Episode 28

Ageing, Death, and Bidets

With Sarah Macdonald

17 October 20261 hr 9 min

Show notes

This week we're joined by broadcaster Sarah Macdonald about Club Sandwich, a podcast community for people caught between caring for ageing parents and everything else in life. We discuss ageing, caring, and how the generations look after each other. Sarah shares her years in the sandwich generation and how that led to building Club Sandwich. We delve into the hidden army of family carers, our awkward relationship with death and dying, the strain on aged care and private health, generational fairness, and what we do with the wealth older Australians hold. Along the way we explore how the system could better support the whole family, and the communities, cultural attitudes and conversations that help us age with dignity.

A reminder that tickets are now available for our first live show at the National Press Club in Canberra on Wednesday 25 November, 6 to 9pm.
https://events.humanitix.com/what-s-your-poison-live-show-last-drinks-for-2026

You can find Club Sandwich wherever you get your podcasts.


Chapters

  • 00:00 Introduction and Personal Updates
  • 03:41 Introducing Sarah McDonald
  • 07:35 The Sandwich Generation Explained
  • 15:02 Generational Perspectives on Aging
  • 18:59 Navigating Aging and Death Conversations
  • 24:05 Navigating Death and Communication
  • 27:18 Personal Perspectives on Death
  • 29:04 Aged Care Politics and Challenges
  • 30:55 The Aged Care System's Burden
  • 33:18 Financial Implications of Aged Care
  • 37:43 Intergenerational Issues in Aged Care
  • 40:50 Policy Responses to Aged Care Crisis
  • 48:17 The Sandwich Generation's Struggles
  • 49:39 Cultural Perspectives on Intergenerational Living
  • 52:54 Redefining Community and Housing
  • 54:49 The Challenge of Inheritance and Wealth Distribution
  • 57:39 Societal Attitudes Towards Aging and Caregiving
  • 01:01:46 The Future of Care: Robots and Community Solutions

Full transcript

Read itHide it

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.

Peter LewisWelcome to What's Your Poison, the show where people who disagree on just about everything agree that it's best to do so over a drink. My name's Peter Lewis. I am the chair of the progressive strategy shop Essential. Joining me as he does every week is my evil twin, Dame Domyanovsky from General Strategic, former Morrison strategy guy and man with the man flu. How are you this week? Or I've just I've just done

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter Lewisa spoiler alert, but what is Are you having a poison or a remedy this way?

Damian DamjanovskiI'm gonna say that I'm actually having an old school remedy from Bubba this week. So my poison this week and I and I'm well other than having the man flu and it's a proper flu. I did the the rapid antigen test and it's actual flu so I'm staying clear of everyone.

Peter LewisYeah. And and we know that man flu is the worst flu of all. It's way worse than any other flu. Most people don't realise it.

Damian DamjanovskiSo this is called a Rachovatz. and what it is is a walnut

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskiliqueur, which sounds ridiculous, but it is so delicious. and it's bound to make anyone feel better. So hopefully by the end of the show I'll get be have made a a decent dent into this bottle, but we'll find out very, very shortly. How has your week been and what's your poison?

Peter LewisMy week's a little bit sad in that my cat is in its last 24 hours of life, which feels a little bit on topic for where we're going this week. And Timmy the cat never really loved him. Very transactional, but really Gracious in death, I've got to say. I feel like Timmy is raising rising to the occasion of the last few days, being very good company for about the first time in its 14 years. So I'm toasting Timmy with an Albo Pale Ale from Willie the Boatman, which is some of the best branding. Because if you want to remember what hot elbow looks like, you can get this beer, which listeners will know that I'm not a fan of the Hawk Lager. I think it's really insipid. But Albows, Pale owl isn't bad. I drank a lot of it on election night at the Hurston RSL and it feels like something that's worth coming back to. So cheers. Here's to Timmy.

Damian DamjanovskiWell, he here's to here's to Timmy. Yep. What kind of cat is Timmy if you don't mind me asking?

Peter LewisJust a cat, Gray. I don't know. It was it was just a cat we got for our kid who and it and he all he ever wants is the food and he kills too many animals. He's been like Jack Goff would have hated him as an invasive species, but here he is. It's still seeing someone pass off.

Damian DamjanovskiDoes it does it so would it surprise you to know that I am just not a cat person at all? Like I do not care for cats. No no,

Peter LewisI reckon you could have gone either way. Do you get them?

Damian DamjanovskiI d we we we had both growing up and I just do not care for cats at all. I I find them just utterly nothing as a pet. I would rather have goldfish than a cat.

Peter LewisReally. That's harsh. I just feel they're really manipulative and two-faced and they're just after the food. But I've had some good relationships with cats, but this one wasn't a great one. But anyway, it's still one of God's creatures.

Damian DamjanovskiHere's to Timmy. W Now w we spe speaking of the exit lounge, you you've got an interesting guest that you've brought along this week. Sarah tell us a bit about Sarah and your guest this week.

Peter LewisWell, I was very excited to have Sarah McDonald, ABC, royalty, it talk about the return lounge. She's not departing, she's going back. and then you go Sarah Who, which talk tells us a little bit about the filter bubbles that we all live in. So rather than me bigging Sarah up, like Sarah, introduce yourself to Damien. What do you do for a living?

sarah: Tamian, you don't even know who I am. My God. I'm just, yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiI'm so sorry, Sarah. I d my my A B C viewing is limited to the morning breakfast and Bluey reruns, that's it.

sarah: my God, Bluey, if

Peter LewisIt's just

sarah: I got on Bluey, that'd be like bucket list ticked. Yes, thank you for, as my son said at my birthday recently, Zed grad celebrity, if you listen to the ABC. So, I have been a broadcaster at the ABC on and off for many years, started in the newsroom, then went to Triple J and was their political reporter for a while and then did the morning show there. Yeah, that was interesting.

Peter LewisIn Canberra, that's right. Yeah. What era who was who was in who was in power when you were running around? Wow.

sarah: Keating. Yeah, so I got one of the last interviews with Keating actually before the election campaign.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

sarah: He was not, sorry, before the election on the campaign. And the night before, I know that was the election before I went to a pub where he spoke, but yeah. And then I was there when John Howard came in, basically covered that election night, Mr. Mardi Gras to cover the election and was not happy about that.

Peter LewisThat's right. It was on the same night 'cause I was I

sarah: Mm.

Peter Lewiswas watching that election night on Oxford Street. That was a strange. Yeah.

sarah: Yeah I was in the tally room thinking god damn it. So then I went on to, I lived overseas for a while, wrote a book about India, came back and then went back to the ABC in 2017 and built a weekend nightlife show which went around the country which was really interesting and then did the evening show and the morning show and then I left a couple of years ago and now they've asked me to come back so it's

Peter LewisYou let let's

sarah: a very bizarre thing.

Peter LewisI don't think you so much left as got lefted.

sarah: I got dumped. Yes, I got I got dumped and

Peter LewisHa ha ha.

sarah: now and then they asked me back. So it's been quite a time the last few months thinking about whether I would come back. This started out on on the first of April when Hugh Marks the managing director of the ABC texted me and I was like yeah haha which friend of this of mine is making this funny joke? Haha I was about to text back something rude going yeah yeah and then it really was him.

Peter LewisDo you know I sat next to here marks at primary school? Have I shared y with you that humble brag? Yeah. He was

sarah: Did you? Wow!

Peter Lewisvery un I don't what's the word? prepossessive.

sarah: I'm assuming.

Peter LewisHe was. He was dull. He was pleasant but dull. He was like a Canadian, like he was

sarah: like I was gonna say that.

Damian DamjanovskiWas it Hm. Was was your primary school sorted alphabetically? Did it go Lewis to Marks or?

Peter LewisNo, I think this was it I it was one of those O C classes where you bring kids who ha before

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

sarah: Of course. You were clever.

