Episode 3

NDIS, AUKUS, and Energy

25 April 202640 min

The video for this episode is on our YouTube channel.

Show notes

We're in person this week talking about the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) and its complexities, international alliances, defence relationships, energy policy, and nuclear technology.

Chapters

  • 00:00 Drinks and Introductions
  • 07:12 History and Reform of the NDIS
  • 13:17 Challenges and Controversies of the NDIS
  • 21:08 International Alliances and Defence Relationships
  • 32:59 Nuclear Technology and Energy Transition

Full transcript

Read itHide it

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.

Speaker 2Alright, welcome to What's Your Poison? Episode 3, live in person. My name is Damian Damjanovski I'm joined by my colleague Peter Lewis. I am a... Oh, you do a whole great spiel that I actually...

Speaker 1is the spill. This the time that people that agree that the only good way to do so is over. A Friday afternoon which is what we're doing today. Well, this is actually something introduced me to. This is a cider. I was always cider refuse nik until you took us for lunch down at King Clarence, home of the Bunnings roll. ⁓

Speaker 2Agreed. And what is your poison today Peter Lewis? the Chinese modern one.

Speaker 1I am kind of sick of beer, which happens. Like I think everyone's born with a certain number of beers their algorithm. maxed out a long time ago, but I've been continuing regardless, but I've been finding it quite refreshing.

Speaker 2And I think I'll I hope you like this one. So this is obviously from our fridge collection here. It's my new favorite cider. It's called better cider. I do know it's got a lot of sugar. Well this one's got very little sugar in it. Which is why it's really nice and refreshing. So it's quite nice. My poison is quite the opposite. I've gone for a Brookvale Union vodka passion fruit which tastes like an alcoholic passion fruit.

Speaker 1We're both on the lolly water and will notice that both our guests bailed on us. But we had actually a member of the blue team and the green team so we're going to mush them up into a tail but we'll save that for another...

Speaker 2That's totally all right. Say that for another time. I don't know if you want to run us through some of the interesting things that happened this week. Obviously, we've had Mark Butler up at the Press Club doing some stuff. We had Hasty at the Menzies Centre down in Melbourne, which is not the Menzies Research Centre, it's the Menzies Institute.

Speaker 1kind of interesting set piece speeches are back in vogue. It's kind of like the to slopinion, no one's reading op-eds anymore, thank you Klaus. And tweets go either, so long considered speeches are starting.

Speaker 2think there's a correlation between the death of Twitter and the rise of these speeches and these op-eds. And I think also the death of Twitter has led to the rise of the sub-stack, which I'm loving.

Speaker 1At the height of Twitter, is how bad Twitter was, used to a live celebrity live Twitter, which was a very BC class celebrity, but I used to get caught up to be their live Twitter. was the biggest adrenaline. You'd be sitting there on your tweet deck and you'd be trying to pump up, ⁓ prepare whole bunch. You're trying to pump up about a hundred tweets in the 40 minute period. was like a high adrenaline rush with ⁓ absolutely return on investment. ⁓

Speaker 2Yeah. I'm five people reading the tweets. days of Twitter were very early days when it a platform that had just working in Australia and they didn't have an app because apps didn't exist yet. It all happened through SMS and the only people you had on Twitter were people you physically knew. It was such a great tool because rather than messaging 10 people, again group chats didn't exist, ⁓ you would send tweet that said I'm heading down to the cafe, the pub or whatever and then 20 of your friends would receive the same tweet as an SMS message, two of them would respond back going, great, I'll you there in half an hour. So was this immense coordination.

Speaker 1It's almost like the small closed groups that we think of. I was introduced by a guy called Eric Lee who was one of the first labour online activists out of Israel and the UK and he used to run Labour Start but he came out to Australia one year and I said what's going be the next big thing and he said on Twitter everyone's going be organised in their workplaces using it. Now that was before it enshitified but here we are.

Speaker 2But wasn't wrong. Yammer tried to do an internal Twitter and that completely failed when they got bought by whoever they got bought by. But along comes half of the in Australia now run either on a Teams chat group thing or on Slack or some variation.

Speaker 1Slack's almost getting, everything becomes peak. It's not just the business models that are about that instantification, it just becomes too much content. So you know, you and I have both sort of ourselves into Substack recently, but I'm finding it so tiring because there is just so much there. So how do you actually build, even something like Substack, a small, like the people you want, ⁓ like people listening to, what's your which this week is probably just you and me, but anyway. ⁓

Speaker 2journey. If I'm a little tribe, yeah. But I think, to answer your question by the way, think AI is how you get around that. So I think the way you get around that, drinking from the fire hose, is get AI to filter the fire hose for you.

