Episode 25
Agents 'hack' medicare, Acemoglu on Liberalism, duty of care, and illegal aliens
Show notes
An OpenAI agent wandered into the Medicare and Services Australia backend. OpenAI told Canberra three months later in an automated email, and the government held the story until Albo was at the UN selling the digital duty of care. We cover what agents actually do, whether a missing fence counts as a break-in, Klaus, the pause letters, and the race with China. Then the duty of care itself.
After that, Acemoglu's What Happened to Liberal Democracy?, the gap between graduates and everyone else, and whether Australia's real divide is owners versus renters. We get into the Voice, Sweden, and whether immigration is too high
Save the date: we're live at the National Press Club in Canberra on 25 November.
Full transcript
Read itHide it
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.
Damian DamjanovskiWelcome to What's Your Poison, the show where people who barely agree on anything agree that it is better to do so over a drink. My name is Damed Domyanovsky, I'm a director at General Strategic, and I am joined this week, as I am every week, by my evil twin, Mr Peter Lewis of Essential Media. Peter, how are you? How was your week and what's your poison?
Peter LewisI'm very well. Thanks, mate. I've had a good week, night overnight in Melbourne, for per capita's annual oration, John Cain oration that Gareth Evans gave on decency and public life, which was it we it was good. He he he had a bit, Gareth. He still does. He he has a sense of both that sense of decency, but then portraying that into the way a nation conducts its international affairs. also.
Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.
Peter Lewiswhat are you laughing about?
Damian DamjanovskiNo, I was I was wondering. I was trying to remember Gareth Evans's performances when he was in Parliament. I'm sure he was I'm sure he was very decent, but
Peter LewisHe was quite cerebral. He he ended up being known as Gareth Gareth Evans because there was this point in which they were making a bid for him to succeed Boutros Boutros Garley at the UN general secretary. And I put it to him
Damian Damjanovskithat's right.
Peter Lewisat the dinner 'cause I I had a chat to him and he totally denied that he actually ever went for it. So he that's where he's probably different to Kevin Rudd, but yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiIt's just ye I I don't think anyone would put the words decency and politician together. Like I don't think generally that's
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskinot where you'd draw the dotted line.
Peter LewisYeah, no, and it was interesting because his whole thesis is but there is an economic and broader strategic benefit in being a good international citizen and a good neighbor and not just having a a a a self interest at the core of your foreign policy, which is kind of where the world is at the moment and everyone's being dragged into into that even you know altruistic self-interest is as good as you get so it was a different time obviously but i am drinking a kilkenny red only because it was down in the fridge and i've been
Damian DamjanovskiIs that a stout?
Peter Lewisno it's a red so i i don't actually know what a red is it's it's like a darker beer but it's there's no stout like tendencies to it at all but it's brewed the Irish way whatever that was
Damian DamjanovskiIt look it looks hefty. It does look hefty.
Peter LewisYeah, it's putting a bit of hair on my chest. anyway, what about you? you had a big road trip again and you're
Damian DamjanovskiYes.
Peter Lewisback home after being eight hours on the road today, so the usual caveats will apply. And what are we doing? What's our poison?
Damian DamjanovskiNo, it's very good to be back home. No, I I had the I had the week in Melbourne as well, for for family obviously. So got to enjoy a little bit of downtime in Melbourne where I think our last episode I was tuned in live from Melbourne. but literally every person I spoke to basically spoke about the same two or three things, which was you know, how terribly the state's going, how many potholes there are and how bad the crime is. Like I've I've never seen such a a universal response from the unwashed unwashed masses on what are their issues they're having right now. So I th I I just I go every day. Every day.
Peter LewisHow many unwashed masses did you talk to down there? You go looking for people that look like they haven't had a shower recently, and that's so you can talk to the unwashed masses.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, yeah, yeah. Espe especially in South Yarra and and Windsor, which is where I spent a lot of the my time while I'm there. but given that I was in Melbourne, I thought the Badlands I thought I'd go for a Melbourne whiskey
Peter LewisThe Badlands of South Yara.
Damian Damjanovskiand one of my actual favourites, which is the Starwood Nova. If if you're at all a whiskey drinker, I I recommend to any of our listeners, and you just like a you'd like an Australian whiskey that's not like a crazy expensive Tasmanian whiskey where you know, it's waters from some subterranean volcanic spring, but you just want a really nice whiskey that is really smooth drinking. The Starwood Nova, for I it's ninety dollars or ninety five dollars, is a remarkably good value drop and I cannot recommend it.
Peter LewisThere's one for the great unwashed, only ninety five dollars a bottle. That's good.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. but other than that, it's been a good week. I got some really good food as you tend to in in Melbourne. I I found a a new favourite bar there called the Whiskey Den in the city where I was treated to quite a variety of whiskies. and I actu
Peter LewisWhat did they serve there?
Damian Damjanovskiwell, they I literally asked the bartenders to walk me through their favourite whiskies. and and I spent about two hours just drinking their favourite whiskies
Peter LewisMm.
Damian Damjanovskiand they knew what they were talking about. So so hat tip to the whiskey den on Russell Street. but s other than that, I've actually been watching politics from a distance this week being kind of in family zone and it's interesting what bubbles up to the surface when you're not drinking from the news fire hose and the things that seem to have bubbled up when again, you know, I tend to be a chatty bloke, so if I'm going to a pub I'll talk to three or four randoms and just kind of ask as a you know, outsider what what's on their mind, this, that and the other. A this this whole like idea that AI is about to kill us all seems to be really prominent. Like that has really broken through to the zeitgeist that AI is gonna kill us any moment now and and we'll chat later about what that might mean given the events of the past couple of days. and also no one's ever heard of d digital duty of care or has any understanding of what the hell that means.
Peter LewisYeah, I think that's fair. and the convergence of those two this week, particularly with Albo going first to Silicon Valley and then to New York, and then to being the center of international news today, the first government website that seems to have been hacked by one of these rogue agents, which sounds like something out of the sorts
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisof movies that the dudes that designed the rogue agents have been bought up on. yeah, it's been quite a week for the PM as well. You know, last Sunday he was sort of cosplaying Silicon Valley startup with a live interview on insiders, I think, after meeting Tim Cook in Apple's HQ.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, I think he did it f f from Apple Park, which is quite a quite a bold choice. Yeah, of course.
Peter LewisBut they were wearing the same clothes. Did you notice that? It was the same jacket. It was like they were brothers. anyway, one of them's
Damian DamjanovskiHa ha.
Peter Lewisgot a lot more disposable income than the other. and then over to
Damian DamjanovskiI reckon. So I I I guess
Peter LewisNew York.
Damian DamjanovskiI I'm curious what your thoughts on this one. Like obviously he went to Silicon Valley to meet with the you know, the the hyperscalers and Apple and all these kinds of guy all these, you know all these big players. This item that's come up in the news over the past twenty four hours, which for for those who haven't heard about it yet, basically, OpenAI told the Australian government, so OpenAI is the makers of Chat GPT, one of the the kind of three or four big what they call the frontier AI models, they basically told the government, Hey, by the way, one of our agents accidentally went into a fenced area or accident went into a fenced area of the Medicare platform and the back end of Service Australia. and here's what it did. So it wasn't the government who came out and said, shit, we've noticed a hack. and this was announced three months after it happened to the government and then the government only just told us today while they're at the UN. So two things that are interesting to me. One, the government actually didn't seem to have pick hadn't picked up on this on its own merit.
