Episode 21

Going bush - road trips, endings, and new beginnings

29 August 20261 hr 10 min

Show notes

We talk about living wakes and their significance, then take a deep dive into the Bush Summit in Dubbo, where farmers air their grievances and political figures respond. We get into the dynamics between the Nationals and One Nation, and what they mean for regional politics. We cover the challenges facing the agricultural industry, how geopolitical issues ripple through the food supply, including biosecurity, fertilizer and the impact of climate change on farming.

We then celebrate Peter's stepping back from Essential media after 30 years and reflect on how politics and activism have shifted over the past three decades. Building alliances, the power of lobbying, what long-term politicians actually change, the value of failure, and the stability of government and the role of public service.

Chapters

  • 00:00 The Significance of Living Wakes
  • 03:25 The Bush Summit: Farmer Grievances
  • 17:27 Political Dynamics: Nationals vs. One Nation
  • 25:12 Agricultural Challenges and Food Supply
  • 27:18 Biosecurity and Fertilizer Industry
  • 30:30 Climate Change and Farming
  • 43:47 Changing Landscape of Politics and Activism
  • 52:02 Building Alliances and Social License
  • 52:59 The Power of Lobbying
  • 54:30 Impact of Long-Term Politicians
  • 01:07:31 Value of Failure and Stability of Government

Full transcript

Read itHide it

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.

speaker-1: Welcome to What's Your Poison, the show where people barely agree on anything, agree it's better to do so over a drink. My name is Damed Domyanovsky. I am a director here at General Strategic, and I am joined this week, as I am every week, by my evil twin, Peter Lewis. and Peter is excitingly no longer the principal at Essential Media. He is now a are you an executive

speaker-0: I'm non executive chair, so I've moved to the emiritus part of my career. Emeritus chair non material I don't know, like I'm still gonna be around, but yes, Around but not around. Big week, recovering from a big night last night. We might talk about that later, but thank you for and Jules for being part of it last night. Incredibly overwhelmed.

speaker-1: It was very exciting. It was a great send-off. Now before we dig into it, we're sharing a poison this week. So what's your poison?

speaker-0: I've never done one of these before, but the I I feel like the only thing that I can take in is a soft drink, so I've gone for a hard rated alcoholic lemon drink, which allegedly is made with crushed lemons. I find that hard to believe. I'd like to see the lemons being You want to see the lemons being crushed. yeah.

speaker-1: Now I don't know if you know any of the colloquialisms for this, but my business partner Matt introduced me to one of my favorites, which is the lemon weapon. which I think if you have enough of these, you become the weapon rather than

speaker-0: I'm hoping it's a weapon to my let's let's not beat round the bush hangover. I as I've got older been able to deal with these better, but not this week.

speaker-1: I I c I I mean, having been there last night I can totally understand. It was it was a beautiful evening. tell me about your week. Why has this week been special to you? why has it been interesting for you?

speaker-0: Well, i the the week was actually bookend. So I I started the week at the living wake of one of the great innovators of our generation Australia, Evan Thornley, who's been given a terrible diagnosis of terminal brain cancer, but he put on an amazing show Down in Melbourne in St Kilda. this is a guy that set up Look Smart, the one of the first search engines, made s some money before the Doc from Catch. It was the search engine that Microsoft used. And then he since then he had a a short time in politics. He also set up or or rescued ABC learning, turned it into good start early learning. set up a he had a play of setting up charging stations around the country, a project Better Place, which didn't get there, but it was about a decade ahead of its time. And he's been working in a property player called Longview for a while. But anyway, so was all these different people from around his life coming together, which was really r remarkable. And I ended the week with my professional living wake. at Essential, I've made the decision to put more time into doing stuff I like like this. Yeah. and I've got a really In a really lucky position. They've got a great team who are ready to take it over. Pete's been on the podcast before. you you've met a few of them now as well. So yeah, it's it's just the end of a it feels like the end of a week and an end of thirty years as well. So I'm a little bit tired and emotional but

speaker-1: We're feeling very emotional for you and I and I do want to come back around to that. we'll we'll talk about some politics and

speaker-0: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

speaker-1: Come back to that, but I did want to ask you before that, you because this is a trend I've noticed lately, which is I feel like a lot more people are having living wakes. Like that is something that when I was younger and you'd go to funerals and stuff, like living wakes weren't a thing as much as I feel like they are now. And I feel like it's happening more and more frequently where either people get you know terminal diagnoses or that they kind of know they're you know they're on their way out and they're going

speaker-0: Yeah, James Valentine did a similar thing. mate of mine Tom O'Sullivan did it three or four years ago, even longer now. So I think and not in those shoes yet, if you know it's coming, why wait why leave it so long but you don't get to experience the love? Because that is what a funeral i is often almost the things people wish they'd never said to each other. and yeah

speaker-1: will still have a funeral after their living wake? Like is there like I I don't know with James but d was there the Living Wake and then a funeral?

speaker-0: With James there was the living wake and then there was the memorial service in a town hall. I'm sure the family did something as well. I don't know what Evan's planning. but I feel like that was a great way of saying I see you, I respect you and you know, it it felt more real to me than yeah, going down and saying goodbye to the ashes, so

speaker-1: It feels like a lovely thing to do. I just I I think I appreciate that more people feel the permission these days to like it feels l less of a weird thing to do these days than maybe

speaker-0: And it's interesting because the taboos around death, like so voluntary assisted dying, is much more a thing now, and obviously it's legal in some states.

speaker-1: Legalized in the Northern Territory, I think today.

speaker-0: Yeah, what and I don't know, like so I've always thought one of because we've moved away from being a spiritual society probably I I've always thought we we we are less comfortable with death and you know, there's always that stroke so particularly when my parents passed, like doctors can't even talk about death to you, like 'cause yeah, that's their sign of failure. but there's al Yeah,

speaker-1: All the all this beating around the bush when it comes to

speaker-0: yeah. Rather than just saying, Look It comes to everyone. It's gonna come at a certain time. You can stretch it out if you want. You can compress it if you want. I think also when you've got that sort of terminal thing, it gives you something to I don't know. Maybe it gives you something to own for. I don't know. if if my living weight was gonna be anything like my professional weight this week though, like I'd up for it 'cause it's so nice. Yeah. It's not about Yeah.

speaker-1: we're gonna come back to your professional time talking about it. politics

speaker-0: Yeah, so you and Bush.

speaker-1: So I did go Bush, so I spent the week out at at Doubo. So at a thing called Bush Summit. So back in two thousand and nineteen during What felt the time to be the and it was the the height of the drought. So we'd been in years of drought. Farmers were really, really struggling. It felt as though government at the time, which was a coalition government, wasn't really doing much for the regions. Like and to be honest, there's there isn't a lot government can do when there's drought. Like you you can't make it rain. Like, yes, you can provide financial support, this, that, and the other loan extensions, but ultimately, unless it rains, there's not a lot you can do. Either way, the Daily Telegraph organized this thing. Called a Bush summit, right? Which was one in each state, so Queensland, New South Wales, South Australia. and the idea was to give farmers a opportunity to kind of have a whinge and have a little bit of a Davos style summit where they all come together and some government representatives turn up the PM, turned up the opposition leader. So that's been going on for a while. Well since twenty nineteen, that was the first of the draft.

speaker-0: So how long's it been going for? Right. So you guys were in power.

speaker-1: Seven, yeah, so this is the seventh year and this is the first year that it was a national bush summit. So rather than having one in each state, they just had one. It was in Dubbo, which is where the first one also was and it was literally just one two-day event for everyone rather than a lot of single one-day events.

