've had to say that, like, in football, at clubs. And, you know, they're kind of all kind of shocked at me, which is just like, stop with, you know, they had a few drinks and they're boys being boys and they had a whole lot of big feelings. Yeah, it's like, fuck, you don't go and sexually assault somebody because you've had a few drinks. None of the men in my life would do that. So I, you know, I have... ranted and raved about that in football. Now, the second thing I'll say though, is this issue about, I wanna get to culture, but this issue about the Faustian bargain, because we just need to recognize what's really changed in the last maybe, you know, 10 years. And I know this is close to Peter Lewis's heart, which is about, you know, the kind of social media. But a lot of these players now... You know, they have their own channels and they all have their own agents. That's, know, the

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Elizabethkind of agents have been around. So you've got the players association, you've got agents and then you've got the clubs. Who you've also got now is not just agents, but people who kind of monetize brand agents, right? Yeah, yeah. And

Peter LewisBut like brand agents just selling them out into influence the community. Yeah.

ElizabethPete and I had a quick discussion about this, which is we can both remember giving advice to kind of political. or union people over many, many years ago. It's going to sound really old fashioned, is, okay, you want to do a picture of yourself and your wife and your kids to get elected? Don't come running to us when the media want to do a story about your wife and your kids that you don't want, right? If

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Elizabethyou want to put your family out there, then it's on show. You can't pull it back, right? Once you let the family into you, once you let the media into your family, don't ask them to walk out the door and something.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, they're the the the conscripts as they used to say, right? They you're the volunteer, they're conscripted in.

ElizabethYeah, now I think a lot of these players, live their life online with their brand and reputation. they are so, think they, when that's good, it's really, really good. And when it's bad, it's just dreadful. Everything about their life that goes wrong is done in the glare of the kind of... the media that they've invited in. So they're not conscripts here. A lot of these people making money out of their own branch. Yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiBut but

Peter LewisBut also the partners as well tend to have their own little micro businesses as well, don't they?

Damian DamjanovskiThis is the the wags, is that right? Is this the wags as they're referred to? The wives and girlfriends? Is that is wag a bad term, wives and girlfriends? Is that not the

Peter LewisLet's call them partners on this pocket. Yeah.

ElizabethYeah, let's call them partners. let's call them Wives and girlfriends. look,

Damian Damjanovskibut

Elizabethit's a bad term, Damar, because, you know, we can't look at these things as this incident or this incident or this incident. All male sporting environments have got a history, a long history of kind of being a, a hotbed of kind of male entitlement and misogyny. Hashtag not all clubs, hashtag not all men, right? But that notion that we pump them up to be, you know, like we pump them up, we celebrate them and that male bonding, you know, really important to the team, the team, the culture, the culture. Why in the fuck are we surprised that that all-male culture hardly can get to this?

Damian DamjanovskiAgain, just gonna point out that I think with the exception of maybe Kyrios, tennis does not suffer from these slings and arrows. So again, a good reason why it is the best sport.

ElizabethHere it is.

Peter LewisCan I just reinforce that? I my daughter's in a AFL chat group and that sh I said, What's your group been saying? And she just sent me one that is, but I sorta don't look at them as any sort of role model beyond being good at their sport. I'm just never really convinced that a man who is hanging out with only men twenty four seven in a sport specific space is gonna be all that decent. Like

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

ElizabethYeah, yeah. So your daughter is less surprised than you,

Peter LewisSo totally unsurprised.

ElizabethPeter.

Peter LewisThat is interesting, is it? Like I feel like

ElizabethYeah.

Peter LewisI'm being harder on them than you are, but I feel like I've invested more energy. And I don't know if it's about I feel a self-

ElizabethNo, no, no, I think there is something.

Peter LewisI feel a real sense of betrayal of and and and I feel like

ElizabethDo you know what? Yeah, I know.

Peter LewisI've been taken for a ride with the Sydney culture bullshit for about the last decade. But can we also like before we get there,

Elizabethlet's get to culture and women. Yeah.

Peter LewisI'm interested in how Melbourne because I feel like Sydney's always been seen as putting themselves up on this pedestal. Is that part of what's happening as well, do you reckon, out of Melbourne in this context, or is it all part of the one thing?

ElizabethYou mean it's kind of finally the swans have done something that drags them back to all of us? you mean a bit of that?

Damian DamjanovskiSo sorry, how is

Peter LewisOr just

Damian Damjanovskihow are the swans viewed in the in the AFL landscape? All I know is that everyone everyone hates the magpies for some reason. Everyone thinks San Kilda are losers,

ElizabethOkay, yes, yes, here's something to say about the swans. Yeah, if you thought.

Peter LewisYeah, that's a better question. That's a better question. They used to, they used to. We can talk about that later.

ElizabethNo, the

Damian Damjanovskiand everyone thinks the swans are.

Peter LewisGolden shot.

