Episode 32
The rest is democracy
With Tom Mooney & Yaron Finkelstein
Show notes
This week we're joined by Tom Mooney, executive director of democracy at McKinnon, and Yaron Finkelstein, former principal private secretary to Prime Minister Scott Morrison, about the health of Australian democracy. We discuss trust, citizenship, and what it takes to make government work for people. Tom shares the work McKinnon and the Democracy Counts campaign are doing to renew our democracy. We delve into falling faith in politicians and institutions, the rise of outsider parties, what COVID did to our relationship with government and expertise, and the role of big tech and social media in our democratic life. Along the way we explore the cooperation across the aisle that rarely makes the news, the incentives that reward conflict over substance, the case for regulation and social licence, and why democracy is a practice that goes well beyond election day.
A reminder that tickets are still available for our first live show at the National Press Club in Canberra on Wednesday 25 November, 6 to 9pm. It will be our final episode of the year, and the link is in the show notes. If you enjoy the show, please like, share and subscribe.
Chapters
- 00:00 Introduction to the Discussion
- 05:30 Understanding Democracy and Its Challenges
- 08:54 The Role of Citizens in Democracy
- 12:59 Trust and Distrust in Political Systems
- 15:31 The Rise of Alternative Political Parties
- 20:17 Impact of COVID-19 on Trust in Government
- 24:54 The Evolving Relationship Between Citizens and Government
- 31:02 Navigating Information Confusion
- 32:01 The Role of Big Tech in Democracy
- 33:55 Hyper Democratization and Technology's Impact
- 36:01 Regulation and Accountability in Tech
- 39:10 Government's Role in Safeguarding Democracy
- 42:44 The Functioning of Democracy in Practice
- 47:31 Reforming Democracy: A Long-Term Vision
- 49:59 Public Discourse and Civic Engagement
- 53:43 The Energy of Anger and Change
- 56:18 Perceptions of Wealth and Political Trust
- 01:00:56 Predictions and Future Trends in Tech
Full transcript
Read itHide it
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.
WYP32 03 Auto cut v2Welcome to What's Your Poison, the show where people who disagree on almost everything agree that it is better to do so over a drink. My name is Damed Domyanovsky. I'm a principal here at General Strategic. Joining me this week, as he does every week, is Mr. Peter Lewis from Essential, as well as two new guests, Jaron Finkelstein and Tom Mooney. Welcome guys. Thank you. Thank you. Firstly, Mr. Lewis, how's your week and what's your poison? Week's been good. Couple of days down in Melbourne, watching the car wreck that is the Australian cricket team. unfold in front of our eyes and drinking as we all are, Negronies for this discussion on democracy today, which we're about to jump into. Yes, introducing two of our very esteemed guests, Mr Yaron Finkelstein, who used to be Principal Private Secretary to Prime Minister No. 30, Scott John Morrison, and is now has his own firm, Society Advisory, and Tom Mooney, who used to be Chief of Staff to Penny Wong, now Foreign Affairs Minister. welcome to the both of you. What's your poison this week? W we're all under gradient. So you're in the grain as well. No backups for you guys? Yeah, it's a a cappuccino served at COP thirty one. That seems to be quite toxic. but that's a different story all the time, as we know. I just want to say up front, it's great to have four blokes solving democracy around the coaches, but I would around the couches, although I would say we've got diversity here, we've got a Jew, a gay, a WOG, and I'm sure that I could get a diagnosis if needed. And probably should after that statement as well. But you are also our matchmaker. You introduced me to Dharma. Very true. About 18 months ago. So you're responsible for this whole mess. That's right. Although once we put it through the computer system, it wasn't going to work. Remember Dexter? Am I too old? Dexter. Perfect match. Other good an old person remembers it. But they used to give this robot a bunch of data points and pretend that it was matchmaking and a bunch of people and then they'd go on and fever dreamer. And if we'd run it through Dexter, you two shouldn't be here. We wouldn't we could have. That would be a great idea. But the other it does strike me getting an app to like you know, everyone makes their friendships now through their little you know, their their Tinder or their grinder. I think I think that's actually gone on the outs now. So most people are now starting to join us. In real life, the run clouds walking clubs that you introduced to your evil evil twin. We could build the what's your poison? The Singaporeans though have just introduced an app to introduce public servants to each other. It's the the dating app is only open to public servants. That's correct. But for dating as well. Yeah, they're trying to reduce their population. What are they calling it? That's a good question. So Tom, you're now the executive director of Democracy at McKinnon. for lofty title. It is a lofty title for a lot of our listeners who who like listening to the show because we talk politics, democracy, where it works, where it's broken. I I do know, having spoken to a lot of people, that a lot of people aren't aware what McKinnon is, let alone that McKinnon exists to strengthen and improve our democracy. Tell us about it and why you reckon our democracy needs any improving or tinkering with at all. well McKinnon has been around for about 10 years now. It was founded by a couple called Dr. Sophie O and Grant Rule, with the idea that better governments can improve the outcomes for citizens. they do a range of things, better political or better training for political leaders and elected representatives. That I think we have seen that there is very little training for people who are elected to Parliament. You kinda get there and do it away. If you become elected MP, there's there's no initial training. Nothing. There's basically this is where your office is. Good luck, get some stuff. Have you done a day's training in your life? Yeah. I've run training. I've never done no one's ever trained. I've never done the training. I've run it. Yeah, no, but I'm never you need more boot than camp, I think. In most professional contexts these days there is training, but you know there's almost a disincentive to giving politicians training because then they might succeed. so no, but McKinnon is trying to fill that gap and make sure that there is an environment for that. And the idea is that you also bring together senior backbenches, so people who are likely to be in the executive, like shadow ministers and ministers, and you bring them together. So you at the same time as you're giving them better skills, you're actually building the relationships and civil Across the aisle. Across the aisle. And how does that work? Yeah, it works really well. Does Bob Catter do a talk every time? He must. As father of the house, surely he must. He comes in translations as well. So so there's the McKinnon Institute, which has been around for about six years now. They've got a hundred and seven alumni, so people who have been through that program. then we do work on p policy innovation, so looking around the world for best practice policy that can fix challenges we're facing. and I've run the democracy work, which is trying to make democracy more resilient. That's awesome. That's great. What I know that that's a wide range of programs. What Do you guys mean when you say democracy? Is it question? Is it the elections? Is it the broader practice? Is it because it feels like it's Yeah, is it the rules, is it the game, is it the teams, is it the spirit of the thing? You well, you say that there's different programs. I think they're all trying to solve the same problem in slightly different ways. So I think for us we're talking about outcomes for citizens, better policy development, better delivery, better more or better