Speaker 1But AI is turbocharging the fire hose, even the I get I Klaus is an experiment, but the number of that are putting their ideas out there, I won't name the pollster, but a high profile pollster who's gone from putting out a post every other... month to like daily and I know that Klaus had a look at it here I am talking about it and I and found how the writing had changed like there were so many tells

Speaker 2It's great because you can pinpoint the moment at which someone got their subscription to either Claude or open AI or whatever ⁓

Speaker 1Cheers, Kos

Speaker 2that's for defamation, we don't have any money. ⁓

Speaker 1truth and public interest. ⁓

Speaker 2good there. do think you're right about the slop thing, we'll come back to it but like... I think that's also just people misusing the tools because suddenly people have been given all these tools. don't know how to implement it yet. So they're just throwing everything at it and producing content at volume. So they're like, it must be good. I actually as it matures, people will start dialing it down because of the fatigue and they go, hang on a minute. ⁓ How do actually want to use this? Where do I actually want to use this? And I think it will get better. But it's the with the, you remember when open AI and the chat GPT had like, ⁓ we can generate images. ⁓ And there was huge influx of people doing, you know, spirited away style ⁓ of themselves and their dog or whatever ⁓ that was the thing for three weeks and then it dropped off right when people went like okay actually I don't need it for that but what I do need it for is image of ⁓ you restoring an image of my old grandma that was in black and white and I want it colorized so they ⁓ know finds its level I think the commercial world hasn't its level yet ⁓

Speaker 1I guess as practitioners we're going be looking at how it's going to be used in the midterms in the States and then obviously we've got a runway of another couple of years. know one of the things that I took out of working with the kids in Labor HQ... ⁓

Speaker 2time.

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, but they're good. But it was this notion of strategic slop, so it is all slop, but there is a strategy behind it. It's just another delivery mechanism of the core message, which is, I think we're talking about the Sloppy Gander in last week. ⁓ that's what they're doing. It's just different ways of telling a story, but you still need the story to be ⁓

Speaker 2I'm I can't remember where I read it, but it's this idea of you can't the problem you're solving clearly before put it into AI ⁓ and then able to criticize the solution, then it's not good use of AI. So you need to be able to both define the problem that you're solving by putting it in and criticize what's come and how it attaches. Back to politics.

Speaker 1Well, yeah, back to the... I do want to talk a bit to you about the NDIS because I feel... like this was a really big moment. was actually a big reform moment for the government. But I feel like been on this journey since 2012 when I got called in to set up the Every Australian Counts campaign with John Delaboska, which was the community campaign that got all the MPs to only MP that would not sign the pledge at the time, Joe Hockey, he was poised ⁓ to be next treasurer and see what was coming around the road. So ⁓ let me ⁓ step this but interrupt for clarification. But also if you

Speaker 2I didn't.

Speaker 1feel like I'm pushing too hard on bullshit. first thing about the NDIS was that it came out of ⁓ Rudd's, his 2020 summit? ⁓ was an idea that Bill Shorten was pushing the National Disability Insurance. a big idea. And they put it through the Productivity Commission. The dirty secret of the NDIS was it was a voucher system. So they went from a where states had delivered services on a ration basis, because they've only got so many services, to one where if you pass the threshold, ⁓

Speaker 2then.

Speaker 1get a plan and you are in control. in terms, more like in ⁓ it was more the sort of policy expect to come from your side of politics than mine. ⁓

Speaker 2of this is based on the whole thing of every gets better outcomes the more control they have over their own health and future, right?

Speaker 1But there's also this thing that if you support people, they're going to be more likely to be in the workforce. So a few things. so one of the problems was that it became Gillard's legacy piece. they knew because once, you know, everyone knew that they were not going to win in 2013. And so she was desperate to get her legacy piece up and they sold it to the states with the most terrible deal. They said, we'll take all the risk. If it blows up, the feds will pick up the upside. The states cap their liability. Not only that, but then the feds said, we'll take disabilities, all the states. you couldn't see the disability services being wound down for the dust. Like they just closed down community transport, they closed down all these departments that had been delivering the systemic ration support and they replaced it with a market. But then you guys came in, Mitch I think was the minister ⁓ and had a, were bringing this massive scheme but they had a staffing freeze so they couldn't hire anyone. So they didn't actually bring in anyone to run it and everything became outsourced and so you created a...

Speaker 2The market.