Elizabethmost important thing to know about the Swans is they are probably Australia's biggest sporting brand by numbers, right? And I don't mean number of members, because really they can only sign the number of members to get a seat. Haven't got a stadium big enough.

Peter LewisThey they haven't got a stadium big enough for all the fans, yeah.

ElizabethBut if you actually go and do a poll that says, who's your team? The swans would have more people lining up with them, and it's because they're in Sydney. you know, so they, I think there's a right.

Peter LewisYou know the origin story, don't you, Darmay? They were originally a South Melbourne club and they got transported to Sydney and they were loveless for decades and then they

ElizabethYeah, yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, Sid Sydney wanted a club or something, so they basically bought South Melbourne who didn't have any money and were losers.

Elizabethon, yeah, Sydney didn't, yeah, Sydney didn't want a club. The AFL

Peter LewisDidn't want to tame by any

Elizabethhad a growth strategy that's been, well, the biggest, you know, the biggest, successful club in growth strategy is the Sydney Swans. And let's talk about their brand because they have had this brand, is like, you know, the no dickhead policy. And that just morphed, yeah,

Peter LewisThe bloods.

Elizabeththat just morphed into a kind of like, they're kind of being the good. guys of the AFL, their brand has been really very welcoming to women, very important around their relationship with Indigenous Australia, kind of cultural leadership. They've just never had a dickhead coach who I could name a whole lot of dickhead coaches, they just had this really beautiful brand.

Peter LewisAnd they always played above themselves because there was that sense they were more than the sum of their parts or whatever that cliche is. That's how I felt.

ElizabethThat's so romantic, Pete. No, they played above themselves because they had, you know, the AFL made sure that was successful.

Peter LewisThat the the blood's That too.

Damian DamjanovskiSo I assume g given given the d the general kind of Sydney Melbourne relationship, I assume most of Melbourne thinks that the Swans are like too good for the rest of the league, think they're too good for the rest of the league. And meanwhile the Swans doesn't really think about any of the Melbourne teams.

ElizabethNow it is.

Peter LewisThat's the normal Sydney Melbourne. Although the other bit is, most of the media in Sydney also want the Swans to fail 'cause it's an NRL town. And so the NRL particularly so they're being dumped on. Like it's the perfect storm, isn't it, Liz? Like League always

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

ElizabethYeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Peter Lewiswants to go AFL, Melbourne always wants to go Sydney. and if there wasn't something real at the center,

ElizabethLook, always say it.

Peter Lewisyou'd say, This is totally unfair, but it's not.

ElizabethYeah. Look, the Sydney Swans, if you could talk about this from a footy fan's point of view, fans don't hate the Sydney Swans. Kind of, it would almost be everybody's second team. know, there are people in Melbourne who would support the Sydney Swans rather than Collingwood at a grand final between Sydney Swans and the Magpies, right? So the

Damian DamjanovskiYeah. That's the magpies. Yep, got it.

Elizabethhatreds amongst the fan groups in the teams in Melbourne, Carlton hates Essendon, Essendon hates, you know, like,

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

ElizabethJalong hate Hawthorne, Hawthorne hate Jalong. you know, people don't, if it was kind of, if the Sydney Swans were playing the Melbourne team, most of Melbourne would go for the Sydney Swans rather than the Melbourne team. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Cause they haven't, you know what? They haven't offended anybody. That's the other

Damian DamjanovskiRight. Even though the swans might be a bit of a the way you color it well, I would call it a a woke team based on how you colored it, but l it's a Yeah.

Elizabeththing though. They're very

Peter LewisThat's

Elizabethwhite bread peep. And this is the other thing it's going like those.

Peter Lewisyeah. It's the whitest game. AFL is the whitest game in Sydney. Like all the white kids and like yeah. We always used to joke about that.

ElizabethYeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Correct.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, I don't know any of my like Islander or Western Sydney friends who could name a single team in the AFL.

ElizabethNo, they're rugby league supporters.

Peter LewisYeah, yeah, yeah. So we were gonna

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter Lewiswe're gonna ask Dame about the the view of the AFL from the Liberal side as well, 'cause that notion that Sydney's woke but the AFL's woke and I don't know how that plays into all of this as well.

Damian DamjanovskiI I'm not trying to understand the question, sorry, Peter.

Peter LewisI don't know, it was just a talking point more than anything.

ElizabethPolitics.

Damian Damjanovskisorry.

Peter LewisWe can cut that out. You're about to s cut that bit out. You go, Liz. You're about to say something intelligent.

ElizabethLook, was going to say, Pete, I love your shock and horror about this. Part of that is being a fan. So I love all that. But I also think.

Peter LewisShould get off Reddit.

Elizabethyou should get off of it. When I say I'm not shocked,

Damian DamjanovskiHa.

ElizabethI think what I'm saying is if we behave like the men who do these things are complete absolute monsters, which is what the whole white ribbon thing was about, So like, yeah, if we need, yeah. Right, just.