equipped leaders and elected reps. ultimately I think it's about making sure that we're solving problems that people are facing in their li everyday lives. And as long as democracy actually is important 'cause we are going to have governments and we are going to have leaders and we are going to have a whole range of things that matter to people beyond their own small part of life, the big part is government, what it does for you, then they should have an interest in making sure it works. Otherwise they'll just complain. That's not good and we want to make sure that people are happier. But there is also this tension between politics and making democracy work because there is always one team in the politics wanting the other side to fail. Like because there is because of the nature of the contest, isn't there? Like you've been in the middle of it, yeah. I think that's a very realistic assessment. There is Is that but I think voters are a bit more sophisticated. They actually give an opposition a role in this drama. Keep them to account. Tell us something we didn't know. fight for me if I think that the government isn't fighting for me. So it actually works quite well. There's a it's in balance to some degree. Although we are now seeing third ways, third parties, well, outsider insurgents on the absolutely people that are running the government. Some people argue that of course Parliament is not the be all and end all when it comes to democracy. We're now seeing a lot of other forces, a lot of players. You can do a lot of good outside of the outside. Yeah. Well, because it's interesting because obviously in Australia we still have that 30 to 40% of like the apathetic voter who, you know, self-admittedly don't really care about politics. They're not the kind of people who who watch or listen to this kind of stuff. But even in your framing, you talked about them as citizens. And I would argue, I think the majority of them probably wouldn't self-identify. As citizen in their top three things of how they they would sooner call themselves a consumer than they would a citizen. So I hate that that everyone's become like consumers and products. Well how would you how would you self describe would you do I could citizen is a good identity for people to carry? I don't like being in a hospital and being referred to as a customer. When I'm on a plane I'm a passenger, not a customer. I I actually think citizen although you're right, they may not self identify. I think it's distinctive to participating in and there was this whole push over the last decade in public sector about creating a better experience for citizens and they started using the whole consumer customer and it is it misses something because the interaction with the state is more than just a transaction. Correct. But but but I guess my my question there is because increasingly you've got this this big at least a third of the population who who they don't self-identify in that relationship. They're starting and have been trained into seeing their Relationship with government is transactional. I pay you tax, you do a thing for me. So I just wonder how this improving democracy initiative works with this third of Australia who's so disconnected from. This number, this third. Where are you going? Where what is this? Where have you conjured this number from? This is in the the post-election survey when people are from the ANU where they always ask about like when they'd formed their vote, did they care? Was it a firm vote? It always sits between roughly 30%, 40%. Okay, I know the study. But I think That there are different ways of measuring that. And we force people to vote. That's the first thing. In Australia, we have compulsory voting, and that that changes it. We don't force people to vote, we force people to turn up and take a ballot. As my wife always reminds me, nobody's forced to vote. So we are requiring them to think about it, even if it's just for a moment in time, and that that does change things. If you look at other jurisdictions, and we've just seen the US elections, where turnout was just under fifty For their midterm elections. And even when they had a hotly contested presidential campaign, Trump versus Harris, which was pretty big, it only reached 63%. So we are doing more to stimulate. And they also do it on a workday and make it incredibly hard to do. And there are no free sources. You need the horse and cart to be able to get to the polling booth. And it can't be on the Sabbath, so it has to be done on Tuesdays. I I think you're right though. I mean, think whilst people might not, Australians might not think about themselves as citizens or as consumers necessarily when they're talking about government and democracy. That that group of Australians who don't aren't interested, self identify as not being interested in politics, they are the people who are least trusting of our politicians and elected representatives at the moment and least satisfied with how the system is working. so they are the people who we actually need to try to get to think of themselves and democracy and our society slightly differently. That's a number that that distrust in democracy that seems to be on the the increase especially lately. So the latest Scanlan report on social cohesion came out and we saw especially amongst One nation voters, which is this growing group now, close to forty percent of them now agreeing with the idea that democracies might not be the best system of government. that is a huge number. How do you even start approaching arresting this decline at least amongst one segment of the population? Well, and the McKinnon index, which was out what, ten days ago now, I think, on the second of November, similarly found so we we The McKinnon index finds that seventy six percent of Australians still think democracy is the best system of government. That's holding pretty steady. But satisfaction with how it's working is low, about fifty one percent, and that's down from fifty five percent last year. So there's people going, I like the system, but I don't think it's running particularly. I don't think it's running particularly well and I don't trust my my elected representatives. I don't trust federal politicians, the federal government, state politicians, all the state governments. Tom, do you think that a lot of people are in in interpreting that data thinking of the parliament and the politicians in their version of what is a democracy? Yeah, as an abstract idea as well. And when when we ask people whether they like their or trust their local MP, it's a it's a better result. So when it's when it's a real person, it there's a higher level of trust. Although we saw this during the Banking Royal Commission, right? Everyone thought the banks were a bunch of C U N T But they like their bank. okay. Yeah. It just means it doesn't get into any of the algorithms that those five We get shut it down by the algorithm. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Thank you, YouTube and the team over at Google. We appreciate you as always. but no, it's it's that whole thing of like I hate the banks, but I like my bank. Correct. So so how do you how do you try and fix it? I I mean, people are already frustrated with the system. We're talking about that. and whilst people might not think about democracy as the term or as the idea that they are angry about, people already think that there are vested interests who are controlling decisions that impact them. they already think that there are lobbyists who are influencing their politicians. they are already struggling to get access to information about what's happening in in their lives. So I think it's tapping into their experience of it. and trying to provide the answer. And that's all a really rational response. And one of one of the and the drivers of outsider parties like One Nation are the system's not working for me. So they say epox on both your houses, of which you guys have been members of both those two houses. I I kind of sometimes worry, particularly on the progressive side, we go, One nation's on the rise, or we're not winning the debates we want, therefore democracy is broken. And so I aga again I think it's it's a definitional thing because if people are making Making those decisions, that's a sign, I think, that democracy is working, not the other. And then it's just understanding within that what the right rules are. Like so w how do you guys think of one nation within the context of building a healthy democracy? Well he went there pretty soon, didn't he? well I I'm happy to to start that because I take out the word one nation for a moment and ask the third party option or the fourth party, you know, an alternative. The Greens. The teals. It's that's right. And I I argue back to the compulsory voting aspect. If if we have roughly a third of people who we know from the presidential elections don't want to vote, your data, darn their people who are unengaged. A and us data not mine. A and us, that's right, the McAllister work, I think, from memory. So let's say about a third of Australians actually might not actually want to vote. Right? We force them to. There is a market at every election for some third Force on the so-called progressive side of politics, the teals are gobbling up that third vote, and on the other side it seems to be one nation. There's a market for it. It's as simple as that. The core part of this argument though is that people are seeking some kind of alternative. Doesn't matter left or right, they just want something different. Is that a good thing for democracy or a bad thing? And that's the bigger question. And what's interesting compared to the states, that the insurgence has happened within the old two party system, whereas here It's fragmenting a bit more like it does in Europe. Correct. That's exactly right. Yeah, most people don't appreciate that but there's a takeover of the existing parties in the US, not new parties. But that doesn't explain away why One Nation's vote had such a sharp rise, and especially after the tragic events of Bondi last year, One Nation has had a sharp increase, and we haven't seen the same sharp increases amongst the Greens, we haven't seen amongst the Teals or Independent Case. It's very much been all of that has gone to one nation. see that as correlation or causal. That's still reckoning a lot of it's the economy too, because that's when things started going south. south Yeah. Like it's been going south for a while. Like I think a lot of I don't know. There was kind of a latent frustration and anger already there though, right? We we did the 2025 McKinnon index before we saw that sharp rise in support for One Nation and we also did some of the other foundational research for the our campaign before that and we were seeing that deep distrust and frustration and dissatisfaction. And it's not an isolation of the two major parties. So Labour, it's a sense of I don't know, what would you describe people's dis disaffection for Labour? On the coalition side it's disappointment. You haven't been a worthy opposition. So all these people who are unhappy with their two current choices are then drifting to other places. Yeah. That's not just because of one nation or the Greens, that's because the two majors have done something to their c their I was I was gonna say consumer, to their their voter. No, I I'd agree with you on that. I guess that to what we were saying earlier. I d that's why I was saying I don't think that one third who's disinterested in politics is naturally up for grabs and One Nation's gobbled them up. It seems more that One Nation has gobbled from the coalition and from Labour voters, both of whom, like you rightly said, have are either disappointed or disenfranchised. And I mean, you know, the the rise in one nation happened after, you know, Albo And the mob properly cocked up the response to Bondi over all of January. That's when we started seeing that uptick happen quite a Like I would I I I think there's been a slower burn as well, which I'm interested to hear from you guys. So when you were both in the main game was five years ago. We didn't No. No. Which is indicative anyway. Well, you have to know that I mean I d I don't know about you, but my experience is I've had really positive working relationships with staffers and parliamentarians from across the aisle. Yeah. No, that wasn't the point. My point was gonna be so five years ago we were in lockdown, you were in the PMO, you were chief Of staff of one of the senior ministers. That that seemed to be the moment where, if we look at trusting government and functioning democracy, it was probably a high point. And what's happened since then that has gone centred in the opposite direction, do you think? Well, if you mean specifically, what did COVID do for people's appreciation of government? I'm reframing your question, that it was so big, it was so beyond them, it was so macro, they had no reference point. of research on this and we realized that Australians are quite what's the word for it? They've got their way of saying, no, no, that's not how you do it. You bring in a tradie and and you're the first person to say, are you sure you want to do it that well? he's an expert but now you've got an opinion they had to do it and the same with your mechanical whatever it might be. Australians have always got a view on how something could or should happen. How it ought to be done. How it ought to be done, exactly. But when it came to a once in a hundred year pandemic we found that people just said shh Just tell me what to do. I do not have a reference point. So government became relevant to their lives. And that's the key to it. And the other thing, Tom, was that the opposition made a decision not to play politics at that moment, which a actually ended up being really good politics. Not to be obstructionist. yeah. and to cooperate and to try to help clear the pathway and to think about how we were making those decisions in and convening parliament and yeah. Would you have done it different if If you were in opposition at the time, or would you have played opposition? No, I I don't think so. well No, definitely not. We'd have done exactly the same thing. no, you wouldn't. You realise very quickly that you aren't dealing with the Because there were some oppositions that played silly buggers and they really did approach. Amongst the states there was a different approach. It took a while. I mean it's one of the reasons why, and and everyone might have a view on this, probably couldn't do the same things a second time. Some of the restrictions, some of the behavioural changes required. It's gonna be hard to sell again, particularly in Victoria. Yeah, we talk about high levels of trust in governments through that period where there was that need and and people didn't necessarily have a a better answer and were looking for that kind of clear direction. But it feels like COVID also unleashed a license for people to question information, to and there's been a change in how people respond to institutions, governments, health officials, health advice, doctors, science. We also and I mean it not to shit on the work we all did 'cause it was a as we all know and you're on you'll remember, it was a very stressful time for all of us. But, with the benefit of hindsight, a lot of what happened during that period was government Stand so politicians are usually down the bottom of the rung of trusted professions alongside real estate agents, advertising executives. Journalists. Journalists are down there as well. they're at the bottom. Consistently the top two in Australia, and it has been consistently the top two for close to two decades now. Pharmacists always number one. So pharmacist is always the most trusted profession. Followed by yeah, followed by GPs, right? So doctors. So pharmacists doctors. And so government borrowed this incredible amount of good. Will during that period from doctors and pharmacists, which became our touch point during that two-year period, was what would the chemists do? No, no. But the thing