Episode 27

Gin, God, and Gaza

With Rabbi Gersh Lazarow

10 October 20261 hr 8 min

Show notes

This week we are joined by Rabbi Gersh Lazarow, founding rabbi of Shtiebel in Melbourne, for a conversation we have mostly avoided on this show. We recorded it a few days after the anniversary of October 7. It is frank, sometimes uncomfortable, and one of the more important episodes we have done. We discuss personal journeys, cultural traditions, and identity. Gersh shares his story of leaving apartheid South Africa and how he came to be a rabbi and build Shtiebel. We delve into faith and culture, the war in Gaza, the experience of Jewish Australians over the past three years, and how hard it has become to hold complexity when everything pushes us into sides.

We close on how people with very different views can still sit at the same table, what the rabbinical tradition of debate offers here, the need for community and understanding amidst division, with an emphasis on the role of language and shared experiences in fostering connection.

A reminder that our first live show is at the National Press Club in Canberra on Wednesday 25 November, 6 to 9pm. Invitations go out this week.


Chapters

  • 00:00 Introduction and Personal Updates
  • 03:34 Welcoming Rabbi Gersh Lazarow
  • 05:32 Rabbi Gersh's Journey and Background
  • 11:01 Exploring Faith and Spirituality
  • 14:00 Cultural vs. Religious Identity
  • 19:12 The Complexity of Current Events
  • 26:30 Navigating the Dichotomy of Opinions
  • 30:48 The Impact of Technology on Discourse
  • 35:33 The Pain of Innocence in War
  • 36:38 Accusations and Social Dynamics
  • 37:19 Emboldened Voices and Experiences
  • 41:04 The Ugliness of Modern Warfare
  • 43:54 Personal Responsibility in Discourse
  • 46:45 Navigating Community and Identity
  • 50:55 The Shift in Political Discourse
  • 54:21 Historical Context and Responsibility
  • 57:10 Building Community Amidst Tension

Full transcript

Read itHide it

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.

Damian DamjanovskiWelcome to What's Your Poison, the podcast where people who barely agree on anything agree that it is better to do so over a drink. My name is Damed Damianovsky. I am a principal here at General Strategic. And joining me this week, as he does every single week, is my evil twin, Mr. Peter Lewis. Peter, how are you? How is your week? And how was your day?

Peter LewisDon't even ask, Dame. So I have I have come to this realization that the one skill I had with my hands in life is now redundant, which was to be able to change a car tire. I was on my way to where I am to be part of this show and my tire blew, but because I'm a good citizen and I've bought myself a hybrid EV, there's no spare tire. I had to get a tow truck to take me across the road to get a replacement tire and I was lucky to get that. it was stressful. We're late. and as you know, normally I either drink beer or wine, but this week I think it's a week for the spirit. So I'm on a OP Sydney Gin from Blackwattle Distillery for political junkies. This is run by a guy called Mark McClay, who was leaping Leo McClay's son and was used to be part of the labor movement. Go down and say hi to Mark if you are around the Blackwattle distilling area, which is just up from that craft brewery down on the water. But it is a a lovely

Damian DamjanovskiNuts.

Peter Lewisjob. So This is the best moment of my day so far when I get closer to the spirit. And I think that's going to be a bit of a theme for today. So maybe it was meant to be.

Damian Damjanovskijeez, I'm s I'm s yeah, I think so. And I'm sorry to hear about your journey. I I would have assumed that anyone who drives an EV and gets a flat tire could reinflate it with hot air and hubris, but apparently that's that's not the case.

Peter LewisWell there's this black goo you can put in, but if the hole's big enough the black goo doesn't work either. So

Damian Damjanovskiyou looked at the black goo and went, this looks like a fossil fuel. I can't know. I'm gonna call a combustion engine tow truck to get you. Well

Peter LewisYeah. And then I rang the NRMA and he waited forty minutes for him and he said, nah. And then I was in the end I offered a guy cash in hand to tow me across the road. So we got there. And thank you, Kevin.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah. letting you know my poison this week is a winner of the world spirits competition from Scotland. It is called We Smoky,

Peter LewisNo.

Damian Damjanovskiwhich comes in this strange blue bottle, which I found very intriguing. it was finished in petered casks, so it's a very smoky whiskey. However, it is oddly clear for a whiskey.

Peter LewisMm.

Damian DamjanovskiSo it's off brand for me because I I feel like a middle-aged woman drinking clear spirits as part of a diet, but in fact it's a petered whiskey. And the only other thing I'll add, Peter, is last week in my prediction for the week, I told you that due to the hot summer, we might see an early bloom of the jacaranders. And I woke up with joy this morning because I saw the first purple leaf on a jacaranda around the corner from my house. And it was beautiful. It is my favorite time of the year.

Peter LewisOne of my one of my favorite invasive species just nodding to Jack off from a few weeks ago. Love the import

Damian DamjanovskiGood.

Peter Lewisof a jacaranda. Anyway, you've brought a guest along today. on the spirit theme.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah. So w we'd like to say a big welcome and hello to Rabbi Gersh Lazzaro. Welcome, Rabbi. Lovely to have you on our show.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowGentlemen, it's lovely to be with both of you. I'm coming all the way down from Melbourne where we're enjoying our first our first rays of sunlight of of a real summer. So I'm on Lemoncello.

Damian Damjanovskiphenomenal.

Peter LewisPlay.

Damian DamjanovskiPhenomenal. Now I I've known Rabbi Gersh through his congregation, I guess is the the right word. Stiebel. Is congregation the correct word?

Rabbi Gersh LazarowIt's a word we don't use, but yeah, I could I'm not saying it's incorrect.

Damian DamjanovskiIt's I

Rabbi Gersh LazarowWe struggle with definition.

Damian Damjanovskiyeah, well I I I like to hear that. I think we all do to some degree, but I I've I'm as you know, Peter, I'm I'm not Jewish, but my partner's Jewish. So I've I've and I'm also a huge lean into people's cultures kind of person. Like I I do Chinese New Year every year. I I like to do Diwali when I can. I do Catholic Christmas, I do Orthodox Christmas. I just I love people who love their tradition and heritage and lean into it.

Peter LewisBut just to interrupt, aren't you registered as a reverend? I remember you telling me this story.

Damian DamjanovskiI I am, I am. So I I'm an ordained reverend, which was something I did to get out of COVID lockdown and it was successful because it meant I could provide pastoral care to anyone who really wanted it. but I am an ordained reverend and have married people. but the only condition for my ordainment was that I had to believe in a higher power outside the self. That was the that was the condition.

Peter LewisAnd that was Scott Morrison.

