Episode 29
Sobering conversation - the state of political discourse in Australia
Show notes
This week it's just the two of us, after the alleged attack on Helen Haines, the independent member for Indi, outside her electorate office in Wangaratta. We felt it was a week to talk it through rather than bring in a guest. We discuss safety, public service, and the state of our political culture. We delve into what the attack means for elected representatives, the people falling through the cracks of our support systems, anger as a force in politics, and what it would actually take to turn the temperature down. Along the way we explore humour and larrikinism in public life, the professionalisation of politics, respectful disagreement within parties, and how we rebuild the connections that let people disagree without hating each other. Our thoughts are with Helen and her family.
A reminder that tickets are still available for our first live show at the National Press Club in Canberra on Wednesday 25 November, 6 to 9pm. It's $20 at the door, which comes back to you as a beer credit, and free if money is tight. If you enjoy the show, please subscribe and share it with a friend.
https://events.humanitix.com/what-s-your-poison-live-show-last-drinks-for-2026
Chapters
- 00:00 Introduction and Context
- 10:31 The Attack on Helen Haynes
- 18:51 Mental Health and Violence
- 20:23 Mental Health and Societal Fringes
- 23:39 Political Discourse and Public Sentiment
- 30:12 Impact of COVID on Government Perception
- 37:30 The Role of Humor in Politics
- 51:53 Cultural Norms and Political Etiquette
- 52:12 Cricket as a Metaphor for Political Norms
- 55:51 The Need for Diverse Political Backgrounds
- 58:28 Feedback Loops in Governance
- 01:02:28 Encouraging Respectful Disagreement
- 01:06:54 Empathy and Civil Discourse
- 01:09:25 Navigating Complex Political Issues
Full transcript
Read itHide it
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.
Damian DamjanovskiWelcome to What's Your Poison, the show where people who rarely agree on anything agree that it's better to do so over a drink. My name is Damer Damianovsky. I'm a principal here at General Strategic. And joining me this week, as he does every week, is my evil twin, Mr. Peter Lewis
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskifrom Essential Media. Peter, happy Friday. How are you? And what's your poison?
Peter LewisWell, I'm hi, Dame. obviously it's been a sobering week and we will be discussing I guess everything that flows off the horrible attack on an elected representative, but it won't stop me drinking. and I'm on a Talascus Scot so a Scotch from the Isle of Skye, which was given to me by my tech guy when I left. He also gave me, which is up behind me, which I've proudly mounted, a mounted iPhone 3,
Damian DamjanovskiDismantled. Yeah.
Peter Lewisbecause he thinks that's as far as my technology ever went. So shout out to
Damian DamjanovskiHa ha ha.
Peter LewisDarcy. Thanks for the Scotch. I'm opening it today. I'm doing a terrible thing and having it with soda just so I just because I'm also a bit thirsty, but a good.
Damian DamjanovskiI no, I I'm I I I I actually think a Scotch and soda's quite nice and and I think I'm on Das's side. that is a beautiful piece
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskiof art. I've seen those dismantled iPhones and pieces of tech before. They're a lovely lovely piece of artwork. A very nerdy piece of artwork, but a lovely one all the same.
Peter LewisIf only the world had stopped in twenty ten, I reckon I'd be a happy cookie now too. So anyway, I'd be very happy with my talicus.
Damian DamjanovskiYou'd be like, All right, this is as far as it needs to go.
Peter LewisSo what about you? What's your poison this week, Dame?
Damian DamjanovskiI'm actually I was going to have a whiskey, but I'm I'm trying to be good, so I'm sticking to my better ciders. This is my my my low alcohol, low sugar ciders that I'm trying to have at the moment as I attempt to get something resembling a a summer bod. but I do appreciate a Talasca Sky. They're a very good peted whiskey, aren't they? It's a nice smoky
Peter LewisYeah, no. Well I've just opened the bottle. I've been saving it for a special occasion and this is it. Made
Damian DamjanovskiSo
Peter Lewisby the sea, which is where I am too, so that's very nice.
Damian DamjanovskiIt's so for our listeners, we don't have a guest this week and we we debated whether or not we should have one, but but it's been a pretty heavy week, so it made sense for us to just kind of try and unpack what's happened over the past week, what it means, how people have reacted to it, how politicians have reacted to it. And how we feel about it as well. So I don't know Peter if you want to kind of give a bit of an overview of the v events of the last week, 'cause this all happened after the recording of our last show. So it's it's been almost
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskia full week.
Peter LewisThat's right. I think it was Monday. I think
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisit was Monday. And look, I think the elected representatives, without exception, have been moved and visibly shaken. I thought the Prime Minister when he got up to announce the attack on Helen Haynes he it was raw. he was I think his best self totally in that moment, sharing the trauma that elected reps feel. female representatives in particular have been reporting more and more extreme trolling on sites, messages. I I I think jumping into the physical realm takes all that to another level. Now, but I also think it's also a genuine it it seems so shocking because it's Edge cases colliding, you know. Helen Haynes is the archetypical, good MP, loved by her constituents, respected across the house. She was an independent. She wasn't part of the teal wave. She that seat in die had been won by Kathy McGowan originally about four cycles ago, I think now, against Sophie Mirabella, but they really built an embedded community independent movement there. Helen Haynes has had it in the last couple of cycles. I I didn't know her particularly well. I I I I ran an event during the voice campaign down at Wadongo, and ironically, irony is not the right word, but it was there were concerns about security at that event as well. And we had a police briefing beforehand and everything, but it was an a a fantastic community event when we're running town halls to explain the proposition behind the voice. So I think Everyone's you know, I I've been really grateful also that we've had a week, so it's not just a hot take and I don't even want to give you everything up the front of the show except to say that I feel like the nation has been moved by a woman who's dedicated her life to public service. She was a midwife before then, before she went into elected office, has had such a horrible experience and I feel that it will have an impact. on the way we conduct politics in this country. What about you?
Damian DamjanovskiAnd so I I mean just just for our listeners, just in case you haven't for whatever reason seen or or don't understand what happened to this event. So Helen Haynes is a an independent, obviously. by many considered one of, if not the first teal, before teal was really a thing. in Indai, which is the northern part of the state of Victoria. Her head office, which is known as the electorate office, is located in the city of Wangarata, which is kind of south of Wadongo as you as you're going between Sydney and Melbourne. she was just going about her business. She was loading some stuff into her car. allegedly, the gentleman who Was driving a vehicle, spotted her, did a U-turn, and then plow allegedly plowed his car towards her and pinned her between the front of his car and obviously the back of hers, then reversed and did so again. Allegedly. I'm so sorry for the fact that we have to repeatedly say allegedly, but just to make sure we're not on the wrong side of anything. Helen obviously suffered huge amounts of physical blunt force trauma, was helped by a lot of people in the area. the man was instantly pinned down by local citizens and and
Peter LewisHmm.