Peter Lewisthe days of hot housing, but we all ended up in the same room. he was a lovely fella. he wouldn't know me from Adam, but yeah, I sat next to him. anyway, the the the other bit though, Sarah, and congratulations on your return, is that in that interim you've had this really interesting project looking at the experience of people going through life, but with pressures of aging parents and kids on either side. And yeah, it it's a really interesting anchor point for this discussion today. So tell us a bit about Club Sandwich.

sarah: So Club Sandwich started early this year because there's not really, I mean, everyone's got a podcast, right? And I was approached by Melissa Reader,

Peter LewisWait a.

sarah: who worked for Violet, exactly, and then was starting something called Vera when I went on the podcast she was doing, which was called Age Hood. And she said to me, would you come and work in this space with us? Because you're a good representative of the sandwich generation, because I have been in the sandwich generation for 15 years. And caring for my dad and now for my mum. So the Sammage generation are mid-lifers, not all of us are women, but women are doing a huge stack of this, but there's a lot of sons stepping up as well. And they've got aging parents and the first Baby Boomers turned 80 this year. So we are at the beginning of a massive bulge in this. Like this is going to get real in the next. 15 years is the baby boomers age and more of them come into this space. And the number of people aged over 85 in Australia is going to double. It's already over a million. It's going

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

sarah: to double before 2042. So we're a growth club. We let anyone into this club. We have no door bitch, but we do expect that people will need a drink through it.

Damian Damjanovskiyeah.

sarah: and we'll need some representation and some help because we've just done some research on this and a lot of us don't even see ourselves as carers but it is this invisible army which is holding up the entire aged care system.

Peter LewisMm.

Damian DamjanovskiAnd and and so d is it primarily Gen X's who are falling into this category, Sarah?

sarah: Well, that's interesting because in the research we've just done, we were assuming it was mostly Gen Xs, but there's a lot of millennials in here as well. In fact, there's basically the same proportion of people doing it at 35 as doing it at 70. It's sort of 20 % of them. we thought it would,

Damian DamjanovskiWell, okay.

sarah: yeah, we actually thought it would be more older women. and older blokes in Gen X, but there's a lot of millennials. So it depends on obviously how old your parents were when they had you, what their healthcare is like, where the needs are and where they start relying on you more and more for help. But it's interesting, it's younger than you think.

Peter LewisIt's also people having kids older as well, which stretches it out. How old

sarah: Yeah, that's right.

Peter Lewisare your parents, Darby?

Damian Damjanovskimy parents are nineteen fifty six and nineteen fifty eight, so the maths on that would be seventy and sixty eight.

sarah: they're young.

Damian Damjanovskibut the you know, the the Yugoslavia you you y you had kids young, right? So I was I'm

sarah: Hmm.

Damian Damjanovskithe middle child, so my my older brother's five years older, my younger brother's five years younger. so my older brother's an ex, I'm a mid to early millennial, 'cause I'm a nineteen eighty four. And then my younger brother's nineteen ninety, so he's like a late millennial, I guess.

Peter LewisMm.

Damian DamjanovskiSo and and Peter, you're you're a you're a Gen Xer, you're a squarely a Gen Xer, right?

Peter LewisI'm an early Gen Xer, so I'm yeah, like it I love in I love generational politics because it's the only area where I'm a minority group and I can actually experience

sarah: Yes.

Peter Lewismy my full selfhood.

Damian DamjanovskiHa ha.

Peter LewisBut I was born I I shouldn't be an ex. I so so the actual definition of generation X is when the pill came online in a different because that was where

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter Lewisthe the birth numbers dropped off. But I'm also an adoptee. So I'm I another couple of years and I probably wouldn't have been here. So I was sixty-six, and my parents were not boomers. They were war generation, whatever they call that. They were they were born in the the sort of the thirties. So the no, no,

Damian DamjanovskiThe great generation. The greatest generation.

Peter Lewisthe great generation were the ones that were

sarah: Now they're older.

Peter Lewiswere actual fighting and part of the war effort.

sarah: Hmm.

Peter LewisAnd then there was this other generation who are the parents that there's these guys,

Damian DamjanovskiUh-huh.

Peter LewisI forget their names, who've done this

sarah: think they're the silent generation.

Peter LewisThe silent, thank you. But they're also a hoarding generation. They just, they

Damian DamjanovskiSilent, that's it. Silent generation, yeah. Yeah.

sarah: Yeah.

Peter Lewisjust collect stuff because they knew they grew up with with with with And

sarah: with scarcity. Yeah.

Peter LewisI think what you're doing is so interesting, Sarah. Like, and I'm not a beneficiary of it. I lost both my parents a decade ago in in quick succession and did it really, really badly and had no idea what was doing and got caught in because cause there are so many different bits. There's the health bit, there's the housing bit, there's the financial bit. And they're all really complicated. And I remember when I was going through it, just thinking, gee, I wish someone could guide me because it's like there's this really mature system. And everyone in the system knows how the system works, but you hit it as an outsider. And you know, I got a law degree. I I had no idea what I was how how the whole thing worked. And you know, the difference between retirement

sarah: It's, yeah, yeah, it's insane.

Peter Lewisvillages and nursing homes and Aged care plans, it y like tell us a bit about how that navigation piece is working for you and how you're trying to turn that into something that people wanna be part of.

sarah: It's really, it's so complicated. mean, you mentioned the economic, the financial, but behind all that is the administrative. And that is the stuff that probably

Peter LewisNo.

sarah: does your head in the most. It's almost like being gaslit on a massive scale because yeah, I have an honours degree and I cannot do it. I mean, I'm not a good admin person anyway. I'm, I'm, I'm, must say,

Peter LewisYou're a Journo.

sarah: I'm, I'm just terrible at it. So having to do my mother's administration as well, I just sometimes, that's the thing that reduces me probably to tears, tears of frustration the most because it's a bloody nightmare. And if you see a middle-aged person or a gen Y crying at Centrelink, just be nice to them because it might not even be about their own stuff. It might be about their parents' stuff. It's really complicated.

Damian DamjanovskiSo Sarah, can I ask, why is it why have you why is it named the Sandwich Generation? What's the origin of that name?

sarah: because you're being squished, right? So you're being squished between caring for your parents and caring for your kids.

Peter LewisHe'd never grow up.

sarah: who never, who in this, well, but can I, I'll say something about kids in a moment because I actually count people who don't have kids now, but a lot of Samish generation have kids still at home. And as Pete said, we've had kids later, so they might still be. still at school when you're going through this depending on when your parents need the most help or like me it's stretched over a long time from my kids were really young to now they're older but still live at home because they're in their 20s and they can't afford to move out in their very early 20s. But I also think that people are in the same generation if they don't have kids because they have other layers of responsibility and work. And so when my mum was in the sandwich generation looking after, she had four kids at home and my grandmother lived with us, which was how my parents afforded our house. My grandmother pitched in and lived in a section of the house and that's how they could afford it. But when my mum was caring for her and still had kids at home, she wasn't working full time. Whereas now, everyone in the sandwich generation, pretty much everyone is working full time. It is very rare. Of course there's some, but it's very rare for people not to be working full time. So I think the pressure has got greater in the work department than

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

sarah: the kid department. And I know a lot of people in the sandwich generation who are managing many layers of life and feel left out when people talk about the sandwich generation because they don't have kids, but they're in it.

Damian DamjanovskiI I'm I'm just gonna for any of our listeners do a bit of a trigger warning that I think today's episode we we are gonna talk about deaf a fair bit. So if you find those conversations

sarah: Are we?

Damian Damjanovskihard to listen to, this mo the yeah, this might not be the episode for

Peter LewisWe've already spoken about Timmy, like so.

Damian Damjanovskiyou, but before we get into that, Peter, what do you think the defining like characteristics are of your generation, Gen X? Like what what would you consider the def like the the

Peter Lewisinteresting.

Damian DamjanovskiYou know, the the stereotype. What wh what is it? What makes Gen X Gen X?