Damian DamjanovskiVery good. So

Peter LewisHe

Damian DamjanovskiI've I've been to, you know, a few a few different Jewish services and sermons and you know listened with with varying levels of interest. But I've I've been to a few of Gersh's services now and they really struck me as something really interesting. And especially on topics that I think Peter, you and I haven't really broached on this podcast

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskibecause they're they're just too tricky and and I don't know if it's a cop-out on our behalf and not a Approaching these topics because we know they're tricky and they're divisive and they're hard to talk about. but hearing Rabbi Gersh's sermon at Iom Kippur made me go, actually, we have to talk about this stuff. and Gersh is a good person to help us with that conversation,

Peter LewisYeah.

Damian DamjanovskiI think. So Gersh, I don't know if you want to maybe tell us a little bit about yourself and your journey.

Peter LewisBefore Gersh starts, I just I I would just double that. I've had a lot of trepidation ahead of this discussion because we're having like a private discussion but with a public audience. I hope people will listen to this with the kindness that we hope to bring into this discussion as well. I feel particularly We are all conditioned to be outraged when we start talking about what's happening in the world and what's happening in our own community. So let's give it a crack anyway, in the spirit

Damian DamjanovskiTry.

Peter Lewisbehind what's your poison, which is not trying to convince each other they're we're wrong, but just to hear each other a little bit better and also hear from our guests. So on that note, really welcome and I'm really glad to meet you, Gersh.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowThanks. And I listen, I think the first thing to say is I think the two of you are are courageous, brave, and possibly a little stupid. and and and that's probably a healthy

Peter LewisHmm. Tick, tick, tick.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowmix to to kind of get through the days in in in in in the world that we live at the moment.

Peter LewisMm.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowbra courage and stupidity in in in appropriate measure. I won't say equal measure, but appropriate measure. my story. my story is is is is both long and short. I'm a migrant to this country. you can pick up elements of my South African accent when the right word comes out. my parents came here when my eldest brother got conscription papers at the age of sixteen to do medicals for what was still an all white South African army. And I'm

Damian DamjanovskiThen

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowthe youngest of four boys and my parents didn't see that as a future for their children when they didn't agree politically or socially with what was happening in the country. we made our way as part of white flight, particularly a Jewish white flight to this country, settled in a diaspora community within a diaspora community, South African diaspora within a Jewish diaspora, and and settled into doing doing our version of the of realizing the Australian dream. and I I I think

Peter LewisHow did apartheid approach Jewish people? Were you seen as part of the white minority or your own subset within that society?

Rabbi Gersh LazarowSo I I won't pretend to be an expert on the same things

Peter LewisYeah.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowand I was eight when I left. and I think that the the nature of the human experience is we look back at our history in different ways,

Peter LewisYeah.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowand understand it in different ways. But but I can say that like many Jewish communities throughout history and throughout the world, the South African Jewish community was on the edge of not fitting into one place specifically, you know. comfortably enough and and also aspiring

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowfor the world to be better than the reality in which they encountered. So there there were lots of people involved in in change actions and social actions and to the extent which their abilities allowed them to do. I think in hindsight lots of people would l have liked to have done a lot more a lot earlier.

Damian DamjanovskiHmm. And so then you you've you've come to Australia and and

Rabbi Gersh LazarowCame to Australia, grew up in Australia, married an extraordinary Australian woman whose whose family were refugees from Europe and and Holocaust survivors, and and grew up within the the Australian Jewish community, within the Melbourne Jewish community. I had the the privilege of attending one of Australia's fine Jewish day schools that now exist behind ridiculously unnecessary, necessarily unnecessary fences.

Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowAnd and like so many of my classmates headed off to law school on graduation, decided very quickly that there were enough Jewish lawyers in the world. and and and that I had a a calling to to to teach. and teaching required a bit more learning. And that that learning was about my people's story, our cultural tradition, our religious tradition and and the love that comes from helping people find their place within it.

Damian DamjanovskiSo so you got the calling to to to teach, to be rabbi?

Rabbi Gersh LazarowYeah, I got the calling to be a teacher in the classroom, help people helping people understand who they were. Then that led to me wanting to learn more, which took me to, you know, from university to seminary. seminary in the States, I encountered something called American summer camp, which is everything you see in the movies, just a little less sex. I actually

Damian DamjanovskiR is it all right, okay, yeah.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowsay, from my perspective, a little less sex, because I was already married then. but but I'm sure the 19-year-old counselors were having a time of their life. but it it was an extraordinary to be able to create an idealistic environment for twelve weeks every summer. So I worked I worked summer camps for for five years in in the States while while studying. I came home to to to to return to school as a school rabbi and school chaplain here in Melbourne. I left that and went into a congregational setting for for a decade. I I fell out of that in the less than comfortable less than comfortable circumstances and and coming out of that decided that authenticity and honesty was was was really at the core of my being. Took me a while to reconnect with what that meant. And Stiebel, which is our current project where I've come to meet you and and your extended family, is is is is the is the I suppose the quintessential representation of the work that I do. That's the on one foot version of my story.

Damian DamjanovskiThat's grand. No, that's that's great. And I mean, Peter, I don't think you and I have ever had a chat about this, but are you are you a religious person? You're a spiritual person?

Peter Lewisdescribe myself as a practicing agnostic and I don't mean that as a cop out. I I was brought up Methodist. you know what they say about Methodists. Why don't they have sex standing up because it might lead to dancing like it's a very stay religion. Didn't take, have never been part of the institutionalized church. But the older the I get, the more I am open to The notion of another spirit. And I think interestingly, I think physics is set head taking us in the same direction. The the idea of a binary, like, you know, material world. There's something else going on there. And I think the the the journey of faith is to go exploring that, whether you are a member of an institutionalized religion, a tradition, or if you are soaking up as much as you can. So I like I don't mind that

Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.

Peter Lewisidea. Like so I'm I'm definitely not an atheist. I find people that just say there's nothing there to be I feel I kind of feel sorry for them. so I don't know, a bit of sympathy towards you too, 'cause you're you're you're a a sack of sales guy, aren't you? But notwithstanding your reverendness.

