Episode 5
By-elections, Big-Media, and Budget
Show notes
We talk about Farrer by-election , First Nations tragedies and political failures, the impact of AI on media, challenges in journalism and media revenue, and predictions for the upcoming budget and its economic impact.
Chapters
- 00:00 Introduction and Drink Choices
- 23:05 First Nations Tragedies and Political Failures
- 31:37 The Impact of AI on Media
- 55:05 Budget Predictions and Economic Impact
Full transcript
Read itHide it
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.
Peter LewisWelcome to Your Poison? The show where people that disagree on everything agree it's best to do so over a drink. My name is Peter Lewis. the director of the progressive agency, Essential. Joining me is my evil twin, who is the principal of General Strategic and former Morrison advisor, Dame Damjanoski. Hey, Dame, ⁓ how's your week and what's your poison?
Damian DamjanovskiSo, thank It's been an excellent week, Peter. I am very happy to say my poison this week is colloquially known as the lemon weapon that I still refer to as a hard solo, but political correctness makes me call a hard rated now as though that will somehow fool the children. What about yourself? What are you drinking this week?
Peter LewisWell, I've been told I've got to cut down the number of drinks I'm having. So instead, I've got a very large Sapporo black beer, but I am also pouring it into, I don't know if the camera can see it, a pewter that was handed down from my late father. That's my favorite thing. Traditionally, beer was meant to taste better in a pewter. I think there's been health studies saying there's high lead content. It's probably not so good for your health, but I still choose to toast Kev through the pewter. So bottoms up.
Damian DamjanovskiWell, he's a toaster kev. I will say that Pewter is significantly underrated having been to Malaysia and explored all the Selangor of stores. I'm a huge fan of Pewter, ⁓ but it's not a thing anymore. I think it's one of those crafts that has gone by the wayside.
Peter LewisYeah.
Lenore Taylorto give
Peter LewisI drank it out for a... I've got a friend that does Oktoberfest ⁓ every year in his backyard, he's a home brewer, Jason, and I always bring it and I feel like Graham Kennedy in the party where he turns up to that election night party with the pewter on a chain around his neck and it all gets worse from there and that kind of sums up Jason Hardy's Oktoberfest as well.
Damian Damjanovskiamazing. And now Peter, we have an amazing guest this week who you know quite well, and I've never met face to face, but I've long admired. So give us a bit of an introduction into Lenore and then Lenore can obviously give us bit of an introduction to herself.
Peter LewisI remember noticing Lenore's work years and years ago at an ALP national conference down in Hobart. She probably doesn't even remember it, but she was a perky, Fin review, probably political correspondent, and she was on top of it and all the craggy old guys were running around and Lenore ruled the roost. got to know Lenore better when she became the first Australian editor of Guardian Australia about a decade ago. ⁓ ⁓ we have worked together with the Guardian essential report and my columns and ⁓
Lenore Tayloryou
Peter LewisIt's been great sort of catching in and out with her and now that journey's over. So it's great to have Lenore here to reflect on her time at The Guardian, but also drink some drinks with us on a Friday. But what's your poison, Lenore, before I ask you about how you're feeling?
Damian DamjanovskiOkay.
Lenore Taylorjust going to say that's a very kind introduction Peter and also I think I've got like half a cupboard full of pewter and I know where to bring it now that's excellent. My poison is a four pillars Shiraz gin the alcoholic kind as it is Friday. I have the bandwagon kind for other days but and as you can see from the lipstick mark I've already had a sip.
Damian DamjanovskiThat is a, it's a fantastic gene.
Peter LewisAnd do you mix it or do you go straight?
Lenore TaylorNo, no, it's got tonic.
Peter LewisWell, tonic, we were drinking it straight the other day, but it's quite good. Yeah.
Damian Damjanovskifever tea, I hope. Now, Lenore, congratulations on your amazing run at The Guardian. ⁓ I'm so curious as a ⁓ coalition staffer long gone. That's right. No, I'm curious about the start of The Guardian Australia, because obviously the rumour mill and as it was published in the memoirs, The Guardian Australia was a brain fart of
Lenore TaylorYes. Thank you. I'm taking a drink before this question. Hang on, keep going.
Peter LewisYeah.
Lenore TaylorMm-hmm.