Speaker 1This is where you got, they didn't have registration of providers. ⁓

Speaker 2This is where you the dodgy operators starting to introduce and go hang on here there's some buckets of tens of

Speaker 1But even the non-dodgy, they've all got If you're setting up a business where your job is not just ⁓ like get accredited to be in the NDIS, but then deliver services, ⁓ which is what's happened with those sort of neurodivert, like whatever you want to call it, ADHD, whatever you and I have got. ⁓

Speaker 2Modern fashionable disabilities.

Speaker 1No, but then you get to the ridiculous point where you've got like, I the figure was one in eight boys under the age of 14 were in the NDIS on an autism. And it was because, know, Bruce Bonahady, who was the grandfather of the scheme, who came up with the whole idea, brilliant man, he this idea that it became the oasis in the desert. So because the rest of the services are gone, that was that was left. So of course it was a rational approach. so ⁓ particularly if kid had problems, like ⁓ your parents fight so hard and that

Speaker 2on ADHD.

Speaker 1And the proof that you were delivering for your kid was you get them into the NDIS and it almost became this.

Speaker 2pride point there's a program in place they've got their case manager

Speaker 1And so it became this frank. And look, and there's two things true at once. It is demonstrably improved the lives of people with high level disabilities. there is a lot more agency and choice, but also the market is a mess and it's growing at 10 % a year. that, and is.

Speaker 2Which is an insane level of growth. 10 % a year is an insane level of growth. Not just that it's unsustainable, that is not a natural level of growth for any government service.

Speaker 1So this is the next bit of the story. We knew. You could tell that it was heading this way, but you guys were in charge we had Bill, particularly so Bill Shorten who loved Bill death, think he should have been prime minister, think you guys were terrible for what you did to him. then he gets, after

Speaker 2training people to do.

Speaker 1But he then defends the scheme and the sorts of changes that Butler's now talking about. To be fair, think you guys... It was rovo-debt and then was rovo-NDIS and now there is a tool being built. ⁓ was, ⁓ know, forcing people to register their ⁓ that's an incredibly... ⁓

Speaker 2I propose that, What an imposition.

Speaker 1So the politics at that time was hanging fruit. We had all these people really worried and made it really hard to reform. Bill came in, set the scene for the reform. Butler's delivered it. I'm really here's where the rave ends for now, on how the respond because I think a way, if the Libs, and I Taylor is actually that he is to support the changes. The biggest question whether Libs think they can win government in the next 10 years or not is whether they help the NDIS so they don't have the same problems affecting them.

Speaker 2At this point I think it's costing, it's equal to or larger than Medicare in terms of the cost, which outrageous. Like it's an outrageously large cost. So some of the measures proposed under Butler's thing, so basically about 160,000 participants are going to be off the scheme the decade, by the end of the decade. So that means within the next four years, in theory, ⁓ instead growing by it should go down from the 760 odd thousand it is now to at least about 600,000. The average plan value should from 31,000 to 26,000.

Speaker 1Although that's a dive, like the bit there that's interesting is there are people with high knees who are rightly on large plants. are people on six bigger numbers because they need round the clock care and so they should ⁓ then there's a lot of people on very low level. ⁓ then the challenge is the idea was they get kicked off.

Speaker 2long tail of the lower level.

Speaker 1the scheme, but then they were going to build what they're calling foundational supports, which is the systemic and they haven't built those yet. And so that's the other problem that they're jump off is going to occur before the safety nets being built. And so that's going to be the challenge, but that's all on the States. And the feds have linked hospital funding to building the net. Get back. So how are how are you approaching this as a liberal strategist and be as a citizen?

Speaker 2So, okay, say... ⁓ So as a citizen, I'll start there first. So get the NDIS, I get the need for an NDIS. And I get that there are a lot of people out there who have high needs, who like they will never get the opportunity in theory to be hyper productive member society that can earn a income or a large amount of money and have a social net of their own. ⁓ And so society should after them because they would dealt a shit hand in life for whatever reason. I get that. Then there's that, like we talked about, that long tail of people who have varying levels of level of needs that, you this becomes ⁓ ethical argument how much does state need to support your ADHD? Is that something you manage without really having state intervention? Which we go, all right, maybe it's only costing us 10 grand a year or five grand a year, but that's the equivalent of including... dental in Medicare. why are we paying for a small group to be able to needs coverage for their ADHD rather including dental in Medicare? ⁓

Speaker 1want to be individualizing the care rather than if you are and this is the thought behind thriving kids it should be delivered in groups not in individuals which is obviously a lot more rational but also good for people to be

Speaker 2But then you get down that hairy road of like, right, well, where do you cut it off? are you know, is it okay to be on the NDIS if you ⁓ lost both legs, but not if you've lost one leg, or if ⁓ below the knee, doesn't count, but it's above the knee. So you have to start drawing these arbitrary lines. ⁓

Speaker 1normally that would just be a bit of equipment to support you, maybe a one-off payment.