was, don't forget, like the pharmacists were an integral part of it. That's where we all went for our jabs. If we didn't go to the mega like there was a whole mechanism behind it, but for two years. Most governments, state and federal, went, We're not making this decision. The doctors are telling us that this is the right decision. So a lot of the actual decision making when it came to the health measures were like was relegated to, but this is what the doctors said is the right thing to do. Which is why every Australian knows who Dr. Nick is. They saw Professor Murphy, they saw Brad Sutton down Victoria, the hot dog. Everyone has that in their mind and it's not because people suddenly went, Well you love governments you'll bring it. It's because they went governments have shut the hell up for a little bit and they're listening to the professionals. But I'm still interested in what what caused the cliff because it seems to me that it was almost like an outsized trust in government and now there's been an outsized distrust in government. Yeah, because you you gave people enough time to think through what they were actually doing and everyone went, wait a minute. I actually think there's sorry Tom, I was I was gonna say one thing is there were inconsistencies. A good rule needs to be applied consistently. And once the state started doing things differently, it meant you could look across the border and go, well they're not doing it there or they do it that way there. Yeah. And that's a real challenge for anyone trying to bring in an enforcement of something that's, you know, f for a good reason because people will have a reason to go, but it's not happening there. You know it in your own lives. If you see a cop, you know, not shutting down something, but your party was last weekend, you know, you go, Well, that's not right. Consistency is the key to a a reasonable enforcement regime. Yeah. And that's a problem. No, I to go back to what I was saying before, I think it did unleash a yeah. And and licensed the capacity to really question evidence and information and ad and government advice. And and I think the in with retrospect there's this long hangover of people questioning measures that they might have accepted at the time, but thinking about the negative impacts of it. And there is no kind of counterfactual what would things have been like if if they were managed differently and and people are left with the consequences of really long lockdowns and and the impact that had on their lives. Pretty hard to It was very brutal. And I the only thing I'd add to that is to to in terms of where did that cliff start happening. whether it's causational correlation, but you can definitely see that the point at which it started dropping off was A, when we started having the discussion as to whether or not it was respiratory or whether it was in water vapor, and the the doctors started disagreeing and then they started having all the arguments about which vaccine and this is a good vaccine, and and also the enforcement of vaccine mandates created on consistency once. Once you've lost that, everyone has a chance to take whatever argument they want out of it. Yeah. And we fragment and we find out. And this is where I argue that while I think it was good that Labour, you know, didn't play politics with it, I think they also releg they federally, they relegated what their role should have been, which was to provide very crucial opposition to how things were being implemented. There was a job to do there, and I think they were so scared of being seen and this could be completely wrong. Probably is, I assume. Based on your face. I've got a I've got a response coming. All right. Well y respond. I don't need to finish the question. let's go. I think there was an initial period where people were very much focused on cooperating. But don't forget the long kind of COVID committee hearings that were chaired by Katie Gallagher, which did a lot of work questioning the implementation of a lot of those measures and policies and the financial responses and economic responses. that's fair. I just think it could have gone further. A bit more. And on on your point about relinquishing government to the white coats, I think different governments d had different versions of that. I feel like we had Scott Morrison standing up for three hours a day at the height of the at the height of the Every word golden and every word golden. Polish every one of them didn't see us. Where whereas in South Australia I think there was a very different approach from Stephen Marshall and largely the face of the response was was the police and health health authorities. and But on both cases, I think there was a punishment for incumbents in the management of it, regardless of who fronted it. That was very different. And there was also a natural diffusion curve, right? So by the time we'd done the bulk of the all right, the worst of it is done. The first two, three, two, two and a bit waves have come come and gone worldwide. We were now on Delta, which while still deadly to a small portion of the population, was nowhere near as bad. We were still counting numbers. And what was actually happening out there in terms of the ground intel was people going, Well I know someone who had delta and he had a flu for a week and then he was fine, right? So those kinds of things started happening and people are retrospectively applying the measures that they've been through. With their lived experience, but disconnecting the fact that what I had as Delta is not what I was being protected from. But we didn't update the settings to match to go actually we can probably just let things rip at this point because we don't we don't necessarily have the same fatality rate that we were going to have with the first two waves. People were now challenging their trading. I don't know if I'd do it that way. And that was that's accelerated. Social media plays a huge role in a so-called awareness of different versions of truth, and that was happening, yeah, and there were a lot of Of people with a lot of newly acquired views on on medicine and that was all happening at a time when people were online more that's very bar in a in an environment where the that that attention economy was really maturing and the rise of influences rather than tradition like I think people went back to traditional news sources and those daily press conferences, but then it was also all those other influences that built all the time. And so we come The other end, A, the economy has suffered because of all the you know the debt that global governments went into to keep their societies together for good reason, and now for other reasons as well, including a mad war. But within that sort of pressure on quality of life, there is also this constant challenging of it it doesn't need to be like this. So again, so much harder to manage flows of information. Which is and then which undermines the sense of democracy. Well that's why it's a lot harder. Democracy is harder. It's harder to direct it probably is Yeah, absolutely. Building consensus, communicating directly with citizens. you used to be able to do user format I'd prefer if you call it users. Prime Ministers could do the rounds of the gallery in Canberra and speak to the major editors of the newspapers and that would be enough to convince a an editorial approach of a whole masthead. that doesn't happen anymore. You have to communicate with everyone on their devices and get them where they're actually what's right. No, the the media's partially to blame for that. The media is the one like the media the press gallery in Canberra is the one that's kept a lot of the new media outlets at bay. protect their patch for quite a few years now. So I think that's a their own a problem of their own making. W Ryan from Politico was telling us how difficult it was just to get an office for politico, a global publication. Yeah, and the Albanese government's been laughed at and ridiculed for having content creators and creative journalists