Damian DamjanovskiNumber 29 PM Malcolm Turnbull who on a weekend decided that he wanted a guardian in Australia. So as Mr. Turnbull does makes a couple of phone calls here, there, wherever else. And suddenly things move into motion and here we are with a guardian. What's the inside story or at least what you're allowed to tell us of it.
Lenore TaylorI think I can tell you all of it that I know and I mean I wouldn't, I think brain fart's a little bit unkind. I think Malcolm had been, was communications spokesperson or minister. It was in 2012. He thought that there should be better media diversity in Australia. He had a conversation with Ellen Rusbridge who was then the global editor in chief of The Guardian and said, why don't you set up in Australia? And Rusbridge said, well, we don't have, you know, that's not gonna be financial. And he said, what if I could find a philanthropic partner to start you? And then he put Graham Wood, the philanthropist, in touch with Alan Rusbridger. And then really Malcolm departed the scene at that point. mean, sometimes his telling leaves him around a bit longer. He really just facilitated that introduction. They then did a deal. Graham gave us the startup loan for The Guardian. And this all took sort of more than a year. ⁓
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Lenore TaylorAnd that was where it started. you know, the start at the start, was truly insane. We were tiny. ⁓ It was a risk. I always tell the story how Greg Highwood told me that I was being an idiot for leaving the Sydney Money Herald and that ⁓ nothing would no masthead would ever succeed in Australia other than News Corp and Nine Fairfax as it then was. ⁓ And at the time, I've got to say, you know, there was a good chance he might have been right. Like there was no
Damian DamjanovskiAlright. They're faxing.
Lenore Taylorguarantee, but I'm happy to say now it's the fourth biggest site in Australia with nearly nine million unique readers a month and that's really great from my point of view.
Damian DamjanovskiWhich is, which is amazing. And sorry, just for those who don't know, so Graham would, was the, was it what if? Yeah. What happened to what if? Is that still around?
Peter LewisGood.
Lenore TaylorWhat he's got.
Peter LewisBut what if they?
Lenore TaylorHe sold it ages ago. I don't think it is. I don't think it is.
Peter LewisI still use it. Well, there's still a website.
Damian Damjanovski⁓ I figured you'd still go down to a travel agent, Peter. I figured you went down for one of those plastic envelopes where they give you the printed tickets.
Peter LewisI prefer when I really care, do. Lenore, 10 years is a journey and I've been privileged to be on it for a fair bit. But a few things people don't know about The Guardian. It's run as a trust and its only objective is the promotion of journalism. It's also got this extremely novel business model where you give something away for free, but then you ask people to pay for it. So it's very counterintuitive.
Lenore TaylorYep.
Peter LewisWhat's your reflections on the role that sort of dug into the Australian media at a time, you know, when you were coming in, News Limited was putting up the paywalls. ⁓ Fairfax was trying to work out what was it was going to be. The ABC was totally under assault. And then you sort of come into the middle of it. And, you know, if Malcolm Turnbull was a, you know, a media mogul, he was a pretty bad one because it was not his mouthpiece in any shape or form. But what's the reflections on where
Lenore TaylorNo, no.
Peter LewisThe journey has been on over that decade and where you see it sitting now.
Lenore TaylorI think we launched at a pretty fortuitous time. It was when ⁓ Fairfax had been a sort of progressive center leftish kind of publication. I think they were moving more towards the center. ⁓ And News Corp's clearly, sorry, exactly. And so there was sort of, mean, the Guardian used to hate me saying this, but there was a sort of Guardian shaped hole in the market for us to go into. That said, that was the decade where we got...
Peter LewisAnd then Costello became chairman and like the whole thing. Yeah. ⁓ Hmm.
Lenore Taylorabsolutely smashed by the digital platform. So it wasn't an easy run by any means. actually, very soon after I became editor, your friend and mine, Stinton and I launched the the reader revenue program here. that, you know, asking people to give us money for something they could get for free. And again, you know, I remember the Australian was writing all these articles about the, they used to call us the left leaning loss making guardian Australia, London based guardian Australia.
Peter LewisSomething for free. ⁓
Damian DamjanovskiSo, thank you.
Lenore Taylorthat is now putting out the begging bowl. Well, we don't make a loss anymore. We probably are left leaning and the begging bowl wasn't a begging bowl. It was actually a really great way to create a proper relationship with your readers, a relationship of trust and communicate with them and say that you appreciated what they did. And against all predictions, it worked and it's now, I think, sort of 60 % of the revenue.
