Episode 2
Immigration, Racism, and AI
The video for this episode is on our YouTube channel.
Show notes
The war in Iran, a human rights commission report, community identity and racism, class struggle and racism, and immigration policy and racism. We delve into the global impact and structural problems of racism, community identity and class.
Takeaways
- Global Impact of Racism
- Structural Problems of Racism
- Community Identity and Racism
- Class Struggle and Racism
- Immigration Policy and Racism Immigration and national identity
- Impact of immigration policy on social cohesion
Chapters
- 00:00 Introduction and Self-Improvement
- 08:05 The War in Iran
- 18:16 Human Rights Commission Report
- 23:32 Community Identity and Racism
- 31:20 Class Struggle and Racism
- 37:49 Racism and Immigration
- 50:05 The Role of AI in Writing
- 57:02 Predictions and Shoutouts
Full transcript
Read itHide it
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.
Peter LewisWelcome to What's Your Poison? The show where people who rarely agree on anything agree it's better to do so over a drink. My name is Peter Lewis. I run Australia's most progressive campaign agency, Essential. And joining me is my friend, Dame Damjanovski who's one of the masterminds behind Scott Morrison's reign and is now principal of General Strategic. We it last week because you were having a surgical enhancement, Dame. How's it gone?
Damian DamjanovskiI was indeed Peter. Good to see you after a break. Some of our, I don't want to say regular viewers, but if you've viewed the first episode and then this one, I guess you're a regular, would have seen that my hair's changed. I got a hair transplant, didn't travel to Turkey or Thailand.
Peter LewisWell, both of you, yeah.
Damian Damjanovskigot it right here in Sydney. it comes back. look, I think we won't find out for six to 12 months, but other than the pain so far, so good. So I'm looking forward to seeing my luscious locks come through. How have you been, Peter?
Peter LewisAnd how's it taking? And yeah, good. you know, you're a big believer in self-improvement, aren't you? You're a big fan of semi-glutes or, and you're also a big fan of AI doing all your thinking for you. So there's a few things we'll talk about the better improved Dame versus the very human Peter this week. ⁓ Yeah. been great. I've been up running. Sorry, Yeah. The hairs.
Giridharan SivaramanHahaha
Damian DamjanovskiI'm happy to outsource the entirety of my life if I can.
Giridharan SivaramanWhy don't you just embrace the bald though Why did you just embrace the bald? mean, why go for it?
Damian DamjanovskiHahaha!
Peter LewisWhereas here is about the only part of my body that hasn't let me down. So I'm sort of wearing it with pride. So look, the setup for this show for first timers, including our first two guests, like who are past the first threshold. So it's a no dickheads policy. and I bring a friend along from our side of politics and we bring a we bring a friend and we bring something to talk about. There's no shortage of things to talk about this week.
Giridharan SivaramanLike, you know?
Peter LewisMy drink this week is a Kirin Ichiban, which I've always been a bit of a on Japanese beer, but this one's totally won me over. So Kirin Ichiban is my poison this What about you, Dami?
Damian DamjanovskiI'm actually drinking a Hobart whiskey this week, a Barrel Lane limited edition. I happen to be a member of more than one whiskey club where I get delivered new whiskies every single month. ⁓ And I get through them with gusto. So cheers to everyone in Tasmania who knows how to make a fine drop. I thought, Peter, I might do a quick roundup of the somewhat ins... ⁓ we just introduced. ⁓ My non-dickhead friend is the one and only Gisele Kapterian, one of my
Peter LewisDoes not surprise me. So. ⁓ no, let's introduce your non-dickhead friend first and then I'll introduce mine.
Damian Damjanovskifavorite people in the world. is a lawyer, a former staffer. She's a tech executive. She's a liberal moderate. She was the candidate for Bradfield at the most recent federal election raised and lives in North Willoughby. Daughter of migrant parents from Armenia. She's on the board of the Armenian national committee. She is one of the most intelligent, articulate, amazing people you'd ever meet. So I'm very, very honored that Gisele is joining us for this week's What's Your Poison?
Peter LewisAnd what are you drinking Gisele? And just question. What was it like being in the opposition party room for that week? And then looking back on it, do you feel like you got to get out of jail free card?
Gisele KapterianPeter, you know, it is a beautiful from that question to what I'm drinking and the connection is a one. Look, it was a to be there. My one moment where, you I got to help shape the future of the party and hopefully there'll be another, I'll be future facing and say, hopefully be another occasion to do that and quickly pivot. to drink of choice, which is today I am delighted to be joining you with, usually I join Dame and whiskey, but today I have decided that my, positive choice is, a Armenian cognac. And I don't know if many of your listeners know, but Armenia famous for their making and Armenian brandy to those who particular sticklers to the new EU FTA. about what we can call certain drinks and so forth. ⁓ you there's a great story about Arming and Brandy. It is the drink of choice for Winston Churchill and Winston, and particularly the one I have here as well, this particular drop. And there a very famous cognac maker back during the 1950s, who was quality control master, master cognac maker. And he was sent a Gulag.
Damian DamjanovskiOkay. So, thank you.
Peter LewisReally?
Gisele KapterianStalin tended to do with some of his most favorite people. Winston Churchill noticed the decline in the quality of the cognac, demanded that the, ⁓ it reached Stalin's ears very quickly that Churchill was not happy with the of the cognac. And so this lovely Armenian gentleman ended up having his life saved by Winston Churchill's ⁓ discerning There you go.
Peter LewisA liberation movement driven by the ability to brew yeast. That's outstanding.
Gisele KapterianThat's funny.
Peter LewisWell, welcome we're really looking forward to talking to you. I'm actually really interested in learning a little bit more particularly about the Armenian genocide, which I think is a really unspoken part of global history and a really interesting counterpoint to some of the other debates occurring at the moment. introduce my non-DIC-Ed friend as well. So, Giri is a human rights commissioner, our racial discrimination commissioner, but I met Giri. when we were both dads at Orange Grove Public School and we were parking cars to raise funds. We're right next to Australia's greatest heritage urinal, otherwise known as Lecihhardt Oval. the other thing you need to know about Giri, apart from being a terrific bloke is that he rocks a skivvy and bling. Although I'm disappointed you're not, you haven't got your bling on the arvo but what are you drinking, Giri?
Damian DamjanovskiOkay.