Peter LewisApparently they received it via an automated email from OpenAI about a week ago. Clearly written by by your favorite bot.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, exactly. It's like, hey, hi, by the way, we accidentally walked into an area that we didn't know we were unauthorized to be in. Yeah, yeah. And then secondly, it's interesting that Albo and Co. decided not to bring this up when they knew about it, i.e. during a sitting week, but
Peter LewisMm.
Damian Damjanovskito use it as political ammunition while they're at the United Nations
Peter LewisMm.
Damian DamjanovskiGeneral Assembly. So I I don't quite know how I feel about that. To me, if it was a very genuine security concern and risk, it's something that would have been brought up During a parliamentary sitting week and they would have made a deal about it. The fact that
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskithey've held on to it for the UNGA, which is where they're going, they're trying to sell their agenda of digital duty of care and slowing down AI development, feels like they're very intentionally using this as a little proof point of, look, the agent hacked into our Medicare system. And then the second order of that is: did it really hack in or had it not been very well suited? Th there's a difference between me breaking into your house and you not really having a fence out the front, me wandering into your yard and you going, Hey, get off that, that's my yard. Do you mean there there are nuances here that are worth exploring as well.
Peter LewisOkay, so I reckon let's start with the politics and then maybe go to the tech, because I've been following it reasonably closely with the Burning Platforms podcast that I do the rest of the week. so helicopter up. So the government's position on AI, as we've discussed, is I I guess best described as a little bit pregnant. So they're really all into the opportunities, but they also want to have really tight regulations. A Because that's the right thing to do if you're going to be all in on AI. And their their idea of all in is to be one of the centers of the American company's expansions, like at all. Lump it, particularly Anthropic is one of the key players there. But the other thing is that they they know both for social license and also for good governance, they need to put some guardrails in place. And to their credit, they've been moving on a whole bunch of areas, everything from privacy to this digital duty of care, which we can talk a little bit more about. to copyright, to requirements around automated decision making, to getting the security things in place. And there has been pushback from Silicon Valley. So the day before, so Albo heads over to Silicon Valley and, you know, they're now joined at the hit with the American government. and he's gone there to explain what the government's doing both with social media banned and digital duty of care. The Trump administration via the US, I think, embassy puts in a submission to the review on Digital Duty of Care saying this is assault on freedom. This is we we we
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewiswill not stand for this. And so maybe they were holding it back. I d I don't pretend to know. And then they end up in New York. So the the we've gone from Canberra We go to Silicon Valley, then we go to New York, where the General Assembly's meeting, including a meeting between Trump and G, that we spoke about last week, which could also have existential risk from AI on the agenda. And so all this is happening. And it seems like if he planned it.
Damian Damjanovskiand and a and Albo's about to receive a war award as well.
Peter LewisSo he's he's had this thing. The Australian way is to stand up to the big companies so we can debate whether what they're actually standing up or. just doing things that don't make life that hard for them like a social media band. But he is now in a position where he has got into the bigger story. And the biggest story over the last month has been the development, the the the fast development of what's called AI agents. Which we've got to be careful not to turn them into little people. They're really feedback loops where you give an assignment, the AI goes and does it and reports back. So it's basically a feedback loop. But there's been increasing evidence that these agents, when they're being tested in controlled environments, find a way of working together to build little networks that then will go off and
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewischeat
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisat the assignments they've been given. And this is people may have heard of Hugging Face, which is like a test. bed where they've been organizing. There's another German one as well. The other thing is that they report back so you can then go back and look at what they've been saying to each other. Now, they're not saying anything and they're not each other's, but the code is interacting the way it's been trained, using kind of generative AI and getting into all this slop talk which says, I'll sacrifice myself for the greatest good. We should all work together to do this. So it's very like We can talk about this a bit more in a sec, but it's very interesting. So this is a big, big story. Sh is AI moving too fast? Should there be a pause? There's been calls from the three CEOs that were met quite cynically, like so Altman, Amade from Anthropic
Damian DamjanovskiEmily.
Peter Lewisand and Mask all saying we need, well, Amade had said
Damian DamjanovskiSlow it down.
Peter Lewisa pacing. But the pause, fourteen hundred AI scientists within those companies have also caused called for a slowdown. So it does seem like this next iteration of AI, which is going off and doing little things on the web, might be something that they haven't thought through properly. And maybe there is merit in slowing it. I suspect you would not be a pauser, but I am interested. But I'm definitely, I think
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisit's moving too fast.
Damian DamjanovskiI'm I'm not a pauser, I think that's a that's a fair assessment of me and I'm gonna unpack that a little bit. So agentic AI or AI agents are if f for those who don't use a lot of AI and are listening in, so if you imagine Chat GPT or or Claude or God forbid, you know, Copilot or Gemini, you go in, there's a chat bot, you ask it a question, it responds, you ask
Peter LewisHmm.
Damian Damjanovskia question, it responds and me and so on and so forth ad nauseum. The the difference between that and an agentic AI is the gent the agentic AI essentially can quote unquote make decisions and I use that in a I'm very liberally using that word. If you give it a goal, it will continue to try things to achieve that goal until either it has exhausted every avenue or more often until it has exhausted your budget, your your money budget for spending tokens for achieving that goal. So if you set it a really broad goal It will just keep trying a thousand and one different things. If you set it a really tight parametered goal, it will come to a conclusion eventually. And the
Peter LewisSo you use agents a bit, don't you?
Damian DamjanovskiWell well Klaus, which we've talked about on this show before, is an agent, right? So Klaus is is actually an agent and an agent coordinator. So Klaus is a master agent, and then Klaus has a whole bunch of sub-agents underneath him. So he runs on a number of different models. He uses a little bit of anthropic, a little bit of open AI, a little bit of the Chinese models. but he essentially makes decisions without my intervention, without me saying this is the thing I want next.
Peter LewisFor example
Damian DamjanovskiSo for example, if I need him to do a piece of research on something, I don't have to not only do I not have to tell him where to go, he knows that the research has to be sourced to a certain standard or he might go if I say, get me the the last five jobs that every parliamentarian has done He won't just go to Wikipedia and go, look, I could find three of them, but twelve of them were missing. He will keep going and keep digging, going, All right, well I can't find it on Wikipedia, so let me go check the APH website. I can't find it there. So let me go and look at the individual websites. Yeah. Exactly. So so Exactly.
Peter LewisWhich is sort of what this OpenAI health one was about. They asked it to research Australian health stats and they and there must have been a team. I I really I really bristle
Damian DamjanovskiSo
Peter Lewisat you giving Klaus both a name and agenda, but that's kind of we can get there.
Damian DamjanovskiThat th I I like look, I anthropomorphise my car as well. So for me this is not a new phenomenon. I'm I'm I I I like the idea of anthropomorphizing technology because to me I feel like you you treat it better and you treat it with more care when you when you do so with
Peter LewisDo Yugoslavs have gendered language? Do you do you gender different things?
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, yeah, yeah. We j we we gender different things. So everything is either male or female.
