Episode 24

Weeds: brumbies, bird flu and humans

With Jack Gough

19 September 20261 hr 11 min

Show notes

We're joined by Jack Gough, CEO of the Invasive Species Council, to talk about protecting Australian wildlife, including when that means culling other animals. We get into feral cats, the Brumby wars, and how a feral horse became a protected heritage item in a national park. We also ask why every conversation about the environment becomes a debate about climate change, and whether conservation should be a natural fit for conservatives.

We then take a deep dive into bird flu, what it could mean for Australian wildlife, and how dead birds on beaches might shift the politics of the environment. Damian explains his “inverse pyramid of f!cks given”, and we talk egg prices, pets, tourism, and when an environmental problem becomes everyone's problem. We finish with immigration, housing, and whether a stronger connection to Australian nature could give us something to agree on. Plus our usual Kiss of Death predictions, and Jack gives us a reason to worry about honey bees. Because apparently the cats and horses weren't enough.

Chapters

  • 00:00 Introduction, Victorian Potholes and Poison of Choice
  • 03:41 Introducing Jack Gough
  • 06:15 What Does the Invasive Species Council Do?
  • 09:11 What Makes a Species Invasive?
  • 11:31 Cane Toads, Rabbits and Biological Controls
  • 15:52 Feral Cats and Australia's Extinction Problem
  • 19:05 The Brumby Wars: Heritage, Horses and Politics
  • 24:24 Conservation, Conservatives and Climate Change
  • 28:14 Has Climate Change Swallowed the Environment Debate?
  • 30:57 Bird Flu: What's at Stake for Australian Wildlife?
  • 37:39 Preparing for Wildlife Loss and Building Resilience
  • 39:59 The Inverse Pyramid of F!cks Given
  • 42:34 Egg Prices, Beaches and the Politics of Bird Flu
  • 47:32 Why Not Just Let Nature Take Its Course?
  • 51:16 Custodianship and Australia's Changing Landscapes
  • 52:37 Immigration and Our Connection to the Bush
  • 58:46 Population, Nature and a Shared Australian Story
  • 01:02:58 Immigration, Housing and the Skills We Need
  • 01:06:22 Kiss of Death: China, AI and Bird Flu
  • 01:08:44 Culling, Honey Bees and a Live Show Teaser

Full transcript

Read itHide it

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.

Peter LewisWelcome to What's Your Poison, the show where people who disagree on just about everything agree it's best to do so over a drink. My name's Peter Lewis. I'm the chair of the progressive strategy shop Essential. Joining me, as he does every week, is my evil twin, the man who put the Mo in SCOMO, the principal at General Strategic, Dame Damjanowski. Dame, how are you? How's your week? What's your poison?

Damian DamjanovskiVery good, mister Lewis, and all the better for seeing you. I am as you might be able to tell, am down in our southernmost mainland state, which is Melbourne.

Peter LewisIs that public building behind you or a sports ground?

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, it's the Arts Centre. Yeah. So I think that's Melbourne's attempt at an opera house. It's it's looks like a big telephone tower kind of thing. It's not too bad. my week's been great. I've been enjoying travelling as as you might remember, I was in Queensland last this week this time last week. and I've driven from Queensland all the way down here to Melbourne, so quite a drive. And I actually stopped there for Yeah, it's it's

Peter LewisWow, clicks including through that great border town of Aubrey where I did a bit of my cadetship. Yeah.

Damian Damjanovskia great town actually, but I will say before we dig into it. I know a lot of our Victorian listeners and in general complain to almost comic levels about the potholes of Victoria and we all have a laugh and a giggle because we go, well there's surely more important things to talk about than potholes. But by God is there a lot of potholes in this state. As soon as you cross the Murray, I reckon my car and I don't drive a a big four-wheel drive SUV thing. I have a a small, close to the ground car. My car definitely felt Victoria, I can tell you that. So. Bumping,

Peter LewisYour Starlink was bounc bouncing off the road.

Damian Damjanovskibump, bouncing up and down. What's your poison this week, Mr. Lewis?

Peter LewisDid you give me yours?

Damian Damjanovskisorry, no, I am I'm going old school and I'm going back to Strongbows in my little apple cider exploration because they now have a Strongbow Hard Cider, and this is a berry infused Strongbow Hard Cider. So it's kind of like

Peter LewisThat's just an alcohol pot.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, it really is, but it's a little bit sour, it's got a little bit of raspberry in it, a little bit of apple in it, and it's eight point two percent, which is fantastic.

Peter LewisGot a bit

Jack GoughYeah.

Peter Lewiswell, I've got a bit of berry in mind too, according to this, some rich cherry. So I've just come back from Mudgy, where I spent the week helping out my sister in her terrific restaurant, Food and Farm Dining. While I was there, I dropped in on the mayor, the unofficial mayor of Mudgy, Pete Logan, Logan Labs, are coming up with a Sangiovese out of the laboratory. And I got a case of that on the way back. So I'm topping one of those. Terrific a Mudgy This time of year is beautiful, obviously, but they've had a bit of politics up there. The mayor of 20 years was rolled two nights ago. Not the unofficial mayor Pete, but the real mayor, a guy called Des Kennedy. and yeah, he got rolled as mayor. no one saw it coming, including the guy that beat him. Apparently, it's blow back over the tourist push that he's been having in the area. So When we talk about immigration in in a little while, it's a little

Damian DamjanovskiSo

Peter Lewisbit of a microcosm of that. So the old school pushing back against trying to bring people into the region.

Damian DamjanovskiWell I think we're seeing that in more and more regional towns. I will say by the way, I've actually tried that Logan Labs Sangiovese and I'm not a wine drinker, but I loved it. And I'm glad you

Peter Lewisa light red.

Damian Damjanovskigot a whole case of it 'cause we know what you're gonna be bringing next time we see each other in person.

Peter LewisAbsolutely. We've got to get you and Jules out there actually and do a show because he is one of the sort of leaders in Australian wine making, some great stories about how that industry works and trying to set up a sustainable wine industry at the moment as well.

Damian DamjanovskiWell, speaking of all things sustainability, wine industry, farming and whatnot, who is our guest that you've brought along this week, Mr Lewis?

Peter LewisWell, it's it's someone that I've been really wanting to get inside his head for a while, largely because I've

Jack GoughOkay.

Peter Lewisgot this immense sense of doom coming over me about what the summer's gonna look like around bird flu. So Jack Goff, who is the CEO of the Invasive Species Council, longtime friend of Essentials as well, couldn't think of anyone better to finish the week to give me a reality check on my gloom and doom, or actually embed it further. But welcome, Jack, and Thanks for coming along, and what's your poison?

Jack GoughGreat to be with you. Yeah, no, there's a little bit of doom around Birdfill, I must say, and it's probably spring, not just summer, that we've got to watch out for. But no, I've got the the Jervis Bay pale ale because I was down at Jervis Bay on the weekend, so a mate of mine's the brewer down there and he and so we brought a case of it back and that's what we're drinking at the moment the time.

Peter LewisWhere's the whereabouts in Jervis is the actual has he got a brewery and everything down on the water there, does he?

Jack GoughYeah, so Wallemire actually. So just basically just outside of Jervis Bay, so outside of Huskison. so there's there's two breweries I think out there now. There's it's sort of become a bit it's like basically the old industrial estate, out that way and it's it's become a bit of a hub now. and they've you know

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, you're both saying it Jarvispay, not JavaSpay. Is that an insider thing or?

Jack GoughIt's actually so it's the the naval base, they call it Jarvis Bay and the locals call it Jervis Bay. So it's a it's a it it's a bit of a thing down there.

Peter LewisSo that's a way of telling if you've actually got military next door or not, just by the way. That's a good tell.

Jack GoughYeah, well I mean I you know

Damian Damjanovskimy understanding is that the guy who it was named after was actually called Jarvis, but the you know, the the official towns planner or the surveyor general miswrote it misspelled it in the writing as Jervis. And so the reason the military pronounced it Jarvis is that was the guy's name. but much like, you know, we all pronounce former Prime Minister Robert Menzies as Menzies, which is not how he pronounced his last name, he pronounced it as Mingus. the

Peter LewisReally?

