Episode 22

Covid, conspiracies, and chop-chop

With Dr Nick Coatsworth

5 September 20261 hr 3 min

Show notes

We're joined by Dr Nick Coatsworth, former Deputy Chief Medical Officer, which means we talk the pandemic. What the public health measures actually did, how governments and the media shaped what people believed, and why conspiracy theories filled the gaps. We get into the geopolitics of the pandemic, and what happens when the argument is happening on someone else's platform.

We then exlore social cohesion and why trust in government went up for a while then didn't stay, vaccine disinformation, the tobacco excise, and what the political class does with public health. We also get into how much of what people believe is evidence versus culture, history, and old colonial hangover, whether Dr Nick will take a run at politics, plus a few historical mysteries, because of course we do.

You can also catch Dr Nick and Richard Baker on their Conspiracy Cabal podcast here https://open.spotify.com/show/17VXANMDCOpaSwdDRVjTTQ?si=4921fb5c58124607

https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/conspiracy-cabal/id1882577385

Chapters

  • 00:00 Introduction and Poison of Choice
  • 01:11 Dinner Salon Discussions
  • 02:02 Bridging Divides and New Polling Methods
  • 03:17 Three-Dimensional Political Landscape
  • 04:04 Digital Duty of Care and Consent Education
  • 06:19 Introduction of Dr. Nick Coatesworth
  • 07:34 Media and Public Perception
  • 08:42 Transition to Deputy Chief Medical Officer
  • 09:15 Path to Deputy Chief Medical Officer
  • 10:07 Formation of Deputy Chief Medical Officer Position
  • 11:27 Public Health Expertise and Media Exposure
  • 12:26 Public Health Crisis Communication
  • 13:31 Media Exposure and Public Speaking
  • 14:09 Government Response and Leadership
  • 15:28 Institutional Response and Public Trust
  • 16:40 Institutional Resilience and Social Media Impact
  • 17:44 Shift in Public Perception and Political Leadership
  • 18:07 Public Health Measures and Economic Impact
  • 19:22 Public Health Measures and Societal Values
  • 20:40 Reflection on Government Response and Policy Shift
  • 22:23 Policy Decisions and Path Dependency
  • 23:44 Public Health Messaging and Communication
  • 25:00 Public Health Messaging and Public Perception
  • 26:19 Evidence-Based Decision-Making and Public Perception
  • 28:49 School Closures and Decision-Making
  • 29:54 COVID-19 Origins and Conspiracy Theories
  • 31:05 Conspiracy Cabal Podcast and Critical Analysis
  • 40:09 Tobacco Excise and Public Health Policies
  • 41:12 Freedom of Choice and Public Health Policies
  • 41:30 Philosophical Differences in Public Health Fraternity
  • 42:16 Conspiracy Theories and Illicit Tobacco Trade
  • 43:15 Disruption to Social Fabric and Public Health Policies
  • 44:03 Bureaucracy and Policy Making
  • 45:00 Influence of Bureaucracy on Policy Making
  • 46:13 Regulated Vapes and Nicotine Content
  • 47:18 Challenges in Accessing Medicinal Vapes
  • 49:33 Political Aspirations and Career Choices
  • 51:01 Shift in Moral and Ethical Foundations
  • 52:09 Conspiracy Theories and Cultural Beliefs
  • 55:27 Conspiracies, Mysteries, and Unsolved Disappearances
  • 01:01:31 Predictions and Speculations

Full transcript

Read itHide it

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.

PeterWelcome to What's Your Poison, the show where people who disagree on just about everything agree it's better to do so over a drink. My name's Peter Lewis. I'm the non-executive chair of the progressive strategy shop Essential, and joining me is my evil twin, General Strategics, Dame Damjanovsky. G'day, mate. Good to see you. What is your poison?

DameFriday. my poison this week, as it has been a lot lately, because I'm trying to cut down on the sugar intake, is the wonderful boys at Better Beer. My health kick is make better cider, which is a low sugar apple cider, and I do love an apple cider. So thank you guys for making this beautiful beer. and I have had a a a nice week, Peter. What about you?

NickThat's not.

DameFantastic dinner. This is one of your dinner salons with a It was a round table. Well it was a it was a it was an oblong table at best, an underutilised word. we had a wonderful ragtag group of people that you had brought together and got to discuss all kinds of things.

PeterAnd

DameSo Tim Dixon from More in Common out of the UK where they do some interesting things with grouping cohorts and

PeterBridging divides. So Tim worked for Rudd back in the day and went over to the UK. was really good friends with an MP who was stabbed to death very publicly about a decade ago and was motivated to move into interrogating what was sending people to those extremes. and has been doing really interesting work in America, in the UK and Brazil talking about

NickYeah, I f***ing about.

PeterPoland and And I'm looking at setting up shop in Australia. So we were just sort of introducing him back to a few

DameI need some fantastic some fantastic viewpoints and again the w the way they look at data i is quite novel which is to group them into tribes and cohorts based on their values and behaviors rather than what a lot of pollsters typically do which is purely look at your socioeconomic profile, your education level.

PeterAnd then link that to your voting intention and then turn it into a contest. And I thought the most interesting thing out of the discussion, or there was many interesting things, but this idea that there like like the sticker says, you look at on most debates, there's all these extreme positions that you can push people to, but you actually give them space and there's a lot they agree on as well. Now that's a challenge to the way that we do binary politics as well. And I think that conversation and we had some people linked to the teals, we had some we might we won't name names because it was a private dinner, but some media people

DameFantastic and I think the biggest lesson to take away from that style of new generation of polling is increasingly the political landscape is not a two-dimensional left and right. It's a three-dimensional playing ground. So obviously you need three-dimensional polling and you need three a three-dimensional understanding of the voters, and I think Tim's doing a great job of bringing that to life.

PeterJust to finish on it, what I found interesting, the output is really not a two PP or a 78% of people agree with this, but these are the groups that you should then go in and do your focus groups to interrogate more clearly because that will actually bring to light what's going on around different issues. So yeah, it was fantastic and you know we wish him well. So I'm on the the Melbourne Bidder, which back before craft beer was the best beer that Carlsman produced and about the only thing that's ever come out of Victoria that I like.

DameMy understanding is that much like that episode of Simpsons with Duff Beer, V B Foster's and Melbourne Bitter is one big pipe that goes into different coloured cans. Is that not? It's got a red label. Well therefore it tastes better and it goes faster.

PeterOkay.

Damenow you've been enjoying by the way your first week of dilettontery and not being

PeterI was also I I thought like last week was about me, but it's been Wednesday down at the National Press Club, Chanel Contos, a incredibly impressive young woman doing the national press club, around the digital duty of care and giving people back control over their algorithms. The one thing I'll say, this woman's twenty eight and she made me feel so old because she's talking about the good old days when Instagram was good. Back in twenty thirteen, when my scroll ended and I didn't have to keep going with all the everything.

