Episode 31
Bluenami, Brazil, Belgrade, and Bibi
With Cory Alpert
Show notes
This week we're joined by former Biden White House staffer Cory Alpert, now a University of Melbourne researcher studying the impact of AI on democracy, about a big fortnight of elections around the world. We discuss democracy, populism, and who people trust to deliver. Cory shares his view of the US midterms from inside Democratic politics. We delve into the results, the pull of cost-of-living politics over the culture wars, the gap between winning on protest and governing well, and the growing reach of big tech into elections, with the contests in Brazil, Serbia and Israel as cases in point. Along the way we explore the anti-corruption movements emerging across the globe, the sense of lost agency in politics, and whether AI could ever play a role in representing voters.
A reminder that there are some tickets remaining for our first live show at the National Press Club in Canberra on Wednesday 25 November.
Chapters
- 00:00 Technical Setup and Challenges
- 07:29 Personal Experiences and Mental Health
- 08:11 Insights from Serbian Elections
- 10:18 Global Political Movements
- 11:00 Predictions for Upcoming Elections
- 16:31 Discussion on AI and Democracy
- 17:30 Meta's Influence in Brazilian Elections
- 19:00 Health Challenges and Political Reflections
- 21:07 Introducing Cory Alpert: A Polymath Perspective
- 21:58 Processing Election Results and Emotional Responses
- 24:05 Democratic Mandate and State-Level Governance
- 24:59 Diverse Perspectives on Election Outcomes
- 27:06 The Revolving Door of American Politics
- 29:12 Economic Messaging and Voter Sentiment
- 29:59 Impact of Fuel Prices on Election Results
- 31:57 Campaigning Mechanisms and Democratic Strategies
- 34:01 Local Politics vs. Centralized Campaigning
- 37:05 South Carolina's Political Landscape
- 40:01 Michigan's Dramatic Senate Race
- 42:56 The Rise of Progressive Populism
- 46:03 Cultural Conversations vs. Economic Realities
- 49:00 Texas Elections and Shifting Demographics
- 51:00 Challenges of Governance Post-Election
- 54:00 The Role of Tech in Elections
- 57:03 Brazil's Presidential Election and Meta's Role
- 58:03 Foreign Interference in Brazilian Elections
- 01:01:50 AI's Role in Political Campaigns
- 01:04:19 Political Dynamics in Brazil
- 01:05:15 Youth Movements and Political Change in Serbia
- 01:10:14 The Rise of Leaderless Movements
- 01:18:29 The Impact of Technology on Political Agency
- 01:24:22 AI and the Future of Democracy
- 01:30:18 Predictions for Upcoming Elections
Full transcript
Read itHide it
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.
Peter LewisWelcome to What's Your Poison, the show where people who disagree on just about everything agree that it's best to do so over a drink. My name's Peter Lewis. I'm the chair of the progressive strategy shop Essential. Joining me back from the dead is my evil twin, Dame Damjanowski. Welcome back. So glad to see you, Dame. And how are you?
Damian DamjanovskiIt's very good to be back.
Peter LewisAnd what is your poison?
Damian DamjanovskiI am better. I apologize to yourself and to our listeners for my absence for last week. I was I was not in a good point having I think what what turns out to be not just flu, but some kind of RSV that had some terrible lingering effects. So would not recommend RSV one star thumbs down. but slowly, so
Peter LewisWhat is RSV? Sorry.
Damian Damjanovskiit's it's a respiratory virus. It's one of those nasty things that gets into your lungs and then refuses to leave and makes you cough everything
Peter LewisNoth
Damian Damjanovskiup and
Peter Lewisnothing to do with
Damian DamjanovskiIt's horrid.
Peter Lewisthe ongoing vaping while we're doing live shows.
Damian DamjanovskiNo, but believe it or not, I did actually get a lung function test as part of this. And the the lovely specialist there was like, Look, you should count yourself lucky. You do not have a smoker's lungs. And I used to smoke 25 cigars ciggies a day for about 25 years. So I do consider myself very lucky lucky. And the the vapes are are helping with that, but that is not an endorsement or a recommendation. my poison this week, given we're going to be talking about elections and politics, and I remember as a kid. The grandparents and the uncles all talking about politics and elections, and they would always do so over this little drink called a Polinkovat. So if you've not had a Polinkovats before, it's a Croatian drink. I believe it's a type of amaro, essentially. So it's a whole bunch of herbs and other stuff squished together. and it's very bitter with a little bit of sweetness, but it's delightful. So
Peter LewisIt sounds medicinal, yeah. So hopefully that keeps you
Damian DamjanovskiNaz Nazdravia to everyone. What's your poison, Peter? And who have we got on this week?
Peter LewisYeah. So I'm up in Mudgy at my sister's wonderful restaurant, Food and Farm Dining, where I will be running the floor later this evening. normally in Mudgy we drink wine and I will be dropping into Logan's for a case of his finest. But there is also a brewery. The Three Tales brewery has a beer called Love and Chaos, which I kind of feel like is the the avatar of the week. So Love and Chaos is a Hellas Lager, volume three point five, which is reasonable given I am having to dispense with my RSA a bit later. so there you go. Love and chaos from
Damian DamjanovskiSounds delightful.
Peter LewisThree Tales. but I'm really excited to introduce our guest, Cory Alpert, who has a real polymath CV. So apart from having worked with the Biden administration on the Kamala Harris campaign last time around. You might have seen his work in Fairfax. He's been writing some fantastic columns on US politics. He's also in Australia doing a PhD in AI and democracy. so many things to to bring to this discussion today. And I thought when we're thinking how do we make sense of the world, I thought I'm gonna ask Cory. so here he is. Welcome, Cory, and what's your poison?
CoryThank you both so much for having me. I am not an alcohol drinker, but I have a ginger beer here with me. But much more important than that, I have a ginger beer in the mug from my home state in South Carolina. and it is a blue mug representing my new blue, well, purple state.
Peter LewisYour state has got a distinct tinge of blue at the moment. How how did you process l we'll talk about South Car Carolina specifically in a sec, but how did you process the events of the last week as somebody who's obviously learnt to taste the bitter pill of defeat on on a fairly regular basis?
Corygoing into this week, all the polls had us up, saying we're gonna have a 40-seat House majority and we're gonna win the Senate and all this stuff. And all I could think about was 2016, was that moment of, you know, I was working on the Hillary campaign, was certain that I was gonna go to DC and work in the White House and blah, blah, blah, blah. And then the just utter devastation, the polls were wrong. America had swung against us. So I'd refuse to let myself Have any sort of hope that we were going to do much. I even had a column earlier in the week explicitly saying, don't trust the polls, we don't know anything, don't have hope, don't have faith. And then, you know, the results start coming in and you start watching a few of the races. And I just remember there was a span of about an hour where they start calling all the Senate races from the East Coast and Central Time Zone. And you just start going, well. Shit, we might actually win this thing. And then one after another, and then it's looking good and it's looking good. And finally you kind of let yourself start kind of living out a bit. And you know, by the end of the night, here, once once most of the races have been called, it's just joy. It's just absolute joy that we get a chance to govern, that we get a chance to win. And we have massive majorities everywhere. This was, you know, this was one of the biggest elections I think of my lifetime, really, probably since 2008.
Peter LewisDo you process this as being able to govern given the orange man is still in the White House?
CoryAbsolutely. Look, some 24 states elected Democratic governors on Tuesday. in in battleground states, so in Georgia, Texas, and Arizona. So three now battleground states. Every single statewide office was won by a Democrat. So we flipped seven state legislative seats. So Congress is one thing. I I I think that we now have a mandate to sort of have a conversation with Trump. That's now one element, but at the state level where most American politics happen, Democrats now have a mandate and the ability to govern, not just to sort of make noise, but there's now there's now an open question of what will Democrats do in power?
Peter LewisHow did you process it, Dummy?