Damian Damjanovski.
Peter LewisBut also it means you're not checked. But it also means you're not chasing clicks. Like if your primary thing is not to get the next eyeball. I know you've got an advertising stream as well, but.
Lenore TaylorWell, I mean, it's still 40, 45 % advertising, so we still want traffic. But I mean, as the whole kind of AI summaries goes on, I think that trust relationship of people coming back to you because they trust you, because they really want your journalism as opposed to everything else that's flooding into their feed. ⁓
Peter LewisI'll say you still do click that.
Damian DamjanovskiHmm
Lenore Taylorthat reach for reaches sake is less important and a proper loyal relationship, a really engaged relationship with readers becomes more and more important.
Damian DamjanovskiBut to some degree you could argue that's also just, you reinforce my worldview, therefore I'll give you money, right? Not necessarily an individual article, but your overall vibe reinforces my overall vibe and that's why I'll financially support you.
Lenore TaylorOr maybe you could say, like your fact-driven, trustworthy journalism and that's why I support you.
Peter LewisThat's definitely the Australian Swiss Miss Model.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, yeah. mean, yeah, you could dress it up any which way you want, but that's not a criticism by any stretch. think they all do it.
Lenore TaylorNo, no, I know, yeah.
Peter LewisHow was The Guardian regarded by the Prime Minister's office when you were working there? Like I'm assuming it wasn't, ⁓ my God, The Guardian's got a headline today. was it, like how was it regarded?
Damian Damjanovskibe honest, Peter, from like I wasn't in the media team, but from what I saw of it, I don't think it really played into the consideration of the Morrison government in any real way, shape or form. again, I don't mean that as neither a criticism nor ⁓ an accusation towards the media team at the Morrison government. Like I just genuinely don't think it played a particular part in it. I.e. doesn't matter what we do, the Guardian's going to shit on us. So why bother? ⁓ I think that that came to a head. And again, there's no accusations. observation is I think when Scott did his, don't hold, well, no, no, his, don't hold a hoes mate moment, which was not one of his finer moments for sure. I think the team pointed out at some point that the Guardian simultaneously had lambasted Tony Abbott for getting in on the fires rather than doing the prime ministerial job. And then lambasted Scott Morrison for not getting in on the fires.
Peter LewisWent to Hawaii. I don't think Tony Abbott was PM under the Guardian, was he? Maybe.
Lenore TaylorNo, no, think, don't you mean as a firefighter?
Damian DamjanovskiAs the firefighter, as the volunteer, yeah.
Peter LewisMmm.
Lenore TaylorYeah, I don't remember that, but I'll take your word for it.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. So it's one of those things where like the same situation that happened, but when it was Tony, they were like, you shouldn't be down on the front lines. You should be doing the prime ministerial job. And then when Scott did it, it was like, no, you shouldn't be doing the prime ministerial shop. You should be getting in there. And it was one of those moments that reinforced the, think, conservative view of doesn't matter what we do. The guardian's never going to be on our side. And I think it just didn't factor into equations.
Peter LewisJules just wants it to know it was criticizing Tony for having a hero complex. ⁓ So there you go. Thank you, Jules. ⁓ In the booth. ⁓ So one more thing that I wanted to go to, which now my mind is escaping because that word there. ⁓ Did Malcolm keep an active interest in the Guardian through that period, particularly when he was PM? did you have relationships on that?
Damian DamjanovskiThere you go.
Lenore TaylorI I spoke to him as a when, so I finished in the press gallery in 2016, so that last election. And I spoke to him as a journalist and periodically as an editor, but not in, he had no say, he had no sway. You know, I would talk to him as I talked to other people. I mean, we invited him to our 10th birthday celebrations as a, you know, like,
Peter LewisHmm.
Damian DamjanovskiTalk to him as I talk to any other Vaucluse resident.
Peter LewisHe Yeah.
Lenore Tayloryou know, on big occasions we invited him along, that's what she meant.
Peter LewisYeah. Before we move on, just one other. I remember what my thought was. don't. Everyone thinks it's a mirror image. The Australian on the right cheerleader for the government, Guardian on the left cheerleader for the left. And what has always frustrated me as a spin doctor as opposed to like a pollster is the Guardian doesn't play it like that. They actually are just as hard on sort of the left as they are on the right. Notwithstanding, I don't think it's a net. I don't know what you think, Lenore, having worked in News Limited as well.