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, he's Scottish. So Menzies in in like Gallic Scottish is pronounced Mingus. Yeah. Yeah.

Peter LewisI did not know I knew that he was known as Ming, but I'd never got that that cheek is.

Damian DamjanovskiSo until he got to Parliament, he would refer to himself as Bob Mingus. Like Bob Mingus was his name because he was Scottish. and then you know, in the Australian fashion we pronounced we decided we pronounced it Menzies and so Menzies is what stuck after it.

Peter LewisWould have been much better for Limericks anyway. hey Jack,

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter LewisI was hoping you'd actually bring a Cosy Oscar you threatened to, because I thought that'd be a really good segue into our history together, which was researching public attitudes to the Brumbies, which was one of the most wicked environmental problems we'd face. But for those that don't know much about the Invasive Species Council, like you guys do the hard work, which is not hugging trees, but killing critters that ruin the environment. So tell us a bit about the work that you guys do.

Jack GoughYeah, I mean I think a lot of people get surprised around the invasive species issue. But basically Australia's a continent and we're an island and because we're an island and a continent that's been isolated from the rest of the the world for millions of years, geographically isolated, means we've got pretty unique wildlife, pretty unique species here, but also very under threat from invasive species coming in. So a lot of so actually in Australia where we are pretty much the extinction capital of the world, the majority of extinctions have been caused by invasive species. But the majority of the public conversation is around, you know, deforestation and you know what's happening in the Murray Darling Basin, all pretty legitimate environment issues. But yeah, our work was set up in 2002 by a group of people that basically came together, scientists, and said, we can't get the traditional environment groups. to care very much about invasive species is an issue. but also the majority of the sort of bureaucratic focus on biosecurity and invasives is focused on industry priorities. So, you know, we basically went from a quarantine system that was set up for human health. And, you know, if you go to Sydney you can see the quarantine station and and other places where people do ghost tours now.

Peter Lewisalso the f spraying of you when you come into the country, that all that stuff, right?

Damian DamjanovskiHmm.

Jack GoughExactly. And then 150 years ago, foot and mouth disease turned up and basically Australia cobbled together this biosecurity system from there and was able to eradicate foot and mouth disease. But the environmental side of invas of invasives and biosecurity really has only been something that's been focused on for the last couple of decades. and it's still pretty low in the sort of broader side of things. And yeah, a lot of the things that we're dealing with, we're not dealing with sort of politically contentious issues in the in the same way of left versus right. A lot of it is actually around, you know, are you able to kill some of these invasive species like horses and cats and foxes? but also, you know, when it comes to something like say fire ants, there's a huge amount of backlash from some groups around the use of chemical poisons that are are needed

Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.

Jack Goughto be used. But

Peter LewisLove the Chris Ants.

Jack Goughdefinitely Yeah, exactly. And which mirrors some of the things that you see in those

Damian DamjanovskiSo so Jack, I'm I'm g can I ask some like

Jack Goughanti vaxx and covet debates.

Damian DamjanovskiL let me ask some basic questions just 'cause A, I need to wrap my head around it and B I'm sure there's a lot of people listening who this might be the first time they've heard anything in slight depth about invasive species. So w firstly, what counts as an invasive species? Are we talking just animals, or are we talking plants as well? Like what's an invasive species? What do you classify that as?

Jack GoughSo we classify it's it's the things that have come to Australia by human-assisted movement, which then have a detrimental effect on the native ecosystem. So a huge number of species come, and that's that plants, animals, it's also, you know, things like mollusks that come in ballast water, it's also things like fungus that turn up, ants, a whole range of different things and and and so you know. Given Australia had, you know, European settlement over two hundred years ago, there were things that came at the time on the ships. There were a whole heap of things that got deliberately established. So they had what was called a acclimatization societies. And in Queensland they were all about plants and in New South Wales and Victoria they were all about animals.

Peter LewisSo they'd bring in a bit of Europe just to make it feel like home.

Jack GoughExactly. Well

Damian DamjanovskiThat's that's that's why we have pine trees by the beach, isn't it? Like that's the whole thing of that weird Australian habit of putting pine trees by

Jack GoughYeah, though so Norfolk pines tend to be the ones.

Peter LewisWow.

Damian Damjanovskibeaches.

Jack GoughYeah, yeah, yeah. So Norfolk pines, but though though they also, you know, tend to be planted partly because of the way that they can withstand, you know, the the the the breezes. And so people want trees next to beaches that otherwise would have been mainly just shrubs. But yeah, so a whole range of invasive spit it comes to things like wolf snakes getting onto to islands and wiping out pipestrels like small native bats or you know deer that were introduced for hunting in the 1800s that that slowly started to spread from Victoria and then took off when a venison market was established in the 90s and then essentially that the collapse of that venison market meant that they started to spread out across the country or fire ants for example up in Queensland that people may have heard of which turn up in container ships with soil when that comes along. So Really, it's about the the the vast array of different things that a huge increase in shipping and trade brings.

Peter LewisOf course, the pin up the pin up child of ugly invasive species would have to be the cane toad, right? Like so the the cane toad was specifically introduced to get rid of another introduced species and then did the whole Frankenstein thing, right?

Jack GoughYeah, so the cane cane toad to to take out the cane beetle that was impacting on cane growing didn't do that, but then very quickly spread and yeah, has been a real really devastating for for native wildlife. So particularly things like goannas and snakes, which when they eat them get poisoned. And so you get this sort of invasion front of cane toads where as they'd be moving west and south, you get, you know, massive impacts on quals and and and a lot of the things that go to eat them, snakes, goanas, but then obviously also in places in Queensland now in particular, they're also a massive pest for people and when you, you know, breed up in massive numbers.

Peter LewisSo it's almost like a biology version of economics in that you put in a theory and then it's only in retrospect you can work out if the theory's actually worked, and normally it doesn't.

Jack GoughWell, no, not not normally it doesn't actually. We've got a pretty good history now around biocontrols being introduced. And people may remember when Barnaby Joyce was pushing pretty hard for a carp herpes virus to be introduced. I don't know if you if that ever made it up to the PM's office, but it was a a pretty big debate, Damien, when towards the end of the coalition government

Damian DamjanovskiWe we avoided all of Barnaby's herpes

Peter LewisBarnaby

Damian Damjanovskirelated issues. Yeah.

Peter Lewiswas pro Herpes though, that does not surprise me at all.

Jack GoughHe was. He's and we we work pretty well with Barnaby on on a lot of things in this space, which is interesting. But the you know, that's one where it hasn't quite been introduced 'cause there are a lot more tests and things going on and there's been huge numbers of biocontrols and in particular people would know for rabbits, myxomatosis and Khaleesi virus. And so that's where, you know, we've probably had a billion rabbits at least in the country back in the nineteen fifties, mainly that went up and down on the basis of droughts and and seasonal cycles. And then CSI O bring in a virus specifically, could have been a cane toad, but they did a lot of testing and things and that actually wiped out ninety nine point eight percent of the rabbits very quickly. That

Peter LewisThat was mixed somatosis, right?

Jack Goughwas mixed mitosis back in the fifties and then Khaleesi virus in the nineties and the early twenty tens as well. So

Damian DamjanovskiSo hang on, isn't most of Australia's wildlife these days and like farmed, you know, animal stock and plant stock, isn't it all introduced and potentially invasive species? Isn't like the majority of stuff that we rely on, not just for food and fibre, but like I'm thinking like even

Jack GoughYeah, so

Damian Damjanovskicats and dogs and

Jack GoughAbsolutely. So I guess we make a distinction between introduced species and invasive species. So invasives invasive is a reflection on impact. So you know, when when things are you know, a horse that is in a paddock on someone's farm is, you know, a domestic horse, a horse that's got into a national park and is trashing and trampling that area we've set aside for nature and causing damage to the headwaters of those rivers.

Damian DamjanovskiRight.