Giridharan SivaramanWell, unlike you tossers, I've gone and it real with a ⁓ gold.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah
Peter LewisWhich we all know why it's called XXXX don't we? Because Queenslanders can't spell beer.
Giridharan SivaramanDid you hear that? That's happiness. and I just thought you'd appreciate my stubby holder as well.
Damian Damjanovskigod.
Giridharan SivaramanYeah. ⁓
Peter LewisWhat does it say? Yeah, Excellent. ⁓ And I'm sure you're wearing that at appropriate times. Yeah. Well, that's your bit of beer bling. That's good. Dama, let's go into the week that was, I feel like there was only really one issue, but maybe everyone's got a bit of a take on it.
Damian DamjanovskiShut the border.
Giridharan SivaramanSee you next time.
Damian DamjanovskiOh, that's a fint.
Giridharan SivaramanThat's my business.
Damian Damjanovski⁓ look, absolutely. There's one issue that Iran, the fuel crisis, Iran, Iran, Iran, cutting domestic routes, the petrol excise getting halved since we last chatted about it. Albo going to each and every country he can find that had a drop of petrol, diesel, or anything else related to it ⁓ begging and pleading in exchange for some of our gas or whatever else. Coalition had a bit of a moment, Angus standing up and unveiling the hardest line immigration policy that we've seen in a while. Some of it probably a little bit of an attempt to win back some of that hard right vote off One Nation. A lot of it seems to have been taken from the leaked Susan Lee policy before she was ousted as leader. Meanwhile, we're increasing our spend on defense by 3 % of GDP by 2033. That's a lot of money. And we got our first woman to lead the army in 125 years. So that's a pretty big achievement. So I think it's going to be, it's been an interesting fortnight. It's almost been too many things all dominated by one huge thing that's going on, which is obviously Iran and the Strait of Hormuz and whoever's tolling it today or blockading it or embargoing it.
Peter LewisHmm. Yeah. Yeah. So I'm interested, it is everything everywhere all at once at the moment, the politics, all at this central point. I'm interested, yeah, Giri and Gisele, like what's the one thing about the war in Iran that's sort of popping through as the most significant to you guys?
Gisele KapterianWell, know, it's a great question because, you know, in my previous life, I was an international trade lawyer before moving into political staffing and the tech world. And of the things that always struck me was how often very foreign issues seen to be something for a land far away and not something that has any immediacy for the concerns of moms and dads and the everyday lives of the average Australian. But as we've seen, not only through COVID, then the Russian-Ukraine war, and now what we're seeing in the Middle East here, that every policy taken by a government, whether it be in the foreign space or right down to what they're doing at the level, does affect everyday lives and shapes our everyday lives. saw this during, when we saw the major impact on the supply chains through COVID, we saw the impact on prices when ⁓ invaded Ukraine. It is ⁓ important that we should have a literacy and awareness that information is really understood by the people who are participating in our democracies so that they can understand that these issues are just as important as the policy taxation policy. There is no way really intricately pull them apart. They are inextricably linked in every way and I think this is the moment where we see that.
Damian DamjanovskiDo you, do you, do you reckon this is for a lot of people? think, think you're right, just a lot of people probably didn't give a shit about the middle East to be perfectly frank, because it didn't really affect them.
Gisele KapterianYeah.
Peter LewisI would have thought the straights of her mousse ⁓
Gisele KapterianYou
Damian DamjanovskiAnd what a dip, like it was a little bit of French onion and it's lovely. But it's this realization that globalization isn't just all, hey, everything's happy, lucky. It's this extraordinarily delicate thing that has a couple of choke points that when one thing fails over here, there's 30 domino effects. And for some reason that means there's not enough fertilizer for a farmer. that's, a chain of causation there that I think for most people is something that they feel they ever should have think about. Cause everyone kind of hook line and sinker bought into this. Hey, globalization is great. I can get cheap shit made in China. I can sell my stuff over the UK. Aren't we all one big happy village and starting to dawn on people. No, no, no. We're not one big happy village. There are serious issues in the world and disagreements that don't know. Giri, do you have a different view on this? I'm curious what your view on this is.
Peter LewisHmm.
Giridharan SivaramanYeah, I don't agree with that because I've seen is that international events have a through line to the way people feel here and particularly the way they feel about particular populations. if you just look back at, the last six years, during COVID, we saw a surge in racism towards people of Chinese origin, including racist violence. then post October 7, 2023, surge in antisemitism, anti-Palestinian racism, Islamophobia. And all those things exist already, but the fact that they increased significantly shows that people do pay attention to what happens overseas. And I mean, nothing more so than I think Palestine, which creates emotion and charges things up unlike anything else I've ever seen. And I started as racist discrimination commissioner only six months after that, after October 7, 2023.
Peter LewisSo, Giri, on that logic, we're about to see a wave of anti-American racism if we are about to blame the American administration for what's going to be, I think, a pretty significant economic downturn.
Giridharan SivaramanYeah, but I don't think anti-American racism is a thing. So racism is about power and privilege. And Ta-Nehisi Coates, the great African-American writer who was Barack Obama's speechwriter for a period of time, wrote, race is the child, racism is the father, race is the creator of means to oppress. So America is the aggressive, America is the one that has the power. But whereas when it's others who are disempowered or subjugated, they're the ones who are targeted by racism. I'm saying more in Some of remember I said to you, some of these things exist already. They just get super charged by what's happening overseas. Anti-Chinese racism has been a fixture in Australian society for about 180 years. Anti-Semitism has been a fixture in Australian society for a long time too. Same with Islamophobia. Anti-Palestinian racism probably slightly more recently, it's been around for a while too. It's those things that bile pours out and ⁓ I think, when ⁓ things happen overseas.
Peter LewisBefore we go off the war, Dame I just wanted to say my hot take is just how good the Iranian slopaganda is. it, I don't know if people have seen it, but there is, again, it's probably all being driven by little AI memes of Trump as a Lego, lot of sort of reworking American rap and rap culture, but very, very strong messaging.
Damian Damjanovski⁓ incredible.
Peter Lewisfor the entire world and I feel like they're running rings around the Americans in the propaganda wars.