Damian DamjanovskiI mean, yeah, my my my famous line is where you know, we're all sacks of meat and chemicals trying to find our way in this universe. I don't think that excludes the idea of higher power or spirituality. But I think, and I don't know, maybe Peter, for you, I don't know if you grew up where faith was exclusively a spiritual affair for you, but for me, it faith was cultural. It wasn't necessarily

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskilike the idea of your your In the Orthodox Church in the Balkans wasn't really a question. It was more about carrying on a tradition that we'd secretly held for 600 years under the Ottomans, high up in mountains and and hidden away, right? So this idea that you had to carry it on. It was kind of like your duty to carry on this thing that they've been doing for seven, eight hundred years in secret and a thousand years before that. which is I think why Judaism is quite interesting to me, 'cause that that's at the to the heart of Judaism is passing on and Gersh, I'd love for you to talk to about this a little bit before we go into some of our media topics, but that that's kind of a big part of Judaism as I understand it, is the the rituals.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowYeah, I think I think that what a a lot of people who who've grown up within institutional religion struggle to grasp in terms of Judaism is is is is is the weight of the of of of of the cultural tradition alongside the religious tradition. you know, most most prayers begin with the the a three phrase Hebrew expression, Baruch atta adonai, blessed are you, eternal. But the sociologists and the the the the research on this is is is is is absolutely clear would say that that that if Jews were going to be honest, that sitting around a table on a Friday night, and I'm sitting at my dining room table at home at the moment, that a third of them would say Baruchatah don't I blessed are you eternal? Another third of them would say Baruchatah, I don't know, because they fall into that agnostic space.

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowAnd another third of them would say, Baruchata don't care.

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowand and and and and that's not an oppositional statement. That's not a rejection statement. It just means my place around this table, engaging in life, community tradition, culture, is not dependent on there being a higher order. In fact, I haven't spent a lot of time thinking about it, so it's not relevant to me.

Damian DamjanovskiHmm. Yeah, it's super fascinating. I mean, especially when so obviously we're we're we're recording this a couple of days after the anniversary of the October seven terrorist attacks in Israel, which were obviously horrific, but but I guess the idea that some people who are Jewish don't necessarily care or don't know, but then you have people who are targeting them because of that belief, that that kind of Judaism. Like it's hard to reconcile because I think we we like to paint people with a singular brush of you're this, therefore you believe this, therefore this is the entirety of your beliefs. And I think the last few days, just reflecting on that, I don't know, Peter, if if you've got solid views on this, but It's that thing that

Peter LewisYeah, I

Damian Damjanovskiwe've talked about previously, Peter, with you, the the unicontext, right? Which is the idea that we're we're flattening everything down into

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskithese one dimensional characters that we're all walking around in this plane of existence.

Peter LewisWell, back to that idea of a binary with you know, the really interesting stuff, what sits between it, whatever whether that's the spirit, whether it's complexity, whether it's the juice of life. So yeah, I so how do I think about I so you go.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowWell that's sorry, Peter, that's the scarcest that's the scarcest thing in our in our society at the moment. The complexity is the s is is the scarcest resource we seem to have at the moment. That that

Peter LewisYeah.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowthat you you have to either be binary, that that and and this is a little what you know I I spoke about over the new year when I had community together is this idea This idea of the fact that that that that that the way in which we're fed information, or in the way in which we consume information, if I'm being polite to the to the the to the tech

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowbros, i is is is is it's narrow casted. I I remember I remember a great teacher of our tradition, Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sachs. He used to be the the the chief rabbi of the British Commonwealth. And he gave a TED talk one side the privilege of seeing Where he where he spoke about his childhood experience growing up in the UK, with the family sitting around the the transistor listening to the great BBC news. And he spoke about what that meant. He spoke about, you know, they sat around to listen to the British broadcasting company. And what were they doing? They were broadcasting information.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowLanguage is important. Broad is what they were looking to do. To meet as many people where they were and help them find meaning and depth within that. He then went on to bemoan and he passed before he saw the where it's gone since then. The the fact that we live in a world now where broadcasting is is is something we seldom encounter, regardless of what these companies or institutions' names are. And we live in a world that where where where things are narrow cast. It's kind of cute that we're doing this on a podcast, but but but

Peter Lewisit I know but it's

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter Lewisa curated audience of one like everybody b it like the whole business model of the technology is to reduce you down until you are discoverable to the algorithm rather than to each other and you are fit so yeah

Rabbi Gersh LazarowWhich means which means if if we if if that means we no longer have the complexity that once made society so strong, and the word that is rapidly disappearing from our individual or our communal or even our religious vocabulary is and Then we have some real challenges. And the fact is, as both of you know, as both of you unpack each time when you get together each week, we have some serious challenges.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter LewisMan. So could could I give you, you asked me what I I just want to put this on the table in that context, a couple of things without saying I've this is this is just where as an Australian progressive comes at this, but also one many close Jewish friends who I have spoken to over the last three years. So October 7, horrific massacre, helicopter up. it came in the context of s the a push into the settlements, the rise of a particular breed of far right government in Israel. the response, to my mind, disproportionate and horrific to the extent that the slaughter of tens of thousands of children whose lives are worth no more or no less, because they're all humanity than those that were massacred in the attacks. But our inability to hold those two truths at the same time, which has been amplified by the information ecosystems people are in, I think has been what has turned people against each other. Don't know what you think.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowAnd the and and the fact that I had to sit here listen to what you're saying, trying not to debate your version of reality. Hold

Peter LewisMm, mm.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowholding back to not question those numbers, those statistics, those those things, so that we find ourselves exhausted through the debate of facts rather than then

Peter LewisMm.

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowgetting to the next part of the conversation, which is so more important, saying, What can we learn? from this this this horrific sequence of events. How is it possible to say that that that that I'm grieving for for the for the for for the for for the for for the the the people of Israel and what they experienced on october seventh, two thousand and twenty three? And and that's that word that's missing from our vocabulary, and horrified by the plight.

Peter LewisHmm. Because we say but rather than and but becomes a reduction, right?

Rabbi Gersh LazarowWell but yes, correct. Correct. And and and and and and what that leads to is to a further narrowing. That reduction leads to a further narrowing. And then people retreat to their corners, they jump onto their social media, they find that that that the the person who thinks other than them that's posted, who is the extreme viewer, if they if they are if they are progressive. Then they get this extreme fundamentalist view, you know? And and they say, well, that represents all Israelis.

Damian DamjanovskiHmm.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowOr they sket position of of of of of of of of of the the most hideous of of of Hamas terrorists who engaged in in the most brutal of actions and says, Well that is all Palestinians.

Peter LewisAnd it's all reductive.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowAnd you can't go anywhere from there. There's nowhere to move when you've been backed into a corner like that.