Speaker 2And I always get, I start to get suspicious is who draws those lines ⁓ how they review where those lines are drawn and I never trust to draw those lines is a bureaucrat in Canberra. I will never trust a bureaucrat in Canberra ⁓ to a decision on behalf of the Australian people, one, because they live in Canberra, right? So is the bubble of it.

Speaker 1The cult of sex. ⁓

Speaker 2It's the cul-de-sac of the roundabout. No, but these are people who are, the most part, obviously massively generalizing, but these are not people who are exposed to, you the wide tapestry that is Australia. They live in the biggest bubble, ⁓ Canberra, the bubble state of the ACT, within the bubble that is Australia. ⁓ Like are so far down the rabbit hole at that point that I think you are divorced from the of, okay, well this is...

Speaker 1The NIS is disaggregated, like they've got officers around the country.

Speaker 2That's service delivery, that's not policy making and decision making. but they're making decisions, they're making the decisions in Wode and they're making the decisions in Turner. ⁓

Speaker 1rail. the politics of it though so how you be playing this from the libs at the moment because I feel like they rightly feel like you you did ask like why do

Speaker 2You expect Angus to go hard on it. The benefit from the liberal perspective is the NDIS doesn't have the cache social license as we like to call it now because that's the new buzz term for everything. societal capitals are much more, know, a trade master. no, it's a creative comment. given it to world.

Speaker 1for us to start with. Mark.

Speaker 2So the NDIS doesn't hold the same place in the hearts of Australians as Medicare, right? So if you're the libs and you go after overspend on Medicare, go, well, well, well, hands off my Medicare. The is currently in that point where if you rely on the NDIS, it holds a place for you. If you rely on the NDIS, it's become the butt of a joke that this is where basically, you know, go to rip off the government by starting up a provider scheme and, you know.

Speaker 1And hand jobs, yeah.

Speaker 2with that kind of stuff and you know kids getting paid $45 an hour take granny to the movies or some shit like that so... ⁓

Speaker 1It's not great care either. To the grannies, like a 65 year cut off. what you hear is, support for people, particularly people with more profound supports like intellectual disability, embraced by communities. Now they've got this single worker who takes them to the shopping centre, plays on their phone while the person's just sitting, and there's no stimulation, there's nothing.

Speaker 2It's in all the time in Leica you see the little little old Italian nono getting walked around by the giant Maori guy They've no like personal connection because he's he has no interest other than a financial trend

Speaker 1because the thing is Uber's come into the sector, or the model, let's not, Uber's responsible for many bad things, but not this. So I think...

Speaker 2They move them out of here.

Speaker 1The politics is going to be interesting. think there's going to be lots of justifiable stories of people that are losing something and the government is spending its political capital on that. But in terms of an ROI on political capital to I think it's like $50 billion. It is probably worth the risk at this stage.

Speaker 2Thank Well look, this is the political calculations of it worth trying to salvage the NDIS or it a case of going ⁓ you what if you're the liberal boat going what we should be doing is killing the NDIS starting again and building a good system. ⁓

Speaker 1you hate disabled people. knew it. that's what's going to happen. The bit that I would take probably is a different I think the NDIS has been... over a decade it's seen as, NDIS is proof that we care for people with disabilities. so I think ⁓ messaging of Butler is ⁓ got to cut it back to save it. ⁓ I think that works. And I think if the Libs just said ⁓ it, ⁓ think that would then become not for them. I think there are enough. ⁓

Speaker 2Look, I don't disagree with that other than depends on how you frame the killer. Like if you can introduce a better alternative option, which is actually of the NDIS, we're going to do a ⁓ to high needs program ⁓ the NDIS was doomed from the start. It was poorly designed ⁓ we now have a decade's worth of evidence of how bad it is. Another of labor overreaching in government and creating that are unsustainable. They're about to do it to childcare. them doing it with the NDIS, you need the Liberals to come in and manage these programs and make them, know, ⁓ and sustainable in the long run. Like you could a line of argument there that would be, that could work well, but you're right that it's a very fine line to trod. I have a feeling at the moment that it doesn't matter what Butler or anyone else does, these programs are just going to continue to blow out. There's going to be more in closets of dodgy providers doing really dodgy stuff. Those stories going to keep coming out and they're going to overshadow any changes that are being made. ⁓

Speaker 1So Liebes could be talking about economic management. Instead, Andrew Heastie is talking about August. Like I'm starting to feel like he's in the wrong party.