Jack GoughThat's an invasive species. Similarly, you know, w you know, obviously sheep and cattle have in enormous impacts where they are, but for areas where we've set them aside for nature, then when these get get in there, that's w where they tend to be called feral animals. But for a lot of our, yeah, a lot of invasive sorry, a lot of species that have introduced haven't become invasive. So for example, you know, at the moment there I think there's 34,000 at least exotic plant species present in Australia, but only a small percentage of them have ever become weeds that have got out and caused a lot of damage. But when they do, the damage can be enormous. Transforming ecosystems, one of the big things that's happening with some weeds, for example, now pasture grasses like buffal and gamber grass that were planted for cattle have become these huge transformers of inland and tropical. savannas in Australia because they changed fire regimes, for example. So now they're considered a weed and we're trying to get rid of them, but originally they were planted as cattle feed.

Peter Lewisso the the general rule of thumb is the bigger and furrier the critter, the harder it is to get social license to eradicate it. But do you want to just talk about maybe horses and cats are the two that I know you do a lot of work trying to get to convince people that the only approach is to actually eradicate them from particular areas. And I know the Brumby stuff in the in the in the snowies has just gone crazy over many years.

Damian DamjanovskiSorry, did you say horses and cats?

Peter LewisYeah.

Jack GoughCats. Yeah. So so I would I would I would get death threats daily on some of the on those two issues, horses and cats, I must say. so

Damian DamjanovskiI wanna hear about Brumbies but just just explain cats to me so I understand why this is an issue.

Jack GoughYeah. So cats have actually been the biggest driver of extinctions in Australia. So over twenty native species have gone extinct to cats. So we're talking about no, we're talking about cats

Damian DamjanovskiWe're talking about like cats, like normal cats. Like there's not some special scientific cat you're talking about. Like you're just talking about

Jack Goughthat were domestic that have got out into the bush and are now literally killing millions of native animals every single day. So about eight million native animals killed every twenty-four hours by cats. And so there's I guess two categories of cats. There's

Damian DamjanovskiAre they banding together? Have they organized? Have they unionized? What's how?

Jack GoughThey they're incredible hunters and killers. Like they're Yeah, yeah. No,

Peter LewisThis is the free market in operation. There's no union involved, are they?

Jack Goughno, no. They're they're incredible hunters and killers, cats. you know, that's how they've survived in you know in in the wild in areas where the native wildlife have adapted to having that that particular predator there and Australia's native

Damian DamjanovskiWow.

Jack Goughwildlife haven't. And so what we talk about is Australian mammals in about the Half a kilogram, 500 grams to about two and a half kilograms, to five kilograms, that's the snack size for cats. And basically a lot of our native wildlife, huge numbers of you know, bilbies and bandicoots and betongs and you know, quals even, so some of the bigger predators, have gone extinct in the presence of cats and foxes because they are such efficient hunters and killers, and because in Australia our native wildlife. haven't adapted over millions of years to having that sort of a predator. I mean, the the predators that were here before were Phylosanes and Tasmanian devils, which probably got wiped out by dingoes, and and really it was dingoes and quals.

Peter LewisDingo's an in in dingoes are kind of an invasive species, they were introduced, weren't they?

Jack GoughYeah, introduced species. pretty limited circumstances where they're invasive

Damian DamjanovskiThey're they're a canine, aren't they?

Jack Goughnow. So

Peter LewisYeah.

Jack Goughso they they were they were brought here by by humans about five thousand years ago, certainly introduced, but they wiped out and caused a lot of the extinctions all the way back thousands of years ago. So we used to have, you know, Tasmanian wood hens used to be on the mainland, thylasanes, and and Tasmania devils all used to be in mainland Australia and were probably sent extinct by the dingo, but now they're limited circumstances where they're actually invasive but certainly introduced in terms of their

Damian DamjanovskiI this it feels like another reason to not like cats. And I'm a dog guy, so this

Jack GoughYeah.

Damian Damjanovskithis I'm I I'm lining up with this. but tell us about

Jack GoughYeah.

Damian Damjanovskithe Brumbies and the horses. So obviously this has been a big issue

Jack GoughYeah.

Damian Damjanovskifrom a political landscape, so

Jack GoughSo yeah, and and a really interesting one from the political landscape because of the players that have been involved over a number of of years. But you know, Susan Lay and and Angus Taylor are two of the the big players who have been on two different sides of that debate. it's been one that's involved, you know, some you know, really going to the leadership of Liberal and Labour Party for the last you know decade, which has been very interesting. But I think going back to what Pete was saying before, there's this concept of charismatic megafauna. So both both the things that are problematic if they're big and look nice, but also the you know it it's they they tend to want to be protected rather than removed. But also when it comes to some of the species that are threatened, you know, there's a reason why a lot of the environment debate ends up being about koalas and pandas and lions

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Jack Goughand tigers and not you know, large snails or even things like bandicoots and and betongs. The smaller they are, people care less. But yeah, so the the feral horse issue in Kosyosko is one of these ones where you had a essentially what's gone on there is that the there used to be in the mountain cattleman up in the up in the high country of Australia. And there was a recognition in the 50s to the eighties That that was damaging the headwaters of the Murray, the Murambidie, and the Snowy, that those alpine peat landscapes couldn't cope with really heavy, hard-hooved herbivores at scale there. And it used to be previously that, you know, cattle were up there and so the horse numbers were kept pretty low by the cattlemen who didn't want horses competing with the cattle. When they were removed, you've then had this slow growth of the numbers of of horses in the high country. And I s often say with invasive species that no one cares until everyone cares. it tends to be one of these

Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.

Jack Goughthings with exponential growth. And it's happening with rabbits right now. I've been chatting to a lot of politicians saying rabbits are gonna be a massive issue over the next few years because we're starting to see them at levels we haven't seen since the nineties, and th and as they build, they will suddenly be in everyone's backyard and everywhere and people will be talking about them. But those horse numbers started to really escalate and they It was an issue which the former leader of the New South Wales opposition, Mark Speakman, who w wa at the time back in the 2006, sorry, two thousand and sixteen was the environment minister. He tried to get on top of and it caused this huge rift with John Barrellaro, who was the leader of the National Party, but also the member for Monero. He worked with the former member, Peter Cochran, who's now with One Nation and and a big part of of One Nation.

Peter Lewishas he jumped the fence?

Jack GoughYeah, he jumped the fence. He stood for one nation now, even though he was the nationals member of the century, and the member and they put together a bill which protected the horses in the high country and that got through the parliament.

Peter LewisSo they made a weed a heritage item, Dame. Genius.

Jack GoughYeah. So they basically

Damian DamjanovskiSo

Jack Goughsaid that in a national park a feral animal was protected. And that caused a huge amount of backlash and a real rift, interestingly, between the liberals and the nationals. So it was this and and a and an interesting one also because I remember at the time we couldn't find anyone except for John Barillaro within the Nationals who actually thought it was a good idea, but he staked his his full political capital. on wanting to get this bill through because it was directly tied to his pre-selection and and the local politics of that. and yeah, a really interesting one where there was then a backlash to that from the community. You had a total change in the politics.

Peter LewisAnd it's interesting. The backlash was often the backlash on environmental is, that'd be very nice, but economically we can't afford it. This was a cultural backlash rather than an economic one, which made it even more, you know, febrile, right?

Jack GoughAbsolutely. I mean it's it's it's been a it's it's there's sort of three groups of people who are opposed to removing the horses. One of them is like the old mountain cattlemen groups, and that's what Angus Taylor's very linked to. So the current so he's been doing podcasts on this and speaking about it in Parliament since he became the leader. and his, you know, there's links to to his his his brother's wife who was a New South Wales Nationals minister. That so there's that side of things. And they really have been pretty clear that it's about getting cattle back into those national parks and sort of the locals taking back control. Then there's another group which is quite connected to the Silver Brumby books and you know Russell Crowe Silver Brumby movie and that sort of ethereal, quite spiritual connection to the horses being in the land in the landscape. And they can be pretty full on, I must say. and then a third group, which is people who don't believe that any animal should be killed. So like a lot of that animal justice party, animal rights movement. Yeah. So and

Peter LewisWhich is more the left, right? It's I I'm really

Damian DamjanovskiSo

Peter Lewisinterested in the politics, Dame, because I've always felt that the in the politics of environmentalism generally is quite confused and it's not an obvious left right. Like on one level, you know, the ACF, the Australian Conservation Foundation was I think its original trustee was Sir Garfield Barwick, who is like a you know, a doyen of of the Liberal Party and that whole idea of

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter Lewisconservation conservatism makes sense and I And then you've got the climate movement that's seen as a left wing movement and a market intervention. I don't know, like what how do you

Damian DamjanovskiYeah. I I think

Peter Lewissee it as somebody that sort of sits on the right side of politics with some conviction?