Damian DamjanovskiWell, I think it's quite interesting. And and Corey, obviously hearing the way you're talking about it, I find it I find it fascinating and I'm very keen to dig into this a bit more because I I think I've seen a lot of and you know, for the record, Corey, I'm sure you've you've seen some episodes of the show, but I'm I'm not a card carrying lefty. I I'm a I'm a center right conservative. I don't think that puts me on the Republican side of things because I don't think you have a center right. The United States anymore. And honestly, I would actually argue some of the Democratic nomination nominees are center right of the ones who've been elected. I've seen a lot of people celebrating this. I think blue Nami is the term that's caught on, which is very catchy. A lot of people are celebrating this as a return to progressive politics because I think they're very much paying attention to Michigan, like they're paying attention to one or two races and go, well, The left is back. People have come to their senses and we're back to it. I read this and I go, people are still deeply unhappy and they're very, they're very much looking for anyone to answer their questions, which is, doesn't matter who we put in charge, doesn't matter what they promise us, we're not getting ahead. The system is not working for us. We're being left out. We were told X, Y, and Z, and none of that is happening. So I I'm seeing this through the lens of this is just another protest, specifically in a system that doesn't necessarily allow or award third party candidates. the US system doesn't really allow for, yes, there's a few independents, but it's not designed for that, right? It's designed for being a very true two party system. I think it's just a continuation of what we're seeing around the world. And I know we're going to talk about Serbia and Brazil and Israel.
Peter LewisMm-hmm.
Damian DamjanovskiBut it's people on mass going, guys, there is and I think someone put it as this is a top versus bottom thing, not a left versus right thing. And we feel like we're getting the wrong end of the stick. What about you, Peter? What was your view on it?
Peter LewisI I thought one of the most compelling tapes was Robert Reich, who talks about anti establishment populism and so there is the risk it becomes a revolving door and you put somebody in to get rid of the other guy and then and it's almost been the story really since Hillary lost in twenty sixteen, Cory, that you you you first it was to Trump was to sort of drain the swamp and then it was kick Trump out, then it was kicked Biden out, and now it's you know, and so around and around we go. I guess the challenge is what the Dems do with power because their track record in terms of Really addressing the drivers of what is causing the dislocation ain't great. So yeah, I don't know.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd I was just gonna add to that, Peter. I think one of the things that I don't think came as a surprise to us, but clearly came as a surprise to the Trump administration is a lot of the voters who voted Trump in in twenty twenty four, like people like a a lot of the Latino population and other different minorities, there was this kind of presumption that the MAGA movement was growing. but it turns out that these weren't these weren't subscribed MAGA voters. These w this was a borrowed audience who basically went, Well, I'm voting for you because I think Biden is half dead. So basically any yeah, I'll t I'll take Trump because at least he's saying he's gonna do stuff. And I don't believe the last guys 'cause they didn't do anything. So I think you're right about the revolving door being at the core of it. But Corey, you you've been in this a lot deeper than any of us. So
CoryI think the thing I'll point out here is every Democrat, from Abdul al-Sayed on the further left realm of this campaign, to people like my new senator Annie Andrews, who's much more moderate, every message was on affordability. You know, it took different flavors. But one thing that I was very impressed by was every Democratic candidate did not waver. You know, Republicans were throwing everything they could trying to inject culture wars into this. Donald Trump Used a slur against transgender people to refer to Annie Andrews.
Peter LewisYeah.
CoryAnd her response was that doesn't help lower the cost of groceries for my constituents. That was it. She did not engage with it. She just pivoted every single time. one of the sort of more wild scandals at the end of the election was in Michigan where Haley Stevens, who had won the or who had lost the primary, ended up backtracking, endorsing the Republican. It sort of threatened to derail. the democratic campaign at the very end. And Abdul Sayyed, the Democratic nominee, now senator elect, he was in an interview and they said, you know, do you have any response to Haley Stevens making this comment? And he goes, No, it doesn't help anyone with their cost of living. And that's the only thing that I'm willing to talk about. And
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
CoryI, you know, I think yeah.
Peter LewisSo question so obviously Trump's war on Iran has been an absolute disaster for the global economy, but also, you know, for America. Absent that yeah, is this just a rejection of a failing economy, or did you see more to it than that in the results that that flowed through?
CoryI think it's that. I I you can pick and choose, but look at where the victories mostly were. So I think South Carolina is kind of a different, different sort of thing because Trump named a senator that we never signed off on. That was we can get into that. But you look at where most of the Democratic pickups were, they're in the middle of the country in agriculture, in ac in a in the agricultural states. Those are states where two things matter a lot: tariffs and immigration. And what did Trump put his name on is tariffs. Increased cost of fuel and making farm labor a lot more expensive. I think that is the entire story of this election.
Peter LewisHmm.
Coryand I think voters are
Damian DamjanovskiAnd and and
Corypissed off at MAGA.
Damian DamjanovskiCorey, it's worth noting, th those middle states, if you're if you're driving around Kansas or even Minnesota or or the s outside of Chicago, Illinois, you you're not a urban driver, like you know, most of us here in like Australia in Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, Perth, Adelaide, whatever, like we we might do 30, 40 kilometers and we, you know, complain about the price of petrol. But these are people who are on a daily basis are doing two, three hundred kilometers. So they are burning through diesel and unleaded. And the US is used to having a very low base price of petrol compared to the rest of the world. And they always have. So for them, this the petrol price shock is more of a shock to them than I think to the rest of the world. I think Europeans are used to the high price of petrol because they've had so many government based interventions on fossil fuels that they're kind of used to paying this, like, you two, three. Euros a liter price. In Australia, we've slowly become accustomed to paying over $2 a liter. But the US, where it's by the gallon, right? So that's what a gallon's four liters. Yeah, gallons four liters. So I don't know what the price is over there at the moment, but but it's it's approaching similar levels to what it is here in Australia, which is outrageous for farmland people who are doing this three, four hundred kilometer. trips per day often. that's that's a huge shock and a huge impact
CoryYeah.
Damian Damjanovskito their wallet.
Coryone of the the best graphs you'll you that you'll see and you'll see it every cycle in American politics, the price of gas going up and the price of the the party that and the support for the party controlling Washington going down. Those two graphs are exact inverses of each other nearly every time.
Damian DamjanovskiSo
Peter LewisMm-hmm.
Damian Damjanovskilet's let's say we all agree on the fact that and and I I do agree with you, Corey. I think where the Democrats campaigned really well is their discipline of of economic messaging and and re returning to the Clinton era of Democrats where it's the economy stupid and just stick to that message. I think parties here could learn a lot from that where culture wars are something you can have when everyone's doing really well and you've got nothing else to talk about. Sure, talk about whether or not they're pronouns are correct and who we're welcoming where. but when wallets hurt, you've got to talk about the the economy. So that to one side. I'm so curious about the actual campaigning mechanisms because I from an external perspective, it felt like the Democrats stepped up their campaigning machine this time more than I have seen it in the past two cycles.
CorySo a lot of this you know is because the money was coming into the campaigns. Democratic campaigns were quite often outraising their Republican counterparts. now I need to caveat that with the Republicans had a cash advantage for outside spending. This is where Elon Musk's half billion dollars went to.
Peter LewisYeah, he put a sh shed light in, didn't he?
CoryShit ton of money and I and he burned every dollar of it because the every race that he put money into they lost pretty handily. But democratic campaigns had a cash advantage. and I think one thing, one of my friends, Katie Hall, pointed this out yet the other day. I think Democrats also had an advantage by not having a single single identified party leader. It allowed each campaign a lot more flexibility. To not, you know, be tied to a single person. Yeah.
Peter LewisChoose your own adventure. Yeah.
CoryAnd I think that allowed them to build campaign apparatuses at a much quicker rate and not be tied to any one person. So
Damian DamjanovskiMm.
Coryyeah, I I think the the Democratic campaign apparatus was a lot more unified, had more money at the candidate level, and had and had grassroots support for volunteers that were just pissed off at the Trump administration.
Peter LewisThat is that is actually so interesting, Corey, because midterms are there. Every election like the i it it is a s a a a collection of individual seats. But Trump was trying to unify it around Trump, whereas the Democrats were totally disaggregated, which allowed such disparate candidates to run their own races. in their own communities, which is harder actually when you've also got a presidential nominee, which is the personification of the party. It's also harder when that personification is a mad guy. But yeah. So let's
Damian DamjanovskiPeter, do you think there's a lot for for us to learn here from that kind of thing? Because to to your point and Corey's point, I I think that increasingly a lot of parties around the world are remembering that all politics is local. Like as much as they like we we all there was a period where we all in Australia started buying into this presidential
Peter LewisMm.