Damian Damjanovskilocal shop owners and and detained until the police got there. So he was taken she was taken to Wangarata Hospital and then airlifted to the Afred in Melbourne, where she she underwent, you know, immediate trauma surgery. unfortunately in the process she's lost two legs both legs so far. she's still in a critical condition. We're recording this on Friday the twenty third of October. obviously we we all hope deeply that she makes it through. but I think that's a pretty reasonable kind of quick overview of of what
Peter LewisMm.
Damian Damjanovskihappened. there's a lot of speculation as to the motive, why he did it, this, that and the other. You can probably Google and and read a thousand and one different things online, but
Peter LewisWell, I think we should yeah, just to pin that. So two things there, Dana. Firstly, I think it is notable the way that the committee reacted to the moment. it did remind me a bit of some of the heroics at Bondi when another terrible event was occurring, that people stepped up and took it upon themselves to intervene.
Damian DamjanovskiMm.
Peter Lewisthe other thing is that, you know, again, alleged, alleged, alleged. There is no doubt this is a politician, an elected representative, let's say, because people seem to like their elected representatives, even though they dislike the class of politician who has been targeted because they are an elected representative at and but pulling it back, does that make it I don't think it's like a capital P alleged political attack. If you look at the things that have been been coming out. everything from, you know, this could be a story about politics. It can be a story about system failure, about NDIS, about drugs, about mental health, about gendered violence, about toxic infosystems. Like the Venn diagram is so large. It feels to me where whereas Helen is The edge case of the good MP, this appears to be the edge case of everything that is happening in
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Well
Peter Lewissociety not working. And again, alleged, and we don't know yet, but it I think we are still grappling to ununtangle what that is. Yes, there is the question of safety for MPs, and there's the broader, this is the interaction between the bits of society that are no longer enfranchised. And an elected rep.
Damian DamjanovskiI mean I'm trying to figure out whether to start by talking about the alleged perpetrator or talking about Helen. I think I'd rather talk about the perpetrator
Peter LewisMm.
Damian Damjanovskifirst and and then not talk about him anymore. and then we could focus on Helen. I think
Peter LewisHmm. Well, I feel like we minimize that because I think something has happened. There is a process to uncover what has happened.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisand you know, we're we're we're pretend journalists or whatever, we're not. We're we're people commenting on the news. We've got certain legal correct,
Damian DamjanovskiNo we're not journalists.
Peter Lewisbut we've got some legal obligations on how we can frame this, which feels weird to have a bit of a straitjacket on it, but I think that's probably a good thing as well.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter LewisBut
Damian DamjanovskiI I wanna say this though. I think I think it's interesting that a lot of people with with this guy and and i he's not the first, reach for mental health. And I've two things that I wanna explore on this. One is I I I think anyone who commits this kind of allegedly commits this kind of act has mental health issues. Whether it is, you know, Attacking an individual, attacking a group of people, attacking someone in the home. Like I think it's almost like a foregone conclusion, of course they have a mental health issue because of the fact that they decided to that the only way to resolve whatever their gripe was was through physical violence. That i is of course a mental health issue. And I and I feel like increasingly we're using that or that's being used as a shield for bad actions. It's like, well, you know You know, he he had a mental health issue. Like the the that insanity defense thing is like, well, you know
Peter LewisWell, yeah, that that is the thing. Like I've always when I was studying law, there was I always said, How can you have an insanity defence? Surely when you murder someone, it's an act of insanity and there's this weird
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisconstruct in the law. I think it's a disease of the mind that prevents one from telling right from wrong, which creates all sorts of legal gymnastics. but there is also there there are there is an excuse and there's an explanation. And the explanation, I think, that we need to be awake to is that there are people that are on the fringes now of society. and there's more of them. And we're not in the American world yet, but as wealth concentrates, services fall apart, you know, the cuts to the NDIS are going to leave a lot of people on those edges more exposed. So there is conditions for this.
Damian DamjanovskiBut then I go and and and I guess this brings me to the second part of of this, which is let's say you accept the mental health component, go, well, look, you know, there's some sympathy for this guy and what he allegedly did because he was suffering from some mental health issues. Sure. In that case, the question becomes how did all these different services, safety nets, NDI, all this crazy amount of stuff that we collectively pay for?
Peter LewisMm.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd this is not a question of cost, but more how do all these things fail to catch these people before these kinds of things happen? How are we failing these people? And I mean, we know about this case because it was an MP, right? That's why it made the national news, because it was an elected member
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskiof Parliament. But these kinds of things happen throughout Australia every single day in various, you know, in various formats, wearing different clothes, whether that is, you know, in the in the guise of domestic violence, whether it's, you know, just family violence, whether all these kinds of things are happening regularly that don't get the same press attention that this does. And I'm not saying this shouldn't get the press attention. press attention, but my question becomes if this is an epidemic of people with mental health issues that are committing these kinds of acts, wh what is wrong with our system that we're letting that happen, that that is getting through? Why are we paying all this
Peter LewisMm.
Damian Damjanovskimoney if this kind of stuff is still happening?
Peter LewisYeah. And and that goes to the way we design services, we design systems. I th I think the reason this is rightly sh going another level is that that sense that it's cross it's not that it's even a worse attack than it would be on another woman who wasn't an elected rep, but it it is bringing some the the two extremes the power embodied in the parliament and people on the fringes that
Damian DamjanovskiHmm.
Peter Lewisis a chasm and when that connects there is a dangerous situation for our elected reps and you know it wasn't
Damian DamjanovskiSo let
Peter Lewisthe only and and and like and so we keep looking for big organized conspiracy around this and I just think that people are falling through the cracks and the last vestige of someone your elected rep is the embodied representation of the government, the the state. And if that
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Yeah.
Peter Lewisbreaks down then things you know, Just on the mental health, so the other and s I'm it's not a fun fact, but it is the other bit of our history was the only other attempted assassination of a federal leader, Arthur Caldwell, in sixty five was by a guy who ended up spending a decade In a mental institution. He he he shot through a window at Mossman Town Hall, Arthur Corwell, who was the opposition leader at the time, mid-sixties. He his name was Peter Coken, and he ended up writing while in Callum Park, I think it was, these incredible two books, Treatment and the Cure, about mental illness and dealing with it. Put us link in the notes. It's very there
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisthey're but but what I I don't know what I'm saying here. but the the difference there was he was very much the only way I will be noticed is if I do something that will make me seen. I feel like this we're in a different era now when people are doing this are doing it because they're broken. Like it's not like John Hinckley. This is this is anyway.
Damian DamjanovskiD do you think this is just a another symptom of people feeling deeply, you know, disconnected and disenfranchised from the political body? People feeling like like we we don't know whether or not he his intention was a political act
Peter LewisBut yeah.
Damian Damjanovskior a personal one. Like we don't know that detail yet. But let's assume
Peter LewisCorrect.
Damian Damjanovskifor the moment that it is a political targeted act and and you know, he's not the first one to make threats against voted you know, elected representatives. Do you think it's just people are getting to a Or have passed their
Peter LewisWell,
Damian Damjanovskibreaking point.