Peter LewisYeah, but that's not where I am. Like I I I don't wanna yeah. And I'm not casting moral well, I'm not it's not it's not a moral outrage. It is like a sense of no, no, no, it's not. It's it's

ElizabethYes.

Peter Lewisa sense of betrayal of culture after investing so much time that the culture allow I I think this is bigger. And you know again, I wait I'll wait for Francis for the other bit, but I I do think there's stuff going on that

ElizabethYeah.

Peter Lewisthat the club should be more responsible for that they haven't been. That's all I'll say.

Damian DamjanovskiSo so Peter, in your view, is this the sorry,

ElizabethYeah.

Damian DamjanovskiI beg your pardon, this?

ElizabethWell, I was going to say, I've been into clubs where they're explaining something going on, you know, and we have a media response to that. And the much harder question to these organizations, not just for, not just clubs, you know, I've done issues in crisis management with lots of different organizations. And the question for the board, you know, is kind of like, how assured, because we know the crisis management playbook, Behaviorally outraged. call a review, leave no stone unturned, sack whoever needs to be sacked, cross the bridge, yeah, blah,

Peter LewisIf it's really bad, make it an independent review.

ElizabethBut to actually say to a board, how can you be assured this won't happen again? What is the decision making that led to this occurring? And, yeah.

Peter LewisBut before you get there, you've got to say, how do you know that this is not a more general cultural issue? Cause I just think I think part of cauterizing the wound has been avoiding that bigger question that they couldn't respond to today.

Damian DamjanovskiWhat was the question that is like

Peter LewisHas this ever happened before? Are you aware of anything like this ever happening before? They cannot answer that question because they'd have to lie.

ElizabethWell, look, other thing I found fascinating, yeah. Well, and also most of these footy commentators, male footy commentators, who kind of came through the 70s

Peter LewisUp to the neck in it.

Elizabethand 80s, it's like, right, fellas, which one of you have been to strip clubs and used sex workers and blah, blah? You wouldn't want to turn over that rock. Now, that's leaving totally aside what might've happened.

Peter LewisAnd this is a first joining us t halfway through the show. a special correspondent and a friend of what's your poison, Mr. Francis Leach. We invited Frank in because he's been talking about this issue in between his overnight shifts on ABC Radio and also his work with the St Kilda Footy Club. So Francis, we were we were just talking about before you came on, whether the sanctimony of the Sydney Swans is a contributing factor. to the reaction in Melbourne. Interested in your thoughts on that.

Francis LeachI don't know about that. I I think that that it's been a let's be honest, I think it's been a while since the media cycle has been able to f and I'll be recruited about it, feast on the drama and the sordidness of a story like this within AFL football and the frenzy reflects that we live in an age of spectacle and and a demand for you know detail and for every every element of the story is open and fair game in a media cycle that's just hungry for more content. and I think that it's got less to do with the Sydney Swans and more to do with our media culture and the unhealthy lack of perspective when it comes to covering Australian rules football, in Melbourne in particular, which is a city that loses all perspective on the game. it's placing the culture and the society and that's reflected in the response to this story.

Peter LewisMm.

ElizabethDo you think the media's overplayed the seriousness of this, Frank?

Francis LeachNot at all. I think the seriousness of the actual issue is significant. And but but I think the way that the media handles the details and the importance of due process and the importance of looking after the the the women who have been affected by what occurred in that hotel, all of those things have been thrown out the window

Damian DamjanovskiAllegedly.

Francis Leachin pursu in pursuit of in pursuit of a story, in pursuit of the of the next rumor being published and the next conversation being had and the next hot take that's going to come on a radio show and the next moment of outrage that's going to be go viral on the internet.

Peter LewisIt's just the attention economy.

Francis LeachYeah. It is the attention economy in overdrive at the expense of a a perspective on the impact of an event like this and what impact it might have both on the on everyone involved but more particularly to those who are alleged to have been victims in what occurred.

Damian DamjanovskiSo I mean, d do you think the the swans are held to a different standard to other clubs? Or or is what you're saying, Frank, that basically there's basically both the media and the punters at this point just kind of are happy for any kind of outrage and pound of flesh because that's what that's the machine we've built, right? It feeds on that stuff. We had Ed Coper

Francis LeachYeah.

Damian Damjanovskion the on the show a few weeks ago talking about angertainment and the idea that we now feed off this anger because it feeds the algorithm.

Peter LewisYeah. The difference being I think this is genuine and righteous anger. So the two things are going on at the same time.

Damian DamjanovskiSure, sure. But to to Frank's point, and and again, I I I keep saying allegedly because

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskione, we don't want to get sued as a as a little podcast. B, surely like everyone, these boys and the alleged victims deserve due process, right? So it's not for us or the media to judge what happened, it's for, you know, police, investigators, everyone else to make that determination. So

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskiare we just is that all feeding the anger in the meantime?