Damian DamjanovskiIt's it's it's it's a real interesting question. I think it's actually one where it's one of those very important questions that could benefit with a lot more of our kind of discussion that we usually have rather than the usual, you know, yelling that you see on various TV channels and on on in newspapers and more often than not online, which is I would argue that most conservative people like like there are gonna be there are always climate deniers and climate change deniers. They over index on being conservatives, but it's not because they're conservative that they're climate deniers. They're climate deniers and the conservative side of politics appeals to their value set more than the progressive side of politics in general, right? So that Yeah. Yeah, exactly.

Peter LewisBut also if you're anti statist, like a state like be 'cause they see it as creeping socialism and everything as well, right?

Damian DamjanovskiI exactly. So most conservatives aren't climate deniers. What they are against is the net zero movement and part of that is it goes fundamentally against their ideas of smaller government and free markets are better and the idea of you know, the mega government in the form of a Paris Accord telling us all what we should do and we here in Australia suffer because we happen to you know, dig up a lot of this stuff while others do XY and like it's that kind of stuff that I think.

Peter LewisBut wasn't Paris a market mechanism? It was quite a capitalist way of dealing with a a problem if you

Damian DamjanovskiYes and no, depends if you only talk about stage one emissions, stage two emissions, stage three emissions, and all these definitions then get blurry and blurrier. And as bureaucrats do tend to do, and you know my love of bureaucracy, they start conflating issues more and more and making it more complicated to the point where no one understands what we were doing, and in the meantime the planet continues to burn. So was Paris and all that good intention ultimately a net positive? Probabs not. You know what has made the biggest impact? is individual consumers going, if I can get cheaper electricity by shoving a solar panel on my roof and buying Elon Elon Musk's power battery for my wall, I'm gonna do that. That's how it No it no there was a subsidy, sure.

Peter LewisThat was a state intervention in the market for individuals to make consumer choices. Cause it's all subsidised.

Damian DamjanovskiBut P Australia was installing solar panels en masse before the subsidy and they were installing battery plaques on s on mass before that subsidy. It was the market that led people to go, actually if there's a cheaper and more cost effective way for me to do this And lower my power bills and maybe sell it back to the grid, I'ma gonna do that. All the government's done in the meantime is made the process more convoluted, complicated, and gotten everyone off side in the meantime. Like they to me the the climate crisis is an example of when sometimes government should set a direction and then get the hell out of the way, rather than making these huge mandates and making what could have been a simple process like making it incredibly complicated. But that's for another day.

Peter LewisGiven you guys ran it for a decade, I'll take that as self self-reflection. But Jack,

Damian Damjanovskiabsolutely. Absolutely.

Peter Lewiswhere do you sit where do you see your work in that ideological spectrum? Like how do you see the politics of what you do?

Jack GoughLook, I find it really interesting that we went from, you know, horses and nature to climate change and emissions. and the reason I find that interesting is because I see this happening all the time in the public debate, which is that increasingly in both politics and I work in every single parliament in the country, with politicians of all sides, you know, I've you know, can pick up the phone and chat to Barnaby as easily as chatting to the, you know, head of the Greens or the or or you know people within state politics and federal, is that the environment has become climate change. And this has not served Australia's nature. I mean, climate change is one factor that impacts on nature, but it is also something that is massively going to impact on, you know, economic policy and disaster resilience and you know, infrastructure and housing, like a whole heap of

Damian DamjanovskiFarming.

Jack Goughit's really a social decision. We and we have to make these Massive shifts to our economy to deal with it, nature often requires direct intervention and on-ground work to restore it, to protect it. and a lot of that stuff is actually cuts straight across the political divide. So we work probably in a lot of circumstances actually better with conservative governments than labor governments. And one of the one of the reasons for that is because I do find often that. I I've I find this thing a lot and I don't know whether Peter and Damien if if you guys see this as well, that l I I find that Labour governments tend to put a lot of a lot of faith into the public service and conservative liberal governments tend to put a lot of faith into outside sort of actors giving them and and a lot of the public service I think has been quite depleted. So we have this this issue often that ideas don't come from the public service, but left wing governments want to you know rely on that public service and then they don't get the ideas. Whereas conservative governments I tend to find often are driving down those public service so that it's gonna generate less ideas but are much more open to players like us bringing in ideas, engaging with them. But I do think we have

Peter LewisParticularly when you guys

Damian DamjanovskiYeah. That's o that's only because can Yeah.

Peter Lewisare bringing in solutions to be fair. Like you're you're you guys you you guys find a problem and you're coming in and saying this is what you need to do, which is where I've seen you from the cheap sea. We could talk about this

Jack GoughYeah. Yeah.

Peter Lewisall show, but I do wanna get into bird flu, which I don't know if it fits in the frame of invas well, I guess a a germ is an invasive species, isn't it, Jack? But you you really put me back on the on the on the on the soles of my feet when I saw you at ALP National Conference, you say, You you got no idea how bad summer's gonna be and I've almost had tears in my eyes every time I've heard a bird since. So can you tell us what what's going on, particularly through this invasive frame and then what's the summer going to

Jack GoughYeah.

Peter Lewislook like?

Jack GoughYeah, look, I think I have been saying to politicians that bird flu is pretty serious. In terms of what we've seen around the world, we've seen millions of dead birds, tens of thousands of dead mammals, something that really could be an extinction crisis for a lot of our species. The Australian government's own review, which came out, suggested that almost one in five of our mammal and bird species are at high to severe risk of of sorry, high to extreme risk of severe population declines. And that's like even really common species or or really high profile species, cassawaris and pelicans and ibises, so you know, and and seals, huge so there's a huge potential for death. Yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiSo So sorry, sorry Jack, sorry to interrupt you, but like j just run me through bird flu. So this is a is it a virus that only affects b bird life but is deadly to them or is particularly bad? Like wha what is it again, just for people who who don't necessarily have their heads around this?

Jack GoughSo bird flu emerged in Asia and and I mean there's lots of different flu viruses that you know, ones that humans have, ones that most mammals and birds

Damian DamjanovskiWas it because a bird went to a human market?

Jack Goughpardon.

Damian DamjanovskiDid a bird go to a human wet market? Is that what happened? They went the other way around?

Jack GoughBut yeah, I mean look, it is one like COVID, it's one of these ones where you have you know, the concentration of livestock production and people being very up close and, you know, mass flock sizes means that you've got a much higher chance of viruses mutating and becoming really bad. And so there's been a whole heap of different bird flues that have circulated. so last year we had a variety in Australia, the H seven variety, and that H seven variety just got into a few chicken farms in in Victoria but took, you know I think 1500 staff off their normal job to manage, huge numbers having to be culled, and that's just in a few chicken farms. but those bird flus have tended to be quite matched to poultry. So they're ones they've emerged in chickens or ducks, and then they spread through you know, contact of hu with people moving chickens and ducks into other chicken and duck farms, can and you know, hundreds of millions of birds have had to be culled or have died because of these bird flu varieties. Then in 2022, a new variety emerged. So it's this clade 4.33 B of H5N1 bird flu. So technical specific one. And that started to really wipe out wildlife as well. And the problem with wiping out wildlife and getting into wild birds was that it then becomes something that you can't really contain. Because wild birds move.

Peter Lewis'Cause they fly around the world.