Damian DamjanovskiWhy why do you think, Gersh, that people are so drawn to the red like I I and I agree with you, the tech bros and the the algorithms and all this kind of stuff plays a large role in this. But ultimately, you know, regardless of how much confectionery and sugars put in front of us, we still have to pick up the sugar and put it in our mouth, right? So there's something appealing about the reductionism to the human condition where so many of us are so quick and eager to lean into that rather than say and

Rabbi Gersh LazarowI wish I had a clean answer to that and a clear answer to that. I think that in a world where we feel individually and collectively threatened, when we look at the other and see risk rather than reward,

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowthen then we we close ourselves off to the possibility of of of dialogue, of discussion, and and and and and we we we we we further constrain the narrowness that surrounds us. I I I think that when we look at the the the the events of Let's let's set aside if we can, and I gently do so because it's unconscionable to do so for too long, the events of October seventh, or the events that took place in in Gaza in the months and years that followed, and look at what happens to people on the other side of the world. when the assumption is that you're either on one side of this argument or you're on the other side of this argument. Where where the fact is that that that that that if we are a progressive and if we are s socially progressive, then then our moral responsibility is to support the underdog. And we look in this situation where where where does perceived power sit? So then we know we know we know who the underdog is and we know who the big dog in the fight is,

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowand we're gonna we're gonna we're gonna push back against that. And then anyone who supports the big dog in the fight, for whatever reason they might choose to support that big dog in the fight, has absolutely no care or concern for the suffering of the underdog.

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowIt it's it seems nonsensical, but that's the lived experience of my entire community.

Damian DamjanovskiI and i i it is nonsensical. You're absolutely right. It is. I mean, my first hand experience with this is it's very hard to if s so you're you're right, Gershon, that people will often ask you or or try to goad you into what is your position? Which side are you on? And if you gently or otherwise try to steer away from the dichotomy and say, Well, it it's it's not about you know, the side. I I I'm not picking a side, but I I do want to explore the situation and that there are pain, there is pain on both sides, there is wrongdoing on both sides, and it's ultimately a situation that either we it's not going to get resolved, or we have to work for a solution. And you can't possibly work for a solution by picking sides. Like it's just that there is no pathway through that. But if you're if you If you're getting pushed to to pick a side in the dichotomy, usually people just want you to pick a side in the dichotomy. And that's just I I've never been able to find a way to elegantly navigate that scenario. And I don't know if you have Gersh, but it's just Peter, I don't know about your experience in your circles, but

Peter LewisSo, you know, I've got lot of progressive Jewish friends who gr and I think some of the most interesting interventions in a way, as a non-Jewish person, it's really hard to even enter the debate. I I think and I'm really interested in your thoughts on this, Rabbi. I can I really bravely give you my take on what's happened with anti Semitism, please.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowPlease.

Peter LewisWhen people started protesting the response of Israel to the massacre, there was an immediate that is anti-Semitism. And I think some of that was ceded by the Israeli government and some of it was amplified by local politicians. And I personally don't think at that moment that was what was going on. And I I was brought up with the Jews being the plucky underdog, the the the the tragedy of the 20th century, right? So we all were schooled in the Holocaust. There was so much like I I just I don't buy that there is an innate anti-Semitism in Australia, but it was almost like the fig leaf not to talk about what was happening. So you can't talk about it. And it created, because of the way algorithms amplify difference, its own reality. So I do not deny for one moment. your community's experience, but I also think it got caught up in a vortex and it wasn't it wasn't like it was sitting there latent to be tapped in Australia, but I and I I I I do not presume to talk for your community at all. But

Rabbi Gersh LazarowYeah.

Peter LewisI do think there was a political strategy by the Israeli government to shut down any criticism globally as being anti-Semitism and then that became its own reality.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowYeah, I I I I've heard that narrative. A and and and and I understand the organization of facts to present that narrative. The things that I struggle with when I hear that is is how do you explain what took place on this on the steps of the Sydney Opera House on the eighth of October, thirty six hours before Israel had had reacted in any way. Had

Damian DamjanovskiAnd and and it wasn't just the opera house, it should be said. And I'll I'll back you in here, Gersh. Like there were parts of Sydney where people were celebrating with Palestinian flags and with fireworks in the street before Israel had made any response. So they w they were responding to a terrorist

Peter LewisBut again, one or two of those get amplified by the algorithm, much like everything else, and becomes reality. So I'll tell you two other things. One is that the weekend after there was a protest in Hyde Park that was deemed illegal. My my son, who was sixteen at the time, really wanted to go and I said, I will go with you. It is the first time as a privileged white guy that I've ever felt that my right to speak was under threat. And I thought if News Limited takes a photo of me, I'm in all sorts of shit, but I wanted to support my son. The second one was a lot of people of really goodwill would did that march across the harbour bridge because they were wanting to end the killing. And again, after, particularly after Bond died, they were being accused of being complicit in what was basically an act of, I'd call it domestic terrorism slash mental illness. So again, I don't want to dominate this because I've like I'm I'm just I'm just

Damian DamjanovskiNo no, it's it's it's

Peter Lewisobserving that I e even you saying Damien like because my read of that opera house was that's there were people that were going beyond where it should go, but it wasn't the vast majority. I remember that second pro that protest the week after, the organizers were saying this is not about this is about protecting children. it is not about hating on Jewish people. And they were really clear on that. So again, it's the stories that get amplified and the stories that take hold

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, yeah.

Peter Lewiswithout undermining there was, you know, shootings at Bondi Beach, which were awful. And not to diminish any of that, but Our inability back to Gersha's point to and things just leaves us in this mess. But I'll shut up now.

Damian DamjanovskiNo no, it's mm.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowWell no, I'm I I I I I I don't want you to shut up. I I I I I

Peter LewisMm.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowI I I wonder what is the what is the i if if my end requir if my moral, spiritual and religious end requires me to to recognize Palestinian suffering, to recognize the weight and the and the impact of of of living under occupation, to to recognise the the impact that that that that that that seventy five years of UNRWA maintaining a refugee status for for for a population of people where in every other conflict that has ever occurred in in human history, we have absorbed and integrated the victims of that conflict into in into neighbouring societies and helped those people move forward like so many of our families and however they found their way to this country. If if if if my moral obligation is to meet and do all of those things, which I do every single day, I don't understand how one can't in the very same sentence say when twenty five hundred one thousand two hundred and fifty people were were brutally massacred, that you didn't expect a a sovereign state which had been invaded. to to to to go after those that that that crossed those recognized national boundaries. I'm not talking about the occupied territories. there is a hard line border on ba on Gaza with an elected government, an internationally recognized border, and and and not expect a nation state to to to to to defend itself and secure its citizens.

Peter LewisI I I totally recognise that. then it becomes the means to those ends. And again, the hostages made it incre incredibly embedded. It wasn't just a traditional theatre of war.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowAbs no absolutely. There were there were significant investments in there were significant investments

Damian DamjanovskiHello.