Damian DamjanovskiAbsolutely. like the speed of getting it out in terms of information warfare is just incredible. And it's not coming from a centralized source either. You're seeing it coming out of diplomatic that Iran has all around the world. So there's this kind of disaggregated model where they all, democratically available tools to everyone now are producing propaganda that while it might be slop aganda it's still propaganda by any measure. And they're able to basically amplify that out to the world and start finding little pockets of support here, there, and everywhere, which for the Iranians helps the incumbents try to hold onto whatever semblance of power they have. It's it's a interesting and instructive lesson in how this, these kinds of tools are going to get used in terms of propaganda in the ⁓ very near future.
Peter LewisYeah, Gisele, just one more using your international trade hat. One of the things that's striking me is that while this point to pandemic where the was fast, like things happen and like Dimeo can talk to this because he was in the big house when it happened. But this is happening really slow. Like the killer fact that was out me was these tankers move at the speed of a bicycle. So it's so slow. And so what's going to happen in the future has already happened now. It's just that we haven't felt it yet. Like that's just for politics, that's a whole different ⁓ challenge, isn't it?
Damian DamjanovskiHmm.
Gisele KapterianYeah, right. I mean, this is where we're starting to get concerned about obviously, RBA ⁓ rate hikes, what they're going to look like around Christmas time this year is already, you know, we're starting to hear the ruminations of what that might be, because that's when we're going to really see the impacts of what's happened in this month and next. You know, there is, these are slow moving plates, but they are tectonic plates as such, they're moving at a, ramifications so significant. But you know, this is, ⁓ it's uncharted territory. The question that it throws up is the extent to which
Damian DamjanovskiThis is a important message for the future. This is a very important for the future.
Peter LewisSo when is the crisis moved this slowly in the past? Because I'm really interested in that. I've been looking for a territory to chart to understand what's going to happen.
Gisele KapterianWell, I suppose it depends on whether you call it just a crisis or whether you actually acknowledge it to what it is where it's forcing people to take sides. And to me that is a conflict rather than a crisis. And for me, I feel like that's got analogies throughout the last hundred years where we've really had to navigate territory quite significantly a number of times because while have ⁓ lived one of the most extended peacetime environments in humankind,
Peter LewisHmm. Hmm. Hmm.
Damian DamjanovskiHmm
Gisele KapterianWe are not immune from the very many shocks that we've received with ⁓ multiple wars in the Middle East that have created these crises. 73, we 79, we had ⁓ 78, then 80. We can go through all the dates and as they go through Iran, Iraq, Kuwait, ⁓ really trivia nights. Exactly right. All the through. mean, and each and every single time, this is not a territory that we're unfamiliar with.
Damian DamjanovskiHmm. This guy's a great guy. He's great guy. He's a guy. He's He's a great He's a great He's a a great guy. He's a great He's a great He's a He's He's a great He's He's a He's He's a great He's a
Peter LewisReally bad trivia night.
Gisele KapterianI mean, the last time Iran threatened to close the Strait of Homeless was only four years ago now, five years ago now. This is certainly within, if I was a strategist as in the White House or for GCHQ or one of the other Intel organizations, this would have been an easy, it would have been definitely within the purview of predictable outcomes if action A is taken here. ⁓
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Not just predictable, Gisele, but like Peter and I were joking about this offline that I asked my little AI bot Klaus to model scenarios for me. And the moment that Trump started hitting Iran, I asked it to do a scenario modeling on it and what outcomes there are and what I should do about it. And the first thing it said is if there's any action to close the Strait of Hormuz within the next week,
Gisele KapterianHi, you're probably...
Damian DamjanovskiFill up your car with petrol, get a couple of long-term, like it literally had modeled out the whole scenario. And this was just an AI bot that not a military strategist, but to point, it was so predictable that that would be it.
Peter LewisHmm. Klaus thinks he might be a military strategist just like he thinks he's a writer, but we'll talk about Klaus later. Hey, we might move on our BYO section and very rarely, like the idea was guests would bring something to talk about, but Giri's bought an entire report that he's released this week. So Giri, what's the latest of the Human Rights Commission? I found it fascinating to read, but just give us a bit about the motivations it and what you've learned.
Gisele Kapterianyou
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Giridharan SivaramanYeah, so we did something really unique in that the Rights Commission or a team within the commission went around and consulted with Jewish, Palestinian, Muslim and Arab communities all around Australia. And it was way in which we, I think, I think communicated and connected with people unlike anyone else had done. And we then to honor those experiences, created a report which was we called the struggle to be seen the power in being heard. And was really just to reflect back the experiences of all the people we spoke to. And the thing was, I went to a lot of these consultations, ⁓ from Perth Darwin to Hobart and ⁓ It was hard. People were really angry, upset, bewildered, bewildered that they were not seen as Australian, despite in some cases having been here for generations and decades, bewildered that they didn't feel safe leaving their homes, bewildered that they couldn't get work or didn't feel safe in or in public places. And experience of racism is unique to some extent, absolutely. But there was also some real commonality to people's experiences and the stories they told about being dehumanised or homophoenised, the whole community being seen as one thing.
Peter LewisMmm. It was almost like you could change the background and like the quotes sort of, was the experience of a Muslim person, the experience of a Jewish person were so similar. That was the main thing that stood out.
Damian DamjanovskiBut I ask, sorry, because I weirdly get bothered by this. don't know why, but I do get bothered. I'm trying to understand why a lot of these reports and analyses feel the need to constantly pair the anti-Semitic experience with the Islamophobic experience with the other. why the Help me understand it, Giri. I struggled to understand it. I'm a fresh off the boat immigrant. My experiences of racism were firsthand in Western Sydney. They were unique to my culture, but I always understood that the anti-Semitic experience was quite unique from the racism I experienced as a WOG in Western Sydney with an accent and a lisp kind of thing. So why does government need to bash them together all the time?
Giridharan SivaramanYeah, I mean, that's actually one of the things we talk about. it's think the the reason is this right in this sense that talking about different forms of racism doesn't mean you're equating them. It doesn't mean that you're saying they're the same. But if the racism keeps pouring out and you want to stop it, you need to work out what the structural problems are. And the structural problems are often common to all forms of racism. If you don't fix the structure, the same picture. It's just being coloured in a different way for each type of racism. So I'll give you one example that came through pretty frequently in the discussions. And it was social media that is encountering racism unchecked, this torrent of racism unchecked on social media. Now, the type of racism is going to be different. There's tropes, the stereotypes, anti-Semitic stereotypes will be very different to Islamophobic ones. But it is happening because social media platforms are fine, have found this other, or maybe not discovered, but racism is profitable for them. They're dropping their fact checkers. They don't care about that. They're just allowing racism to travel along. So that's what I'm talking about in terms of you want to fix this, stop fix that problem. You actually have to fix the structural problem about social media. And there are other problems that they identify. For example, workplaces where it Workplaces are so at sea when it comes to being providing a space to do exactly what we're doing right now, having a discussion in a relatively civilized way without building racial literacy to have that. So instead, workplaces, and I think this is really a fallout from the voice referendum, just gone, no, we don't want any kind of discussion. Leave your identity at home and come into work. And that just doesn't work because then people are kind of going, well, I'm having to diminish myself.