Jack GoughThey exactly, but no, but even just at a local level, you can't just be going out and culling masses of wild birds, like you can, you know, shut down a chicken farm, cull all the birds, stop the spread of it. and it started to spread really quickly. And it caused, you know, in the UK they lost 30%, for example, of their breeding shorebirds in one year. You know, so you get thirty

Damian DamjanovskiYou say thirty percent.

Jack Goughpercent. So you get these images of islands that are so off Scotland, for example, that are just Packed with birds. You can't there's not a single space on there that's not a bird. The next year, there's almost no birds. you know, y and so huge devastation in the Netherlands, all over the place. It then moved really quickly, got into the US and in the US started to impact i even on dairy cattle, and and and was actually one of the reasons

Damian DamjanovskiSo this can jump across species as well.

Jack GoughWell s yeah, so it really goes across different bird species, but then when mammals consume those birds, and it's not a risk for human health when they're cooked, but when they consume them, they it can pass on to them, have really high death rates. I think there's about 70 US dairy workers who got infected from it with a number dying. and actually this bird flu, this H five N1 clade four three three B was one of the reasons Donald Trump got elected. So if you go back to The

Peter LewisEx

Jack Gougheggs. If you go back to whenever Donald Trump talked about cost of living under Joe Biden, he talked about eggs. And the reason the egg prices went up and they tripled was because of this bird flu. It wasn't be it wasn't, you know, because of wars overseas. That was his reason. It was something out of control of the

Peter LewisSo that is a Chinese style.

Jack Goughgovernment. Pardon?

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, right. So so so so just to confirm, like my my dog's okay, right? Like I like people with dogs or cats, whatever don't need to stress about bird flu.

Jack Goughso certainly pets can get it and pets have died and cats seem to be more susceptible than dogs and and so it's a reason people need to be keeping their cats contained and dogs on leads and not going in interacting with birds if you see them dead on the beaches. But this this variety then spread into the southern hemisphere. We'd never had these H7 varieties in the Southern Hemisphere before, spread down the entire South American continent within six months. Within the first

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Jack Goughfour months, six hundred thousand dead birds, you know. in Cape Valdez in South America, you had areas where the elephant seals the year before one to two percent death rate of the pups. The year it turns up ninety five percent death rate

Peter LewisWhoa.

Jack Goughof the pups. Like massive tens of thousands of dead seals. And you can see online the videos of these animals that are, you know, struggling to breathe, struggling to swim, moving around in circles, 'cause

Damian DamjanovskiJesus.

Jack Goughit's pretty

Peter LewisAnd is this all happening out in the boondocks or is this on beaches? So are we looking at this summer lots of dead animals on our beaches? Is that what you expect to see or?

Jack GoughSo we don't know is the real answer because we haven't had these clades turn up in Australia ever before. So our and as I said right at the start, our wildlife has been geographically isolated for millions of years. But one of the things we do know, for example, the death rate for white swans in the northern hemisphere from this this bird flu, I can't remember the exact number, but I think it was in the forty percent range. but black swans, Australian black swans that are in captivity in northern hemisphere, one hundred percent of them have died within a few days of catching it. And they didn't seem to produce any immune response. So we've started to see it. It's come up from An Antarctica now.

Peter LewisSo our black swans could fall victim to a black swan event.

Jack GoughThe Australian government have said that they are ic at extreme risk of basically being wiped out from this. So and I guess

Damian DamjanovskiNicholas would be proud of that one, wouldn't he?

Jack Goughin terms of the politics of it, Pete, like the thing I was saying to you is I think there's a bit of complacency among government and and opposition. Look, we've had, you know, good people from both sides who are paying attention to this and doing doing things on it. But the environment's been a really sleeper issue within politics, right? It's not a massive issue that's shifting huge amounts of votes in, you know, critical areas. But what I've been saying to politicians is remember the black summer bushfires. Look to what happened with the algal bloom in South Australia when that started to take off and realize when people start to see wildlife death at scale, then that opinion on environment issues can shift really quickly and shift at scale quickly. And so I was talking, for example, to the a very senior person within the Victorian opposition about this recently. and they were saying, look, like we're, you know, work with them on environment policies for if they get into government, but at the moment it's not part of what they're gonna talk about. But basically they were saying,

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, don't give a shit.

Jack Goughbut but they were saying, but if bird flu starts to take off, we need policies

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, then it's a different thing.

Jack Goughin reserve. ready to go 'cause they are starting to think this is something that

Peter LewisBut what are the policies apart from bring out your dead?

Jack GoughReally, a lot of it's about invasive species management. It's about cats and fox management and dealing with deer and pigs that, you know, get into wetlands. It's about things that build up the resilience of wildlife populations because that's this is going to be with us really for the next five plus years of decline. and so the things that governments can do to build up the health of wildlife populations, making sure wetlands are well watered, making sure you're dealing with invasive species that are causing declines, making sure that you're got habitat connectivity, that you're not destroying habitat, all of these things are going to be key to whether or not species just, you know, see modest declines or and and then are able to recover from that, or get pushed into new categories of threat and, you know, potentially go extinct.

Damian DamjanovskiThis is I mean, look what you're saying is absolutely terrifying, I I won't lie. I'm not a environment nerd. Like I enjoy the environment f as a screensaver, but beyond that I'm not I'm not a man for the outdoors, right? It's

Peter LewisHave you ever walked in the bush?

Damian DamjanovskiI've I was forced to once it just turned that a I lost my way when I was at a wedding at a marquee and I ended up in the bush. Anyway, so I I I I have huge respect for the environment and all that kind of thing. I I really do. So I mean, generally politically obviously, the wealthier people are feeling, the more they care about issues that are outside of their immediate sphere, right? So if you imagine here's here's Damien and then around him is the people he loves and cares about, around here marries friends and extended family, around that is the community, around that is his like city, state, whatever. Like the

Peter LewisBirds are a long way out.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, so jokingly, s someone from the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet, I'm not gonna say who, but when I was in the PMO years later they remembered me because at one point I went in there and said I I need to talk to you about the inverse pyramid of BEEP given. And basically the further it gets from you, the number of fucks you give about that issue decreases. But the wealthier you feel, that sphere increases. Like the number of fucks you have to give increases, so therefore it trickles down. So when I'm not worried about my the value of my house or how much petrol's gonna cost or this, that and the other. I care about climate change and the environment more and healthcare and education. As soon as I start to feel poorer, my world contracts. It's like a natural you know vasoconstricting effect where it's like, hang on a minute, none of these issues affect me directly, someone else has got to take care of them. I gotta look after number one, which is me, which is why we end up with the Paul Inhansons of the world. So that aside, I care about the environment, but I much more care about the weather. I'm a weather nerd. And I've been watching the strength of this El Nino build and the southern oscillation this year, and I'm like, there is I feel like everything points to a large weather event this coming summer. Now that could mean an especially dry summer. It could just mean that you know, South America gets completely drenched in rain. My big two things for it is coffee and chocolate prices are gonna go through the roof because the only coffee and chocolate cocoa growing regions in the world. are all about to simultaneously be hit with a massive

Peter LewisSo you'll give a fuck factor's just gone up hugely if coffee and chocolate go up. Yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiWell look, thankfully I can switch to T quite quickly so it doesn't even that doesn't really bother me that much. But

Peter LewisBut on that give a fuck thing, I think it's a good analysis, Dame, but like for Jack, like apart from caring that all these beautiful birds are gonna be lying dead on the beach, like are there economic impacts that we should be giving a fuck about as well, which feels a very human centric way of yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiWell that's the question here is like, does this mean my egg prices, chicken prices are gonna go up that if it gets into the the w into beef stock that

Peter Lewis'Cause that would be bad for Libra at the moment.

Damian Damjanovskimeat prices are gonna go up? 'Cause i it's also a lot of hurdles and a lot of dots to connect to say to someone, Hey, there's actually nothing, you know, the government can do about this because the reason your meat prices are high aren't because, you know, woolies are being arseholes though they are being arseholes, it's because this Bird flew over from you know s Southeast Asia into northern Queensland, which then got eaten by a fox which then went into a chicken but it turned back the birds.