Peter LewisBut you know and and I and sorry, girl.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowin creating a prolonged conflict that would create camps, not just in the land and of the people, but globally, that would move society into our corners and put us as if we're in the boxing ring to to have an arg to have debates and arguments and and and and and and to become accusatorial or or that's the wrong word, but but to to be in active conflict when really what most of us want to do is to say, how do we create a a secure, independent, flourishing Palestinian state where people can live freely and recognize their opportunity and have that live alongside a a Jewish state. what are the ways in which to do that? How we can go back to the UN resolution from nineteen forty seven which sort out that sa that's that same goal and recommit to those things, but we don't seem to be capable of it because now we need to prosecute.

Damian DamjanovskiWho who committed the vigor grievance against who and when and how and

Rabbi Gersh LazarowBecause someone has to be right. Someone has to be right rather

Peter LewisI think it's also it

Damian DamjanovskiSomeone has to be right.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowthan everyone being wrong.

Peter LewisAnd and you know, moving it from Gaza to Iran for a moment, it's also the conduct of war now which we think has become more sophisticated with AI powered technology, but has actually become a much blunter instrument. And I just I think I don't Th the the number of like the the collateral damage of so is it is it a am I arguing with the the strategy or the execution? Like I I think after what happened there was going to be a response and I think it was calculated probably by those who were all like it they they said, Okay, we're gonna blow the whole thing up and see what happens next. But

Damian DamjanovskiI think

Peter Lewisthe going I don't know, like how do you like I How do you sit with the the number of children non combatants that have been killed in the response, Rabbi?

Rabbi Gersh LazarowI struggle with innocents dying in war. I struggle with the fact that thirty-five people died in the U in Ukraine yesterday from a from from a Russian bombardment that the world should have intervened on years ago, but it wasn't in their interest or it wasn't in their in the in their social media feed or it's disappeared out of their social media feed. I I I I I I struggle with the fact that that that there was an entire army buried underground and not one bomb shelter or safe or safe zone above ground in Gaza. War and conflict is there's not there's not a strong enough word to describe how ugly it is and how bad it is and how painful it is. But when you have i individuals and nations and organizations that are committed to war rather than peace, when the price of burying a child is is a price that you're prepared to pay to be right. Then I don't know how we can move forward.

Peter LewisI do know that that accusing people who are moved by the plight of others as being anti s anti-Semitic doesn't help. I think it's the same as calling somebody a racist or a homophobe or whatever, like the labeling. I think has got to start without but I also want to ask you about your experience in the three years since then, because here am I telling you what your experience should be. Because I do not believe

Rabbi Gersh LazarowI well first of all say I I I I will totally agree.

Peter LewisAustralia's become an anti-Semitic society. I just don't accept it, although I think there is amplification of voices that give that impression.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowYeah. I agree with you. I agree with you that Australia has not changed significantly in the last three years. What has changed, which is extraordinarily significant, is that people who have thought what they've always thought now feel that they have a right to say it and to act on it. I believe that these positions remain as marginal as they've ever been, but

Damian DamjanovskiBut now they're emboldened.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowbut they are emboldened and the lived experience.

Peter Lewisthey're amplified by our friends in Silicon Valley as well.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowAnd the and the lived the lived experience of that are things like the attack in Bondi, which I won't put down to mental illness. That was radicalization over a series of years and effective use of of Australia's gun laws to be able to create an opportunity to to to to to have a mass casualty event which was significantly planned and prepared. When we look at events like the bombing of the Das Israel

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowsynagogue, which is just six hundred meters from my home right now. If someone actually knew anything about the politics of that community and where they stood around the the sovereignty of the state of Israel, as as as as as ultra Orthodox Jews, they believed that Jewish sovereignty can't exist without the Messiah. And so they were the worst community. They

Peter LewisMm.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowwere the last community that were deserving of being firebombed, attacked, and destroyed because of the actions of a nation-state on the other side of the world. but yet they were the first attacked because no one's stopping to actually ask questions. So, what is my lived experience? My lived experience is, Peter, this country's probably not more racist than it was, or anti-Semitic than it was 10 or 20 years ago. But when I walk up, On a s wake up on a Saturday morning and take my two dogs for a walk, one of whom's asleep on the couch behind me over my shoulder, with my wife. And we do a lap of our neighborhood before I go off to synagogue. And there is fresh graffiti there every single Saturday morning because people have rolled into our neighborhood on Friday night knowing that we would be walking, not driving, and have put things to make us feel uncomfortable. Unsafe and unwelcome, then I cannot say that this country is not anti-Semitic. Our lived experience, our lived experience, our

Peter LewisOr people i people in this country, your experience of this country, I suppose.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowlived experience is acute and horrific anti-Semitism, which has been emboldened by the environment in which we are in. I will not say that this country has changed. I think radicals and idiots. In this country have been emboldened and empowered. When the people that firebomb a synagogue are the same people that firebomb a a cigarette store because

Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowthey got paid by professional criminals to do that, who got paid by someone in Iran who thought, hey, he has an opportunity. that's stupid meeting malicious. We can debate the accuracy of those facts for as long as you want, but what's undebatable. Is the fact that it makes more people who are born in this country, who live in this country and are deeply proud to be citizens of this country and are committed to its future, not just its present, feel unsafe and unwelcome.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah. And that and that's unacceptable. And it not to change the tone of this, but I'm so curious. You you mentioned Gersh and and Peter, you talked about it as well, this this idea that modern warfare is ugly. And and I'd argue Gersh, it's it's actually uglier now than it's ever been. Like this br new brand of warfare.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowTwo armies going against each other in a paddock seems almost romantic now.

Damian DamjanovskiSo we and and you're absolutely right, because like between what's happening in Iran, what's happening in Israel-Palestine, what's happening in Ukraine, Russia, these conflicts are not just messier on the battlefield, but more importantly, they're messier in the information arena and the information domain, because we as spectators to these conflicts, a large part of us outside of these areas, are To your point, Peter, we're fed it in the algorithm in the way that either reinforces our view or disgusts us or glorifies a position or whatever it is. And so the very nature of warfare is no longer this who's right and who's wrong, but it's just this horrific, never-ending just miasma of shit in every direction.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowAnd there's an entire industry that is dependent on there being continued conflict.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah. You're talking about Google

Rabbi Gersh LazarowContinued conflict, the the bullets.

Damian DamjanovskiGoogle ads.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowWell the g no, but beyond beyond the Google ads. the people that own shares in in in Google also own shares in in in in in in in in in

Peter LewisHm. Well there there's a strong argument the AI industry is really a military industry and they're also an attention industry and the two things create a perfect circle. You get s people so angry they'll tolerate military.