Peter LewisWell, Gen what makes Gen X Gen X Gen X is that it was a minorit it was a smaller generation than the precursor. So there was the baby boom after the war. All this infrastructure was built for the demographic ma demographic mass that were young people coming through. Schools were built, culture was created, and Gen X was kind of just there in the shadows and we just sort of fitted into the schools that were built and we fit it into culture that would like the c w we we were we had that culture imposed on us. We were halfway between the internet. So we were the we were the net migrants. So the next generation sort of grew up with the internet being part of their life. So that's the other side. And also, you know, millennials are just the most they're they're the children of the baby members. So they're entitled and painful as we know. So which is your generation,

Damian DamjanovskiHm.

Peter LewisDame. But I I I think it's just a

sarah: We invented grunge. We invented grunge. We're the cynical generation, right? Like grunge, nirvana,

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter LewisIt was cynical disengaged, the Douglas Copeland stuff.

sarah: yeah, that kind of stuff. we also had a free range childhood that we were just sort of left around devices was the parenting. Yeah, we weren't as sort of

Peter LewisYeah. So this

sarah: hot housed as the boomers were with their kids. But we kind of, I think some Generation X's resented the boomers opportunities that they felt they had. Like a lot of younger people may resent that for us. Fair enough.

Peter LewisWell there was that fantastic Mark Davis book, Gangland, which was like the the generational book of baby boomers just holding all the space and not

sarah: Yeah.

Peter Lewisbecause they created

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Peter Lewisit. and it's so good to be in a minority group and just feel aggrieved. Like I love talking about this stuff.

sarah: You just want to be in a minority because you're not on any other level.

Damian DamjanovskiIt appe it appeals to your to your leftist instincts to be like, well this as a cisgendered white male like

Peter LewisNothing. absolutely. I'm no longer being an ally. The only things that I've ever had lived experiences as a Swans fan and is Gen X now. The other fun fact is.

Damian DamjanovskiWell c can I let you know that I'm a I'm a Gen X ally, just letting you know. So I'm here to support you.

sarah: the

Peter Lewisgood. but the other the last thing I say about Gen X is that fun fact, so Billy Idol named his first band Gen X, and that kind of was the inspiration for Douglas Copeland to coin the term, but it was based on a book on his mother's shelf that was actually about baby boomers. So even Gen X is is a steal from Baby Boom. So that there you go.

Damian DamjanovskiNot one original thought amongst all of you. No, that's good to hear. it's funny 'cause when I think Of course I know who Billy Idol is.

sarah: Hang on, just don't even know who Billy Idle Even is. Okay, right.

Damian DamjanovskiI because I when I think Gen X, I think the MTV generation where their future was so bright and optimistic, and then it kind of fizzled. That's that's the that's

Peter LewisNo, it was

Damian Damjanovskithe mental image I have. The the roaring eighties

Peter LewisMm-hmm.

Damian Damjanovskithe kind of early nineties of anything is possible and then this kind of like fizzle that happens.

Peter LewisNah. It was McJobs. Like the whole shtick of Gen X was McJobs. Like that we that the boomers had taken everything and we just got left with the shit. And that's part of the theory of why we went longer until we had kids, which is why we're in this bloody sandwich now, I guess.

Damian DamjanovskiSo Sarah, Sandwich, what what's the what's the go here? What's the what are the issues? Do we j do we just have too many old people?

sarah: What are the issues? Well, where do you? No. We've got a good problem. Long-term, it's a good problem

Peter LewisThat's we're gonna get we're gonna get there, but yeah.

sarah: to have. No, it is a good

Damian DamjanovskiIs it?

sarah: problem to have. Yes, we're living longer and you know, people want to live longer and they are living longer and that's what modern medicine has

Damian DamjanovskiPeople think they want to live longer.

sarah: given us longer. Well, it's an interesting topic actually and it is one that lot of people talk about. But what I have noticed in this is everybody says I don't want to live really long. I'm not going to go into a nursing home. That's never going to happen to me. But when people get there, there is this real urge to cling to life and life is everything. And they... We normalise it, right? And the human brain finds it very difficult to imagine us in the future. So we don't know what sort of person we're going to be then. And we can't pre-plan for it. And that's why it's getting really messy, because one in four sandwich generation have no idea and no plan to how to help their parents as their needs increase.

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskithat's I I I wanna ask you something, Peter, 'cause it yeah, actually this is a super fascinating topic to me, as you can imagine. I I actually love talking about this, Sarah, so I'm so excited about today's chat. Peter, what's do you have a good relationship with death?

Peter LewisIt's a really good question. So and I was thinking we would land here, but let's go here now. I think part of the whole issue with so much public policy is that people don't want to talk about death. I was talking to my GP today. He was saying that I had my checkup at 60, looking good, dropped some weight. hi Greg. But he's he got me he he he said 50% of our health budget is spent on people keeping people alive for the last 12 Months of their life. And I do feel that our inability to deal with the fact that we are mortal souls and that we have lost a sense of faith or a sense of anything bigger than the material makes it so much harder. So, of course, if people don't think they're going anywhere. They're holding on. Now, I turned 60 recently. I'm really looking at the next 20 years as my fourth quarter. Like I don't really want to go long. And like Sarah, I don't want to die in a hospital. I don't want to die in nappies. That might change. But people don't have those and and because they don't have that, there's a whole lot of decisions that are made all the way down from government to families to health. Like, you know, that whole thing that doctors, are all superheroes. So they're even really bad at having death conversations with their patients. And you know that Greg was

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Peter Lewissaying like people pump pump patients up with chemo even though they know how the story's gonna end. So I think it's almost like you y they say you get the government you deserve. We're kind of getting the society that we've decided we deserve as well. And it and like of course you don't want I I was devastated when my parents died, of course. But this idea that everyone's gonna live to e forever is just it it it it bases all this public policy on a fiction.

Damian DamjanovskiAnd so you're I I agree with you on all that like your relationship, are you are you comfortable with your own mortality?

Peter LewisSo I'm absolutely I don't want who wants me hanging around past their use by date? Like and like I I don't know. Like what about you, Sarah? You wanna go along?

sarah: I have times where I think I am and then I have times where I feel really scared. So I'll be, yeah, I like to think I am and I've done kind of meditations on dying and all of that sort of stuff, which is part of Buddhist teachings. But then you kind of go, but. I'm not finished yet. And I think a lot of people in their 80s and 90s have that same feeling as we do. I don't think inside there's that much difference to us. I think people cling to life a

Peter LewisMm.

sarah: lot more than we think. And I think, Pete, you may say you don't want to stick around forever, but it'll be really interesting to see what you do when you do get older, if you're lucky enough to do that, right? But yeah, you write about, I mean, I've talked to people

Peter LewisYeah. One of my dad's gone.

sarah: about the hospitals and stuff and it is pretty messy because there is a yeah, yes, yes.

Peter LewisThe machines that go beep that keep eighty five year olds alive for an extra couple of years.

sarah: And there's a lot of intervention being done that some in the family will question. I mean, I can talk to you about some stuff that the doctors have said to me about this and about coming up with advanced care directives and all of that sort of stuff. Because I've learnt a lot about that over the, because we're going to death pretty quickly in this conversation. But yeah, it gets very messy and you need to think about it ahead of time. You really do and you need to talk to your family about it and you need to get everyone

Peter LewisYeah.

sarah: on the same page in the family or it gets a nightmare and they will just keep intervening.

Peter LewisMy mum had the worst death because she didn't communicate with us, the children, on where she was up to and then she didn't get an advanced care plan. She bloody she died of metastasized breast cancer on Panadol Forte because they

Damian DamjanovskiOof oof.

Peter Lewisbecause the system was not user facing. Like it was horrible. But yeah, I feel like I'm bringing it

sarah: I'm sorry.

Peter Lewisinto this. No, it's fine, cause it but if I had my time over again, you would have had Club Sandwich running and people would have been more engaged about the way the system works. But Damien, go

sarah: Well, we I mean, look, we don't talk about death all in the podcast. There's so many

Peter LewisStop.

sarah: layers of things we talk about, but death is one of them. And I have interviewed some really fabulous people in this area who are there is really interesting work going on. It is getting better, but

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

sarah: it's all about.