Peter LewisCan't we turn back the birds? Can't we turn them back? Like you guys knew how to do that. Turn

Jack GoughIt it no no no, it it it came it came

Peter Lewisback the birds. I reckon the we decide which birds fly into this

Jack Goughfrom Antarctica. It c it came up from Antarctica and it's

Peter Lewiscountry in the conditions under which they come.

Damian DamjanovskiJust bob Catter with a rifle at the at the coastline and we're done.

Peter Lewiscould get drones. Anyway, sorry, Jack. Why should we give a fuck?

Jack GoughIt look no no I I think look, I mean I think there's lots of good reasons to give a fuck, but I I think my my analysis is pretty similar to yours, Damien, on on on the sort of broader where where society's at on these sorts of things. I guess what I'm predicting and expecting is that mass wildlife deaths on urban beaches and in places that people are starting see it actually brings these things

Peter LewisSo you can't surf.

Jack Goughinto people's sphere in a way that and and that we do have good examples of that occurring. And also that while the cost of living crisis side of things is definitely impacting on lots of people and you know driving a lot of that political conversation, that there are not managing Australia's environment well goes to the credibility of government as a as an institution. people do start to see when they see degradation, when they see deer getting onto their roads. I mean, in fact, you were talking at the start about potholes in Victoria. the number of deer that are now causing crashes on the road in Victoria is going up significantly as well. And that we that I I guess what I I and what I was saying to Peter, Pete, when we we caught up was I do think that one of the things that bird flu could do is bring the environment closer to home for people because they start to see that. And while, you know, some people might not be too worried, I there will be critical mass in some people.

Peter LewisI do think if there are dead birds on beaches over summer, like that will have

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter Lewisa real impact. Particularly if it then says you can't let your dog off a leash because they'll catch it. Like that will be a very human impact. It's not a material impact, but it is a very much a cultural impact. Like Australians

Damian DamjanovskiIt's it's a s it's a strong visual. I mean we saw that in in South Australia, right? With the with the fish. Yeah.

Peter LewisLook what happens when a shark takes one person. you know, we close beaches. If if there's full of dead birds, are are people gonna swim around that shit? I don't know. Like are the beaches gonna be closed over summer, do you reckon, Jack? Like what's the best case, worst case scenario here?

Jack GoughLook, it'll have impacts on tourism potentially. I mean, I like they've all it you know, this is what we've seen with fire ants, say up in Queensland. When football games started getting shut down because fire ants are on the ovals, you know, that suddenly makes it much more of a serious issue. I mean, you go to Houston in Texas, they have I think six or eight people whose full time job is just clearing fire ants from ovals to make sure kids can play sport on the weekend, right? Because fire ants kill people.

Peter LewisJesus Christ.

Jack GoughAnd so as soon as that started to happen, we started to get real critical mass. you know, I guess at the last federal election, we felt not many of our issues were shifting politics, except for fire ants up in Queensland in the handful of seats, which were Peter Dutton's seat and around that area. And Peter Dutton was meant to announce a fire ant policy, but he didn't because of the floods and then never got back to it.

Peter LewisWas Dutton pro or anti Fire Ant?

Jack GoughPardon?

Peter LewisDutton pro or anti fire ant, he would have been pro fire ant.

Damian DamjanovskiIs antagnostic.

Jack GoughNo one was anti it, but it's one of those ones that goes to government credit

Damian DamjanovskiAntnognostic.

Jack Goughcredibility.

Peter LewisHe'd love a far end.

Jack Goughand so I guess there's a I like I I I I mean, there's definitely potential for impacts on egg prices and and chicken prices if it gets into the chicken system. But I do see a s a credible scenario where if b bird flu starts to ramp up in the way that you

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Jack Goughknow the experience overseas suggests that it will. that it becomes a factor, not a ma not a massive not the biggest factor, but a factor of expectation from people in the Victorian election. if that happens over the next bit and potentially in the New South Wales election next year. It starts to become something that a cohort of people ask questions about.

Damian DamjanovskiWell

Jack GoughAnd particularly if you go to Victoria in a potential change election, where it becomes quite emblematic of a failure of government, even if that's not fair.

Damian DamjanovskiSo I I totally agree with you on all this, Jack. Now I I while I think the bird dead birds on beaches will be a potential issue, I reckon Pete, that's one of the ones where people will just say, Hey, local council, you need to be cleaning this up more frequently. I think once egg and chicken prices go up, that's when people get a bit weird on it. Jack, this this is not I'm not putting this to you as a way to justify anything, by the way. I'm genuinely asking 'cause I know that a lot of my more conservative than me friends would would couch things this way, so it's a genuine question. like you said about the dingos kind of being, you know, brought in five thousand years ago and they they killed out the Tazzy devil and they killed out the Thalcene and blah blah blah. the argument that a lot of people would make is that that kind of is nature, right? Is nature is species move around. Yes Sometimes they're brought over by humans, sometimes they ride on the back of a bird, sometimes they're stuck to a whale and they move around the planet and that's part of the great circle. But it's it's the part

Peter LewisThe Darwinian Conservatives. Yeah.

Damian Damjanovskiof the great circle of life. And you go, I completely understand that some small, you know, barnyard critter might disappear as a result of this. I'm just trying to get back to the Why why should we care? Isn't that part of the natural order of things and isn't that okay? Like, can't we just leave the Brumbies? They're there now. Like wh why why should like why?

Jack GoughYeah, look, I think it's legitimate. The what's happening is we are massively speeding up the process of new introductions, and the consequence of that is entire ecosystems being transformed. so ecosystems don't work on a time frame of within the last two hundred years now we have, you know, tens of thousands of new plant species. I mean, I think in the you know, the one in every nine Plant species now growing in the wild in Australia is exotic, where you've got, you know, we now have the world's largest populations of horses, sambar deer, water buffalo, camels, goats, bantang, foxes, all in Australia. These are not native species. And that has consequences. I mean, if you look at the largest Australian native animal, right, is a male red kangaroo in the 90 kilo range.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah. That's the that's the big one, the muscle one. Yeah.

Jack Goughthe next largest Australian a animal, the big muscly one, you know, 95 kilos around. the next biggest is a female red kangaroo, which is under 50 kilos. and then you look at what we brought in is actually these hundred to thousand kilogram animals with hard hooves in environments where the plant life has not evolved with that level of grazing pressure, that level of damage, but also where you get these You know, so for example, the horses in Kosyosko, that's the headwaters of our major river systems. You know, the Murray and the Murambidji. Huge amount of the flow into the Murray Darling Basin comes from that area. a lot of that is snow melt, which then gets held by peat bog systems.

Peter LewisYeah. I've been up there. Aunt Shawood took me up there who wrote the great book on the Brumby Wars and it is they've totally fucked it. I should take like if you went into the outdoors, go up there and it would would absolutely break you out. You must get a good

Jack GoughYeah. And we don't have like you know, we don't have tigers and and things to move them on either. So you don't get these natural relationships between the the animals and the plants that

Peter Lewisthe tigers and the water

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Peter Lewisbeast. Hey, Jack, you must get a good hearing with One Nation though. Like 'cause this feels like real nationalism, like it's saying like like you know i Australian fauna, not not the introduced types. Like it d it

Jack GoughYeah. No, look, I mean, we we no

Damian DamjanovskiThere's no such thing as a good Brumby.

Jack Goughno, we definitely find I mean, I think most people, even if like like you, Damien, they're not feeling particularly connected, feel a sense that Australians have a responsibility of custodianship to this continent. You know, we've got a continent that ha is pretty unique, pretty interesting, and that we don't want to have it you know, eroding away, trashed and trampled. We don't want to have the native wildlife going extinct on our watch. And we recognize, particularly in regional communities, and you know, you you were there at the Bush Summit, you know, there's a huge amount of understanding that that these landscapes need to be looked after, protected, and that invasive species are one of the biggest factors driving decline. and so I certainly Pete like I do frame this as a As a nationalist issue. This is something

Peter LewisNationalists.