attend the budget lockup. Example, and this is where people are getting their information their news. But isn't it getting confusing though? Because what standard is are we being held to? What are they being held to? And that's the real issue. Back to consistency. So whoever it is that challenges the existing status quo, I think that the the issue is: are you meeting a standard? What is a fact? What is truth? What is verifiable? What is a true source? That's the challenge. We're getting a lot of information that is complete bunkam. And and and that challenge also all the incentives are against those principles. So if you want to b make a noise, if you want to be seen, you're not embracing nuance. You are shouting and you are having a fight because I do not like you because you are from the other side. I didn't know it was that kind of show. It's not. I was that was true. It was very performative. But I agree with you completely. So I think this is a good segue into we want to talk about the the big tech companies and and kind of their role in democracy. How do you guys see the the role of I'm We're not just talking AI hyperscalers, though I know Peter wants to talk about always wants to talk about AI hyperscalers, especially after Jensen Wayne's been in the news. and for anyone at home, you know, NVIDIA shares are more affordable now than they have been in quite some time. So This is not financial advice. how do you guys see the role of Where should I get my crypto from now? Yeah, let me tell you. not only the role that the big tech companies as in the social media players have, but over the past twenty four hours we've seen Everything yeah, so much stuff happening in AI world that we can unpack, but also Microsoft's global outage has just starting to tie up now. What global outage? I didn't get an email. What is it? Seventy two countries I hate teams. Seventy two countries impacted by a global outage that Microsoft had. For a whole bunch of technical reasons to do with its servers. Pretty much every government department was affected, every major university, major hospital, the entire Victorian healthcare system. I don't think this will f have the same level of scrutiny from ALBO that OpenAI accidentally getting into a Medicare statistical database had. Yet this was a severely more impactful problem. Coming back to tech is now integrated into democracy, whether it's leading it or a tool or infrastructure for it. I don't think you can unscramble the egg that is technology and democracy, but I'm so keen to know what you guys think about. Well, we were talking about the notion of hyper democratization. I think tech's been a big part of it. I think young people almost tech has allowed a fraud to be perpetrated upon them when it comes to their version of control and power. So tech means that an entire citizenship can now be a taxi driver. We call it Uber. Right? When I leave here, I'm gonna try and get a you know, an Uber in two minutes. I have full controls. Device will create a transportation system. To take me somewhere. FinTech, I can do all sorts of strange financial transactions at 3 a.m. I'm in control of money transactions and all sorts of things. Tech makes me feel very powerful. Yeah. But it's a fraud because the real things that matter. Can I afford to buy a house when I'm 29? Can I get a well-paying job to live in an expensive city like Sydney, New York, wherever you happen to be? These things aren't happening. The true pillars of of making you feel powerful are not being. We've told them that the tech makes them feel good and they've bought it. And we have a job to do to show them that's not real democracy. Or or to borrow their tools, because to be fair, like Uber for example, since Travis and the team found it and kind of got it to where it is, one of their key tenants was People need to feel in control of an uncontrolled experience. I.e., in the old days when you used to either call on the telephone for a cab or wait on the side of the street, you had no idea how far it was, therefore you had no ability to decide whether you're gonna wait on the street corner, whether you're on the right corner, when it was gonna be, all that kind of thing. Uber gives you the perception of control and agency. And so people surrendered themselves to that experience voluntar voluntarily because they preferred that. Not blaming. No, But what I'm saying is but even democracy, there's no reason why we can't Borrow some of the trick. That's right. Well but U Uber was also interrupting a substand like a market where there was a substandard product. people chose to get an Uber because at the time it was cleaner, more efficient, friendlier than the taxis that they were catching. So and illegal. And entirely illegal. Breaking, yeah, totally illegal. Wild West. tech touches every part of our lives and we are completely reliant on it. So there is no unscrambling that egg, right? half half the countries had pretty low productivity today because they can't access their emails or their files. those of us on Zoom know better. but tech can also be like it's just a tool. Yeah. I think the biggest failure is that like governments have failed to regulate tech. you know, there's been social media has been the Wild West. They're a publisher of a scale that we have never seen before. we haven't allowed newspapers to run wild and just do whatever they want and to publish any statement without any responsibility for the impact that it has. But tech has just had no rules applied to it. But it's it's regulations. It didn't actually you weren't liable for what was running over it. And I think Ever since we've been playing catch-up because the actual building blocks of the technology was a lack of accountability. I think there's something fundamentally undemocratic in a world in which you've got large companies that are building an infrastructure and then people are sort of retrofitted into it. And I think it's a real challenge for government. I think where government has intervened, they've kind of come up with, particularly in Australia, like pretty crappy policy actually. I know that you and I first got to know each other trying to sort of get through the new. Media bargaining code, I think in retrospect, it kind of was meant to be part of a broader package and it the the other stuff never happened because the media's the most important. And the social media ban was terrible policy. All the experts were saying don't this lets the tech companies off like putting up it's never gonna work, but also it doesn't actually make them change their behavior. So I think we tend to, because we lose control, come up with the worst policy responses at the end of it. But Tom's point is that What the consistent rules that need to be applied? If you say you are an information platform, right, which is essentially what publishers are saying, we provide information to readers and viewers, then there are standards, and they're not meeting those standards. And that is a challenge for government. But we can't have it both ways. Either you want to be that and then be governed by certain standards, not even regulations, just standards, is what I'm saying. But then who determines the standards? And did your duty of care wouldn't you're on? I've s well, I think in principle it's the right thing, but in execution's always the key. So there's there's I suspect it's the beginning of how we help protect. It's not the end. Yeah. I I still go back because I I don't know, I I'm assuming that we yourselves and also McKinnon more broadly, not that you're here representing McKinnon, but like Is regulation the answer? Is that the answer to this? H has it ever been I we've we've just we're almost a year into the under sixteen's ban? Social media ban. The social media ban. by e Safety's own account, eighty percent of these kids are still online. Just just because something doesn't have a hundred percent impact doesn't mean it's not worth doing. But I think the point that Peter's made is I think well established that a lot of the