Peter LewisI feel like you've got an empty kettle and then you're putting it on the boiler, which is the engurtainment industry, which politics has become. In a way it's always been, but it really feeds off it. with you know, we've spoken about this in the past, you know, the way, you know, with Ed Coper, the way that anger drives engagement, engagement drives the metrics that create political avenues for persuasion. And I don't like we do not know. But the conditions for a breakdown in social contract is co-created by the political system, the media system and those that are participating in the information ecosystem. And I think I don't think it's like this told the government and elected reps anything they didn't know, but I think it just shows that shit's just got real. Like I'm interested, Feam, you like when you were working with Scott Morrison as prime minister, was safety something on your radar when you were out and about in the community? Or was it mainly protecting
Damian Damjanovskilook I I think
Peter Lewiskids from his crash tackling?
Damian DamjanovskiI think Scott was in a particularly specific situation and without breaking any confidences obviously You know, before he was Prime Minister before as Prime Minister Scott was treasurer, before that he was also you know, immigration, right? and I would argue that immigration is probably one of the trickiest portfolios to hold along with maybe home affairs that is not the Prime Minister. because those seem to be the ones that invite the most amount of anger from people, whether it's because they're upset
Peter LewisMore so than family services, 'cause he had that for a while too, didn't he?
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, but d don't forget a lot of that family stuff is administered by the states, not the Commonwealth. Whereas all the all the home affairs and immigration
Peter LewisMm. What about the family court?
Damian Damjanovskistuff is squarely in the realm of the Commonwealth and people know that. It's one of the few areas where they understand that is the federal government.
Peter LewisMm.
Damian Damjanovskiso I think Scott was probably gone through the portfolios that you'd least want to go through. You know, even as PM people associated Scott with immigration, like the he'd been doing that for so so look, I I I think
Peter LewisSo how conscious were you about that when he was out and about?
Damian Damjanovskithe the teams that dealt with his logistics, like I think it was a a very high concern. It was ever present. then obviously we had COVID, so it was a very different situation during Scott's prime ministership because a lot of it was, you know, people were not saying locked up, but you people were We weren't moving out and about as much as prime ministers before or after had or or will do, so it was a slightly different scenario, but it was definitely a key concern whenever You move a prime minister. I don't forget, like, when we were kids, I'm sure you remember Peter, like Parliament House didn't have gates on it. You could walk over the top of it. People could freely walk into Parliament House without so much as a a body scan, let alone, you know, having to empty your pockets and go through all this stuff. Now, if you go to Parliament House in Canberra, you can't go up the grass hill anymore. You can't roll down it. You can't like it
Peter LewisI know.
Damian DamjanovskiIt's it's much more of a fortress than it ever used to be. And while, you know, that that's basically been put in the last ten years, it hasn't been put in out of nowhere. There has been active threats to parliamentarians and MPs and senators.
Peter LewisYeah, Berkey was saying something like over a thousand threats logged.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, it th there's a lot of unhinged people out there who, regardless of whether or not they're planning on ac acting on it, yeah,
Peter LewisLike the law of averages, yeah.
Damian Damjanovskithey they they will make the threat regardless. and unfortunately for the rest of us who would never think of doing something like that, let alone making the threat, that means that all the systems have to be locked down and people have to be protected in case one of those nutters decides to act on their threat. and don't forget it was it wasn't
Peter LewisCan I ask you one more question?
Damian Damjanovskithat long ago where, you know, Parliament House was stormed by by groups as well. Like th this is, you know, recent history.
Peter LewisWell, that was the union rally on Canberra, the cavalcade to Canberra when John Howard came up in nineteen ninety six. Most
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, sorry, thugs. I meant to say thugs. Yeah. Yeah.
Peter Lewisof them were lovely nurses. but there were a few big boys that got into the gift shop. I will grant you that. It was not it wa
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisit was a it was a momentous own goal. do you think it's got worse post COVID?
Damian Damjanovskiyeah, I I I think COVID was, I reckon, an interesting example of people realized just how much government can affect their day-to-day life and really how much government has the ability to put the screws on people in terms of their physical movement, their way of life. now the cost of living as a result of decisions that were made during COVID. Like people for the first time, I think in a long time, whereas Australians have always been quite apathetic towards government, being like, well, I don't need to worry about them as long as they stay out of my way, kind of went, hang on a
Peter LewisAnd that's interesting, yeah.
Damian Damjanovskiminute, you have a huge amount of power over me.
Peter LewisYou've just locked down the country for the best part of two years. Surely you can fix my problem as well. If you've got all this power, why aren't you exercising it for me?
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, why aren't you doing anything about it, right? Like you you were able to do this, that, and the other. Why why is petrol so expensive? Why can't I f why is my you know, why are woolies and coals getting to put their prices up and and you can't do anything about it and you can't help me and my doctor's more expensive and petrol's more expensive? Like the amount of pain that people are feeling And when you don't know who to blame individually, you go to the highest authority in the land, which ends up being in Australia, the federal government. And you point to them and you go, What the hell are you doing to help me out? And instead of answering it, this federal
Peter LewisSomeone's gotta be in charge.
Damian Damjanovskigovernment has gone, well, what we'll do is increase your, you know, your capital gains tax if you have a small business or if you own a home and we're gonna get rid of negative gearing and we're gonna do this, that and the other. And so but but that's how but that's how we see the rise of these
Peter Lewisyeah yeah yeah yeah. Diamond temperature.
Damian Damjanovskilike crazy sovereign citizens and all these fringe groups is because even though a lot of people aren't a f but the thing is they
Peter LewisYeah, I don't think the sovereign citizens about the capital gains tax, but yeah. I don't know.
Damian Damjanovskimight they're not directly affected by it, right? It's not like they're sitting there with a successful business going, but I was gonna exit in a in a year. But what it does is it adds another proof point to their view that government is infringing on them. So it's adding another little proof point on top of this what started as a fringe belief, even to them.
Peter LewisThat's such an interesting take. Cause I would have took the capital gains and we don't need to debate this big was a sign that government is going to start making the system work for them rather than for the rich people. But anyway. I've got a question. So I think we've got to so ALBA was called, and I think bipartisan there's been called to turn the temperature down. What does that mean? And what does politics look like with a lower reading on the On the on the gas
Damian DamjanovskiI mean, look, it's I think this is an interesting one, and I'd be curious for your take, because I think Albo obviously Bondi was a big moment in Australia and I think universally everyone agrees Albo didn't quite react to that the way we would have liked our federal leader to react, right? So he he obviously didn't quite play that correctly politically or even just as a normal human being. and so this kind of was like a little bit of a all right, is is this gonna is this gonna be a different elbow? Not that this is at the scale of a Bondi, but you know, it's still one of those moments. And we saw a couple of like a day or two of elbow kind of going, Hey, this is a terrible incident. We need to turn the temperature down. And then getting caught in this miasma of craziness about You know, th they had prepared a you know, a a dirt sheet on Helen and sent it out beforehand,
Peter LewisA def yeah.
Damian Damjanovskiwhich which which is the normal course of politics, right? But but then he goes on to
Peter LewisWhich is normal politics as usual, right? Yeah. Which was a defensive document, yeah.