speaker-0: So it's like the ALP National Conference for the Daily Telegraph.

speaker-1: A i and for farmers, really. So so they don't actually farmers don't have a lot of like they have a lot of smaller conferences, but they don't necessarily have interfaces to government all that often other than through the Farmers Federation.

speaker-0: What about the national party?

speaker-1: Well yeah, but that that's a that's a direct engagement rather than like a bigger media covered conference. Do you know what I mean? Like the media doesn't cover any rural affairs in a bigger sense other than the Bush Summit. There's a handful of other events. There's landline, but

speaker-0: And what's like the telly's obviously doing it to sell papers. Well yes. News

speaker-1: Telegraph it's it's

speaker-0: limited.

speaker-1: News corpse properties kind of all together at once. They're the media s the media provider and event sponsor. Hancock Prospecting is the principal sponsor. Then you've got the Quantus which

speaker-0: Jay No.

speaker-1: is Gina Reinhardt. so there's quite a few of now. but the basic idea is to try and focus Canberra and everyone's attention to the regions for a couple of days and the problems facing the regions. So that was a it was a two day summit, so we were there for a few days and it was

speaker-0: What's the vibe?

speaker-1: so So the first day was more agriculture farmery and the second day was more politician. The first day was definitely packed out every session.

speaker-0: And how what how many people's the capacity?

speaker-1: right. And they've come in from Queensland, from South Australia, from parts of New South Wales. And

speaker-0: And they're live streaming it through

speaker-1: It's on it's on Fox and all kind of stuff. and the issues are exactly what you'd expect. They're talking about water issues, the big the big questions around El Nino, potential droughts, the H five avian bird like the things that you and I, to be honest, probably don't think about on a day to day basis. But maybe we should more because we need to think about where our food comes from and our food security, not just from an export perspective, but if we don't want to be playing paying ludicrous prices. prices for you know our wheat bicks and our sunrise and all that kind of stuff. these are actually like really important

speaker-0: And were And were there interesting discussions or was it just agrarian socialism, like give us give us the dough so we can feed the nation?

speaker-1: So actually I think the majority of the argument I heard from the farmers' side of the fence was we need government to get the hell out of the way and just let us farm. So there seems to be a huge feeling amongst farmers of we are crazily overregulated.

speaker-0: Around land clearing.

speaker-1: Land clearing, water allocations is a huge one. So the Murray-Darling Basin, which is where most of our farming land lives. Farmers kinda have to pay for water.

speaker-0: Yeah, there's a weird trading system. There's a trading system. Angus tailors up to his neck in it, isn't he?

speaker-1: I I don't know about Angus but like there's a lot of people who who have either had a say or had a hand in doing something. Yeah. if if you're a listener and you don't know about this and you find this particularly boring, I get it. It is done.

speaker-0: Just hit the ten second flash.

speaker-1: But the thing is, when you dig into it and you go, Why are these guys so up in arms about it? You do start to unpack it and go, holy shit, we might only have a year or two's worth of food if we don't solve these issues and then that means we're having to buy shit from Latin America, Indonesia, this, that and the other. Problem is, a quarter of the world's you know, wheat comes from the Ukraine and Russia, can't right now. A whole bunch of stuff comes through the Middle East, can't right now. Latin America being hit With an El Nino, which means they're not going to be able to farm. Indonesia being hit with the other side of an Ind El Nino, we might not have enough coffee. So there's all these compounding polycrisis effects going on, and you're like, are we up for a couple of really bad years because inflation's already hitting us all cost a living? but if coffee starts to cost us stupid prices and cereals and rice and pasta go from I

speaker-0: The cr polycrisis requires more than less red tape. But it it's interesting. And one of my mates, Jack Goff from the Invasive Species Council. So this is really smart because he's an activist and he's a very effective one. They're the guys that ran the campaign to save the snowies around the Brumbies and they want to get feral cats killed. Like they did the hard environment work, but he sponsored and I think he was I don't know whether he was major or mid, but he said it was a huge return on investment because he went out, he got the stage. Got really good coverage, obviously.

speaker-1: And he was an amazing speaker.

speaker-0: Was he talking about the bird flu or

speaker-1: He was on a good he talked he talked about 'cause it was the that panel was on invasive species and and all that kind of stuff. So it was a a broader panel talking about everything from, you know, mammals all the way down to bacteria.

speaker-0: We've got to get him on 'cause like the what he's been telling me about what's coming with bird flu, we don't know the half of it. Like it's gonna be very confronting. The summer is gonna be on the beaches. We are not gonna be bodysurfing this

speaker-1: We are not and it's like if you're living in a metro city, you're like actually probably don't want to know about this stuff because it like if I did I'd I'd go to woolies and fucking stock up on every piece of canned food I could and dry food I could find and keep it somewhere safe 'cause I don't know what's gonna happen because no one does, right? So so it was an interesting summit from that perspective of getting to see life through the farmer's eyes, which most of us don't, right? If we're f like ninety percent of Australia's urbanized, we're in the cities, we kinda don't give a shit. Food comes from Coles and Woolies, it does Doesn't come from a farmer, if you know what I mean. but when you go out there and you see the kind of strife they're going with, and then the reception that then day two was all about the kind of politics of it. So there was Albo speaking, Angus Taylor, Matt Canavan, Pauline Hanson. So like the full kind of kitten caboodle, which was really interesting because it was more of the politics rather than the agricultural problems that we're facing.

speaker-0: How did ABO go?

speaker-1: there were audible loud boos happening. And look, you're a sitting

speaker-0: From the sky journalists or the whole road.

speaker-1: From the audience, so firstly I think the room was th only three quarters or two thirds full at best.

speaker-0: That's interesting, yeah.

speaker-1: compared to obviously Pauline who had a packed house really ransom. and there was obvious there was a lot of audible, rambunctious booing for Albanese, especially and I think he he got caught in the issue of You know, there's there's there'd been a whole day of people complaining about over regulation and confusing red tape and this, that and the other. And he kind of tried to echo their sentiments, which led to booze, because people are going, Well, you're the government. Like if if anyone can fix this issue, it's meant to be you. So if you're sitting there trying to empathize and being like, Yes, I really want there to be less red tape for farmers, you go, so make there be less red tape for farmers. You you are the government. Like, go forth and do it. so he definitely didn't have a a good reception there. I don't think Angus had a particularly strong reception either, to be perfectly honest. I think Angus who who himself claims to be like, you know, a land holding

speaker-0: Yeah.

speaker-1: he should have gotten a stronger reception than he did. But Pauline and Barnaby were by far the the rock stars of the event. And I I it's easy to think that because it's a news event that it would just be kind of r right wingers and, you know but news isn't particularly friendly to who are the

speaker-0: The two thousand people from Dublin they're pe are they like

speaker-1: From Dubbo, they've they've driven in from all over the country.

speaker-0: country and are they and flown in. Are they like industry people and like is is it is it like it's not I'm gonna go to Dubbo to see the Bush summit. Like they're all people there for a

speaker-1: That's increasingly what's happening. So like people, you know, the tickets become available, the tickets cost nothing. So if you're a farmer, you get invited to come along, you you register and you you turn up. so you had people there who were landowners, people who were stockholders.

speaker-0: That's so inter and so how did the gnats go? Like is is d did you get the sense that the gnats

speaker-1: them to have been the superstars of it 'cause they're the Nats. They're the Nats

speaker-0: That's what they do?

speaker-1: country. So you would have thought and Canavan ha did an amazing performance. He was on a panel with Pauline together. So Pauline and and and Matt were kind of shared a panel.