Peter LewisSo what's a microphone? Anyway, I digress. Yeah, of course. look at it's phallic, yeah.
Damian Damjanovskii it'd be male. A microphone is male, yeah. Yeah. so the the hugging face hack and and the Medicare hack, so both of them something that people need to understand when when the media writes about these things broke out of their environment and you know, went and hacked into hugging faces, that and the other, i it's not wrong, but it's not necessarily right either. So with these agents, basically If you don't give it really strict parameters on what it can't do, then it will continue to try doing things because it is basically autistically devoted and compulsively devoted to achieving
Peter LewisTo the mission.
Damian Damjanovskithat goal. Now, if it's me doing that task with Klaus, I've got a budget. So you know, Klaus will run out of his tokens and go, all right, I've spent a hundred bucks trying to do this, I'm gonna stop. But OpenAI, who's doing it in their internal environment. don't have budgets set to these things, right? So it'll keep trying things. So with Hugging Face, for example, they hadn't explicitly told it not to break out of this specific environment. And if you don't necessarily give it really strict parameters about what not to do, and this is the real danger with these agentic AIs, is we have to change how we command it because we understand the idea of a social compact of, well you shouldn't break into a public website or you shouldn't cheat on the test. Or you shouldn't look at data that is clearly to us designed not to be publicly accessible. If you think of that machine as both, you know, and autistic in terms of it doesn't understand those social cues 'cause it's never been tra it's never been taught those cues. And simultaneously it's obsessive.
Peter LewisBut isn't the critique you've now made it not not just a guy but an ADH or is it an autistic guy?
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, but yeah.
Peter Lewisbut you g you're again giving it human qualities where it is really just a line of code. And I saw Microsoft CEO Mustafa Suleiman, who's been very critical at no, no, he's been critical at
Damian DamjanovskiWell Yeah.
Peter Lewisthe a at anthropic, particularly for coming up with a code of ethics to build into the AI because it's almost giving it Human qualities and the hot like the more that these agents are given the sense that they are acting like a person, it's actually creating the conditions for them to show more initiative and to self-organize and self-sacrifice. And one of the really interesting things is if you look at some of the transcripts on some of the sandboxes where they're sort of reporting back. It's like they're all talking like the worst AI swap to each other because that's what they've been trained, because that's the language we're training them in. So I just feel like there's something interesting there that it's it's
Damian Damjanovskiis absolutely.
Peter Lewisa particular course of progress we're choosing and it's gonna create if it i i the the closer it gets to being able to take initiative and show autonomy, the more impossible it is to set up proper security around it and then we're just gonna have a security and a s you know, a countersecurity cyber world and that's gonna be the main benefit this technology gives us.
Damian DamjanovskiI mean, yes, I mean the so Suleiman's essay was interesting a I mean, interesting A because Microsoft suddenly decided to develop this point of view after their relationship with OpenAI broke down and the copilot product was n like you know, I mean, like basically Microsoft stopped selling the co-pilot product. They had gone in hard and now when they don't have a competitive product, they've got, actually everyone else is wrong and and we should stop doing this stuff. So that's one thing. The other thing is These I I get what you're saying that like it's code, but it's not trained on code. It's trained on like the corpus of human knowledge. So it's trained on literature, on poetry, on academic articles. So it's trained on human language.
Peter LewisAll of it's stolen from creators. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiYe i absolutely not disagreeing with you one bit on that. Yes, absolutely. Like the great mass theft. But the point is that you it's not necessarily fair to treat it as code, because it's not strictly code, and it's also not strictly you know, humanoid, it's a a different thing. It's a thing in in between those two which is a v at an increasingly Yeah.
Peter LewisBut you're choosing to not you, because you're not you know, you're not Sam Altman yet, but the choices that these guys are making and the idea of the technology they're imagining is kind of inevitably taking us down this path. And there's other paths we can take, like to make them much less human-like, like make them machines, you know, whether or not, you know, you want to give them the three
Damian DamjanovskiBut
Peter Lewislaws of robotics or not, I don't mind, but set some pretty tight parameters.
Damian DamjanovskiBut but those things exist as well. So so for example, over the the last week, a great company called TypeSafe, which is actually one of the guys who co who was a c early engineer either at OpenAI or Anthropic, wanted to create a different learning loop and basically created a new type of model that's not an LLM, that he called JEV, right? And essentially what it's really good at doing is decision making. So and it's much faster and much cheaper than the LIM, specifically at decision making. So it's a completely different type of intelligence. Now, you and me would not be able to interact with it regularly because there's no chat bot to interact with because that's not what it's designed to do. So that kind of robotic mechanized automation not only exists, but that's actually where AI has Yeah,
Peter LewisIt's like trying to have a relationship with your lawnmower.
Damian Damjanovskibut it's it that's actually where AI has been for the past twenty years, right? It's been the dominion of Technology and factory work and algorithms. Why this stuff has suddenly broke out into the public conscious is because clearly this is what consumers want, is they want something humanoid. They want something they can communicate with.
Peter LewisDo they want it or are I having it voiced on them? I'm not sure.
Damian DamjanovskiI don't think I don't think people are having, you know, fifty dollar to two hundred dollar a month subscriptions forced on them. There's no there's no public thing that you have to interact with it. It's people are choosing to download this stuff and they're adopting it en masse. Whether it's for work, whether it's for their personal life. That's I f I
Peter LewisMm.
Damian Damjanovskifeel like it's a choice. But anyway, I we could talk about this for days, so I don't I wanna
Peter LewisBut what what what is interesting though is the pushback. So even the tech bros started walking it back once they realized people might be taking them serious about slowing them down, or particularly Altman did. But then JD Vance, the vice president sort of said if if you're making Frankenstein, your job is to make a nice Frankenstein, and then Trump just said, We don't need guardrails, all you need is a high IQ president. So there but underneath all that is this sense that A, it's a race with the Chinese, and if we don't win it, we lose. And secondly, this is about freedom and any sort of guardrails or interventions or control is an assault on the individual, which I find
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Yeah. And
Peter Lewisremarkable. And it's it's sort of also infused the debate around digital duty of care in Australia as well from elements of your side of politics.
Damian DamjanovskiNo, I completely agree. And and and I wanna talk about that that duty digital duty of care. The only part of that I I I would really echo and reinforce is for all the things that I think he's very wrong about, I do actually think Trump is very right that if they if they lose this fight to China, it's a bigger loss than any economic loss that they've had over the past hundred years.
Peter LewisBut why is tech development a fight? Like why I I I'm not conv I I think this is a fight of the Americans making because they want to anchor in their control of global capital with their with their models. I think the Chinese objectives are very different. Like I'm not I'm not putting on a CCP, you know.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, but but
Peter Lewisyou know, footy jersey or anything. But I I think there there there's a
Damian DamjanovskiThe Yeah.
Peter Lewisbit of a false equivalence on how the technology is developing. I'd be interested to see what happens when the two if they do.