Damian Damjanovskibut then he goes on to deny that he'd ever seen it, blame it on his staff, and then this crazy move in terms of telling people, no, it wasn't a dirt sheet. It was actually a celebratory document, a testament of how
Peter LewisA testament of what a effective
Damian Damjanovskigreat, you know, H Helen Haynes is and you're just watching this and going, What is going on?
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian DamjanovskiLike
Peter LewisYeah. I think even his friends would say Albo sometimes tries to recreate a truth that hasn't occurred. He didn't fall off the stage, rah rah. so but beyond that and I I take that, that is but I and you know, if you if yeah. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiSo so sorry, but my point to that, sorry, just to tie it back to what you actually asked me is my point to that is in the on the one side he's going, we really need to take the temperature down on this political stuff and do better discourse. And I go, if you're the leader of the country, mate, that starts
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskiwith you. Set the example. And in the next day, if
Peter LewisAnd own and say
Damian Damjanovskiyou can't even stand up and go, hey guys, we we put we did put out a dirt file beforehand, it's kind of part of what happens in Canberra. It's really ugly. We get it. It you know, in hindsight, we didn't know what was gonna happen, obviously. In hindsight that was a bad move, but me a culpa, I feel terrible about it. Like s
Peter LewisYeah. We all are well, we all need to rise to a higher standard. But
Damian DamjanovskiExactly. So so so what happens is on the one hand he goes, we need to take down the temperature. And then the following day he does the stuff that increases the temperature, which is create a political storm out of something because he literally just can't own up to the simplest, smallest of things. That that drives me nuts.
Peter LewisYeah. A lot of people went to a lot of people into reflex. The other one that got me was the guy on his social media had said something positive about Palestine, so it was out being this is a sign. You know, like none of it helps. So but so let's let
Damian Damjanovskiand and
Peter Lewislet's go sorry, go, you go.
Damian DamjanovskiI was just gonna say but before the the guy was identified and named, I you know, I've recently rejoined Twitter after a a long absence
Peter Lewisreally?
Damian Damjanovskiand and you know, like a 10 year absence. And it was very interesting to see that in my feed simultaneously there's a whole bunch of people there going, look at this guy. This is the guy, he's a crazy he's a left-wing radical. And then there's a whole bunch of people going, Look at this guy, he's a right wing radical. And both of them are entirely
Peter LewisIn cooker, yeah, I know.
Damian Damjanovskiconvinced that they're right. In reality,
Peter LewisI know.
Damian Damjanovskithis guy's n I don't think this guy's either wing. I think this guy's, as you've talked about in the past, just an outsider, right? Who just feels disenfranchised from the whole bloody system. that people are so quick to want to paint him as a thing. This is the enemy he is. Yeah.
Peter LewisAnd to and and to fit it and to fit it into their narrative. So, yeah, no, I left Twitter when Tweet of God left, after Elon Musk took it over. And it's the only time I've followed God, but I like to say that my life has become demonstrably better since I made that decision. So thank you, Tweet of
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter LewisGod, who also left Twitter. He went to Tweet of God actually went to that other one. What is it, Blue Sky, but I couldn't make Blue Sky work. Blue Sky was a boulevard of broken deep.
Damian DamjanovskiC can I tell you when I left Twitter? Because when I s when I joined Twitter was in the very early days, like within the first six months of it being launched, and it was all nerds on there.
Peter LewisMm-hmm.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd when Oprah Winfrey started recommending Twitter, I was like, I can't be on here anymore. I'm out. And so I just like put my account to like silent mode basically.
Peter LewisYou left Twitter when it went good rather than when it went bad. But yeah, welcome back, I'm sure. They're happy to see.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, and now I'm coming back and and because we're in the age of like AI, X as it's now known, is now filled with nerds again talking about like interesting tech stuff instead of politics. That's why I've returned.
Peter LewisSo what do we mean, notwithstanding the you know, politics as usual over the dirt file and all that? What does turning down the temperature mean in a competitive political system? And I I've been reflecting on this myself. So I've spent most of my career supporting progressive organizations run campaigns for social change. Like I don't know if you know this. In the in the union movement, the theory for running a campaign is anger hope action. You've got to start with the anger. And it is really, you know, it is a skill, but it is something you give people. The information wrapped up in emotion, wrapped up in a bit of class analysis. Normally, I would argue totally legitimate. And then you fire them up because that's the only way you can break through an impenetrable system. I would argue the writer's done it well at times as well. You know, when, you know, you guys organized in 2019 the spurious campaign against Franking credits and Tim Wilson and his uncle. got everyone, all the old guys fired up. It was anger, hope, action. So anger is anger is an energy in politics. and I've been reflecting I don't I and I think it was Barnaby Joyce who's who said this week, you don't want to take the right for people to get angry out of the equation. But I do think you've got to look at it almost like a finite resource that, you know, you've got to If everything is angry, if everything is bad, nothing is bad, you know? So you've you've got to Be more be recognize that whatever you're going to do is gonna be hugely amplified, but also use those tactics deliberately, mindfully, sparingly when you need to. Like ever people don't want our elected reps to hold hands and sing kumbaya. what they do want is a degree of respect at the center of our polity so that we can actually have the friction without the whole thing going up in flames.
Damian DamjanovskiI look, I I I think you're right, and and I mean I'd add to it, and I think when we we talked in a few a few episodes ago with Rabbi Gersh and I I still
Peter LewisMm.
Damian Damjanovskireflect on his yes and kind of thinking
Peter LewisMm.
Damian Damjanovskiand I've been you know trying to apply it to this but also that anger and I think what Barnaby was talking about, if that anger goes unrecognized, and by that I mean Rather than people acknowledging, yes, we see your anger and we understand your anger, and here's what either we're gonna do about it, or here's why we can't do something about it, or here's an alternative plan. What we're increasingly seeing is people's anger going getting the response of your anger is wrong or your anger is inj unjust or your anger is you know bigoted or your anger is you know woke is whatever it is. So when we dismiss people's anger and somehow tell them that that anger is an incorrect feeling, it basically gets people more angry and more angry and more angry.
Peter LewisYeah, the bigger question is why you tell me why you're so angry. But
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisbut that is hard because it is also so there is and you know, I think the untold story of the rise of Trump and One Nation and all of it is there is a totally justifiable anger that a system is not delivering materially for the majority of people anymore and it's been captured by elites. But so but there is all so that is true. What is also true is that anything that is angry is the thing that's going to work. So that our whole life, we were talking about edge cases of the good MP and the outsider before. Our whole world is now made up of edge cases. Like they're
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisthe bit that the boring bits in the middle just don't travel. And so how do you create how do you create that?
Damian DamjanovskiWell that that was that's you know, Menzi's forgotten people, Howard's battle is like I think the traditional Labour Liberal Party of yesteryear, it traded on this world. Yeah, but like
Peter LewisMm. The working class, the union movement. Yeah.