speaker-0: And what are those dynamics like?

speaker-1: I mean you'd th again you'd think they should be good and there's kind of this like needless back and forth jibing and controversy between the two of them. where you can see that they're obvious obviously jostling for the same electoral space But you think that like you would think the Nats who have had a lot longer in this game, a lot like a a well-oiled machine, that they haven't really lost any seats in the past four or five elections, like they've actually either gained or held almost all their seats. it was weird to see them being as on the back foot as they appeared to be, with Pauline seeming to be on the front foot in the middle of regional New South Wales, which is not necessarily natural one nation territory. Like other than the fact 'cause

speaker-0: Well the local member there's Andrew G, isn't it? Or is that that's much

speaker-1: Andrew G's further in. This is Jamie I I forget his last name, but so the the guy who took over from Mark Coulter, I think it was.

speaker-0: This is a very bad game of pub trivia now.

speaker-1: So but but the point is like These aren't the kind of these farmers aren't the kind of people who are like, yeah, screw the immigrants, we need less of them. These are these are, you know, orchard holders and vineyard holders and whatever they go, like, we need immigrants to pick the food. Like without immigrants, our business model is completely screwed. And we treat immigrants well and we house them and this, that, and the other. So these are not natural one nation supporters, and nor should they be. Yet, one nation got a better response than anyone else in the room. Like rock stars.

speaker-0: And what was Hansen and Joyce's pitch? Was it just we feel your pain or was there any

speaker-1: grievance. Yeah. So I mean Joyce a little bit more developed. Barnaby, you know, he he's of the he's of the regions, he knows the regions, he knows their pain points. So he's happy to sit there and go, What we really need is more dams because when it's times like this and there's a lot of floods, we need to keep that water somewhere so we can use it when there's a drought because that's a country we live. And he he's he does talk sentence. Australia hasn't built new dams in a very long time, which is one of those things that again in the cities we don't really think about because all our cities hug the ocean but inland they go why the hell aren't we building dams? Like they're not particularly expensive to build.

speaker-0: I don't think ocean's very good for agri I'm I'm not an expert. We're we're from the city.

speaker-1: But like is in we we don't think about it 'cause we don't need to think about dams as a thing in cities. but farmers do think about it and go like, Well why the hell don't we build more dams? What is h what is meant that we've gone decades and decades without building a brand new dam? So he he speaks their pain points because he knows them. Pauline just kind of repeats her standard talking points, which is immigrants but the right kind and then she gets tongue twisted because she goes, Well, you know, I'm not a I'm not against all immigrants. I know that you guys as Some immigrants, but I want us not to have the wrong kind of immigrants, but then you can't dig into well, what's the wrong kind of immigrant? Because then she has to pick an enemy, so then she'll go, well, it's universities it's university visa holders, but then it's and then she kind of gets into the the pauling, she gets you know a bit ruffled by all that and then kind of ends up in a little loop. So her performance isn't particularly good, but she's still a rock star. And that's the thing, and and I think it goes to your theory of outsiders versus insiders. Where people are going, I'm tired of labor and the libs and the gnats. None of you are under s you're not hearing my pain. So I'm gonna go over here because these guys at least understand. I don't know if they've got the solution, but when Barnaby talks, I get that he understands my pain. And when Pauline talks, at least she's, you know, she's understanding the the pain in the cities or whatever else it is.

speaker-0: So did you walk away thinking there is a real prospect of one nation displacing the Nats? or is there a world in which we end up with a thruple coalition?

speaker-1: My what I walked away from it going is I think Pauline Hansen's actual like she poses a huge threat to some Nats seats and regional Labour seats are actually I think the two things that should be the most concerned.

speaker-0: That's what we're looking at in Victoria, I reckon, 'cause they've got the I think we've spoken of this before, the red the red wall for Labour is the Bendigo Ballarat, Geelong. Yeah. And if they went one nation, that actually does shift the needle in if you still look at it as a two party.

speaker-1: So I d I don't think like in New South Wales, I think maybe in the Hunter region they they do stand a pretty good shot of one or two seats. I don't think necessarily they'll grab that kind of parks region or any of that kind of outer outer because while they speak grievance, farmers are very pragmatic people and and do genuinely want actual solutions, not someone who's gonna cut migration and then mean that they don't have anyone to pick their crops come end of season.

speaker-0: Yeah.

speaker-1: So I I just think it's a very interesting dynamic at play and the thing that I walked away from it going is how have the gnats been this unsettled and unfooted in their heartland? That's the bit that I was like, this is Nats heartland and they work on the back foot. That is very interesting.

speaker-0: And like you say, they've been holding the line over the last decade when the libs have been decimated in the city.

speaker-1: And i th th the only other thing I walked away from having spoken to quite a few farmers and and people from different industry organizations there is I don't think people in the cities like ourselves

speaker-0: Yeah.

speaker-1: Understand what the agricultural impact of the next 12 months might be to our food supply in terms of food security and what that means. Not just in terms of cost, that is going to be a big one. but there's a very real chance that certain items over the next 12 months, depending on how the weather goes, may be unavailable for purchase, which I don't think as Australians, we're I don't think we don't we know how to deal with that, right? I don't remember when bananas were unavailable for like one half of a year for a season because there was a huge typhoon. Or something in Brazil, and everyone was outraged that bananas, this one, bananas are not available, we had to import those tiny bananas from plantains. Yeah. And people lost their minds. So you can only imagine when the supply chain gets affected by we don't have enough wheat, there's not enough rice, coffee's in short supply, tea's in short supply. Like all these things are grown within the same region of Earth, which is A, being hit by the worst El Nino ever on one side. And on the other side geopolitical issues mean that we just we we're there's a constriction of supply. And we're twenty-six million people. A wealthy twenty-six million, but there's a whole world out there of pe there's a Europe, there's a US, there's a Canada, there's a Brazil where there's a couple of China, a couple of billion people who need to be fed, and their governments are probably gonna put out a lot of money to make sure that they don't have uprisings, riots, this that's a

speaker-0: And so just to round it off, beyond getting rid of red tape, was it what were the most interesting ideas that you you took away from the summit?

speaker-1: So biosecurity is the other big one. Again, it it's a boring topic to talk about because why would you talk about it? Yeah,

speaker-0: Until the pandemic.

speaker-1: it's it's like trying to talk to people who are infectious disease experts. You're like, this is a really boring topic. Until the COVID hits and you go, right, okay, this is that thing you were talking about and why we should

speaker-0: But you're the rock.

speaker-1: you're the rock star. So, biosecurity, which is, you know, making sure that these zoological infections and things that hit Europe, Asia, wherever don't get to Australia, we don't think about that often because all we think about is like, I'm not allowed to bring wood back into Australia or natural fibers or blah blah blah. Nanny state. Nanny state, we're so annoyed at and then you go, shit, right, that ensures that our crops because if what like this bird flu, which is currently confirmed in Australia but hasn't hit any of our agricultural stock, if that gets into that supply chain, if it gets into our chicken supply chain We might go a year where we don't have any It's not even the KFC, we don't have eggs.

speaker-0: What does KFC do?

speaker-1: And eggs is not just the thing on toast. It's like literally goes into the supply chain for so many other products as a you know, as a binding agent, as a coagulant, this that and the other. You go, right, okay. It's like we live in this supply chain that is so extraordinarily delicate. And the other thing they were all complaining about obviously is urea, so if you know nothing about farming

speaker-0: Nothing about urea.

speaker-1: So basically it's a it's a fertilizer, right? So when you fertilize nitrogen

speaker-0: Of course, yeah.