Lenore TaylorYeah, no, I would absolutely agree with that and I used to really rail at any comparison like that in that, sure, we come at things from a centre-left position and the AUS comes at things from a right position, but we didn't run campaigns like the AUS did and I think we were more, probably a bit more even-handed than the AUS in my opinion.
Peter Lewisyou
Damian DamjanovskiHmm. It's a good opinion. And before we move on to the news of the week, Peter, I want to thank you for that Freudian slip where you accidentally alluded to the fact that the Australian supports the government and that the centre right is the natural party of government, which it is, but that's fine. It's neither here nor there. ⁓ Can we, if you don't mind, I'd love to move on to the news of the week. Most importantly, this incredible batshit crazy upcoming Farah by-election where basically
Peter LewisFair done, I know. Well, it's been my life experience anyway, yeah. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiLet's be honest, the two major parties are not playing a role in it. have Michelle Miltthorpe, who by all standards looks like an outstanding candidate for the region. If you're in the city component of the region, arguable how it is on some of the other, some of the other parts of Farah. And then Daley, the one nation candidate who ran for labor at some point, who wanted to run for labor, seems to be slipping up left, right and center. His supporters getting into fights with Senator, like this is.
Lenore TaylorMm-hmm.
Peter LewisMmm. head on to the branch man.
Damian Damjanovskigoing to be an amazing weekend, I'm hoping.
Peter LewisI thought that was the main of the election, like two parties that have swapped preferences getting into fisticuffs outside of polling booth. That is so good.
Lenore TaylorI'm But if you get right down to it, the thing that I find really interesting is that the two, like David Farley and Michelle Milthorpe, look to me, both of them, like quite reasonable local candidates, and they kind of are interested in the same things. Like they both oppose water buybacks, they're both worried about water security, they both want more funding for the Albury Hospital, but then the national kind of political overlay comes on top of it and...
Damian Damjanovskiwhat is going on with our democracy.
Peter LewisMmm.
Lenore Taylorone side, you know, labels Michelle Milthorpe as a teal because she took some money from Climate 200. And I just listened to the podcast interview with her just then. She sounds like a pretty average, you know, rural regional candidate who knows her area. And then David Farley gets slammed because he was supportive of Michelle Milthorpe last time and toyed with the Labor Party at some point. So there's kind of this national political fight being played out through these two proxies, who if you left them alone, either of which might be quite decent local candidates.
Damian DamjanovskiHmm. And now Peter, you're a pollster. Have you got any predictions for it before we move any further?
Peter LewisMm. So I can't, we don't poll seat by seat because rovo polling is shit and everything else is really expensive. But I'll give you something that has given me pause for thought. And let's mark this. It could just be pub talk. Ben Rao, who runs the tally room. I was sort of talking to him the other week because I was sort of doing a quick cheat before I did an interview on this. And I said, it's obviously one of the first ever elections where it's a two horse race between an independent and a one nation candidate. And he said, just watch this. While it looks like the Libs are coming third, it's basically two elections. It's the Alderby election, which just to mark that home of the birthplace of the Liberal Party, where it is a Liberal-Till contest. And then in the regions, it's a One Nation Liberal contest. And he was just saying, watch it. In that scenario, the idea that even though the Libs are polling the third in primary vote,
Damian DamjanovskiYIP.
Lenore TaylorMm.
Peter Lewisthat the idea that they will be the first ones out don't bank on that. And if that's the case, it's still a three horse race. So I hate to offer you false hope, but I think there's something interesting going on there.
Damian DamjanovskiNo, no, I'm so glad you said that because I think it's really easy to flatten this into a one nation versus Teal, as you pointed out Lenore, Teal, maybe tealish, teal tinged kind of candidate. But in actual fact, there's so many layers of things happening here. Number one, it's the first election, the first test of Angus's leadership in a real sense, right? This is a seat that has been a liberal seat for quite a long, I think 25 years or whatever.
Lenore TaylorInteresting.
Damian DamjanovskiAt this point, like, so losing that is, still a loss, right? Under Angus's watch. Canavan, the Nats are actually campaigning pretty hard for their candidate. And even though they're not getting a lot of traction, the Nats still see Farah as a natural seat for the nationals party. And it should be a nationals party seat. Like was Tim Fisher's seat, right? So there's a, exactly right. So it's a bit of a test of Canavan's leadership. If you accept then that Milthorpe.