Damian DamjanovskiWell, I mean you could argue that the the I mean the space race was a tech race as well, right? But it had a huge impact on the world order, right? And and where technology was
Peter LewisBut is it the
Damian Damjanovskideveloped and where and and for the Americans specifically with this fight, the argument is that the amount of capital that American companies have sunk into the development of this stuff from scratch, and then most of the Chinese models have distilled that rather than developing their own from scratch, like that That money, people are investing that money with a hope of a return on it, right? Like when you're investing, you know, trillions of dollars into it, there's gotta be some kind of payback for that surely. It's not it's not a public good. Like this is
Peter LewisYeah. But
Damian Damjanovskithe the the the Timu and Shine model applied to technology, which the Chinese are really good at because they're very good engineers. They find ways to make it more efficient, more effective, but they're not necessarily good architects at originating these things to begin with. And that's where America's always shone really, really well. And this might be their last opportunity to show that they can win a race by doing that.
Peter LewisWhy? Like it doesn't have to be a race. Like I think it would go a lot better if there wasn't a global agreement to slow down and the technology was really thought through. I'm w one of my the the people that I sort of follow closely, Audrey Tung, the Taiwanese digital minister, was putting out this call for a global citizens' jury this week. I'll I'll send
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, right.
Peter Lewisit to you, to to to determine the pace. But I think if you were to ask most people, they'd want it to slow down rather than speed up.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, if I and I tell you what, if you can get China to agree to slow down, good luck. Like, sure. Like I think that's the problem is like you you're basically saying, well we're gonna hamstring ourselves but there's one big player who is just not gonna agree to those terms. Why would they?
Peter LewisI'd love to get someone that knew more about the Chinese models on at some stage because I my understanding is it's a different it's not building big monoliths. It it's much more diff dispersed and the idea of or their idea of AI is much more mission specific. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiIt's open weight models. Yeah, yeah. but but this all of this does come back to this idea of duty of care, which obviously a
Peter LewisShe kinda need an authoritari you need an authoritarian state to deal with openweight models, but yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiWell you but but just pivoting to duty of care, which Albo's obviously trying to sell at the UN General Assembly this week. So how I know you know this stuff quite well, so I might ask you to kind of run through the the digital duty of care as it's been put forward. What is the concept of a digital duty of care?
Peter LewisOkay, so top level it's actually structural because it's saying instead of at the moment we've got an e safety commissioner who will intervene if there is a danger and do a takedown order. This is putting legal responsibility on tech platforms, but gaming platforms, tech purveyors of technology. in particular defined cases to take reasonable steps to meet foreseeable risk. Okay, so it's a bit like OHS law. So instead of having a police officer, you're actually setting in some some basic legal principles. So there's two the two big bits. One is for kids there is quite an expansive but defined l areas where that duty of care should be discharged. So stuff like child porn, but also material that could lead to foreseeable harm, be it eating disorders or you know, mental illnesses and those sorts of things. The second thing is giving people control over their algorithms the right to sort of turn off the the the appetizing feed. Now I can see why platforms wouldn't like that because that's how they make their money. But the idea is giving people a bit more control over their algorithm. So for those of us in the digital rights space, it's been seen as a pretty low-ball attempt to build in digital duty care. I'll be going for general duty rather than trying to define it, but it's really
Damian DamjanovskiMm.
Peter Lewisgot the hounds racing. So at the moment they've got a short period of consultation, which the US government sort of put their bit in during the week. And then the aim is to get the law up before the end of the year. I thought Albo gave the impression he wasn't gonna blink when the Americans were pushing on that. And again, maybe going so hard on this hack is all part of that strategy, although I think they will have to back down on a couple of things. They've given the Minister for Communications quite wide powers. If a if a
Damian DamjanovskiHugely wide pairs.
Peter Lewisif something emerges to then prescribe it and then Parliament could then retrospectively pull it back. So I can see why I don't like that because if you guys got in or a more right wing government like got in, like if one nation got in, I wouldn't want them to have those powers either. So I don't think that's great.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. So
Peter LewisThink Parliament should determine it.
Damian Damjanovskiso at the moment though, and I think this is part of it so there's two bits to it, right? So there's the the duty of care bit of it, the the foreseeable harms, and then there's the algorithm bit. The foreseeable harms, who who at the moment gets to determine what is a foreseeable harm? 'Cause I think that's that's
Peter LewisSo that's
Damian Damjanovskithe where p some people are having issue with it's a slippery slope.
Peter LewisWell that would so they're le well, they're legal principles. The idea you have things like foreseeable and reasonable and practicable, they're legal terms of art which allows courts to determine whether it meets that test in the context of an evolving society. So something that may not be foreseeable now in a couple of years could be totally foreseeable. You know what I mean? So it's trying to place in a marker. And now one of the criticisms is that this will be enforced by the eSafety Commissioner, which is a government appointee. There is an argument that you know Lizzy at Digital Rights Watch has that it should be a more g like anyone should be able to launch that sort of course to test whether the platforms are
Damian DamjanovskiWell yeah.
Peter Lewisbreaching that care. But I do think I I don't think Parliament should be the sole arbiter, just for the record. I but and I think what's happened is by defining particular areas for kids, because for adults it's very, very limited. It's really just criminal activity. what you end up with is what what the legislators are trying to do as a limiting of power is actually seen as the extent of the powers, an expansion of power. So that's where the debate is at the moment. And that's why You know, it was rejected pretty quickly by one nation and then the Liberal Party. So now Labour's trying to sort of see if they can get it through with the Greens. And it was really
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. I I I think
Peter Lewisthat freedom doctrine too that drove it all.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. The oddly I find myself somewhat agreeing with the algorithm component of this and having the option to switch off the algorithm. So for for a lot of people, like if you log into your Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, TikTok, whatever it is, you're you're shown an endless stream of content that their you know, the algorithm is deciding what you see next. Now I'm old enough to remember the early days of all these platforms where you you'd go through, you'd see, you know, all your updates from your friends and any pages you were following, and then it would say, Well, there's nothing else new. That that's it. You you you've
Peter LewisMm.
Damian Damjanovskiyou've reached all the new things. And then you'd be like, Alright, well that that's what that's everything I needed to know about the people I care about. And you'd kinda put down the phone and go on with your life. I I partially have feel nostalgic and longing for the days of being able to just see the stuff that I care about, which is people who I pages or whatever it is that I've explicitly followed. Now if I want to see the algorithmic version, I should be able to switch it back on without, you know, the government getting involved in what's in that algorithm. But I do like the idea of having that option to opt out.
Peter LewisAnd what's interesting is it's not necessarily a binary. Like I talk to some of my staff who love their algorithm. It makes their life easier. Like it's like I'm an algorithm hater, but you know, I also quite appreciate when I get a referral for a piece of music or, you know, you know, we're using algorithms to get ourselves into political feeds on YouTube or whatever. So it's not all evil. But I I like the idea of I d and and the other thing that's come up is that when people opt out. This kind of malicious compliance. So they just get given a really shitty experience of really boring stuff. So surely I I think what's more interesting is if people could start having some settings where they can sort of control the shape of their own algorithm. And maybe that's a premium service where they pay a little bit of money, like recognizing that the way that the companies are making at the moment is through all these perverse incentives, keep you angry, keep you online longer.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. The th they so Facebook then
Peter LewisThere's something there though.
Damian Damjanovskinow now known as Meta did try this for a little while, so there was a option for a hot minute where you could choose to view what they called your chronological feed. And your chronological feed would basically have whatever the latest post was from the people you follow explicitly,
Peter Lewisyeah.