Damian Damjanovskicampaign style thing. but I think people are slowly realizing, wait, no crap. It all politics is local and people actually are voting for their specific representative. I feel like you're right, Corey, that this midterm
Peter LewisMm.
Damian Damjanovskielection, the candidates did that really well and moved away from the highly centralized model of everything goes up to DNC and comes back to, yep, here's the rough guidelines, but you run your own race and
Peter LewisYeah, absolutely. We we spent the last election testing local candidate ads to be targeted straight out into the geo targeting on feeds rather than so many. You know, you did the hero leader ad because, you know, every leader needs a hero ad. But the main money in local races were going bet behind the ev you know, even you know, the a lot of the Labour races, it was the candidates you were bringing to life rather than, you know, you would I remember seeing a docker when Hawkey was prime minister where he'd just sort of each candidate would sort of have their hand shaken and there'd be the photo with Hawk and that was the main pitch. It was totally different. Yeah. So if that's the case though Let's talk about some of those specific races. I I wanna hear about your home state particularly and what went on there 'cause she looked like an amazing candidate, a pediatrician, was it? so what was the back story there, Corey?
CorySo South Carolina is a story of a state that's been building infrastructure and just sort of waiting for a while. If you if you remember, the analogy, I think, to the race in South Carolina was Alabama 2017, where you know, a Democrat had not won a Senate race in a very long time. the Republicans nominated someone credibly accused of child sexual assault. And the Democrat ended up winning because there was a good Democratic campaign that was waiting for an opening. Same thing happened in South Carolina. the we had an incumbent Republican senator, Lindsey Graham. he died in the middle of the year. He very likely would have cruised to victory. He probably, even in this sort of environment, I think that he probably would have won by at least three or four points. he died. Donald Trump named his replacement. He he named Lindsey Graham's sister, Darlene, and most states. Anywhere you know in Australia and the US, they don't like having their their leaders named for them instead of, having any say over who they are. and
Peter LewisAnd Darlene was no rocket scientist, was she?
CoryNo, quite. She you know, South Carolina's a very global state. We're we're the home of of early tr of basic training for both the Army and the Marines, you know, very sort of outwardly thinking state. And in a debate, she said, I don't know much about foreign policy. Well, that's an important thing for the senator from South Carolina. and Annie Andrews just run a fantastic race. I think, you know, she she just didn't make mistakes. She was, you know. Very much in the center, I think, what in Australia you would call center right, what in the US we'd call center left, down the line, everything that she did was about affordability, her signs were about it was something grits and groceries. it was about healthcare, it was about f cost of food, it was, very very focused on on pocketbook economics. And then when you have a terrible Republican candidate who's tied to a to a president that Even voters in a state that voted for Trump by double digits were starting the souron. It created an environment in which the Democratic Party in South Carolina has been organizing for years. And and I do want to give huge credit to Jamie Harrison and Crystal Spain, who who helped lead the Democratic Party in South Carolina. This is the first time in in I think 50 years the Democrats ran a candidate in every single state legislative seat all across the state. And having that organizing apparatus meant that when you have an opportunity, you're able to win even in a place that no one expected you to win even a year ago. so massive credit to to the the team in South Carolina that had been sort of building the groundwork. And then when the Republicans put up a very silly candidate that had no business being there, Democrats could take advantage.
Peter LewisHm. What about you? Did you have a favorite race, Dhammy?
Damian DamjanovskiI I did. the Michigan race, I think, and I think it's one of the ones that most people tuned in for because it it was fascinating on a whole bunch of levels. I think for me,
Peter LewisFull of drama.
Damian Damjanovskiit was a lot of drama. so for those who don't know, the the the Michigan Senate race, which was Abdul El Sayyid versus Mike Rogers, who was incumbent, Abdul got a lot of
Peter LewisNo. Au contraire. He had knocked off the sitting senator in the primary, Haley Graham, I think.
Damian Damjanovskiyeah, sorry, sorry, in the in the primary, yes, he knocked off the sitting site. You're absolutely right. But
Corycontrary to both of you, it was a Democratic seat who decided not to run for reelection. Gary Peters was the incumbent.
Peter Lewissorry. Lucky we've got an expert in the room.
Damian DamjanovskiThere. That's right. Yeah. Thank you for the clarification. But so this was I found this a very interesting race. And please, Corey, correct me where I'm wrong here, because again, American politics is not necessarily my forte. But he's he's beat Mike Rogers, which was the Republican Senate candidate, by about seven points. He will become the first Muslim US senator, which is I I actually think it's amazing that the the United States has not had a Muslim senator up until now. I think just statistically that's fascinating. he's never actually held elected office before this. He he used to be a public health director, but he's never really held elected office. The primaries was the really fascinating thing because he just he literally just scraped through. the Democrats did not want him to run, right? There there's there's no way you can look at this and go, the Democrats really wanted this guy because he was going to shake things up. The Democratic machine was entirely designed to make sure he didn't run. And if he did run, that he didn't win. And yet he defied those odds. Now, one thing that says to me is again, this is a story of an outsider versus insider thing. So that even within the democratic machine, he is very much an outsider to the system.
Peter Lewishe's part of the Mandami, Bernie, AOC, DSA push, isn't he, Corey?
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, so so why I find this interesting is I, you know, seeing a lot of people talking about this as a huge win for progressive politics, I think is a bit of a misread. What I see it as is because outsider is is very much another a very polite way of saying a populist, right? They're they're synonyms for one another. So when we say, he's an outsider, what we are saying is he's a populist, right? Just like Donald Trump was an outsider and came into power and then Came in to dominate the Republican Party, these characters are very much the same thing, but they're taking a very different populist angle. Most of his message was focused against corruption. And yes, there was a message around Medicare for all, but that was kind of the third tier on the point. And then if you look at the counties where he won, outside of the ones that you'd expect him to win in, it was a fair few rural counties. So these are not people who are voting Medicare. For all what they're voting for is I need to get, as Corey mentioned earlier, we need to get rid of these tariffs. We need to make sure we have fair trading conditions. I need to get im I need to get immigrants in here to help me on the farm and I need petrol prices to be lower. So you need to end this war.
Peter LewisHis was money in your pocket, money out of politics, public health for all. I think or healthcare for all. What what do you make of the DSA piece of this puzzle, Cory? Because it it does confound the idea that it's a clean hit, because that is a real insurgence within the Democratic
Corylook, I'm my flavor of Democrat is whoever can win in whatever state they can win in. You know, John Osov won by 30 points in Georgia. I don't think he could have won in Mich in that race in Michigan. Abdul Al-Syed wins by seven in Michigan, he wouldn't have won in Georgia. Like whoever matches their state and is able to win, fantastic. I think the sort of nature between DSA and and And for those who don't know, the DSA is the Democratic Socialists of America. they're sort of the the furthest left side of of American politics. I think at this point, especially given the success that Zoran Mamdani is having in New York, they are realizing that their chance success is through these sort of this sort of economic populism rather than going after culture war issues. And I think they've made a couple of missteps in going towards. some of the culture war issues, particularly on on Israel, on trans rights, that,
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Coryyou know, like Dama was saying, the the American public just isn't ready to have that conversation right now. But I think they, much like the moderate side of the of the party, understand that what voters want to hear is about cost of living and that's it. And they're gonna be more aggressive on certain elements of that. But you know, they they did did run a couple of candidates in major statewide races. The other one that that I look at is Angie Nixon in Florida, who came within two points of winning a Senate race in
Peter LewisWas she DSA too?
CoryFlorida. Yeah, she was DSA.
Peter LewisWow.
Coryso you know, this was a you know, I I think if if in some states a DSA candidate is going to be more electable than a moderate, and in that place, great, run And yeah.
Peter LewisCan I ask so it looking at the Australian equivalent, is the DSA kind of green vibes? Like if the Greens and Labour are in coalition, is that how you'd see that, like, you know, the more afflu like you know, the the wealth like with New York, it's kind of like the inner city seats the Greens have picked up?