Damian Damjanovskithat middle is always gone forgotten, right? And I think and I mean look, l let's take a interesting example of that anger and not at the edge cases but in the middle case, 'cause we talk about it quite often and and we're both quite dismissive of it as well. But you know, the the recent budget You've got a whole bunch of people who are angry because they go, Look, the system's not fair. There's all these people out there who own houses and make all this money and have trust funds. And meanwhile, I'm on the I'm on the bad end of that stick. Why are you giving all this stuff to the rich people? Make the system fairer for me. Right? So they're angry at that. Then on the flip side, you've also got people who are They don't feel rich, but they're business owners with family trusts and this, that and the other and have managed to get one or two properties and usually deeply in debt, working to a system that they've been told this is how things work for the past thirty years. And then they get angry because they go, hang on, you can't just pull the rug from under me. I've just I've been d doing this for three decades to try to get to an outcome. So both of them are rightly angry. And at no point has the government or the opposition gone, Well yeah, your your anger's justified and here's what we're gonna do about it or here's why we're doing this.
Peter LewisSo, where is the incentive for any political party, unless you're trying to manage incumbency, to get the frustration before it boils over it to anger? So it it it feels to me you've almost got to harness it at the point of frustration before it boils over. But the whole trick of politics is to get it up to boiling as soon as possible. And, you know.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, 'cause 'cause you need people to lift a placard and hold up a sign and
Peter LewisAnd the other bit is that we personalize it because the system is so complex, like, you know, we we we personify our political propositions, you know, you've done it effectively with some of the shortcomings of ABA. We used to sort of make John Howard, you know, the devil, and then, you know, there was, you know, you've very effectively destroyed Bill Bill Shorten. Lovely man. we then destroyed Scott Morrison, that we then destroyed Peter Dutton. So this whole cage fight of destroying a person as a proxy for politics, I think is interesting as well. And again, this is the world we have created. I think, Damien, the if and I think what will happen over the next few months is there will be a real attempt to bring some civility back into the parliamentary system. We both know that across the aisle there are really good relationships. I thought it was really interesting. I think it was John O Dunnium when he was leaving saying she'll hate me for this, but I really have a great friendship with Katie Gallagher. Like it's it's like it's the sort of thing that people don't see because the only bits you see are the anger bit. I think the risk, I think one nation has the most to lose. By the temperature being turned down. And I think there will be a concerted effort to do that, maybe to drain them of a bit of oxygen. And I think the way that Please Explain cartoon played out this week is quite instructive. I don't think Pauline would have apologized and pulled the cartoon that made fun of Jackie Lambe's health conditions. If this
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisweek hadn't happened, do you?
Damian DamjanovskiNo, I'd agree with you. And and e we've talked about this before and I I I think I still hold to the theory and maybe it explains a little bit of this, not all of it, but a little bit of it, is if you think about some of our most effective politicians and even the rise of one nation over the past nine months, what they generally have in common is they tend to be characters who have the ability to laugh at themselves when they need to and introduce what I guess we used to call Larricanism, but these days we just call a little bit of humor and not take themselves too seriously. So you you know, the Barnaby Joyces of the world, the Bob Catters, even the Jackie Lambys, like, they get fired up, obviously, but they also they know they recognize they get fired up. They're happy to take the piss out of themselves a little bit and not take themselves too seriously. Maybe what's happening here is that the Our political bodies and our political elite have become so sensitive to any form of mocking, humor, Larricanism that because that's missing, the temperature's being turned up. Because politicians can't
Peter LewisYou're saying because there aren't the outlet valves.
Damian DamjanovskiTh there's no yeah, there's no release valve, right? The the Christopher Pines of the world and even the Bill Shortains of the world are not in Parliament anymore. We now have these the
Peter Lewiszinger of the day.
Damian Damjanovskiwe have these political, lifelong political actors who are very serious people. They're all lawyers and economists now. There's very few in there who are just regular people and they they can't take a joke and they don't know how to crack
Peter LewisMm.
Damian Damjanovskia joke. They don't know how to do a release valve for people to go, yeah, they're a normal human being like me.
Peter LewisIs that is that your experience? Do you reckon the humor's gone out of the parliament? That's interesting.
Damian DamjanovskiHundred percent. Like compared to how it used to be even even five or six years ago. Like the humor is is rapidly escaping from that building and for all their faults
Peter LewisSo are you saying Scott was actually a master comedian? Because I could I've I could never work out if he was serious or if he was actually he was he was a post
Damian DamjanovskiNo, I I w I would I wouldn't call him a master comedian, but he
Peter Lewisa postmodern genius. Like he was he was performance art. I I feel like that. I think I I think I under I think I understand him better now.
Damian DamjanovskiPerformance art that is Scott Morrison. No, s look, Scott has his own brand of humor. I wouldn't I wouldn't call him slapstick funny kind of guy, but you know, he does have his own form of humor. But But this is the thing, like
Peter LewisNo, I think I think he was I think he was totally in character the whole time. I've got new respect.
Damian Damjanovskiwhat what you can't fault One Nation for the fact that they're trying humor, right? And they're they're doing it quite well, but like
Peter Lewistightly.
Damian DamjanovskiThey've gone too far in a lot of instances. They've crossed lines because that's their brand of humor, right? They they need extremism to keep pushing the boundary because the people
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskithey appeal to will go, Hey, look at them. This is demonstration that they are an outsider because they are pushing the boundary, right? This is what South Park started doing twenty years ago. It's not new.
Peter LewisYeah. Yeah. And look I've Yeah, look and I I've I and controversially f I've been a massive fan of that approach by One Nation. The I I think the Please Explain cartoons have been genius. I feel like they jumped the shark and they knew they had because if you watch that whole cartoon that they've now pulled down. There's a scene in which the Jackie Lambey character goes, There is no way they're gonna make fun of my health condition. And then they just go, Yes, we
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Yep.
Peter Lewisare. And then the rest of it is that's the running joke. So they it w it struck me like the the edgiest I think one South Park has got has been in the recent series where
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter LewisDonald Trump with a micro penis sleep is sleeping with Satan. And like so they
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisthink, how far can we take this? And They've worked out how far they can. They've worked out what the line is. and
Damian DamjanovskiAnd but again, that that's one s very specific brand of humor and not every not all comedy is the same, right? So if you think of Bob Catter, Bob Catter is the best at making fun of Bob Catter. Like everyone makes fun of Bob Catter, but no one does it as well as Bob Catter.
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian DamjanovskiLike he understands the edifice that he's created, that iconoclastic character that he is, and he both plays into it and deconstructs it simultaneously through
Peter LewisMm.
Damian Damjanovskihis social media, through when he talks to like he he, you know, when he goes on Batuder Advocate and all these kinds of things. Like he plays into it and plays around it really well. Barnaby, for all again, he he's a really good retail politician because he knows how to play his audience on the ABC and then his audience on Sky, how to kind of play them off one another. Like they're different brands of humor, but there's not many characters in our Parliament who still do this.
Peter Lewisthere's a but there's a difference between humor that underneath has a shared humanity and empathy and one that's just mean. And I think Lenore nailed it a few weeks ago where sh her concern with the One Nation cartoons was they're allowing them to say things that you wouldn't be able to say in other contexts. And I think she had a point there. The other thing, fun fact, do you know in nineteen ninety eight Pauline Pantsdown was doing these It was a drag queen that was doing a parody of Hansen and she took legal action to stop the ABC running her song. I think it was
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. From Yeah.