experts said that it wasn't the best response. But it was bipartisan and it was w wildly popular. We all agreed that if one News Limited really wanted it. So bipartisan News Limited, it's probably wrong. It's gonna win. but I mean the r what is the role of government? it is to keep the citizens safe. and we have a national government that is responsible for ensuring Australians are in control of how their country is operates. and we have these foreign tech companies that have license to operate across borders with no rules. and the capacity for that tool to be used by others who want to undermine our trust in each other, our social cohesion, our democracy, I think we actually have a a duty and our governments have a duty to safeguard that and to protect our sovereignty. I love the way you've talked about almost Australianising it because i it we have a hyper global economy, but we also have an increasingly hyperlocal response to it. We see that with data centers, which is the ultimate clash between something really big, tectonic and its its its movement across the globe, but then we see it play out in suburbs and streets because then they see it in its physical form, a data center. It's quite interesting that a physical manifestation of something otherwise it's a great invitation for community democracy at the moment. It's gonna stop it's gonna create a huge speed hump on the rollout of the Well you saw in the US midterms, I think there's some forty one states that had put a proposition to further regulate data centres. we'll see people manipulate the issue. there's there's there's there are responsible ways to do this, but there are some people who will use it as a means to stir up more trouble in communities and that's a shame. And and it and it's and and there's kind of th there's there's the let it write which I just don't think can happen, like it can't be imposed. There's stop it all. Jess Scully, who we should get on next year, Damien. Well, how does that make us feel? We haven't even finished an area of No, no, no, yes. No, no, no. Better taste. Peter just needs to make sure that we have a gender balance on the couch, otherwise it's going to look like a liberal party room. But remember when we brought Audrey Tang out to Australia, she's using those techniques down on the Southern Highlands to get people to think through what the community contract around a data center should So there are there are other models. Yes. And I think particularly if people wanna see the rollout of this technology. It's gonna take more than just Senate committees and government pronouncements and regulations. It's gotta be a social license around it as well. Well it's it's it's more than that. It the macro story has not been told of why these things are good, why AI is good. No one's doing that job. The the resource sector No one's going to get people to appreciate what it does for the whole country. How you use resources before they could then go and And try and find local social license. No one's doing the AI bit. I was watching the For My Sins that Senate in the Joint Committee Inquiry into AI and they had the department of the industry up going. So what's the positive use case? They could not give up. Exactly. Because the bureaucrats they said we're gonna bring back a few Australians. I'm going, I'm not gonna give up my creative rights and everything to bring a few people. Anyway. I feel like we're jumped over and that's mainly because I've been ill disciplined, Dharmay. But I also wanted to hear from these guys about the practice of government in power, particularly the bits where you feel like democracy is working, like where you feel like the system does deliver outcomes. So we talked about the black swan event that was COVID. But are there what are the bits that people don't see where you go, This machine actually does work? The the bit that I think the bit that people say Is the conflict. I mean, that is what the media reports on. They are interested in political contests and conflict rather than where it is working well. It's a better story to say who's had a fight rather than the positive bill or committee outcome that's been done by consensus. But I think well, 90% of what the business that happens in Canberra is negotiated and there's compromise and people work through complex problems. I think democracy works well when people have relationships and they can pick up the phone and say, Hey, how are you thinking about managing this? this could be a real problem. What are we gonna do about it? And there have been staffers and shadow ministers and ministers who we like I've personally have had that kind of relationship with where you can say this is an important thing for the country, we're gonna have different views about it, but we should at least have a shared basis of facts like lit let's have a briefing, let's discuss what we think about it. And that stuff happens every day. And do you like have relationships across the aisle where you know the other person's not gonna do you over? Like, you know, there's Some. Some. You wouldn't granted. No, I I I don't But no, actually at a at a level where everyone let's call it a political professional level, you do find that people are just good at what they do and they respect each other and you get the job done. It's probably the ideologues, the ones who are there for, you know, slightly different reasons that can't see the trees for the woods or the woods for the tree would have the Sorry to say the greens. no, the ideologues. So easily I put the reference to the woods and the trees. But but yeah, I don't know. Mostly people there. But but Or people who enjoy the game and more than the outcomes. Exactly. And that's a bit sad. There's a few of those. There's a few of those. Or again, all the incense the reward incentives are for those behaviors, aren't they? Not necessarily. I think people want to win. It is it is a combat. It is a contest. You believe that your party has a better way of solving the same problem. So you need to be in government in order to bring about that solution. But it doesn't mean that it's just But that's not necessarily true because a lot of the best policies have been formed and shaped by oppositions and crossbenches. So you don't necessarily need to be in government to form the best outcome. You need to be able to influence the outcome to form the best outcome. That may well be true, but government makes it possible. Well it's one of the factors that make it possible. Yeah. Well I I your point on incentives though, I think Well, not to go take it back to social media, but I think everyone is desperate for engagement and attention. And the way at the moment of doing that is by being sensationalist, by trying to get people to react to something. Hijacking a committee. Hijacking committee. And committees who would often good committee processes are about delving into the complexities of an issue, hearing from members of communities. Boring. Yeah, boring, right? But boring, but good work. And now committees, I mean, if anyone watched the the committee hearings on Monday and Tuesday into the digital judiocre. I did it was it was people running lines. I mean there wasn't there wasn't any interrogation of issues. It was people justifying their position. But again the like we So, without pointing any fingers, we have a handful of senators who are happy to use the forum of an inquiry to grandstand. As we know, any Senate I remember Bromman Bishop doing that back in the day, I'm not saying hasn't been done at Mauseum. But any senator can walk into a Senate inquiry and ask a crush ask a question of an inquiry, right? Where are all the senators from both sides of politics asking the actual important hard questions? And why are they not holding the people who are appearing before these committees to account? It's basically turned into a game of everything on notice, everything gets shuffled away into a half-assed, you know, submission thirty days later, as long as we all forget about it because we no longer have