CoryI think, remember the the Overton window in America is much further to the right than it is in Australia. I think it's a little more labor left, labor right. you know, what people like El Sayed are pitching isn't that far off from sort of labor left here. in terms of sort of urban power, kind but like Angie Nixon wasn't from one of Florida's big cities. So, it's it's hard to paint that. Of course, the the DSA has strongholds in New York and LA, and in sh in probab in in Chicago to a certain extent, but I think it's you know, they also have have they're able to win races in a lot of other in a lot of other
Damian DamjanovskiHmm.
Coryparts of the country.
Damian DamjanovskiBut but Corey and Peter, I want to know what your district is, but I like just to I I love what you said there at
Peter LewisYeah. Mm. Rat of that.
Damian Damjanovskithe beginning, which very much is and I was wanted to point out on both Mamdani and Elsaid, which is whenever they tried to step into the culture war, the reaction they got across the spectrum was the same, which is, you know, to sum it up in a crude way, shut the fuck about shut the fuck up about pronouns. Tell me how you're gonna make petrol cheaper, groceries cheaper, and my life a little bit easier. I I I I do not have the capacity to care about whatever these other issues are, whether it's
Peter LewisBut that was the genius of Mandami. He didn't even go there. he was so disciplined on like he was yes, he was socializing bodegas like seven elevens, like
Damian DamjanovskiBut but Peter, isn't this isn't this a broader issue where we're realizing more and more across the world that people are going, wait a minute, you as a government, your job is to redistribute wealth and funds, tax people properly, provide services, and then get the hell out of the way. we we don't really want you to do the other things. That's not what you're there for.
Peter LewisHm. I think it's also a reaction to that idea there is no alternative, this is the way the system works, and people that can find a way into that conversation. So, you know, in a way, identity politics is about a system imposing itself on voters, whereas the economic populism is the voters imposing it themselves on the system. So it is really interesting. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Well what was your favorite race?
Peter LewisWell, I have a little bit of well A little bit of skin in Texas. One of essential staff in Sydney Kat's brother is Greg Cazer, who was the Texas congressman, who romped home, like with 83% of the vote in his district. He was actually a beneficiary of a gerrymander that the Republicans had bought in. But Texas has always been this state where It's almost, I feel like Cory, the boulevard of broken dreams. I remember Bed O'Rourke was going to win it. And I think he had a tilt for president at one stage as well. And traditionally there's hype in Texas and then there's an underperformance. But really interesting that a lot of, you know, border operations around Texas had a real impact on both you know, construction and agriculture, but also people just being dragged out of neighborhoods like it was like, you know, the jack boots coming into town and the The pushback has been so significant. So the the Senate race, Talarico got fifty-five percent. They've got their first Latina governor, a woman, Gina Honjella, who was on fi with a 52%. So really
CoryHe knows up.
Peter Lewissignificant shift. And I guess the question there is, Cory, like, you know, Texas isn't redneck land at all. Like Austin is a very, you know, progressive city, but can can they build a base that that becomes an ongoing part of the map? Democrats.
CorySo two things as we lead into that. one, you know, t going back briefly to the to the point about identity politics, you know, mentioned Gina Gina Hinahosa, who will be the first Latina governor of of Texas. By running on this sort of economic platform, Democrats elected a huge number of of demographic firsts. You it's it was first Muslim senator, first fem first Latina governor of Texas, first N
Peter LewisAfrican American governor, yeah.
CoryFirst black woman governor in Georgia and Keisha Lance Bottoms, first Native American woman governor in Deb Holland in New Mexico. you have all these first because when you put the economics first, you can then start to go and and and have some of these more cultural conversations.
Peter LewisYeah. So they weren't running on DI, they were running on economics, but the the a the end point is diversity. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiBut here's part of the issue, and I I think as we talk about some of the because I I wouldn't mind moving on from American politics because we've had so many elections over the past two weeks. But the only thing I was just gonna
Peter LewisThink Cory's got one more point before we get there 'cause I cut him off.
Damian Damjanovskiadd to that is there is such a huge distance between being elected in based on a protest, based on a yes, I agree with you. You're pointing out the problem and I agree with you. I see eye to eye with you in pointing out the problem. But then fixing the actual issue. I think Trump too has discovered this. I think Biden discovered this. I think in Australia Albanese is slowly discovering this, which is being the one to point out, yes, there's a lot of problems and we need to fix them, is very, very different to actually implementing solutions that appeal to people or that at least are at a level of pain that people are willing to tolerate for long enough to go, yeah, we have to do this thing if we want to fix the thing that's wrong. And, With all the other priorities we have to balance.
Peter LewisBut there's a di there to be fair, there's a difference between grappling with wicked problems and actually using the presidency to make yourself and your friends rich and actually making things a lot, lot worse. Like I don't know if there's
Damian Damjanovskic completely agree. Sorry, that that wasn't in defense it was not a defense of Trump. It was more of a a a little bit of an indictment of it's one thing for the Democrats to get this kind of blue nami in the midterms. It's going to be a whole other task for them to actually govern effectively and achieve something without just within six months or twelve months saying, we can't achieve every anything, any of the things we set set out to do because of these 20 excuses that we have.
CorySo this is what I want to end on in terms of the the US politics segment here. Is again going back to that state level. So on the political front, the fact that now Texas, Georgia, and Arizona, every statewide elected office is now controlled by Democrats, that does a lot both for the political organizing side. Now that gives an anchor for future organizing, it gives a Capacity to raise more money. An incumbent governor can raise a hell of a lot more money than someone running for office somewhere else. But I think, you know, Demo's right. The question now, I sort of put Congress and Washington on one side. People living in these states, the just elected Democrats into their state's executive offices, are now gonna look to those people and say, you promised me that we were gonna get corruption out. You promised me that we were gonna lower the cost of living. And I think Democrats now have a massive opportunity to do that. And if they do that, that then changes the the national conversation around the quite awful brand of the Democratic Party right now. This is the first step. We could we could fuck it up. we could, not be able to to deliver on our promises. But this is the first step to be able to say, You you voted us in on a promise to get rid of someone you didn't like. You you've put your trust in us to do something different. Starting in January, they get to they get the opportunity to do that.
Damian DamjanovskiSo I've I've I I agree with you, Corey. I just I I find it very fascinating because obviously, you know, twenty twenty four and even Trump one point like the the platform that he campaigned on wasn't all that radically different, right? So he the language was different, yes. But essentially he was saying the same s the same things, which is we need to end corruption, we need to drain the swamp, we need to get the all this stuff out of politics and really you know, we need to get Here are all the problems, and this is how I'm gonna get rid of them. Yeah, yeah. It's it's it it's literally the the exact same stuff. So that's what I'm saying. It's it's this, it's this, it's the
Peter LewisBut also end foreign wars, bring down prices, and then you are presiding over a dying empire, so you've got challenges, don't you?
Damian Damjanovskisame, so, so people, I've got mates who are very, very left wing who are like, this is so amazing, this is so refreshing. And I'm sitting there going, This is the exact same stuff Trump was saying, but in different words. this is nothing different. So why are these guys gonna do it? they were in government for four years, they weren't able to achieve it. Dr. They brought Trump
Peter LewisSure.
Damian Damjanovskiback. He hasn't been able to achieve it. Next up, whoever's like, 'cause there are structural problems underlying this whole damn thing.
CoryYeah, but I think what Mom
Peter LewisYeah. Can I
CoryDonnie shows is you can actually do stuff. it you you have to just be willing to go into government and do things that help people. n mayors of New York have for so long said, we have these institutional blocks to being able to do these things to help people. And then it seems like every day Mom Donnie has a press conference saying, All right, for thirty years they said we couldn't do this. Well, it just happened behind me and happy that happy that we did it and on to the next thing. I think it's just a matter of political will to do it. But also the reason that Trump couldn't do half of it is just incompetence. he very easily could have used Republican majorities in Congress to pass bills to do things. He just didn't care to do it.
Peter LewisCan I ask one more
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, no.
Peter Lewisquestion before we move on and it might be a segue into some of the other elections that we're going to talk about because that wasn't the only election this week. Cory, what role did the tech oligarchs and AI do you think play in the election? 'Cause there's a reading of this that that was the other thing people were voting against, both data centres but also the trajectory and the velocity of the change around tech.