Peter Lewiswhich was a mashup of all all her speeches.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd Pauling Pants down, like it was a it was a triple J hit that it was on Triple J Hottest 100 that year. I think it came in in the top 20. you know, like
Peter LewisI don't like it. Yeah. Hmm.
Damian Damjanovskithere is, and I'm not trying to present a master theory here, but for any of our listeners, like do tell us what you think of this, because I'm pretty adamant that the best way that Albo and Co. could help take the temperature down is to Introduce a little bit of Larrakanism back in. And that doesn't have to be elbow doing comedy, right? The Prime Ministership still has a degree of prestige that should always keep. However, and I'm not saying they should take their jobs any less seriously. However, when things do happen, like what happened this week with the dirt the dirt sheet on Helen, instead of treating everything as a political hit job. And pretending we're on House of Cards, reminding ourselves that we're in Australia, that it's a media story, that
Peter LewisThat we're also on vape.
Damian Damjanovskiit'll pass in a week, that you can own it, you can explain to people, hey, sorry that you had to see how the sausage was made. These things go around. You should see the dirt sheet on me and the dirt sheet I have on Jim. and then move it along. Like
Peter LewisYeah. So this is where I think we're talking about not so much the rules of engagement that the norms of what behaviour is. And I thre I'm gonna do this. I wasn't sure if I'm gonna I'm gonna give you a little lesson in cricket. Do you know anything about cricket?
Damian DamjanovskiI can tell you I know nothing about cricket. Like like I
Peter LewisOkay. So it
Damian Damjanovskidon't know, I think you think I'm saying I know a little bit about cricket and not a lot. I just want to reinforce I know nothing about cricket.
Peter LewisSo let me tell you a couple of things. And and the reason you don't is you're a WOG, and unless you are someone that came from the British colonial empire, where it was the colonial game. what's been happening over the last week, apart from this tragedy, is Australia losing the second test over in South Africa. It's the first time they've been there since this big incident about a decade ago called Sandpaper Gate, where astray across a line by tampering with a ball using sandpaper which makes it swing more through the air. And the captain, which used to be
Damian DamjanovskiSorry, what do you mean they with sandpaper?
Peter Lewisthey had sandpaper in their pocket and they were rubbing it on the ball to scuff it up to make it swing through the air. And the Captain of Australia used to be described as the second most important job in the country after the Prime Minister. He got sacked, stood down for a year over this. It was a big, big deal. So this is the first time they're back. But the when people looked at what had happened, it had been this breakdown in cultural norms. And there's always this etiquette in cricket, you treat people with respect, blah, blah, blah. And this Australian cricketer had this line. which I think sort of summed up where things went wrong, which was we know there's a line, we go up and headbutt the line. And I feel like a lot of politics has been done recently around that idea of headbutting the line, like the line of what the norms of politics are. So you don't cross it but you push it, you push it, you push it, because it works. And it works and works until it doesn't. And this week it didn't. And I think people are recalibrating. The good news is what happened out of Australia is they recognized that. They picked this fantastic guy, Pat Cummins, to be the captain. they had a generational change. They've kind of found success by not being aggressive, by finding a way of embracing the game. So it it's been a really interesting story, which will mean nothing to you, but hopefully some of the listeners will see that that was and you know.
Damian Damjanovskilook, I'm I'm I know for a fact we have many listeners who enjoy the sports and know what cricket is. so I
Peter Lewisknow what cricket is. It's like meditation with a ball. I'll have to take you out to a game. It is fantastic.
Damian DamjanovskiI just think and I this idea that we I don't know if it's the class of politician we have at the moment or maybe maybe we've elevated our politicians to the point where they think a lot more of themselves than we do. My actual instinct is is that we've over professionalized politics. I think there's actually maybe too man too much professionalization of politics. Like it's a career path now.
Peter LewisBut you want more of them. You want to up the number.
Damian DamjanovskiI I want more politicians because I want fewer professional politicians. I want more average people. I want more normal people. And Helen was. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. She's a nurse. She's a she's a independent who like
Peter LewisBut Helen was Hel Helen is Helen is not a professional, right? and can I it it does gore me a bit. Yes, there are those that go through staffer. I I will always say someone that's worked organizing workers in an industry where workers have no power is as an organizer. That that that's a real job. It's a real hard job too.
Damian DamjanovskiI agree.
Peter LewisI think the same as people that work with an industry association trying to help them navigate. That's a real job.
Damian DamjanovskiAgree.
Peter Lewisso I I don't know. I I've I've been doing this thing for the ALP recently where we do little sessions online with some of the first term MPs. They're terrific. Like there's a whole bunch of people that come in with diverse life experiences, really good skills. And maybe, yeah, we say that and and and we've done research on this in the past that people don't like. politicians, but they like their local MP if they've met them. like my MP's not like well, they don't have a bank anymore. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, and people hate banks but they like their bank. Yeah, right? But and yes, I agree with you all on all of that. All I'm saying is yes and it would be great if we had a better balance because at the moment We overindex on on the Labour side people who've either come through the union movement or have been staffers and then end up as elected representatives. And on the conservative side, people who have gone to one of three
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskiuniversities and then become a staffer or worked at an industry association. And yeah.
Peter LewisMaybe, but that's our institutional advantage. We've got this network of organi
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisinstitutions that have a deep feel into different industries. And I think that's a positive.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd and and all I'm saying is I'd love to see that balanced with more people who've actually had real life experiences, whether that real life experience is thirty
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskiyears of changing bedpans or administering cannulas or having to stress out on a Thursday night, figuring out if you can pay staff and you have enough money left over. I want people in our parliament who aren't just that. And I think
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskithose kinds of people are also a little bit better about not taking the job quite as seriously as some of the people who we've got in there at the moment.
Peter LewisBut I Jess Teesdale, who sits who's she's the young woman with glasses that sits behind Albo's shoulder. She was a teacher in Tassie. She knocked off I think like there there's a but
Damian DamjanovskiI I'm not I'm not saying there's not some of them, right? Like
Peter Lewisthere's a lot like I just think that again we we reduce them all down to a cliche. But I also think it's not the people, it's the game. Because we are still in this system where we get all these complex problems and then we turn it into a binary and a yes no vote and then And then as if that's going to solve the problem and the problem doesn't solve. So I do think the crisis, the crisis is
Damian DamjanovskiI I I agree with you, Peter, but but we can't
Peter Lewisnot the players, the crisis is not even the issues. The crisis is the game. Like how in a complex world where everyone's been reduced down to a universe of one, can we create a a system of Let let's call government a feedback loop. Let let's how do we create feedback loops where people feel heard, responded to, and that, you know, the government's on their side in a world where there are immense challenges? It's I'm glad I'm not doing it for a job, you know, it's hard.