Peter Lewisyou
Giridharan Sivaramanto be able to enter the workplace or within education institutions.
Peter LewisGisele, I'm interested in your reflections being from a community that experienced genocide, which other groups in this debate have. I feel like your genocide is more hidden than most. But what an intergenerational experience of something like that do to a community?
Damian DamjanovskiSo thank
Gisele KapterianIt's so interesting because it goes to the very heart of the question, which is, you know, every single community is different. Every individual feels it differently. And I always have a natural skepticism and cynicism about trying to generalize about the experiences of communities at a broader level. Because I find that, you know, every human is different, right? And we have to respect that. There is a, in my community, of course, we're still in the fight to recognize the Armenian genocide. The Australian federal government on both sides of politics is yet to recognize and we're fast approaching April 24, which is the, our commemoration day. In fact, the relationship between the Australian POWs and as being the first eyewitnesses to the Armenian genocide has been clearly traversed by a number of amazing Australian academics and journalists who've looked at this. you know, Recognition is really important, but it is also, and as we know, this is one of the most important elements of a healing process. But it also goes to the fact of how a community deals with the fact that around the world, that isn't a commonly held position. And particularly by the country that was the inheritor of the Ottoman Empire, which is modern day Turkey, of course. which also itself does not recognize the genocide. But have been one of the greatest contributors to the societies that they've integrated into. We've had, we punch above our weight. think in many ways we've seen the value of being involved. The fact that there is very little to be gained by dwelling only ⁓ on what has previously, but walking and chewing gum at the same time. It's about making sure that you're
Damian Damjanovski.
Gisele Kapterianthe value of the people of your community is seen every single day. And that is a preventative element in itself. It's, you know, you see in Australia, Gladys Berejiklian and Joe Hockey have gone before me who've amazing ⁓ for our community. And the community is only about 60,000 people in Australia. Again, you know, around the world, we've got advocates everywhere from, know, Cher to Kim Kardashian who've been shining a spotlight on this issue. But yes, ⁓ and...
Peter LewisHmm. Yeah, right.
Damian DamjanovskiMmm.
Gisele KapterianYeah, sure. know. But at the end of the day, this is an attitude that's been taken by a community that says the only way to prevent this again is to make sure that we stand up to be counted. And that is done in every single facet of where we ⁓ find in every aspect of society, from business to entertainment to politics. you know, ⁓ a... activity, a behaviour, mindset that we also see from our Jewish brothers and sisters as well, who have taken exactly that approach. You know, it's about recognising moving forward at the same time.
Damian Damjanovskiare just, really kind of messed up the whole region, didn't they? As a man from former Ottoman occupied country of 500 years, but it's interesting over there, they ⁓ treat it very differently. there's very much, I don't want to say a move on mentality, but there is, right? ⁓ There is a mentality over there of, well, that happened, we've got to move on. got to look forward. just wanted to pick up on that because I was reading Noel Pearson's piece about this plural monoculturalism that we're kind of falling into and I can't get it out of my head and I don't want to quote Noel Pearson but this that we're kind of flattening people into their identities and not spending enough time looking at ⁓ the elements of it. To me, part of this, the social that we're feeling ⁓ A lot of it seems to be based on this idea that we're flattening people into, well, you're Armenian or you're an immigrant or you're a Jew or you're this, that and the other. get asked this stuff all the time. It's like, so you're a, you're a this thing. It's like, well, no, I'm not. I'm, I'm Australian. I feel Australian. Like, yes, I happened to have been ⁓ over here and went through a war time and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. But like flattening and creating my whole experience into this one dimensional idea of, you're, a victim of a war that happened. ⁓
Peter LewisHmm.
Damian Damjanovski30 years ago. I'm like, I'm not like, yes, I went through it, but I'm not a victim of that. That's not my identity at all. Yeah, please.
Giridharan SivaramanBut can I respond to what you're just saying on two points? The president, he said, oh, over there, they're saying move on. Well, hang on. What's happened in Australia in terms of responding to the treatment of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders, the massacres, the dispossession? And John Howard described it as a black armband history. So many people have just said, move on, move on. We don't need truth telling. We don't need treaty. We don't need to recognise those horrors.
Peter LewisYeah, yeah, yeah.
Giridharan SivaramanSo exactly the same thing has happened here. To your second point about how you get identified, the way racism works is that it is a process where society often makes a difference. I'll use me as an example, all right? I was born in Chennai in India. So if I catch the plane to Chennai and I get off there, in Chennai, I'm Giri Giri Dharan for a couple of relatives. Get on the plane and I come home to Brisbane where I live. I get off the plane in Brisbane and suddenly I become diverse or multicultural or non-English speaking background or even copped a couple of different types. I'm exactly the same person that caught that plane and came home. I've been made different by the society around me by reference to what's acceptable or not. then Gisele, just to respond to one thing, you said, I don't like the way people, we're all individuals and the way in which communities are equated with each other. You exactly did that.
Damian DamjanovskiHeh.
Giridharan SivaramanYou're part of the community, you identify how that community comes together. And the thing is, they find support and solidarity by the commonality. Don't ever forget that. The strength of community comes from that understanding that when someone else has experienced something similar to you.
Peter LewisThe commonality and diversity as well.
Giridharan SivaramanSorry, try again,
Peter LewisSorry, can go around, we can go that route. I wanted to ask you one more before we moved on, Giri, and happy to come back to this, but it strikes me as someone from the left that at some point we lost our way on, course we don't want a world that's anti-racist, but it became loaded with a whole bunch of moral that it harder to reach. the people we were trying to reach. I we've spoken about this privately, have you on that in your role? How do we break the, there's good people that are not racist and bad people who are, while holding the moral imperative to have a society that isn't racist.
