Episode 23
WYP After Dark: News, Traitors, and Freedom
With Lenore Taylor & Ben Pike
Show notes
This week we talk in-depth about the media landscape and the influence of news outlets on political engagement, including the role of news organisations and the impact of media on public opinion and political discourse.The death of humour in politics and the impact of political satire on free speech.We talk pork barrel politics, bureaucratic accountability, digital duty of care, leadership turbulence in the Greens, ICAC revelations and political fallout, and will Josh Frydenberg's return to politics.
Chapters
- 00:00 Introduction and Personal Updates
- 01:40 Road Trip Adventures
- 03:00 Guest Introductions and Poison of Choice
- 06:48 Reflections on News Corp and Media Influence
- 15:05 Media Landscape and Political Influence
- 22:18 Role of News Outlets and Political Engagement
- 27:35 The Role of Humor in Politics
- 28:19 Political Satire and Free Speech
- 48:39 Pork Barreling and Political Funding
- 53:02 Pork Barrel Politics
- 54:08 Bureaucratic Accountability
- 01:00:32 Digital Duty of Care
- 01:07:22 Leadership Turbulence in the Greens
- 01:09:05 ICAC Revelations and Political Fallout
- 01:12:48 Josh Frydenberg's Return to Leadership
Full transcript
Read itHide it
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.
Damian DamjanovskiWelcome to What's Your Poison, the podcast where people who barely agree on anything agree that it's better to do so over a drink. My name is Damid Damianovsky, I'm a director at General Strategic, and I am joined this week, as I am every week, by my evil twin, Peter Lewis from Progressive Media Agency Essential. Peter, how has your week been? And what is your poison?
Peter LewisSo week has been frustrating. been trying to pass an RSA course that so I can go out and serve alcohol at my sister's restaurant in Mudgee, and also fighting off an automated camera that's claiming my wife wasn't wearing a seat belt because the belt went under her boob. So between those two things, I'm having a bad user experience
Damian DamjanovskiHa ha ha.
Peter Lewisof government and really thinking about Those wise words of our friends from the Westminster tradition a few shows ago, Danny and Carolyn, that the main reason that people lose trust in government is when they have a shit experience of government. And that's been my week. So to quirl my nerves, I am having a singer for no other reason that people left it down in the fridge last time I had people down the coast with me. So I'm on a singer, trying to recover from a week of frustration. But you've had a better time, you've been on a road trip.
Damian DamjanovskiI'm on a fabulous road trip. I went up to God's Country, Queensland, one of the the last remaining coalition held states and and I g honestly as soon as I passed the Tweethead's cool and gatta border I felt freer instantly. I lit up a Siggy, had a beer in the street, no. just on a road trip up and down the coast enjoying
Peter LewisDid he get lost in Brisbane?
Damian DamjanovskiNo how can you possibly get lost in Brisbane? Just aim for wherever the brawl the brawl the brawls are heading.
Peter LewisBecause the river has no logic and you're always in relation the brown snake.
Damian DamjanovskiNo, I know, I I I I have a huge soft spot for Queensland. I love it up here. But then we since come down to Byron Bay, which I I have to admit is not my people. Like I I love the nature, but Byron Bay is definitely not for me. Well that's it,
Peter LewisYou like vaccinations too though, so they're not the people, yeah.
Damian Damjanovskiyes. I believe in science and a modicum of freedom, so it it's really hard for me to enjoy Byron Bay beyond the landscapes, but it it has been an enjoyable experience nonetheless. We're in this in a beautiful Airbnb cottage which you know was rented for a reasonable price, and then we found out it's for sale for an outrageous four and a half million dollars for a Federation cottage in Byron Bay. That is housing price has gone absolutely. Thankfully though, they ha they do have a television
Peter LewisIn a west by the sea.
Damian Damjanovskiwith with a satellite dish and a live feed, so I've gotten to enjoy all of the week's happenings from Canberra and everywhere else and been watching everything unfold as it has. But why don't we introduce our guests for the week, Peter? Because we've got I think two interesting guests and some interesting topics to talk about this week.
Peter LewisWell, why don't I start with mine? returning, the first return, I think, apart from Pete and Jules, come back for more. Lenore Taylor, former editor of The Guardian writer, you can see by her surrounds that she's bookish. and she is actually working on a book at the moment that I don't think she wants to jinx by talking about too much. But hi, Lenore, thanks for coming back. And what's your poison?
Lenoremy poison is bog standard gin and tonic. I was gonna say though, Damo, I I sort of escaped from Queensland many years ago when Joe Bielki Peterson or s just after Joe Bielcki Peterson was premiering it didn't always feel free. Like you couldn't street march, you couldn't there were a lot of things you couldn't do back then. But anyhow.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Well, look, things are better now.
Peter LewisBrisbane's so interesting though too like 'cause there was always there was always that radical core in the middle of it 'cause all these people growing up fighting Bjockey Peterson there was really cutting edge music and cutting it They're the
LenoreIt politicized a whole generation. Mm.
Peter Lewisonly city that still has a Labor Day march where you get people actually out on the streets and
LenoreMm.
Peter Lewiseverything. Yeah. If you can find your way around Brisbane, it's a good space. Who have you bought, Dam?
Damian DamjanovskiI've brought along Ben Pike. we've known Ben for some time. Ben is over at Business New South Wales, which is the fancy name we give to the New South Wales Chamber of Commerce and Industry. Ben also used to be one of Ulot. He used to be a journo back in the day. So I thought Ben would be an interesting addition to our podcast today with some interesting topics. So welcome Ben. What's your poison?
Ben PikeThank you so much, Damien. today I'll be drinking a pint of the nectar of the gods Guinness, which I have only come to in the past eighteen months, because I've got a couple of Welsh mates and they drink it like it's water and it is just beautiful. And I cannot believe I didn't have this in my life earlier. I've been drinking a lot of bad beer and then this came along and it's the only one I drank now.
Peter LewisBut you're not splitting the G,
Damian DamjanovskiThe sandwich in a glass.
Peter Lewisyou're just doing it straight out of the thing.
Ben PikeWell, I've actually my father in law showed me this. He has a wine glass to which he pours it in, so but yeah, it's an absolute winner and I'm in love with it. So that's my poison for today.
Damian DamjanovskiDoes the wine glass
Peter LewisIt does look thick. That's what you were drinking.
Damian Damjanovskiaerate it better or is it just for show? Sorry, I'm I'm on the Adelaide
Ben PikeJust for sure.
Damian DamjanovskiHills Three Oaks cider. Usually I have the black one which is an eight percent cider, which is my preferred percentage, but this is only five percent, so I have to drink twice as much. But I'll get there. Don't you worry. now, Peter, this week there's been a lot of interesting stuff going on, I think, in the world of politics. I I I want to get to a few of the items, such as obviously digital duty of care and elbow, and whether or not he should have declared his membership to the Marrickville Golf Course before he gave a a stack
Peter LewisWe're all married though.
Damian Damjanovskiof funding. And of course one One Nation. But before that, I understand all three of you at some point have actually worked for News Corp or News Limited as it was back in the day, which I think is quite fascinating because I think a lot of people either I think people fall into the either lovers of News Corp or haters of News Corp camp and there's a lot very few people who are kind of very neutral on it. So I'm just curious for starting with you, Peter, your view on kind of being a News Corp alumni, what your views on it are now.
Peter LewisYeah. And look, if you're a journalist, chances are at some stage you've had a job at News Limited because there aren't many other options. but I I was the industrial reporter in the mid nineties when Cole Allen, otherwise known as Cole Pott, was editor. And I had
Ben Pikewow.
Peter Lewisa terrific experience. I was young, I was running around, you know, filing stories. It was a different telegraph. I sat in Candu Corner with the guy Simon Benson, Mark Skelsey, and Kelvin Bissett, and we were hungry for news. And I loved tabloid. I loved cutting stories down to their bare essence. There was this guy on the backbench, Campbell Reed, who was just a master at pulling a couple of pages together to turn something complex into something people could read. So I I love the tabloid sensibility and I Back then I thought the paper was terrific. Cole was the only editor to endorse Keating in ninety six,
Damian DamjanovskiMm.