Peter Lewiswas Tim Fischer's seat. It was the seat of the deputy prime minister 30 years ago. Mm.
Damian DamjanovskiIs it feels candidate by extension of the fact that she accepted some climate 200 money, depending on how you define it, a Teals candidate. It's, it's a good test for deep regional, um, ability for the Teals to break through, not necessarily the first one, like we had one and we'd count with a few other ones, but it is still a test of them. And it's kind of the first federal seat test of one nation since they've come to this new found surge. So there's four. semi-tests all happening concurrently and I'm not sure the results are going to give us a clear answer on all four of them but someone's got to win!
Peter LewisCan I just?
Lenore Tayloryou think wouldn't you think Michelle Malthoaps a lot more like a voices of candidate like Cathy McGowan then Helen Haynes like those sorts of people?
Peter LewisExactly. So this is a point I was going to make. And also, I actually did my cadetship on the Board of Morning Mail back in the back in the day where it was very much the paper for Aldbury and Wodonga. And it was very much seen as the same region. Amazing paper. You have eight photographers used to go out of the road and just do it's a different story. But if you look at the Wodonga side of it is actually now Cathy McGowan, Helen Haynes territory and that.
Lenore Taylorwe have an expert in the ranks.
Peter LewisIt's much more that area, the Murray area is a thing rather than New South Wales, Victoria. And I think what's happened there, and I actually think this is why the Libs have chosen to preference One Nation because in terms of if they lose that to a Helen Haynes style candidate, they're never getting it back like it's off the map. Whereas One Nation will implode and they'll probably be a one term seat. So that would be their calculation, I think, in
Damian DamjanovskiEver.
Lenore TaylorSure, but aren't they white? Sorry.
Damian DamjanovskiHmm.
Lenore TaylorI think it is, but I'm interested in your view, Damien, about the decision there, because aren't they weighing up two bad options? Like preference, Michelle Milthop and their base might get mad and she might dig in and become a sort of long-term candidate. But on the other hand, preferencing one nation means that if they win and get all that momentum and validation, which really eats into the coalition's credibility nationally, they've facilitated it. Like I find it a...
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. I think it ultimately, I think becomes a political calculus of can one nation gain enough momentum to be a significant block on a federal level, or will it also be a slightly smaller than the nationals party ⁓ party on the right? And if it is that latter one, then they're going to support the coalition, not the Labour party ultimately. Right. So better them than an independent where they could swing either way.
Lenore TaylorI don't get the decision myself, but.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd I think that the real thing here is the winner of these tests, no matter what is Albo because he very cleverly decided, you know what, we're not running a candidate. We'll let the right eat itself, have fun. We will all watch from a distance and enjoy it. And you got to, you got a hat tip him for what was him and Paul Erickson for what was a strategically genius decision to just step the fuck out of it and go, this is between y'all.
Lenore Taylorcan duke it out.
Peter LewisWhy would you go into a five horse race? Like that's the other bit that the Libs and the Nats both competing. But I just don't preferences, Lenore. I wonder if Ben Rao is right, then the Libs calculation is who is going to come third rather than and so if, so the scenario, I very rarely say this sentence. So if you're playing to win, you are saying who's going to come third.
Lenore TaylorMm. And they think they could still hop over.
Damian DamjanovskiBut have to play as if you're going to win, right? There's no point in playing unless you're playing to win. There's no other purpose.
Peter LewisOne nation is going to come third. Therefore, I get their preferences. Therefore, that's my best chance of holding the seat. If that happens, they are geniuses and I very rarely put those words in the same sentence since probably 25
Damian DamjanovskiBut that's the, but Tito, know, that's the only way you can run it. But, but, but that's the only, but like you do not run a candidate and put a lot of your donor money into a campaign unless you genuinely believe there's a pathway to either win or to stop your opposition. Right. And if the only pathway to win is. Who? Rutkowski? ⁓ sorry. But Kowski I've mixed up racer, but Kowski. I just, ⁓ portmanteau her first and last name. Apology.
Peter LewisWho is the liberal candidate? I wouldn't even know. Trivial pursuit, who's, ⁓ is that the name? Bud Kaspi. Not, not Carl Botovich. Class. He could run a bot. He could run a bot. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiOne of my Slavic peoples and then, ⁓ Robertson for the nuts. So look either way for those of, for the people out there who are sad and pathetic enough like myself to be watching it on a Saturday night, I think it's, ⁓ it's going to be a fun, ⁓ bit of viewing.