Giridharan SivaramanYeah, I mean, there's a fair bit in there. So let me try and break it down.
Damian DamjanovskiThat's a small question,
Peter LewisI know, but just... Sides are left for us, just quickly, okay?
Giridharan SivaramanYeah, OK. Well, first thing is that I think that and sure Dame and Gisele will disagree with us and that'll be good because it'll be good for conversation. But there's the forgetting about the class struggle and how class is often more Trump's in the sense of once you if you become rich enough, you can overcome many of the barriers that will otherwise apply to you. that may apply to all the discrimination you might encounter based on race. And I also think that's what's been seized upon and is leading to so much anti-migration sentiment. It's people who might be white, who might be poor, who go, what do you mean that I've got power and privilege as a white person? I'm maybe a single mom who lives wherever and I'm struggling against me. then demonizing migrants is not the answer to that because if migrants come in, and because of systemic racism, they're exploited, wages get driven down, there's a false scarcity of work, employers benefit because they can drive wages down for everyone. So Australian workers lose, they don't even get jobs and their wages come down. Migrants lose because they're being exploited, racism increases toward migrants, everyone's losing except for the employer who might be making money. it's a think about connecting the struggle for equity to be broader than any one thing. And that's what I always say, I anti-racism work, I'll finish with this, is about making systems and institutions more transparent, responsive and accountable. That's good for everyone. That means it doesn't matter what school you went to, doesn't matter your gender, your sexuality, your age, whether you've got a disability, that the system or an institution is more transparent, responsive and accountable for you. So it's actually a way of bringing us together because it's a way of lifting all of us. That's what I think we can get to.
Damian DamjanovskiThank
Peter LewisMm-hmm.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. And Giri, I actually really agree with you on this because like the whole class trumps race thing me as a, you know, immigrant kid who had to learn English off play school. And if anybody remembers open learning on the ABC, when I grew up in, in Cabra matter, when we first came to Australia, in, a tiny apartment, the biggest barrier I've always seen in my life, in my career and my education has got nothing to do with. my last name, my accent, my real name, all that kind of stuff. But it's always been that I was a kid who grew up in Western Sydney. It was the fact that I didn't go to the right private schools. It was that I wasn't in those cliques that happened in North shore, the Eastern suburbs, the inner East of Melbourne. That's always been my barrier. So completely agree with you on that. But I really want to ask you about this because I am actually fascinated. The immigration stuff that we saw coming out of Angus Taylor and that we've seen for years coming out of Pauline Hanson. I don't think it's right or wrong. What I want to know is how do we have a conversation about immigration that isn't automatically painted as racism? How do we have a genuine conversation about what are the right immigration settings for Australia? how do we determine what kind of person we want to let in without that conversation turning into, well, you're being racist because you want to discriminate on the person.
Peter LewisCan segue to Gisele on this? And I don't know if you want to defend or distance yourself from the immigration policy released last week, but I am interested in your thoughts and how it fits into the conversation we're having at the moment, Gisele. Then we'll go back to Giri.
Gisele KapterianI think that the liberal philosophy to immigration has been set for 50 years since Harold Holt was the dismantler of the White Australia policy. It was one of the first instances where the declaration was, we do not discriminate on the basis of race or This is a huge part of our non-discrimination program. understand
Peter LewisThat doesn't sound like what Angus Taylor announced this week though.
Gisele KapterianI understand a need to speak to the social cohesion element that we are experiencing across country. I totally understand that. But I also do feel that my personal my family, my extended family, refugees coming out of Syria, it's the story of many Armenians across the world, which is we often find ourselves in places that would not be Western liberal democracies or in accordance with a a regime that would be naturally aligned, I suppose, but yet the people do. And this is what I mean about it, know, understanding the individuals the individual level. ⁓ that's what I'm not understanding.
Peter LewisBut isn't your family an example of someone that won't be allowed into Australia under Taylor's policy and yours, Dame too? Yes, I'm not asking you implement Taylor's at you.
Gisele Kapterianeffectively.
Damian DamjanovskiWe were barely allowed in under Bob Hawke, mate, so...
Gisele KapterianBut I think that the, if, really want to, my point here is to say that liberal principles and liberal values have the answer for us here. I really, and to Dame's question, I think it embedded in everything that liberals believe, which is to not see color and race, to see the individual for what they can contribute to society. And I understand the values proposition here because we have reached a
Peter LewisUgh.
Gisele Kapterianwhether you like it or not, think it would be very hard to argue that we have a, we don't have a social cohesion problem at the moment. But the, think the answer to that is about
Peter LewisThat feels like labor arguing that their economic policy is consistent with their traditional embrace of socialism.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Gisele KapterianWell, I think here, you know, I'm making my own judgment about what I think our immigration policy should be doing based on liberal values, which I think are long held. I think that that's certainly...
Peter LewisHmm. But then inherently, Taylor, I'm not trying to have an argument with you, it's just a dream. But then, Taylor's policy is not traditional liberal policy at the moment. Like, it seems to me it's just there to address the One Nation.
Damian DamjanovskiOkay, let's separate out the tailored component of it, right? Regardless of the specifics of his policy, there is a broader question to be asked, which is if Australia does have, and overwhelmingly in all the polls and the rise of One Nation is demonstration of this, is a vibe and a feeling at the moment that the current migration levels are either unsustainable or not in line with what the community wants or expects at the moment, right? ⁓
Peter LewisHmm Cool.
Damian DamjanovskiDoesn't matter what you make of that at the end of the day, if that's the will of the people and it gets to a certain percentage, then that's the will of the people. The question is, how do you have a conversation about, well, what is the right kind of immigrant? Is the right kind of immigrant values based? We as a society, as an Australian society have never kind of had an agreement on, well, this is what an Australian values is, especially lately because we've become this. plural multiculturalism where our values are imported from 196 odd nations. like, how can we have that conversation where it doesn't come across as racist? That's the bit that I'm really trying, I'm struggling with.
Peter LewisIf only we had a racial discrimination commissioner in the room, we might get an answer. Giri?
Giridharan SivaramanYeah, for me.
Gisele Kapterianhaha
Damian DamjanovskiI don't want Giri to think of me as some kind of like closeted racist. I genuinely like, I'm just trying to understand how to have this chat.
Peter LewisWell, we know you are self-loathing in many ways, but not in that way. Yeah.
