Episode 26

Louise Clegg (Angus Taylor’s better half) on Law, Liberals, Lemonade Beer

With Louise Clegg

3 October 20261 hr 4 min

Show notes

We're joined by Louise Clegg, former Sydney barrister, Spectator columnist and wife of Opposition Leader Angus Taylor. She takes us through life at the bar, the Constitution, and her views on the Voice.

We talk technocracy, and how it affects everything from native vegetation rules to renewable energy zones. We explore why the Liberals are roadkill and why One Nation can't survive captain's calls with Pauline as the whole brand, and of course we chat about life as the partner of Opposition Leader Angus Taylor.

We're live at the National Press Club in Canberra on Wednesday 25 November, tickets out this week.

Chapters

  • 00:00 Introduction and Weekly Updates
  • 03:11 Introducing Louise Clegg
  • 04:28 Louise introduces Shandys
  • 06:54 Reflections on the Legal Profession
  • 11:58 Constitutional Conservatism and Political Culture
  • 16:30 The Voice to Parliament Debate
  • 30:00 Technocracy and Its Implications
  • 34:43 Navigating Energy Transition Challenges
  • 40:07 The Role of Technocracy in Politics
  • 48:00 Political Dynamics and Party Identity
  • 53:58 Personal Insights on Political Life

Full transcript

Read itHide it

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.

speaker-0: Welcome to What's Your Poison, the show where people who disagree on just about everything agree it's best to do so over a drink. My name's Peter Lewis. I'm the director of the progressive strategy shop Essential. Joining me is my evil twin, the principal at General Strategic Dame Damjanowski. Hi mate, welcome. well you're welcoming me. We are in the set of mad men.

speaker-1: Yeah.

speaker-0: How's your week and what's your poison?

speaker-1: I'll start with my poison. I'm having some general strategic rachia as we like to do here every now and again, as well as some beer and an exciting new drink that I have never had before, which we'll dig into in a minute, but something called a shandy. Yes. Not a chanty, not a shanty, a shandy. So we'll we'll unpack that in a minute. my week's been good actually. We've had interest rates go up by another quarter point.

speaker-0: That's good.

speaker-1: I mean depends if you've got savings or debt, really. We had the end of the credit card surcharge, which, you know, means Albos simultaneously saving everyone eight cents while costing everyone fifty cents more because businesses just put their price up to make up for the fact that they can't pay for the credit card surcharge anymore. and obviously the tax office in a bit of heat for the fact that they're not accepting credit cards for tax debts anymore. But otherwise it's been a little bit of a non event this week from a political standpoint, which is not a bad thing to me.

speaker-0: Yeah, I feel like it's a week where the world came to the conclusion that no one is actually going to come and save us. So I think it's been this week of sobriety after the bizarre non summit between Trump and G. yeah. followed by the kind of bizarre press conference with the tech bros where we basically said, yep, you you asked us to constrain you, but we don't want to do that. We just want to rename AI super intelligence because we're the only ones that really know what intelligence is.

speaker-1: Did you did you see the document that they all signed? So there was like a a memorandum or a document that like Trump signed, and then Jensen Wang, who's from NVIDIA, signed, and Zuckerberg. there there was a whole bunch of them. So like Sam Altman, this, that, and the other. So the document has, you know, Trump with his very distinct Sharpie style signature. And the rest of the signatures, I swear to God, looked like they had come from some people with some serious developmental issues. I'm like, surely these people

speaker-0: These are number guys, nothing.

speaker-1: Yeah, these are number guys, not signature guys. They never they've never taken a calligraphy class in their life, with the exception of Jensen Wang, who had just the most beautiful

speaker-0: But you also w notice that they misspelled United States.

speaker-1: No proofreading on their own documents there.

speaker-0: you know, as people that fly by the seat of our pants, I think there's probably a fair bit of sympathy there, but we're not running the free world yet. Yet. anyway, you've got a guest that we brought along onto the couch. introduce

speaker-1: Absolutely.

speaker-0: it and explain why we're drinking shandy.

speaker-1: So, our guest this week, we're very, very excited to have Louise Clegg here. So thank you very much for joining us, Louise. Now I know of you, Louise, but I've never actually had the pleasure of meeting you before. So Louise used to be is a is a former Sydney barrister, in public law, employment law, judicial review, like a whole bunch of legal stuff. I'm not a law person, so I don't know what half these things are, but this is what I'm told. you obviously made your name as a as a barrister and you're also one of the first people to break with the rest of the legal establishment on the voice and kind of come out against it. Whereas I think most of the legal establishment was cheering for the voice at the time, being like, yes, pro voice. So that we'll we'll unpack that in a minute as well. but you know, you you you used to work at Clayton Oots, you you topped some of your bar exams and also you your your your hubby works in politics as well, which is nice.

speaker-0: Is he staffer or does he do anything like what is like

speaker-1: I have to check my notes. no, so your husband Angus is the leader of the opposition.

speaker-0: Yes, Tyler.

speaker-1: so quite interesting as well, and I'm sure we'll unpack that. But Louise, thank you so much for joining us on the show. We're excited to talk to you about many a thing. and I kind of don't know where we even want to start.

speaker-0: I think we start with what's her poison.

speaker-1: Tell us about this shandy.

speaker-2: Well, I'm very proud that I'm the first to bring a shandy to the program. I had a shandy on Tuesday afternoon at the Trundle pub. and for those who don't know where Trundle is and a lot of people won't, it's in the middle of New South Wales. almost smack bang in the middle of New South Wales, but it is a long way from anywhere. and anyway, I was out going to a family extended family funeral, which was a little sad, but with my eighty-three-year-old father and my sister. And it's a bit of a tradition on our doing a home road trip out home to stop at often the Bogan Gate pub actually, but it was closed the Bogan Gate.

speaker-0: That's the gate for

speaker-1: For the burgunds.

speaker-2: Well, there's no river there. Right, okay. Funnily enough, the Bogan is over at Ningan, which is quite close to Topin where

speaker-1: It is.

speaker-0: A moth or a

speaker-1: No, it's a it's actually like a boat. So it's a giant statue

speaker-0: Like a per

speaker-1: of a of a person in a singlet in a hat.

speaker-0: Si I've got a guess. I've got a guess.

speaker-2: Like a bog. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Anyway.

speaker-1: What's in a sandy?

speaker-2: So, well, it's just half beer and half lemonade. It's very exciting. and I am not a beer drinker at all. it tastes a bit like a PIMS, really, for those of you who are a bit more you know upmarket.

speaker-1: Both behalf.