Francis LeachI also think yeah, I th I think also the other element to this which isn't spoken about enough is that the media environment in which this is predominantly spoken about is populated solely by middle aged white men who've lived and worked in a hyper masculine environment for their entire lives, have no points of reference

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Francis Leachwhen it comes to power dynamics or the context of the relationships with women, have barely ever worked with women in a in a in a collaborative sense, might have had women working for them or alongside them, but never in an equal and opposite relationship, very rarely, have many of them never worked outside the football realm in and of itself. So they've got no cultural reference points. they've lived in a shelter workshop of leather poisoning and and and and school boards and and injury reports and they've got no tools with which to deal with this conversation in a way that actually gives it the j the i the import it deserves. And moves the conversation on to take responsibility for what it actually says. And that is that still in this country, every week two women are dying at the hands of their intimate partners, mostly men, and we don't see that as a national emergency. And we don't connect that the behaviors of men in circumstances of their own choosing leads to attitudes towards women which

Damian DamjanovskiSo

Francis Leachgive permission to for for this sort of violence to occur. Nobody in the football media has had the stones to come out and say Can we just talk about us for a minute? And I'm talking about all you guys? This is us. This has always been us. Why aren't we talking about it? Why aren't we talking about it? Because,

Damian DamjanovskiSo

Francis Leachyou know, a and and that that that's what really drives me crazy. Is that there's after after all of these years, and I worked in it, and I don't know what that hypermasculine environment is like. And I know that and I I I can say any environment that doesn't include strong, powerful intelligent women in terms of, you know, working alongside them is a is an environment, a working environment that's running at less than half power. They are doing themselves a disservice as a game and and and and as a consequence they can't deal with it.

Damian DamjanovskiSo c can can I ask on something you mentioned in there, Frank?

Peter LewisMm.

Francis LeachYeah.

Damian DamjanovskiSorry, can I just ask something you mentioned there? do the people who manage

Francis LeachYeah. So I'll turn off this buddy.

Damian Damjanovskithese clubs, the CEOs, the trainers, so all of them have kind of been through like have they all previously been players? Is that what's happening? Is this a closed system or

Francis LeachI think in the media environment it most definitely is. And it always has been. It's very,

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, okay.

Francis Leachvery difficult for for outsiders, even male outsiders to have any real currency within that environment. they are the they are the outliers and it's twice, five times as hard for women to to do so, to have equal and and o opportunity and voice in that environment. it's changed a little bit, there's no doubt about it. I mean the AFLW's been the driver of that and we're seeing some some some progress in that regard, but we're still a million miles off what we need to be. And Liz has worked within the AFL system too. And she knows that the the prospect, if you want to sort of zoom out and say, the prospect of there ever being a female CEO of the AFL in our lifetime is like the idea that a unicorn's going to fly to the moon. Because the boys are never going to give up the power. And that it's the same power dynamic all the way through. It's it's as plain as that.

Damian DamjanovskiSo so how do you break that how do you break that cycle, Frank?

Francis LeachBy having conversations like this. By by put you know, by them

Peter LewisCan I

Francis Leachbeing go ahead, Pete.

Peter Lewisso the the other bit that I want to throw in, Frank, and I'm really interested in your thoughts as somebody who is now working within one of the clubs on match day is It's kind been an open secret amongst Swans fans that some of these players have really embraced the manosphere. one of them's got the nickname MAGA amongst some of the fans. And I feel a little bit like we've been seeing this come out in plain sight without actually calling it. I do think it's part of the conversation. So, you know, I know you spoke earlier this week about that sort of that the culture of the these young boys are consuming, but what's your take on that?

Francis LeachWell, it's become such a predominant force in our wider culture. we can't be surprised that it's bled into other f other spheres and other sectors that inevitably it was gonna manifest itself in in professional sport, professional male sport, which remains a hyper masculine environment where models of masculinity are, you know, are the are the the norm and have are are the are where young men assert themselves. It was always gonna happen that somebody or there will be people within like the s wider society who believe that that sort of Andrew Tate model of masculinity is the way that you should behave. and it's not I'm sure it's not just the Civil Swines. I'm sure, you took a sample of young men across all sectors. they're they're in all walks of life. They they'll be walking down Collin Street and in in a domain today in their suits as bankers and they'll be working on work sites, you know, in Brisbane and Perth and everywhere else today as well. It it's

ElizabethYeah.

Francis Leachjust it's so predominant in the culture.

ElizabethDo you mind if I just say something here? This has been on my mind, Frances, since I watched the Louis Thoreau documentary on the Manosphere, because one of my nieces wanted to watch it and she didn't want to watch it on her own. I feel like what I didn't know about the Manosphere, I mean, kind of, know, the misogyny, all of that, I knew about all of that, right? But to me, the business model, of the Manosphere, which is actually the finance bros taking control of your life. Don't let the man tell you what to do. You can use my app and buy and sell these shares and stocks. It gave me some sense that it's not just hatred of women or dominating women. is a kind of, maybe it's just the old Marxist in me trying to find the kind of, that it was really about money. and finance. And so one of the things that worries me, I think about the manosphere and where sport might meet is kind of sports gambling, right?