Peter Lewisbecause he said to me, It's not gonna win, but it's you know what our readers want. I thought it was still a good paper under David Pemberthy. I thought he had a great tabloid sensibility. I kind of I feel like, you know, it's changed. I'd be interested in Ben's perceptions. I you know, Ben English is the current editor, used to be the state political correspondent, used to be known as Chauncey Gardner. And he he sort of I feel like they've they've just kind of almost become the cliche of themselves in recent years. He kind of lost me when he did that hit job on Bill Shorten's dead mum in the lead up to the twenty nineteen election. But I I just feel that the best of the telegraph was not being quite as partisan as it was and it was it was it would you you you always knew where the biases lay, but it wasn't cheerleading. Like You know, I knew that if I had an anti union story, I'd get a run up the front. And if I wanted to get a pro union story, I better file early to get up the back. And that was just taken. But yeah,
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter LewisI I'm not a hater of news. I think a lot of good journalists go through there, but I just wish they were better and I wish they weren't quite as wanting to play an active role in shaping the politics, you know, because then I think they'd be a great Australian company.
Ben PikeI think everyone who's been through News Corp is changed one way or another. I've spoken to a lot of journals and photographers who have been through it and it is the ultimate baptism of fire. And I remember I can't remember who wrote it, it might have been Margaret Simons that talked about she interviewed someone and said, If you're at news, they're gonna stab you in the front rather than the back. And there's a part of me that really likes that and I I Peter, I too love the tabloid sensibility and we often would laugh at the odds just because of the way that they were so verbose and they could would say in 30 paragraphs what could be said in five at the telly. And so I had a really I worked under Mick Carroll, the Sunday Tele editor, who now runs all three sites. and that was kind of my time with the telly and being at a s at the Sunday telly we had more time to find yarns and pretty much the job was go out and find a yarn and that is
Peter LewisAnd then protect it till Saturday so no one broke it beforehand. Is that really nice, stressful thing about the Sundays?
Ben PikeWell yeah, it used to be there used to be a lot of locking of of of drawers if there was information in there to sort of keep it secret from the daily and there was and there were and there was a lot of competition with the daily. but that doesn't really exist anymore 'cause all of them have been brought under Bed English now. and yeah, I too think there are amazing journalists there and there've been incredible stories that they've written. But yes, there's no doubt that they take a a conservative line of thinking. but some would say that that runs in counter to a lot of other parts of the media as well and that there has been a sort of general move towards sort of talking more to your core audience. I think that's sort of true across a lot of media now.
Damian DamjanovskiHmm. L Lenore, your thoughts before we I've got a question for you all on this, but your time there?
LenoreSo I had two separate stints at The Australian. the first one was about nine years from very early in my career, like the late 80s through till 1996. at that point, I think the Oz was a little bit less ideological, and I was also quite junior. So I was a rounds person. I was breaking stories in different rounds and the
Peter LewisThat was the poor Kelly Oz, wasn't it, when it was the paper address? Yeah.
LenoreWas the Paul Kelly Oz and I was doing environment and indigenous affairs around Marbot. It was the 1990 election, which was the Greens Preference election. And, you know, I didn't I felt like I could do my job and it was a demanding and really good place to learn press gallery journalism. I went back for a couple of years in the early Rudd government years. By that point I was more senior and it was, I think, a lot more ideological and I found it a more difficult place to work. But that said, you know, overall I think there are some there's some excellent journalists at News Corp and they do some brilliant journalism across a whole lot of a whole lot of subjects. I think they are more willing to campaign and use their clout than other media organizations are. So it's not just that they run a sort of centre right line on op-eds and editorials, which, you know, that's what they are, but that they will push it and push it, both for an ideological reason and also sometimes I think against people that they've taken a a dislike to and kind of
Peter LewisYeah.
Ben PikeYeah.
LenoreI think that does sometimes verge on bullying. So
Damian DamjanovskiMm.
Lenorethey're my problem. So I s yeah,
Peter Lewissome of the pylons are outrageous, I reckon.
Lenorethat I mean that's my problem, but but that's not everything about News Corp. Like there's also really, really good journalists there.
Peter LewisYeah. It's a bit like AI, you've
Damian DamjanovskiIt cannot
Peter Lewisgot a good AI and bad AI. And you know, we haven't even spoken about Sky After Dark, which I would say is the bad AI that's really just producing content to be pushed into be monetized in the States. And I think it's having a pernicious impact. Like the after dark bit.
LenoreAgree. I mean, I have a particular problem with Sky After Dark and and News Corp more generally, really, on climate. Not not because you can't have a view about what to do about global heating. Like of course you can. You can, you know, figure one technology over another, whatever. But I mean, Sky After Dark is overtly climate denialist, and that's like being flat Earth or you know, the moon is triangular. I mean it's just not scientific.
Peter LewisTwo sides to the story, Lenor.
Damian DamjanovskiSo sorry, can I can I just confirm,
LenoreYeah, yeah.
Damian Damjanovskido we believe that I mean, cu i this it does seem to very much couch it as though Newscorp is ideological and the other news outlets aren't? Is that what we're saying? We don't believe that the alternative news outlets are ideological?
LenoreNo, that wasn't that's not what I think. I mean, I used to run the Guardian, the Guardian runs the center left line, right? Yes. And the and the opinion pieces are informed by that, and probably the choice of news stories are informed by that. But
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
LenoreI would argue we would always follow facts and we would never run anything that was f not factual because it suited our way of looking at the world. Whereas I think not all but parts of News Corp do do that.
Damian DamjanovskiSo so
Ben PikeYeah.
Damian Damjanovskiif if we kind of take it as a given that most of the most news organizations at the moment are so have some ideology behind them because to Ben's point, that's kind of the way content works these days is they they kinda you kinda have to pander to the algorithm, and which we'll get to the algorithm a bit later, but you kinda have to pander to whatever the algorithm is. Peter, you you talked about the fact that you you can't kinda can't avoid News Corp these days because can't remember the words you use, but it was something along the lines of th they kind of own everything or they're the the most dominant player. We are c
Peter LewisWell no, they're just the the dominant player in the Australian media. Yeah. But I'll say you got
Damian DamjanovskiBut we are we are currently in a weird environment where we we have more a larger variety of news publications now than we've had in a very long time. So your average Australian reader now has a choice, like just z Sydney take Sydney if you've got you're in Sydney and you have an interest in politics and business, let's say mo most broadly, you've got the Sydney Morning Herald, the Daily Telegraph, the Australian Financial Review, the Australian. Then on top of that, you've got the New Daily, you've got The Guardian, you've got the ABC, you've got now Politico, as we talked to Ryan Heath a few weeks ago, you've got Capital Brief, you've got Crikey, you've got the Com like there is a like the nightly, like there is a plethora of news organizations now because the cost of entry for these news organizations is lower than it's ever been, because they don't have to buy printing presses anymore. And you don't need to put a building press.
Peter LewisIt's low. You don't need to build a printing press and a distribution network. That's right.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd and what we have to to some degree acknowledge, reluctantly or not, is News Corp has one of the largest readerships because that's what people want to read. And if it's reaffirming their worldviews or
Peter LewisWell also because Well, yes. So I'll go I'll go back a step. So I will give Murdoch credit. He was the guy that when the internet first came along said we cannot make news free. And he was the first guy to try to get his head around the paywall. But I think what's ended up happening in all media as in all information is then to if you're relying on either subscribers or clicks, you're giving them what they want rather than sounds really you know, paternalistic what they need, which is the full suite of of views. so you know, Lenore and The Guardian, which was set up by a trust to promote the interest of journalism rather than the bottom line. And I think it's fair to say they didn't chase the clicks as hard. but where we've ended up is this world where news has an out like in a way, it's got this outsized impact because it is still followed by a lot of the other outlets. it gives a lot of their stuff away for free. Like I think it's remarkable that they're paid Sky News services free in the regions and that's having a real impact out there. So is it popular or is it just there?
Ben Pikeyeah.
Peter Lewisbut yeah, the I I just have always had this thing. If news actually had the same thing that they
Damian DamjanovskiI'm I think that sorry, I'm just gonna say that's a bit of a It I mean SBS, NIT V have been freeing the regions for you know NITV for at least a decade and SBS for at least four or five decades, like but that hasn't made them popular. Like people are watching the things they want to watch.
Peter LewisYou're not cooking people's brains though.
Ben PikeYeah, and
LenoreBut think you
Ben PikeI think
Lenoreneed to I need to need to separate out how many clicks they get, how many readers they have and how they use their influence. Like so news.com.au is always like number one or number two news site. The Oz,
Damian DamjanovskiMm.