Peter LewisHave you spoken to any duelers, like death duelers? I'm really interested in the

sarah: Death,

Damian DamjanovskiDefdul is

sarah: yeah, I haven't spoken to one on the podcast yet, but I plan to, but I did an event with this fantastic doctor who has abandoned medicine to work in this space about death, because she just said they were so bad at being at death that she's the first time she had to tell someone that her husband had died, this woman just punched her in the face because she just didn't know how to articulate,

Peter LewisMm.

Damian DamjanovskiProcess that

sarah: tell her this worst news that.

Damian DamjanovskiWow.

sarah: she could possibly tell her. And she just has done such fabulous work in the conversations you need to have and how you have these conversations with elderly people or with your parents or with your spouse or anyone around if this is something you really think about. And it is really difficult to approach it, right? But it's really important and I'm lucky in my family because my dad was a doctor. And we were all so clear what he wanted, but it was still bloody messy towards the end. And my mum has an advanced care directive, but I'm not 100 % sure it won't be messy. And there is a deep level of trauma amongst the sandwich generation, often for when their parents do die and they have to kind of have these terrible conversations in hospital corridors. And then there's all this sort of weird

Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.

sarah: stuff that happens, like just on a little family level, for instance, and doctors will tell you this, that... There'll be one, usually the sandwich generation carer, there's one person in the family, usually the one that lives geographically closer, who does all of the care and the help and the assistance and knows the parent and what they want. And they'll be in the hospital saying, yeah, look, I think mum will be done now and she doesn't want any more intervention. And they call them the brother from... America or the you know the cousin from LA that flies in and says no no no we have to do everything we can and I have heard terrible stories of people

Peter LewisSo crawl.

sarah: being in comas for years and

Peter Lewisman.

sarah: yeah kept alive after massive strokes and things and and it's the death duel of work is brilliant and and but they say a lot of families just can't deal with it because as you said we're just crap at dealing with this and they just go I can't deal with this I'm leaving.

Peter LewisI feel like you've got a fairly healthy attitude to death, Dame.

Damian DamjanovskiI look, I'd like to think so. I I I never used to actually, much like Sarah, I I used to have a lot of fear of death. and then in my early thirties just went through some stuff that kind of helped me develop a much more comfortable relationship with it. To I think now the point of having a very open relationship with death.

Peter LewisYeah.

Damian Damjanovskiwhere, you know, my my my partner and family know my clear intentions. I've I've spent the last ten years growing the Port Jackson fig which sits right here in my living room, with which I am to be my remains to be cremated and and fused with the Port Jackson fig and planted wherever the fuck you want, or, you know, not planted anywhere. It's really I don't care at that point, I'm dead. but no, I like to think I have a pretty healthier than most relationship with it in that I've no no

Peter LewisC

Damian Damjanovskiintention to be kept alive on machinery and and my partner knows that if I'm incapacitated in any way to give me the tontines send off.

Peter LewisYeah, nice. You do the voluntary assisted dying if you got the if if if the universe is aligned.

Damian Damjanovskino no, I'd insist that my partner smothers me with her own hands as I stare into her eyes. It's much more dramatic.

Peter LewisThat's so romantic, Jills. Beautiful. Hey, can I

sarah: That's love.

Peter Lewiscan I go from the the the celestial back to base politics? I'm interested, which has been we've got this whole show a bit arse end up, but anyway, that's fine. Like, so you ran You were working strategy for a prime minister who had to deal with a Royal Commission into Aged Care when everything came out. I'm interested, Dame, how you guys looked at the whole issue from the center of power and then we might talk about some of the the the policy debates that have even been playing out in the last week in Canberra because

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter Lewisit's such a big part of the budget that it forces you as you know, that it forces your attention, doesn't it?

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, and look, the the kind of broad stroke Cliff notes here is that aged care is one of those footballs that neither the states nor the Commonwealth ever really wanted to handle, right? So Aged Care is is the poorer cousin to both Medicare and now the NDIS where it's an enormous cost to the taxpayer. none of us really want to think about it and none of us really wanna pay for it. So whether it's something that the states should administer, but the Commonwealth pays for, or the states should pay for, and how it hap like this has been a an area of contention contention for many for a very long time. and I'm not sure when, but it was it was decided that this should be a essentially a federal responsibility to to do age care. and it is still a bit yeah it it's

Peter LewisI think it was under Howard. Like I think you might know more, Sarah, but I feel like it was run by charities and then Howard sort of turned it into a marketplace.

sarah: Yes, I think it was the beginning of the change towards more of the, well, privatisation or whatever you call

Damian DamjanovskiCompli.

sarah: it was under John Brown.

Damian DamjanovskiAnd and a and a big reason for that is obviously there there are a lot of people you know, dying in

Peter LewisLiving longer.

Damian Damjanovskiaged care centres and a and a lot more people living for a lot longer than we ever expected, right? The system was not designed for people to live this long and was never redesigned for it.

sarah: Hang on, we did know. Well, except we knew the baby boomers were coming, right? Like we've, you know, we've known this for a long time, for 80 years they were coming. I agree that we didn't know people would live for this long. We always knew there was going to be a period of aged care and people needing aged care and people being old. Because now I think in the old days people would go into aged care at 70. or maybe 80 and now they're going at 90 right towards the end of their life. And their needs are much more intense than they were,

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

sarah: but we still needed it. We knew the boomers were coming. Why did we? It was just like, we

Damian DamjanovskiBut to to

sarah: don't want to deal with it.

Damian Damjanovskiwell, correct me if I'm I mean, I I agree with you, Sarah, but I I think us as a public and governments knowing that a problem is coming is not an incentive to fix it and never has been, right? Like we we don't fix problems that we can see over the

sarah: Yeah.

Damian Damjanovskihorizon we because it's easy to ignore. But my understanding is that aged the the amount of time that people would be in aged care facilities has increased dramatically as well. And the cost of taking care of people in aged care has increased dramatically as well. And simultaneous to that we've developed an entire NDIS system, which means the available workforce we have for those things has actually decreased. So the the numbers are not on the side of aged care. and I think we are to your point earlier, Sarah, we're at the very tip of the iceberg of the problems we're gonna see. with aged care, where at some point over the next decade or so there's gonna be some big questions of who's gonna do the job, who's gonna pay for these people, you know, what how are we going to adjust to life where we now have, you know, a an enormous cohort of people with dementia, with chronic issues, with mobility issues in aged care facilities where there's not enough spaces to even house them in some instances.

Peter LewisAnd then you've got the other complication, because it's so expensive, you try to keep people at home for longer, but there is capacity constraint on home care. And that has a whole flow on effect on property as well. Like it's it's all like how do you look at it, Sarah? Like how would if you were, you know, Queen of Australia, how would what would how would you think about this system? And I'm not ruling it out just quietly, but or precedent at least.

sarah: Yeah, if I was Queen, I'd just look fabulous and I wouldn't overstep my powers.

Peter LewisYou'd keep your sons under check though, wouldn't you? You would teet

sarah: But yeah, I mean, look, it is, I understand what you're saying there, Dame, it is getting more difficult. The needs are much higher, but the cost of keeping people out of aged care, it's sort of that, it's like a preventative medicine. It is much cheaper to help people at home, say about 30 grand a year, whereas if they're in aged care, it's about 150 grand a year. This is the former commissioner. really stated this very clearly. So we sort of need to front end load the system a little bit more. But you're right, the people that no one goes into aged care willingly, they often go because what's happening now is they can't get the help they need at home. So they might end up in aged care because they're waiting so long on the waiting list because we've got this bulge of population.

Peter LewisBut isn't the stat also that the average stay in aged care is eighteen months? So the

sarah: Yeah.

Peter Lewisstep in is like, you've got to admit, back to our earlier discussion, clocks ticking, like, and that's a really hard conversation.

sarah: Yeah, that's right. You've got to be assessed. You've got to be, you know, in enough of a decline and high enough needs to be assessed to be needing aged care. But the problem is we're not building enough aged care centres. The number of beds we need compared to how many we're building is just radically different. But it's interesting because in my area, there's like four new sections, areas going up. Like this is a growth industry. So people must be making money out of this because in the five kilometres near me, there's four new aged care places being built. But it's just not going to be enough.