speaker-2: I I don't drink beer. I was going to have a white wine, but because we did this road trip and we did the traditional thing. Which actually started when we had young children and we needed to get them out of the car after being in the car for hours before the last hour or so. But you want to So we get

speaker-0: So want to give them a bit of alcohol

speaker-2: them. No, no, no, no biz for the kids. But we just let them out, we'd have a shandy. It was always late, it was clo it was, you know, Christmas Eve or the day before. And that got us through the last hour or so of the trip. So that was the tradition. And so I was sitting there in the pub with my father and my sister and I thought, this is what I'll bring.

speaker-0: This is your reason. Friday.

speaker-2: Do the podcast on

speaker-0: Yeah, I I think I had a grandfather as well who who loves his shandy and I used to get a a little bit of a sip if I was very, very good from a very early age. Hey, Louise, so I I did love in your bylines when you're published in the SMH former lawyer. Like it seems like a sign of intent that you are no longer lawyering. And I'm I'm interested a little bit about your impressions of the legal profession. I was actually I trained as a lawyer. I never proved it. Did you really yeah. I I actually was a couple of years I think ahead of you. Sydney uni down under Phillips Street where Yes. I think the

speaker-2: I went to Phillip Street.

speaker-0: and so it was this bunker underground listening to lectures on things like constitutional law or administration. The only thing I really learnt to do in that time was how you can have a fifteen minute nap by hooking your ears under your thumbs and leaning down and looking like you're concentrating Life skill. It's it's a really good life skill, but it didn't really take the the legal side of it. But obviously you you leaned in and interested in your perceptions of the profession and particularly what people that are just observers of politics probably don't know about the legal profession. So

speaker-2: Okay, there's a lot, there's a lot. I didn't I wasn't proposing to be a lawyer. I wanted to do a comms degree at Charlestot, like everyone else who wanted to be a journalist and I wanted to do political commentary. So but I I did well at school and so I had teachers who encouraged me to do combined law at Sydney Uni, so I did it.

speaker-0: Smart kids that were no good at science had to become lawyers.

speaker-2: yeah, no, I was a word I'm definitely a word person. I mean Angus will tell you if he can that I am innumerate. He tells the children, reminds them constantly.

speaker-0: So you're not behind the scenes doing the numbers for him?

speaker-2: Definitely not. Yeah, yeah. Definitely.

speaker-1: That's a that's a condition now. So you know how some people have dyslexia. You can have discalculus, which is w not being able to quite process numbers properly. That's a whole thing. Anyway, so

speaker-2: Yeah. So so I look I did law, And well, I don't I try not to criticize colleagues or even opponents. Yeah, nice. but so I did law. I wasn't a very good student at law because I was just a bit of a party girl to be honest. And then I met Angus and I decided I needed to impress him at

speaker-0: Him at law school.

speaker-2: law school, yeah, at at residential colleges where all the country kids went at City Union. And and so I was at the university and I'd met him and I Decided I need to impress him because he was a big brain box and I mean he was good at partying too, but for the last few weeks he settled down, you know, the last few weeks of term and he was yeah, he was pretty studious, as were his brothers. They were quite academic. And so I thought I have to be, I have to work now and impress this bloke, who I liked quite a lot. So I I think I can thank him for having getting that reasonable job in law. I got there by the skin of my teeth. And it wasn't until I started practicing that I actually started to enjoy this.

speaker-0: And were you guys political at the time? Like I'd r that was the time when Joe Hockey was running the campus party and he was SR

speaker-2: Definitely not. not at uni. I mean we we're at college and the college kids were always very busy doing other things. I think that's just yeah that's just sort of what happens. but I also had a teacher at school, funnily enough, I went to a school called Hurston Agricultural High School in South Southwestern Sydney, which was half-priced boarding school for, you know, kids like me. And but I had a a mentor there who was an agriculture teacher and I did well in AG, who was a Salvation Army sort of officer and a Randwick rugby guy and a big Labour man. So he was this very interesting fellow. And he said to me, never get involved in student politics. Do not do young libs young labs.

speaker-0: Teach you how to count, they teach you how to hate. You already can't

speaker-2: He just said if

speaker-1: Or the cop count so they played.

speaker-2: you w if you're interested in politics, just go straight to the main party. Now, I mean Angus and I did actually join the Liberal Party in our twenties, you know when we were young professionals before we started having children, possibly before we got married. And we went to a few meetings and it was all just too hard. Meetings aren't far. Yeah. So so we weren't very political, but we came from country families, country farming families, and my parents were small businesses. They were all gnats, hardcore gnats. My dad was Joe for PM gnats. And so but we did a lot of politics around the kitchen table. A lot. in both families. Angus did a lot of that. We didn't. My Angus's father ran for pre-selection for the country party in 75, in the city of Golden, actually, for the Nationals, against Alan Jones and other such assorted people. So that's an interesting bit of history. So we both were from pretty hardcore pretty hardcore country families.

speaker-0: Which is really agrarian socialism.

speaker-2: Well, not if you're a small business owner like my father and his father was definitely not a socialist. Definitely not. Yeah, right. So no, look, people like to say that about the bush, but it's not really true.

speaker-0: Hiya.

speaker-2: so sorry, you wanted to talk about the law. I did. So I I did the law, I did I started working and I I just I started to love it. And I enjoyed it. And and then I started briefing barristers. I was a litigator in employment law and I thought, Mm, I could do that. And so I ended up at the bar after seven years at Clayton Newt's and I love that too. And I I I have before I ditch on the profession just a little, I mean I do want to say that it was a huge privilege and a huge responsibility, you know, being anyone's lawyer. I mean it's just a huge privilege and it was mostly really good fun. and I was surrounded by really good, smart, mostly humble, decent, clever people. And there's a lot And I so I enjoyed it. It was

speaker-0: She was around being like so y do you get the difference? So you got solicitors and like

speaker-1: Could not

speaker-0: so you solicitors of the back room and then you got barristers who put on the wigs and go out and do the whole court show. So did you were you a what was your style were you were you a flourishing barrister or were you

speaker-1: Yeah week and everything.

speaker-2: I was not a flourishing barristers. There aren't that many of them actually. there they turn up occasionally. They often they're almost always men who were thespians at school or something like that. I mean look

speaker-1: So not good not good enough to be an actor, good but good enough to be a barrister.

speaker-2: No, look, no there are some brilliant people and some brilliant flourishing va barristers and some brilliant, very serious, careful barristers. Like I I there are different styles, horses for courses in different areas of the law. And I mean even

speaker-0: Who's your favourite all time on the yeah?

speaker-2: Barrister.

speaker-1: Do people have favourite barristers? Is this a thing?