Nickthe slopping.

PeterSo everything's relative.

Dametoo. And now I'm gonna ask you a really tricky question that we haven't prepared for, which is do you believe consent should be taught in schools?

PeterAbsolutely that there should be

DameLike it's not a hard question to answer, is it? It feels like one of those ones where you should be able to answer it pretty straight up front, but for some reason Angus really struggled to answer that up front in an interview. He just kept going around it and just

PeterIs he just worried about opening a culture war or being on the

DameI'm not sure if it's just his natural speaking style where he thinks he's answering yes, but in the process of not actually saying yes of course he he comes across like he's trying to skirt the issue rather than just saying, Well yes, of course it should be taught in schools and yes and dot dot dot he does the kind of consultant thing where he kinda talks around the thing but it's a very bizarre moment.

PeterWithout putting you on the spot, do you think they're starting to worry about Angus? Like he like I I don't think I'm sure that he's got charms, but they're not coming through.

DameWell I think look it You would have expected a little bit more of a bounce after the lead to Angus changeover. and I think the hope was put on Angus that maybe he would cut through in a way that Susan wasn't able to cut through. And we just haven't seen that yet. So if you were in the the party administration, there is no doubt that you'd be going, All right, is this gonna take a turn or is this as good as it gets with Angus? And if this is g as good as it gets, then we need to think about how do we get better. The problem is, as we've talked about before, there's not much of a talent pool in there right now to pick from. Like you you don't have a lot of

PeterAndrew Hasty's now wondering if he's even gonna be there after the election, after that by-election over in WART C to go.

DameThere's a l yeah, there's a there's a lot of Secret Harbor. Secret Harbor. Fantastic scene.

PeterA B C miniseries is amazing. So who have you brought along today? 'Cause he's sitting on the couch.

DameHe he is indeed. I I've brought along someone who I got to meet during the the height of COVID as the the nation was learning to bake sourdough bread and do various other things while we were unceremoniously locked in our own houses and that is the one and only Dr. Nick Coatesworth. Very good. What's your poison this week?

PeterWelcome Dr. Nick.

NickWell my poison was given to me by you guys I was instructed to bring a beer but I'm hopeless with that sort of thing and so I've got a Asahi Super Dry which I was gonna actually was gonna get it. It

PeterIt's gonna go well with your sushi.

Nickgoes well with my sushi I was gonna get a heaps normal because I wanted to sort of promote 0 % alcohol drinking because as you know now I'm the doctor that wants every young Australian to smoke a cigarette.

DameWell yeah, I mean it's

PeterThe

Dameliterally you got me started, I'm kidding you No

NickGlad to see you on the pipe.

Dameobviously medically prescribed vapes at that Absolutely. before we dig into some of the amazing events of this week, give us for people at home who who may not know much of your story but probably have seen you either during COVID, or post COVID, hosting you know, we weekend breakfasts and and other television shows with a much larger audience than we have.

NickYou know, is fleeting. Fame is fleeting. And one of the interesting things about being a doctor who is also on one of the networks, the network being nine, is that you can go into a four bedded bay. Keep in mind this is in Canberra. So public hospital, four bedded bay. ABC. g'day doctor, how are you going? Channel seven. Didn't I see you in my restaurant the other day? Channel nine. Hey, it's Dr Nick. The fourth one? I saw you on Sky.

DameHang on, which one was the best patient out of the four? That's the case.

Nicklook I can't say that.

PeterSo you were was it deputy when

DameDeputy Chief Medical Office.

Peterthe whole thing hit. So how do you like so

NickThis is a branding issue and I need both your advice on this because you know once a deputy always a deputy I'm not likely to be a CEO anytime soon and I keep getting introduced as the former deputy chief medical officer There's

DameIt's a l a lot of caveats.

Nicka lot of caveats

PeterThat's

NickAnyway I'm looking I'm looking for a rebrand so I did that and

PeterBut how did you get there? Like you'd worked in the public sector

NickI had, I mean there's a very specific way that I got there. I was up in Darwin working for the National Critical Care Trauma Response Centre, another mouthful, but this is the mob that goes overseas when there's a disaster and the Prime Minister decides to send someone over, bit of flag waving, but hopefully saving some lives as well. So we were working there for four years, that was the first place I became a specialist. There was that policy developing the north, which I think was previous coalition policy. and I did develop the North. We built a house, had two more kids, all in the space of four years. Up in Darwin? Up in Darwin. Fantastic place. In order to be sent overseas, these medical groups had to be sent over by not only the FM, but also by the Australian Health Protection Principle Committee, so that all the chief health officers would get the staff released and off we'd go. So within the architecture, I was a sort of familiar face. And I had a background in respiratory medicine and infectious diseases. sort of helpful in COVID and I knew the players. So this was not a position that had advertised for. In fact, you might remember that there was no Deputy Chief Medical Officer position until Greg Hunt announced it at a press conference and he announced Paul Kelly first and then they realised they needed more people.

PeterYeah.

DameBecause Brendan Murphy was the the chief medical officer at the time. Yeah. He was the first up who was he was the existing chief medical officer. And then Paul Kelly yourself

NickSo I get a call around about early March of 2020 and Paul Kelly asks me We need more firepower, we need more people. We particularly need someone who's got experience in hospitals and can bridge the gap between public health and hospital doctors and nurses and staff and so on and so forth. And that is true. The health department doesn't have anyone like that. so for the next six months, I was that person. And for the subsequent 12 months, because I went back to Canberra Health Services, everyone, I mean, it was hard to release the senior person from a health service to the feds at that point. It took me back to the Canberra Health Service but I stayed on as a vaccine communication sort of person. No, no, very much a hospital doctor. Hospital doctors. So fundamentalist public hospital doctor. the ground. Never been much into private medicine. I've been doing that for, I suppose 10 years as a specialist and 10 years prior to that as a trainee.

PeterAnd then COVID hits and all of a sudden public health specialists become rock stars. Like the world there's one story in the world and you are the experts in it. Like I'm interested in that experience of kind of going from someone that just does their job to being, you know, and I I think it's fair to say you're probably superficially attractive and so you like an and the profession tends to

NickIt's the rotten corp!

DameIt's like we don't know if you're actually attractive, we just know that you're superficially

PeterLike books on everything, but

NickPeel away those layers!

Peterbut at a time when and let's be honest, like I've worked around public health that they tend to be dowdy. beige. Yeah.