Damian DamjanovskiTh the and you know th and look to your point, Sarah, I think, you government's been cutting funding for things like meals on wheels and all these other services that used to exist to keep you in your home for longer.

sarah: Yeah.

Damian Damjanovskifunding has been kind of decreasing for these services for years on years. There there was a I'm gonna say it was an episode of Boston Legal or something, where they posited the idea that old people would start committing crimes to be basically sentenced into prisons 'cause they weren't able to get into aged care facilities. So watch this space, this might be this might be an Australian future we used to

Peter LewisAre you doing some work on for the Liberal Party on their aged care policy here, Damian? That's good. Can I

Damian DamjanovskiHa ha ha.

Peter Lewisbut the other the other thing?

sarah: I'm just seeing someone escape on one those motorised scooters out of her bank.

Damian DamjanovskiA little motorised scooter, well. If you can't get a spot and you can't wait for the waiting list, well

Peter LewisThe the other bit on this, so Howard it's it's interesting. We've got three care sectors in Australia. We've got NDIS that is basically a voucher system, you get past a threshold, you get them out. There you had the early learning system that was really linked into local councils, preschools and everything, with some not-for-profits coming in. And then aged care was private, and there's that that there's there's a two models. So retirement villages that are basically Property developer Ponzi schemes. And then you've got the aged care, which is now very much determined by the bond. So a lot of their business model is you raise like the the the ones that are sort of for people that have got some money behind them at least. You've got to put a bond in behind it, and then they make money off the interest, I think, off the bond, isn't it, Sarah? So is that the right?

sarah: But I think they're getting rid of the bond. They're getting rid of the bond under the reforms.

Peter LewisAre they? Or are they limiting

sarah: That's what I thought.

Peter Lewisthe Because the idea I I I personally didn't have a problem with the bond because I felt if you could afford it like 'cause

sarah: Mm. Mm.

Peter LewisI'm not an inheritance guy, we can get into that in a minute. Cause I think

sarah: God.

Peter Lewison that damn I a unity ticket. But the idea that you put the money in, they make money off the interest, and then you the family gets the money back at the end. Like that seemed reasonable for me rather than taxpayers funding for all of it 'cause it's just not a

sarah: Yeah, yeah, I mean, look, I actually agree with that, too. I do agree with that. think and I

Peter LewisIt's a bit like Hicks.

sarah: think for and it's not all government. Like

Peter LewisOkay.

sarah: people have got a big factor in this, like individual families and people, because we get back to that denial thing. If we're thinking this is never going to happen or if people are trying now, what's happening is people are trying to not spend their super. right, so they can keep it for their kids for inheritance and the family home and

Damian DamjanovskiNah.

sarah: all that sort of stuff. And I'm like, no, no, no, your super is there. You've earned that money. Like spend that if you need that money in aged care. But then you're kind of also getting into all this stuff of pressure on families and elder abuse and things, because you've got to be very careful about what's going on with people's money. And it goes

Peter LewisHm.

sarah: to this sort of intimate, we're going back to the generational thing. of the intergenerational problems because as the baby boomers move through and now we've got different populations coming through in the future, there's not going to be enough taxpayers to pay for the older people. So you're going to want to build up your super.

Peter LewisParticularly if we cut the immigrants.

Damian DamjanovskiToo many old people.

sarah: Yeah, well, if we cut the

Peter LewisCh

sarah: immigrants, then who's going to work in the aged care centres? Because I've got to tell you where my mum

Damian DamjanovskiWell look it's

sarah: is, they are all from Nepal and Malaysia and

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

sarah: the Philippines and they're divine.

Peter LewisJust just as an aside,

Damian DamjanovskiThen then

Peter Lewisdid you see the AHA ad this week, which we which we

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, yeah, it was great. It was great. And they're they're but they're

Peter Lewisit's it's a toilet paper is the gag. It's like, can you do something for me? Wipe my bum, because there's no longer anyone here to do it.

Damian DamjanovskiAnd and can

sarah: I saw that

Damian Damjanovskican I can I say something on that, Peter, as a as a ethnic man who came here in the late eighties, early nineties, the fact that the son would look at the mother and like scoff at the idea of wiping his mother's ass, how dare he? If your mother

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskiasks you for whatever reason to wipe her ass, you say yes, that's it. There is no questions asked at that point. You wipe

Peter LewisYou're a you're a good boy.

Damian Damjanovskithat ass and you wipe it proudly. Like I was like I loved that ad. I thought it was actually very clever. But that point I was like, man, that is such

Peter LewisLost me.

Damian Damjanovskia typical attitude to be like, no, I'm not not wiping her ass. Like, mate, she wiped your ass for quite a few years, I think you'll find. You will say, Yes, ma'am. What else do you need? Can I cook you a meal?

Peter LewisI told I told you we'd tackle the big issues today, Sarah. sorry Damien. C so

sarah: We've had this conversation in my family, my mum's like, you're never to wipe my ass. So another one you could have in your family, like, would

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter LewisYeah.

sarah: you like your ass wiped or not? There is many details you can go into in terms of care down the track.

Peter Lewiscan we go back to the politics? So a couple of things happened this week, and I'm interested in both your thoughts on what they're saying. The first was Labour was trying to put a limit on the over 55s currently get support to stay on private health insurance, which is a benefit that under 55s don't get. and they wanted to wind that back and they've been sort of hit from both the libs and the grains. This is this was actually my prediction of the week, I will just

Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.

Peter Lewissay my kiss of death wasn't fatal. So that's been going on. So that that's topic one. Topic two is the aged care reforms, which is putting more of the incidental if they're not incidental, like access to TV and drinks and so sort of things I think, in in that that that aged care providers can charge the family. So there's kind of a user pay model there and then there's a winding back of the taxpayer subsidies. They're both kind of now in an environment where there is obvious pressure on budget spending that is flowing aro along in inflation, which is a tax on everyone, firstly Damien, what's your thoughts of of those two bits of policy and, you know, particularly the way the coalition's responding to it.

Damian DamjanovskiLook, I think the coalition responded exactly as you would expect the coalition to respond. and I d I don't think that surprises anyone. Whether or not it's the right response, I I'm honestly not sure because I understand the argument that and and I I can actually be very easily persuaded into the argument that if you have if you reach a certain age threshold where basically you are a larger burden to the system then y y you should pay more. That's kinda how insurances work. However, government has created this horrible perverse incentive with private health care where you know we we reduce your Medicare levy if you buy private health care, but then the government sets the costings of the private health care, which means private healthcare providers and private hospitals can't actually make reasonable amounts of money or or set their own prices or or do you know graded systems based on age or all this other stuff. So th the whole system's been cooked over years and years of governments trying to basically make sure Medicare doesn't become this huge cost. and in the process we've ended up with this horrible private healthcare system where if you're young, you're basically buying it to avoid paying tax and then by the time you're old and actually need it, you're now getting slugged with extra fees. Neither of those two things are fair. And I would argue that the that what we're seeing happening is actually a symptom of the way we charge for private health care is fundamentally broken. And we should rethink if we are gonna stick to a hybrid system, we should kinda rethink how we do it because

Peter LewisSo what would you do?

Damian DamjanovskiI don't know that I have a good answer here, but I I think that the government I think that reducing your s like basically reducing your Medicare surcharge if you have private healthcare is a is a perverse incentive. So I don't think that's a good idea. And then having government setting the private healthcare rebate rates doesn't allow a free market to actually occur with private healthcare. Because in a in a free market, if private healthcare was way too expensive, you you wouldn't get it, right? And you would just stick to Medicare, assuming that you didn't have to pay a surcharge. And that would force private healthcare's companies to look at their model and go, hang on, do we need to find either a more effective way to deliver these healthcare measures? Or is this a product that we can sustainably do? And if we can't, then we have to do something else, right? So it's a that's what I'm saying, it's a perverted system at the moment where n nobody wins and I don't think we can keep that up for much longer as as we've got a huge part of the population aging.