Peter LewisMm.

ElizabethAnd, you know, so many young men in our lives have their, you know, the sports apps on the phone. And this idea that, because I think some of those kind of the new, finance channels and finance apps are the same thing. You don't have to do what the man tells you to do. Don't put your money in super, they're all a bunch of old boring people. Like you can take control of your life. if you do

Peter LewisMm.

Elizabethwhat I tell you to do. And so I just feel like, you that kind of, you and I have been through the time in sport where we just have been the tsunami of that super masculinist framing of sports gambling. know, the voices on sports bet and Neds and all of that kind of stuff. It feels like it's connected to, you know, feels connected to me.

Francis LeachYeah, it's like a twenty first inch door.

Damian DamjanovskiBut sorry, just to just to clarify sorry, sorry, sorry, just to clarify that there is nothing inherently wrong with masculinity or even supermasculinity. There is something wrong when people sexually abuse someone or take illicit like take substance as legal. There is nothing inherently bad about being masculine or super masculine, whatever that is. There is something wrong when you impinge upon the rights of others. So I don't think painting

Peter LewisHence how you define it.

Damian Damjanovskimasculinity as some kind of Bad thing is necessarily a fair thing to do, and then to lump in, well, gambling because it's masculine is also by proxy bad. Like I think

ElizabethNo, no.

Damian Damjanovskiyou're conflating a lot of different things there to get to

Elizabethin.

Damian Damjanovskia conclusion that's quite suitable in this instance. But in reality, these five guys grew up in an environment where multiple senior people basically created a permissible. behavioral trait that it is okay to sometimes do drugs and sometimes let off steam by partying with your mates without drawing boundaries to go, hey, you are always on, you are your own personal brand, you have sponsorships, you are a model citizen, under no circumstances should you do the kind of things that put that at threat, because otherwise you will be taken down by the media, by commentators like these guys, you will lose all this kind of stuff. Not to mention pursued by the criminal justice system. Like they are different things, just pointing that out.

Peter LewisThat is a fantastic analysis of non woke self interest to lead to the exact point where woke has not been able to get people actually. I I think that was very interesting, darling.

ElizabethExcept what I'd say to that Damian is. If you say there's something wrong with masculinity, I'm not saying it means there's something wrong with men. Masculinity is a construct and I feel like the choices around how boys and men grow up, that's what I mean by masculinity, right? So when I say masculinity

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, absolutely.

Elizabethand hyper masculinity, I'm not saying all men, but if we treat these men, or these boys or these sexual harassers or these men who murdered their intimate partners. If we treat them as monsters, we will never come to terms with, you know, I'm not somebody who thinks all men do these things, but I, yeah. No, no, no, no, this is a really good discussion,

Damian DamjanovskiYeah yeah. I'm not and I'm not I'm not meaning paint you that way, Liz, by the way, sorry.

Peter LewisBut I don't think we're sa we're saying idiots, aren't we?

Elizabethright? It's a really good discussion.

Damian DamjanovskiIt it's it's to to me it's it's that thing of the the and and I and again I'm not accusing anyone on this podcast, by the way, but the increasing meta picture we're painting is that to be masculine is to be entirely aggressive without care for anyone else. To be feminine is to be entirely submissive without care for anything else. So therefore we should all coalesce to some amorphous blob in the middle. Where it's like actually some people want to be masculine and they can be deeply

Francis LeachNo, I I just I Yeah.

Damian Damjanovskirespectful of women as well. That's part of masculinity. They they're di it's a different thing to

Francis LeachYeah. Damien I

Damian Damjanovskibe

Francis Leachyeah. I d I disagree. I don't think we're saying it's binary vision of what masculinity is. I I when I talk about hypermasculinity, I talk about it in in a sense that where masculinity is defined as as as the gold standard of the human experience and everything beyond that is is making up numbers. And if you do work in a hyper masculine environment where it's only men, And it literally is only men that you have you have to negotiate power with, you have to negotiate and deal with problems with, you have to do work relationships with, and you have no concept of of a different way of behaving that isn't that hy that really aggressive masculine culture. You're you're having a an a a a a life I feel that's being nowhere as near as rich as it could be, but you're not learning about

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Francis Leachhow to deal with it with a bigger and wider world. And the the form of masculinity that that is more powerful is one the masculinity that listens to to that perspective of women and understands, for instance, things like when you walk down the street at nighttime, you don't just walk up behind a woman, even if even if you're, you know, in in innocently, you know, five metres behind her, because you you're not thinking about your impact on her feeling like she she she might be in danger. It's that that masculinity of understanding that you move in the the space that you move in isn't just yours, it's others. It's a masculinity that doesn't sit on a tram and spread its legs and and do the manspread because he feels like it and doesn't think about the consequences for others around them.