NickYeah,

DameWhat Dorian Gray contract he made with the devil, I call

PeterI was just saying like what was the experience of all of a sudden being like this voice in the middle of it and they put you out a lot? Yeah. And you had to keep trust and confidence and what's your reflections now and all that?

NickYeah, mean, it almost depends on what mood I'm in at the time when that question's asked. I'll try and be relatively consistent with what I say, but the first... The first time I was really in front of the cameras was at a press conference with Maurice Payne and Greg Hunt and we were announcing the number of ventilators that we were going to procure. We'll get into the whys and wherefores of that number and why it all fell apart 45 minutes later. the experience of being there and walking in Parliament House and actually being there at a presser, that was unlike anything I'd ever done before. I mean, to the point that... I'd obviously done public speaking before, I could string a yarn, all those sort of things, I could communicate, but I'd never been thrust into that sort of position. And I remember starting to talk. And I still, I'd love to, I'd love, if Phil Koury is watching this, I've always wanted to ask him, I see him a fair bit, so I should just go and ask him. He looked at me and then just gets this little wry smile on his face, just as I start to talk.

PeterThe trick is never to look at anyone, you look just to the left of the camera.

NickYeah right. That's not what I think he was doing. I think he was going, hang on, like we haven't heard this voice

DameIt's like this is gonna be fun.

Nickbefore. This is someone and something new and it was. We all brought something new to it.

PeterIt wasn't just getting a grab on the news, the whole nation was watching every single press conference. Like and I was someone that while Damien was saving the country, I was in my attic trying to work out how to use Zoom, but everyone was watching what you guys were doing. I'm interested how important good communications was for the job the government was doing through that. How did

DameI mean okay, th not to not

Peteryou guys become buddies?

DameI mean I d don't want to talk up or or it's for other people to reflect on on how the period went, but we were certainly flat out trying to communicate the moving feast that in the first instance was, if you remember the term, flattening the curve. Yeah. and it's one of those things where Australia had never been publicly communicated to en masse in a digital first environment. Like we'd we'd never had if you think back to like world wars and things like that, where people, you know, you have those nostalgic images of like you know, fight for your country or enlist now. Like that kind of mass effort had never happened in Australia in a in a digital communications environment. So there there were things that w nobody knew how to do, like you know, getting outdoor billboard providers to coordinate, you know, when we put things up, how we put them up, going, hey, we're not going to follow your two-week media cycles. We might need to put something up with two hours notice or one hour notice. So we need to be able to do like there was just a lot of creating new things that had never been done before. Thankfully everyone was happy to play along because everyone's like shit, we're all in this together. We we need to figure out a way to make this

PeterYeah, there was incredible goodwill as we said before, even from my side of politics to the effort you were doing. What did the government look like from where you were sitting when you're going out there to deliver the messages? Like how

NickAlright.

Peterdo you mark these guys?

Nickin the initial period, 12 out of 10. Like, I they were extraordinarily focused. I had never seen anyone work as hard as our minister at the time, Greg Hunt. It was just astonishing. The work rate of Hunt and Murphy, you know, the people within the PM's office, the PM himself, and cascading all the way around the Fed, it was extraordinary. And I think this is the thing that really was invisible. The 3am calls trying to get a billion dollars. probably was a billion dollars in total, but $10 million worth of personal protective equipment off the tarmac from China when we literally had ally nations, there's pretty much only one that can do it, know, gazumping us and taking that stuff off the tarmac and those negotiations going on at the highest possible level, extraordinary, extraordinary times.

PeterLike, in retrospect, the institutions held up, didn't they? So we we wring our hands about it but as opposed to many other countries, things held together.

NickLook, I think the institutions held up at the time. I think what we're seeing now with... You know, I just did this PhD and I know we're going to talk about it later, but there's these concepts of critical junctures, these huge crisis events that shift people's view of politics and the world and the way things operate. And whilst our institutions held up and responded very well, I think the real challenge for our institutions is now because of how... how far we went with some of the impositions on our human and individual rights and what that has done as a sort of the kerosene on the fire of social media. You know this is interesting, I'd love your view on this Pete, but I take the view that the left side of politics ultimately just blames social media for all this, whereas I sit there and go yeah well social media will amplify anything that's a problem. The fundamental problem was We went a long way further and I said I marked it as 12 out of 10 to start, I would have given us a 5 out of 10 towards the end of 2021.

PeterSo what where was the shift for you? Like where do you go from twelve? So twelve was the lockdown and five was the dis

Nick12 was the flattening the curve. Then we get into crush the curve. Then we get into every Australian listening to the Chief Health Officers instead of thinking a little bit about...

DameThe the numbers chasing, right? We maybe we got into that phase after we f flattened the curve where it's like today there was three

NickAnd you know what, I'm not going to blame Victoria or Brett Zun or anyone for that because it Greg that started that. And I remember distinctly at the time when Greg was announcing these and saying, you know, every death, like every death he would use the word tragic. And I went, hang on, this is going to be a problem. Like I couldn't quite articulate why in the way I could now.

PeterThat balancing act between the impact of the virus and the broader impacts. Which I remember there was this economist that was trying to make this point and she just got hailed down as well. Yeah, no Yeah,

NickYou're faster.

Peterso she had a c but and it is interesting reflecting back, and I think we might get there with a when we talk about your your conspiracy theory podcast, but it did feel at the time like there there was this national view that we were crushing it because we because that was the indicator that we'd set ourselves and then it's only in retrospect I think we're seeing this playing out in Victoria now where people are going, did we overplay our hand here? And I do think particularly the way that there was this sort of virtue signalling around a lot of the public health measures and everything and I I think at the time I think a lot of it was well intentioned. It was like this sense that if you don't wear a mask or if you don't sit then you don't care about the health of an old person who's

NickThere is no doubt that it was well intentioned. Similarly, very high tobacco excise is a well intentioned policy.

DameBut and and you're right, like that that doesn't mean it's good, right? Because if you you know the the positive spin on it is we as a country got through COVID with minimal deaths and a very high vaccination rate within a reasonable time frame and we came out of all right, right? That's if you wanted to paint the golden picture, you'd do that. If you wanted to paint the inverse, which you very well could, is we as a federation, number one, closed borders to one another's citizens for a medical crisis where we became so abused Obsessed with the individual numbers of deaths. And yes, every death is a tragedy. But as a doctor, you know that death is also a very natural part of life, and this is a thing that happens day in, day out in every hospital that doesn't get talked about. And worse, from a liberal perspective, is we threw out our core values. We literally sat there and went, actually, economic rationalism doesn't matter. You can dig into your whole And we're gonna give every business a bunch of money. Screw it, we'll just get ourselves into debt. And you go, hang on a minute, but what about our principles? And even John Howard got up and went, Well, in times of crisis, you've got to put this stuff aside. And you go, But Mr. Howard, that's not a principle anymore if you put it aside.