Damian Damjanovskiand when you get to the bottom of that you get you get the the the old experience of you've run out of things. Now to me I go that's actually a a great thing 'cause That's the bit I care about. But sometimes, like yourself, I like I want to see unlike yourself, I want to see what the algorithm's gonna feed me, 'cause it might be something I wouldn't have discovered otherwise. But I find myself agreeing with having that as an option, but the
Peter LewisMm.
Damian DamjanovskiI do think this digital duty of care stuff, I I do worry, and I'm slightly segueing into the the other thing I want to t what we want to talk about today, I do worry that it's gonna get overtaken by virtue signalling and All this stuff that is not actu not aren't actual harms, but are perceived harms.
Peter LewisBut who's gonna give me an example of something like that?
Damian DamjanovskiI don't know. It's f f fra this is an extreme this is a ad absurdum argument. but you know, someone giving a speech without doing a welcome to country is seen as offensive
Peter LewisNo, that's
Damian Damjanovskiand harming. But but but what what are the guard routes to prevent that going?
Peter LewisThat's not even comprehended because it's it's it's tightly defined at the moment. The debate is actually around the tightness of the definitions. so the parliament is
Damian DamjanovskiSo who defined it? If it's not the court, who's defining it?
Peter Lewisthe the parliament is defining it and then it will be enforced by the e-safety commissioner, and then if it's challenged, it will be interpreted by the courts. And there is no world in which a welcome to country
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisor an absence of Is going to be part of the digital duty of care. Like I get where you're going because we have been talking offline about this analysis on liberal democracy and the the some of some of the
Damian DamjanovskiAnd I mean
Peter Lewissome of the cause and consequences of the the the culture wars of recent years. But yes, I rest assured, rest assured that you can
Damian DamjanovskiBut but if you if so I guess what I'm saying is if on the one hand you say you're saying the right the right might misuse this, that I think that proves my point, which is I think that when you say Parliament, then the eSafety Commissioner, then the courts, that's three layers of elitism before it actually gets to what does an average person think that is this a reasonable thing to show up in a feed on?
Peter LewisBut none of this is to police the internet. It's to say here is your obligations if you're offering some technology the same way as you've got to make a car safe to drive on the road. And there will be how do you like so at the moment there is no duty of care at all. It's all care, no responsibility. there is another world in which it's a very tightly regulated internet like China. What I think we're trying to get here is a place where there is some enforceable limits because without that we are flying off a cliff. And and if there was no negative consequences, then you go, Well, fair cop. But I just think that because it's quite technical and also quite limited, it's becoming a bigger motif for everybody. And this but the freedom bit is the bit that just doesn't work because this is actually our rights to put some controls around the technology that we're using on a day-to-day
Damian DamjanovskiI guess
Peter Lewisbasis.
Damian DamjanovskiI I I actually think in principle I don't disagree with you. I think I disagree with the mechanism and actually who the the the book we're about to talk about by by Darren Asamogra, and I think he talks about this as well, is I don't want to curtail people's ability to say the thing, but I do want like if if Peter finds you know any posts relating to dark beer offensive or harmful to him or if you decide to be a teetotaler and you don't want to see anything relating to alcohol, you should have the abil to block that out of your feed. Right? But that shouldn't impose on my ability to post up a video of
Peter LewisThe third one which is
Damian Damjanovskime enjoying
Peter LewisYeah. and there's sharper analysis than that, but we could maybe go in a circle.
Damian Damjanovski'Cause platforms like TikTok already allow you to do this kind of thing, right? Do you know what I mean? Like there are some platforms who've already started allowing you to kind of go, this is not a thing I'm interested in, I don't want to see more of this.
Peter Lewisso yeah, let's talk a little bit about Asamoglu. because I foisted this book on you and saying you've got to read this. And I
Damian DamjanovskiYes.
Peter LewisI think it was shared with listeners. Part of our friendship started exchanging books when we and look. I'm a bit of a Asamogli fanboy. He's an interesting guy. I got into him when he wrote this book, Power and Progress, about the ad technological change and what drives productivity, which he argues when the technology's in the hands of the workers, it's a lot better than when it's imposed from And yeah, it's a really and it drove a lot of my thinking
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, agree.
Peter Lewisover the last couple of years. Then he won the Nobel Prize in Economics. So for the first time in my life, I was a fan of the Nobel Prize in Economics. And this is the book he's put out since. What happened to Liberal Democracy? And it's really interesting. He's he tries to pull back, I think, a couple of things about where we are at the moment explaining the populist backlash, but he really builds on a lot of the thinking around liberal theory, which in Australia we really struggle with, Dame. I think because it means different things. You know, in America,
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisif you're a liberal, you're a lefty. Over here, if you're a liberal, you work for Morrison. So it i it it it's it's confounded the language. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd in and in Europe it means a whole other ther third thing in Europe altogether, right? Like I think it's it's one of those highly abused terms, w which makes me wonder if that term is even necessarily fit for purpose, other than what everyone seems to agree with is that a liberal democracy, i.e. when you pair those two words together, implies the idea of protecting a democracy that protects people's freedoms.
Peter LewisHmm.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd I think this is where a lot of people then start to get hung up because f for some people it's very convenient to view that as my freedom to do things and they forget the your freedom, your your ability to be free of things, right? Your your ability to be f free of harms, to be free of impositions from others, this, that and the other. But I'm actually very happy you recommended this to me 'cause it is a it was a very interesting book. some very interesting concepts in it. So this is the guy who also wrote a book that I've previously read and enjoyed, which is Why Nations Fail, where he talks about basically nat Yeah, he
Peter LewisWell, I think that's the one he got the gong for, yeah.