speaker-1: that occurs in a few different places in nature. So you you know, you you get it out of pig urine and things like that ureas. but the best way to produce it on an industrial scale is it's a byproduct of extracting natural gas. In Australia, because of the way we treat natural gas and because a lot of those industries are now poo-pooed on, we don't produce our own urea. We should in theory have a huge amount of fertilizer because we have one of the largest supplies of natural gas in the world, but we don't. Instead, we import it from the Middle East, which is hard to do when the Strait of Hormuz is in a very delicate balance of is it open, is it closed. So while we all go, Trump, what an idiot, like why is he messing around with the Strait of Hormuz? I'm paying an extra 20 cents a litre for petrol. Farmers are going, we don't have diesel, but more importantly, without fertilizer, we can't grow food. And it doesn't matter if it opens in three months' time, because if we don't do it during planting season, we have no we will have no yield. At the end, like we will lose six months, we can't just choose a different time of year to plant it. So, timing is everything for farmers. So they go, We should have a homegrown industry in fertilizers and urea and all this stuff that is critical to the food supply chain, but because of the political pro and all what all this means is a lot of farmers are starkly, even though they're not climate deniers, are starkly against net zero because they see all these things as a byproduct of this march towards net zero. So they're

speaker-0: Whereas they don't see it El Niño as a by product of a lack of net zero.

speaker-1: Absolutely do, but they go, Well, El Nino is a byproduct of climate change. Absolutely. But we've been planning for that for ten years. We understand how to basically make sure that our crops are rotated correctly. So in a dry season we've got dams filled up and make sure they don't evaporate. So they've got all these clever ways of maximizing the because they're ultimately business people. So they they know how to maximize the utilization of their assets and they're always at the behest of the weather. So to them it's like the weather's the weather, we will plan accordingly. What they can't account for is if government goes all right well now you have to you have to import your fertilizer from Saudi Arabia and that may or may not happen depending on what these four countries that you have nothing to do with and we don't have control over decide to do. So long and short of it very fascinating.

speaker-0: question. So I know Labor's very proud of saving the last fertilizer plant. I think it's up around Gladstone as part of and it's part of their ill-defined but good vibes, a future made in Australia. So it's one of the the tangibles 'cause I've been going on them like give me something tangible. We saved that. Like was there any recognition that that has been a good intervention at the summit or in those discussions?

speaker-1: No, 'cause I think and and some people did talk about it, but it was one of those like too little too late. Yeah. Like you it's like you we don't need you to save the last one. We need you to open more supply 'cause that w it's like the whole thing of like, Yay, we have two onshore refineries in all of Australia. It's like that's not enough. Like

speaker-0: Which is a which is again the insider outsider pox on both your houses 'cause it's been happening for a long time. Yeah.

speaker-1: Because and i i from an insider perspective it's like what a great photo opportunity of Albos saving the petrol refiner the Ampole refinery in Geelong. from a punter perspective they go, Are we making any fuel? Is it enough? Does it help bring my prices down? No, no, no. Why do I give a shit? Yeah. Like it doesn't matter to me. So the fertilizer falls into the same. So all in all, very fascinating. Again, I apologize to any viewer who gets really bored by farming stuff. I'll be honest, I was bored by farming stuff. You've made it. dig into it I'm like actually I think this is something I should know everyone eats right and it's like unless

speaker-0: 'Cause we all 'cause we do like food. But food is interesting.

speaker-1: you just want to have like you know dehydrogenated powder that you mix with water to get your sustenance which is a very disturbing way to live I can tell you

speaker-0: Feels like it's lived experience there.

speaker-1: Experience that unless that's how you want to live through your next year or two, you need to give a shit about our farming and farmers would love you to care about the farms beyond just my milk is too expensive or my eggs are too expensive. They want you to understand that they are out there trying to manage a supply chain and turn a buck.

speaker-0: But aren't farmers sorry, now I now you have got me interested, but aren't aren't farmers basically big international corporations now? It's not like it's not like your your picture of a guy in a nacobra with a bit of

speaker-1: Yeah. It's a great question. So it it's kind of halfway between the two. So if you go to the US, for example, most of their farming is essentially industrialised, right? So we're not at that stage of farming, but we're also not at the hobby farm stage where it's like a thousand little guys with, you know, a hundred acres are, you know, planting lettuce. What you do end up with in Australia is multi-generational families with large land holdings where they have stupid amounts of money that over generations have been invested in farming that land. Right? So all their capital has been sunk into this cotton farm. And on paper they look extraordinarily wealthy because you're like, wow, you have ten thousand hectares and all this equipment and you plant cotton and you make a lot of money out of that. But when you do the balance shit and you get through the process, you're like, harvesting ten thousand hectares is a very capital intensive job. Making sure ten thousand hectares of cotton doesn't get a pest, you know an invasive species in it, doesn't you know, go into drought, gets watered, like all the things that go into that amount of land and making sure that as much of that land is productive as possible is extremely capital, like it takes a lot of money. So these are people who are investing a lot of money in order to reap back money out of it, but they're at the behest of weather first and foremost. the natural elements of Australian wildlife, invasive species, foreign species, and worst of all, government policy, which does might decide actually you're allowed to take out less water from the ground than you were last year because we decided that your allotment is lower this year. Or or whatever it is, right? So this kind of stuff means that they're in a huge amount of uncertainty and we as city folk go, yeah, but I don't care. I just want to pay ten bucks for my t-shirt from cotton on and I want to make sure my milk stays at two dollars without necessarily thinking through the economics of what it means to be a far it's very

speaker-0: Can I just ask one more question? I might go next year. It sounds fun. Gina, Australia's Richards Woman. Yep. Did she lead the karaoke? What was her

speaker-1: So Gina didn't go. So Hancock Prospecting's obviously the the the I think they call them the presenting partner. They they provide most of the funding. Because remember this is free for for farmers. So no no one pays for a ticket. and when you put on an event for, you know, two to four thousand people, so four thousand

speaker-0: There are costs.

speaker-1: There's costs associated with it. All of the sponsors were very generous. They leave a whole bunch of slots for non-for-profits like Lifeline, the Rul Royal Flying Doctor Service, the Country Women's Association, all this kind of stuff. So they all come free. Adam Giles, which is kind of Gina's right-hand man and the guy

speaker-0: The old N T chip.

speaker-1: Minister of the NT and he now heads up S. Kidman, which is kind of as R Williams is to Twiggy, S. Kidman is to Gina, right?

speaker-0: What does what are S. Kidmans?

speaker-1: So S. Kidman does clothing, boots, hats, it's the exact same stuff, right? Trying to dries a bone. So it's all those kind of iconic assets. including the Kidman estate, which is Australia's largest cattle station. It's it's enormous, it's the size of France, right? So bigger. it and they raise cattle on it and sell the meat, you can go buy it employee. So

speaker-0: Yeah.

speaker-1: he did a good kind of on behalf of Mrs. Reinhardt speech talking about the same complaint. No.

speaker-0: But there was no peak weirdness.

speaker-1: No, other than he you know, wore his giant S. Kidman style cowboy hat indoors. yeah, so if if you find any of this stuff interesting, it'll be at least another year before there's another push summit on. But It it's I think overall it's just worth chatting to anyone you know in the farming community, visiting some of our regions, just having a chat to random people there, 'cause Australia is essentially built on mining and farming are our two kind of core exports and industries. and as a city person it's actually kind of worth finding out a bit more about how they work, what their problems are, how they make their money and how they feel about government 'cause I think th there's a lot there that we don't necessarily think about day to day.