Elizabethyou

Francis LeachIt's a masculinity that understands that you have a a a power relationship in the world that is greater than ninety-nine percent of the women who also populate it just by the the mere fact that you're a man. And you can h be masculine and you know, I I I'm as masculine as the next guy. I like boxing. You know, I've I've gotten a ring of fort and put a mouth guard in. I can fight like anybody. But I still under I still think I understand that my relationship with the wider world and and with women and and the need for for me to make women feel safe and respected is something that I need to work on because I was not brought up and we have not been brought up to understand about our impact on the way they move through the world.

Peter LewisAnd question for you, Frank, do you do you feel that work is going on inside the AFL club you're working in?

Francis LeachI think so, but you never know. And I think the the feeling we're speaking to people I was at the game last night is that i there's still an understanding there for b but for the grace of God go go all of us. Because th those environments remain you know, overwhelmingly hyper masculine, as much as you try to change them and you do your best to to make sure that those young men coming through understand their responsibility and to give them the wider perspective. But no one I I don't think anyone's under any illusion that it couldn't happen at other other clubs. you know, just because th they're wearing a re red and white jumper that that's the reason why they behave the way they did. They're fools if they do it.

ElizabethFrancis.

Peter LewisHey, we're coming we're coming up to Kiss of Death, but Liz, I did wanna ask you

ElizabethI've got a question for Francis, right? Peter is ...

Peter LewisCut that out then. She's my big sister. She tells me where to go. Start again with a clear bit of air. One, two, three. Go.

ElizabethPeter is absolutely heartbroken, Frances, about what has happened to his team.

Francis LeachYeah. Sure it is.

ElizabethAnd he's even talked before you got on that this is the end for him. He's given 30 years of his life, he's invested so much, he's heartbroken. Now, as someone who's a St Kilda supporter, can you give him the lecture about how to stay committed to your club through the ups and downs, even when they break your heart in this way?

Francis LeachYeah, because the club yeah. Yeah, because the club doesn't belong

ElizabethGood.

Francis Leachto the players that are moving through it right now, even the ones that you love and even the ones that behave badly. and it's your club and it's your tribe and they will come and go and you will still be there. So and they don't represent all of the history of the club and all of the great things that football club has done. And I've had experience with the Sydney Swans as a football club and I've always admired them enormously. So this is this is a moment in time that the club has to deal with, but it's not the whole story. And You've done nothing wrong. You d shouldn't deny yourself the pleasure and joy that that gives you. And I understand how heartbreaking you are the moment because, you know, it it really has been really traumatic for for mostly for the people involved, the women who might have been involved in that incident. But no

Peter LewisAnd I'll be clear, it's not about the season. I thought we would lose the grand final by ten goals. I had no illusions whatsoever. Like it's not about the football. I just feel

Francis LeachYeah. No, it it's your and you

ElizabethYeah.

Francis Leachknow what, y I think as Liz said earlier when we're offline, if you if you want to live in a pure world where everyone li lives and behaves the way that I would like them to, listen to me being the sanctimonious kid, give up watching sport. Because i it's gonna be it's gonna be it's gonna be a reflection

Peter LewisYeah and I get a job at the swans.

Damian DamjanovskiSo

Francis Leachof the wider world that we live in already. It's just you've got to keep finding a thing for for change and enjoy it while you can.

Peter LewisSo

Francis LeachAnd if you can get involved to make a bit of difference like I'm trying to do, then you should do it. I guess that's it.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, I I think that's really good advice, Frank. And and before we go to the ki before we get to the kiss of death, I guess my my broader question is what in the AFL world can we do or can people do to help nudge it towards the direction where either these kids n not only are better role models but have better role models themselves if, you know, the the people leading these clubs or the people reporting on it are all of the old guard that, you know, this either used to be acceptable or they went through this back in their day or whatever it is. how do fans get involved to be like, hey, this is unacceptable. We need some heads to roll. Some CEOs need to be fired. Some trainers need to be reshuffled.

Peter LewisYeah, I reckon

Damian DamjanovskiWhat is it?

Peter LewisI reckon the Swans fans will want to see some of these boys cut loose, even though they're some of the best players in the league. I reckon the coach is in trouble. I think, you know, it's really interesting. This weekend they were having the first double head of the women's and the men's, and there's this whole call for people to turn up to the women's and then walk out when the men's are on, which I feel is really unfair on the guys that weren't involved, but I also feel

ElizabethYeah, so.

Peter Lewislike statements need to be made. But I am interested, you know, in you, Liz, w where do you think this goes, notwithstanding the case, but but like culturally within the AFL and the Swans. And I'm also interested in like what the residual damage is.

ElizabethCould I just go to Damo's question and answer it by saying

Peter LewisMm.