Speaker 2Dingo. I think he's trying to find his feet, like, I think...

Speaker 1So let's just go, so what did he say? What was the cause? Because I've only read the headlines, I haven't seen the whole thing.

Speaker 2So, and you know, I don't think many people did watch the whole speech, but basically he gave a oration at the Robert Menzies Institute in Melbourne, talking about basically that, Andes is a species of alliance, not a hard treaty guarantee. So what's interesting is a species of alliance is a Menzian phrase. So that was quite interesting that he leaned into that. Through the Menzies AI.

Speaker 1You can put it through, have more.

Speaker 2And the idea that each country meets is common danger in accordance with its constitutional process, right? So it's a caveat that is attaching to it, which is interesting. I thought the, you the coloring of the eagle and the dingo as the analogies for the US and Australia. So the US is the eagle and Australia the dingo was very fascinating. ⁓ Very, very, very, very, ⁓ very, very But I think the idea that

Speaker 1It's interesting revealing as well. I see the resemblance.

Speaker 2that he kind of put forward is that the relationship is very transactional rather than sentimental, it's really interesting. ⁓ Just the US-Australia is basically transactional, I think one of those things that we kind of all know but ⁓ goes is we go into these wars with the US on the ⁓

Speaker 1That's Ray Trump.

Speaker 2that if anything ever happens to us, they would step in. that's something that's essentially yet to be properly proven outside of World War I and World II, but I how that actually fell out. But the idea is we step in almost blindly because the is that that's return. So it's a highly transactional relationship. We're not doing it for some sentimental reasons that have these deep cultural ties to the US. So I thought it was really interesting that ⁓ he brought that. But I the line that really landed is we forgot the hard lessons of war and outsourced our security to the United States. we need more dingo to balance the eagle.

Speaker 1I'm with you, Hastie. and you know, he's been interesting on, you know, I think there was a fantastic line in that interview with the insiders that it's not our job to defend multinational corporations. Again, tick. So I thought it was interesting also that I don't know if Macron's been listening to Menzies Institute speeches, but he was out there this week saying, I'm all there for if Australia wants to come back now.

Speaker 2It's all about the middle powers, right?

Speaker 1⁓ huge skeptic of AUKUS. There are a bunch of people in Labor that aren't comfortable with the position. I've put to a few people down in Canberra they go, it would take 30 years unwind this alliance. ⁓ It's so locked in there's so much. is it... Maybe it's not a binary thing either. Like, you know, we're in this interesting position where our biggest economic partner is China, not America. My personal view is with the different models of AI coming out, the Chinese model is much more attractive in that it's small models dispersed, use less energy, whereas America is a whole bit. Take away, like... ⁓

Speaker 2Just take away the technological element here.

Speaker 1Take away the role of the state in terms of a model of the technology developing, it's much more aligned with the interests of a middle power that's trying to build its own.

Speaker 2But think part of the point is like we want to be able to have a foot in each lane, right? That's the whole idea is.

Speaker 1And his orcas, like it's pretty hard to straddle orcas and China. would have been easier to like of defend, self-defense. And what are we defending from? Like we're from, if you listen miles and everything, ⁓ our main defense to protect our supply chain. Who's bugging up our chains? It hasn't been China.

Speaker 2Maybe, but if you're gonna... No. back to Hasty for one minute. I your person is not watching Hasty speeches ⁓ and average person is probably skipping over the articles about Hasty speeches in whatever their outlet is. Clearly what he's is testing ⁓ lines that are for leadership. His testing positioning, his finding positionings that

Speaker 1Is anyone doing research for him, do you reckon? Euron!

Speaker 2Look, I wouldn't be surprised if he's getting his own polling done outside of the party mechanisms. I don't know for a fact, but I wouldn't be surprised. ⁓ he's clearly testing some positions to see how they land. And think increasingly finding a sympathetic audience. he started in a very far right position on a lot of issues, and he's slowly himself to where's where's the furthest of right that he feels comfortable that he can ⁓ genuinely occupy? and gets people going should be leader because you've got some clever ideas about X Y and Z and you're saying something different to the party that's in power right so instead of getting the same sameness that you usually get with ⁓ Labour Liberal you start hearing some messages that you go that's a bit different that's a bit interesting and he does perk up. ⁓

Speaker 1Actually also on a unity ticket with up in terms of the attack on if look at this as an attack on one nation because ⁓ get doing all these things about how close Hanson is to Trump. It's interesting seeing hasty again saying and so you can see if he's playing ⁓ a of chess the first bit is to call that out and the next bit is to tie one nation Gina to Trump isn't

Speaker 2You're doing the whole thing down in the thorough body, Shabbat.