speaker-0: So yeah, nothing like it out. Yeah.

speaker-1: In the meantime, tell me about your week and this exciting emotional week for you.

speaker-0: I don't even know how I'm processing it, Dame. So I made the call probably it's been an ongoing conversation, right? So I'm sort of hitting sixty this year and I have all these things I wanna do, but more and more it's been I I d I'm feel that the work is getting in the way. So I love doing stuff like this. love writing my stuff for Guardian, love running events, putting on dinners and getting people to work together for what I think are the right political outcomes. And that's always kind of been the same mission of the company that I've worked in for thirty years. But I'm in this lucky position where It's done the job for me for that amount of time. I've got a fantastic group who are ready to take the reins. And so it just it it's almost just become time. So as we said before, Pete's taking over as So Pete

speaker-1: It's our

speaker-0: Starl, who've had yeah, so he's CEO, I think he's gonna call himself, and we've got four fantastic women. what are you I don't know. They don't know what part we are.

speaker-1: I'm saying.

speaker-0: Never, never. I was always just director, I think. But but also we can go into this if you're interested. But so the I've always got four t terrific women who have all put their Hands up to be minority sh shareholders' partners as well. So we've got this. We've got the triple A's.

speaker-1: All their names start with A. So it's alphabetically and went, crap, they're all A names, we should

speaker-0: So yeah, Alyssa Henderson who has been our head of research and ran the Qual program for Labour in the last elections, Alice Gagnan who runs our Melvis team, Alana Mu who's was one of my first employees has been there come and gone and then Nat who's our business manager, Nat Dubois, who has also stepped up. So it's just time and I I'm calling it my post material phase in that I just really want to have Interactions that aren't underpinned by a commercial relationship in each

speaker-1: So that means that basically we never plan to make any money out of this pod.

speaker-0: Absolutely.

speaker-1: If you're interested in being a sponsor, don't. Just

speaker-0: Go away with it. That's all right. I d I but but but you know, like we work in consulting where every hour is billed out, every conversation, regardless of the faith in which you have it. Because the need is like you we we we got twenty five staff and so you've got to keep the money coming in to keep people employed and that's the price of the freedom of working for yourself rather than for someone else. But you get to the point where if you've you know, and again like Very, very privileged to be in a material position where you'd like I'm not a wealthy man, but I've got a year's salary out of

speaker-1: And and but if you if you aren't driven by material things I'm a

speaker-0: You've said that you're totally a post material guard.

speaker-1: very die with zero. Like I'll if I die in debt I'll be a happy man. Like as long as no one else has to pay it. But if I die in a mild amount of debt, I'd be very happy man. Like I don't like I

speaker-0: We'd do a fundraiser to pay for your funeral. Yeah, yeah.

speaker-1: I I it's probably too much info on me for for the podcast, but I genuinely view hoarding money as a mental health issue. Like people who hoard money should be treated the same way as we treat any other kind of hoarder where i it's a mental health disease. Like there's no purpose in hoarding money. Like it's not true freedom. Like

speaker-0: And like the money plays an interesting role, doesn't it, right? So money meets material needs. It's also, I think, a signifier of value. there's always this thing if they're not paying you for it, they're not gonna really value you. So it's a bit of an experiment and maybe just for the next little period. So yes, of course, if we can get sponsors to this, that's great. Because that's not to draw a salary, that's to pay for our beers. hello hard rated if you'd like to help us. Just get send us a few

speaker-1: Who sells hard red? I it's Asahi actually. So from Asahi wants to reach out and send us a couple of cases of free

speaker-0: But now I've lost my thought process. that's fine. so what does it look like, particularly when you're involved in politics? And I found it really interesting. So I've got lots of people that I I wish well to and traditionally I've sort of been a consultant, which is really just selling your advice. But If you move into a position where instead of that you're just someone that's almost like an unpaid civic diplomat, I don't know, like just get people together for the sake of it. Like is there value in that? I don't know. Like I mean so experiment. So, you know, I've got my writing, I've got this stuff and ma you know, a bit of activism. So I reckon that'll keep me busy and just see if I'm happier.

speaker-1: Well just winding back, 'cause you said obviously like it was time. So I found out that essential media's thirty years old. which I didn't know. And you know, muzzle twelve for a thirty year old business like a business a

speaker-0: And then moving into a second generation, like remarkable.

speaker-1: That's yeah a tru what I would call a true achievement 'cause a lot of these businesses either, you know, sell out to some big company and then disappear, or become kind of husks of their former self. And I feel like Essentials kind of obviously gone from strength to strength. My first question is like thirty years ago, so we're talking nineteen ninety six here, then to now the difference. Yes. Like I'm so fascinated in the business you started.

speaker-0: Yeah, cool.

speaker-1: political landscape in nineteen ninety six, which we were in deep John Howard territory, you know, the the economy was recovering.

speaker-0: John Howard had just become Prime Minister. In fact, at the time, full circle, I was working at the Daily Telegraph as their industrial reporter. under the cold pot regime, Collen was

speaker-1: Everyone's been happy to take Murdoch money at the end of their lives. No one's no one's said no to the Murdoch

speaker-0: So the origin story of Ascension is actually another guy, Tony Douglas. I don't know if you meet him last night, but Tony had been this guy who'd set up the first national public radio network. So all the public radio stations set up a newsroom and distributed the content. So he was real entrepreneur. and he set up the company, you know, Kennet in power in Victoria. And so he's the first client. Yeah, so it was like the education union, the police union, and the every every union was fighting Kenneth, and we set up He d he did two things. He set up a PR company, but he also hired this terrific guy, Andrew Barne, who was also there last night, who'd been the ages market researcher. Right. And so it was really revolutionary at the time that instead of just sort of being a PR agency or doing media relations, you actually privileged the research. And so they were researching messages in nineteen ninety-six. And so then the waterfront dispute came along, and that was a big long running dispute. So, you know, Howard and Reith unleashed the dogs on the wharves and, you know, this is our narrative anyway. And there's the public like the the pickets and it was it was sh it was national. It was huge. And we

speaker-1: Well I was like a young kid. I remember the news of

speaker-0: the picket line. And we but we were running strateg

speaker-1: Catrice.

speaker-0: The Patrick's dispute, but we're running str like government wasn't doing strategic research because they FOR'd it all and there was nothing but the unions had strategic research behind it. So long story short, so Essential was a thing in Melbourne. I got out of the telegraph, did a short term in the car government as a media advisor to the late great Jeff Shaw. And then at some point in about ninety eight I There was a crazy genius who was running the unions, a guy called Michael Coster, who became New South Wales Treasurer, and he was running the unions at the time. Yep. And I'd just turned thirty and I decided I wanted to write books. And I thought I I went to Michael Costa and I said, can I you just give me a couple of days a job and he said, no, mate, set up your own business, then I'll give you a contract. And so he made me set up my business. I was a little guy I was sitting inside Sussex Street. I think I'm safe because there's nothing street, yeah. I know, but Sussex Street's the building, three, I think it's three seven seven, Labor Council was up on level ten. I got an office in there and I turned it into a little newsroom and we put out a the internet was coming on and we set up Workers Online, which was the first political website in Australia. There was us in Crikey. And I I got unions who were prepared to pay me ten grand a year to be on call and help them with their media and I was a heap and they'll go, this is great. And then these guys come up from Melbourne during the Col Royal Commission. Tony and Liz, who was on the show last week, and they give me their business model, they yeah, we do what you do, except we do it properly. We we have research and we charge 10 grand a month. And I was like, Okay, I might be part of this. And we just gelled and it grew and rights at work, every Australian counts from Indo guys like the show reels, as you saw, it's fun. But more fun than that was just getting to be part of politics and, you know, over the years probably a couple of hundred people gone through the company as an and it was all there.