CorySo if you look at the ads, you would think the data centers were a big part of this campaign. You know, in South Carolina, Annie Andrews was running ads against Darlene Graham, calling her data center Darlene. That if you look at the polling, though, that was not a main issue in terms of like the AI industry itself or data centers. Again, it's all cost of living. So I think it mattered in in the sense of cost of living. I think the the tech oligarchs mattered in the conversation about corruption. Those are the sort of avatars of corruption in the Trump world because it, that goes to crypto, that goes to, the people sitting around Trump at his inauguration, that picture featured in in several ads. so I don't think that like AI as a technology played much, much here. There were a couple of instances in terms of like AI-generated ads, but I don't think much happened there. I think the much more interesting things happened in Brazil. But AI came in into play in terms of sort of the oligarchs around Trump. And importantly, sort of to put a button on this, the when Democrats take control of the House in particular, they've already signaled that they're going to bring the CEOs of the major tech companies that have financial dealings with Trump, his family, and the White House in front of congressional committees to give testimony. So I think it mattered in the conversation about corruption. I don't think the technology of
Peter LewisMm.
CoryAI was actually something that most Americans really tried to to recognize. I don't think so.
Peter Lewisdamn. So it wasn't a Luddite backlash despite my Hey, but take us into Brazil, 'cause that was another election of last week where a stripling insurgent, eighty year old Lula, has regained power. What went on there and then you you wrote about Meta's involvement in that. Do you want to take us through that a little?
CorySure. So this year in Brazil, they had their presidential election. The incumbent Lula, who's now 80, was seeking a fourth term. in 2022, he had beat a guy named Jair Bolsonaro. viewers and listeners may remember in 2022,
Peter LewisSun off.
Coryafter Jair Bolsonaro lost, he tried to January 6th his way back in and then ended up fleeing to the United States, only to come back and be arrested and sentenced to 27 years of prison time, including a ban on participating in politics. That becomes important in a moment. his son Flavio Bolsonaro ends up running, becomes the sort of right-wing candidate in that election. and then Flavio Bolsonaro actually won the first round, and that was late September, early October. And then as we go into the second round, Lula comes back, there's a there's resurgence, Lula ends up winning by four or five points. That campaign. one of the big elements of that was about foreign interference. It was about who gets to decide control of Brazil's future. Lula being a leftist firebrand, particularly amongst unions and native communities. but one thing sort of on the tech side of things was Meta had so the company that owns Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp. They publicly acknowledge that they accidentally, in quotes, interfered in the election, that they allowed the Bolsonaro campaign to do things, they allowed people to interact with the Bolsonaro campaign in ways that they did not allow people to interact with Lula's campaign. That came to play a role when in the protests in the final week before the election, people were on the street chanting. That Meta needed to get out of their elections. They began to see US involvement via Meta in their election. That became something that people in Brazil voted on, which I think becomes quite interesting. The other thing that I'll mention on Brazil, about two weeks before the first round of voting, though, the round of voting that Bolsonaro won. So his father, Jair, is banned from participating in politics. He cannot. Release ads, he can't endorse candidates, he cannot speak in public when it comes to politics. This is, he tried to overthrow his own government, fair punishment. So in response, his son's campaign released an AI-generated video of his father endorsing him. And the AI-generated video said, This isn't actually, was open saying, This is AI generated, this isn't actually me, I'm banned from participating in politics. But it was a fascinating use case of AI to say, to to bring someone banned from politics in. And I think raises a big question of when are we gonna start seeing those AI generated images of, historical figures, of
Peter LewisMm.
Coryyou know, w whatever the case may be. That it was a fascinating election to to watch and ends with Lula winning.
Peter LewisThis is why I just think there is no positive use case for deep fakes in politics. Can you see one, Darmy?
Damian Damjanovskidisagree, but we'll we'll we'll come back to that. I think the the only thing I'll add to the Brazilian stuff, Peter and Corey, because I think it's quite fascinating, is again, I think I think there's a lot of surface level celebration of Lula getting re-elected because he is a, you know. As you called it, a left-wing firebrand getting re-elected as president. But in many respects, the Brazilian election was a a mirror image of what happened in the US because they had their congressional election around the same time and their Congress moved to the right. So Lula as president has a hostile center right. It's it's not quite as formalized as the US because there's a lot more parties involved, but it is definitely a right-wing Congress where he is gonna. very much struggle to achieve anything because even though he got re-elected as a left-wing fire brand, congressionally and in individual electorates, they moved further to the right, which keeps on track with what is actually happening across the board in Latin America, which is most Latin American governments have moved further to the right than essentially they've ever been before. So I I just find it interesting that again, the the that surface level celebration by a lot of my progressive friends being like, yes, we Lula again. I'm like, but but your con the Congress moved much further to the right than it's ever been before. And I don't know,
Peter LewisCan I
Damian Damjanovskiit's the like the Bolsonaro's party got the largest single bench majority since the constitution was set up in eighty eight or whatever it was in Brazil. Like that's that's that's significant.
Peter LewisThen how do you explain Lula winning, Corey? And then just explain to me. So was the pushback on Meta just the presence of the company serving ads, or was there a sense that Meta was actually interfering?
CorySo on the first one, Demo's right, that this, you know, Brazil as a whole, especially in those congressional elections, did did move to the right. I would push back a little bit. I don't think it's the furthest right they've ever gone. They did have a military junta for quite a while.
Damian DamjanovskiWell yeah, I w I that but I wouldn't
Peter LewisFair point.
Damian Damjanovskiconsider that a democratically elected
CoryNo, but you know, the I I think the presidential election was a rejection of Bolsonaro personally. And I think this is again a different dynamic. in terms of meta, there were a couple of things that that happened. it allowed Bolsonaro's campaign to serve ads during a a time where legally they could not serve ads. It allowed people to generate AI-generated content of Bolsonaro in a time
Peter LewisMm.
Corywhen No campaign should be allowed to do that. And it did not allow the Lula campaign the same thing. And it allowed Bolsonaro's campaign to show up in algorithmic searches. So not just like going and directly searching for a candidate, but sort of algorithmic ranking. They allowed the Bolsonaro campaign to show up in algorithmic ranking, and Lula's campaign didn't.
Peter LewisDid they allow the attacks on meta to turn up in their algorithm or did they block those as well, or don't we know?
CoryThat's a question. I don't know. the the sort of
Peter LewisZuckerberg's all for freedom, so you'd assume that that would have been all for
CoryYou you'd think, but I to me is coming from the American political space, but also thinking a lot about how American tech is woven now into so much of the rest of the world, there's now a really fascinating case where you have a Brazilian population, regardless of who they voted for in that presidential election, that now has a sense that this massive American company that has its hooks on on so many parts of Brazilian society. Tried to influence their election in a very political way. and the implication here, and Meta didn't I have to be clear, Meta denies that this is the case, but the implication here is that they did it because Lula's government in this past term had tried to limit some of the power that foreign social media companies had in Brazil, and this was sort of their attempt to put their thumb on the scale.
Peter LewisThat's so interesting. So tech becomes not just a target but part of the the the actual.
Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.
Peter LewisHey, we could stay on each of these for so long, but I also want to talk to you, Dharma, about Serbia. I know you were over there, was it earlier this year? It must have been. so tell us so
Damian DamjanovskiNo, it was la it was this time last year. Just before this time last year.
Peter Lewisanother so student list has taken power there, which isn't really
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter Lewisa party, it's more like a gang of like in the nicest possible way.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, so s
Peter Lewistell us what's been happening.
Damian DamjanovskiSerbia's super fascinating. So I'll I'll give you the very brief backstory just for the for the sake of time. So about two years ago in Serbia, in a northern city called Novi Sad, what happened was a railway station canopy. So, you know, when you go out front of the railway station, there's a covering, it was made of concrete, it collapsed and killed 16 people. this got basically put down to the The funding that was meant to be used on the canopy, it wasn't done correctly, corruption, who's responsible, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. people believe the government was basically covering over the fact that people had taken money out of what was designated for construction of this railway canopy and the upgrade of the railway station, and instead pocketed that kind of money. The government basically wouldn't point a finger at anyone. They no one got charged, no one got all this kind of stuff happened. Anyway, it sparked a movement. Hundreds of thousands of people across Serbia, generally younger people, because most of those 16 people who died, including you know, 14-year-old, were students. So we're talking like two years of nonstop protests of hundreds of thousands of people. If you don't follow Balkan politics, and I imagine most of our listeners don't because they've got better things to do, just do a
Peter LewisIs it balkanized, Balkan politics, by the way? It's heavily balkanized.