speaker-2: I have to say, I mean I and and this will not go down that well with some of my conservative lawyer colleagues, and I'm a reasonably conservative lawyer, but I had the privilege of working with the current Chief Justice, Stephen Gagler, who's a Labour appointee. but I had the privilege of working with him because I did some public law when he was Solicitor General and he was an exceptional and is an exceptional human and human being. An amazing lawyer and I think we're lucky to have him as as a Chief Justice of the High Court. So probably yeah, I mean he he taught me a few things that I've remembered about less is more. You know, he was very much in in written submissions he was just awesome. He just sort of pull all those extra words out and make something stronger. And I like words and Yeah,

speaker-0: Kill your darlings.

speaker-2: yeah. So he look he it was a great privilege to work with him and other, you know, many brilliant people. So I had a Good time. It was f I was very lucky. sort of it had good mentors and ended up in good spots. And then and then we went into politics.

speaker-1: Well

speaker-2: Well, I don't know if he's a favourite barrister, but he was just someone I looked up to.

speaker-0: Why?

speaker-1: Yeah. Do you watch Barrister Summers or Barrister Channel?

speaker-0: Have you been watching the live eye caps?

speaker-1: I I have, but that's mainly just pretty good.

speaker-2: They're not real court. Sorry, I'm going to go it's not a real court.

speaker-0: Such a

speaker-1: Is that a c is that a can?

speaker-2: Rules of evidence it is. The rules of evidence don't even apply. Even the rules of cross examination, you can wander everywhere. I mean it is incredibly unfair. It it makes my skin call.

speaker-0: Like it's the WWF of or the you know, the UFC

speaker-1: Gaelic football.

speaker-0: of

speaker-2: I I re I don't want to go there because the Liberal Party, you know, is under there and they tried to pull Angus into it as usual, you know. but I'm not a fan of the New South Wales ICAC because I think it's done it's done some good, obviously. but it's done a lot of damage to innocent people. And it's because of the Yeah, it does. Anyway, yeah.

speaker-1: There's a lot of reputations just by being called up to the court. can I move on from the law? Is that all right?

speaker-2: have we finished?

speaker-0: Well the only other thing I wanted to ask you, Louise. So you you are a avowed conservative, but in in legal terms, conservative is got a slightly different characteristic like constitutional conservatives versus activists. I'm just interested in you know, we've got a pretty boring constitution. there's not much to w you know, we it's not like the

speaker-1: But a nice short one.

speaker-0: It's a nice there's all those placidums and like the but but like America's got a Bill of Rights and all that sort of all the rights embedded in their constitution. So h what does it mean to be a constitutional conservative and how has that informed your broader politics?

speaker-2: I'm I don't think I'm an arch Constitutional Conservative. but, you know, I I was opposed to the voice because I thought what the model was too big. I was certainly wasn't opposed to an amendment to the Constitution, recognising indigenous people and even giving them a small substantive right that was consistent with the Constitution and therefore I would say our culture. I think our constitution has informed our culture. I mean it was created by our founders who were by then sort of dinky die Australians in the way that they were in you know those days. But I actually you see people love to criticize our constitution. I think we're so lucky I to have the constitution that we have. it's a hybrid constitution. People like to think that it's very Westminster, but there's a lot of the US Constitution in it. It has a similar structure. it was heavily influenced. Without the rights, which is a Big difference and that has changed our culture. Well, that's informed our political culture.

speaker-0: So more institutional, less individual.

speaker-2: Well well, we're less aware of our rights. So I think politically that makes us more relaxed, lackadaisical, less less interested. We don't teach it in our

speaker-1: Can't use them as a shield and we can't use them as a sword if you don't have an ex

speaker-0: You're not going to get kids citing section twenty four of the Constitution and getting a

speaker-2: No. So we have quite a few American friends through Angus's time at Oxford and we keep we've had family holidays with them and we're really quite close to quite a few American families, Dems and Republicans, believe it or not, we're all still friends from those days when everyone agreed to keep it. Quite nicely. and so whenever we go on we would go on h family holidays with the American families, you know, those children all they it's the kids just I mean they were from their parents were reasonably educated, but I think most American children know about the First Amendment and the Second Amendment. and so look, they're just more aware because of that. So they have different political culture. There are upsides and downsides to that. I mean I think America has all our big democratic debates on behalf of the West for everyone and they get themselves all tied up and into knots. You know, they've had the Civil War, the civil rights movement, that they're doing populism sort of bigger and crazier than the rest of us. probably, arguably. So far. Maybe. So far. But so I just think I I think we've got a really good constitution and I would like to see it taught. We you can extract much more from it.

speaker-0: And what and what do you mean by cult like what do you mean by reflecting Australian culture? How would you

speaker-2: Well I I th well when if you take freedom of speech, for example, at the moment, we don't we don't because we have a written constitution, the court has for over a century implied certain things and you know, looked at text and said, well that doesn't really work like they did with section ninety two and reread it and so they've implied this in implied freedom of political communication thirty years ago. Now, most people don't know about that, but that's actually operated quite well. And it actually has an impact on our Parliament when bills go through parliamentary draftsmen, women, every people and and politicians are saying, Well, this could infringe the implied freedom. So there's a there's a really positive process that you know we we should understand better than we do, which means that the Parliament is less inclined or, you know, would scrutinize more heavily a bill that offends, you know, that limits political speech. So that's a good thing that people don't even know about. And that's a result of our that our constitution, which the court has implied and managed, I think, pretty carefully. Whereas in the UK that has they say they have an unwritten constitution, well I like to say to the POMs, no you don't. You don't have a you don't have you know, an unwritten constitution is really just a bunch of conventions and norms. And we have a lot of those too. But in times of sort of strife and populism and fragmentation, norms and norms and sort of conventions break down more quickly than say a written document. And so the UK at the moment is a basket case on freedom of speech. w we we've got some issues and we can talk about the Hanson case and things like that, but but we are sort of in the middle between the s some would say crazy US. But the UK is a basket case. And I think it would be nice if people understood how clever our founders were. I think they knew what they were doing. And then how well our High Court has more, you know, you can conservatives or progressives can, you know, have take issue with certain results in certain cases. But I really think we're quite lucky. and I think we're the because we're the hybrid, we're sort of in the middle. And I think that makes us a sort of a lucky country.

speaker-1: to change with the times, right? So if it's if it's set in stone, then regardless of how the the common opinion changes, it's kind of like, well, this is what the founding fathers said. So that is the rule of l rule of God. If you have it way too easy on the other side, there's no guardrails. And like you're saying, this kind of hybrid model gives you a few guardrails but allows the the court of the day to kind of interpret it based on the acceptable city. But if

speaker-2: Really you can't go too far with that. so the the Conservatives say, well, you you can't have any implication. But the the court actually started implying, you know, federal and state immunities and things from from the beginning of federation, you know. So when you've got a written text

speaker-0: But is there the risk you get it locked in? So we we lock in our political culture in 1901, which is another

speaker-2: We have a

speaker-0: country. And it's been so hard over the years to change the constitution. And you don't want to change it to next year's fashion, I get that. Like I was very supportive of voice. More because it felt like unfinished business and it felt like a pretty minimalist lift to create some sort of body to manage what has been unmanageable today. But also in retros I was also pro-Republic, obviously, but I also in retrospect think that the particularly the idea of coming up with a direct elected president just would been a disaster. So I kind of ended up thinking, I'm actually a bit of a constitutional conservative as well on that

speaker-2: Yeah, so I'm with you on that.