speaker-1: The essential media. So you you started obviously n like that ninety six, ninety seven kind of period, thinking about people who are maybe considering doing a similar thing now. Do you think the same kind of opportunity exists now for young people that would have existed?

speaker-0: It's really interesting 'cause we were right at the beginning of the internet coming on and so we were learning as we went. So, you know, we were building websites, we were trying to sort of work out how you do offline, online. We were face like, you know, with the disability campaign, like f one of my English like we hired a woman who'd been in Oxfam and she came from England and she was keeping in touch with her family on this new thing called Facebook and she was going I reckon we could use this in politics. I go, don't be stupid. And we ran this whole campaign for the NDIS basically, a series of Facebook groups. So you you're using new technology. So I think for and and you know, you're you're starting a consulting business pretty fresh. And I think a lot of it is about just accessing the new technologies. Obviously in this era it is AI AI. And so, you know, we had good discussions with my team, and I know you did. sort of shared some of your insights today about how you do that well, how you do it to make it more effective. So I don't know, like I think

speaker-1: Yeah.

speaker-0: starting something fresh, there's always going to be opportunities. And I think businesses run the risk of getting stuck. So there's always room for a new a new entrance.

speaker-1: D do you think politics has changed a lot in that time?

speaker-0: I think it's changing now. Like I think basically for those thirty years it's really been a binary contest. Yeah. And I think also the model has always been, at least on the union side, anger hope action. So you get people fired up, you give them something to believe in and then you get them to do it. I think collectivism, which really came on probably mid two thousands, like it's the way up and Yeah, get up and then advance. But I and so I think all of that's changing. So what's changing? there are mu You know, the two party system I think is really compromised at the moment. media as an outlet is just one of a number of options. and how you build, particularly on a progressive side where, you know, at least we believe we try to build movements for change, that's becoming more and more complex as we get more and more atomized.

speaker-1: Yes, I mean When you started, finding people for these like coalitions of activism would have been a very different proposition to these days where it's like y y you can find people online with relative ease like you know what I like you can build a flame to which moths are drawn to these days. What what was it like in the late nineties, early two thousands? Is that what it

speaker-0: it is because I think what the internet originally offered was the chance to find people. Yeah. Like, you know, and back to Evan's legacy, it was like almost search was the the killer thing. You could find stuff and you could connect to stuff. And I think the light to the flame was probably the story for that sort of good years of the internet. I feel like the problem now is it's just a fucking bushfire and there is no way to get close to it. So I find I think it's getting harder and harder to build those consensuses and I think You know, I I think the challenges always change. But I I but I I think the the one thing which I've found really revealing, even in the way we've built our friendship and relationship over the last couple of years, is that I reckon the the killer app is no longer how you have a fight and win a fight, but it's how do you build common ground and come to a position. And it's not about seeing Kumbaya and agreeing with everyone. It's about starting with a place where let's agree on something. And then you can build the friction, but you've got something to build it off the back of. And I don't think many of the orgs It's interesting, like we traditionally we would run either EBA campaigns where you're having a fight for more money or campaigns to stop things. One of my favorite I've just got to digress. One of the unions, the ETU, used to have

speaker-1: Yeah, yeah.

speaker-0: Electoral Trains Union, and I worked for them on and off over the years. They had this banner ETU says no. And it would work at every single they'd just take it out. Very reusable. It's really good. so whether it was workers' cant reform or whether it was power privatization, was it ETU says no. So there was lots of really easy to run negative campaigns to stop things. but a lot of the work we do now is more and we're talking about this today than where where you guys go as well. How do you build alliances to get people to work together to create the social license and the case to get government to do what is a rational thing to do? So that's a totally different in a way, it's not even a battleground. It's like it it's it's a playing field that you set up to give yourselves the best chance. Like so for the farmers for instance, like I guess that's what they're trying to do.

speaker-1: It's coalitions, right? And it's actually quite interesting because obviously I I don't know if you saw it, but on Monday night, the ABC in Four Corners did its exposing lobbying

speaker-0: Alumni Emmin Fitzpatrick in the good fight.

speaker-1: and lobbyists. I don't know what your view I'm curious what your view is. if you haven't seen it, it's on ABC IV. It was a piece on The power of lobbying in the Australian as if the ABC has just discovered that lobbying exists. not to be highly critical of it, but I I did think it was a very big beat up piece without necessarily fair representation, but

speaker-0: I so What was your view on it? Well, I think the question of money in politics is an incredibly legitimate question to pursue. I thought The guys that put themselves out, like and it was Simon Banks, it were Ayman and a couple of others. And another

speaker-1: Christopher Pixar.

speaker-0: guy. I thought They ponied up and made the case for what they do and it is serious work and it helps government operate. I I think a public that just is totally cynical about government isn't gonna hear that at all. I don't think making two people sign for your orange po po pass as opposed to one is gonna fix that. but I do think that putting a focus on how money works in politics is good work to be doing.

speaker-1: But but this is about that's donation.

speaker-0: Not just donation, but the the power of different lobbies to have the to have the conversations and the people that aren't in the room. I think that's and we've probably got a different view against Pocock 'cause I I I respect him for coming up and and and pushing back because he's almost the black swan that isn't caught up in in that system.

speaker-1: He and I'll I'll get to the the crux of my argument of why I think the the whole like lobbying and and parliamentary passes thing is a complete farce, right? It comes down to any and every lobbyist, whether they're internal or a third-party lobbyist knows that the best lobbying does not happen in Parliament House and it doesn't happen in Canberra. If you want to see a minister, a prime minister, a backbencher, an opposite a shadow, whatever it is. You go see them on a non-sitting week in wherever their hometown is. There's no record of it. There's no need to report on it. No passes are required. Oftentimes you're in somewhere where it it doesn't matter w like no one's gonna notice you. You're you're not being there's no press gallery there. Do you know what I mean? Like the the real lobbying does not happen in Canberra. So this idea of putting a focus on, all these lobbyists who have access to Parliament's like you shouldn't be worried that they have access to Parliament House because Parliament House, the press is like they will be seen lobbying.

speaker-0: We probably need to rebrand as well because what

speaker-1: Worried about the fact that when sitting weeks aren't on and the cameras aren't on, the lobbyists are at the Commonwealth Parliamentary offices in Bly Street having conversations that no one is paying attention to. That's when the real lobbying happens. And none of these changes to legislation or what Pocock is doing even remotely touches on that. So that's why I think it was

speaker-0: I do th I d I do think the revolving door is a legitimate issue. Like I I d I do feel like Pine was unconvinced. So

speaker-1: Explain the revolving

speaker-0: the idea of the revolving door, so One of one of the cases and if I get my specifics wrong here, forgive me, it's been a big week. But Christopher Pine was Defence Industries Minister. Defence Minister pretty much went straight out into setting up a consultancy pineapple. he he sat on the bait. Okay. But then reactivate all your relationships and then you're the voice of the defence industry into the government. Also having done that really awkward version of what's your poison with Richard Miles for a best part of a decade on Sky TV, if you remember. So I none of

speaker-1: So you're against them being able to do that? I'm not against, but y do you find a discomfort in them doing that? Like

speaker-0: I feel like if you're mapping power and influence against the l the the the matrix of good public policy and in a way that builds faith in the public in the way the democracy operates, I feel like there are some hairs on it. I'm not it's not my

speaker-1: So I don't do

speaker-0: special subject. I don't I don't I don't think this is the biggest problem we are facing as a society. But you know it's

speaker-1: B.