Jack Goughthat matters to the identity of us as Australians, you know. Do we care about the plants, the animals, the soils, the rivers that make up the continent? I mean, behind me I've got that, you know, picture of all the you know native animals looking in, you know, this is a government poster from the 1970s, you know, to an Australia taken over by the invasive species. You know, what's happening often with invasive species? We call it the the McDonaldization of landscapes. So everywhere

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Jack Gougharound the world is increasingly looking the same.

Peter LewisFlattening of fauna. That's really interesting because it's in it. Can I ask one more thing? The ultimate invasion

Damian DamjanovskiContext flattening.

Peter Lewisthe ultimate invasive species has to be the human. and I don't know, Dharma, I just thought that was a a neat segue into immigration. We're kind of fighting the clock

Damian DamjanovskiIt was very well done.

Peter Lewisnow. But there is an element of this immigration debate if you take the technocracy out of it and you take The race out of it, it is actually people saying we've got too many of this invasive species called humans coming in at the moment. Like is that a is

Damian DamjanovskiCan

Peter Lewisthat a fair frame?

Damian Damjanovskican I add one more thing to that before you you give us your thoughts, Jack? Is as a, you know, I'm not I wasn't born in Australia, I'm a you know, off the boat immigrant as they say.

Peter LewisYou are genuine invasive species.

Damian DamjanovskiI'm a genuine invasive species, or species if you prefer. I honestly like I love Australia, but I've got to admit I have never felt any connection to the concepts of bushwalking, camping. Like I love my family, but none of us were ever you know, we would never like just pop down to the local caravan park or holiday park and go for a weekend together. Like and I know all my immigrant friends who have shared a similar story as me where they came quite young to Australia. None of us have that connection to land.

Peter LewisSo you've just done the highway from Brisbane to Melbourne and all you've done is stop at the servos. You haven't gone off and looked at country or anything?

Damian Damjanovskino, th there were some pubs along the way that we looked at and I mean I love

Peter LewisA ribbon?

Damian DamjanovskiI love looking at it from the car, but we were taught a very healthy respect for just how dangerous Australia is, and you should never go in the ocean and you should never go into the bush because you'll die. Because again, in Europe you walk around and the only thing that can kill you is a giant bear. Do you know what I mean? Like you you walk around European forests and you could get lost in there for days,

Jack GoughIncreasingly wolves too.

Damian Damjanovskiy and it's like either you'll hear the wolf Or and usually if you've got a big dog, like you could probably take on the wolf, or there's a bear and usually and it's not an American style bear, it's a European style bear where it's like, all right, you've got to either make yourself really big and scare the shit out of it, fire a gun, or you you'll get a p bore it to death

Peter LewisOr get a podcast.

Damian Damjanovskiwith your podcast. But do you know what I mean? So I d I wonder if the increase in immigrant Australian immigrant culture that hasn't necessarily been included and this is not all immigrants, there's plenty

Peter Lewisfair question, yeah.

Damian Damjanovskiof immigrants who love the bush and lean into this. But I guarantee you right now if you pop to a caravan park or a campground, you know, somewhere in in country New South Wales or Victoria, ninety percent of the people there, like it is not going to be representative of Australia in general.

Jack GoughI mean, I I think I got a couple of responses to to to that. there is a disconnect that Australians have with nature and I don't think that's, you know, whether you're an immigrant or, you know, born in Australia, that is actually a broader issue and a reflection partly of the urbanisation of a society, also just a reflection of changing you know, entertainment options. for people and you know distraction options that that's a huge issue and it's something that I think is you know makes us poorer as a community and so that would be you know it's important for us to address. I think the other thing for me is important issues don't have to connect to every single person for them to be important. you know, obviously often, you know, in politics people are looking for the things that impact on swing voters and I it would make it makes sense to me that a lot of where some s swing areas are, there is a level of disconnect. But huge numbers of tree changes have gone on tree changes have gone on post-COVID of people who really do care about these things. And you know, I I think one of the shifts with the teals, for example, it gets framed around climate change. But we talk to a lot of people for whom it's actually about Australian nature. And I know a lot of senior people within the New South Wales Liberals in particular, who feel like not enough is being done in that space to talk to a constituency for which it does really matter, and that some of those teal seats in particular, you know, maybe reflecting what you were saying at the start around people's options and care. So I do think that it's there there's a there's you know, there's a real element here of for I I guess I don't think that any political party, and I include the Greens in this, is taking nature seriously. put climate change separately. But the sort of investment at scale in nature, building the narrative for Australians around that, getting people out there and engaged, making sure that we're doing the workforce planning and the and that side of things, telling a story about what Australia can be. I don't think any party's doing that. And I do think that there is an opportunity for a party that does do that, to speak to quite a large constituent in Australia and to, you know, fire the imagination of people like you, Damien, to go maybe I need to look at Australia in a different way and think about how I, you know, when I'm driving from Brisbane down to to Melbourne, decide to get out onto, you know, the area at the you know, around Armadale out into some of those national parks and see what's going on there and and connect to the country that I'm part of. I I'm an immigrant too. Like I wasn't born in Australia. We came here, you know, a as well, but I do think we I think there's a real opportunity. And I, you know, I must say I talked to someone like Barnaby Joyce, I talked to someone like Matt Keene, I talked to someone like Murray Watt, you know, three different parties, and there are and I know there are people within those parties who are saying, actually, why don't we capture some of this narrative? And the thing holding it back is that is actually that capturing that narrative requires investment at scale. And it requires investment that is disproportionate to the current budgets within those departments, not disproportionate overall.

Peter Lewis'Cause you're investing in something that is economically nothing as well, which is the problem. Like, you know, it's not a data

Damian DamjanovskiWell if if if

Peter Lewiscentre you're investing in, it's it's space. but just give me indulge me a bit and your lens, Jack, of the immigration debate that's going on at the moment through humans as an invasive species. See if we can land that plane. Then I'll ask you, Damien, as well.

Jack GoughConsequence of massive increase in populations, massive increase in consumption, and massive increase in geographic spread has seen enormous declines in nature. I mean, almost all the mammal biomass now is humans and their livestock. So yeah, humans have been a huge problem for nature, but We can have societies that live alongside nature and that allow it to you know be vibrant and and it does incl involve planning, it does involve investment, it does involve telling stories about this that connect the populace. The I I I just I guess I don't see that, I don't see it as a factor in terms of like the scale of our immigration. When people coming in, most of them are going into cities where, you know, highly concentrated. It's not a factor really for like further decline of nature in Australia. You know, we're not we're not talking about numbers that are equivalent to what you see in parts of Asia, for example, where you know or or Europe, where you really are talking about every square meter starting to get absorbed by the scale of human habitation. In Australia, we're still highly urbanized, highly concentrated. And we could absorb absorb a lot more people and continue to be that way. So I guess I don't see the scale of our immigration program where it's at at the moment as being a factor on further impacts of human on nature, apart from increased consumption at a global level, putting increased pressure on these things. But yeah, I I I'm I

Damian DamjanovskiSo so you don't think there's like a number like there's a I'm not not asking you to put a number on it, but like reducing the number of people overall in Australia doesn't really have a make a big difference or?

Jack GoughI think the narrative we tell about ourselves as Australians is shallow. And I think that makes it really hard for us to make sure that s that that you know communities can feel integrated and connected to something bigger and that drives disconnection. I also think that, you know, there are clearly baked-in problems associated with the way that you know media consumption and social media is causing, you know, bub bubbles of people's experience of the world and that causes increased friction. I don't see that in an environment lens. I probably I see that in a social lens, but I do think the Australian environment is one of the solutions to that. Like I wrote an op-ed recently in the Daily Telly saying, you know, in a in an age of of of disconnect and division, nature is something that can bring us together. There's an opportunity, I think, for parties, it doesn't matter where you're sitting on that issue, to drive a narrative around who we are as Australians that that is inclusive that brings people in. And I think that will be part of addressing some of the tensions in society. I don't think it's all the answer. I mean there's clearly, you know I mean I was just chatting you know on the weekend sorry last week to someone who's a deputy principal at a school out in Southwest Sydney who have gone from he was saying in the last year a year ago they were using about 30 loaves of bread a day to feed the kids in the morning. Now they're using over a hundred loaves of bread a day to feed the kids in the morning out in South West Sydney at this school. Like clearly these sorts of tensions don't get resolved by narratives, but broader as a society, there's an opportunity to tell a better story of who we are as Australians. And part of that needs to be making sure people like you, Damien, when you come, feel like you can understand what it means, you know, like that to connect to the the continent that we are all custodians of.