Damian DamjanovskiIt it it was we we gave you the term, so enjoy. do a YouTube search for Belgrade protests just to see the scale of these protests. military was involved. It was it was insane.
Peter LewisI know. I I went down the wormhole today, it's wild. Yeah.
Damian Damjanovskiwhen we were there in October of 2025, so roughly this time last year, the it was the one-year anniversary, the mother of I think it was actually the 14-year-old who basically was both still grieving, but you know, needing a sense of justice, decided to do a a hunger strike outside the parliamentary, the the presidential palace, the parliamentary building. And so where the presidential building is in Belgrade, there's an exclusion zone out the front. out the front there's a big park. And that's where the pro-government protesters camp out. So she stood outside that to basically do a peaceful, you know, a silent hunger protest. And then what the government decided to do, well, the government, what the pro-government protesters decide to do to basically annoy this woman was to play turbofolk music at crazy volumes to two, three o'clock in the morning, just so that she couldn't sleep.
Peter LewisThat's gotta be against the International Human Rights Convention, I would have thought. That sort of music. Yeah.
Damian Damjanovskiif you've listened to TurboFolk, you would you would know just how outside of it it is. But so anyway, all this said is basically there was deep seated dissatisfaction with the government in Serbia. Vucic, the the president, has most of the power. He calls a snap election in September of this year. And the students basically get together and form what they call the student list. So, number one, no students can be on the student list. What it is, is a list by the students of people they are nominating in these SNAP elections to be in power. They do not assign any leader to the movement. They have like spokespeople and ambassadors, but there is no single leader.
Peter Lewisleaderless movements.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd basically it's a leaderless movement that is entirely a cobbled together anti-corruption movement. It isn't like a lot of people I think have couched it as a left-wing movement. It definitely isn't. If you look at some of the people in that in on that student list and who are part of that, it is very much across the board. The primary focus of it is anti-corruption and government reform. So I would call it a populist reform movement, which is very fascinating because I don't think we've seen a populist reform movement anywhere in quite some time.
Peter LewisIt s feels a bit like Vaslav Havel in Czechoslovakia out of yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiExactly right, exactly right. And so they they sweep into power. So they they Vucic is now gone. So so he resigned from the presidency with the intention of getting voted in as prime minister and shifting power out of the presidency into the prime ministerial ship, which is exactly what Putin did in Russia. Vucic also mates with Putin, like that they do they they are friendly. So not that he's anti Western, but he's not pro-Western, if you know what I mean. He's very we do our own thing because Serbia. and so he's now completely out of the picture, essentially. And this student list of a leaderless movement now has to actually
Peter LewisWow.
Damian Damjanovskifigure out how to reform a country that has been wedged between not being towards the West, but not bending the knee to Russia. remembering that the, you know, Yugoslavia back in the day was the founding member of the non alignment. Right. So this is the part of the world where even after World War II, they went, you know what? Your Western versus Eastern divide. We don't care for it. We're just going to do our own thing. So it has this history of basically going, we we don't want to be aligned to either of you. We just want to, we just want to do our own damn thing. And now you've got this crazy mishmash of academics and doctors and economists and the student list and the candidates on there. Very fascinating. who now somehow have to reform this system. And it just reminded me of that episode of The Simpsons where they put all the Mensa people in charge and they think they're going to do a really good thing, but they end up screwing up the whole system. So I I've I've got so much hope for them, but I have a horrible fear that it's going to collapse and turn into populism in the wrong way again.
Peter LewisHey Cory, one of the things that strikes me with that story that it really starts with a breakdown of basic public infrastructure. And if you look at a number of the movements that are emerging around the globe, the French students started with the state of classrooms, the cockroach movement in India started with corruption in education, the Spanish protests started with the elderly woman being evicted from public housing. These are not right wing. like anti-immigration movements. They're about corruption and delivery of basic services. It's so interesting, isn't it?
CoryWell, and I think that's the story of of politics right now. we we've spent a long time sort of trying to figure out left-right divides in in sort of the global elections. And I think the result of sort of the the right-wing movements that happened in 2016 and sort of around there are now sort of coming into fruition in in particular ways. I mean, and this isn't all sort of you know, against Right wing governments, Spain has a a fairly socialist government,
Peter LewisYeah, correct.
Coryand you're seeing those protests. I mean, I it's hard for me to ever define what Macron exactly is, but I think that's kind of the point.
Peter LewisI think he struggles as well, yeah.
Corybut you know, I I think you're right. I think this is now the story of
Peter LewisWell, actually, sorry to interrupt, Macron's an embodiment of that student list vibe, someone coming in with no political history saying, I can fix it all up, right?
Damian DamjanovskiAnd and and
CoryWell
Damian Damjanovskidon't forget how quickly that movement collapsed in the first instance after he got voted in, and it took him years to build it back up.
CoryWhat I would argue is, and and this sort of leads into a question I've for Damo, I don't think it's I don't think Macron's probably the best example here. It's Zelensky. I mean, Zelensky was a Canadian. you know, he played a president on television and then somehow rode that into being sort of the central force of Ukrainian politics. But one thing that's fascinating to me, well, one one quick note before then, I think you've also seen a lot of this in Ukraine in particular. I was there last year. Covering the anti-corruption protests when Zelensky tried to get rid of Nabu and Sapo, the sort of corruption watchdogs. and then you had tens of thousands of people on the streets of Kyiv protesting, and and there's a particular line from a song that was quite popular in Ukraine at the time saying, Why the fuck would I live in a system that doesn't work for me? And I that to me feels like one of the the sort of kernels that this has grown into. And then of course, this year, the the protests against Zelensky for firing Fedorov. Those sort of meted out once Fedorov, I think, took a step too far and and tried to sort of demand too much and then the the protests went away. But those at the start were were very much anti anti-corruption protests. but the question that I have for Damo in sort of thinking about Serbia, where does the student list go on Russia-Ukraine? There's been That's a it's a fascinating dynamic. I've seen some of the the student list people say, you know, they're gonna become much even closer than Vucic was to Putin. I've seen some of them sort of look westward. You saw you had both Putin and Zelensky releasing statements congratulating the student list. You had Ursula Vanderleyen, you know, stepping in here. What's your take? Where do you think Serbia now?
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, it's such a fascinating question. My I think there there's two camps at the moment. One is Serbia has to lean into the European Union and start its ascension planning and become a a candidate for for for EU membership. that's the only path for Serbia. And then there's the other camp which goes, no, no, what we need to do is, you know, align with our Slavic brothers and lean further into
Peter LewisJoin Briggs.
Damian DamjanovskiRussia, this, that, and the other. I think what will actually end up happening. Because it's happened so many times in that part of the world before, is they will go, hang on a minute, why are we stuck in this dichotomy? What is the other way? And I think there was, there was actually a Vucic era plan, which was the the what was called the open Balkans, right? And I think Vucic had a grand vision for it, but it was very Serbia-centric. And I think a lot of countries in the region didn't want to take part in it because of Vucic. I think under this new leadership, if they're really careful with it, They could do exactly what they did with the non-alignment movement, exactly what they did with the formation of Yugoslavia in the first place, which is go, actually, we don't have to be part of your union or your union. We can find people who are like-minded, similar to us, who bel who share our values, who share our way of life, and who share our want of prosperity without interference from Russia, the US, or China, and just be able to do our own thing. And they're the stubbornness in that part of the world means that they're one of the few areas that are actually capable of achieving that if they do it well. So
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskimy my hope is that that's the pathway they actually go down, which is moving into that kind of a functional open balkans between a lot of the economies in the area. Because together they, you know, they it's you know, Yugoslavia used to be a very powerful economy. Like it used to be a large economy. They have a big manufacturing industry, a big technical industry. They're a food bowl. there's no reason why they shouldn't be a prosperous economy in that
Peter LewisCan I ask one more question on Serbia Dame? would this have happened if was was the collapse of the railway station the catalyst or would like would have a hap would this sort of have happened anyway or yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiIt's such a good question. Yeah. So the the I think the the dissent and the dissatisfaction with the state of how things were was there. And what was happening was
Peter LewisYeah.