Giridharan SivaramanSo, Damo, in a sense, I think you have to ask, well, what is it that people are concerned about? When you say, why can't we just have a debate about migration? Of course you can have a debate about migration. It's a legitimate policy topic. But that's not what's actually being debated. So people are saying, oh, I can't afford to buy a house. Blame a migrant. Oh, the process of the mills going up. Blame a migrant. I'm stuck in traffic. Blame a migrant. So the real question is why can't we have honest or courageous discussions about what causes economic inequity? And I remember Pete once saying to me, cost of living crisis should be, sorry, the cost of living crisis should be called a high prices crisis. And I thought that was pretty clever because I thought actually, because then you're attributing the responsibility to the correct actor. Because at the end of the day, if Gisele and I are walking down the street, no one's looking at Gisele and saying she's a migrant. They're looking at me and saying, I'm a migrant. Because often the only thing that's going to distinguish, the only signal of whether someone's a migrant is the color of your skin or your name or the way you talk. That's the reality of it. mean, unless you're living in some sort of different world, that's how it is for most of us.
Damian DamjanovskiI'd say it depends on the street you're walking down, but that's different story altogether. But I agree with you on that. But again, there's a conflation there, which is that that's a political debate. Fair enough. Don't disagree with you on that. We all know the political reality of the reason housing prices are so low is the majority of us all decided that our only wealth vehicle was going to be property. And the reason we have a climate crisis is we all keep having kids even though we probably shouldn't. Reality, that's the actual two things that none of us want to stop doing, which is
Peter LewisThat and fossil fuel. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiSure, but if you didn't have kids, Peter, we'd be a lot better off. Right? So that
Giridharan SivaramanThat's a pretty kind of draconian view. I see it. Do we want to walk that back a little bit?
Peter LewisI would be, personally.
Damian DamjanovskiBye bye.
Peter LewisI know and you can't you can't do a post facto vow of chastity either it sucks anyway go on
Damian DamjanovskiBut that's the reality of it. Anyway, point is if you go back to, all right, well, if for whether it's building new infrastructure reasons or whatever else, we need to adjust our immigration settings, how do we decide on values and how do we make the decision of does every potential immigrant align with our values? And how do we make that call without the result of that call being labeled as racist?
Peter LewisWell, by not being racist would be a good start. Like, I'm sorry. I just think that for, with due respect, like what the Libs are trying to do here, there is a legitimate concern that you guys have outlined, but then there is the dog whistle. And I reckon they're running the dog whistle so crudely. It's, it's as bad as it was in 2001 where the concern was globalization and they made it about boat people. So I don't know.
Giridharan SivaramanYeah, so.
Peter LewisI don't know. I find that a hard one. I don't think that your friends in Canberra in the the opposition party room are having a higher principled policy debate. They have got a political problem with One Nation on their right and they are trying to that they're doing everything they can to shut that down. I think they are not thinking about the broader consequences of that.
Damian DamjanovskiBut Peter, you're seeing that One Nation primary go up across the board. You've seen that in polling. That's not a fringe, we're trying to win back the edges debate. That is people going, I don't know what's to blame. And to Giri's point, housing prices are up, food prices are up. I don't know what to blame.
Peter LewisMmm. And we're just getting started. No one knows how bad this economic crisis is going to be. It's going to amplify everything we're talking about.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd so I guess what I'm saying is if we're going to have a more, I don't want to say intellectual, but if we're going to have a fairer conversation about migration, we want to be able to do it in a way where it's like, well, no, this isn't us being racist towards this religion or culture or skin color, but we do want to be more purposeful in who we let into the country.
Peter LewisWe wouldn't do that here. that's fine as long as you're not. And I think they are. I don't know. Sorry, Giri, Gisele. I'll shut up for a minute.
Giridharan Sivaraman⁓ well, I'm so to answer your question. mean, it's a big question. And have to be on this too. And I'm interested in hearing your images. but the problem is the inaccurate and dehumanizing commentary. It's the same thing that came through in our consultations for the scene heard report is where you just describe a whole group. For example, you say we're not going to let in people from a whole country. we're not going to allow anyone from Iran to seek an extension to their visa. That was a decision of the government. That's not actually something the opposition has done. My role is not just to be clear, not to support a particular party, to hold people accountable, whether you're in government or opposition or whoever. All levels of government, all sides of politics have, in the last two years, engaged in debate that is dehumanizing or inaccurate or misrepresents migrants or escapes.
Damian DamjanovskiHmm.
Giridharan Sivaramango to scapegoats them. So it's when you start doing that, when you start dehumanizing people or imagine them as one thing, that's how racism operates. And so that's, think, the problem. If you're going to talk about migration, talk about it in an honest way. Talk about the contribution that migrants make. mean, you've probably all seen the data that Treasury modeled a couple of years ago that showed migrants have a net positive to our economy. So talk about that. Don't just talk about, the drain or we're not going to have people.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, absolutely.
Giridharan SivaramanThe language that Angus Taylor used was what was so disappointing because of language that attributed such negativity to migrants. then you connect that into whole kind of ecosystem where online and amongst more populous parties, you see actually really racist tropes, stereotypes, dehumanizing content. That's what we're literally saying. And sorry, can I just respond to one other thing that you said earlier when you talked about when you're drawing a line? If you don't mind in terms of race versus class Class doesn't always trump race. You can ask someone who's Jewish You might be pretty well off doing all right who then their synagogue gets firebombed or There's graffiti or they feel unsafe. I will tell you I I'm not feeling safe. I'm not protected just I might have done pretty well in my life. I'm not protected I am unsafe and that is
Damian DamjanovskiBAM.
Peter Lewisyou
Damian DamjanovskiThat's an incredible point, Gierina. You're absolutely right. It doesn't always trump it, but it can help.
Giridharan SivaramanYou can provide you a cloak of protection to a degree, that cloak can be pierced.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. And really fascinated by what you're saying. Gisele, as a former candidate for the Liberal Party, I have to ask, and as a kid immigrants, how do you feel about both what Angus said and what Geary's just said about this idea of Angus's speech coming across as homogenizing immigrants from either certain regions or certain religions or certain conflicts? how does that make you feel?