NickI think you can put it aside and I think as a result of COVID, there's going to be a lot of developing or developed economies that if faced with another crisis will pull the Keynesian lever again. That is kind of the thing that you do now. No, no, the back, not the back hall. I'm just, I'm just sort of trying to respond to the, was there an opportunity for Morrison and Hunt and Cabinet to sit there and go, actually, no, we're going to be liberals on this. I'm not sure there was, but the problem is, and this is the reflection for the future, once you choose to go down that path and see

PeterNo one dies, no business goes broke, so you're just trying to hold things.

NickYou're trying to hold things with policies that you would consider left of centre. Then try to hold that back. trying to drag that back, you get on this path dependency and you see towards the end of 2020, which is where I think the wheel started falling off, know, Hunt and Frydenberg couldn't say anything to Dan Andrews about that horrible, massive third lockdown or second or third lockdown it was. they were...

PeterI think in retrospect is still brutalizing Victoria.

NickIt's still brutalising it. there was just some really interesting dynamics there about once you make decisions in crisis, really do set yourself, regardless of which side of politics you're on, you set yourself down a particular path.

DameNo, I would agree with No, no, I d I I just think though the the the financial measures, which I think are easier to debate than some of the health measures, because the health measures become a question of life or death, so they become very emotionally heated. But the financial measures you go, Well, did we need to do Like did we like what is the financial cost that we are now paying in the form of crazy amounts of inflation, crazy national debt? Like wasn't

PeterWasn't that the political calculus from you guys? No one could you couldn't tolerate a death that you a preventable death and you could not tolerate a preventable bankruptcy. So you made the political calculus and I think label would have made the same calculus.

DameIt's such an easy thing to defend, but once you start feeding the public that opiate, it's really hard to take them off that opiate. And we're seeing that now because governments go, well, if we just pump more money into the economy, people will be happy. That is a really hard drug to wean people off.

NickIt is. On the lighter side, I do have to ask you, mate, the COVID 3, I mean, where did that come from? Because this is where you and I met on Ward 7A, which was deserted in Canberra Hospital. And I was picked as the guy who would wear a white shirt and a stethoscope and talk about the COVID 3, which I can't even remember which infection control measure.

DameSo that with the COVID three, so before we came up with the term covert safe, which I just never want to hear again, but the COVID three was distancing yours washing your hands, distancing yourself and something else.

Nickand something or other it wasn't masks quite yet but that was that had to be the worst ad ever made like I think Todd Sampson in his doji is going to be on ABC looking at that going wow.

DameTell you what, the best ad we made during that series, because obviously we had a whole bunch of stuff in the can and it was actually quite a funny story. So we we we had experienced and seen like some people who in the early stages where COVID was quite severe, right? If you remember the first variations was

Nickabsolutely severe.

DameSevere disease. And some of these, especially younger people who had caught COVID, I mean, you know, you know, women in their thirties or whatever, they when they would catch COVID and it had affected them, they would be taken into the respiratory wards and they would be struggling to breathe. Part of the reason was like that they'd never experienced this kind of respiratory distress before. So they were they were wheezing and coughing and unable to like catch their breath. Basically, like you go from zero to still

NickIt's quick, you finish the story and then I'll...

DameWell I just gonna say so we we we wanted to capture this as a bit of a like, hey, this is the reality of what it could be.

NickHey.

DameYeah. And we we had forgotten some footage and we're like, all right, well we can't go in there and like film it's like one of the doctors had taken on their iPhone. We needed to film it as a ad. So we got an actor to come in and basically replicate what that person in the ward was doing like for like. And then we showed it to a few focus groups and people being like, Hey, you know, is it like would this help you to go and get your vaccine or whatever it was? and people were like, Well no, that's not realistic at all. Like it's just too over the top, it's too crazy. So we actually had to pair back the ad to make it seem

NickLook, I remember this very, very clearly because you guys came to me and said, is this realistic? And before I went out to the focus groups. I think when people ask, I've never said this on a podcast before, so this is an exclusive, but I've certainly thought it. When people say, is there anything you would have done differently? You know, when I saw that, the first thing I really should have thought was actually, if I look at the stats, the likelihood of this happening to a 30 year old woman is tiny. And we knew that at the time and this is where the critique starts to have some validity. What did you know when and did it, should it have shaped your decision making differently? Well certainly the picture of an otherwise healthy young adult female in respiratory failure due to COVID was not entirely accurate because that happened so very rarely. Now by contrast if you'd stuck a 60 year old woman or man it would have been more accurate and I think When the far-right sits there and goes, it was convict, it never happened, you made all these, you were trying to scare us. It's like well, look, we had some pretty devastating images coming out of Northern Italy.

PeterYeah.

DameAnd the U Yeah, the US.

PeterLining up like like the public hospital wards and the numbers like

Nickoverflowing and we were hearing from credible people, credible ED clinicians in New York telling us just how bad it was. Now, I was always of the view that our health system would cope better and our public health system would cope better, but we were genuinely worried. It's just, I think the thing to go back and ask, if we were ever to have a forensic look in the form of a Royal Commission, it's when was the earliest evidence available about the demographic that this affected? And then the explanation for what we did is, know, Australians don't like seeing a single death from Meninga Cockle B on the front of the Herald Sun. They don't like it. We've got a low public pain tolerance, particularly for infectious diseases, and were we to lose retiree Australians who were just starting their retirement and enjoying their life with their grandkids and great grandkids, that would have been intolerable and rightly so. And that's why we did what we did.

DameSwedes the Swedes and their sorry, their midsummer attitude of like when you become you know, a burden to the community, you throw yourself off the top of a cliff, which is like you know, that Swedish kind of mentality. Very Viking. It is very Viking. But

NickBurning ship.

Dameth but it's built into the a lot of the Nordic countries, like that's why they took such a different approach, because they went, Well, you know, you you're you're elderly, you've lived a good life and you know it's up to you to figure out how to survive this and if you don't, well okay, well that's all right.

PeterSo last question before we kind of move into your your next phase. So the the lockdown of schools, like or the closure of schools. Like what's in retrospect, what's your take on

NickNo retrospect needed, Like I have the receipts for this. was on Q &A with Angelo Gavrilatos from the union here in New South Wales and the principal, a young female principal of Whittle C High down in Victoria and both of them were arguing for school closures and I was passionate.

PeterThe basis of the teacher's help.

Nickon the basis of the teacher's health. And I was passionately arguing against it. I was always

DameYou've been dead s you were always

Nickdead set against the school closures.

PeterSo

DameSo

PeterCOVID kind of it does it hasn't ended, but the vaccines arrive. We'll save the story of the the rollout of vaccines for another day 'cause that probably wasn't

NickIt's a very different story as well.