speaker-1: Peter if with the the voice thing and and I'd love your views on this, Louise, like there was no reason why we couldn't have done indigenous recognition in the constitution and Albo couldn't have trialed a some kind of parliamentary committee without a constitutional change. It was like would you agree in hindsight and this is not me trying to convince you by any stretch, but that the overreach or the overzealous reach that ALBO went forth, misreading the the room at the time. meant that we got neither or neither. and that's been a net detriment because of that overreach. Like he could have easily just gone, yep, we're going to pass a constitutional amendment that recognizes that the Indigenous people were the first occupants of Australia. It was not Terranulius, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And

speaker-0: I caught it already.

speaker-1: exactly yeah, but like having that enshrined in the constitution, right? And then he could have gone, well, we're also going to have a voice to parliament that if you vote for the other guys, they may choose to remove it. But while we're in government, this is what it's going to be.

speaker-0: Yeah, I think hindsight says that it was overreach. I personally politically think the mistake was actually vowing to do it on election night because you kind of politicized it. I thought there was a moment where there was some bipartisanship in moving to a position. and Louise, I I feel like yeah, guys like Julian Lisa who really put their careers on the line to land it. I feel really more I don't feel sorry for them, but I I respect that they they sort of took took their stand. But I Ultimately I think that the damage it's done to that sense of what the nation could be, like we've gone back a step by failing. and like in retrospect we probably should have just gone for something that was achievable, which is always that sort of push and pull of politics.

speaker-2: Well, I mean I when I I wasn't proposing to get involved, but I did write early in the piece a a piece in the Australian which I didn't run by my husband or any of his colleagues of course, where I where I pr I proposed a very minimalist version within the current races clause which would have done what I thought was I mean one left wing academic said to me, Yours is so small it you can barely see it but I thought we had to do something fairly minimalist to get everyone on board. now the Conservatives

speaker-0: Went on board. Like

speaker-2: No, well well I mean I I w when Langus walked, you know, in the door I mean I got a call from Tony Abbott and John Roscom and a few people saying, What what are you doing? I said, I'm just doing the right thing. And I really felt because I I mean I'm much better at politics than now than I used to be when I was just a lawyer because I'm exposed to it. And I thought this can only possibly get up if it's very small.

speaker-0: But what was the risk of it being what it was? Like how would you articulate the risk? Why did you think it was too big a risk to support?

speaker-2: because it was a voice for just a small class of people based on race, not on things that just impacted them, but on things that impacted all of us. Now the argument was, well that impacts them too, but it had to be much narrower. So the way I mean to have a separate chapter, which is really important in constitutional interpretation, like chapters are really part of the way our court has sort of managed our constitution. So it was big to have that separate chapter that was deliberate. It was it was making a real mark and it would then pervade everything else and that was what it was designed to do. But it was the fact that there was a voice on everything. So I could see politically, the voice was going to then have a say on everything. So if you had Sarah Ferguson on 730 every night, they'd be talking to the Leader of the Opposition. Labor Party, and now of course we'd have Pauline Hansen in there too, and you'd have a representative of the voice on a lot of things. And I could see, having grown up in rural Australia and living in rural Australia, that where lots of indigen indigenous people live and flourish, some are needy but some are not, that that would create resentment because of this constant focus on. a s an an an elevated say for just one group of people, some of whom did not need it. Some did, but some did not need it. Now, progressives you know look at me quizzically and say, What are you talking about? Why can't they just have a say? What is the problem with that? But I think it would have become so politicized.

speaker-1: Course it is. I mean that th that's what's happened to welcome to and acknowledgements of country, right? That is like

speaker-0: That was contested before we took it to the boat and it's all kind of come out

speaker-1: I disagree with that. I think a lot of it was contested. What the the the voice did is gave it a lightning rod for all of that contest to then immediately rally around this one thing and go, nah, that's too far. We already we're already peeved off about the fact that XY's like this is such a huge part of our lives when this culture or this subset of people is not necessarily as big a part of our lives. Yeah. I think a lot of people resent that.

speaker-0: I just think it was so the I having worked on the campaign, it was a genuine invitation to move the country forward. And what I I totally respect your legal interpretation, but I think what that did was create a momentum that was not as considered as yours, that was just no, we're not ready. And I like basically the invitation was made and the invitation was rejected and people are living with that and maybe the invitation should have been framed differently, but

speaker-2: I mean I I I think it was at the apex of the progressive left, sort of identity politics. There hadn't been a I mean, Trump was challenging it in the US but it hadn't been challenged here. and and they just I mean, even calling it the capital V voice, the chapter was headed that in the constitution, a voice, I mean it is a representative government.

speaker-1: Sind those main things.

speaker-2: But it's so it's emotive. I mean everyone needs a voice. There's a but some people are so done with this. They're just done with

speaker-0: Yeah, I don't do I don't do

speaker-2: So I think it was just I think it was utterly misconceived and the people who designed it and who drafted it out of the University of New South Wales, that's where it came from, who were well intended. Megan. I yeah, Megan and Gabrielle Appleby, and others. I mean I don't know who finally was in the room when that model was drafted, but it was it was just too big. They didn't understand how it would roll out on the ground. So so it's it is a shame.

speaker-1: This is a really good segue into something something you've written a fair bit about that I find really fascinating. Yeah. it's kind of two topics you write about that I find really fascinating. So you you obviously do semi-weekly thing in the in the spectator. First weeks. First weeks. Fascinating reading. It really is. And one of the things that I really gravitated to was a piece you did called Sliding Into Technocracy. yeah. And this idea that we are slowly being that our democracy is slowly being captured by I think you put it as like the the elites, the academics, these unelected experts. and we're basically losing our elected say to technocrats of various forms. And I would actually put the teals in that category as this kind of increasingly non-representative, they're elected, obviously. Yeah. But this kind of non-representative cohort who takes an attitude of, well, we know better than you.

speaker-2: yeah. The sanctimony. The

speaker-1: The sanctimony, that's a really good

speaker-2: sanctuary of the the non elected expert knowledge class. Yeah. I mean I'm part of that, right? I mean I'm we are all swap,

speaker-0: We're on the cat.

speaker-2: we're all shoa. We're all

speaker-1: I'm a Western Sydney first generation immigrant. I get to claim many things.