Damian Damjanovskifeel like Peter, you're very quick to blame AI for all these things, which is fine. I'm I'm not I'm not

Peter LewisWell, the business

Rabbi Gersh LazarowBut at what point, at

Peter Lewismodel's undoing it.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowbut Peter, at what point do we take personal responsibility? At what point do we at

Peter LewisWell, all the way along.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowwhat point do we recognize and say, hey, that word came out of my mouth? Now, I can't control what's going to come out of that person's mouth. But if I know if I say something in a tone, they're going to say it back to me in a tone that's a little bit more stronger and perhaps a little bit louder. And then I'm going to respond a little bit stronger and a little bit louder. And then before we know it, we're gonna be screaming at each other. And then at some point, that's that's

Peter LewisThat's what happens when no one's heard, right?

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowgonna that's that's gonna escalate. At what point

Peter LewisMm-hmm.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowdo we recognize the fact that having the debate which you just engaged me in, which you began this conversation in, because it's what's weighing on you so much, which I deeply understand, and say, you know, how do we resolve the immorality of what occurred what occurred in Gaza, the the impact. on that No, no, no, no, no. But the impact that it

Peter Lewisand what like not just Gaza, yeah.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowhad on the innocence. And I'm saying if we keep having that debate, but at forty paces with guns in our hands, as if we're having some sort of duel from the from the from the the the the the the shows I watch on television, We can't move past it. So I take personal responsibility. I am not going to use language which is going to inflame debate. I am going to hold my tongue, not because I think that you are right or I need to prove that you are wrong, but that I understand that there is no benefit. in actually engaging in that debate. What there is is emotional exhaustion. What there

Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowis is us us retreating to camps. There is the opposite of social cohesion. If I hear another person talk to me about the importance of social cohesion, no, social cohesion begins with shutting up. Stop thinking it is your civil libertarian right to say what's in your head. Because that has never been a reality in our society. I'm not telling you to think differently. I'm just telling you to have some modicum of humanity to understand how those words land and the experience that they have on others. Because I am trying

Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowmy best to do that for people who politically and religiously think differently for me. Because I want to move out of the reality which I and my community currently exist. I will fight as loudly As I possibly can against Islamophobia in this country, as I do against anti-Semitism or the configuration of anti-Israel and anti-Semitism, because wow, it's a very fine line. When you firebomb Adas Israel, which doesn't believe that the that the at least theologically it doesn't believe, I'm not speaking for every one of its members, but theologically doesn't believe that there should be a sovereign Jewish state until the Messiah comes, then you actually aren't thinking anymore.

Damian Damjanovskithis stuff is so hard to talk about. Like I don't know for you guys, but I I find it's so hard to talk about because I find half the time I feel for everyone and I also simultaneously feel like it's not my place to have a position on this. Like as a not that it's not my fight, but it's not fair for me to have a position on this other than I want people to be able to move forward. I can't imagine, Gersh, for for your community, the the mix of views and emotions that must exist. And Peter, I know I know like in our political community, there's definitely very strong opinions from different sides

Peter LewisYeah.

Damian Damjanovskion this issue that I mean, I don't think they're all well informed. I think a lot of them are very uninformed from from both sides.

Peter LewisWell, for example, David Shoebridge takes over the Green leadership and he's accused day one from a Labour MP of being anti-Semitic. That doesn't give you a an opportunity to sort of start a conversation. I am interested in your take on how politics in Australia is managing this, Gersh. or the

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowth listen, I think it's complicated. I think that that that the history of of of of of of Jewish Australia and the communities that settled within this country speak to the the deep connection with the the labor movement that the Jewish community has had. the the extraordinary advocacy and and and and and legal work that that the Jewish community did with our indigenous communities. the the the legal team that fought the Marbo case not selected because of their religion, but as a happenstance, happen to be very

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowmuch represented by my mob. and and we look at these examples and I think that what we have here is is in in communities where they have grown up, there are many, many people in my com in my extended community who no longer feel that they have a place. I think you can extend that into the LBG L B G T IQ. Plus community. I I I I think that there are there are I met with someone last week who identifies as a tran as as a trans Jew a and and and in tears saying that their friends who went to went to a protest two weeks earlier, if they were if they were in Gaza, they would be hung or shot, regardless of their concern for the children of Gaza. because they can't differentiate those debates. And what I use these as examples. They're they're extreme, but I use all of these as examples of saying that that those who had found comfort and a reflection of their values in the in the in the progressive community, in the advocacy community, in the people who were doing work with refugees, in the people who were doing work with those people that lived on the margins of our society, find extraordinary discomfort. in the isolation that has occurred over the last three years. If I think about that and then I take it to the to the Jewish creatives.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowand and those that are that are that are that are that are that are not being put on playbills, who are not being allowed into venues, who who who are not being given opportunity for for for art exhibits, because the proprietors simply think that those venues are going to be placarded, are going to be are going to be they're gonna be venues for protests. When I think about the the the amount of philanthropic support that members of our community have given to to to the medical field, to the to the cultural field, to the to the to the to the the arts center here in Melbourne. And to think that people are saying you can't go into that exhibit hall because it was funded by someone who owns a shopping center, who also gave to the United Israel Appeal to help with migration into Israel. I I think that we've become so binary. That we almost have no way forward. So the answer to your question, Peter, is I think everyone in my community has taken wrong language, has been pushed to the right. And so those who were centre right leaning have moved further right.

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowAnd so what I'm hearing for the first time in my community are far right, politically speaking, that's the frame you asked for me, voices who are saying things that that that that that speak like they're coming from the Pauline Hansen playbook, which is not something I've heard in mainstream Jewish community before.

Peter LewisYet they're the ones that give succor to neo Nazis as well. It's wild, isn't it?

Rabbi Gersh LazarowIt it's it's insane. But that's the horseshoe theory of anti-Semitism. W the the death knells of our of our people's belonging in any place is when the far left and the far right push so far to the edges that they find themselves agreeing on how much they hate us.

Damian DamjanovskiGush.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowAnd then and then we move again. And I promise you this country will not be better off if the Jewish population leaves. I've no idea where they're gonna go 'cause not all of us necessarily want to find home in Israel, want to raise our kids in to go to the army. You know, I think about what drew my parents to this country rather than keeping them in South Africa.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter LewisHave you ever heard that story that when they were working out a homeland they looked at the Ord River up in the

Damian DamjanovskiW I

Rabbi Gersh LazarowKimberley's.

Peter Lewisup Yeah.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowYeah. C the

Peter LewisInteresting.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowin in in the British government's wisdom, they put two two plans for the creation of a sovereign Jewish state to the to Chaim Weitzmann, who was the chair of the the Zionist movement. the one was what they called the Kimberley Plan. that would have been very fiscally advantageous.