PeterBut

DameSo

Peteryou finish up there, you go and do this PhD in what we could learn, which sounds like a good way of getting a book out.

NickYeah, well, could be a book. I'm interested to see what Josh says about that period when his book comes out.

PeterAnd then the other thing you've been doing is Conspiracy Cabal, a podcast about conspiracy and I must say when Dame said, yeah, y we gotta have Nick on, he's doing conspiracy podcasts, I said, is he gone cooker? Yeah. but it's not that, is it? And I've listened to it, it's fantastic. And you're basically p packing where where there is a conspiracy, then you are going back with Richard Baker who's fantastic journalist and going through the evidence base. So tell us what got you into thinking that was how you'd wanna spend your time.

NickLook it took me a year to get myself around to thinking I should do this because I was worried exactly as you framed it Once he's gone full He's gone conspiracy

PeterYeah.

Nicktheorist it funnily enough I have found the one that I completely believe in we can get into that in a second I I got approached by rich so 12 months before we launched and he said listen. I've got this idea That we're both credible. We can both research it. It'll be a bit of fun You know, the kernel or the seed started to develop and then 12 months later we kicked it off. And really what attracted me to these stories was the storytelling element to it and understanding that, you know, throughout COVID and amidst all the information or misinformation, whatever you want to call it, actually they're stories and it's how the stories are relayed. And if you can understand why people believe what they do, and have a rational, and not necessarily a rational discussion, but have a reasonable discussion over a beer about what they do or don't believe in, then you can connect with them on some sort of level. So that attracted me to it on a huge scale.

PeterYou can kind of build in that fact base. One of my favorite American writers, Kurt Anderson, had this amazing book, Haywire, How America Lost Its Mind. And his theory was that the conspiracy ecosystem had been a result of two things: postmodernism in the 60s with the undermining of truth and then the internet. So you had the undermining of truth and then the distribution network, and then that went into overdrive during COVID. But I'm interested in, given your conspiracy theory discipline now. you know, the big one at the time was Wilhelm Lableek. so before I ask you for your hot take on that, like how do you think about something like that?

NickI mean, think when you think about conspiracy, there is a sort of scientific way that I think about it and that's sort of Bayesian probabilities. So given a certain set of circumstances that we know, how plausible is the outcome? Now, you sit there and go, okay, most of the infectious diseases we know, they don't do a species jump, they do species incursions. They're like little spies coming in and we know about it and we've got some sort of signal and then they'll be human to human transmitting. So already the bar that you have to go to to get to the Pangolin being the real culprit in this is being raised.

DameAnd these zoonotic transfers, they're not common, are they?

NickThey're not exceptionally common. That's what we always worry about. But take Ebola virus, instance. That circulates regularly between humans and the zoonotic host. But we know that that's been doing it and it sort of evolves and we don't think that it's made a huge jump. So was the pangolin ever plausible? I think if we genuinely sat down and thought... you know, based on what we understand about the dynamics of infectious diseases, did this come from the wet market? Before the the pandemic, if you presented that to an infectious disease doctor as a scenario, they would have said no, less likely. you've also got a lab, the lab in the same city where it and we know

DameIt's a lot of coincidence.

NickAnd we know that gain of function research was going on there. so, you know, just on these, discussion alone, and this is how we interrogate conspiracies in the cabal, you sit there and go, well, what's more probable? Occam's razor. Occam's razor, the simplest explanation is the one. So, and I think there's the only other thing I would say is that you've also got the geopolitics of this. You've got two global hegemons that have an equal gain to be made by pushing their version of

PeterBut it was also interesting, Dame, how that debate was shut down. And was that a public health measure? Was that driven by government or was that driven by the herd?

DameI would I would argue that it was a combination of government and media. So I I think for that rare period of time, government and media were very in lockstep. So during the pandemic period, you you'll notice there wasn't a lot of media outliers. Like ever there would be a few journalists here and there, but in general, the media establishment as a whole and the government were all swimming in the same direction, which is a very, very rare thing. So I think more than anything, they both simultaneously

PeterAlbo had made the strategic decision not to play silly buggers. So then there was no questioning of anything going on with the need.

NickThere was actually no need to question that narrative because we were fighting, the virus was here, we were fighting. It

DameThat was kind of a

PeterIt w

Nickwas kind of irrelevant. mean, where it becomes relevant is the geopolitics, is calling for China to have a more thorough investigation, all that kind of stuff. But purely on the public health terms, was that question relevant in April and May of 2020? No.

DameBecause but but then you look at other countries where they didn't where they did like violently oppose any form of lockdown and I I refer specifically to my homelands in Eastern Europe where, unlike Australia, rebellion is a core component of their personal their cultural personality. It didn't matter whether or not the virus was here, out of spite, they would not be locked down. They're like n you no disease will stop me from going to my auntie's house for a coffee at eight PM if I want to. I will not tolerate a government saying to me I can't do this for XYZ reason whereas Australians are it's a terrible word to use, but we are much more compliant with institutional direction and for better or worse, I would argue that's for worse, but that's the society we have here.

NickWell it was for better at the time. There's no doubt about it. Objectively a lot fewer.

PeterBut the other

DameAgain, if you value that over people's freedom. That's a philosophical question to have.

PeterBut other thing interesting on the wheel hand bit just was that It was also removed from all the digital platforms, right? So there was this whole thing of stopping disinformation. I think that's had a real impact on our ability post pandemic to actually build platform accountability for the really bad stuff because when they exercised their power, it was over something that I think the revisionist history is gonna say that it was an open debate. And I I and you say on on the balance of probabilities whether or not it was the important question at the time. And there was probably also an element of social cohesion because there was that anecdotal that then it was the Wilhelm flu and then Asians were being blamed in America and Australia, whatever and totally unfairly of course but

DameIt was it was a like on on reflection now with sober minds, it was a crazy period and you know we we should at some point microscopically look through and go. Someone should do a PhD on it. But someone should

NickBut think...

DameThe things we're seeing like the rise of the right.

Peterwent to did did we take too long to close?

NickNo, no, it was just asking ourselves, well, we just signed off on a document in 2019, which said that we were going to manage a pandemic flu within borders. We were going to let it in. And yet within 80 days, we'd managed to shut the entire country to travel. the whole world did the same. So we weren't a particularly unique nation, but very few people have gone in and asked themselves why, how does the political class get themselves to the point where they can take this sort of measure? Everybody's just assumed was normatively the correct thing to do so no one's asked that question.

DameYeah.

PeterIt's interesting, we were scared and we expected the state to

DameInto it.