Peter LewisYeah. If there is a Venn diagram of sad and pathetic people watching our podcast and watching on Saturday night, I reckon they're right here. So tip. So what's your tip? Damaie and then Lenore.
Damian Damjanovski⁓ I actually think Milford is going to come out on top. I don't think it'll be a huge margin, but I do think that she'll get a run at the last minute, ⁓ of support because.
Lenore Taylorbecause of the revelations about Farley or just because she's campaigning well.
Damian DamjanovskiI think it's a combination of the revelations. And I think there's just actually a lot of quiet supporters in the community who've been supporting Millthorpe through quite a few cycles now, who just didn't want to get into the, ⁓ the muck of what the, the loud conversation in the media who are just quietly supporting Millthorpe.
Lenore TaylorMm. Interesting. I thought, I think One Nation might do it.
Damian DamjanovskiWe'll find out in just over 24 hours, interestingly. ⁓ Peter, what else have you got from your reflections from the week?
Peter LewisWell, I guess my tip, ⁓ I'm not going to tip the Libs. Like, I just can't. I think it will be Millthorne. But I am interested. if the Libs win, Ben Rao is a bigger genius than I already think he is. ⁓ And we'll have to get him on to post.
Lenore TaylorInteresting. Well, for your Saturday night viewing pleasure, Damien, I was talking to Casey Briggs the other night because I did the party, the ABC's party room podcast. had a sort of live event for their 10th birthday. And he was saying he's got Anthony Green Jr. He's got every booth plotted. Like they've got a full almost like federal election do up for the by-election.
Peter Lewisyou
Damian DamjanovskiIs that sorry that's Anthony Anthony Green jr. Yeah
Peter LewisYes.
Damian DamjanovskiHa ha! That's how you know we're giving the ABC too much money.
Lenore TaylorYou if
Damian DamjanovskiPeter, tell me about some of the interesting stuff you noticed from the week. I know there's been a few sad stories as well.
Peter Lewis⁓ I just, it's the second week in a row where there's a First Nations tragedy. This was the death of a newborn baby in a series of huts on the Murrumbidgee River in Wagga Wagga, so just out of Farrah. ⁓ The week after the tragic and then ⁓ murder of the little girl up in Alice Springs and the riots there. And it has got me thinking, about ⁓ where we've gone over the last three years and the failure of the voice referent. I'm not saying having a voice would have stopped these deaths happening, but it's got me reflecting how we've gone backwards ⁓ on our relationship with our First Peoples. ⁓ I was, as you know, heavily involved in the campaign and I kind of got blindsided when it all fell over in the day. But it was actually about stuff like this. And the failure of the campaign was that people didn't see it being about stuff like this. And it's just on one level just incredibly sad news. I think also the political establishment just shrugs their shoulder. The other bit that's been happening, particularly in New South Wales, with, as we discussed last week, my least favorite Labor government ever, has been the, ⁓ you know, jailing of young kids in Moree, now the drone surveillance of the activities up there. And again, no Indigenous involvement in the solutions, which was to my mind what the idea of The Voice was about. I guess my reflection is that there are consequences when people get the politics wrong. I know a lot of First Nations people who really have felt
Damian DamjanovskiDamn.
Peter Lewisdisengaged and deflated. And there are a lot of reasons why that went wrong, including the fact that Alba politicized it on election night by making his first promise. It was also because the Libs were on board and then they weren't on board. But the consequences are significant. And I don't know, Lenore, you guys at The Guardian did a lot of fantastic reporting on these sorts of issues, but it feels like we've gone backwards.
Damian DamjanovskiThank
Lenore TaylorWell, I thought there was always a kind of false binary between the voice and tangible outcomes. Like the no case always tried to say that one of the reasons the voice was pointless or you should vote no was because it wouldn't lead to tangible outcomes. And the point was obviously the voice would give First Nations people a better say in policies about them, but it was never gonna solve everything overnight. guess I get, don't know, both of the stories you mentioned are. terrible tragedies and make you incredibly sad. But I would really like to hope that this outpouring of sadness and grief actually leads to something changing. And it's interesting the stories that capture that national imagination. You have young Indigenous kids incarcerated at record levels, you know, in terrible circumstances. You have all kinds of tragic circumstances, but there's sometimes these stories that just kind of capture the imagination. And if that's the impetus it takes to get something to change, then I suppose that is a small positive in a horrible story.