Damian Damjanovskia lot of people, especially talented younger people, were just were just leaving Serbia, right? They would they would move to Germany, Sweden, anywhere Austria is the main place, they would leave and basically go and work there and then, you know, do that for 10 years, come back home, buy a house and and and live out their life peacefully. I think what the Novi Sad incident did is basically give everyone a rallying point. What the technology did is allowed everyone to organize better than they'd ever organized before. So the the amount of Viber groups and sorry they use Viber in that part of the world, not WhatsApp, but the amount of Viber groups that would coordinate action webs like the way these
Peter LewisWho owns fibre?
Damian Damjanovskiit's a Finnish company, I think it is, or Swedish or Finnish.
Peter LewisMm. Off sure of Nokia or something.
Damian DamjanovskiIt's a Scandinavian company. It might be Estonian or something. Anyway, but it's it's a
Peter LewisIt's karma.
Damian Damjanovskiit's it's basically the the technology combined with that event, combined with the dissatisfaction, was a great confluence point for, and we say young people, but we're talking about people under 40 who are not employed by the state. That's the primary audience, right? So people who are not living off government money. So they're not a public servant here there or wherever, whereas public servants were very pro-vucich. and they were a younger generation, were able to. Coordinate and mobilize en masse. And I do think we're going to see more of this all around the world, which is people dissatisfied. Right. The the the whole point of the game of monopoly was to remind people that at some point, when someone is treated really unfairly in that game of monopoly, the board will be flipped over in anger. That's what will happen every single time. And we forget that lesson.
Peter LewisThe game of Monopoly was to teach people capitalism, which is inherently unfair, Darwin. anyway, look, we've spoken about three elections. We haven't even got to Israel. Do either of you have a hot take on like that, it's kind of still in a state of flux, it seems like the the preparedness or otherwise to do a deal with the Arabic parties probably will determine. in in place.
CorySo, yes, you know, the thing that I think is that I've been struggling with with Israel in this election, but really since October 7th, was, and I think this election showed it. Eisencote's supporters, the average age was in a 60s and 70s, where Netanyahu's supporters in this election were quite young. The Guardian had a fantastic video. Where they went and and interviewed several of of Netanyahu's supporters, twenty, twenty-five years old, who are far right, you know, to the point where they are openly saying that, you know, Palestinians deserve to be murdered. That I think one even called Netanyahu too far left for them. And this was outside of Ben Gavir rally, so you know, take that for what it's worth. But I think that distinction is something worth Taking into account, because if you're looking at these anti-corruption movements around the world, you know, whether, you know, whatever political flavor flavor they are, everything that you just mentioned is largely being led by young people. That that is where
Peter LewisMm.
Corythe political base is. In Israel, it's the exact opposite. October 7th had a really severe galvanizing effect on young people in Israel in a way that I think we're gonna have to deal with for a long time. Because that's going to be a political coalition that is going to force rightward shift in whatever government comes next and whatever government comes next for
Peter LewisMm.
Corythe next generation or two.
Peter LewisYou also hear anecdotally a lot of the the settler movements are being driven by young Americans coming across to Israel. Like the New Jersey resettlement movement appears to be a real thing.
CoryWell, one of the things that I think people miss is the support in America for the settler movement, for sort of the the more extreme sort of Netanyahu Ben Gavir sort of side of Israeli politics comes not from American Jews. It comes from American evangelicals. So a lot of the money that that is coming in and supporting this comes from American evangelicals who are behind things like APAC. They are the ones so I'm Jewish. I went on birthright in twenty sixteen, went on the the trip to Israel. That is almost entirely funded by American evangelicals who have a theological
Damian Damjanovski'Cause they they believe you're the chosen people, right? It they
CoryAnd beyond that, it's not just that we're the chosen people. They believe that if they can somehow get all Jews into Israel, that Christ will come again and you know the world will be saved and blah, blah, blah, blah. The that dynamic of of the American evangelical support for this movement, I think, deserves a lot more attention. There are fantastic journalists covering it, but it deserves to be more, more part of the conversation. Because yes, you the People are moving into the West Bank, these, American settlers are coming in because they're being there are financial incentives for them to go and do it. When they go and move to the West Bank, they are being given a house. They're being given, financial resources to go and live on this land that does not belong to them because there
Damian DamjanovskiAnd security.
Coryis a political project. Yeah, exactly.
Damian DamjanovskiI I I I I think that's fascinating. And I my only addition to this, Peter, because I I'm very reticent to talk about Israeli politics because someone is bound to be offended. and what I appreciate and I you know, like B B and Gardi both have, you know, things about that are right and wrong or whatever, depending on your point of view.
Peter LewisI think you've already offended a few people with that statement itself.
Damian DamjanovskiProbably so this is a part of the world, one of the very few parts of the world where you literally have th you know, at least three very prominent religious groups in terms of Jewish people, Muslim people, Christian people, not to mention subdivisions and all the others. And they are very wedded to their religious beliefs. Within them you have Very Orthodox Jewish people. You have very liberal Jewish people, like reform progressive Jewish people, same with the Muslim populations. You have both Shia, Shia and Sunni Muslims there. You have all kinds of different Christian sects there. And all of these people came together for what, for the most part, was a peaceful election where they did their vote. And it's not a two-party system, it's a multi-party system of. Coalition and negotiation. And I gotta say, for all the shit canning that people do about the Israeli elections, I go, that is a feat. To be able to pull that off in that part of the world should be applauded because
Peter LewisMm.
Damian Damjanovskias of right now, it is the only country in that part of the world who is capable, that is capable of pulling off a election in that level of complexity. Like I don't think Australia would be capable of. A multiparty coalition based system of elections with people with such strong views to the degree that Israel has done. And that needs to be applauded. I'm sorry, but it does.
Peter LewisWell we might be about to find out. Hey, I know we've gone a bit over time, but it just is such a fascinating convo. Before we let you go, Cory, like so the the the research you're doing in Australia around AI and democracy, I wonder if there's anything from this broad discussion we've had that's traversed American politics, the role of big tech in Brazilian politics, the the importance of moments to drive movements in in Europe. Is it all just chaos theory or is there something that you can see that's holding like how should we be thinking about all this?
CoryI think putting my academic hat on, which is square and rectangular or square and felty.
Peter LewisThe roof.
Corythe I think the way you sort of can read all of this is the last 20, 30 years, from an American perspective, I would I would sort of put it around 9/11, but you know, you can put that dot in lots of places around that time. People have felt like they've lost agency in politics. Now, what I look at particularly on the technological side is As a result of machines now making socially relevant decisions, people feel like they're losing a sense of agency in society, that it's no longer they, you know, just humans that are making these consequential decisions. They don't know how to push machines to make decisions in the way they knew how to push people. I think that is also being reflected in a broader politics that you're seeing in all these protest movements, where people have, for several years and several decades now. Felt like they're losing a sense of popular control. Now, that is in a way politically neutral. popular control could mean anything in the political spectrum. But when you talk about corruption, corruption is essentially the removal of agency away from citizens. And I think on the technological side, that's something that people are also experiencing via this push AI.
Peter LewisAnd the betrayal
Damian DamjanovskiDo do you
Peter Lewisof trust as well though. So I've s I've heard people with a similar analysis say that it really comes down to GFC and Obama bailing out the banks and the banks not having to pay the price for their failure. And after that there are no consequences to anything, and that's where trust got beaten as well. But yeah. Sorry, Dama.
Damian DamjanovskiI was just gonna say I was wondering, Corey, if you ever thought we'd we'd get to a point where we would elect a AI agent slash bot as a representative. And I'm I'm happy to defend why this is a really good idea, but I'm curious as to your thoughts.
Corylook, Albania has an AI minister. I I'm probably a little
Damian DamjanovskiSo it's listening to Peter's outrage at how loudly he slammed his glass down.