Peterintervene and we our trust in government went up, we thanked them and now we I'm not saying we've got buyers regret 'cause a lot of people that wouldn't have been alive otherwise. But there is this sort of reca and I think on both sides of politics it was like, you know, what did we give up in order to meet that objective? Which again I Glad you guys were making those decisions, not me. Hey, the other conspiracy theory of course is the vaccines. Like I was up in in T. All the number of people that say, I'm glad to put that shit up your arm and like there it it's residual, isn't it? Yeah. And has that created broader public

NickHuge public health problems. the measles bumps, rubella rates are down at 70 % in some parts of Australia. Those were already parts that were problematic but 70 % is low.

PeterYeah.

NickAnd so this is that argument again that you know whilst whilst we've got RFK Junior and we've got Joe Rogan we've got all these people that are sprouting vaccine disinformation and the fact that people can hold on to the pandemic and then every little thing that we might have done wrong or explained wrong or the timing was wrong they point at the institution of government and say you got a wrong ergo I'm right not what I'm saying is right I'm right because you were wrong and there's an Good.

DameAnd I mean this is a I'm gonna kind of try and tie this into what's happening with the tobacco excise now, which is I think it's fair to say to people, look, there's a vaccine available, if you want it, go get it. If you choose not to have it, that's okay because at this point you understand the material consequences of not taking that vaccine, both to yourself and to others around you. At what point do we go, well, people are adults, we're in an adult society, and they should have the freedom to make that choice? Like Which is kind of what's happening with tobacco as well, right? It's like we people like this is still a legal product that is sold on almost every street corner in the country, and yet we're trying to treat it as though, no, actually this is some kind of underground product that you shouldn't be able to have access to, this, that and the other. Like these are

NickWell that, you've just hit the nail on the head of the difference in philosophy between myself and what I would call the more establishment public health fraternity. They have said enough in the media to make me think that they genuinely don't want cigarettes available anywhere in this country.

PeterBut isn't that s so from the cheap seats, the evidence that tobacco is lethal had been growing, it was denied, they reached a point where, particularly around workplaces, couldn't smoke inside anymore. and then I the public health and initiative to increase taxes worked Because A it stopped as many people smoking and B, it brought a lot of money into government. And it's it feels to me it's almost just reached a point now where it's almost created the obvious conspiracy, if it is in even a conspiracy, that the p the prices have inflated so much that there is going to be something to fill the void. So, you know, give me the conspiracy cabal take on tobacco and the black market because it feels kind of inevit inevitable.

NickWell, I mean, the cabal take this the episode we did on illicit tobacco was was the least conspiratorial of all because we thought that these were just facts that were not adequately being reported, which was the extent of organized crime, the fraying of the social fabric. I mean, it's in the news now in New South Wales. We have that poor young fellow who got shot in mistaken identity. You cannot tell me that those criminal elements are not involved in illicit tobacco. If you're not involved in illicit tobacco and you're criminal in this country, you're pretty...

DameYeah.

NickSo it's all fomenting this disruption to the social fabric. That's the conspiracy. The conspiracy is that we're not for some reason as a society, although I would argue now the general community, like with COVID during Omicron, they're getting to a tipping point where the epistemic group, which is the academics who are saying keep the excise high, their influence is going to steadily diminish because the community is going to move. I think that dials.

Peterit's to date it's been like a victimless crime, like except for poor people who smoke a rise in the price. But now it's creating this other market, so there's actually now a cost benefit.

DameBut but I mean so I agree with you, especially with the the wonks in Woden who make these decisions and feels as though for those who don't

NickBe a wonky white.

Dameknow. So Woden is where the n the Commonwealth Department of Health is based and wonderful place though it is. i it does feel like the the wonks of the Department of Health in Woden have not lived a day in a normal life outside of the bubble within a bubble within a bubble.

NickWe should just be honest about what a bureaucracy is. mean, there's no point in attacking the bureaucrats. And to be honest, the APS, as I said at the start, the Australian Public Service, absolutely shone during crisis. But Canberra is two and a half thousand square kilometres surrounded by reality. There's nothing about that. And it's a very different, it's like the viewers of The Truman Show, it's The Truman Show. And so you're going to have problems with people within the Truman bubble making rational policy for people who live in the western suburbs of Melbourne.

PeterSo you feel like there has to be a certain number of smokers in every government group that is making a decision about

NickI'm going to buy some double happiness and Chesterfields. I'm going take them in. I'm going to buy them from the Griffith survey and take them in.

DameIt it is and mean I I kind of understand the academic argument of look, you know, you might increase the smoking rates if you lower the excise. But I think the reality is that the smoking rate has been pretty stable for quite some time now, not just in Australia, but in a lot of markets where they don't have the excise that we do. Now, of course, if it's too cheap, the smoking rate does go up, but smoking seems to be one of those things where the rate of smoking is more reinforced or punished by the social currency that it holds rather than the amount of

NickThat would be my view. mean, I just can't see a 17-year-old taking up smoking because the Winnie Blues now cost 25 bucks at the IGA. Because of all the other tobacco control measures that are around. And in any case, that 17-year-old is not getting their first durry from the IGA. They're getting one double happiness stick from a guy on a work site as their first pass.

PeterSweet vibes.

Nickor a sweet vape with so much nicotine in them that you know I had a I had my niece come down here from the UK where of course there's regulated vapes and they're in the other direction they've got you know lots of colors they're all made by big tobacco and it's terrible and they're trying to push it to a more plain packaging you know unflavored vape but their regulated vapes are low nicotine content. Where she came here, she had her first puff of way, nearly blew her head off. So we're petrified about addicting a new generation to nicotine whilst we're creating the very market where that's possible.

DameBut that and that's exactly like as though we'd learnt nothing from all the prohibitions that have happened in history. Like it it feels like a mistake that we're keen to repeat over and over. I I obviously was a you know a two-pack a day smoker for a very long part of my life and I got switched by a GP thankfully to the medicinal vapes, which are the ones where they're you know they're not allowed to have any flavour, that it's just plain tobacco, so it's just glycerine and nicotine in it essentially, with a controlled nicotine dose in it. But trying to get a pharmacy to Yeah. They're all like it's too much procedure.

PeterStraddling a hobby horse here. so what's your what's your thing, like what what what's your call on this issue?

NickExcise has got to come down, absolutely got to come down radically. You've got to get smokers back into the legal market because that's where we've got most chance of getting them to quit. We don't have much of a chance in the illicit market of getting them to quit because it's easily accessible, it's cheap and all their mates are doing it. if we want to change that social dial, it's got to be within a legal market. The other thing that we've got to do is you're lucky to find a GP, would actually have done that for you because the prevailing view of the Australian Medical Association, the Cancer Council, the Lung Foundation and nearly every doctor in this country in contrast to the rest of the world is that vapes are bad

DameSo as bad if not worse for the debate.