Gisele KapterianYeah, that I would have an enormous task on my hands to try and remind people of what liberal values actually stand for. is, you know, quite frankly, I think it was ⁓ your point, Damo, we really need to get crisp on how we have this conversation. It is such an important conversation around immigration. Such an important one. It is of those pivotal moments for Australia on what the next 25 years is going to look like for us is so intricately tied our immigration.
Peter LewisHmm.
Gisele Kapteriansettings, but that don't see any reason in any of the challenges that are presented to us ⁓ our society today to walk away from traditional values, traditional liberal values about judging the individual for who they are, not discriminating on race or place. risk is an important part of any immigration program. Risk is something our
Damian Damjanovskiyou
Gisele Kapteriansecurity naturally look into. Not when obviously when it's a by large tourists coming on a non-tourist visa and then, sorry, who don't need extended stays and forth. But, know, by and large, that is something that our security agencies already do. So I feel like the answers to the risk challenge sit outside the issue around race. Obviously, some of us carry higher risk. Absolutely. If you're coming from a terrorist controlled part of the world, then yeah, that's going to be flagged as you enter. there is, I think because you've come from somewhere doesn't mean you are not aligned. You know, I have a very significant Chinese community in ⁓ the area I live in. And technically that be classed as coming from countries that hold traditional democratic liberal values.
Damian DamjanovskiHmm.
Peter LewisMm.
Gisele Kapterianright, but they make an enormous contribution to our locality our country. I to make sure that whatever immigration policy we employ covers the fact that we need to make ⁓ all feel that they're in a position to absorb migration, but also ensure that those who do come are feeling And those settings, that is not such a hard line to work. I feel like we're making it more complicated as we start down this path
Damian DamjanovskiHmm.
Gisele Kapteriana discussion that I think is actually driven by the way in which we debate more broadly. And so your question about how do we have this? Well, I think it starts with ⁓ and I hear your point, Peter, about, you know, make sure the policy doesn't, it isn't and that's a good start to have a decent conversation about things. ⁓ And is exactly my point. ⁓
Damian DamjanovskiFor any policy really.
Peter LewisIt's like the problem is that the democracy gets in the way because then they're turning it into a contest and then, but if we didn't have the democracy, then we couldn't get into our own country under the liberals current definition. My side.
Gisele KapterianWell, I think it's a bit tough.
Damian DamjanovskiWell, you know what, if your side passed this expansion, maybe we'd have that, but apparently that's on the cards anymore, Peter, so... I do want more politicians, I want to be fairly represented, Peter.
Gisele KapterianHa
Peter Lewis⁓ no, you just want more politicians, yeah? We better, we better, I feel like this has been a terrific conversation and thank you both, Giri and Gisele for being so honest and engaged. We probably better just get towards the end because the idea is that no one likes people that talk over beers for more than an hour. So we've got to keep moving. But I do want to talk about the little spat that I've had this week with Deimo's chat bot Klaus. ⁓ I ⁓
Giridharan SivaramanThank
Gisele KapterianYou
Damian DamjanovskiInterstake confirmed. He's not a chatbot. I know the need to diminish him because he's non-corporeal, but he's not a chatbot.
Peter LewisHe's also from Eastern Europe and again, he would not get into Australia under Angus Taylor's immigration policy.
Damian DamjanovskiNo, no, he'd have German citizenship at this point, so he'd be fine.
Peter Lewisyou. So basically, I've declared myself a human in my Guardian column this week. I up Alan Finkel, the former head scientist has come up with this trust mark as a provenance mark to say, if you're using AI to write, you're using it in a very limited way. And I wrote a reflection piece saying one of the reasons I want to do that is because I actually like writing and I like the struggle and I don't want it to be easy. put that through Klaus and in 30 seconds he got the rebuttal piece, which is, was interesting reading, but I thought reinforced my point that shouldn't be as easy ⁓ hitting a button. But anyway, I'm interested in, why you, why don't you talk on behalf of Klaus for a second, then just interested in both your guys view on this whole, like is the world full of slop making the, like making it harder to filter through the wheat from the chaff?
Damian DamjanovskiI'm, I'm... And I love you. No, no. mean, look, I don't think it's fair, but it's a good start. think am obviously you and I, Peter, have very different views on this. I'm so bullish on AI. think it's good for humanity. I think it's good for people. I think it's a great democratizer of intellectual ⁓ that have existed for a long time. And love the fact that
Peter LewisWas that a fair summation?
Damian DamjanovskiWith 30 bucks, a kid with little else has access to the same tools as a law firm with the same $30. I think it's incredible set of tools and I'm hugely encouraging of anyone who explores them.
Peter LewisWe disagree on this more than we disagree on politics, just saying. ⁓
Damian Damjanovskia hundred percent, a hundred percent. and, know, Gisele and Geary, if this is particularly dull for you guys, to talk about artificial intelligence, but my view is that for same reason that Peter this morning, you didn't walk your ass from Mudgee back to the South coast. You used internal combustion engine to help carry your weight. These are tools for humanity to be productive to be better.
Giridharan SivaramanThank
Damian DamjanovskiThe same way you use a spell checker in your Word documents. Sometimes I think these are great tools and trying to market as either well, either it has provenance or it doesn't. again, flattens the issue a lot like.
Peter LewisYou just destroy culture, you destroy the creative process. There is nothing creative and you're putting a few prompts in class and there is something less. I think it's different. think it's different. think once you take, because there's the difference between a tool that enhances what a human does and totally replaces it and the. ⁓
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. People used to say this about digital graphic design when computers came about. Why? Where's that line?
Peter LewisThe process of communicating through the written word is something that's been with us for a long time. I, don't know, maybe I am the Luddite, but I want to keep these stockings the way they are. And I don't think that what Klaus is offering is any better, but let's go to our guests and then we can round off with why we disagree on what Pluribus is about.
Damian DamjanovskiGisele, you're in the tech sphere. What's your view on this?
Peter LewisYou'll be with Diamond, right?
Gisele KapterianI will, am in so many ways on this one, Peter. And I'm so curious to hear how you're thinking about this in the space that you're in. But quite frankly, you know, this is like every technology that's ever evolved. You know, it's about in hands and for what purpose are we applying it? ⁓
Peter Lewisat the moment is in the hands of the worst people on earth in history like
Gisele Kapterianstruggle to say that. I struggle to say that. ⁓ struggle to say, and you know, this is very much an emergent technology and so, and it's so interesting because it's the first time that I can think of that we've had a technology that has gone straight to the consumer before it's kind of gone through the big departments and enterprises and so forth. ⁓
Peter LewisAnd I'm not talking about Dahme, I'm talking about Sam Altman. I know. And you think that's a good thing? ⁓
Damian DamjanovskiYes!