Damian DamjanovskiYes. Yes. And could I give you the the expansion on that, which is I'm not saying that's wrong by any stretch of the imagination. I think the the question you then have to answer is so and you know, ignoring the teacher and the nurse because ultimately they're all still paid by the government. I'm talking about the person who is really struggling either to find a job or running a business or whatever else. And you're saying on top of all your existing stresses, we want you to take this nuanced approach and nuanced view of government and policy and spend your time thinking about this issue that you know then adds more to your mental burden on top of the ten thousand things you've got to do. So If that's the case, me as the, you know, the business owning constituent goes, What the heck am I paying you guys all this money for and all these bureaucrats? If you then need me to come in and weigh in more than just a yes-no answer, but to give you all my nuance. Like what are you doing? Like what the heck are you doing in that case? I was like the the reason I elect you is to make good decisions. The reason I pay the bureaucracy is to inform them.
Peter LewisBut that's a very transactional that's a very transactional relationship with democracy. Once every three years you cast your vote and then you guys go off and run the world. I reckon there is mo I don't know. I I think citizenship is more than a vote every three years. It shouldn't be a chore, but it should be embedded into our into our lives a little bit more. I don't know. You know, I
Damian DamjanovskiIt's I I I I I don't disagree with you. I just I don't know what the answer is 'cause I like I I also
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskiknow what it's like to sit on the you know, on the business side of things as do you, where you go, I've got so much stuff on, I I don't really have the time To deliberate NDIS policy and go, hey, have you thought about this slightly more nuanced approach? And I appreciate there's organizations out there and a lot of non-for-profits who are trying to do this well and go, hey, let's get all these people in a room together to discuss
Peter LewisMm-hmm.
Damian Damjanovskithis. But I go, you know, my mate who runs the coffee shop or has the, you know, the the business down the road, they're never going to participate in this because the fact that they've got to run a business.
Peter LewisBut this but this is where the that idea of countervailing power comes in, right? So J.K. Garbra, the great economist of the twentieth century, always said that the way a functioning democracy works is you've got your government, you've got your institutions, but then you've also got groups, so a chamber of commerce or a union or a progress association. People used to to join things and they would find commonality, they would find a a voice. And it wasn't always around politics either, but there were just groups that were so you weren't or you weren't just on your phone being fed the algorithm. And I you
Damian DamjanovskiGetting angry on Twitter.
Peter Lewisknow, and I and I'm big about this. Like how do we actually build networks again? And I because I think that is actually I think we were saying this before a little bit. How do we create a polity where we start with the bits where we're all together and then we can have divergent views, but if we've started with a point of connection, we don't need to hate on each other, right? Which is kind of, you know, maybe what we're
Damian DamjanovskiAnd and and so I'm gonna I'm gonna
Peter Lewistrying to do here.
Damian DamjanovskiI'm gonna give you my final piece of my theory on Albow's
Peter LewisHmm.
Damian Damjanovskiwe need to turn the temperature down and how we can do politics
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskibetter. And alongside the we need a little bit more humor and levity back in our political class, I think the final piece of the puzzle is firstly on the Liberal Party side of stuff, but also on the Labour party party side of things. We have lost the ability for individual MPs to disagree with a party position. So obviously in Labour what happens is caucus must agree. So if you're a member of Caucus, if you're a backbencher, whatever the party position is on this thing, you must agree
Peter LewisHmm.
Damian Damjanovskiwith it. You cannot dissent. And if you do dissent this, you get kicked out, right? Ed Husick is the best example of this. You basically get isolated into the woods if you have a differing view. The Liberal Party w he got he got regardless, see he he's isolated in either case.
Peter LewisNo, he got isolated into the woods and then had a different view. Love Ed, hi Ed. Yeah, yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd then on the flip side, the Liberal Party was always meant to be the antidote to this, but since they started importing more and more of the American Reagan era politics and being like, well, no, you can't cross the floor, you can't have a differing view. Hey, Bridget Archer, if you have a differing view, you're gonna get punished, X, Y, and Z, they've by default become much of the same. So if we're saying that at our most our highest level of government, we actually don't allow my individual rep elected representative to disagree with the party position respectfully and then they still do the action, how are you expecting individuals down on the ground to do it? Set the example.
Peter LewisBut isn't the other lesson from the states, when that's the case and everyone has autonomy, they all just get targeted by the powerful vested interests and the money. Like it actually
Damian DamjanovskiAnd surely there's a halfway point between those two things, right? We can disagree respectfully. Get to a position and then row together. Like that, those are not opposing ideas.
Peter LewisMm.
Damian DamjanovskiWe're like, there's just no way to do that thing. Of course there is. Lots of places around the world do it. You disagree respectfully, and then you go, This is the position we've landed on. We understand that these people disagree on this position, but we've heard their disagreement. It's been noted. As again, as Rabbi Gersh said, the minority view was always noted when the rabbis made a decision. So we don't just go, this is what we decided, we
Peter LewisYeah, that was really interesting. Yeah. So
Damian Damjanovskigo, this is what we decided, but no Noting that these MPs had a differing view for these reasons. So you're respecting and acknowledging the disagreement rather than dismissing it and saying either it's you know silly or it's misunderstood. And I really think that if we can get our, you know, Labour and liberal parties to start setting the example of this is how we respectfully disagree yet still row in the same direction, that's the best thing that ALBO and Angus and Pauline can do for our democracy. Show us what good disag disagreement looks like.
Peter LewisOur bo and Angus have been talking together on a few issues recently, haven't they? Was it around the AI stuff or the immigration? I I feel like there's it was it's interesting on the Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiThere there's a few topics that they're collaborating on, but again, that happens behind closed doors, so we don't see it, right? But I would love to see both the Liberal Party and Labour Party be much more open to disagreement within their own ranks and openly talk about it.
Peter LewisMm. And you know, I I guess without wanting to drink our own bath water, this is kind of what we're trying to do with this podcast as well. Like clearly different views of the world, but not letting that be a barrier to listen to each other and get a better understanding. And, you know, I and I think the bit that you also get there, the secret source, if you can Get yourself into another's shoes and listen to them is the empathy
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewispiece. And I think it's an untapped piece because sometimes when you watch politics and the empathy comes through, which only comes through from vulnerability and open-heartedness, which again, I sound all woo-woo. It's it it's political Viagra. Sorry, that's the wrong term as well, but it is strong, it works, you know? I shouldn't say that.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. It does. And and I think, you know, we yeah again, we're not trying to be self indulgent here, but I think for me at least I I think for you as well, Peter, like part of the reason we started this is I deeply agree with you on the need for better civil discourse. Like I deeply do. And I believe that you and I both agree. That we want a better country where it's managed better, governed better, and that as many people as possible get a better outcome as a result. I don't think we always agree on what we need to do to achieve that, but I enjoy that we disagree on it. Because if you and I just
Peter LewisHmm. Hmm.
Damian Damjanovskisat here and agreed on everything, I feel like I would not enjoy that society.
Peter LewisBut it's also so boring, right? do you know who's regarded as the standard bearer for civility, by the way?
Damian DamjanovskiOkay.