Nickif not worse. Whereas the highest level of medical evidence that we've got says that they should be first line for people like you who are two pack a day smokers. We have a medical fraternity that's got its head stuck in the sand.

DameAnd look really bizarre. I'll be honest, no, like I've I've no financial or otherwise interest in any of these products, but I've gone from two packs a day to I will have one analogue cigarette maybe every week. Yep. And that's happened in a period of six months. Yeah, and that repeated. And now I've been able to start reducing the nicotine. Thank you're very nice. But like the the the ability to get off the cigarettes after, you know, twenty years of smoking almost two packs a day, like that's not a small thing to do. And without like a good GP who's willing to go through the process and a pharmacy who was willing to stock it. But again, like the process of doing that took forever.

NickNow I've got to say that that's not to say that you should stop here. Yeah, like your next step

DameIs to keep reducing yeah, exactly. And but that's what they're reducing the you know, there's a planned reduction of nicotine content in each of them. So I've slowly been going down and that's a great thing. I would have never done that with a cigarette. Yeah.

PeterHey Nick, Little Bird tells me you're gonna do something pretty insane and have a look at going into the public realm. What the hell and what flavour and what's your

NickWell, you asked me, why I do conspiracy cabal and that's so I can pull the rug out from underneath any political career that I

PeterI was thinking it'd be a great job running when I thought you were a cooker against me. Like doing the dirt unit on you is gonna be fertile ground.

NickWe've got 25 episodes of Nick talking shit and wearing a ringer's western truckers cap.

PeterBut you're looking at it.

NickIt's a niche that I'd love to scratch. Yeah, I think so and I'll tell you why I just I just think that there's You know, there's probably there's probably not enough people who've done different stuff in politics I think that's probably a truism. Yeah, you guys would have heard that I said it before so and and that's not to say that it has to be everyone in their late 40s early 50s who who turns around and wants to do politics, but you got to have some sort of sort of balance there and and look I think there's a fair chance that I'd have a crack. I'd do it on the blue side.

PeterYeah. What what's what's landed you there apart from him?

NickI'm absolutely screwing up my preselection. Although Brendan Nelson I think was someone.

PeterBrendan Nelson was this weird like he was AMA, he kind of wore an earring and then he became liberal. All you're missing

NickRight? Later.

Peteris the earring, yeah.

NickLook, I think... The pandemic did shift the way I thought about what the foundational moral, ethical, philosophical points are that I start from. And from there, I'm prepared to go left, right, up, down. You were talking about three dimensions of polling. It's almost four dimensions.

DameYeah.

Peterthe system not outside like so you know you put your hand up for one nation you're in parliament next term

NickWell, that has been put to me.

DameYeah.

NickI am unfortunately not. That's

DameYou know that crazy.

Nickthe world. I mean, look, I don't.

DameThat's right, you can get voted in on one nation and just leave the party. Like so many others are probably gonna do

PeterYeah.

NickI just find it really interesting that people can ignore Hanson's comments about DV and there being no Muslims that, what did she say, there's no peaceful Muslims.

PeterI couldn't think of anything worse than putting your hand up for public life. A lot of my life decisions have been to totally

DameTo avoid it

Peterthat that would ever be the thing that would hit me when I was having my midlife crisis. But

DameI'd do it either if I'd be perfectly honest. Like I genuinely I I think no party will ever have me, let's be honest. I applaud people who who do put their hand up and we've talked about this a lot. I I believe that The more we get away from institutional politicians who've followed the pathway of if you're in Labour, you know, doing the union thing and then getting into a Senate seat and then getting into a safe, you know, lower house seat, or if you're on the liberal side of stuff, it's Sydney University with a law degree, then getting into the young liberals. Like these standard pathways are not producing the caliber of representational leadership that Australia deserves. And having more people from a diversity of backgrounds rather than just lawyers and economists which we do need some lawyers and economists, not this many.

PeterIt was interesting, one of the the the byproducts of Labour's wave last time was there was a whole lot of normal people that entered the parliament because they weren't the ones that were in the the winnable seats.

DameNo one expected Charlotte Walker to be a senator. Like do you know I mean? Like that that

PeterThe guy down in Cook as well. but what's it wasn't Cook, it was Hughes, first time ever. But so what's your game plan? Like is like had have you do you have to go and

NickI look at very early days, like this is about as much as I've...

PeterSo are you announcing publicly on what's your poison? Are we gonna sort

DameMm.

Peterof put the sentence?

NickI in the Daily Mail about two years ago. Apparently. You

PeterIs that a newspaper?

Nickdon't pay your 99 cents a year for that.

PeterI definitely don't.

DameBut you should if you if you do decide to run, I think there's definitely a great behind the scenes documentary series in it. So I think that's

Nickor conspiracy cabal.

DameBecause Conspiracy Good Bob, but like just following that adventure. Because I think for a lot of people who aren't inside the tent, the process of becoming pre-selected, the process of going through the party mechanism and then going through an actual election is actually a really fascinating process that doesn't really get exposed in an interesting way ever to the Australian people. And I think people like yourself who come from I'm gonna call it normal backgrounds, I think normal people would be interested in that story and be would want to to follow it and see.

Nickwant to produce it lads then or maybe we just do a little doco pod.

PeterBut just back to conspiracy, 'cause I think the c th the existence of the conspiracy is actually an expression of lack of faith in the the system. I've always said the conspiracy is there's no conspiracy, it's just the way the system works and then people get surprised. So everything from, you know, corruption in the building industry, like that's not a conspiracy, that's the way that industry works, sort of pharmaceuticals, like you know politics, everything everything's got a game book and people aren't aware of it. And so where I think what you're doing is quite interesting is this little coda between being the public health expert and whether or not you become a public figure. It's just sort of saying evidence is kind of important. Yeah.

NickThat's what the cabal's all about and I'm glad you like it. We obviously want more people listening to it. Same here.

PeterThat's our concern.

DameThey'll put in the show notes.

Nickdo!

PeterYeah, what's your favorite conspiracy? Yeah.

NickBefore I get to that, just want to that one thing that I learnt was from the National Congressional Electoral Survey in the US, it's an ongoing survey that they do, apparently the belief in chemtrails, know chemtrails, know, strontium and all that kind of stuff that's supposed to be seeding the clouds, it's not just vapour. extraordinarily highly believed in the US and it splits even between Democrats and Republicans. How's that? That's crazy. That's really interesting. Bipartisan. Yeah, bipartisan.