speaker-0: Like i i it it doesn't help the brand of politics that there is this class that just is there sort of and it feels like I suppose I say maybe it no I don't know. Feels like it's greasing the wheels and there's money changing hands and you know, all the lunches and stuff which as an independent polster I've never gone to any of them and thank God never

speaker-1: Yeah.

speaker-0: been one of those five grand a head or anything. I don't do that stuff.

speaker-1: I guess the what I'd put to you is in the past, and I think it was pre-Howard or up until halfway through Howard, the system was that a minister or a prime minister or whatever would serve their term and then when they either left office or were booted out, they received a very healthy pension.

speaker-0: Pray Mark Lytham.

speaker-1: Premark Latham, they received an extraordinarily healthy pension.

speaker-0: And they could go and do good j good work with it.

speaker-1: The reason to give them that pension is to keep them out of these kinds of roles, right? It was basically th the deal is by giving you a really well paying defined benefit or whatever it was, same with staffers, you'd get a defined benefit and that way

speaker-0: If you were a minister a minister or something, you'd be on a couple of hundred grand for life, wouldn't you? And index

speaker-1: So you you don't And the idea is you're you're not meant to lobby. Now, we got rid of that 'cause the Australian public got outraged at the idea that why are we paying all these ministers like who aren't ministers anymore, they're still getting two hundred grand a year. and it and these guys like the Christopher Pines of the world leave Parliament. They go, What am I going to do now? Like I I have a skill set, my my marketable skill set is understanding government and understanding politics and I'm not getting a defined benefit and I still have to make money and pay for my mortgage and all that kind of stuff. So they go and lobby. So I feel like

speaker-0: There are other ways that politicians can earn a decent living after having politicians. I don't know, some of the best people I've worked with over the journey have been people that have worked in politics and then gone like so two examples. John Delabosca, who was a New South Wales minister, became the brains of Every Australian Counts and the N DIS scheme. It was like having a test cricketer playing park cricket, if you get my metaphor. Someone that had played and understood how power worked, working with people that have no power. Likewise Jay Wetherall who managed the every Austral sorry

speaker-1: He was the premiere.

speaker-0: South Australian Premier and then went in and yeah, went on in and worked for Twiggy Forest at Minderoo, but basically running Thrive by Five, which was early learning. So you had real like there it that skill set doesn't need to be done to I gu I guess they're just

speaker-1: billionaire patron to give because they want an ex premier on the books. Like I

speaker-0: But

speaker-1: guess as an Australian as a country, we I think we have to decide what's are we happy for our politicians to potentially eventually become lobbyists, which means they will utilize and possibly abuse. Not that we're saying anyone is abusing, but that they may have abusive relationships with people that they used to be in charge of, like departments, that and the other. Or are we happy to just pay the price and go, once you're done with politics, we'll make sure you're taken care of, but now you stay out of the system.

speaker-0: Well the third option is that we don't have a assembly line of professional politicians and we have people coming in from a diverse range of areas and they go back to doing after their time of public service they go back to being the

speaker-1: No.

speaker-0: teacher or the nurse or the doctor or the architecture.

speaker-1: Saying that there should be term limits on individual MPs?

speaker-0: Happy for people to have a long term career, but I also think that the feeder in of young Labour and Lung young liberal is creating kind of quote

speaker-1: A political

speaker-0: a political class that thinks a particular way which when we were talking about context collapse a few months ago, like it means that everything is kind of the same and you don't get that diversity of experience and strategy.

speaker-1: How long how long has Albert been in Parliament now? Thirty years. Thirty years. So he's been there for the entire period of essential.

speaker-0: Yeah, he went in ninety six I think. There you I know?

speaker-1: So I mean, he is a career politician. Yeah. Right? You think about Pauline as a

speaker-0: And you look at what he's really good at. It's that. It's the politics. And he is exceptional. Even last week he got legislation through, like he gets things done and he gets things through. there are other things that he isn't so great at, which I think is a reflection of not having that diversity.

speaker-1: I find increasingly as I age definitely at the exact same rate, believe it or not. I find it harder and harder to justify why anyone should be allowed to stay in Parliament for more than ten years. And I I think the same about we talked about this on when we had the the ladies from the Westminster report on. I feel the same about bureaucrats. I feel like if it's public service, everyone should do a public service, but there should also be a cap on it. I think ten years out of your career in either politics or the public service is a great amount of time. You have done your service.

speaker-0: The only thing I question so our two most stable governments of the last thirty years have been the Howard government and well thirty years and out and now this government, like two full terms with the one leader, what's the two things they had in common? Long-term professional leaders. Rudd came in, Gillard have been a lawyer, came in. Like these th like so I'm almost arguing against myself. So but they have been long-term players and they have managed to hold in a period of chaos. governments together.

speaker-1: But is is the mark of Australia being governed well just stable? Like is having the same leader in for multiple terms, like is that a mark of Australia?

speaker-0: But I think I think stability is the entry price to have a decent government because if you're an unstable government you can't do any of the good stuff, whether it's whichever side of politics.

speaker-1: So we are The the current system and the way we are at the moment, the stability is stability means having the same leader over long periods of time. What I'm saying is if that stability didn't come from the person who's in the chair, but rather what and how they're trying to achieve rather than the specific person that's in the chair, like i.e. their plan for the country and it doesn't matter whether it's Albow or Mars or Butler, the plan's the same, the person who's executing it changes. Every four, five, whatever, however many years, the stability just comes from a different source. Sorry, I know we're getting very philosophical and

speaker-0: I'll just say so I am more inclined to engage your argument on 10-year terms for elected reps. I think pub I think career public servants and and the the good the good in the public service which kind of shone through with our friends Carolyn and Deb. I reckon that's that is a vocation and people should be encouraged to commit to a life in public service. But but what I'd say for both of them is a bit like lobbyists, I think the problems we've got are far more than a ten year term or of course whether you've got one or two like this for an orange pass, you know, like

speaker-1: The problems are much deeper, but we've got to start somewhere, right? Like otherwise what ends up happening is we have an ineffective public service that then we need to bring in external consultants to help or fix the problems of where where public service is lacking. We have what is it, five percent of the population now are public servants, cl higher. I think it's maybe twenty percent Australia wide, are somehow

speaker-0: That would include people that'd include people working at hospitals and schools and stuff and sure. And I'm all up for that 'cause I'd rather have that being run by the public sector than global

speaker-1: Absolutely agreeable.

speaker-0: corporations.

speaker-1: We have one of the highest rates of people employed by the government, paid by the government of any developed nation.

speaker-0: But I I I'm good with that I'm good with that. Like I think like but my my my starting point as someone that's run a business for thirty years is that you know stable systems should I I I I I just think that a well run government system resourced, properly, is the best way of building a stable society and then you've got to find ways for the dynamism to sit on top of that. But I just think that again it's that the ba it's the base you move off. If you've got a a strong public education system, strong public hospital system, you've got support for people when they need them at different stages of their life. If that's your base, then that creates the opportunities for innovators like you and me to to thrive. whereas if the whole place

speaker-1: Personal question. Did

speaker-0: Yeah.

speaker-1: you send your kids to private or public school?

speaker-0: So my daughter went through the wonderful public system that is the inner west of Sydney, so she went to Lycart and then they've got a senior college down down at Glebe. My son Frank went to a music college that was private out at Strathfield. And they both had great experiences. I'm not like

speaker-1: How do feel about private versus public school?