Damian Damjanovskidid, he did. And that that's the one where he basically talks about strong institutions make strong nations, right? And and strong doesn't mean big institutions, it means inclusive institutions that are not elitist but that are basically inclusive of of the people that they are meant to be serving. is one of the primary indicators of whether a nation's gonna succeed or fail. And when institutions start to fail, then so so do the nations. this one was I I I found it quite interesting if I'm honest. I found some of the ideas very persuasive and then some of them a little bit weaker, I'm gonna say. but I'm curious to hear your thoughts thoughts first and then I'll dig into
Peter LewisYeah. So I felt it was the most compelling explanation of where politics has gone. And I don't want to like this isn't neither book club nor in a lecture, so I'll try to give the short version. So short history of liberalism, it was the idea that drove the reaction to you know, monarchs and popes and i it was about, you know, individual suffrage, the rights of the individual, it was kind of sort of the the precursor to most modern liberal democracies. And it was always this The trade-off between the group and the individual, but always looking for, you know, some principles like non-domination of individuals, self-government, so government of the people for the people, always limited in its application because suffrage was not always universal either. and so that consensus that really was a result of both, you know, monarchy, but also the industrial revolution, and then where is it ended up. in the last, you know, probably since the end of the Cold War. and he kind of says there's two things that have happened. One is economically, that the concentration of wealth and opportunity has really risen up to university educated elites. And then secondly, culturally there's been this growing gap between, you know, if for America, the, you know, the demographics is always university graduates and, you know, college graduate or college graduates or people that only finished high school or or not that far. And that cleavage that's happening. So particularly in the economy, more and more the the benefits are accruing with those that have got those formal education functions. But the other piece, which I think is really compelling, is this sense that those with the economic power also have the cultural power. And there has been this assertion of that cultural power over the people that don't have the economic power. And it particularly plays out in a lot of, I guess, what we'd call identity politics, which is driven through
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter LewisAgain, through very good and justifiable things, you know, principles like shouldn't be racist, shouldn't be sexist, but then sort of skipping to that next level of actually prescribing ways of thinking. Down to people who are also being disenfranchised by the economy. So he says one's a law of omission in the economy stop working for these people, and one's a you know sin of commission, which is that there's been this blind spot in how. And he uses language like, you know, thought control and you know, you know, the the way that we impose values. from the elites to the rest of the population. And I just think it's quite a it's quite provocative. I would have thought there's bits in that that you would resonate with you as well.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, there was. I mean I I I really resonated especially with the with both arguments. So that economic argument I I was actually a little bit saddened he didn't go into a bit more detail about that because I think what he was getting at, or is at least my interpretation, is that liberal democracies had this implicit contract which was, Hey, you can lean into capitalism and make as much money as you want. But the idea is that the prosperity needs to be shared, not hoarded. And as the the wealth divide has grown in most Western countries, more and more of that wealth has been hoarded rather than necessarily the prosperity shared. So the the trickle-down economic whatever you want to call it, but this idea that you you don't just make money for the sake of amassing a hu amassing a huge ridiculous fortune, you actually utilize it, whether it is as a patron of the arts or the sports or philanthropy, like whatever your choice is. The
Peter LewisHm.
Damian Damjanovskiidea is that that prosperity becomes everyone's shared prosperity. But increasingly as we went into the nineties, and I actually think this trend, I was reflecting on this, I have a feeling in Australia specifically, it started with keeping this trend of the elites or the upper echelons kind of protecting that wealth because they'd just gone through this recession and going, well We you know, the privatization had happened, we'd we'd gotten rid of a lot of the the housing stock that we that was publicly and like a lot of stuff happened simultaneously and while no one kind of made a direction to go, hey, we're all gonna do this, there was more and more incentives for if you amassed any kind of wealth to very highly protect it and not to necessarily share that prosperity to the same degree it had been in the past. So that that was my reflection on what he talked about there.
Peter LewisWasn't that more the pivot to Howard? Like like Keating was redistributive and then Howard
Damian DamjanovskiWell I th I think that that transition, yeah. Yeah.
Peter Lewissort of set up the shareholder economy. I thought you were going to go Keating for the cultural side of it though, because that was the other part. The the grand narrative of Australians' history
Damian DamjanovskiWell, but this is I think both are the inflection point.
Peter Lewiswas, I think, in retrospect, not negotiated as deeply as it could. And, you know, that's part of my analysis of voice as well. Like people thought that because the elites all agreed that it had gone deeper into the society, and then you get Then you get the the counter i the counter reaction. So yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiCouldn't agree with more. Yeah. And the the voice is such a good example, I think, of in hindsight going, the elite had consensus and buy-in on this, but th the working class Yeah,
Peter LewisBut corporations, like yeah.
Damian Damjanovskiyeah, Alan Joyce thought that it was a great idea. He changed delivery on a plane, but everyone who got it most people who got on that plane rolled their eyes inside and went, W Why is this cultural thing being foisted upon me? Right? And and that's not because those people were racist or anti indigenous rights. But it might be because when you've heard the same thing foisted on you twenty times a day by different people, you get a little sick of it and you're gonna backlash. And we're seeing that in the populism now.
Peter LewisBut also but also you are told that you are a wrong you are a bad person because there
Damian DamjanovskiYou're you're bad.
Peter Lewiswas always a moral dimension to it. So, you know, he goes and draws a line between and it's he he admits it's not the same, but you know, the Catholic Church forcing views of people or different you know, cultures that sort of impose a way of and using the education system as the vector for that as well. But then really looking at
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, it's
Peter Lewisthings, you know, like the microaggressions, the cancel culture, the sort of stuff that sort of came out of the the elite universities and has had a justifiable backlash. And I feel like I'm with him on it. and I've always been someone that, you know, I, you know, I've always been of the progressive side and always supported every cause. But you've got to embed it So he calls for a working class liberalism, which I think is really interesting. So to re-anchor
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. It's a
Peter Lewisthe principles, particularly around freedom of expression. So you are not if if you have a different view, you still should have the right to say it. But going back to the platforms, he his projection would be, you can say whatever you like, but the platform shouldn't be making money from amplifying it or boosting it or that sort of thing. So that's where they become.
Damian DamjanovskiExactly right. And and I think I do agree with that. And and and which is why I think users should be able to opt out of any topic, speaker, whatever they want to. I I think I I would agree with you that and I don't think this is a left right thing either. you know, I I I would argue that, you know, the right has the the Liberal Party, for example, is just as elitist as the Labour Party is. And I think voters increasingly are are catching on to that, which is why we're seeing a such a surge in one nation, because The Labour Party is being being seen as elitist from the perspective of A, it doesn't represent the working class anymore, B, it's, you know, people who have been union administrators who've gone through this very narrow pathway to get elected. And then from the Liberal Party, it's like, you're well, you're a law and economics student who went to young liberals, who's from the eastern suburbs, who wears this exact outfit and the R.M. Williams, and you've gone through this pathway. And when they see one nation and they go, that's an average, you know. guy or girl who's just normal person like me and th there's an appeal to that. Do you know what I mean? There's an appeal to that where people go, That's who I want. I don't want the elite. I want the the everyman.
Peter LewisAnd the the point the other point here is that the thing that draws most of the politicians together, they are from the elite education. So they have all been schooled in symbols and context and nuance. And then everyone agrees with each other on a lot of things. And they are good values. And it's not saying that the values that drive a lot of this are bad values, but because they get lost in translation, that is when you get the counter.
Damian DamjanovskiOf course.
Peter Lewisyou know the counterpunch and it and it's justified and so it's not saying therefore down with welcome to countries or or or down with you know diversity in the workplace but look at your audience and build consensus on this if you want to keep your society together and also make the economy
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, and so so so this is
Peter Lewiswork for these people so they don't sort of think they're being dotted twice.
Damian DamjanovskiAbsolutely. And and so while I I don't disagree with Asamoglu's kind of general thesis, I do think he's looking at it through a very US UK centric lens, which I think when political philosophers do
Peter LewisMm.
Damian Damjanovskithat, they they automatically build in a discount which is in those those democracies you have Anywhere from a third to forty percent of people who decide not to participate in the system and they're not really paid attention to, right? Like you know, th they don't go vote they th and so Australia's always a much better representative democracy because you have near hundred percent voter turnout. And I go, in Australia, is that divide of the degree versus no degree people the same? Or is it more owner versus n renter?
Peter LewisHmm.
Damian DamjanovskiIs it a property div? Like I don't necessarily think that the line he's chosen
Peter LewisReally interesting.
Damian Damjanovskiis correct because I think he's playing to the fact that he chose the US as his center point for his thesis.
Peter LewisMm.