Speaker 1which is pretty easy to do because you've got all the pictures. maybe there's a longer game here as well.

Speaker 2I think the biggest thing about the ⁓ speech is there's actually a lot more interesting stuff in there than was Like deserved more news coverage than it got. thing that's interesting about ⁓ Haste's speech was obviously talked about defence capability a lot, ⁓ which ties in well to, if people remember, he this like Australian manufacturing thing where he ⁓ tried to look sexy front of an old car and all that kind of thing. This speech kind of started land it because he tied in his current portfolio around sovereign capability with ⁓ we need to make more here, ⁓ right? We need to make more related things here, ⁓ which I think ties his great Australian together with Australian defence? ⁓ Well, if it be delivered, right? So, ⁓ and this the whole idea of we should be making drones, we should be making anti-drone technology, what's our version of, you know, Iron Star Wars, all that kind of stuff. ⁓ This is things Australians don't think about, right? Australians don't think about our defence manufacturing capability our defence industry. ⁓

Speaker 1Sounds like future made in Australia.

Speaker 2having done some work on that portfolio. Aussies assume that everything we use here is made somewhere else, we buy weapons off the US. They about the Bushmasters. They don't know about the Bushmasters, they don't know about the Ghostbusters.

Speaker 1AMWU was an old client back when Tim Ayres, who's now industry minister, there. Their state secretary was. He's gone on my way to him. But, so he's been really committed to this idea for a long time. And again, it feels like, I don't know your view on future-made in Australia, and I think it's still a slogan as much.

Speaker 2was exactly my view, it's a great slogan. ⁓ where is the future made in Australia?

Speaker 1got to flesh it out. At the moment it's ensuring why ALA doesn't shut down. Can I also ask you before we what's your read on the call for attacks on export Because feels like like at least ⁓ the guys in Canberra saying he's going to shut it down, but ⁓ where's hasty on it, the lives on it?

Speaker 2is a good thing, but sure. Well. I mean look, I think the libs are pretty clear position on it, which is don't, right? There's couple of outliers on it who are kind of trying to go... Well, look, depends who you ask and it depends on whether it's a windfall type... ⁓

Speaker 1And seems like a rubbish deal from the cheap seats. and then sell it back to us at a higher price.

Speaker 2So in theory, yes, but the thing is that these aren't, like getting the gas out of the ground is not a cheap operation and it's not a quick operation, right? So you've got to convince a company to come in to spend hundreds of millions of dollars building infrastructure that they then need to sell for the next 10 to 20 years. You need to lock in the conditions for that next 10 to 20 years because they recover over that period of time. They employ people, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. Is it okay to halfway through that change the deal on them and go, actually, we're going to start charging you more or taxing you more, or now you're going to pay this, that, the other royalty on it. Now, if this were any other topic and we were saying, you know what, we're going to suddenly switch off gearing for everyone. And go, hang on a minute, all these people made their investment decisions five years ago based on the tax conditions that were set then you'd be But because it's multinational gas company, we feel like it's okay to be like, ⁓ well, fuck them. They don't really make up.

Speaker 1So what do the Libs ⁓

Speaker 2I think that the Libs are going to go in there calling for an increase to the PRRT, the petroleum resource rent tax, any time soon. I don't know why Pauline, I don't know what her calculations are other than pure populism.

Speaker 1It also feels like gas is our main leverage for guaranteeing petrol supply. That's probably what... ⁓ what Albo's been flying around Asia off...

Speaker 2It's a bugger. But it's a hundred percent off it is our bargaining chip and it's a hundred percent the reason why Albo is not gonna increase the PRRT or Increase the introduce a gas windfall tax because it's literally one of the only immediate bargaining chips with hat we have with people like Malaysia Into all these like oil producing countries because we just don't have a lot of oil in Australia and the oil we do have is really hard to get at it's really expensive to get to got gas and we've got a fuck ton of gas and got all these facilities to liquefy it and ship it offshore because people invested billions of dollars building it. we don't want is those companies to pack up and go you know what and not just the cost increase it's it changes their posture towards us because they go you're not reliable trading partner you're not a reliable government because you could change mind any in ⁓ with a of so we don't want to do business with you we're going to do business over here where we know the whoever the Qataris the Norwegians the Danish whoever we

Speaker 1you get it out of Qatar at the moment but yeah ⁓

Speaker 2The Norwegians have changed. at least the people who went in there knew the conditions and they haven't changed. That's fair.