Peter LewisWell, before we go to Kiss of Death, do you have any reflections on the immigration over the last week or should we put a pin in that for another day?

Damian Damjanovskilook, i it it's an issue we're gonna we are gonna keep talking about for I reckon quite some time and obviously I don't see it as directly through the environmental and nature lens as Jack does. I will say that it's an issue at the moment because we're desperately trying to solve the housing issue, and the housing issue is something that's not gonna be solved by immigration. W we are looking for any solution that is not the only solution. that we need to have for housing, which is houses need to be cheaper and we have collectively as a country put too much of our wealth in housing, which means people have to lose out for it to stop being an issue. It it's just no but we don't want to we don't want to take the medicine. So we're looking for any kind of cheat to get us to that solution. but at some point we will have to take the medicine or the medicine will be forced on us by economics. So that aside Sorry, go on.

Peter LewisI thought the week was interesting, just that Labour is no longer fighting the narrative that immigration's too high. they've come up with a very competent technocratic response. One nation has a populist tear-it-down approach, and at the moment the Libs just have, and it may be the one that works, linking housing specifically to immigration. So you've basically got the wonks, you've got a slogan, and you've got the tear it down. I don't know where the Greens are on it. To be honest, I think I actually think the Greens have made bit of a mistake in saying that it's dog whisting. I think it's beyond dog whisting. I think the good the positive frame of where we've ended, if if we can take race out of the discussion on immigration, then we can actually have a discussion on immigration. So let's just see how

Damian DamjanovskiI I I totally agree and and and I'd also argue that and I mean I I'd there's so much stuff I disagree with him on, but Alan Kohler has actually hit the nail on the head with this one, which is the the immigration debate and whether or not we have this many or that many people is a distraction from the fact that we need to have a better understanding of the kind of people we want, as in the skills we want in Australia to build the next generation of Australia. The number doesn't matter if the majority of those number are hairdressers, with no offense to hairdressers. We we all need hairdressers. But when well, I don't, but it's soon I will. It's I'll

Peter LewisYou don't. Cause you got a mat. You got a w you got a wig. Yeah.

Damian Damjanovskigo the the the amount of people who are on, for example, the construction and trades, which are in like the third or fourth category of requirement rather than the first

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskicategory, is way too low. And I come back to These are things that are a combination of a politician and a whole bunch of bureaucrats deciding who lives in what category. The discussion we need to have over immigration has to be more nuanced where we go, we this isn't about race, this isn't about number. This is about we need to be really careful about how many people of what kind of skill we bring into the country, because our infrastructure, not just housing, our infrastructure is at breaking point. And we can't have a whole bunch of Older people in their fifties who are hairdressers and they happen to be extended family coming here knowing that they're gonna add to the healthcare burden

Peter LewisBeleza, yeah.

Damian Damjanovskiand this, that and the other when we need desperately need people who are builders. We desperately need builders. The builder

Peter LewisLet's put it let's put a pin in this because I reckon there's so many places we can take it. Anyway, kiss of death. I've warned

Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.

Peter LewisJack, you kick off, Darma. What's your kiss of death for the week?

Damian DamjanovskiSo I don't know if you heard, but apparently there's rumors that our mate Xi Jinping over in China had some kind of incident in India where he may have either collapsed or had something weird happen and the rumors are flying as to whether or not he maybe had a stroke. So he left the BRICS meeting early, gets flown

Peter LewisWow.

Damian Damjanovskiback to China. If you read through some of the the reports coming out of like, you know, WeChat and Baidu and all that kind of thing is he The most prevalent rumour is that he had a a small stroke and instead of being having it dealt with in India, tried to fly back to China to be seen over there and

Peter LewisWow.

Damian Damjanovskithey may have not caught it in time. So my kiss of death

Peter LewisWeekend at Bernie's.

Damian Damjanovskiis that maybe he might either step down or step back a bit from his duties if these rumours are true, which I know is bombshell

Peter LewisWow.

Damian Damjanovskioutrageous, but just watch this space. What about

Peter LewisWow.

Damian Damjanovskiyou, Peter?

Peter LewisI was going to go on the same thing, but it's mutually exclusive because he's meant to be meeting with Trump at the end of next week. and I actually think they are going to come up with some form of non proliferation on the edges of AI, particularly around the existential threats that have been raising to the surface. But if it is only an avatar of G, then maybe I don't think we can both be right next week. So

Damian DamjanovskiI think that meeting might not go ahead.

Peter Lewismaybe not. Hey Jack, we warned you, what's your kiss of death of the week?

Jack Goughlook, mine's less global. I guess I was you know, I I do think that we like we're we're now halfway through September, we're starting to see bird flu spreading down the Victorian coast and getting into some of the more populated areas and I do think we

Peter LewisWe had a report at Dolphin Point last week. Don't let your dogs off the leash, there's dead birds.

Jack GoughYeah. I I think we could start to see a mass mortality event down in Victoria in in in the next week or so, which will significantly change the public conversation again in in that Melbourne port area.

Peter LewisWow. Hey, thanks. Do you want one more thing or are you

Jack GoughJust 'cause of the way that it's been spreading.

Peter Lewisgonna do the li like Here you go.

Damian DamjanovskiI was just gonna ask one last question, sorry, Jack. When you're you you've talked a lot about obviously like the brumbies and the birds and wild pigs and all that and like needing to kind of control

Peter LewisCuts.

Damian Damjanovskiand this that when you're saying that you do mean like like they need to be

Jack GoughAbsolutely. I mean you you I mean, not like it needs to be done professionally, safely, it needs to be done humanely, it needs to be done properly. I mean, I've been very critical, for example, of the New South Wales government spend thirteen million dollars on pig control, which I say is basically just to you know, sh shoot a bunch of pigs and put a press release out at the end of the year. it doesn't do anything for the actual population growth dynamics. but doing that effectively, in a way that is actually about reducing those numbers or stopping them spreading into new areas, it has to be done lethal. Absolutely.

Damian DamjanovskiSo we can't just do one big

Peter LewisThis this is

Damian Damjanovskipurge event.

Peter Lewiswhy Damien, this is why I love these guys 'cause they actually put their convictions to practice in the most difficult way. Like getting social license to shoot horses or to kill

Jack GoughSo yeah.

Peter Lewiscats is high degree of difficulty and you get a natural emotional pushback. But for the good of the nation, like, you know, more power to you, Jack. So Yeah, yeah. Thanks.

Damian DamjanovskiMm. It's a super fascinating topic. Super fascinating.

Peter LewisThanks for being part of it. Like

Jack GoughNe the next one we're gonna be be out there on is we're gonna be taking on the bees. So look look for that.

Peter Lewisare we pro B or anti B? We're pro B.

Damian DamjanovskiDo we w we want the Aussie base?

Jack Goughso f well honey bees are feral in and cause an enormous amount of environmental damage.

Peter LewisI reckon get Pauline to be pushing for Aussie Bs, I reckon that would that would be a campaign. Hey, thanks

Jack GoughYeah, but

Peter Lewisfor being part of it. Thanks everyone for listening. Like, share all that stuff. But also put in your diary the last Wednesday in November, which I think is the twenty-fifth. I think we've got a hold on the press club. We're going to do a live show and get everyone together, including all our guests, including you, Jack, off to be part of a Christmas show. So thanks for being part of it today.

Damian DamjanovskiVery exciting.

Peter Lewisand Love your birds before they're gone. Thanks everyone.

Jack GoughThank you guys.