Elizabeththe introduction of the AFLW, I was lucky enough to be in AFL House when that happened, that first year, right? And be there for that first three years. And I'd worked a lot in politics and other organizations and the change that happened, know, still terrible things are happening, but to have this huge influx of women, when you think about these clubs, which were just men went, you know, just the male players. now all of these clubs are really genuinely committed. These workplaces now have women in them to a really substantial degree. And so, you know, it's not, you know, we could have the whole debate now about quotas, Damo, knowing you're also out of politics, but having women at all levels in organizations like this makes so much difference. So we're still on that journey in the AFLW that few years. you know, it went from

Peter LewisMm.

Elizabethkind of virtually none to just this huge number of women. And it does change things. Yeah, I feel more confident about your club dealing with this, Pete, than you do, because I just think they've acted quite in an interesting way this week. They really did not put

Peter LewisMm.

Elizabethfootball first and we shouldn't assume, yeah, they...

Peter LewisNo, clearly. But if they had, it would have been abs like the it was the only choice choice they had. I but I don't

ElizabethSo they haven't, for me, just from a comms and brand and reputation point of view, they have not put us wrong yet.

Peter Lewisknow. I don't know if they come I I st I seriously don't know if they come back anytime soon. Like and and like yeah, but but more broadly, I

Damian Damjanovskithey they've they've lost a stack of sponsors already, right? They've lost some of their major sponsors already.

Peter Lewisthink they've done real damage. And I was gonna say to you, Darma, like you worked in with Morrison when the Britney Higgins stuff went down and it It changed the perception of not just your Prime Minister but the entire Liberal Party and had real consequences. I th I I I don't think the

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, I look I I think

Peter Lewisteal wave would have hit without that. Like it changed history and I like I'm not saying this is at the same level, but yeah.

Damian Damjanovskiit was it was definitely a contr contributing factor, yeah. It's th those things are contributing factors, the to things like the tear wave. But I think people watch how you respond to this kind of stuff very, very closely. and I would argue that the response to some degree i is the part that people are looking to say, well, hang on, what what are you gonna do about this? Because again, everything's allegations at this point, so we're not for one moment saying that anyone is guilty of anything.

Peter LewisAllegedly.

Damian DamjanovskiBut the allegedly, the point is there'd be a lot of people out there looking at this going, should These athletes who are getting paid this money to play at the highest levels of the sport, should they be in any circumstances out at four o'clock in the morning like is that part of that Faustian bargain where the reason you're getting that is to not be that, right? And we expect the same of our politicians, is we're holding you to a higher standard. That's

ElizabethYeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Damian Damjanovskithe danger pay you're getting.

ElizabethYeah.

Damian Damjanovskiis to be held to that higher standard. Exactly, right?

Peter LewisFor recognition and fame and fortune.

ElizabethDamien, just talk, remember, I remember Scott Morrison's response when the Brittany Higgins thing happened. And he did do this, you know, and I know he meant this really genuinely. And he did say, you know, his wife had had a discussion with him, right? And this was one of the things that he really stuffed up from a general kind of media point of view, which was, you know, this kind of like, you know, I've had a discussion, I've forgotten his. wife's name, but you know, I've had a discussion with

Damian DamjanovskiJenny.

ElizabethJenny and he asked me to think about this as if this had happened to one of my children, right? And I remember seeing that thinking, wow, he's got no women in his office telling him, having a look at that statement saying, mate, just hold on.

Peter LewisIt sounds a bit like Wayne it sounds a bit like the Swan's press conference today, actually, Liz.

ElizabethYeah, that's,

Damian Damjanovskiyeah.

Elizabethyeah.

Damian DamjanovskiI I don't wanna comment too deeply on this for

ElizabethNow of course.

Damian Damjanovskifor obvious reasons, but I think there's

Peter LewisDiff anyway, yeah.

Damian Damjanovskibeen plenty of coverage in the press about the women who were in the office who had gone through

Peter LewisIncluding jewels.

ElizabethYeah.

Damian Damjanovskia particularly traumatic journey. and have had to fight tooth and nail with the Commonwealth in the Labour Party to have their fair day in court. and anyone is welcome to pick up an Australian newspaper and actually read about that. And sadly, the Australian is the only one who's bothered covered covering this story.

ElizabethYeah.

Damian Damjanovskiso I'll leave that to readers to determine on their own grounds.

ElizabethYeah, yeah. I suppose I watched the coach and the captain of the Swans today kind of lean into that same thing, which is, you know, to the women in the office, to the women in the team, to the women that we love. And I just, would really like talking about masculinity where it needs to go. Men should feel these things for what it means to them, not because they know a woman or they're married to one. It's like, you know what? Why don't you own this all for yourselves? Please don't drag us in here. Yeah. Yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiYou're y you're you're you're absolutely right, Liz, and I think it In the majority of instances, not that I'm telling anyone how to do crisis management, but it's it's very rare to have the same person who's navigated you into a crisis to be the right person to navigate you out of a crisis. and unfortunately,

Elizabethyou.