LenoreI mean The Guardian had multiples more readers than the Oz, but the Oz uses its position in a way that other news outlets aren't prepared to use their position to try to push the public debate. So it's not always the same thing. And to the point about, I mean, I think you make a really good point about the cost of entry and more players. Like I remember back, do you remember back when Conrad Black was trying to take over Fairfax and we had this huge campaign, Too Too Few was the slogan. Like the mid you know, concentration of media ownership is is way too small. It's almost like now we've got the worst of all worlds. We've got, you have to find your news in this endless torrent of whatever, you know, AI, slot, influences, news, whatever else. And somehow you people have got to find news in all of that. But on top of that, you've still got the traditional media exercising power in the way that the traditional media always have. I think it's almost a more difficult environment, but you're absolutely
Damian DamjanovskiHm. yeah.
Lenoreright. There's a lot more players than there was.
Ben PikeAnd there's so much more dependency. Look, I think Peter, to your point about the power of News Corp. A lot of it because it's print and online. So and a lot of the political debate is shaped by news because they and a lot of the politicians look at News Corp as a as a a sort of way to understand the public more generally. And it is always the case, I mean and PRs do it a lot, and the government will do it, they'll drop a story to News Corp and then the T Vs will follow up the next day. So having having that written
Peter LewisAnd the ABC too.
Ben Pikeword is so much more powerful. Yeah, but having that written that written word is so much more powerful than than what it was. And so for a lot of the calculation in New South Wales, when you wanna you know that if you give the story to the telegraph, it's gonna get under the nose of the politicians. Whereas you can give the story to News dot com and you're gonna get a lot more readership. So it's it's i that sort of relationship between the government and media is so strong with News Corp. And you see it at the Bush Summit, Damon, I know you were there as well a couple of weeks ago, that ALBO and the Labour poly still rock up even though they know they're gonna
Peter LewisYeah.
Ben Pikeget a bad reception. But it's look, Peter, it's smart for ALBO and he always has fronted up to news, unlike Shorten who at the twenty nineteen election just said a big fat no to News Corp. Whereas Albo, to his credit, will turn up, have a tough reception, but keep on going.
Peter LewisFamously he got to payback with such Yeah.
LenoreBut that's because he knows what will happen if he doesn't, right?
Ben PikeWell, he's gonna be alienating a lot of people who would vote for him as well. And so
LenoreWell, I it'd only be alienating them because of what News Corp would say about his decision not to turn up.
Ben PikeBut I think a lot of people look at the politician and they're like, you know what? You're still happy to turn up to a Sky News debate or whatever. And you still argue the point. And I think Australians really respect that. And I and so I think One Nation and Pauline made a huge mistake when she said no to the ABC because there's
Damian DamjanovskiAnd the guardian.
Ben Pikea lot of people in the regents.
LenoreThe Guardian.
Peter LewisThe Guardian.
Ben PikeYeah, and there's a lot of people in the regions who watch the ABC, who would vote for One Nation because it's the only real option. And it was I and I think that was a big misstep from her if she has the ambitions that she does. Because you've got to be able to have the hard conversations with people who don't agree with you. That's that's politics.
LenoreShe seems to have made Barnaby the official ABC representative of One Nation.
Peter LewisAnd he does it so well.
Ben PikeAnd the official and the official mopper opera.
Peter LewisCan I just throw one more thing in that I'm interested in your views on Ben and Dame as well? So so obviously the particular Sky Sky after Dark Crew have been the cheerleaders for the right flank of the Liberal Party, but I feel like they're doing more dat like and now they're kind of creating the whole war room between one nation and the liberal right. I feel like they're doing more harm than good if if the
Damian DamjanovskiMm.
Peter Lewisaim is to support right or centre government, they're not. Really delivering on the brief.
Ben PikeThey're they're a company and I think they're a company that obviously has shareholders and fundamentally they they've got they've got a model that they're looking to replicate from the US here and they've had some success with that. They obviously have a significant number of politicians that come in and do those interviews. I think Polly Hansen had an interview the other night with the the guy from the Oz Chris. so
Peter LewisChris Kenny.
Ben PikeChris Kenny, sorry. So So they've got that they've got that market sewn up. So yes, in one sense they could be causing damage to centre right politics, but those divisions exist anyway.
Peter LewisYeah, we can might
Damian Damjanovskiyeah.
Peter Lewistalk about that a bit later, Damo, some of the ridiculous in inside fighting over whether or not a please explain cartoon about Andrew Hasty is offensive or not or should be withdrawn from
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, w
Peter Lewisthe Libertarians. But
Damian Damjanovskiwe we will talk about that. The only thing I was gonna add is I think it's from a democratic zoomed out perspective, it is important that Australians have free and ready access to a variety of views and opinions and our free to air TV and most of our free news channels, including the ABC and The Guardian. do lean centre left. So it is actually important for a
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskihealthy democracy for us to have centre right and even far right views.
Peter LewisThe seven and nine lean seven to left.
Damian Damjanovskino, I don't think
LenoreDon't think seven and nine lead centre left.
Damian Damjanovskiseven I don't think seven and nine do, but I think the A the
Peter LewisI got no idea what politics is.
Damian Damjanovskithe ABC and The Guardian do, and it and like you said, Lenore, they're usually the the one and two or one and three most read kind of online news sources and through social media propagation and all this. So a having a balance overall is really important and news after dark, which is what Sky After Dark is known as now, does provide an important counterbalance that we we should have on a on a broadcaster. Like w wha what's the harm in having it?
Peter LewisBut what are they counterbalancing? They're counterbalancing crazy, aren't they? Like there is no thing
LenoreWhat's the alternative like there's no left wing version of Sky?
Damian DamjanovskiTh there's the A B C and th they there's n nothing stopping
Peter LewisBut like
LenoreThey're not the same thing.
Peter Lewisthe ABC isn't like sky after dark.
LenoreSo I I
Ben PikeYeah.
Peter LewisYou so
Lenoremean my view is that I agree with the point that you need a a a number of views. Like I absolutely agree with that. But I there I don't think there is any left version of Sky After Dark. I think Sky pushes the boat out so much further than anybody on the left does. And going back to my previous point, they run straight out climate climate denialism, which is, you know, like the basis of journalism is you stick with facts.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. But but
LenoreAnd that isn't like the stuff they say on climbing is just not factual.
Damian Damjanovskibut but but just differentiating daytime sky from nighttime sky and sky after dark does couch itself as opinion,
LenoreYeah. Fair.
Damian Damjanovskinot not as journalists, even though a lot of them are journalists. it does come back to at the end of the day, either you are tuning into this channel in a regional network because you want to watch it, or you are actively paying a subscription fee to watch it. And in Australia you get to have political dissenting opinions, whether or not we agree with them or not is completely irrelevant. The fact is they're entitled to have that opinion and and put together an entire network based around and then if people want to tune into it, which apparently they do, then that's up to them. That's that's the health of our democracy.
Peter LewisYeah.
LenoreSo so two points. Yes, people can tune into it. I think in a lot of the regions there's not a lot of options and it's going out free on those relay stations. That you know, that's tr true. But I still don't think that it's an equivalence. I I mean I just don't think there's an equivalence between what it does on the right and what anybody does on the left.
Damian DamjanovskiSo then what's Absolutely, so w what's going off with the left wing that none of want to pay for a regional channel to tell people in the regions everything to do with climate change and to swap their farms over for solar panels? Like why aren't they running that twenty four seven? There's nothing stopping him.
LenoreNo, that's that's not the equivalence I'm talking about. I'm talking about factual factual information versus versus nonsense.
Ben Pikethink conservative side of politics has always done outrage a lot better than the left. So
LenoreMm.
Ben Pikeyou look at G B, you look at
Peter LewisI don't know. I worked for the union movement for twenty five years. We were pretty good at getting outraged from time to time, but but yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd and David Pocock's
Ben PikeYeah, but as
Damian Damjanovskigiving the right a run for its money.
Ben PikeThat's true. But like generally speaking, if you look at broadcasters, you look at your Alan Jones, Ray Hadley, part of the world, I mean obviously there was Mike Carlton who was a counterbalance to that, but generally speaking, the like the the more conservative politicians and the more con not politicians as such, but more broadcasters, can the conservative part side of politics is more sort of geared towards that kind of emotion driven I'm not saying necessarily that it's wrong, but that more emotion driven outrage style commentating which we've seen. So like it
Peter LewisWhich
Ben Pikeyou don't really get your left wing commentators getting as outraged ev getting up every morning and getting as outraged.