Damian DamjanovskiJoo, jäämint.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowthe other was was was the Uganda plan. Like there were no indigenous people to Uganda who wanted to realize their own future in their own birthplace and their ancestral lands. it's idiocy. That's colonialism.

Peter LewisI know, and in a way, what we are grappling with is actually a vestige of colonialism. and I I am always really conscious of that. Like Australia is a colonial nation that dispossessed our indigenous people. and no one is saying from the river to the sea in Australia, just get everyone out and give the land back. I I've I have progressive Jewish friends who find who've

Rabbi Gersh Lazarownot true. Th there there there is an elected member of federal parliament who says that.

Peter LewisWho's that? Who says that?

Rabbi Gersh LazarowI believe there's former member of the Greens who who who believes that either repatriation should be made or people all people should be thrown out of this country.

Peter LewisOkay. Lydia, yeah. Yeah, okay. Okay. But but

Damian DamjanovskiPay the rent.

Peter Lewisso so and again, because I'm not in their shoes, so so the it's a ridiculous proposition from the river to the sea, but it has a because it is saying totally illegitimizing something that's happening happened through history and again, maybe maybe we shouldn't maybe we should all just shut up.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowYeah, and and and and and I and I t and I and I taught I taught a class to a s to to a s to a to an adult learner who's learning with me this morning, looking at biblical history. And I explained how how how Gaza and Gaza City were never part of the United Kingdom of Israel. They were never part of the lands settled by by the tribes of Israel. that the f that that that that the f the Philistines were a Mycenaean civilization who who grew in strength during the Trojan Wars and expanded in and the the the conflict that we hear about between David and Goliath and we've seen the movies is is is a is is historically accurate between a a Mycenaean civilization and a nascent Israelite community. Those are the archaeological facts. Those are the that's the historical record. But also, I place no claim on that land. It's not it's never been part of my ancestral land. In nineteen forty-eight, it wasn't part of Israel. Between nineteen forty-eight and nineteen sixty-seven, it was part of Egypt. When Israel made peace with Egypt, it offered Gaza back to the Egyptians or offered as a sovereignty. Neither plan was accepted. The fact is that So much of the situation which is currently ripping our community, our society, our nation, and our world apart. Could have been avoided if people thought more about their children than themselves.

Damian DamjanovskiGersh, I know I I know we're we're we're coming up to time and this has been a very fascinating, if not uncomfortable, conversation. And and I I I encourage that. I think this discomfiting conversations are absolutely critical. I think somehow the United Kingdom gets off scot-free in all these conversations. Every time we talk about China, we avoid bringing up the United Kingdom and what the UK

Peter LewisThe Opian Wars, like freaking wild.

Damian DamjanovskiAbsurd so but people Peter, the amount of times I've told people the reason China is what it is today is because it still feels the shame of what Britain did to it during the Opium Wars. Everything that's happened in India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, including Afghanistan,

Peter LewisIran?

Damian DamjanovskiIran, everything that's happening in the Middle East, the the Balkan Wars, these are all byproducts of British imperialism. And I have yet to see a reparation check from Her Majesty or His Majesty in my lifetime. That's another question.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowJust before you move on, because I can hear you tone switching, for anyone that wants to understand the origin of the conflict which is currently pulling the pe world apart, go watch Lawrence of Arabia all three hours. Because the creation of Saudi Arabia, of of of of the the the the the Kingdom of Jordan, of of of of of of of Lebanon and of of of of Syria, and then of what became the British mandated Palestine, which was divided by the UN resolution two for two to become two states. was all part of the deal breaking that allowed them to to to to defeat the Ottomans.

Peter LewisWhich is really oil going full circle back to why we all should have EVs.

Damian DamjanovskiSo before we end, Gersh.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowExcept some of us like our tires.

Damian DamjanovskiI like tires. I like the set I like

Peter LewisI like changing tires.

Damian Damjanovskithe sound of the engine going, but but Peter, you and I have never gone for a drive together. So we'll have to remedy that. Gersh, I if

Peter LewisNo road trip.

Damian Damjanovskiit's all right, I'd like to end on a a bit more of a positive note, which is one of the things you do amazingly is is bring together community. And I'm always very envious of people who can corral community out of seemingly thin air. I think it's a Incredible superpower. And some people just have that ability to create community. And and Peter, I know you're you you you you're one of these people as well. So that's why I thought you and Gersh would get along really

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskiwell together. Is it's a superpower sadly I do not possess. If if I were in your shoes, Gersh, what would end up happening is I would have a small cult somewhere on the edges of Sydney, we'd all wear caftans and it would just be my my very small cult community. That would be it.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowSorry, I thought you already had that, Reverend.

Peter LewisVaping vaping constant constantly. I still can't get

Damian DamjanovskiSo up.

Peter Lewisout how you could get did they ask you whether you were agnostic when they gave you the reverend? Like did you have to

Damian DamjanovskiThey ask you one question, which is, Do you believe in a higher power outside of yourself? To be

Peter LewisYeah.

Damian Damjanovskifair, the church is based in the Cayman Islands, so I don't think they have a higher register.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowSo so Peter, to be clear, the problem is the problem is the is the term they and it's the essence of everything

Peter LewisMm.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowthat we're talking about because no one here is actually taking personal responsibility, least of all your co host, that that he manipulated

Peter LewisHa ha ha.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowthe situation in order to be to for for for self interest and self benefit

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowand self benefit.

Damian DamjanovskiI did provide pastoral care, to be fair. Which was usually drinks in a hip flask. So, Gersh, my question was really about community and and given everything we've talked about, which is again really heavy, and I know I have a lot of friends who either don't want to wade into this issue or honestly just don't want to talk about it because it feels so loaded. How do we bring people together in that environment in a way where they can have this kind of chat and at the end of it still feel maybe not necessarily good, but still feel like they love each other, that they're they're friends with each other, that they did something that was important and useful. How do we get there?

Rabbi Gersh LazarowI think that, you know, you you were you were in in services with us on Yom Kippur morning. spoke to the my concerns about the binary nature of the world in which we're living and the impact that it's having on our personal well being and our collective well being. And I said, you know, at least here in Victoria, there's actually only one thing that we can all agree on. And that's someone has to fix the fucking potholes.

Damian DamjanovskiHa ha ha ha ha

Peter LewisIt's a thing, isn't it?