Peterpartisans conspiracy to unify the nation

DameIt is my my my favorite is so I not my favorite but like in Eastern Europe in the Balkans there's still a weird conspiracy fear around microwaves. so like when you go to the Balkans, if you go to, you know, Serbia, Montenegro, Bulgaria, Macedonia, Albania, whatever, nobody has a microwave because they still genuinely believe that a microwave is gonna like radiate you and make you infertile and all this kind of stuff. And but the thing is it's got a basis in that the very first generation of microwaves, which they never had because they were all under communism or socialism didn't have correct shielding around. So there was like a handful of like horror stories from the US being like actually that they're radiated, blah blah blah. And then every microwave manufacturer went, right, okay, if we shield this thing, the microwave radiation doesn't spill out. The problem was solved in the 50s or 60s or whatever, but it persists. And whenever you're over there and you just want to like use a heat pack or heat up some water or something, nobody like nobody has them at the back

NickNobody uses them.

Dameof the electronics shop, like, you want a microwave? Are you sure?

PeterSo my favorite conspiracy theory was birds aren't real. Did you hear about which was this guy who was almost like a performance political activist who just started turning up at rallies with this sign saying birds aren't real and he had and the theory was the CIA in the fifties had killed all the birds and turned them into surveillance

DameDr. Smith.

Peterdrugs. And he put out this document, they had him up on he he did Fox News and everything and this guy going, Well there's two sides to every story. There is some evidence you should live. And I I I went to the stage, I got quite obsessed with it. They had a book and everything. I bought I bought the T shirt but it was really cheap so the thing washed off after the But birds aren't really my favorite conspiracy.

DameThat in Australia is not real is the other one that's quite good. That there's an internet conspiracy that Australia's a made up place and that we're all actors. we're living with conspiracy. So e this is a good one to do some research on. So there's an internet conspiracy that Australia is entirely made up. We are definitely doing. And that anyone with an Australian actor is actually wi with an Australian accent is an actor and we're all playing along with this conspiracy that Australia is a real place. Who knew? And sorry, you're

NickIt's us. right. Mine's the ancients. So I'm a believer in Graham Hancock, fingerprints of the gods. He's kind of a little bit of a fringe archaeologist. But he reckons there was something around 10,000 15,000 BC that died out in a deluge, which is why you've got common flood myths around the world. But there was some remnant knowledge that made it to the Egyptians and the Incas and the Mayas.

DameYeah.

NickYeah, there's all that yeah, he goes through all of that stuff. Yeah, similar sort of stuff. He's just had Netflix. He's had a resurgence at the age of 75. He's on Rougan, diarrhea as CEO. He's everywhere this guy.

DameWhere was this civilization meant to have existed?

NickNo idea. Yeah, right. There is a is a map called the period race map that was turned up in Turkey This is this is all actually true where they they draw a part of Antarctica. That's actually The land that no one could have seen until we got ultrasonic technology to actually map properly so that that that is and he's it he just asks really reasonable questions, which is you know, why did this why does this happen? Why does civilization have a have a guy with a beard as a god like who was who was that guy.

PeterScrew facial hair.

NickI think the issue was that they looked a little bit like they were Caucasian and so he got in lot of trouble actually. People who didn't like him called him a colonialist and a white supremacist because he was hopping around.

DameDo you do you buy into the theory or are you are you saying

NickI find it really interesting and I like the way that Hancock sort of goes. Look there are some things that are not explained well by... archaeologists. A good one, good example is the pyramids. How do you actually get the blocks up? Well, there is a way. If you've got 27 people, men, can push a block up a seven degree incline with some water on it and it can just be a sandy base and you'll do it. Two to three tonnes, not a problem. The problem is what do do about the scaffold? Because the scaffold's got to be like three or four times the size of the Great Pyramid for it to happen. And everybody's just sort of shrugged their shoulders and yeah, yeah, was a scaffold.

DameI don't

PeterI should just keep you talking for Paul Erickson.

NickYeah, keep recording Paul. There's great material here mate.

DameThat is very fascinating. But I I I

NickWe've all got a conspiracy, it doesn't matter.

DameI love the fact that like different conspiracies appeal to something in different people. Like there there's there's some kind of like core whether it's like a childhood thing or something that you want to believe in.

NickAnd some of the stuff we talk about is not conspiracy, it's just mysteries. There's some great mysteries around Australia, unsolved disappearances. Fred Valentic who went down in the Bath Strait and nobody ever found his body or his plane. Harold

DameHarold Holt for that way, yeah.

NickHolt, we've done an episode on that.

PeterDid you? Yeah. Did the Russians take him?

NickIt's definitely the Russians. He was just an avid pants man who was showing off in a particularly bad day on Cheviot Beach. He had a sore shoulder and dived in and got sucked out.

PeterI reckon we could go on entrapping you for a while, but we probably should be by

DameWait, sorry, we should we should kiss a death?

PeterSo have you got a prediction for the week ahead, Damot?

DameI'm trying to remember my prediction last week. I thought that there would be No you didn't have one. No, no, sorry, the week before

PeterTired and emotional.

Damethe the week before I did have the prediction that there would be a blue between Angus and Pauline or Canavan and Pauline. And I feel like that came true in that Pauline and Carnavan at Bush Summit did have a little bit of a blue. So

PeterYou are embedded.

DameYeah, yeah. So I thought that was a a good one. it's Parliament Parliament sitting again next week. my guess is that Farley is gonna quit One Nation.

Nickwow. I've got to hope that

PeterWell

NickMark Butler drops the excise by 80%.

DameGood luck with

Petermine as always is indulgent. My prediction is I'm not gonna finish my old guy's book club book for the week, which is I

Nickrobot.

DameHave you Red Eye Robot?

PeterNever. and we're we're just doing short classics. So the last couple we did The Quiet American by Graham Green and then we did Heart of Darkness. Yeah. But I don't think I'm gonna get through it. So if anyone has a take, jump on my sub stack at Burning Platform and

DameSo I have I have a love of asthma.

Petertell me what my take should be. I'm I'm about a third in it, but this looks like

DameWell the the robot series is incredible. I mean Asimov basically invented the concept of a satellite. Yeah.

PeterYeah.

DameLike it Asimov has actually been critical in like reality imitating art.

PeterYes, you went.

NickI

DameThree body.

NickI've pronounced that, I've massacred that actually, but in any case we cover that in the conspiracy cabal and that is a fantastic.

PeterSo we'll definitely put a link to your thing in the show notes. Thanks for Yeah, yeah,

NickI've it a billion times.

PeterI know. Like s I think we've we've given you good content marketing too. But thanks for having a beer. that was fun.

DameThank you, Dr. Coatsworth, for joining you are always welcome back. We look forward to hopefully having you again soon. And if there's any conspiracies we can unpack, we're happy to kind of join you on the

NickKeep Phil. Keep them coming.