Peter LewisSo what am I going to be angry with? And I I think like
Damian DamjanovskiNo and and and tr and
Peter Lewiswithout wanting to to dwell on this, there I I f I felt like the Collen era and the Pembothy era, there was a humour, like there was the politics of the paper, but there was also a a a degree of humanity to the paper. And I feel like it's just become mean. And I feel like there's something about news that it could be such a better good faith player if it wasn't quite so mean. I don't know, like maybe I've just got sort of rose coloured glasses about the way it used to be when I was their industrial reporter. Is that fair?
Damian DamjanovskiI I I I look I disagree with you on that, Peter, but I would say that to Ben's point, I think the right has always done a better job of outrage and the left has always done a better job of humour. so e each have their own territory that they have owned really, really well. However, kind of trying to segue us into our next
Peter LewisUntil we outlawed here, the left.
Damian Damjanovskitopic, Pauline has been doing what I would argue has been a really good job at doing right wing humour. And if for any of our viewers, if you haven't watched any of Pauline Hansen's Please Explain YouTube series, she's been doing it for about five or six years now. Because I remember when we were in office, like she was doing she was doing them back then, and they barely got noticed at all. They've only kind of come into like the media's attention over the past year. But she's been doing it and and the the team who's been doing it have been doing it for Five or six years now, and they would take the piss out of everything and everyone using caricature in a South Park style kind of over the top exaggeration. and this has recently
Peter LewisBattery debate trader.
Damian DamjanovskiBarnabas be the bee troop but this has gotten us into gotten her into trouble over the past week it seems, with Andrew Hasty. Peter, have you been following this one?
Peter LewisYeah, I went back over the source material. It's another really good piece of content, I've got to say. And it's interesting, this sort of new media disruptive humor meeting old media anger. And it's been really interesting how it's played out. I was watching, you know, some of the Sky After Dark reaction that it's outrageous they're calling this man a traitor. Like the the actual piece, we should put it in the show notes. It's it's more nuanced. It's trying to make the point that. the the you know, it's the bipartis supporting each other and the conspiracies against one nation, which is one of their tropes. But I do think it's been really interesting this whole, you know, at the same time as Pauline is saying, the idea of taking down stuff off the internet is and the Libs are also saying this, you know, with the digital duty of care, it's outrageous that there would be any sort of limit to free speech. There's this huge pylon saying they've got to pull down this bloody cartoon. So I don't know. I think Hasty's worried. Obviously the numbers in the state by-election should make him worried. they've hit a raw nerve because there's this huge group within One Nation that has sort of been Robert Smith's supporters and he obviously gave evidence in that trial. But I I don't
Ben PikeOn the Super, you know.
Peter Lewisthink the cartoon's his problem here. And I I actually think, you know, elevating that is just gonna get people to go and see it. It's got a couple of hundred thousand views. So Which, you know, any news outlet would be happy with that sort of reach.
LenoreWell. I reckon the cartoons are tran
Damian DamjanovskiBen Ben, have you got any sorry, you go, Leno?
Lenoresorry. I was just gonna say I think the cartoons are transgressively funny and clever. But the thing that I've found interesting for some time is how they let them say things that they that you couldn't say at a press conference. You couldn't say them in a press statement. They let them go that extra mile and it's go, well it's satire, it's funny. Like who's gonna fact check a cartoon? You know, you haven't you've got a sense of humor. So it's really
Peter LewisGood silence.
Lenoreclever political messaging for that reason. And this is the first well, no, there was one other time they got called out way a while ago when they said they kind of claimed that the Labour Party was roarting the AEC. The AEC came down on one of them. But other than that, I haven't seen anyone sort of call out the things that are said in these cartoons because they're cartoons until now. And I just think it's interesting that that's actually starting to happen.
Damian DamjanovskiYe y you're
Ben PikeYeah.
Damian Damjanovskiabsolutely right. I'll Ben I'll I'll flick to you in a second. I was gonna say the the latitude that the that a funny voice and a cartoon gives you in terms of where you can say whatever the heck you want. And you're absolutely right, Lenore. Up until now no one's really connected. Hey, the thing no one's publicly connected, the thing you're saying in that cartoon is actually the one nation party saying it, because one nation party is the logo at the end of it. It's endorsed by One Nation. And up until now everyone's been like hands off, don't stress about it.
Peter LewisAnd in the contract is Andrew Heisty sighing on the trader.
Damian DamjanovskiExactly. So so it's it's interesting that this is the first time that it's really been brought to the forefront. But Ben, your views on this? 'Cause I I know you've been following this.
Ben PikeYeah. I found it really fascinating to see for the first time where I think well, there's been a few but where Pauline has put a foot in it in relation to her c core constituents because I bet there would be a lot of veterans out there. It would be you have got to be kidding me. Like Andrew Hasty, you might not like him and obviously Pauline sees him as a threat because he is by far the most articulate conservative voice. By
Peter LewisTrue.
LenoreAgreed.
Ben Pikefar. You see him, he stands up, he's calm, he's cool, he's good looking, and he's very he's a very good communicator. And so no wonder one nation would have gone after him, because they're scared of him. They're not scared of Angus. Like he just does not have the ability to cut through like Andrew Hasty does. And I think for the f one of the first times it's a really dumb move because I think that they have pissed off a lot of veterans who would be like, He fought in the SAS, he served, he is not he is not an object of ridicule and and Barnaby was in the telly today trying to mop it up and it's that's become the sort of modus operandi for them is that she she says something outlandish and then he'll sort of say, wasn't that bad, I don't think we really meant to say that and that's kind of the you know, the dogs bark and then the caravan
LenoreYeah. Right, great.
Ben Pikemoves on.
Damian DamjanovskiOr him saying that he's he's not watched the cartoons but seeming to somehow know that he was portrayed as a beetroot in them. It's like mate, you've obviously
LenoreBeatrium.
Damian Damjanovskiwatched the cartoons. We know that, you know that. You don't need to pretend you haven't seen it. You're one of those two hundred thousand viewers. D do you think that
Peter LewisI'm sure Charlotte will get us a question later now.
Damian Damjanovskishe she by far has the best portrayal in the series. Do we think that One Nation's gonna keep these up and double down on the cartoons or are they gonna pull back a little bit?
Ben PikeI think I'll keep going because of everyone's talking about it. Like Jackie Lambey firing up like nothing else on that issue, brought to tears almost on Sky yesterday. Like it was I think it is a very sound way to sort of cut through the political noise.
Peter LewisAnd that denial
Damian DamjanovskiAnd and who
LenoreAnd might be slightly more careful in the future.
Peter Lewisthat Lenore's talking about is really interesting too. So the point at
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. And and to your point
Peter Lewiswhich they start trying to censor it will be really interesting in terms of the broader free speech. And I also think it's interesting, like it seems that news has really lent in behind hasty on this occasion. So interesting there. Like, you know, not wanting to sort of remain sort of fixated with news, but if you look at That difficult position that Fox has ended up in the States with Trump and like, are you supporting the machine or are you supporting the insurgents? I think it's not it it's it's not clear where they where they sit at the moment and they've sort of created this whole maelstrom around them and it's all being played out in their network. So,
Damian DamjanovskiHm.
Peter Lewisyou know, you don't see a lot of it. Like I think in both The Guardian, Lenore and the broader press, it's almost being spectators to what's happening inside that sort of right wing sort of
LenoreYeah.
Peter Lewisfight club.
Damian Damjanovskione nation have figured out something that neither the Liberals or Labour, let alone the nationals have figured out, which is in a modern media environment, just getting politicians to, you know, try and do TikToks with ushies in front of a camera is not breakthrough content and is I won't say beyond cringe worthy, but it's terrible, terrible content that is not worthy of watching. How is it that One Nation with its limited resources and again like they they didn't start doing this when they had the Gina money? They started doing this, you know, in twenty nineteen, twenty twenty, somewhere around then they started this Please Explain series, right? It's up to season six or seven or whatever it is. how is it that they've figured out this formula and none of the majors have managed to figure it out yet?
Peter LewisMm.
Lenoreguess they're they're more willing to be transgressive. I mean those cartoons only work when you push it a bit, right? Like they're funny because they're saying things you're not supposed to say. Maybe the major parties aren't as willing to do that. But also it's this sort of what Ed
Damian DamjanovskiMm.