Peter LewisWhat are your reckons, sir?

sarah: Yeah, I mean, look, I've tried to understand the kind of whole health care system on many levels at many times in my life, and I find it really difficult. But on the surface, I think this is going to mean a lot of older people will give up their private health insurance. And after spending so much money for so many years, because you get it, it costs a lot and you think, what the hell do I get for it? And as you said, the 50 % of your Medicare goes in that final year of life. Can that be alleviated with private health care? Probably. So I think that is the issue with the policy. But I think as Damien, I mean, I agree with you. It's just the whole system is just not working anymore. And it's a bloody mess.

Peter LewisAnd then you've got the other c complications like the bed block that's caused by people who should be in aged care being in hospital beds. You've got the specialist

sarah: Yeah, that's right. Yeah. Yeah.

Peter Lewisfees that are just like I know butler's

sarah: in science.

Peter Lewisgoing after that, but that's insane.

sarah: Yeah, but the bed block thing, I mean, it's difficult and it's an awful word to use because you think about when you say the word bed block, I know it's

Peter LewisYeah, fair.

sarah: it's terrible. Like every person that's a bed block is this older person lying in a hospital bed because maybe because they couldn't

Peter LewisBecause no one else will

sarah: get help in the home. And so then they fell over and then they hadn't had discussions in their family or they might not have anyone in their family who can look after them. And They don't want to be in hospital and people are likely being in hospitals for up to a year waiting for an aged care bed. Like up to a year.

Damian DamjanovskiJesus. Yeah. And they're they're not there by choice.

sarah: No, no, they're not

Damian DamjanovskiI think

sarah: there by choice at all. It's just awful.

Damian DamjanovskiAnd this this is gonna be a horribly unpopular thing to say, and and I'm happy for you guys to debate it. But I actually think part of the issue with this is in Australia we make our GP the gatekeeper for a lot of health services, and we end up causing both a lot of expenditure, a lot of cost, by making everyone have to go through the GP for a variety of services. And then simultaneously we've got a lot of our medical professionals caught being GPs because that often ends up being the the the best job to do because it's a best kind of balance between you know the income you can earn and the the hours you can work and the and the lifestyle you can choose. and it's this weird

Peter LewisDo you think that's the choice for a GP? I don't know, 'cause that's the least it's the le I what was your d

sarah: I don't know about that. GP I know

Damian DamjanovskiFor a lot of them it is.

sarah: is struggling like hell to make a living and really worried that there's

Peter LewisIt's the special

sarah: a shortage and there's going to be no more coming through.

Peter LewisThe ones that are making the money are the ones that are doing a colonoscopy every five minutes. Now I wouldn't do that for all the money they're paid, but that's that's how you make the big dough, yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, of course, but if you've got more GPs freed up because if people don't have to go to a GP, for example, to go get a blood test, right? The most basic of things where there there's literally in this country there's no reason you should have to go to a GP to get a blood test. So you imagine that either you're paying via the Commonwealth or out of pocket plus the Commonwealth, you're paying anywhere between ninety bucks to a hundred and sixty bucks to get someone to say, Yes,

Peter LewisMm.

Damian Damjanovskiyou can go and get a blood test. Like

Peter LewisHm.

Damian Damjanovskilike a and what is the purpose of that? What what is like you because you still have to go back to the GP. You have to go back to the GP to get your results. So you have to go twice, once to get the test, then to the pathology,

Peter LewisThere are a lot of interesting D marks. Like one of the things I've Yeah. I have Yeah.

Damian Damjanovskithen back to a GP. That makes no sense whatsoever because we know 70% of all GP visits end up in a pathology test. Why do I have to go there first? That is 70% of the GP visits that's being soaked up in our medical system because we because the RAC GP insists no no no, the GP Knows better than everyone else.

Peter LewisIs that seventy percent you've pulled out of your ass or a an estimation?

Damian DamjanovskiIt's over fifty. It's i it is i according to the pathology people, but it's high.

sarah: 50.

Peter LewisBut I do think there is there is a point here, and I I know there's been a lot of discussion about n getting more skills out of nurses, getting more skills out of pharmacists, getting the mix better. And like because there are all these demarcations and structures and it's almost like the medical profession is almost like a medical style hierarchy. It does create

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter Lewisan upwards cost. What was was your dad a GP, Sarah, or what was his?

sarah: No, he delivered babies. Yeah.

Peter LewisCa can't can't diss that. That's a good that's a good contribution. Yeah.

sarah: No, never had Christmas Day with him because there was always a baby Jesus being born.

Damian DamjanovskiChristmas baby.

Peter LewisAnd you always had to be sober all the time, didn't you, in case you got the call. You couldn't drink.

sarah: Yeah, he didn't drink. Yeah, he never

Damian DamjanovskiSo

sarah: had a proper night's sleep in his entire life.

Damian DamjanovskiSarah, on your podcast you must explore these issues a fair bit for these peop for people, the sandwich generation who's caught between caring for their you know, the elderly parents and then also young kids. So I don't know what it's like, so I I I don't have kids and and my parents still live independently, separately. but back where I come from, multi generational houses were the standard, right? So in and in most of Europe I think you find that multi generational houses is how you live. So I remember growing up there would be You know, you you'd have the kids, you'd have the parents, you'd have the grandparents, like and you all live under one roof together. why do you think that's not a thing here? Why why do we not embrace this idea? Why do we why do we turn our noses at it and go, my god, the kids are living at home for so long, like how terrible is that? And no, I had to take in my parents and like to me it seems absolutely foreign that that should somehow be a negative thing.

sarah: think people think, no, I have to take in my parents. I think a lot of people are coming back to intergenerational living. And I mean, I grew up with my grandmother. As I said, my grandmother lived with us until she was falling over so often that it was really dangerous. And my mum was confined to home and couldn't get anything done. And that's when she was trying to do some work. So eventually when she got really unwell, she went to an aged care centre for about Yeah, I think it was less than two years and then she died in there. So I think this has gone on for a while. I mean, it's cultural, isn't it? You know, this is the thing about my, I think that for my kids, we're working out, could we get a place where they could grow older in and live with us for longer? I offered my mum to move in with us and she was like, absolutely not, no way. I don't wanna live with you.

Peter LewisHa ha.

sarah: Because it did set up issues between her and her mother. So I did offer it. I think we're coming back to it, but we live in it. It's a different society. And also we're scattered. Like, you know, I've been talking to people on the podcast who's parents, she's an Indian Australian. Her parents live in India. So she's trying to do sandwich care across the world.

Damian Damjanovskigod.

sarah: Yeah. And then there's people who live in the country versus the city, or they're driving to see their parents for three hours because their parents won't do a Woolworths order over the phone and or then she won't let them order it. So she drives three hours and then drives back to do the weekly shop. So we just yeah it's it's part of our cultural background and I think with more immigration there probably is more of this multi-generational living. There's moves now to have the whole granny flat thing and a lot of people are

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

sarah: starting to do that. There was a beautiful guy during the pandemic on the central coast whose mother was living in a granny flat in his garden and he used to do these gorgeous posts about what they'd how they'd what they'd do with her that week and they'd set up a fake shop because she had dementia and they'd pretend they were shopping and another night he did this beautiful kind of light show in the garden for her. And it was this divine insight into the multi-generations you can have in the one household. But I also understand my kids desire to be independent and live elsewhere from me because they're like, well, you got to sleep on a bunch of milk crates with a crappy futon on top in a share home

Peter LewisFoot on. Foot on.

sarah: in Redfern with mold on it. The Elvis poster so bad that he looked like a bear.

Peter LewisThat wasn't I had a food on, but I also I

sarah: If we want that!

Peter Lewisalso at one stage bought a waterbed off the street and realized after two nights it leaked.

sarah: you did not!

Peter LewisI did, I slept in

Damian DamjanovskiHmm.

Peter Lewisa leaking waterbed, wake up, almost

sarah: you

Peter Lewisdrowning. That was in Redfern too. if you s because you could, because you could. yeah, I

sarah: Why would you get a waterbed off the bit? You're asking for trouble. Yeah, but of course it was punctured. Why would they throw it out if it was working?