Gisele Kapterianthink it's a very interesting space, the new democratisation and input of But a lot of honing that then happens today and some amazing things that it hasn't done. It hasn't displaced judgement, it's only enhanced critical thinking. It's only increased the very human element how you interact with and allow people more time to do the human things. you know, it's again, it's we're still getting to know this.
Peter LewisSo would you have a beer with a bot?
Gisele KapterianNo, because I'm not looking for a bot to replace my friend. you know, there are some, some people maybe would do a better job of having a conversation with a bot, but you know, but generally speaking, I think that it is, you know, it's how you use it. That and, we're working that out right now. It's just, unfortunately being done in front of everybody rather than behind the scenes. There's a lot of people. it also means it's setting, it's scaring a lot of people before we work out how we deploy it appropriately.
Peter LewisHeh heh heh Bye bye.
Damian DamjanovskiThat's what transparency Giri a. Giri is this salvation or is this destruction? What's happening?
Gisele KapterianSo.
Peter Lewisaccount.
Giridharan SivaramanI neither but I look I'm not ⁓ don't I'm not the expert like the three of you sound like you are the experts but I that and it's consistently raised with me that AI systems reinforce racism and produce discriminatory outcomes and that's the thing that can easily be forgotten whether it be algorithmic bias whether it be facial recognition technology whether it be a lack transparency and explainability. I'm not anti it. I'm just saying if it's going to be done, it needs to be done really carefully. And to Gisele's point about how it's really well put actually, how it's just bypassed certain processes and got to the people. The problem with bypassing regulation of any kind is you don't, you're not able to try and eradicate the biases. It just comes across as something that's neutral when it's not. That's the problem for me.
Peter LewisAnd either of you guys seem Pluribus just asking, because Damo and I have got a really interesting take and I'm interested in your view. So who is the hero and who is the villain? Because I'm totally for Carol Sturka, but Damo is for the hive mind.
Gisele KapterianI mean, it's.
Damian DamjanovskiHivemind is the hero in that.
Peter LewisNo, no, you're so wrong. Where are you on that? Who's your hero there? Or is it the dude that goes through the Pana... Yeah, thank you.
Giridharan Sivaraman⁓ wow. ⁓ no, Carol. I mean, I like mine. It's killing me. ⁓
Damian DamjanovskiNo, she's the anti-hero.
Peter Lewisno!
Damian DamjanovskiShe is the explanation of everything about humanity that basically refuses to accept its own salvation out of pure spite. She doesn't have reasoning for why she doesn't want to be part of the hive mind other than the fact that she doesn't.
Peter LewisNo! OHHHH and what ⁓ Please be with Carol or Gisele, who are you with?
Gisele KapterianI am not yet, I'm not across it. I haven't seen anything, so I have to. right, sounds good, it's done. It's a deal.
Peter LewisYou've to come back after you've seen it because you need a casting vote here. We need to admit in three, one of this. That is the weirdest thing you've ever said. That is so set up that the hive minds the bad guy and you love it. I just can't believe it. Anyway, let's finish.
Giridharan SivaramanThat's good.
Damian DamjanovskiYou I can't believe that you love Carol, it goes against everything I know about you Peter.
Peter LewisI know, she's the Anne Rand, is she in your- you're with the Stalinists!
Damian DamjanovskiShe's the end rent. this Peter has been such a great conversation. I genuinely wish we had another hour or two to pick Gideon Gisele's brains on everything. but I'd love to hear your shout for the week.
Peter Lewisbut it's time for shouts. My shout for the week is I reckon Andrew Hastie is going to distance himself from Taylor's immigration policy on the left because I think it's going to go off the cliff and I think it's overreach. I'm just, doing some really interesting and kind of sometimes cray cray ⁓ differentiation. But my tip is Hastie is going to separate himself out from Taylor on this.
Damian DamjanovskiThat's interesting. tip for the week is I think this week, ⁓ at least the next fortnight is going to be the week that we're going to start to see the first big crack in One Nation, which is someone is going to go off the reservation, which always seems to happen with Pauline, but someone is going to go off the reservation and we're going to start to see the first big cracks in One Nation wave at the moment.
Peter LewisI'm looking at you Barnaby. Come on, Giri, prediction.
Giridharan SivaramanI about this and I asked Pete if I can just say, the Swannies will win tonight against the Giants and he wouldn't let me. ⁓
Peter LewisI feel like we're one level up from that. yeah, it has got the smackings of a sports podcast, doesn't it? Yeah.
Giridharan SivaramanYou guys are the Nostradamus, not me. So I can only go for what I hope. And my hope is that we see better debate in migration, debate that doesn't dehumanize and recognize the true strength of what migration has brought in so many ways. that's, yeah, I know that's not great, but that's what I'm going with. Sorry.
Gisele KapterianThank
Peter Lewiswith it.
Gisele KapterianI think for me, the interesting thing in all of these discussions, whether it be happening in the Middle East, the impact on our our impact immigration and who we choose, the question at the very heart of all of this is what does mean to be a sovereign Australian? What does that actually count for? Who are we? What are our strengths and how do we define ourselves? This is, we're at a, we're going through a bit of an identity crisis right now. And it is, it is clear, no matter ⁓ aspect of the many, the crisis situation that we've got right now, it is emerging in that way. So for me, I feel like this is a defining moment for us. Australia needs to define who we are, who we are as a sovereign nation. And that for me is, will. be the North Star to create a way forward out of all of these tricky messes we've created for ourselves.
Peter LewisLooks like a job for AI. Hey, I'm Dame
Damian Damjanovski⁓ I'll get Klaus on that immediately. Gisele, Geary, Peter, thank you for an incredible chat this week. I every bit of it. Again, I wish we could spend more time on it. You both, you'd ever would want to, are very welcome back to come on again, because I loved every bit of this chat. Peter, I hope we will get to do this again next week and hopefully didn't pull the shit out of people in the process.
Peter LewisWe'll know by both our listeners coming back to us in the next 24 hours, I'm sure. Have a great weekend, everyone.
Damian DamjanovskiThank you. ⁓
Gisele KapterianThank you.