LenoreCooper calls angertainment. It's that kind of melding of popular culture and and and you know entertainment and political information which the right in America did really well and Probably that's what they look to.
Peter LewisAnd also I think the you know, there's a broader analysis here that I think we've touched on in the past. It's the left has lost its ability to be funny because there are so many risks of overstepping a whole bunch of lines that you need to navigate. So,
Ben PikeVery charging.
Peter Lewisone nation doesn't have that risk of transgression because they're the transgressives. And if Labor offends, that's the that's the story. you know,
Damian DamjanovskiMm.
Peter LewisI feel like And I think for the
LenoreMm-hmm.
Peter LewisLibs, I think they've been trying to sort of if they've got any sort of positioning it is as the responsible economic managers and that doesn't really make for stand up slapstick comedy either. So Yeah.
LenoreHilarious. Yeah.
Ben PikeAnd they're also and they're also part of a party machine. Like you you you forget how sort of rigid
Peter LewisWhisk averse.
Ben Pikerigid, risk-averse, and coordinated parties have to be nowadays. And like you look at the UK, th those backbench MPs are free to debate policy issues, right? They don't have to be in line, the cabinet does, but in the backbench, so it's
Peter LewisIt's not the grains.
Ben Pikea lot more robust
Damian DamjanovskiNo one.
Ben Pikedebate. Whereas here it it's it's Bill Shorten saying, I don't know what the leader said, but I agree with it. So they
Damian DamjanovskiCool.
Ben Pikeare subject to a whole they're sub to a whole
Peter Lewismy god.
Ben Pikelot of different laws to what to what one nation are and then LeBron to your point they can be a lot more transgressive. And I think they are also smart enough to realize that the content that you can create on socials. You don't have to go via the regular media who are subject to all the defamation and other laws. So it's you you've just got to beeline straight to your audience. Can you
LenoreYou can still be sued though.
Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.
Ben PikeTrue, but like it's I suppose you don't have the Praetorian guard of editors who would be looking at it and worried about the liability that they would incur. And so one nation would be like, Well, we're happy to take this risk, we'll probably get away with it.
Peter LewisSome of the most radical commentators in Australian media have been cartoonists though, right? Lenore? And you know, y The Guardian always had First Dog on the Moon and Fiona Fiona Katawskis analysing the news. And, you know, most papers like it it is interesting to think that's where humor still existed and was quite subversive,
LenoreMm.
Peter Lewisbut that was the media doing it rather than the left doing it. And I feel like yeah, we just haven't had funny people for a while.
Damian DamjanovskiBut maybe this is changing the and maybe One Nation is kind of pushing out the window for all the political parties. I mean we've seen now in Victoria One Nation's you know, selected leader Warren Pickering, previously facing drug charges or or having, you know, admitted to having done drugs, this that and the other. In the past this would have been a death sentence for any politician. at the moment, A, it's you know it It's a one nation candidate, le well, a one nation leader for a state election, so it seems to be a bit of a whatever. but B, we're hearing, you know, I think it was Paul Inhanson saying, well, you know, who hasn't done it? Who, you know, point point me to someone who hasn't actually done drugs, who's who's in politics, this and the other. Like so are we changing our expectations of not just political discourse, but the quality of our candidates and what we expect of our political candidates? Like, is it okay to be a You know, philandering, rake of a human and then decide, No, I wanna be I wanna stand up for parliament. Are we accepting of that more?
Peter LewisPresident of the United States.
Damian DamjanovskiWell
LenoreYeah.
Ben PikeThey're outside they're outside the party machine. They are and I for a lot of people, one the big numbers that really stood out for me, I can't remember what the other parts of the research, but thirty-four percent of people said one nation represents people like me. And so I don't think they care. They don't care. They just don't care because if you read Cos Samaris, he talks a lot about the the regional areas of New South Wales and the country. out of urban areas, which we've seen all of these services disappear. There's just not the economic vibrancy that they used to be. And you've got obviously the affordability crisis, wages stagnating. So they're like, What what what why why would I vote for these major parties? They're not going to do anything for me. I haven't gone anywhere in ten, twenty years or whatever. So give these guys a go.
LenoreThe rules of political vetting should be kind of like the rules of security vetting, as in it's not so much what you might have done when you were younger, it's whether you're upfront about it, so that you can't be either blackmailed about it or it can't affect your ability to do your
Damian DamjanovskiHmm.
Lenorejob. Because, like, I mean, I kind of agree, we don't want every political candidate to be like head prefect, road scholar, boy scout. Like that would not be a representative of the community. The thing about the Warren Pickering thing that I thought what didn't look good, I mean, none of it looked good, let's be fair. None of it was great. But the bit that I was concerned about watching it was that he didn't seem to be upfront about it. Like it didn't seem like he'd been upfront about it with One Nation. And then he was telling the newspaper it was all a lie and he was gonna sue them right up until when he came out and said, Yeah, actually it's all true, but I'm not like that now. To me, and I don't know whether other whether regional voters or one nation supporters would think this way. But to me, that was the bit that was most concerning, that he seemed a little bit dodgy about it. Not that if if it was just that he'd done it in his youth and now he was a you know fine upstanding citizen, even even as a voter, I wouldn't care that
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Lenoremuch. It's more that he wasn't completely straight.
Peter LewisAl also worth noting that it was a dr it was an exclusive from the Australian. It wasn't a left wing hit job. It was the Australian reporting. I actually thought Pauline
Ben PikeYeah. Good point.
Peter Lewisha handled it really well. And I you know,
Damian DamjanovskiAgree.
Peter LewisI don't want to hate on people that have got histories, you know, and I think that the pylon and the hand wringing says more about that mainstream orthodoxy than anything else, and it will just make him a more attractive candidate rather than a less attractive candidate.
LenoreIt stuff keeps coming out, right? Like he did the drug stuff came out, other stuff came out, then all the traffic like if things keep coming out about his past that he hasn't talked about, that's sort of what I think might count against
Damian DamjanovskiHmm.
Lenoreit.
Damian DamjanovskiI think it's interesting because for listeners who don't know, so any MP who gets elected, you know, gets allocated a number of staff. If you happen to be in the ministry or assistant ministry positions, the all the staff have to go through a a security process, which is what Lenore was talking about earlier, where AGSFA, which is part of the Department of Defense, basically, depending on what security level you get, ask you a whole bunch of questions and do a very kind of intimidating interview with you where they ask you questions and and they're basically trying to figure out A, is there anything in your past that might be compromising? And B, is there anything that can be used against you to blackmail you? They're really the only two questions they're trying to ascertain. What I always found really interesting is that no candidates have to go through that same process. So you often have a Crown Minister who's sitting there handling very top secret or important documents who has gone through no security vetting process. whereas all the staff
Ben PikeMm.
Damian Damjanovskiaround the table have gone through these extensive and sometimes invasive levels of security clearance. I wonder if there's a opportunity there where we need to have some kind of standardized vetting across all parties for any candidate to make sure that they not necessarily to to uncover what was in their past, but to discover whether or not that they have anything that can be compromised by a foreign national or
LenoreYeah.
Damian Damjanovskianyone else for that.
LenoreBuddies do do vetting, right, but just not the same way.
Damian DamjanovskiYep. Not the not the same. And not to the same standard as as Axfa. Yeah.
Peter LewisIt's checking the social media feeds. They haven't said
LenoreYeah.
Peter Lewisanything stupid.
Ben Pikeyeah, I suppose the implication is that the Australian people are smart enough to see through this, Damien. And so therefore
Damian DamjanovskiHa ha ha.
Ben Pikeit's something that that they know about. But I thought it was interesting talking about candidates.
Peter LewisPast performance isn't an indicator of future returns.
Damian DamjanovskiHa ha ha.
Ben Pikebut talking about future returns, like Mike Newman, the One Nation candidate for New South Wales, is a very different proposition. Obviously very articulate, amazing pedigree.
Damian DamjanovskiThat's the Japanese speaking fellow.
Ben PikeYeah. And you you look at you look at a candidate of that calibre and like I was having a chat to a a a Labor MP last week about Cessnoch and they were like, We've lost Cessnoch. We're not
Peter LewisWow.
Ben Pikegonna get it. And it's that and it's and it's that final. They're like, it's in the polling, we're not gonna get it back. So yes, in Victoria it is a shit show, but in New South Wales it could be a completely different prospect.
Peter LewisDo you reckon
Damian DamjanovskiMm.