Damian Damjanovskithe level of entitlement that the Australian leadership class now has seems to be that, well, I got us into this, I'm the only one who knows how to get us out of this. And it's like,

ElizabethThank

Damian Damjanovskimate, that is that's not kind of how this works anymore. I'm sorry to tell ya.

ElizabethYeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Tough week.

Peter LewisAnyway, on that note, so did we tell you about Kiss of Death, Liz? You gotta give a prediction for the week?

ElizabethYou didn't explain.

Peter LewisWell, we it started off being our predictions, but we always got it wrong, and now we're not sure if we're trying to jinx something or actually make it come true. But you've got a prediction for the next week that you might wanna have happen or not happen. So it's pretty open ended. So

ElizabethOkay, well you go first and I'll think about mine while you're doing it.

Peter LewisAll right. Have you got one, Darma? Look, mine is just linked to this. So I don't know. This is what I think is going to happen. The North Sydney Bears are coming back into the league next year. I reckon I'm done with AFL. I'm going back to my roots. I joined the Swans because the Bears got kicked out. The Bears are coming back in via Perth. I don't think they are any more you know, that angelic than than than any other footballers, but I at this stage, I don't know if this is gonna happen or not, but that's where I'm feeling at the end of this week. So and I do thank you all for your therapy through this as well. It has been terrific.

ElizabethDarling, I hate to you.

Francis LeachHa

ElizabethAnd your response to this issue in the AFL is to choose rugby league. Darling, you'll have me back on in a

Peter LewisYeah.

Elizabethyear. Man,

Francis LeachHa

Elizabethman, hashtag not all sports, but particularly fucking rugby league. love it.

Damian DamjanovskiThere's always tennis.

Francis LeachWe are living in the age of we're living in the age of

Damian DamjanovskiElizabeth,

Francis Leachdoubling down.

Damian Damjanovskido you have a Elizabeth, do you have a kiss of death for the coming week?

ElizabethYeah, I think the, I think the Manosphere is gonna fight back and this issue about the Sydney Swans is gonna turn into a culture war real quick.

Peter LewisMm.

ElizabethAnd like I love watching all of our footy people, even people I wouldn't expect, Francis, know, the SEN boys, kind of they know what to say now, they've got the script, there's a victim, there's a woman at the of this and we really respect him, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, Let's watch that all come apart. because you know we don't yeah. Carl Stefanovic yep yeah

Peter LewisHmm. Karl. Carl sk Karl Stefanovich will have the boys on for a pod as soon as they can talk publicly.

Damian DamjanovskiVery interesting case of it.

Elizabethyeah.

Damian DamjanovskiFrank, how about you? Kiss a death for the week.

Francis Leachpredict that there'll be a protest at an AFLW game by the players in some form, shape or other. There'll be something that'll happen in a game where the players will make it known in whether it's a post match interview or somewhere along the line about how they feel about this issue. Because I think they feel an enormous sense of betrayal just for the circumstances as it has been depicted. And they're strong enough now and they feel like they've got a enough of a a toehold in the game that it's their game too, and I expect that someone is going to make that their feelings known.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah. That's good. I'm gonna go a a different a different tact. So next

Peter LewisAbout you something totally away from the swan, so

Damian Damjanovskiweek,

ElizabethThank

Damian Damjanovskisome of our listeners may or may not know, is the fur is the Bush Summit, but it's the first national Bush Summit. so in previous years the Bush Summit, which is sponsored by Hancock Prospecting and is usually like a big

Peter LewisIs it posted by the Bush lady? Is she invited to be the MC? The one that interviewed Albo?

ElizabethWho's the bush lady?

Damian Damjanovskino, no, I don't believe it's it's hosted by her, sadly. So but

Francis LeachHa

Peter LewisHa ha

Damian Damjanovskiwhat's interesting about it is it's

ElizabethI would watch that.

Damian Damjanovskiyou know all all the politicians will be there, but there'll be I think there's a speech by Pauline. I think there's a speech by Angus. So I'm assuming there's gonna be a bit of a pissing contest between the two of them on something.

Peter LewisAnd you're going.

Damian DamjanovskiI will actually be there reporting live from Doubo, so very excited for that.

Peter LewisFantastic. Look forward to that. Hey, thanks everyone for your for your thoughts and prayers. Fantastic combo.

Damian DamjanovskiLiz, Frank, thank you so much. This was a very fascinating convo for a AFL

ElizabethThank

Damian Damjanovskioutsider. I hope we haven't offended any fans. Well we probably will have, we'll phone them off.

ElizabethWe will have, we will have. Won't be Francis.

Peter LewisI feel like I I feel like I I I thought I need therapy

Damian Damjanovskibut if you haven't yet,

Peter Lewisor more of it.

Damian Damjanovskiplease like, share, and subscribe the podcast. we enjoy when you guys comment as well. So please feel free to. and we look forward to catching up with you next week, where it'll just be Mr. Lewis and myself here in Market Street at Sydney. So look forward to seeing you then. Thanks.

Peter LewisThanks everyone.