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowno, no, it's not a thing. A thing understates it and minimizes it. Okay. It's emblematic of the brokenness in our state. But beyond that place of agreement, and if we can use that as a way of bringing us all together to say, actually, we all agree on something, then the next thing we need to do is actively, intentionally, and repeatedly insert the word and into our language. Not but, you corrected me on that quite beautifully, not but, and that I can believe this, and I can accept your understanding of it as that. And we can move forward together without having to be right or without having someone else to be wrong. That allows each individual, whether they be in the room, whether they identify as part of community, to say that. I have personal responsibility. If I'm going to sit here and wait for someone else to come and apologize for hurting for me before I can move forward, I'm not going to get anywhere. And so my advice to those who listen, but really more importantly, what I demonstrate through the work that I do is invite people to come in, to be honest and authentic about who they are, to accept that the person next to them doesn't see the world through their eyes, doesn't have the same lived experience, but yet we can share an experience together, we can share a moment together, and we can share an aspiration that we want tomorrow to be better than today. And That every single one of us is a little bit broken. Because that that acknowledgement of fallibility and vulnerability allows us to accept the fact that we can all be wrong. And the final piece of rabbinic teaching, often ignored, is Judaism is a faith and a tradition of law, debates, arguments, and ultimately conclusions. But since the second century of the common era, Every time a conclusion was reached rabbinically, both the majority and the minority position was recorded. Because since the second century we have recognised that the world changes and we need to change with it, and our minority position, which today might feel wrong, will be the kernel of what tomorrow what makes tomorrow possible. And and and and if people genuinely understood that Judaism was not at its core a fundamental religion, even though there are no shortage of fundamentalists who are Jewish. Judaism was not at its core a fundamentalist religion, and that was committed to conversation and debate and growth, then I think we have an opportunity to move forward. But that requires us to be wrong, requires us to accept other people can be right, and requires us to listen.

Damian DamjanovskiBeautifully said, Gersh. Thank you very much. and we'll go to Kiss of Death.

Peter LewisFeel like it's a mission statement of this little project.

Damian DamjanovskiIt's it's great. And I think it it it often goes very unnoticed, but the Jewish faith and tradition has a mild obsession with hats that I'm very into. Like depending on what subtype of Jew you are, there is a different type of hat, and I'm all for it because I think religion and sartorialism do need to marry in that kind of glorious way. So no, on a serious note, Gersh, thank you so much.

Peter LewisI love how you I I like I love how you drilled down to the most important part of the whole discussion. Headwear. Thank you, Damien. Yeah.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowYeah, and listen, if if you want to dress like sixteenth century Hungarian nobility, more power to you. Personally, I

Peter LewisHa ha ha.

Damian Damjanovskino I I I like the

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowdon't think the Australian environment is kind of built for that sort of attire.

Damian Damjanovskiit's I honestly Gersh, when I was I had the fortune of of visiting Israel and going to Jerusalem and seeing the the Church of the Sepulchre. So like to me that was quite like as a someone who's been raised Orthodox Christian, like it was quite a beautiful thing to go to the supposed resting place of Jesus

Rabbi Gersh LazarowYeah, no.

Damian DamjanovskiChrist, even though I don't believe it was still important traditionally for me to do that. Very

Rabbi Gersh LazarowIt's a powerful place. It's one of my favorite sites in Israel.

Damian Damjanovskiit's a very powerful place. And you know, I went to the Wailing Wall, I put in my my my piece of paper. But there in 35 degree heat in dry Jerusalem, there are people wearing rabbit fur hats. And I'm like, this is not the climate, guys. Like this is like it ain't cold. It ain't ever getting that cold in this spot here. Like you do not need to worry. But it's all part of the tradition.

Peter LewisGotta suffer for your art though. Yeah.

Damian Damjanovskiso Gersh, we do this thing at the end of each week, which we call the kiss of death, which is basically we make a prediction for the week ahead. We call it kiss of death because we've been wrong so many times about it. We're starting to make predictions we don't want to come true. So you can choose whether it's something you do or don't want to come true. Peter, do you have one or do you want me to kick it off?

Peter LewisYou kick it off. I'm just looking

Damian DamjanovskiYep.

Peter Lewisfor mine.

Damian DamjanovskiSo my I'm gonna hope that my kiss of death week this week does come true, like my last week with a Jack Aranders. So over the following week, we're gonna put out our invitation to people who want to join us for our first live event at the National Press Club in Canberra on the twenty fifth of November. we've got some amazing co-hosts and co-sponsors who will be coming up to the event. We'll be going from six to nine PM. There'll be lots of people, lots of drinks. We'll be there live on stage. Everyone's very welcome. So my kiss of death is we're going to sell out very quickly of tickets to that event. So as soon as you get the invite and you see it in your feed, please RSVP because it's going to sell out super quickly.

Peter LewisI know what my prediction was going to be. So the over sixty-fives private health rebate is meant to be going up into Parliament next week, but I think the government's gonna pull it. This was the idea of pulling back concessions for over sixty-fives on private health because hey, they're the generation with the money. But the coalition won't back it. I don't think the Greens will back it. So the Labour government that's under huge pressure to cut spending as a way of bringing interest rates under control are likely to fall at the first turtle.

Damian Damjanovskiokay.

Peter LewisThat was very material after such a spiritual discussion, I'm sorry.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowAnd I desperately hope I will I'll stay

Damian DamjanovskiAs it is, it is.

Rabbi Gersh Lazarowin the spiritual if you don't mind. And I d I I I pray with all of my heart that Manus actually makes some runs and Australia beats South Africa in the cricket this weekend.

Damian DamjanovskiFantastic.

Peter LewisThat will clearly be divine intervention if Mana scores runs. That's good.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowWell I he is a s he is a man he is a man of belief himself and I I I I hope that belief is affirmed because as a South African migrant to Australia I I I I I support Australian sport. I'm grateful for this country and and

Peter LewisDo you? that's good. We could've done a whole episode

Damian DamjanovskiAs you should if you want to stay here.

Peter Lewison Sandpaper Gate, but Damien would have had any idea what we were talking about.

Damian DamjanovskiI'll forta falling asleep through it. Rabbi Gersh Lazaro, thank you so much for joining us. And again, thank you for a a very deep conversation, but I think a very important one for for us to have on the show. And and f for me personally, and I hope for you as well, Peter. I think it's it was an important conversation to have. and one that I think we could spend hours talking about more and more and exploring every nook and cranny on. But thank you very much, Gersh,

Peter LewisYeah.

Damian Damjanovskifor joining us.

Rabbi Gersh LazarowNot a problem. For those I pissed off, I apologize in advance.

Peter LewisMe too.

Damian DamjanovskiThanks everyone. We'll chat to you next week.

Peter LewisSee you guys.