Peter LewisBen Dale graft onto the shooters and fishers that have got a bit of a reach? Are they is there an alignment there as from what you've seen or
Ben Pikelook I can I can see a political alignment. but ultimately I think the shooters, fishers and farmers are sort of traded off being a sort of small party anyway. A lot of them would have the same constituents. So I I can't see one nation wanting to wouldn't they just eat them as opposed to join them?
Damian DamjanovskiDisturbing thought that Mark Latham might be back into some form of power in the near future.
Peter Lewisno, he's left one nation, I think. That blew up.
Damian DamjanovskiIs he not he's left I
Ben PikeYeah.
Damian Damjanovskiyou're right, yes, he's left One Nation. how everyone
Peter LewisEveryone leaves one nation.
Damian Damjanovskileaves eventually. And I do know that my my kiss of death last week was that David Farley would leave this week and it hasn't come true, so but just
Peter LewisSo that
Damian Damjanovskihold hold on to that one for me because I have a feeling that the it's that ain't over yet. how about Elbow and this golf club thing? So Elbow was tabled this week that basically, thanks to the some ABC reporting that the Labour government has committed a whole bunch of money to projects where the majority of them happened to be in Labour electorates, commonly known as pork barreling. This is a term that doesn't get used as much as it used to get used. So we found that a lot of younger people don't actually know what
Peter LewisIs that 'cause people are eating less bacon these days?
Damian DamjanovskiI think so, yes. It's the it's the it's the vegan trend. It's the vegan gluten free trend. But but a lot of younger people don't actually know what Hawk barreling is, which is I thought particularly fascinating. But so this practice of basically politicians committing funds to either their safe or their marginal seat because they're in power through these slush funds where instead of having to demonstrate the you know the the merits of a project, they kind of get to hand pick specific projects that they want funded. One went to the Marriottville Golf course, which for whatever reason needed millions of dollars to keep people golfing. and Albo goes, Well, I didn't know that I was an honorary member there Like is that a th do we really think do we think that's true? Do we think he's handled this well? Like
Ben PikeCan I? Like I've got a
LenoreI think it's the wrong question. I think it's the complete wrong question. Like I've had a very long history writing about this stuff and it really, really gives me the shits that I mean the idea that both parties do it and in and that they can go around the country promising money based on the marginal marginality of the seat rather than overall need. I mean, even putting to side whether the federal government should be paying money for golf courses anyway, which I don't think they should, but putting that to one side.
Peter LewisYou wouldn't post Kelly's whiteboard, Lenore.
LenorePardon, I saw what Ros Kelly's little whiteboard, it was only about this big. and regional
Damian DamjanovskiHa ha.
Lenorepartnerships and every, you know, every sort of boondoggle like this over the years. And to me, the problem is the the idea of it, the idea of pork barreling, the idea that you should be allowed to make election promises based on marginal seats, which safe seats don't get a look in on it. But the thing that really gets my goat is that the parties, because they don't want to actually address that main point, because they both do it. always diverted onto some other thing, namely whether there's a conflict of interest, which is why Bridget Mackenzie fell on her sword the last sports writs under the Morrison government, and now this this one is coming down to a conflict a potential conflict of interest with whether Albo was an honorary member of the golf club. I don't care if he's an honorary member of the golf club.
Peter LewisFive dollars.
LenoreIt it that is completely irrelevant to my point of view. There should not be an invitation only slush phone. Like that's the problem.
Damian DamjanovskiBut mm so
LenoreWhy are we talking about
Damian Damjanovskihe you
Lenorethe honorary membership? That's not the problem.
Damian DamjanovskiLenore I hear you on this and I do I want to agree with you on this, but the alternative bothers me more, which is the alternative is bureaucrats end up deciding where the money goes and I don't think I can trust bureaucrats to make
Peter LewisOn the basis of
Damian Damjanovskithose decisions.
Peter LewisThis is a guy that worked for Scott
LenoreBureaucratic.
Peter LewisMorrison though, Lenore, so he's got a pony in the race.
LenoreYou can have a program that's the federal government golf club program, and here are the criteria, and all the golf clubs apply, and the best golf clubs, most needy golf clubs get the money. Or you can allocate
Damian DamjanovskiBut but
Lenoreit to the golf clubs in marginal electorates. Are you really saying the latter is better? Seriously?
Damian DamjanovskiNo, no, what I'm saying is no no, what I'm saying is that in the in the here's the criteria version of events, what inevitably happens every single time there's a grants program for these kinds of things that's administered by the bureaucracy is that there's a bunch of things that fall outside the criteria but are worthy all the same. And what a bureaucrat does, as we discovered when we had the the ladies from the Westminster tradition on here is they are box tickers and they go, We get it. We get that your specific golf course is really screwed up because of these sixteen reasons, but unfortunately the criteria says it has to be these five reasons, so our hands are tied. Like you need a system that allows for both.
LenoreYes, I but that's a whole
Peter LewisFair enough.
Lenoredifferent question. That's a that's a whole different like by all means make the box ticking
Damian DamjanovskiBut that's what this is.
Lenorebetter. But but but politicians allocating it to their marginal seats is not the alternative. Like that's not the either or here, surely.
Ben PikeThey're not all marginal. Like Granus,
Damian Damjanovskior we or but I don't know. Then?
Ben PikeGranus are not marginal. See, just so I got a call last week from an ABC journalist in relation to this Albos story before it came out because I wrote about it in 2018 or 2019 rather, and like in it I described Mr. Albanese as a non-golfing honorary member of the club. and they were asking me about.
Damian DamjanovskiAre you the one who broke the story at the Daily Telegraph?
Ben PikeI can't remember. It was a long time ago.
Peter LewisCan I tell you calling it a golf club is a stretch? It's a dog track. It is like I used to
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
LenoreWith
Peter LewisI know. I know.
Damian DamjanovskiThe
Ben PikeIt's a beautiful, it's not as Royal Marriottville to some
Damian Damjanovskiit's where the kids in Marrickville go for a bong.
Ben PikeYeah, well look, I just want to read one quote
Peter LewisKids.
Ben Pikefrom Albo. If because it was against the Greens and he was fighting the Greens in the moment, he said, if the proponents of destroying Marriottville Golf Club got out of their ivory tower and went down to the course, they would see it was already loved and used by the public all the time. So he was standing up for the everyman. But I I'm kind of Damien, I'm with you on this one. Like I think it is an imperfect system. There are some things that just do not work in the bureaucracy. And I think that they are an elected member of parliament and they should have some scope to be able to distribute money to organizations in a reputable way, probably more transparent than what they do, but they should have the ability to to sort of make decisions on parts of the electorate which may need some funding for a good reason. And like it's an impact.
Peter LewisThere's another model
LenoreSo if you're in a safe seat you're just a sucker and you miss out. Is that I mean, that's the logical
Peter LewisSo
Ben PikeWell, I mean Granula's
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Yeah.
Ben Pikeis Granula a side same.
Damian DamjanovskiS stop it's
Peter Lewisso so the other model is that each seat gets an allocation of money and the community
LenoreSure.
Peter Lewisdetermines where it goes. And there's this whole system SMARTy grants that
Damian Damjanovskithe community are the worst at spending money.
Peter LewisThe community is the worst. the elites. So you think the
Damian DamjanovskiThey're the worst at spending money.
Peter Lewisbest model is a politician on a whiteboard matching marginal seats to giving car parks and dressing rooms? It's like
Damian DamjanovskiCan I explain why? Can I explain why? Gi give me the opportunity to explain why. Because that politician has a three-year ticking time bomb on their job. And they know that whether or not they keep their specific job as well as their broader job gets reassessed every three years by not only their constituents, but by the entire media mechanism. Whereas the bureaucrats hide behind all
Peter Lewisit's
Damian Damjanovskiof the all of this crazy level of opaqueness where the average Australian has no idea who's making the decisions, why they're making the decisions, what recourse there is, to the point where when we when we get to issue issues where they where they compla
Peter LewisThe allocations are made before the election, not in the term. Like these are always put forward as promises rather than yeah.
LenoreExactly. And and all the all the Australians that don't live in marginal seeds don't get anything at all. It's not fair.
Damian DamjanovskiBut to Ben's point, Grandler's not a marginal seat and hasn't been a marginal seat in thirty years. It wasn't allocated the funding 'cause it was a marginal seat.
LenoreNo, so they're not they're they're skewed to marginality. They're skewed to
Ben PikeYeah.