Speaker 1broader thing on gas is, so on the left we've been pushing for a long time that gas is coal's like slightly less dirty brother and trying sort of phase out gas. I think this embeds gas, like this crisis because gas going to be so central to Australia.

Speaker 2But you know what embeds gas? It's the fact that no one wants to pay stupid amounts of money for electricity and there's some process you still can't do with a solar panel or a wind farm and I'm not a know me. I'm not an anti. Let's do everything we can to fix the planet guy. I'm a genuine like You greenhouse effect real. We should be doing what we can ⁓ but You consumers choice and you say hey look we are they gonna some coal and it's gonna cost you you know ten cents a kilowatt hour or you can wait 10 years and you'll get to pay 12 cents a kilowatt hour for solar, going to keep buying the coal and they do. ⁓

Speaker 1also think gas industry is still ⁓ from an advertising campaign almost before you were born from the 80s which were these dancers blue leotards doing the... ⁓ And they still... you see the industry always, it's natural. But unlike coal...

Speaker 2the natural gas. But what is the solution here? We've been hearing about this energy transition for two decades, RUD, right? Since 2007.

Speaker 1I keep getting into power and slowing it down. You guys put all these speed humps on. So yes, there was a market mechanism to make it work in 2013. Abbott killed that. Malcolm gave it a try. Your guy came in, slowed it down again. A decade is a long time.

Speaker 2But when you say slowed it down, but how are we slowing it down? Because the argument from the labor side...

Speaker 1to make it happen, like you made it harder to It's kind of happening already, but I agree at a slow pace. I also think your favorite technology is going ⁓ to distort the whole energy market as well with all the... sucking energy out of the grid. And so that's something for another day, I reckon.

Speaker 2⁓ absolutely. But are you an anti-nuclear guy?

Speaker 1I was politicised in the nuclear disarmament party. first vote was for Pete Garrett for the Senate.

Speaker 2But explain the anti-nuclear thing to me. I've never understood why, even at the election when it was floated up as a lead balloon by Ted O'Brien, I didn't understand why Albo didn't come forward and go, yep, we're going to include it as part of the mix and we're going to do an evaluation on the viability of nuclear, park it and say, yep, we're going to spend the next five years doing evaluation on nuclear in Australia. Why wouldn't you just take the air out of the sails on that?

Speaker 1First part is for people, I come 20 years old, so for people of my generation up under the shadow the bomb, nuclear was an incredibly dangerous technology, like 20 years before I was born, millions of people killed through ⁓ nuclear The second part of it though is I think that it's always been the case in Australia, we've seen in different parts of the world ⁓ so there's been this sense it is a... A bit like, you know, AGI, it's a form of technology that no one quite knows what the end game is, the half-life of nuke is a long time, everything. it's like, if you live in a country like Australia with wind and solar, why wouldn't you bet on that rather something which by its nature ⁓ is unstable source of energy? ⁓

Speaker 2So, but you've got to see the end argument there that like the amount of solar panels you need to produce the electricity of one nuclear power plant like hectares hectares of panels. ⁓

Speaker 1But it's becoming more more concentrated all the time, the battery technology is in short

Speaker 2But the battery technology doesn't come out of nowhere. We still got to dig up fucking lithium to get to... There's a whole lot of complications there well. agree. Yes, you're right. There is a meltdown risk of nuclear. We've had a few major nuclear incidents around the world that, you know, one was a triple threat natural disaster in Fukushima. Most of the others were basically poor design or poor maintenance or incompetence. The technology's moved on. Uranium is something we're incredibly rich in. And more than that,

Speaker 1Right.

Speaker 2We have one of the geographically most stable spots on the face of the earth.

Speaker 1Do you remember when Hawke was offering Australia to be the world's nuclear in the middle? That was the one moment I thought deeply about it. Like if the world's going to use it and you were going to put it anywhere and there was an economic dividend, why wouldn't But the politics is so hard. Maybe you've to for my generation to die out. I don't know. But I do think that if you weigh up the long-term

Speaker 2Sex is hard because we make it hard.

Speaker 1If you look down the track and assuming that we don't sort of blow the world up in the next hundred years, of course we should be being powered by resources like wind and sun than resources like coal and nuclear. I ⁓ feel like a no-brainer. ⁓

Speaker 2And I tell you what when the yield of a solar panel or a wind turbine closer to required like to the output of a nuclear plant I'm a hundred percent with you what I'm is we've got to build this stuff because ⁓ we've got buy the time and I don't Not I was a but I don't understand logically how anyone who is on left and he like climate change is one of their issues stands up against nuclear.

Speaker 1see that your side slowed it down for a decade. So almost like you're building a straw man saying it's not happening fast enough, even though, particularly Abbott, you took to slow it down.