Peter Lewisdidn't think about that. if we were building this from the ground up,

sarah: You

Peter Lewisright? This is this is a really difficult combo. So if you were building this from the ground up, you would have a world where you've got community, you've got entry-level housing, you've got garden suburbs where kids can bring up their kids and running around, and then you would phase out back into more scaled-down shared living, and it wouldn't be such a big deal. And the economics gets in the way of this, but And it sounds like social engineering, but what we've got at the moment is so dysfunctional, particularly older people who, for totally understandable reasons, don't want to leave a family home. But all these then people with young kids that are bringing their kids up in apartments because there's no access to land. I d like

sarah: No,

Peter Lewishow do you how do we, Sarah, have these hard conversations with our parents? Or can we? Because it feels really mean in a way, but it's also

sarah: Yeah, it's really,

Peter LewisI don't know.

sarah: it's yeah, like a friend of my mum's lives in a big house and I said to her, why don't you get a couple to come and live with you in one of the spare bedrooms and or, you know, and yeah,

Peter LewisSome migrants. Yeah.

sarah: and they could, you know, like help you cook you meals and do the cleaning, say, for instance, and you would not charge them any rent and then maybe pay them a small wage that would be much cheaper. than going into aged care or getting help in the home. But she was like, I just don't want to have to tell people what to do. So that's what I'm saying. I don't think it is just a government thing. We all have to change and embrace the realities, the situation

Damian DamjanovskiAnd

sarah: in which we're in.

Damian Damjanovskifor baby boomers who are I think it's fair to say renowned for being somewhat of a hoarding generation, I think adjusting to that kind of a reality might be a bit difficult because they're they're the ones who

Peter LewisI don't know. Well the ba well, the silent generation were the hoarders, the baby boomers were just the center of the universe. So this is gonna

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter Lewisbe the challenge if if the cent

sarah: Yeah, the silent generation, the hoarding is yes, they kept the soap and they keep things because they grew up in a time of scarcity. The boomers, I think, are used to power. You know, they're used to having things their own way.

Peter LewisI threw out stuff that were 15 years old from the pantry. Yeah. Entitlement. Sorry, boomers.

sarah: Not all of them, of course, and a lot of them. And look at the growing population. The most growing population at risk of homelessness is actually older women at the moment, particularly those who

Peter LewisMm.

Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.

sarah: have been divorced or are being let go in the workplace. they're a rising tide of homelessness and a lot of them at baby boomers. So we can't just say they're all rich, but they are used to having their own way. And we built, as you said right in the beginning, we built universities for them. We built schools for them, but we're not building the other end for them.

Peter LewisWhat about?

Damian DamjanovskiCause we're tired of building stuff for them. We've got to build stuff for other people as well. Like they've they've had their go. It's like we've they've got all this money saved up in their super.

sarah: That's right. Yeah.

Peter LewisSo you're you're in favor of yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiLike, you know what? It's not just use it, it's like

sarah: Use it. I agree. If they've got it, they should use it.

Damian Damjanovskia and I get the argument like superannuation's your money. It's like it's partially your money. It's also partially government money, 'cause you were taxed very little on that

Peter LewisBecause of the tax incentives.

Damian Damjanovskisu superannuation, right? So it's not entirely your money. And the idea that it's like I'm hoarding this and I'm gonna give it to my kids, like nah. If you don't use it, you lose it.

Peter LewisSo, let's finish on this. So a death tax is political death, right? Like you cannot get that conversation. But in terms of an equitable society, the handing down of yeah, you're right, Dame. It's it's like it's not about tax breaks on super, it's actually tax incentives to hand money down. How do you break that? Like your guys will never go with that. I know you're a zero money guy.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, I mean I I I I'm a I'm a die with zero guy and I I strongly believe that anyone who believes they're a libertarian or a capitalist should fundamentally disagree with the idea of inheritance because that's not capitalism, that's nepotism and they're they are different systems. Capitalism believes that you should be able to run your own race at an equal level to everyone else and accumulate what you can and maximize the capital you can gain during your lifetime. So that should

Peter LewisAnd then concentrate the power for your own benefit. No?

Damian DamjanovskiAnd then and then once you die, that you're done. You're game over. Congratulations. You've either won, you came somewhere in the middle, or you lost. Either way, you ran a good race, right? But the idea that you then hand that over, that's a different system. That's that's nepotism, that's not capitalism.

Peter LewisThat's a relay.

Damian DamjanovskiI I I don't think you can get away with at this point in time introducing any form of death tax, inheritance tax in Australia because as we've talked about at nauseum on this podcast and and outside of it, the Australian obsession over property as a wealth building tool is at this point, I would argue it like in the future we would we would almost make episodes of hoarders about it because it's almost a it's a mental disease at this point where you cannot have a conversation in most parts of Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane without discussing property. Like that is that is not normal anywhere else in the world. That is a exclusively Australian phenomenon. and is one we just don't seem to be able to break.

Peter LewisWhat do you reckon, sir?

sarah: I actually agree with that. We are, we're obsessed with it, but it's so ingrained in us. don't know how you, the cultural change on that is mammoth. It's massive. But I do think we've got to have more programs and perhaps it is going back to intergenerational living. Perhaps it's about

Peter LewisMm.

sarah: people thinking more broadly about creating different kinds of community because also as families get smaller and a lot of people aren't having kids that as... more people don't have kids now. You think about when they're getting older, who's going to care for them? So we're going to have to create

Peter LewisYeah.

Damian DamjanovskiBut the the system

sarah: different sorts of communities for that.

Damian DamjanovskiThe the system on a on a Yeah. And and I was gonna say this earlier, Peter,

Peter LewisOr just an AI companion bot that talks to you all day, which is the dystopian vision if we don't get it right.

Damian Damjanovskibut the the the fact is, whether we like it or not, I think we're gonna c th what's gonna come to the rescue in the next few years when we you know we clamp down on immigration and we don't have the Nepalese people to wipe our bottoms anymore is we are gonna have we are gonna have more bottom wiping robots and and and

Peter Lewisbottom wiping robot. That's that's that's Chinese

sarah: A robot wiping our ass. Yeah. I'm happy with a robot. I'd

Peter LewisAI, not

sarah: rather a robot wipe my ass.

Damian DamjanovskiWell but that's it and so so like I think we will see that transition within the next few years. I'd also argue it's a And it's a beautiful thing.

Peter LewisThey used they call it a bidet in some parts of the world, which is just like a water like I'm a big bid I'm a big bid A fan.

Damian DamjanovskiThe bidet is a wonderful invention and again, weird that Australia hasn't adopted it. you talked about social

Peter LewisHa ha.

Damian Damjanovskiengineering earlier, Mr. Lewis. But like I I'd

sarah: That's the cave.

Damian Damjanovskithe bidet, it'll solve everything. So If you think about it, a lot of the stuff we already do, right? Like giving people tax-free savings for their pension, or charging people exercises syntaxes on things we don't want them to do, is social engineering. That that's exactly what it is, right? It's we're disincentivizing you from doing this thing because we don't want you to do it because you're going to become a burden later in life. And we don't we collectively don't want to have to pay for your pension. So we want you to have a little bit of money saved. Maybe we need to readjust the social engineering a bit. Maybe when you hit retirement you you know, don't pay any tax on alcohol or Siggies and go for gold. Get out of here early.

Peter LewisBecause then you die you die early. So you get you you actually you have a express lane. Like so if

Damian DamjanovskiYou get the express pass.

Peter Lewisyou are encouraged to have life ending behaviors or life limiting because that will lead to a

Damian DamjanovskiShould you choose to imbibe in methamphetamines dro like go for gold?

Peter LewisNo, don't go there. No, don't go silly, but I do think like fatty foods, sugar, alcohol and tobacco.

Damian DamjanovskiYep. Alcohol, tobacco.

Peter LewisI haven't heard any better ideas of easing the burden on the taxpayer.

sarah: I yeah, you're going to cost a lot of money in the health department because you're going to get diseases caused by those things that are going to take a while to get take you down. And yeah, sorry. Sorry to poo poo on your genius. But you know, I think you bidet is a better idea than you know.