speaker-0: You weren't falling asleep in Phillips Street in law school.

speaker-1: I don't even know where the Phillips Law School is. Phillips Tree.

speaker-0: But go on, sorry.

speaker-2: Well we're all swamp dwellers here, so I'm not pretending anything otherwise. But look, the technocratic thing for me is something that has been informed by personal experience living in the bush, where we have become the dumping ground. I mean, not just for renewable energy in certain areas, but I mean for me it goes back to native vegetation regulation, which is not you know, this is not even topical. It should be. But when the Howard government tried to meet Kyoto targets by introducing this Australia clause to stop land clearing, there are lots of good reasons to do that. But the bureaucrats took over that and now we have huge swathes of areas in New South Wales in more remote places, northwestern New South Wales, central west where I grew up and on the Monero, where the regulation by the state, to less extent the Commonwealth, but that's now happening more with EPBC Act changes, is utterly suffocating and which basically, and I'm not exaggerating, for some farmers, it means that they are essentially required, and in the event that they don't do the right thing it's criminalized, but they're required to sort of manage their own weeds on not just we're not just talking trees. We're talking grass now. Like as if they are a park ranger. And the cost of it is extraordinary.

speaker-1: To the nature reserve, God forbid.

speaker-2: No, no, I mean they can't even look it is it it's I don't want to get

speaker-0: What's the beef on it? That they can't

speaker-2: Well they they just can't they can't actually there there are big areas there they just lock up and let the weeds just go because the state has overreached badly. And so I'm don't want to do any more on that because it it's such a it's not a retail subject and there's not many farmers. Yeah. The the they are they are the laws are made by regulation, by bureaucrats who do not who just do it from a laptop. they don't even go and do tests and they have no idea of the knock on impact over in some now decades where we have great areas of native and non-native weeds infesting millions in the Northwest, like millions of hectares of land that they've just had to lock up and they can't touch. And it is not achieving the goals, it's not achieving the carbon goals and it's not achieving the biodiversity job. But it ticks the boxes in in in some international sort of climate. And do you get carbon

speaker-0: Credits for

speaker-2: and and there is such resentment and it it it's been it's su it's got so bad that it's just counterproductive. It's not good for the environment. It's gone too far. So the same thing has happened with renewable energy. That's a little bit more on on the agenda. There are now entire regions, renewable energy zones in New South Wales, which are just literally the amenity, the landscape for these people who don't get the benefit of increasing property prices like people do in Sydney, who sort of miss out on a lot of things, but they have their amenity, they have their landscape. And there are people, I mean, in the Central West, there are farmers out there. There's I saw someone on Facebook the other day, or some time ago, who's has got three thousand acres and there's three solar farms going up around him and they're all about three thousand on three of his sort of on on Data centres that don't take up anywhere near the space and as I understand, I don't know much about them at all, but they don't take up they're just big sheds. And I

speaker-0: Are you someone that doesn't think we need to transition the energy base?

speaker-2: I think we need to do it in a way that as my husband used to say when he was energy minister and c and just smashed by the left, by the guardian, like that was a jihad against him. you know, and and you know, the lovely Holmes Accord and you th that that was what was behind the tears, the sanctimony of this expert who wasn't is just an activist, not an expert. look we can just do renewables and and

speaker-1: He inherited a lot of money, so that gives him the right to his opinion, right?

speaker-2: That's right. So I won't

speaker-0: Yeah, hear a bad word against

speaker-2: but I d I just think you I I just think we need wait, why wouldn't you open it up to all technologies to begin with? I mean this is this is just crazy not opening it up to the possibility of nuclear.

speaker-1: And we've discussed this before, like at the beginning of the last election cycle, when nuclear was raised as a possibility, ALBO could have inoculated that so quickly and easily and gone. We should absolutely look at all technological forms. We will start a review into the nuclear process that might take five to ten years. Because that's how long it does take to review, you know, where we're going to get experts from. Like that whole process takes a long time. He could have inoculated that politically and could have been a complete non starter for the coalition. But for some reason But the problem is that him going hard against it turned it into an ideological thing and then suddenly turned a lot of swing people in the middle to go, Well, do you really want net zero if you're gonna say no to something that might deliver that?

speaker-0: I got a different take on the nuclear because the nuance of Labor's position was never anti-nuclear, it was the model and the costs related to it. And they've given themselves a real get out of jail card on that down the track, I think. Now I my I'm I got politicized in the anti-nuclear movement, so you're never gonna shift me on that.

speaker-1: But wha what what is run me through that so I understand it. What is the politicization of anti nuc that movement? Is it that it's just unsafe? Is that the crux of or?

speaker-0: Yeah, like it it's a technology that a the we we still have no strategy of dealing with waste.

speaker-1: But

speaker-0: There is risk around it. And I think, you know, I'm a little bit older than you, probably a little bit older than you, but I sort of was politicized during nuclear disarmament party and Cold War and everything. And you know, for for the left, nuclear is a really challenging issue and one that I don't support the development of a nuclear industry, more because we've got the i the the wind and the sun that we can build an infrastructure to make it work.

speaker-2: But then we have to have all the transmission lines and the battery backups. So the problem, and I mean I draw on Hayek Hayek in some of my writing here because he sort of said central planners, the problem with central planners is they don't know what they don't know. And so you have these technocrats, some of them well intended, some of them listening to activists. There was way too much sort of activist influence, I think, at in that era, sort of dominating this idea that we could just do renewables and what are those Neanderthals sort of even thinking about. But but Getting back to the technocrats, they they actually didn't even give a jot of consideration to the impact on the landscape, or the environmental impacts. And and they didn't even think about remediation. And so I mean you have Chris Mins now trying to defend the fact that there is nothing that solar developers do not have to set aside in a fund f r remediation funds for future remediation. And cleaning up and that is going to be your building in the future.

speaker-0: It's probably with the with the execution of an energy transition or the idea of an energy transition.

speaker-2: not I mean, look, if it all means a cleaner world and a you'd of course I'm not opposed to an energy transition. No, it's the execution. It has become so ideological. And and and I when I talk about this I often I use Malcolm Turnbull, who used to sort of he's sanctimonious too. I mean he I think he and Holmes Accord have been the most sanctimonious, high profile people on the energy transition. And and and and

speaker-0: If you think the world's gonna end because of the way we consume energy, then you probably are gonna take some sort of moral position.

speaker-2: So that's fine, but he would always use the words he'd say the engineering and the economics, you know. And actually it's the engineering and the economics that is putting up huge problems for renewables because one, there was ideology, but two, to the extent that there were well-intended people, you know, geeky people figuring out how to do it and on their spreadsheets, they were not thinking about how that rolled out at the coal face. And so look, I've seen it happen with native vegetation legislation, it's bureaucrats. and no one voted for it. None of this stuff goes to an election ever. well the re the renewable energy does, but they don't say, well it's going to take up, you know, according to Net Zero Australia, three Tasmanias of solar farms on, you know, in in

speaker-1: It doesn't matter 'cause that's not where the majority of voters live, right? The majority of voters don't live in the central west of Rana.