the visuals for it. Yeah. we're getting into a particular kind of aspect of what are the what some of the challenges are and we can go to what I think there is a cultural there needs to be a cultural reset in some of our parliaments to say, okay, let's let's make this process work better. whether it's standing orders or had committee processes, this is boring. I think we'd have governing season and then a contest season where everyone's like in and it w you you got marked down. Susan Collins wrote about this in the Hunger Games, I'm pretty sure hey what so what's the McKinnon agenda to fix this mess democracy what we call because you know so can we do it can we do it over one drink or is it gonna take two? It's gonna take it's gonna take many drinks. we but we have a really broad agenda. Democracy Council was launched in March and I've I've spoken to all of you about this c this effort and this campaign. we've articulated at the the outset six reform themes around civics education and digital media literacy, public interest journalism investment, social media regulation, lobbying and electoral reform, and preserving an impartial public service. Those six themes will come they came from consultation that Jay Weatherall did when he was in my job before he went to London with close to a hundred organizations and academics and people in civil society about the kinds of reform ideas that they had, but then also a survey of about 4,000 Australians to see how they're thinking about the challenges our democracy is facing and the kinds of reforms that they want to see. But that's just like the starting point. We see this as a long-term campaign, both to build the political pressure and space to try and get governments and parliamentarians and our elected representatives to prioritize this, but also to develop the the implementable good actually. Yeah, actual stuff. And it matters. Yeah. Because an unhappy populace is not a good thing. But it's things are working in their favour. and the case doesn't necessarily need to be made that this is a problem. I mean every parliamentarian feels this every day. Yeah. They they know. Yeah. That's right. But but it's hard to camp like I've I've always there there's it I I come out of the peace movement. There used to be this saying There's a peace movement? There used to be it was called fighting for peace, it's like fucking for virginity. And I feel like campaigning for democracy is a bit like fucking for virginity. Like it is hard Hard because to actually get people engaged, you've got to use all the things that you're trying to fix. Like it's really difficult, isn't it? Because you're trying to change the You're heightening the problem in order to get to a solution. But the the the critical thing is is relevance. And the the the more you remind them of what is relevant when you're trying to fix it, the more they'll realise this is something I should invest in. And and I think people are already angry, like it goes to the 40% of people, 30% of people who don't really want to vote, but they're doing it because they might get a twenty dollar fine if they don't rock up to the the polling booth. People are already angry. and I think my hope is that we can jump over the anger bit and get to hope and action and have democracy counts as the vehicle that people can actually you know exercise their agency and be a part of the change. Yeah and I feel like part of it is that it's not democ I think a lot of people think democracy is the election and whereas Democracy is so much more than you know that one big day every three years? This is going to sound very wanky, but like democracy is like a practice. It's not it's not voting. And it's not just the being involved in decisions that that impact you. I think it's how you seek how you're curious about what your neighbour thinks and who the people at the pub are and what's making them go nuts and like understanding someone else's perspective and not just hating them as a result of the the fact that they've got a different point of view. Like it there has to be something more like deeper about that. We we've talked previously about the unicontext and this idea of like flattening pe I can't remember where that unicontext concept came from. It was a good one. Yeah. It was a good one. And then Rabbi Gersh talked to us about the idea of like seeing people as the obvious. boring, but what what are our starting points in any community or any quality, Well, we I don't know, i we're not fancy rabbis and stuff, but ultimately I hope that you got to a point where people need to disagree better. We will always disagree, but we need to do it in a better way. Yeah. And we we like to think we do it every week here at Friday at four PM so the poster boys for doing it, but we all need to be doing a better job of it because we won't all agree, but we just can't get to that point where we are extreme, violent, angry all the time with someone who doesn't share exactly the same point of view. And the other thing is that if you do take the time, like without sort of putting a halo on, like you actually get something out of it yourself because if you listen to someone else then you also feel listened to, you get a broader perspective, it might make you question. And you know, particularly after the the rabbi show, I've had a number of discussions with friends who are Jewish people who have have had a really tough time over the last you know year or two and it and and getting yourself in other people's shoes is really, really valuable. So you know the notion of a public discourse that starts with what do we agree on? Then we can interrogate the points of friction over a drink or over a coffee or something, then then you then you've got a chance of getting something. But conversely, sorry, sorry Tom, I'm then sitting But conversely it's it's really hard to make space for public civilised discourse when I'm suffering, I'm struggling, I can't afford my groceries, my mortgage payments are behind, I had to cancel the health insurance. So yeah, it's like all yeah, the the wankers in Canberra are having a great old time fighting with one another. These charities are telling me all this stuff they don't give a shit about. I'm just trying to make ends meet and you want me to have a civil discourse? Nah. Yeah. Yeah, I agree. I agree with that. And again, anger is important energy, if directed in the right way, but also if it's all consuming and all the time it stops anything getting done. So and I think a lot of people say what do they want from government? They just want to get things done, but the systems are actually stopping that getting done because it's all coming down to you know, but you you you could argue that most anger is the as an energy is designed to inspire. investigate some kind of change, any kind of change. And the angrier you get, the more, the more violent, the more unpredictable that change is going to be. So the angrier people get at the current circumstances. We're just going to get more and more unpredictable change. Acceptable. Yeah. As a whole, Australians aren't that that figure hasn't increased for Australia Australia as a whole. What has decreased The number of people who say they wouldn't support it. So there's more ambivalence about it. There is a kind of a sharp increase amongst young men who are willing to entertain extreme measures such as violence in support of a cause they care about. So it's also genuinely shocking, and this is not an invitation, but given what's happened around the world, it is genuinely shocking that Australians politically have not, and I don't say violence, but protest at the very least, have not. gone further down that route to date, given that, Australians are suffering to the same level that we're seeing in a lot of Europe, that we're seeing in a lot of Latin America. I feel like we've still got basic services. yes, we're we're in a cost of living, whatever cost of living means, but we are still I I d I d I don't see things falling apart the way they are in other