Lenoremarginality. And this this program was invitation only. Since when has there ever been an invitation only grants program?
Ben Pikejust for I just want to raise while we're talking about it the famous John Barrellaro who called himself pork barrellaro
LenoreYeah.
Ben Pikein relation to pork
Peter LewisRight.
Ben Pikebarreling which I kind of admired for his turn phrase. but he was really blatant
Peter LewisYou gotta be good at something.
Ben Pikeabout it. He was really blatant about it. I think for a lot of people who vote, they would be thinking to themselves, well you know what, like if I vote for this party and they get into governing, I'm it I'm expecting some gravy.
Peter LewisYeah. And you know what? When we run focus groups in like people go, I want it to be a marginal seat, so they bribe me. Like there is like it's all sort of created this really perverse feedback loop.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. And that's it's good. It encourages more marginal seats. It encourages people not to just vote for the last guy there. If they go, hey, well look, maybe if we vote for the other guy, we'll get a better promise. Again, this is democracy in action. I'm fully supportive of this. I'm not saying everything should be pork barreled Lenore, but you need a little bit of pork barreling in order to keep the system 'cause otherwise again, like
LenoreYou really don't.
Damian Damjanovskiwe s look look at what's happening with the bureau the bureaucrats now don't even want their testimony in the Senate.
LenoreIt's not pork barreling versus the bureaucrats. That's not the choice.
Damian DamjanovskiBut it be it is to some degree because again the bureaucrats are the ones who administer it. This week we saw
Peter LewisYou need a little bit of pork married.
Damian Damjanovskiwe saw I don't know if you
LenoreHa ha ha.
Damian Damjanovskiguys paid much attention to this, but I I'm obsessed with the fact that bureaucrats now don't want to be made fun of on social media. This is their new thing. As though they didn't have anything else to worry about. These million dollar a year bureaucrats are now concerned that people are making fun of them on social media. And they've politely asked and all gotten together.
Peter LewisWhat's going on is that
LenoreI've got to agree with you on this one.
Peter LewisDo you know the contact of this is my friend David Shoebridge, who's a green senator who does very effective
Ben PikeVery effective. Very effective.
Peter Lewisquestion and answer in those Senate committees. And he he basically it it is the the the the extent it's ridicule is they're delivering like, I don't know anything, I need to get back to you, and he just goes them and cuts them up and they're quite compelling. And like I think there is a sense that, you know. They that these people it it is a new medium and a new level of accountability and they're not ready for it. But seriously, harden up, sweetheart.
Damian DamjanovskiHang on, hang on, I'm so sorry. new new medium?
LenoreAnd yeah, this one this one they they are on a losing wicket. This is they are not gonna win this fight. They shouldn't win this fight. If you go to Senate estimates and you say stuff, you're out there.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, I couldn't agree with you more than all like and and I mean the only thing the only advice I would offer to David Shoebridge, if you want to pass it on, Peter, is that every one of his clips with the bureaucrat saying, I'll have to take that on notice or whatever it is should end with the end music from Curb Your Enthusiasm playing them out. That would be the only thing that I would add into his clips. But th these again
Peter LewisI'll I'll I'll offer it as some pay back.
Damian DamjanovskiThese are bureaucrats who are getting paid in some cases ten to twelve times the median salary of an Australian worker. That is crazy amounts
Ben PikeI know.
Damian Damjanovskiof money. Crazy, like it is crazy amounts of money.
Ben PikeAll of their job titles all of their job titles should be champagne coughing fat cats at the start.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisharsh. But I do
LenoreYeah.
Peter LewisI do feel that your Sydney Swann's analysis of the Faustian pact that if you're on that sort of money you give up certain things like
Damian DamjanovskiYou do.
Peter LewisCoke strippers and questions in Senate committee probably holds.
Damian DamjanovskiGuess part of the reason you're getting paid a million bucks a year is you might get ridiculed by the public in Senate estimates. That
Peter LewisYou don't take the coat, you don't take the strippers and you turn up to Yeah.
Damian Damjanovskithat that's it. That's part of the deal. If you don't like it, guess what? There's a huge public sec private sector out there. You can go and compete with everyone else for a real job. But if you don't want a real job and you want to work in the public service and you want to get paid a million bucks a year plus your 14%, 20% super, whatever they get these days. Then you might have to stand up to a little bit of ridicule and the Australian public thinking you're a nonce because a lot of you are nonces and can't answer questions
LenoreSo I I do think
Damian Damjanovskistraight up.
LenoreWe agree on the on the social media thing. I think bureaucrats are a real job. Do a you know, like do an important job. I have to beg to differ on that.
Damian DamjanovskiSome Summer Some do. Go on, sorry, Leno. Sorry, sorry, sorry, sorry.
LenoreMm, that's it. That's my whole point. Just sticking up for bureaucrats.
Peter LewisWe're going all ranty this week. I feel like we've become sky after dark this week.
LenoreYeah.
Peter LewisPlaying Paul Murray.
Damian DamjanovskiBut look, I I'll be honest, g
LenoreOkay.
Damian Damjanovskiif I give me one FTE's worth of bureaucrat money and I reckon thirty percent of I can automate with a good you know, good little Python script, I can automate their job quick smart. Like there is a lot of useless bureaucrats in there.
Peter LewisSpeaking of which, Pate Shaney introduced the automatic decision making private members bill this week. Have we got time to talk about digital duty of care or do you reckon what
Damian DamjanovskiWe've got all the time in the world.
Peter LewisWell, like of all the things that happened in Parliament this week, this is really significant structural reform if you actually create a enforceable duty of care on the largest tech companies in the world. It is significant, but it is already being dragged into a culture war with both the coalition and one nation jockeying to see
Ben PikeYeah.
Peter Lewiswho can go the freedom line harder. It's actually not what it's about, but I'm really worried about it. I don't know how you've seen it play out, Lenora. I know you've been watching it as well.
LenoreMm. yeah, I d I think the the freedom of speech argument doesn't work nearly as well, isn't nearly as valid or or coherent as it was with the misin d disinformation legislation, because this is designated and delineated harms that the platforms are supposed to be responsible for, andor giving people the right to opt out of the algorithm, which is surely the ultimate freedom as a user. You know, you can do it or not do it as you choose. So I don't think the freedom of speech arguments really hold, but they're certainly being put.
Damian DamjanovskiI'd I'd add to that before we throw to Ben, I I think there's two parts to this that are worth separating and I don't think the coalition or one nation has pursued a good line of attack on it yet. There's the algorithmic opt-out, opt-in, whatever you wanna whate whatever they they finally land on, or but it looks like it's gonna be opt out, which I I my understanding is the coalition isn't arguing against that. I don't think anyone's actually arguing against that. There is another provision within the other half, which is that basically the minister will get a power to define what a new harm is. And I think that's a very slippery slope when you give a minister the power to define a harm.
Peter LewisSo just to explain that
LenoreIsn't that already in the act?
Peter Lewisjust to explain that, Damien, what what they're proposing is so there were two there were two models put forward, a general duty of care, which I support, which is if you do damage, you should be held accountable, and a limited one. And the problem is they've gone for the limited, the paired backed model, and then they've got to codify then what are the constraints. And so the way that it's been put forward. They name specific harms for kids and illegality for adults, and that's the scope of the laws. But there is this thing that which I do not think will probably survive the scrutiny of the review, which is the minister can update it without taking it to Parliament. And I think there is a fair op there. I'd just be really worried if that became a reason to stop the whole thing, because this is our best chance. That and privacy reform. build the structure to actually control this a little bit. And I I I thought it was interesting when Albo was doing back to our original theme, when Albo was doing the announcement, he was saying, and this is something News Limited has been supporting as well and the parents whose kids have died from suicide. So I really hope that the debate, like you can you can quarterise the bit they're fighting over, which is the power of the minister, without losing sight of the broader principle. that if you are offering a service online you should be accountable for foreseeable damage that you can present prevent.
LenorePeter, you you've looked at this in more detail than I have, but I thought there were already designations like that in the act. Like there are already in the act designated harms.
Peter LewisYes, there are, but the difference is now the key bit is that they are saying that there is a duty on the on the name different internet providers or online providers to take practic reasonable practical steps to create a safe environment. That is
LenoreYeah, to look after that. Yeah. But the fact of the designations are already there.
Peter LewisYeah, because they're basically just repl replicating things that are sort of effectively illegal already. Yeah. You're in the telephone you'd be
Damian Damjanovskiopt in or an opt out system?