speaker-2: No.

speaker-1: So as long as you you know, it doesn't matter what happens to those seats because it's actually about making sure that well you convince people in the cities you'll get a cheaper power bill because solar's free, right?

speaker-2: The coalition is at serious risk of losing every single seed, particularly at state level, where those renewable energy zones are or are being planned.

speaker-0: The New South Wales coalition was all in on renewables.

speaker-2: They were.

speaker-0: I don't know if they've changed their change.

speaker-2: The the it's moderated. I'm sh I'm not clear on precisely what the position is now.

speaker-1: I'm not sure they are clear on their position. But the so the technocrats, I think that's an interesting one. We've previously had guests from the Westminster Tradition, which is a podcast kind of of and for bureaucrats. and as you can imagine, I probably took a harder line than needed with the bureaucrats. but look, they made a very good case for the fact that there is not just value to the bureaucracy, but that there are good bureaucrats. And I don't deny that. I guess where I'm going with this is What do you think we can do to if if your cause again, your your essays on this have been really interesting about how we're sliding into this technocracy. and for those who don't know, a technocracy is essentially the the the essentially a country run by bureaucrats rather than by representative democracy.

speaker-0: And then you a kleptocracy where it's just run by criminals.

speaker-1: Well, it's run by Kremlin's yeah.

speaker-2: Well look, I mean I think what's happening at the moment, I mean, there have been a political scientist in even on the left in Europe for at least 15 years lamenting technoc the increase of technocracy in Europe because they've been you know they were the best at technocrats, they sort of technocratic sort of place. And and so it's hollowing out democracy because people feel that decisions are not being taken to elections and they're having no say in it. now On the other hand, to be fair to them, i when citizens demand a lot of government and government has to do so much, you can't expect every elected member to have the expertise to sort of work out how th some of these things are done. So look, there are some great bureaucrats. I worked with great bureaucrats in law and in the immigration department and and there are brilliant bureaucrats everywhere, but I think the problem with the bureaucrats now is that they all swing left. So they're they're all Dems or, you know, Greens or Labour voters here in Westminster, they're all left leaning. So the lens through which they see their jobs and the and and the decisions are sometimes political that they are making. And they pull the they pull the ball over the eyes of the ministers.

speaker-0: I am with you and I think we were discussing this last week, around Darren Asamoglu's book about what's happened to liberal democracy is the sense that

speaker-2: Which one did you

speaker-0: that the latest the latest one, what's happened to liberal democracy

speaker-2: I haven't I haven't caught up on that one. So I've written about Asymoglu a long time ago.

speaker-0: I like his work. And actually wrote a column about him in your favourite outlet, The Guardian, this week. Yeah. But the a lot of the populist backlash is actually being driven by the imposing of both economic and cultural models down from the elites and without a chance to have really effective feedback loops pushing back. And that's p and you know, you can even look at the voice through that prism.

speaker-2: That it is absolutely that

speaker-1: But this is also like we and we've talked about this, but the like the immediately the rise of one nation, you can draw a very easy line fr from the their current polls to this increased sense of helplessness helplessness against what a lot of people think is government, but really what they're talking about is technocrats, right? Rather than just elected met representatives. Because to your point, the elec elected representatives make, you know, a lot of the decisions and and some of the directives, but it's executed by bureaucrats, right? And that goes all the way down to local government levels where people go, Well, it's local governments who are making sure that, you know, things aren't getting done on time, new buildings aren't getting built, land isn't being released, this, that, and the other. That is technocracy all the way through. Whether it's someone in Canberra or someone at your local town hall, it's people basically getting in the way of you being able to live a good quality life because they are you know, using whatever semblance of power they have. For whatever purpose.

speaker-0: But it's interesting, isn't it, that the rogue kill in this debate is the Liberal Party, who which is traditionally the party of small government, and they're the ones that are really bearing the brunt of the populist backlash to this point.

speaker-2: Well, look, it's it's similar to the UK in that respect, although I really take issue with this sort of line that One Nation has sort of been they're they're they're borrowing copying and pasting from the UK and and referring to us as the Uni Party, where I mean the the Tories in the UK have been running the place for fourteen years and they did Boris Johnson did bring in fourteen million legal immigrants sorry, four million. and they did just go full on unthinking, unblinking into net zero. and whereas we actually I lived through it, I mean Angus was just smashed to pieces by the left. You're not serious, you're not doing enough. And he used to say we can't cover the economy, you know, so so on renewables, on immigration and even on economic management, we we just we are not anywhere near as complicit. I mean we yes, we've been a bit disappointing for some Conservatives, but nothing like that. So I I do think I mean we are roadkill at the moment. I do think that the answer for the Liberals is to stay, you know, not small target but stay fairly big target. And are you and and stay and be unapologetically conservative. Because I I mean the other thing I've been writing about, Damien, is of course that I have said being one of the few liberal people in the spectator because it's very one nation at the moment. not entirely, but mostly. I mean I don't think One Nation is a long term proposition. Because for two reasons. just it is in substance and form, it's constitutionally a effectively, you know, a dictatorship or, you know, well or it you know, there's calling it

speaker-1: Personal.

speaker-2: They they cannot have local pre selection. So then they are captain's calls and we know from being in a democ democratic party that in fact captain's calls often and mostly don't work. You don't have the benefit of local people saying, Well, we can't pre select him because you know he owes money to so and so down the road or you know, that he beat up his wife. You're you know, that you people local knowledge is really important back to technocracy, right? So they can't do that. So they are And that will blow up eventually over time. Now they might change the constitution. but I don't think while Pauline's around they will. And the problem also is that if Pauline leaves One Nation, I mean she is the brand, it's pretty much it's not over. But I do believe that there is a a a limit on one nation's sort of capacity to influence our politics was having huge and un un I must say understandable impact right now because I am in many ways I completely understand the grievances. A lot well, many of the grievances.

speaker-0: So the interesting thing that you just said then was that you see the Liberal Party as a conservative party, rather than a liberal party. and and like we I like and like there has always and you know, in a way, th they are different though as well. So I I guess what do you mean by that?

speaker-2: Well, look, everything is polarising. I mean, we're seen today with David Shoebridge coming into the Greens and his his rhetoric is clearly, you know, AOC, Mandami, he's going to go for broke. And that will appeal to a lot of hardcore progressives who are currently voting teal or Labour. So I'm delighted about this. he's he's no threat to the Liberal Party, whether you're a Liberal or a Conservative, but he's going to

speaker-0: Notice James Patterson said some nice things about it this

speaker-2: Actually I know David. He was on I mean I know Zali Step He

speaker-0: He's another barrister, isn't he?