Peter LewisLarry David. curb your enthusiasm. I don't know if you're a fan or not, but Larry David is not polite, and it's the difference between politeness and civility, but he's prepared to take a stand for Doing things in a way that complies with social mores. And I feel like we need more of those people that say, hold on, what are we talking about here? You know, you can't have 10 tastes of the ice cream. Choose it and do that in politics as well. Like, stop. Like, if I had one thing, I would get rid of those bloody Dorothy Dixes in Parliament. Like, it's just, like, it just.
Damian DamjanovskiI I actually agree with you on that. Like I would like love to see question time where there was no Dorothy Dixer. So for again, for any listeners who don't understand,
Peter LewisBut people from the govern
Damian Damjanovskilike so every time there's a question time during a sitting week, what happens is there are Dorothy Dixer questions, which basically means that all the questions, which is meant to be without notice, are all entirely pre-planned
Peter LewisPray script it.
Damian Damjanovskiand pre-scripted and the answers are pre-scripted and they're very intentionally chosen.
Peter LewisAnd everyone needs to look like they're in control. Like how much better would it be? Sorry. How much better would it be if you just and and and and and Minister Sroke, that's a really good question. I'm gonna go and find out and report back to you rather than having to pretend that everything everything is life or death. The temperature is high, the temperature is up in the whole way we run this system. And I don't there are no there are no
Damian DamjanovskiIt's over professionalized. It's over professionalized.
Peter LewisThey're now Asian and we're probably
Damian DamjanovskiWe've imported too much of American politics into our system. And this is one area where we can take it back to a bit
Peter LewisWell, binary politics. Well, and to to what ext
Damian Damjanovskiof Australianism.
Peter Lewisand to what extent is our politics now being developed to serve the algorithm that serves the interests of the technology, rather than saying, our Indigenous politics can look different. We've got, you know, and it doesn't need to be a preservation of the two party system in any shape or form, but it needs to be a way of solving problems that is different to how we're and and you know, we've got some really tough challenges coming up. I think people don't realise how south the economy is gonna head as a result of the you
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. I would love
Peter Lewisknow the mismanagement of a populist leader in Washington, but we're about
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisto say it.
Damian DamjanovskiI would love nothing more than people to be able to, including in Canberra but also in our media, to be able to have conversations about tricky issues without automatically labeling someone either A a, you know, racist, bigot, you know, whatever, or B a, you know, woke snowflake, you know, bleeding heart. Like I feel like the moment you introduce that into an argument, you you've lost like the argument's lost, right? Because
Peter LewisWell, that should be our new rule of politics anyway, I reckon. Or at least here on What's Your Poison? Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiThe the Yeah. They bec because y you're not a bleeding heart just because you believe that people who have a lifelong disability may need a lifelong hand up that will cost the state a lot of money, but those people are entitled to a dignified life. I don't think that makes you woke. Simultaneously, I don't think it makes you racist to go, I'm not sure the Welcome to Country is doing anything to actually help indigenous people. Like both of those things can be true without the people who are making those claims. Because that's people
Peter LewisWell.
Damian Damjanovskicoming into a conversation going, I have a point of view and I want to explore it and I I want to introduce it.
Peter LewisYeah. And look I I reckon I reckon if we had a sensible conversation, and we won't do it today because we're at time. I could make the case. We should do it at some stage, probably with someone who was part of the voice campaign. Like I I I actually think they serve a really useful purpose, but that's for another day. do you wanna go to Kiss of Death?
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, Wood. What's yours?
Peter LewisSo I we were talking about generations last week. I've been watching with interest the protests in France, Spain, Italy, India, Argentina. There's this whole Gen Z protest movement, and it's not about immigration, it's not about climate, it's basically about services and cost of living. the the French protests have started by They that they've started by kids just saying, what's going on in our schools? Like they're like in the they were freezing during the winter. it it it's blown out in all sorts of directions. It's a real challenge to Macron. But this a generational backlash against material well being at a time when the world is going into a global recession is will be interesting to watch. And it will be interesting to see how it finds its way into Australia as well.
Damian DamjanovskiHmm. It's interesting. I look, my kiss of death this week is a bit closer to home. I I don't know if you're much of a weather nerd, Mr. Lewis, but I'm a huge weather nerd. And part of my weather nerdery is a deep loathing of the Bureau of Bureau of Meteorology over the past decade who have somehow
Peter LewisThe bomb.
Damian Damjanovskithe bomb, who have somehow mismanaged everything that's been handed to and I'm increasingly happy to see they're finally being called out on it bit by bit by bit. my kiss of death is that over the next week there might be a government led review or complete overhaul of the Bureau, which I think could not come soon enough because we have so much of our country that depends on the forecasts of the Bureau for their livelihoods that we need a good functioning meteorological agency in this country.
Peter LewisI'll have to get my mate Aunt Shawood on. He works for Weather Zone. He is the weather nerd of all nerds. You guys are gonna nerd out big time.
Damian Damjanovskigreat. I love it. love it.
Peter LewisAnyway, the last thing, guys, let's get serious about this. We've set up the event last Wednesday in November, the date I always get wrong. I'm gonna say 25 today.
Damian DamjanovskiTwenty fifth, yep.
Peter LewisCome. Like we're gonna have a whole bunch of people that have been part of this pod, people that are dedicated to having fun with people with different views the same way we are. the Westminster Tradition gals, Carolyn and Danielle are gonna be there. Ryan Heath from Politico is gonna be there. Lenore Parnell are gonna be there. We're gonna have awards and games and lots and lots of drinks. So
Damian DamjanovskiIt'll be a lot of fun. And it we we probably booked a larger space than we ever were gonna fill, but we still have tickets left, which is really, really good. For all of you who've already booked tickets, thank you very much, Early Birds. We appreciate you. but I'll put the link in the show notes as always. if you know someone who's interested to come along, send a link along to them. Everyone is very welcome. I've had a few people asking me, they're like, I didn't know if I was invited. I'm like, no, no, genuinely, everyone's invited along.
Peter LewisYou're all invited. And at the moment we're putting a twenty dollar on the door, mainly just so that people that say they're gonna come come, but we'll give you a beer credit for that as well. So don't and and
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, you'll get a whole bunch of free drinks out of it.
Peter Lewisand if you've got no money or you're unwaged or anything, just let us know and we'll give you a freebie. Or if you work for the greens.
Damian DamjanovskiWe'll do a subsidy program for you. if you if you don't already subscribe to the show, a lot of you I know listen to the show every week, but for some reason haven't actually pressed the subscribe button. it actually helps us a lot by you pressing the subscribe button because it makes sure that people who have a similar algorithm to you get us recommended in their feed.
Peter Lewisis that how it works? Surveillance capitalism, yeah.
Damian Damjanovskiwhich is why it's really important for us that you like the episode, share it with people you like, and of course hit that subscribe button. But for the thousands of you who already do, we really, really appreciate you. We appreciate you spending time listening to us. We hope you enjoy our civic discourse. And Mr. Lewis, it has been a pleasure talking to you this week, a heavy week, but I
Peter LewisAs always.
Damian Damjanovskilook forward to chatting to you again next week.
Peter LewisYeah, US elections theme next week, I reckon, with the midterms.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. It'll be fun. Interesting. Thanks everyone.
Peter LewisOnwards and upwards.