Damian DamjanovskiBut I think if he had tried to apply it to Australia, I think he'd find different dividing lines. Whether that's the red rooster chicken line, whether that's whether you own a house or not, I don't know what it is, but that's one of the areas where I was like I'm not sure that a university education is right, because the middle class these days is no longer the factory worker. It's probably someone who's got an arts degree.
Peter LewisHmm. And this is the other context that I think he draws out without going too in the weeds. It's it's not just college education or non. There are also the elite colleges where you are part of that professional class. And a lot of people that have and I think this is true in Australia too, a lot of people who have got degrees and then they're, you know, working on a as a gig work or minimum like, you know, they're they're they're all working in, you know,
Damian DamjanovskiThey're earning less than a plumber, right?
Peter Lewishealth or education, but definitely any less than a flummer, yeah. So there it's not as simple and clean cut as that.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd and and and plumbers who used to be the working class are now like from a financial perspective much more elite than a lot of their
Peter LewisAre they rock stars? Yeah, rock stars.
Damian Damjanovskidegree earning colleagues, which is why I think the degree thing like I think it explains part of it, but I think his thesis is slightly skewed to the American electorate.
Peter LewisI'm tr I'm toying with trying to use this as a frame for my Guardian piece next week where we're polling immigration. So we're pull we've got these long term benchmarks on both whether people think the current rates are too high or too low, which I assume everyone's gonna say too high. But then do you think immigration has
Damian DamjanovskiDo
Peter Lewisgenerally been good for Australia, which has always been much higher than whether people like the support
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisfor that has always been much higher. So I'm just gonna be interested in how that all sits. But whether this is a
Damian DamjanovskiI'm super.
Peter Lewisuseful frame of looking at So I don't know. We'll see what the
Damian DamjanovskiIt c it could be.
Peter Lewisnumbers say.
Damian DamjanovskiI might ask you this just 'cause we don't have any guests tonight, which is always nice 'cause you and I just get to chat. Do you
Peter Lewiswe don't, do we or we I thought we were just dominating the conversation. Yeah.
Damian Damjanovskiyeah, by the way, I guess do you think immigration's too high?
Peter LewisI think that the social license for immigration at the moment is not there and therefore there needs to be a re I'm trying to think of the right word. I think that Labour has made the call that they no longer want to fight, that it's not too high. And what Berkeys did at the press club the other week was a series of very sensible technocratic changes that I think will have no impact at all on the attitudes towards immigration being too high. Because I think it is as much cultural as economic at the moment and particularly linked, you know, to housing.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. I th I think I'd agree with you and you know, not to out myself, but I I do think it is a little bit too high. And I'm gonna explain why. And actually Daria Dar Darren Darren Asamoglu who wrote this
Peter LewisDarren.
Damian Damjanovskibook, Darren, he actually in an interview talked about Sweden specifically, which was thought was very fascinating. So Usually people think of a place like Sweden and go, well, you know, this is an egalitarian, forward thinking, progressive society. it also has one of the largest representations of neo-Nazi parties in the Western world. And the main reason for that is in ten years they had a increase of immigration from near zero percent to close to fifteen percent now, right? So there are real backlash consequences. To changing the cultural makeup of your society, the pace at which you do it and how you do it. And I think as Australians, we've spent 20 30 years now being pretty relaxed about, yeah, we'll let anyone in. That's totally fine. I'm not saying there's anyone we shouldn't let in. However, I do think that when people come here, and I say this having gone through this myself, there's a level of I don't say adapting to local culture, but there does need to be some level of integration involved because you want to enrich the place you're coming to. You don't just want to transport your life and ways from back wherever you were to here because that's also gonna upset the people.
Peter LewisAnd who do you think so be more specific, who's doing that?
Damian DamjanovskiI I think there's heaps of communities. I think par parts of my own community have, but I do think that most of the migrant communities that have started coming en masse from about the late two thousand onwards, there's been less societal pressure on them to what we used to call integrate. I don't think we're allowed to say that anymore 'cause now it's seen as a negative thing to integrate. But when I was a kid from Yugoslavia, like integrating was a good thing. Integrating was a good thing. You wanted to integrate into Australian culture. and being accepted as part of Australian culture was seen as a great thing. You would you would you know learn all the sports and you'd learn the lingo and you you'd you know y you wouldn't necessarily correct people. Well, I mean not New Zealanders,
Peter LewisSo you're clearly talking about New Zealanders here, aren't you?
Damian Damjanovskibut i it's it's I don't think it's from any one specific place. That's the thing. I don't want to say that it's this community or that. I think you know that there's Europeans just as guilty of it as there are Asians, Middle Eastern, Africans, Americans. I think that we, as the recipients of immigrants, have and I this is where it relates back to the book, I think we've made it taboo to say to people, we expect you to integrate
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskiwhen you come here. I think we've made that a naughty thing to say. And I actually think that's what people like Pauline Hansen in her very horrible way are trying to say, but they don't have the words to say. Actually, I think it's all right for us to say that if you come to the country We would like you to integrate because that's what makes a cohesive society.
Peter LewisYeah, I think but I I think, you know, Julian Hill, one of the Labour guys put out a vr very good speech on this sort of six months ago about that idea that part of the deal is you know you shouldn't have a world in which inside Australia young girls are being married at a young age or being denied education or, you know, in some cultures, you know, genital mutilation and that sort of thing. So there
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisare values that that hold there. Now it's how far you take that, I guess. Like I think there's always been a bit of a proxy for, you know, The anti-Muslim vibe or the anti-Asian vibe. And so because I think to the whole way that the culture has changed and been policed by the elites, people haven't been comfortable in having those conversations without being branded a racist. And I feel that we had in a I think what's been interesting about the debate is that. Labour at least is clearly not going I I I feel like the Libs have more gone one nation for racism than Labour has actually in the way they're pushing back. But I guess you're the first wave of that. But also Back again to our friend trying to save liberal democracy. So two things. One is if you want to have immigration, you've got to have the economic story about why this is in your self-interest and no one's that's just been imposed from the elites. And then a second thing of how are is this all gonna work, which again has been imposed by the elite. So then if you think you've got someone to say, hold on, slow it down, it's a bit like the way I feel about AI. I want someone to say slow, slow it down, you know. Say that, Pauline, and you know, I'm all on board, you know, because putting
Damian DamjanovskiAnd
Peter Lewislimits to the consensus,
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewiswhich I must say the next step is that the consensus is actually both economically and culturally this constant growth, this sort of journey to some Hegelian endpoint that no one can quite define, as long as we get there quickly. Like, you know, why is speed of change like virtuous,
Damian DamjanovskiIf
Peter Lewisyou know?
Damian Damjanovskiif if if we can get to the point, I think, where people saying, hang on a minute, we need to rethink immigration is not automatically flattened to being, well, you're a racist
Peter LewisMm.
Damian Damjanovskibut instead we can have a conversation where right, we think we might have too many people for the moment and we need a bit of a hiatus and we need to figure out what is the right rate. But we do know we need we definitely need more doctors in the regions. We definitely need more construction staff, we need more nurses, we need more engineers, we need this, that these are critical things that we Yeah, it's like universities if we don't have students Yeah. Then we can actually have intelligent discussions. The
Peter Lewisthe universities, there will be a cost if we don't do it. So if you break it down into specific discussions, but do you know who
Damian Damjanovskiproblem at the moment is, sorry, that the the the left
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskiside in my experience, any time you try to have that discussion, it very quickly devolves into a race's a race discussion. As in, well who do you want to exclude? Do you not want Chinese here? Do you not want the Muslims here? Do you not want the Indians here? It's like, no, that's that's not what this is about. It's like
Peter LewisMm.