speaker-2: was on I was yeah when I first went to the bar I was on

speaker-1: Like everyone in the swamp is just come from the same.

speaker-0: Was it the was he in the same table?

speaker-2: My first floor, he was we and he's a nice fellow and he's a lovely wife and I would never have picked him then to be even a Green. I mean I don't know him that well, obviously, but I was surprised when he got into Greens politics. I was like, and but he's got quite a well he has had until now, quite a you know, a moderate conservative demeanour really. I mean his brother does too.

speaker-0: He rocks the inquiries though. He's really he builds out his barrister things. That was what the whole don't let us do the social media cuts on public servants was all about shooting.

speaker-1: Yeah, the deck the technocrats didn't want to be held to account.

speaker-2: Yeah, so look so I know David, but he is not going to die wondering and he's going for broke because he's seeing that even if you can get socialists elected in America, mm in New York, but also in other places, in surprising places, you can you can go

speaker-1: The limit.

speaker-2: Yeah. And so so we're polarising. we have always been the socially conservative, economically liberal party. I still think that's where we have be and one nation loves to say, well they're no good because of their moderates. I think our moderates actually everyone can see the writing on the

speaker-0: Can you get rid of all your moderates?

speaker-1: We didn't, the electorate did. The election.

speaker-2: Well no I mean no but I think the moderates I mean I th y we're not really hearing pushback from well I d

speaker-0: Would Angus have a camp or like did he come out of like the right or the wets or the dry? I don't know quite how it all worked.

speaker-1: Alright.

speaker-2: Angus Angus went into politics when he was forty-five as a fully fledged grown-up, fully formed human being, with a having had a big career and a very successful one in in management consulting, but you know, he in resources and energy and agriculture. and so and he was very good at it because he was no BS person. He he just cut through the rubbish. So he didn't Come into politics looking for a faction, but he started promoting more democracy in the Liberal Party, and then he was sort of that meant that he was with the right. And that meant that the New South Wales moderates, yeah, well, Michael Fodios and you know, something moderates said, Well, if we get rid of him, you know, he's got to go. I mean, it's quite nasty. that's sort of dissipated now. But I think The Conservatives were right about that because they knew that the factions were toxic. I mean all f all there's factions in any organisation, right? I mean that's fact that

speaker-1: Like it's a political party. There needs to be cabals.

speaker-2: Yeah. So but I do think the right the Conservatives have been right to sort try and bring democracy back to the party because that's actually, you know, that's what one nation is pretending to be, but not. And that I think is democracy. Well

speaker-0: Chris Main stacking or is it?

speaker-2: it looks look it just.

speaker-0: Just looking at it from my pad.

speaker-2: Yeah, no, that's a good it's a good point because in the electorate of Hume where there was A lot of factional activity from the hard right before Angus became the member. And he said, I don't want he's just pushed out branch stacking, but encouraged membership. So that's always been his position. More members, if they're conservatives, if they're Christian, great, if they're libertarian, great. Bring them all in. but I do think where the Liberal Party is now that that is sort of I mean we we can absolutely handle a fairly broad church. And the point I make to the One Nation people again who complain about unmoderates is that they've already got their own moderates. One is called David Farley. He is definitely a moderate. And the minute they start to acquire any strength in any parliamentary they will have faction.

speaker-1: Well it's not even factions, those people leave the party. well of course we've talked about this before. I think

speaker-0: Parcha lounges.

speaker-1: it's the the most likely out but I agree with you though is that I think the the iron grip that Pauline has on One Nation is not that something she's going to give up readily. No. And it will basically leave when she decides to leave. But it's a cult of personality, right? People vote One Nation for Pauline. They don't know who the other candidates are other maybe Barnaby. They don't really know. Right? They didn't really know David Farley, but they voted him in. And David, I don't think, will stick around with One Nation, much like most of their candidates and then most of their elected members have not stayed within the party.

speaker-0: Hm. Hey, before we wind it up, I'd I I've been really conscious, like you're Louise, you're not Mrs. Angus Taylor, but I'm interested in your experience of being the partner of a political leader. maybe firstly, what do you think the electorate's not getting about Angus that you wish they would? But also your thoughts on your role as kind of the partner of a a a political leader, who obviously hasn't even taken their name or anything so you're not sort of

speaker-2: I know. Well one very friendly progressive journalist said to me, I can't believe that a conservative has a wife like you. I'm thinking what do you think we are? Like the like modern conservatives must have housewives at home.

speaker-1: Handmaid's Tales style.

speaker-2: Anyway, look look on the question of what is the what's the electorate not getting, I think we're just having a popular surge like they did in the UK. it's not exactly the same. We don't copy and paste, but it is rhyming. And for the first eighteen months of Kemi Badenok, I they she was written off, she was hopeless, hapless, no cut through, and now she's now that Farage has become part of the political furniture and he's being scrutinized and

speaker-0: Challenge from the ride.

speaker-2: And and exactly, which I f I'm I'm sure will happen here. People watch, they know, they copy.

speaker-0: Fake to crazy.

speaker-2: Well, exactly. so I think I think look, Angus is a very serious person and he's not a narcissist. And I think modern politics really lends itself to you know, and populism, left and right, you know, teals, one nation I'd say they're both

speaker-1: Bit of a nerd.

speaker-2: a nerd. Yeah. God, yes. Okay, right. Yeah. Now I I mean

speaker-1: He doesn't come across as having like a a broad sense of humor, so I assume he must have a very like nerdy sense.

speaker-2: he's very nerdy. Yeah, okay. Yeah. I mean he's he's good fun. Yeah. But I mean, as Tony Abbott once was reported to have said, and I knew it must have been true because it is true, he's not the life of the party. Like he's not, you know, the guy who's sort of getting on the turps or dancing on the table. So he's he's serious, but I mean I find that attractive. I mean I like Stephen Gagler. I find serious people I think we should have serious people in politics. So but he I mean he needs a bit of time for things to settle down. He's always been very popular in the electorate. I mean, he was the only sitting MP in New South Wales to get a swing to him at all in the last election. He's a good local MP. He's a he delivers. He's serious. He's there for the right reasons. It's not about him. I mean, I think he'd do much better if he was more narcissistic, but I don't I don't want that. Have we ever had a

speaker-1: An elected leader who was the life of the party? Is it Hawk? Hawkey. Hawk, that was

speaker-2: No. So this is the thing So so all the p the journalists are writing him up, he's dead on arrival. But that's

speaker-1: But that's who we

speaker-2: actually well it has been in the past. So we don't know what happens.