Peter LewisNo, I'm gonna say if we get to that world, the drink I will be having will help me voluntary assisted dying. I I'm done.
Damian DamjanovskiIt's just hemlock.
Peter LewisI am done.
CoryI generally think that it At this point in human psychology, human development, I think that that would begin to at sort of a societal level, that would begin to unravel a lot of our understandings of how we push officials, how we can, you know, shame or interact with them. AI doesn't work in the same way. And I don't think we as a society have really figured out how we engage with that idea. Now In the future, maybe we've figured out how to engage with this. Maybe the technology's changed. I don't know. But I think as things stand now, human psychology I think would melt down if we hand over even more public control to a decision making system, to a decision making machine that the vast majority of citizens, including people who work in many of these industries, leaving aside the security concerns of it. Just don't understand how it makes decisions.
Peter LewisGive us your pitch. Give us give us your sixty second pitch, man.
Damian DamjanovskiMy 60-second pitch is the whole system is designed for here's five people. All of them have a slightly different view. Pick the one that's the closest to your views that you believe will represent your views best. What if the alternative is help design the thing that is going to represent your views faithfully, combined with all the other views of the constituents in your area? that is essentially incorruptible and will faithfully represent your views and compete with other agents who represent the views of a different region to debate it out and make a decision based on what serves the most amount of people in the best way without offending the rights or the, you know, the values of other people.
Peter LewisAll based on predictive text.
Damian DamjanovskiNot just predictive text, but that's how you communicate through it. Yeah. It's not just predictive text. That's one part of it.
Peter LewisSo I think I'll be fair, I think you'd probably get more rational decisions. You'd probably you could build less corruption into the system, but if you take away the agency, then it is then we are kind of in the matrix, aren't we? Like we we lose control. And I my my counterpoint would be if you want to fix democracy, find ways of building feedback loops that are closer to the ground.
Damian DamjanovskiThis is where I disagree because this is where I say you get more agency. Because right now, how much agency does the average voter have to their MP? The most they can do is write a letter or turn up to the office and complain.
Peter LewisBut you'll talk about a
Damian DamjanovskiWhereas when you have the bot where you can where you as the constituent can interact regularly and go, hey, justify why you voted this way on this bill so I understand it. And it goes blah, blah, blah. You go, Well, that doesn't agree with my views. And it goes, Well, look, there's 385 other people in your electorate that believe this. I have to re like you can you can help.
Peter LewisBut but view views are socially informed
Damian DamjanovskiTailor the system 'cause it was
Peter Lewisand if you take the social out of the informing of the views, you it you you would But the choke point is the point. The friction is the point, yes.
Damian DamjanovskiNo, no, what you're doing is removing you're removing the choke point. You're removing the the professionalization. Is it? But the choke that it shouldn't be a choke point. It should be you having a social interaction with people of your community, not trying to influence one single individual human who's
Peter Lewiswe gotta k we gotta give okay. All right.
Damian Damjanovskionly gives a crap about whether or not they're going to get reelected.
Peter LewisThat seems like a longer discussion for yet another day, but that's great. Hey, before we go, I warned you about Kiss of Death, Cory. have you got a prediction for the week ahead?
CorySo I'll take a little bit of a gamble on the New Zealand election, the Battle of the Chrisses, but I will hedge my gamble and say that we won't know the result of that election until Christmas.
Peter LewisWow. I was actually going to do the same one and I've got a shout out to is it Clark Gayford who is Gacinta Ardern's partner? He's written a really funny piece in The Guardian today about the battle of the Chrisses, while the rest of the world is having these very bizarre elections. New Zealand's quietly having a conversation between two Chrisses. But the other thing, Dame, is so there is
Damian DamjanovskiThe least consequential election in the world is what happens in New Zealand.
Peter LewisBut it looks like there's this new group called Opportunity that has real teal vibes. And they look like they're gonna have the bal well, I think already the Nats have said they won't do a deal with them, but the but opportunity's calling for UBI and land tax and a bunch of things. So, you know, Martin and and and my and our mate Travis from Travis Mills, who spent a lot of time working in there, his prediction was that those guys would So it's might Travis's kiss of death actually. But yeah, so th keep an eye on opportunity.
Damian DamjanovskiThat'd it'd be very interesting, because obviously New Zealand has a mixed member proportional system, right? Which which yields very different results. And I think
Peter LewisMm.
Damian DamjanovskiPeter, you and I privately have talked about what would Australia look like, given that we are one of the only true democracies in the fact that we are compulsory voting, which is the only way you can have a true democracy. what would it look like if Australia had a mixed member proportional system rather than the current setup or our version of it, which would be some kind of hair clerk system? So it'll be interesting to see. My kiss of death, by the way. Very much.
Peter LewisProbably a bit like Tasmania. sorry, what's your kiss of death?
Damian Damjanovskimy kiss of death is, and I know we're gonna have a couple of episodes before it, but the Victorian election, I think I'm gonna I am gonna call it now that I think that we will know on election night that we are shifting away from years of what I would happily call a terrible Labour government in Victoria to a liberal government. I don't think it will be in coalition with one nation. I think it be a standalone liberal government helmed by Jess Wilson. And I think there might even be a minister for potholes.
Peter LewisWell, that is the thing. The one thing I'll say about that, two things I'll say about it. I d I've never seen four terms of government go well. So, thoughts and prayers with Jess Wilson. Sorry, friends from Victorian Labour. The second is the potholes become a genius avatar. Like that is what the election seems to be about. And it is just it potholes is actually what we've been talking about All day actually. We've been talking about the potholes in American democracy, the potholes in Brazil, the potholes all around Europe. and we've got a few potholes
Damian DamjanovskiIt's it's
Peter Lewisof our own. We've got through a whole hour and a bit without really talking about Australian politics, but we got potholes
Damian DamjanovskiNo, but it's it's
Peter Lewistoo.
Damian DamjanovskiPeter, I think it's one of those things where for Victorians, like they they see and in in any normal times, it would be a story and then it would go away that the Labour government spent half a million dollars on a ceremony for whatever. But every Victoria every Melbourneite is sitting there going, How can you spend half a million bucks on this and you literally can't fill up like if you don't do the basics right, you don't get to do that.
Peter LewisBut then once you start talking about potholes, it's like the elephant you're seeing, whenever you see a pothole, you're going, Bloody labor.
Damian DamjanovskiBut that's it because because because every Melbourneite who has to change their tires, upgrade their suspension, or just feel uncomfortable when they hit those gr humongous potholes on the Kingsway, which is one of the major thoroughfares, goes, You do not have a right to talk to me about cultural issues until the basic stuff
Peter LewisSo do you
Damian Damjanovskiis done well.
Peter Lewisdo you reckon there's young liberal hacks in Victoria spending their nights digging extra potholes just to sort of reinforce the key message of
Damian DamjanovskiI don't think they need to. I genuinely don't think they need to. I think that the government's done a great job of it as is. So just let them keep going. But that that's my prediction.
Peter LewisFantastic. On that note, we better put a thank you and we'll hold you to that one. Hey, Cory, thank you so much for sharing your your wisdom and your humour and your insights with us. people that aren't across your work, we'll put a link to your sites. I know you've been out doing some live shows as well. We're doing a live show last week of November that you're very welcome to join us if you can make it to Canberra on Wednesday, November twenty five. I think the tickets are actually starting To sell money because we've started giving them away rather than trying to sell them. But we'll
Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm.
Peter Lewiswe'll get there. And if you are interested, we'll put a link in the show notes. But we'd love to see you there. We're gonna be there with Politico, Ryan from Politico, and also our friends from the Westminster Tradition. I think Lizzie from Digital Rights Watch is gonna come up. We'll do a little burning platform session as well. So it'll be a great night. So I know that you're looking forward
Damian DamjanovskiFair good night.
Peter Lewisto it, Darmo. but in the meantime, Do all those things, share, subscribe. tell people if you like a different way of talking about politics with smart people who know what are going on in both Brazil and Serbia. I reckon that is a pretty niche offering in the Australian political
Damian DamjanovskiVery nice.
Peter Lewisscene. Please tell them about what's your poison. But have a great weekend, everyone