speaker-0: I think I think there is a place for a mixed system but I also think that in a perfect world it it wouldn't be such a it's almost become a consumer choice and that that particularly that period when your kids are late primary school, it's like you feel like the whole life rests on this big decision and there's all this anxiety about, well, is the public system as good 'cause it's free sort of thing. The public system was great. Like La Chia had a great time. Yeah, I went to a public school, but it was one of those rarefied ones back in the day, North Sydney Boys, which was selective but not in the way it is anymore. Like as we were saying before, it's like if you could read you got in basically. But it it wasn't hothouse.

speaker-1: It was a public single.

speaker-0: Yeah, single and then there was a girls' school up the road and life was good.

speaker-1: How fascinating. Yeah. thirty years at Essential, what other kind of key lessons have you taken from it? key memories. Look 'cause I like we could sit here all night about war stories.

speaker-0: I think we could lose some viewers very quickly. So I think the main takeaway is the most fun I've had is when things have failed. And so this idea of failure, which I really try to drill into my guys so tried to set up a new service workers online that sort of did than didn't. My craziest was I built a TV, a beautiful TV studio in the bunker of Trades Hall in Sussex Street and we call it the bunker. Spent a couple of hundred grand because I thought every this is about 2030, I thought every union should have its own talk show. And I we we built it and poor old Ben Gregg who was my partner, he was there last night too, hello Ben. beautiful desk. I had Sarah McDonald as host who's like ABC. I had Ann Connolly, a Workley Award winning producer, and we set it all up and then I had this aha moment which is these guys have nothing to say. And I built this studio. But it was also pre pre-bandwidth. So and and then I think if we were and this is about twenty thirteen, fourteen. If I had that now, I'd I wouldn't go anywhere else. I'd just be plugging myself in every day, just talking to the internet. so that but that was a glorious failure. And out of that, some of the really and so I went around the country trying to sell this dream, but some of the people that ended up being part of the essential client base, I I went I went and pitched this to this young South Australian Union guy who I heard was, you know, gonna go places called Peter Malinowskis. He did his first ever

speaker-1: Immigrant boy.

speaker-0: He did his first ever TV stuff in the bunker. and and we were just packaging it up for members. So that was fun. And then I loved doing the stuff during the pandemic while you were saving the country. I was working out how to use Zoom, but we were running these great national events that were like every lunchtime we'd put on a different talk a speaker, different client. We were getting hundreds of people turning up to it. So all these things never quite worked, but that's the fun but of running a business. And you fail fast, you fail forward. Sometimes I failed a bit too slow. And as long as you're doing your knitting and you're keeping the client and you take them on the journey, like you never know how this is going to end. So that's the stuff I've had the most fun doing, to be honest. And in a way, where I think I've ended up is just sort of putting all my failures together, like a bit of a news service, a bit of a bunker and a bit of Australia at home, all into the one package. And so I'll do that and not expect to make any money out of it and probably have a bit more.

speaker-1: If you set your expectations low, life will surprise you.

speaker-0: Very nice.

speaker-1: We we we use this expression internally here at GS, which I like I I can't remember where I found it or or kind of cobbled it together from others, but like failure is feedback, right? And feedback is knowledge and knowledge is power, right? So failure is actually the start of a chain of things that do really empower you. So when you get to do those experiments and go, I cock that up, but

speaker-0: What did I like that up? What did I like? And also it teaches you humility as well. Like I'm not a genius. Like I'm somebody that's trying to work things out. And you know, I think you and I are a bit similar. We sell our enthusiasm as much as we sell any specific skill.

speaker-1: And we all know and and you know, I'm sure all of our listeners know the worst kind of bloody people are the ones who think they know everything and just cannot accept any form of failure. Like they are the the worst people to be around. They are insufferable in every way. We

speaker-0: Which was probably me for the first half of my career and then I kind of got into that real idea of Socratic wisdom, the wisest man in the village knows he knows nothing. And it just changed the way I did my work though, because you and you walk into a room and they go, We've got all these problems. What should I do? Let's figure it out. Just go and find out. And and the And the question is more important than the a you can answer anything. Yeah. But you've got to ask the right question.

speaker-1: I still walk into most work and you know, you you know, I'm at the a very fortunate point in my career where I'm doing workshops with like very important, like what I would have considered important, very accomplished, brilliant people. And getting to walk into these like workshops, sessions, think whatever you want to call them, and you go like this next two, four, six hours might be of no value whatsoever. I'm so sorry. I don't know if this is gonna work.

speaker-0: Front end the disappointment.

speaker-1: Like, I don't know if this is gonna work, but let's all have a crack because a worst case scenario, we'll have fun. You're gonna have a story at the end of it, which is that fat guy came in and he did this workshop and it was terrible. Like at least you'll get a story out of it. So let's all get into this journey together. And I've never understood people who walk into these things and go, like, we're gonna have an answer at the end of this, and it's gonna be the right answer because what a like setup for failure. Like that is a setup for absolute fa

speaker-0: Absolutely. And there are industries of failure.

speaker-1: The big four approving that first hand now, thankfully, so everyone can see.

speaker-0: And they're the worst offenders at this too because they sell certainty and You know, they they sell certainty off the back of like and in in a way, audits are like if you've got an auditing service, you want it to be pretty certain. You don't want there to be but the the the other stuff they on sell is the opposite to an audit and they sell it as if it's the same thing. So it's definitely we get insert your big four in and we'll meet we'll meet the concerns of risk from the board because they do it for everyone and they do the same thing for everyone in the same framework and you get the same results which is mediocrity.

speaker-1: And and they never Audit their own past results. My my favorite story of this is when ATT brought McKinsey, who are you know the kings of this, in to do a piece of management consulting on what the potential audience will be and the potential size of the market would be for this new cellular telephone service. And McKinsey basically eked it out and said, We think by year three or four or whatever, there's an audience of forty to ninety thousand people in the Unit continental United States for this cellular, this mobile phone product. So and obviously they'd undercooked it by like a factor of twenty, right? So first year. Yeah, yeah. Completely work. But like you said, they they they sold it with certainty and ATT made a whole series of business decisions on the back of, okay, there might be a market for ninety thousand cell phone product users out there. Lo and behold, here we all are with like ten devices connected to, you know, the the cell networks.

speaker-0: one you're watching this through if you're still watching.

speaker-1: You're still watching, I'm so sorry. and I do apologize, we've gone quite a bit over time

speaker-0: Have we? my goodness. So indulgent.

speaker-1: Really, really fun. I think next week we've got a another very fun and interesting special guest. congratulations. Incredible years at Essential.

speaker-0: And thank you. There was a very funny roast tape of which you featured last night as well. So I do want to thank you for that.

speaker-1: To be invited to participate in that. Thank you for having me personally and and my partner Jules, who's also a producer at the farewell event. we're excited that we get a lot more of your time now to to do stuff like this.

speaker-0: Experiment on magic stuff.

speaker-1: So if you're if you're still watching at this point and like what we're doing, please share the podcast with someone who you think might enjoy it. Send us some feedback if you want us to do more of something.

speaker-0: Talk less about us.

speaker-1: Whatever it is, we're very, very happy to do it. otherwise, thank you very much, Mr. Lewis, for another great week. look for seeing you next week. No, no, we can do Kiss of Death. I don't have any predictions.

speaker-0: Should we do Kiss of Death or we record lost people?

speaker-1: I actually don't have any predictions for the next week, if I'm honest. I haven't made any.

speaker-0: Yeah, me neither. Okay, let's call it quiz.

speaker-1: we ended on that. Cheers, mate. Cheers. See you next week.

speaker-0: Take care.