Peter Lewisrunning a war on this one. 'Cause whenever we try to regulate anything that you end up with whatever the Labor Minister is dressed up as Lenin or Stalin or something, you know?
Ben PikeWell that's I was gonna mention the Stephen Conroy famous front page that I think it's still hanging at at Alt Street.
Peter LewisThat was your work.
Ben PikeNo no no, it wasn't, but I remember it famously there was like there was Mao and there was Pol Pot and then there was Stephen Conroy doing that on the front page. And I think he put it up in his
Damian DamjanovskiWas this for the clean feed?
Peter LewisNo, this was for the sense that you'd have some sort of media regulator, but
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, the ISP sensor.
Peter Lewisit as soon as it becomes the pool.
Ben PikeYeah. And it was during it was during a time when there was the antagonism between the Labour government and the tele and News Corp was probably at its height. And yeah, when Julia
Peter LewisThe time. Wednesday.
Ben PikeGillard was the the PM and there were a lot of cartoons that were done of it. And so I remember one story and it was about Stephen Conroy. And because they had the right of report reply, they had one comment to make and his comment was This story says more about the people making the comparison than the comparison itself or words to
Damian DamjanovskiMm.
Ben Pikethat effect. And so I think it's it's it's amazing how you've got this completely unregulated sort of Wild West part of the of the online space and the media space, which probably has the most profound impact on politics. So I think like they are onto a winner because obviously News Corp has been behind it for one, because they don't want to see the harms to their kids. And it's I think the average punter can kind of be like, Yeah, you know what I followed my friends and I wanna see that content. So I think he's onto a winning argument there. I don't think they're gonna have too many detractors apart from obviously people who pay a lot for the algorithm to push particular things.
Peter LewisMm. And you know, particularly one nation being a beneficiary of the algorithm, trying to protect the algorithm, I think is interesting as well.
Ben PikeYeah, of course. Yeah. I think so. That's a big impact.
Damian DamjanovskiFascinating times. Peter, what about our kiss of death for the week? We've we've kicked over the hour, I apologize to our viewers. We've gone
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskia bit longer than usual. Have you got kiss of death for the week coming up?
Peter LewisI apologize to our viewers for the the I think the video quality might leave something to be desired this week too. So maybe listen to it online. So we're entering killing season. My kiss of death is that it may not be Angus, it might be the Greens that are looking at their leadership. So they had a a split. Now they've only got 15, I think, elected reps, but that's enough for a few factions. But what's been really interesting this week is so three of the Greens split over the Koala National Park. There was a disallowance motion to stop the conferring of carbon credits onto a national park that's trying to be built in New South Wales. And there's a a few different moving parts, but the interesting things is former leaders, Bob Brown, Christine Mill, and also Adam Bann, who's now at the ACF, all are scathing about the decision by the Greens to support it. As I said, three of them broke. I'm not sort of calling who's gonna be the next leader, but I just feel there's a bit of turbulence within the Greens, which we really haven't seen this term.
Damian DamjanovskiPhenomenal. That'll be interesting. Lenore, you remember our case of death. Have you got one for the week?
Lenoregoing to talk about the same thing as Peter, but just to add then I think it's interesting on top of that that despite all of the sort of political upheaval and political disillusionment among voters, the Greens voters r remain pretty static. Like there is, you know, angry disillusioned voters on the left as well, and the Greens are somehow not tapping into that. And I think that plays into that whole question as well.
Damian DamjanovskiFascinating. Ben, have you got a prediction for the week?
Ben PikeI I really worry for the New South Wales Liberal Party in light of all this ICAC revelations that keep on sort of bubbling away. I had a chat to someone at the SMH who said that their numbers are actually through the roof when it comes to ICAC th and they've been I think it's like a wet dream for the Herald to be doing stories on ICAC and I think there is gonna be some terminal damage for the Liberal brand in New South Wales. James Griffin, who's the MP for Manly, he's left because I think he realise how bad the polling numbers were with the TLs. and I think Kelly Sloane is a very capable communicator and is probably propping up what is a sinking ship. And I and I and I'd be really interested to see what happens in Victoria and then how that will play out in New South Wales. Like obviously Labour looks like they're on the nose down there. Chris Mins is a lot more capable sort of performer
Damian DamjanovskiMm.
Ben Pikein New South Wales and probably hold on to a lot of a
Peter LewisDamien's favorite premiere ever. I said
Damian DamjanovskiMinzen Malinauskas.
Ben PikeSorry, what was that?
Peter LewisDamien Damien's favorite favorite premiere. Did I hear
Ben PikeYeah.
Peter Lewisthat you got a a mention in the ICAC in a positive way, Ben? Do you want to humble brag that?
Ben PikeYeah, so that was one of those classic situations where there is zero buyer's regret. So there was this dog shit story that was being circulated and I'd written a lot about planning and development, gene the sif and sort of defects a fair bit, and there was this story circulating about the building commissioner supposedly being racist and wanting to take a payout or some money to overlook defects. And Myself and Josh Bavis, who was then at the ABC and now he's at nine, I think he's overseas now, had both said no to the story, even though like it was in our wheelhouse and we were reporting on it. And so there was a few mentions of me making inquiries and then one of me having a conversation with David Chandler about this video. So my old colleague Linda Silmarlis, who I'm sure you would have seen. has had multiple, multiple mentions. because obviously she was sort of heavily involved in reporting a lot of of the chicanery that was going on in New South Wales. But I think it's I think it just speaks true that nothing nothing is private, really. Even if you have a conversation with someone and obviously everyone here on the call would sort of realize about putting stuff in writing and you've got be so forensic about what you do because it's all discoverable. So Yeah.
LenoreDid you not run the story 'cause it didn't stack up or didn't or you were worried about its provenance?
Ben PikeIt was it was it didn't stack up. And it eventually did run. but it was obviously a push to try and get rid of the building commissioner and install someone who would be more friendly to this genius if property developer
Damian DamjanovskiMm.
Ben Pikewho will be getting testimony next week. And it's a classic, you know, story as old as the time as the nexus between property developers and politicians in New South Wales. And it's been sort of fascinating to watch the sort of almost comically bumbling attempts to try and discredit David Elliott, who is one of the most entertaining and effective politicians that
Peter LewisCaptain. Hmm.
Ben PikeNew South Wales has seen in a while. I think he's really good.
Damian DamjanovskiHe's a great man.
Peter LewisSo
Ben Pikeand yeah, it's been fascinating to watch.
Peter LewisSo like John West, the stories Ben Pike rejects is what makes Ben Pike the best.
Ben PikeI'm
LenoreOops.
Ben Pikegonna put that on my business card.
Damian Damjanovskimy kiss of death for the week, Mr. Lewis. firstly, it is just hitting sunset, and we're recording this on Friday, September the 11th. So Shonatova.
Peter LewisWe are now officially after the art, this is good.
Damian DamjanovskiWe're after dark, so Shonatova, and welcome to the Jewish New Year. We are now in the year 5787 for those keeping count. And I have a I I don't know if this is gonna happen, I have no insider knowledge, but I'm saying Jewish New Year, I reckon Josh is gonna officially announce that he's putting his hat back in the ring after the end of the new year next year. That's that's my weird weird little
Peter Lewisbig one.
Damian Damjanovskiguess is he'll take Rosha Shana to reflect and go, Nah, I'm I'm I'm putting my hat back in the ring.
Peter LewisWow, that's a good one.
Damian Damjanovski'Cause New Year's
Ben PikeI don't think he
LenoreInteresting.
Damian Damjanovskia great time to do
Ben Pikecan help himself.
Damian Damjanovskiit if ever there is.
Ben PikeYeah.
LenoreAnd his book.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd his book launch,
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskiof course. on that note, Lenore, thank you so much for joining us yet again. We always have such fascinating and enlightening conversations. So I thank you for taking the time out on your Friday. Ben, thank you again for joining us for the first time. I hope you will feel that you can come back any time. We have a lot more things to discuss, not just related to News Media One Nation and Victoria. so we look forward to welcoming you back again. Mr. Lewis, as it is every week, it is a deep pleasure. to disagree with you on pretty much everything. I look forward to more disagreement with you next week. If you haven't yet, please like, share
Peter LewisThanks, mate. have a good run.
Damian Damjanovskiand subscribe. The show relies on people like you watching us and sharing it with people who you think might get a bit of enjoyment out of it. And hopefully we'll see you again next week.