speaker-0: What what do you reckon of how it's going, Donnie?

speaker-1: Of how Angus is going. I think it's hard to cut through, right? Like with Paul Pauline's just doing all the cut through. I I come back to and I don't think it's an Angus problem. I think it's a Liberal Party problem of until you figure out how to communicate core values, people, the media, and your opposition are going to keep reframing you through whatever lens they want to. Yeah. And I think the party more broadly has a lot of work to do to go, hang on, who do we stand for? What's our vision of the future? What are we? Why should anyone care about us as a party? And Pauline has stumbled into her formula because she's basically been saying the same thing for for 30 years, right? She's just repeated herself for 30 years. The immigrants are to blame for everything. You should be allowed to do what you want to do, drill baby drill. Like she's just repeated the same thing for 30 years, and people have gone, Well, she's not like the others, at least she says the same thing over and over.

speaker-0: Yeah.

speaker-2: So, I mean, I think economic management will become important as inflation probably continues to go up and things get even harder. So we should be able to do well on that. Particularly as one nation. I mean Barnaby, I think, they first said when asked about the costing of all their policies. They're just copying from us and themselves and everyone else and they just throw it all and say and they get they announce at first, but they've never costed any of it. And they said at first, we don't have the resources, and then someone said, Well, actually. So the Parliamentary Budget Office will do it for you. And then Barnaby said to Sarah Ferguson on seven thirty, well I'm not Jesus Christ. I I can't model. Then they moved very quickly and recently to, well, we don't trust economists or the Parliamentary Budget Office. And so they've just basically said we're not going to do it. And I think they're making a political calculation that a lot of people won't care. So again, I mean th

speaker-1: thing is they're not they're not wrong.

speaker-2: they're not wrong, but you would think that the Australian Financial Review might care. So so I think there's a just a I'm and I'm not being critical of anyone but but there is not there's still not that level of scrutiny that needs to that I think will come. so I'm not saying, you know, Angus is going to be the next Prime Minister. there's

speaker-0: Well if he's an expert minister, you're the next first lady, what would that look like? What would I have you looked at anyone that's in that role that you go, gee, they've nailed it?

speaker-2: look I don't I j I think it's a I I don't aspire to it, you know, I because I'm my own person and I don't like to be defined by a I don't like to be a political wife.

speaker-0: But you'll be you'll be drawn into that through the kind of set piece theatre of that should he run in the next campaign.

speaker-2: I don't know. I mean maybe I can carve out a slightly different role.

speaker-0: Just keep running for the Specky and just so they won't wanna have you anywhere near the stage 'cause she's running the crazy

speaker-2: Yeah. I I mean I I actually I I I haven't thought about it and I don't like to think about it. Yeah. I mean I I think Angus ha brings a lot for the country because he is a serious person and sort of knows the problems are big to solve. They're economic, it's for their future. and I think he's the serious person. But but whether that works in this day and age, I don't know. But if not, then We've got lots of things to do and so so and and there won't be sort of any, you know, jobs or lobbying or things like that that sort of take place. So we I'm very, very relaxed about it all.

speaker-1: But he so he just turned sixty, didn't he? He did. Yeah. Happy birthday to Angus. And you just turned sixty.

speaker-2: Wednesday.

speaker-0: Turn sixty on Sunday.

speaker-2: Really? Yeah. There you go. They're only two years older than me. So we're you know

speaker-1: I wonder how many hospitals apart the two of you were.

speaker-0: yeah.

speaker-2: Well he was born in Cooma.

speaker-0: I was nowhere near Kurma. I was in the I was in the used lot though I was adopted, so

speaker-2: will you? that's interesting.

speaker-1: They used lot.

speaker-0: Anyway. That come on that escalated quickly at the end there. Do we should we go to Ki did we tell you about Kiss of Death? Do

speaker-2: No.

speaker-0: a prediction for the week?

speaker-2: Is it prediction for next week or just in the future?

speaker-1: What?

speaker-0: It can be any prediction, we call it kiss of death because we normally get it wrong. So if you really want something not to happen. Like so your your kiss of death could be that they're gonna move on Angus next week and you'll get it wrong and then Have you

speaker-2: No, that's not a kiss of death. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

speaker-0: got have you got one? Well you can have a th

speaker-1: I do. So we'll my kiss of death this week is non political. And I'm genuinely hoping it happens. So obviously we've had a particularly mild winter, very little cold frost. Yeah. So my kiss of death is we are actually gonna see an early bloom of the jacarandas, which will bring me such delight. Yes. So I'm hoping next week marks the start of the jacaranda bloom. that's the

speaker-0: Terrific.

speaker-1: best time of the year in Australia and especially in Sydney.

speaker-0: I am going we mentioned it before actually. I it's more skiding 'cause one of my kiss of death got right a couple of weeks ago. I said there'd be a change of leadership in the Greens. So

speaker-1: Well done.

speaker-0: welcome David. But my kiss of death is that I think he is going to I think he's gonna hit a few marks pretty quickly. And I think bit and and the bit that where he's gonna be really pivotal around quite a few of the bits of legislation going through on AI, I don't think the Libs are gonna play ball and Labor's gonna have to deal with the Greens, particularly around digital duty of care, possibly on privacy reform as well, and also on data centers. So I I think he's gonna be in the game pretty quickly. They wouldn't let him They

speaker-1: Is he on the AI committee?

speaker-0: said th the Greens can nominate as long as it's not David.

speaker-2: So my I mean my kiss of death is related and I've already alluded to it. I think I think Shoebridge with his very radical sort of an an economic populism which he's expressly said he would is is very bad for Labour and the Teals. and so I'm happy about that. I think it's but I think it's bad for the country. And but it it could be good for the Liberal Party. Could be very if they take if they if they take up that mantle and But what you'll see I think is what is happening everywhere in the UK and in the US, this continued polarisation.

speaker-0: Hey, thanks for coming in Louise. It's lovely.

speaker-2: Very, very nice to talk to.

speaker-1: You're very welcome to drop in any time for another show.

speaker-0: Are you hanging around Canberra during sitting time or not? If you do want to be there last week, we are at the National Press Club Wednesday, November 26th for drinks and a live show. 25th? I'm so if you can make it. We're

speaker-2: The press clubs.

speaker-1: twenty fifth.

speaker-0: gonna what's your poison live? So yeah, so we'll put tickets out this week. apart from that, you know, tell people about this show. We're getting lots of really good feedback. As Damian likes to say, like, share and the other one and comment.

speaker-1: Like, share and subscribe. Comment if you like. We don't want your comments, but just like share and subscribe. Thank you everyone who pulls me up in the street to make a comment about our podcast. I really appreciate it. Every single time.

speaker-2: Okay.

speaker-0: Thanks everyone.