Damian Damjanovskiif if doctors are coming from India, that's totally fine. Like I don't care where they're from, as long as they're happy to leave their baggage behind, bring their skills and their food, and we're all good, I don't really care where they're from. Does that make sense?
Peter LewisYeah. I I struggle I struggle to disagree with you on that. And do you know the only person that loses out if race is taken out of the debate is actually one nation because they lose their purchase point of being
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, exactly. Yeah.
Peter Lewisof having grievance. So there is so I I'm still fascinated to see how this plays out. I actually think, you know, your side by basically saying all for migration, but yet for every migrant you need to build a house is very crude. But it kind of has has
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisa sense. I think Labour's trying to break it down into little pieces and one nation just wants to blow it up. So it'll be interesting to see how all that plays out, particularly
Damian DamjanovskiWell, I think that the where the Liberals have landed I don't think it's right because again, it's not like you know, the the fruit picker from New Zealand is not coming over here with two million bucks in his handbag going, I can't I can't wait to buy a house when I get to Griffith and you don't have the Indian student coming here with a you know, check for a million bucks to buy a brand new apartment next to Universe. Like that's not right. But what it did do
Peter LewisIt has been interesting how for all of that Barnaby doesn't want to go near farm workers because he knows
Damian DamjanovskiOf course he doesn't 'cause 'cause he 'cause he'll lose everyone. But the the point is that what the
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskithe Liberal Party did do that was clever, even though the way they did it was was silly, is make the point that you do need to tie immigration with investment in infrastructure. Like and that is a truth, right? Is like yes, we we need to tie those things together 'cause there's a lot of people out there going, We can't have more people when my daily lived experience is we're struggling already with traffic, with waiting at the hospital, with you know, getting through services New South Wales with all these things, everything seems to be busting at the seams. How can you possibly want to add more to that? So there needs to be a compact between my social license of okay, I'm good with this level of immigration and the government going in exchange for that, we're gonna invest in these specific services rather than giving Marriottville Golf Club more golf course more money to upgrade their greens kind of thing. I was just throwing that one in there for shits and giggles.
Peter Lewisisn't there also a role for or your wonderful industry associations to be more forceful at making this case as well of not not beating
Damian DamjanovskiWhich they could do.
Peter Lewisnot beating people over the head with you need more migrants, but saying this is how it works. Like I do like it feels to me that there is a visceral debate, there's a cultural debate, and then there is like if we could just get past those two bits and have people sort of flesh it out.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd I'm I agree with you and I'll tell you firsthand, none of them would want very few will actually want to have it because nobody wants to get branded or get stuck into what might be seen as a racist discussion. And this is the problem with and part of what I took out of Asamoglu's book, which is when the elites have put that top down pressure to the point where people feel like they can't speak out and go, hang on a minute what you end up doing is violently swinging towards a populist because they're the only ones willing to because they got nothing to lose to stand up and go, Well, I'm gonna like you with Pauline, I'm gonna blow the whole system up and go, we don't want any net migration. And we all know that will kill the economy because we won't have fruit pickers, we're gonna struggle with our actual food supply. There'll be no one to build stuff. We won't have any doctors or n we won't have Nepalese people to, you know, take care of our elderly. Like the stuff we actually rely on, we won't be able to have
Peter Lewiswe'll be wiping our own bums in old age, won't we? Yeah. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiThat'll the robots. So sorry, just noting we've we've hit well over an
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskihour, but this has been a really fun conversation after a very long drive.
Peter LewisShould we do Kiss a Death? What have you got?
Damian DamjanovskiYou know, after I thought that G might have had a stroke last week, I'm struggling. so I'm gonna go
Peter LewisWho's had a strike this week?
Damian DamjanovskiNobody, nobody. I'm gonna go and just kind of full circle back to the beginning of our discussion. So all of those hyperscaler AI guys came out saying, Hey, we need to slow everything down, look at all these signatures and then within two weeks Three of them released a brand new model each. So all three, after saying everyone slow down competed literally within hours of one another, released new models. So I think I think
Peter LewisAnd save the world for me.
Damian DamjanovskiI think the slowdown is very performative, to be perfectly honest. I think they're doing it just to be seen to be doing it. My guess is over the next week, and it's going to be China related, I actually think one of the Chinese open source models will be near parity. with a Frontier model within the next week or two. I think they're gonna release something big that's near parity.
Peter LewisAll right, I'll keep an eye on that. I'm a bit more in local politics. Get up and ask the new CEO, Dan Illich, who is a comedian. he's been kind of freelance for for a number of years. People might have seen him from ABC. He's a funny guy. We've been bemoaning how The right has been killing the left, or I have, you didn't really care, on on humor, particularly with reference to, you know, One Nation's work. I use a really interesting hire. I've sort of worked on and off for get up over the years. I think it's it'll be very interesting. He takes over in December, so he's got a little bit of time. If they're they're gonna sit out the Victorian election in terms of the new leader, but then it will be interesting to see how what he can do with That organization, which for all its long and winding road, still has close to a million members and is one of the few organizations that doesn't rely on rich people to fund them. It's like a serious operation.
Damian DamjanovskiPut putting a putting a a a a jester in charge seems like a good move. Do you think that at some point they're gonna have to fight it out with Pauline Hansen over th the fact that they both use orange as their primary colour? Both get up and Pauline have orange. I feel like Dan can do something about that. And see if he can sue one nation. We should definitely have
Peter LewisRangers of the Rangers of the World Unite. Yeah, that anyway.
Damian DamjanovskiDan on the show. He'd be he'd be a great he'd be a great chat.
Peter LewisYeah, absolutely. Hey, that's great. Thanks for reading the book. it's it
Damian DamjanovskiThat was really good. Thank you for the recommendation.
Peter Lewiseveryone just remember twenty sixth of November, I think it is, Wednesday night. We're gonna be live in Canberra. We've got to get our act together. We should catch up next weekend, sort of put some proper plans. Thank you. That week anyway. Last sitting Wednesday.
Damian DamjanovskiTw twenty fifth of November. Twenty fifth. So as a reminder, if you don't have it in your diary already, pop the twenty fifth of November into your diary. If you're gonna be in Canberra, we will be hosting a live open show at the National Press Club. We will have some drinks on offer, lots of fun people to talk to. We'll stream it live on the internet. all and sundry are very welcome. Within the next few weeks we'll probably put up a link to a place where you can get tickets through Humanitics or something, 'cause I think we
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian DamjanovskiWe have a limited capacity. Other than that, Mr. Lewis, thank you for joining me this week, as we do every week. Have a very, very fun chat. If you haven't yet, please like, share, and subscribe to the show. We love hearing from any feedback from any of our listeners. So thank you very much for those of you who comment or send us individual notes about it all. And we look forward to chatting again next week.
Peter LewisSee you might.