parts of the world where people Yeah, but to people who are living through those services, those services are relative, right? So it'll be they'll be relating it to their past experience of those services, not a like for likeness between what's happening here in Buenos Aires. So for them, the s the perception is that those services are falling apart when their public hospital wait time has increased from two months to nine months. that is that is the wheels falling off. But that's never been our thing. Australians don't expect I think that's what it is. I think it's It's more a cultural thing of we just don't we don't protest, we don't demonstrate France has a particular history of getting out on the streets. But it's happening all around the world at the moment. There are protests in the stuff, and and they're not like as you were saying last week with Corey Dame, it's not anti-immigration protests, it is anti anti-government not delivering basic services and government corruption. So that's the other bit that's really important as well, you know. And I know you guys have been doing stuff on the role of lobbyists, the role of money and politics, you know, one of the big wins in America was the the Michigan guy whose big big call was money in your pocket, money out of politics, public health. And with now set up a super PAC and spent two and a half times more than his opponent in getting elected. But apart from that hypocrisy, it's fine. I think Australians look at decisions being made and they wonder how things have ended up the way they have and the only rational way of explaining it when there there isn't a proper explanation is that there's some vested interest that's driven some perverted outcome. And so there is like this perception that it is vested interest and the interest of elected reps that is driving decisions and that lobbying's a real problem and that corruption's an issue both at the state and federal level. I think if you're in a country like Australia where the average household is worth, a million and a bit, right? You on paper feel like you should feel wealthy. It's like I know my house is worth a million bucks. I know I've got a decent income. But I don't live like but I feel poor. Why? And that that incongruity between those things is a really hard thing I think for most people to largely 'cause people are paying a mortgage on a million dollar house. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. household debt has increased massively and debt. And we're we're one of the top ten in the world now for household debt, right? Yeah, exactly. And it's because borrowing from our future because our housing system is to fundamentally broken. As long as there's future ahead of us, we'll be fine. Have we got a kiss of death for the week, Peter? Shall we move on? Yeah, so as I said at the start, I've been pretty obsessed about the implosion of the Australian cricket team. and what's going on, I was thinking about You're not gonna ask me a cricket question. No, I'm not. I'm just gonna make the socket. Basically, the the second most important leadership role in Australia traditionally was Australian cricket captain. Pat Cummins had to do a press conference today dealing with events from a decade ago. And I also last night was the new documentary on Elizabeth Holmes you can see anything and the nation the nature of memory and perspective is just shiftable and I think you're gonna see this played out in our national sports team over the next few months. So my actual prediction though is that this will be the first documentary to win an Oscar. Like it's well worth seeing. I'm very excited to see it myself apart from that the best documentary on the first one to win Your Honor, have you got a kiss to death for the week coming? I think it's the opposite. I think it's a smooch of pain. I don't think there's anything big. I think nothing important will happen next week. I think that we will pass the week and go, that was it, nothing special. Senate sitting. Exactly. There you go. Thank you for finishing my gag. Senate is where the business happens, apparently. No, nothing of great importance will happen next week. Much more than forgettable. week. Absolutely. That's why Google won't go down. Ooh, we're on a roll now with the team. If Google's goes down, we're all screwed. What about you, Tom? Kiss of death? Sorry, I really don't know what the kiss of death So it's just a prediction for the week coming that you either do want to come true or secretly secretly don't want to come true. I didn't think about this. Okay. You can hold While you're thinking about it, so mine's going to be in the world of tech and AI again. Obviously it's a been a big week. Anthropic released their their Mythos Fable five point two model, which has just been blowing every single benchmark crazy out of the water. We are close to recursive self-improving AI. We're on the cusp of it. Anthropic is now also oversubscribed on their IPO, which means that there are more people wanting to put money in. They thought they were gonna get a 1.2 trillion valuation, which I think they will at float, but I think it's gonna jump up. I have a feeling Anthropic's gonna be our first ten trillion dollar company to ever be seen on the face of this planet. Simultaneously, Jensen Wang's b resigned from NVIDIA. Wang. That's it's how it's pronounced in Chinese. Wang. And so I think I actually think what's happened to Jensen, while I don't in any way approve of his actions, I do think it's a bit of a hit job. Specifically, I think that because he's been such a big proponent of open weight models, I think this has been a bit of a insider job between the US administration and the frontier models. And anthropic to maximum just be their brains, Wang. I think they're trying to move Wang on. I have a feeling Elon's gonna definitely pick Wang up. So I think you're gonna see Wang over at at Grok, Space XSI, which is the new name, I think now. And he'll come up with the gaming platform. Well, I don't know what he's gonna do, but I think the next week in AI is gonna be particularly interesting, but more importantly, quite pivotal. So that's my kiss of death for the week ahead. My case of death is that pub trivia is gonna be revolutionized. with the pub test. Democracy Council's got its first takeover of Pub Trivia on Monday Night of the Bat and Bowl. And that's gonna be we're gonna be taking around the country over the next couple of months. And do for any of our listeners, do we have any clues as to the topics or the the categories? No no no, that would be cheating. Yeah, no, it'll be it'll be doing it look probably about the Australian. It's the pub test, it's a way of getting people talking about democracy in an environment that they're familiar with, over beers with their friends and mates, so it should be a good time. So this should be out by Monday. If you're listening to it in Sydney, button ball, can people just come up or is it it is unfortunately booked out, but it'll be coming to oversubscribed. What is clearly not booked out yet is the what's your poison life event at the National Press Club, which I know your on's coming down to. Number twenty five, some very special guests lined up. We're also going to be doing awards now. We've just locked them in. So political players. Very fun and exciting. Political hit job of the year. Stop it. I'm sorry. And whatever. free drinks. We've we've still got about I think about fifty tickets left out of the cohort, so that'll be really, really good. Get to join some fun people and interesting people. So come along. I'll see you there. Done. Fantastic. All right. If you haven't like, share, subscribe, and obviously send it to anyone you think might find interesting. But thank you for joining us for another week. We will see you next week for our penultimate episode before we do our final episode of the year on the twenty-fifth of November live from the National Press Club in Canberra. Thank you again for joining us. And I hereby decree democracy solved. Thank you all for