Speaker 2I completely agree and I with ⁓ policy decisions entirely. ⁓

Speaker 1socialism they just paying well they're basically paying farmers not to grow alfalfa to quote the great Jason

Speaker 2Exactly, but I just it's one of those things I'm passionately believe that like we should take any technology available and if nuclear is there should have been making and I think the Labour government should have made huge inroads to go We're gonna genuinely explore this as an option because your point of like your generation You know ⁓ finding dangerous. It's like we also have proof that like ⁓ burning in populated areas is also really dangerous But you guys didn't have a problem doing that ⁓

Speaker 1The only final thing I'll say is read the small print of Labor's last election campaign it was about this plan, the cost of this plan and I still reckon they've probably, they've still got a hedge bet there. ⁓

Speaker 2Hmm. be interesting if they brought that back in. I know. Yeah, tell me what's picks for the week coming up? ⁓

Speaker 1better wind it. my big thing coming up this week is we're in the field this week with the Guardian essential report so it's the pre-budget one but I'm really interested in you know, how we're thinking about the economic crisis that's about to hit us. I'm also interested in some of the ideas being floated. So I'm testing everything from, know, ⁓ super profit gas tax to the housing changes to the NDIS cuts. But weekend reading is Neville Schuett's On the Beach, which just strikes me as a potential for next week's column. So do you know On the Beach? So it's a famous, it's a fact. Neville Schuett was a Brit who ended living in Australia, who wrote this in the late

Speaker 2No.

Speaker 1Basically what happens is, a pretty depressing book. There a nuclear war in the Middle East.

Speaker 2Jules has been recommending this book to me forever.

Speaker 1And so it's set in Melbourne and basically the world's fucked, there's a nuclear cloud coming down and it's just a story about people waiting for the cloud to arrive. became a Hollywood movie with people like, I think it was Frank Sinatra and Ava Gardner who famously said Melbourne's a great place to make a movie about the end of the world. So I'm going to watch it on the weekend but also reread the book which has got an introduction by Gideon Hague of all people and so I hope that...

Speaker 2I'm That's a great book and I might have to add it to my list because Jules has been recommending it. I actually I was going to recommend Generations but I kind of want to stay on that theme for a minute. I recently finished reading Annie Jacobson's amazing book called Nuclear War a Scenario. this is ⁓ an It's so incredible. So both reading it but

Speaker 1partner answer.

Speaker 2Because I read on the Kindle and then pick up the audiobook where I left off when I drive and back and forth.

Speaker 1Netflix pretty much follows it as well.

Speaker 2Just the first bit of the book, but the whole idea is, Adi Jacobson's done this incredible amount of research with all the big wigs throughout the American military complex who've designed the nuclear systems and what she does is basically spend an entire book tracking the 72 minutes from the point at which there is an unidentified nuclear warhead launched from what we discover is North Korea towards Washington. What happens in the next 72 minutes in excruciating detail it's one of those ones that is both awe-inspiring at the mechanisms that are involved in, you all the that the US, Britain, Canada, Australia, like the calls that are made, the processes in place, the war gaming that happens. and also the utter futility of it. Like the pointlessness of one person launches that nuclear weapon, ⁓ kind of all fucked. ⁓ silver lining being there's basically two places on earth that you're reasonably safe in a nuclear war scenario. ⁓ is the southeast part of Australia and New Zealand. other the southeast part of Argentina. ⁓ So happen to be in a reasonably well-protected spot should a scenario like that happen. ⁓ So you haven't read it, Annie Jacobson, Nuclear War Institute.

Speaker 1would just say that so my my metaphor for on the beach is not that we're gonna have a nuclear war But just that what's happening economically is a bit like that. Yeah, because this is a bit people don't get ⁓ heading towards a serious economic downturn It's already happened. You can't stop it happening ⁓ the politics of that I think we're saying it last week is a very very different. So ⁓ so I feel like this is gonna be the on the beach budget for Jim Chalmers Like how do you actually prepare something? You know, that's already gonna happen

Speaker 2It's the trends driving itself. This is of those buying gold situations where people need to rush off to get some bullion for the in the post ⁓ downturn era. ⁓

Speaker 1Anyway,

Speaker 2This is great. We should do some more ones.

Speaker 1Thank you. In the General Strategic Offices, which is always like the of Mad Men circa 1959. That would have been reading Neville Shute when it was a new...

Speaker 2We try to keep... And ⁓ you are out there listening have a great Anzac Day, play some 2-Up, salute the Diggers and enjoy a long weekend if you're in New South Wales. Thank you. everyone.