Damian DamjanovskiSo it ni so it needs to does it need to be more th thrill thrill seeking

Peter LewisDo you Well the the

Damian Damjanovskiideas.

Peter Lewiswell the the other one though, Sarah, do you re

sarah: Tremis.

Peter Lewisdo you remember Logan's Run? So Lo Logan's Run was a great

Damian DamjanovskiYeah yeah.

sarah: I was just thinking about Logan's rum. But when did they make them die in Logan's rum?

Peter LewisWell, in the initial series, because I remember watching it as a kid, it was at thirty. At thirty, it was determined that you had nothing more to offer society and

sarah: Yeah.

Peter Lewisyou were done. And Logan hit thirty and ran. And I remember watching that going, that's reasonable. You know, Jesus was thirty, like and then and then they did a re then they did a reissue.

sarah: Exactly. Yeah, that's what we think until we're there.

Damian DamjanovskiThere are what look

Peter LewisAnd then they did a reissue and they upped the age to fifty. So the problem with Logan's run is someone wanna up the age to ninety-five and then I don't know. But yeah, I I was a Legends Run fan.

Damian DamjanovskiBut but Peter, I I think it's I mean, look, th there's plenty of societies historically around the world where not at thirty, but where the the elderly of the society have wanted to ease the rest of society of their burden in a respectful way. And you know, that's been tradition in Japan and a lot of the Nordics for centuries, right? This is not a new idea.

Peter LewisThink American Indians, if I remember James A. Michener. Yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiAmerican Indians, yeah, th there's lots of societies where this is actually a construct of the society is there is a point at which you get to your life where you go, I'm no longer I'm more burdensome than my contribution. I've given all the knowledge I have to give and I want to exit on my own terms peacefully and the way I wish to do it. Now, you know, the Japanese would you know that it'd be an honor to carry your your the grandparent into the forest, the Swedes would throw themselves off a cliff, whatever it is. But like This is not a new issue, is I guess I'm saying is this is an issue that, as a species we've been grappling with for thousands of years is how how do we how do we where do we find that line? How do we let people die

Peter LewisHow do Australians do it? We don't we we agree we're gonna go out and not swim

Damian DamjanovskiWe

Peter Lewisbetween the flags and go looking for sharks.

Damian DamjanovskiNo, I think in Australia we just put them in one of those mega RSLs, and just let them get lost in amongst the pokies somewhere and they just never return. I think that's their the Australian ending,

Peter LewisI taught

Damian Damjanovskiisn't it? Somewhere in Wenty Leagues.

Peter LewisGod. What do you reckon, Sarah? I never asked you what your drink was, by the way. Yeah. I never asked you what your drink was, but

sarah: Well, you know, there's a big spiritual festival in India, huh? The Kumbh Mela. it's just, I'm drinking heaps of normal. I'm going no alcohol till the sun

Peter Lewisyou're nice, yeah.

sarah: goes down. But I do think in India, there's a thing called the Kumbh Mela. It's the biggest spiritual festival on earth, right? And a lot of families who can't look after their elderly leave them there. So leave their oldies there. I mean, I think this is one of the things that's meant to make humans feel

Peter LewisIt doesn't sound quite as romantic.

sarah: as an RSL being lost forever between, yeah, the one-armed bandits.

Peter LewisOr the Swedes jumping off a cliff.

sarah: Look, I think one of the things that humans like to think makes us human is that we do care for our elderly. And I can hear older Australians thinking, I've paid taxes all my life, how dare you even have this conversation? And I know you're doing it tongue in cheek, but I do wonder about individual responsibility in all of this versus politics versus society. But the main thing

Peter LewisHm.

sarah: is for me, I just think we need to design the system better so it supports the whole family, including the person in the sandwich struggling to keep it all up. Because these are often during their prime working years and it's having a big impact on their capacity to earn for the future and to look after their kids and to do a good job in their workplace.

Damian DamjanovskiSo so so what could governments do to help this sandwich generation? In your view, what could

Peter LewisQuestion.

sarah: Well,

Damian Damjanovskithey actually do?

sarah: Yeah, so what what the former director general talks about is she says the system has to be designed better to incorporate the carers within the family. And she says the system we have for people who were in the defence forces, they actually have good care. There's better models. are models that we can extrapolate from, but we need to kind of bring the bring the sandwich generation and the family into the system better and incorporate what they do. and get their help because they don't see themselves as carers, they don't get any help. So they're not kind of don't even know about things such as the carers gateway. So the system needs to be redesigned a little bit more, but also the assistance for those who are holding up the system needs to work better.

Peter LewisI f I feel like the the tweak is almost from consumer to citizen and looking at people in the whole of their life rather than just the transactions and the interactions with

sarah: Yeah.

Peter Lewiswhat is a for profit sector. So interesting. Hey, we better go to Kiss of Death. We warned you about this, didn't we, Sarah? Have

sarah: I forgot to think of one.

Peter Lewishave you got one, Damien? 'Cause I have got a beauty.

Damian DamjanovskiI I do. It's it's it's not on this topic sadly, but I as you know, am always very excited to talk about all things artificial intelligence with you, Mr. Lewis.

Peter Lewisyeah.

Damian Damjanovskiand I'm very excited for this coming week, which I believe will be the launch of Anthropic's Fable five point five model, which my kiss of death

Peter LewisWhat's that gonna do?

Damian Damjanovskiis that it will be hailed as the first recursive self improving model. So I think what we might see over the next week is the first AI model that will herald in what in future we will go that's the point at which we started getting proper super intelligence to use Mr Trump's term. I have a feeling that's gonna happen this coming week.

Peter LewisMm. Got anything for us, Sarah? Can be trivial or political or just

sarah: I think big sales are going to go through the roof after this podcast because it's obviously the solution to the whole problem.

Damian DamjanovskiHa ha ha.

Peter LewisSo mine is actually on theme. So I'm giving my kiss of death to Katie Zachariah, who is Trump's new press sec. And

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter Lewissh for those that haven't seen her debut, it was a spectacular car wreck of reading notes and smiling with very white teeth. she's already been exposed as being a fraud on her claim to be an attorney at law. So the thing is that the the record for the shortest ever tenure as a Trump press sect was 11 days from the mooch. Remember Scaramucci? And so

Damian DamjanovskiMr. Scaramucci.

Peter Lewismy kiss of death is that Katie's not gonna make the mooch threshold. She's gonna set a new record of political death

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter Lewisat the White House podium. She's no CJ Craig. That's all I'm gonna say.

sarah: Ha!

Damian Damjanovskiclearly so.

sarah: Can she do the jackal at a party though? That's the question.

Peter LewisAnyway.

sarah: Doubtfully not.

Peter Lewisso good. We we actually did a thing a few few months ago where you you look at politics through the prism of either West Wing, Veep, or what's the other one? House of Cards, but we'll go back to that one day. Love it. Hey Sarah, thanks for joining us. And now that Damien knows who you are, I reckon he's gonna be all over

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter Lewisyour new Career, your new career at AVC, but also we'll put links in the

Damian DamjanovskiVery excited.

Peter Lewisshow notes to Club Sandwich because it really is like some of my mates who are in your world are just going, Sarah's stuff's amazing. So you're building a community rather than an audience, and that's a really significant thing to do. Speaking of which

sarah: That's what we're trying to do. Yeah, that's exactly what we're trying to do.

Peter LewisWe're trying to do the same thing with people that like politics that don't want to hate on each other. So if you like this, we are doing a live show down in Canberra at the press club on the twenty-fifth of November. I think we've actually got the tickets up now and we'll put them in the show notes as well. If you want to come, you'd be very welcome too, Sarah. We're going to have a good night down there. You can you can you can relive your time as the the correspondent for the demise of Keating, which would be a very triggering experience, I'm sure. But hey, thanks a lot. And thanks as always, Dame. great combo.

Damian DamjanovskiThank you, Mr Lewis.

Peter LewisI actually I don't I'll go down and see if Timmy's still alive actually, but it's been a really nice way to spend the Friday, Avo. Cheers, everyone.

sarah: Thank you.