Peter LewisWhat's your observations of where the Liberals stand on First Nations stuff now, you probably want to call it Aboriginal anyway, Damo, but, know, and where the party ended up after sort of being in for the yes vote and then going to the no. Do you see any line to where they are now?
Damian DamjanovskiWell, look, I think painting them all as one big cohort who agrees on Indigenous questions is probably a bridge too far. There's clearly a divide within the party, the coalition side of stuff between those who were supporters of the voice and those who were uncertain or no votes on the voice. ⁓ obviously we had some front benches stand down as a result of that. had people who wanted to do a conscious vote, all that kind of thing. I don't think it's fair to try and, ⁓ to try and categorize everyone on the center, right. As having a constant view or a consistent view on all things, indigenous affairs and all things, the voice. I will say, I don't know enough about. this field to be able to talk to it with any authority. think the Alice Springs incident was…
Peter LewisWhy do you need to know anything? Isn't that the Australian way just to talk fields?
Damian DamjanovskiWell, yeah, but this is one of those things where I go, there is, there is a degree of white guilt here where I go, I don't know where that line stops and the genuine concern begins. Like, ⁓ and again, this is going to sound bizarrely out of school, but you know, the, know for years that we've been as far as I remember, since I came to Australia is the, the, the idea of giving indigenous people agency over where they live, how they live their way of life. ⁓ and. As far as I understand it, the Alice Springs ⁓ tragedy was of the community, by the community, in the community without a whole bunch of external intervention. And then all of a sudden, when something bad happens, a lot of white people in Canberra go, why didn't we know? Why didn't we do something about this? Where were we? Us white people in this process. It's like, well, do you want to give them agency or do you want to intervene and tell them how to raise their kids? Like what's the precedent? And this is a genuine question, not me.
Lenore TaylorIt does, I mean...
Damian Damjanovskipontificating by the way like I don't know how to navigate this
Lenore TaylorI I think we expect in Indigenous or non-Indigenous communities that governments intervene if children are at risk. And I think the Northern Territory government has actually ⁓ announced a review into community children services and how they dealt with that particular family. So I don't know that there's actually, you know, that people are looking at it differently necessarily than if a similar death had happened in a
Damian DamjanovskiBut, but, yeah, but, but, but involvement in the community for a lot of people of the community where generally they prefer not to have government involved in it is an imposition where you're going, well, for us to be involved and to keep your children safe, the government has to be involved, which means we need now need to impose yourself in the old-timers camp in some way, whether that's just a regular check-in or whatever it is, that's still the government.
Lenore Taylornon-Indigenous community.
Peter LewisWasn't that the intervention? Wasn't that Avert's intervention? Which didn't work either.
Lenore TaylorWell, but the Northern Territory Government funds the old-timers, the Northern Territory Community Services is involved in those families. I mean, that is already happening. Is it not?
Damian DamjanovskiBut then these are just a failure of process. that, is that what happened here?
Lenore TaylorWell, I don't know, but the Northern Territory government has launched an inquiry to find out what happened because there was some details about the Kumajar little baby's family leaked, which suggested that there had been previous reports. I don't really want to go into it because it was leaked private information, but I think that was what prompted the investigation by the Northern Territory government. But it looked to me and again, I mean, I'm also not an expert, but it looked to me like a similar process that you would see. if a similar tragedy happened in any other community.
Damian DamjanovskiAbsolutely. I guess, Lenore, this is where I struggle, again, being an off the boat immigrant here and not knowing how to navigate the complexities of the Australian guilt landscape and the Indigenous landscape is Indigenous communities asking for a very high level of agency and decision making over their communities and how they raise their kids and their culture and all these other things. But then simultaneously, us collectively going, well, but there still has to be a level of protection for children and the vulnerable and all this other kind of thing. That means at some point you have to draw a line and oftentimes those two lines will overlap. When they overlap, should the collective protection take charge or should the ⁓ agency of the indigenous communities take precedence and how do we make that decision? That's where I struggle. And who makes the decision and does that change government to government or by what colour the government is?
Peter LewisWho makes, but also who makes the decision, right? Or, and the proposition of the voice was, are those decisions from the bottom up rather than the top down, given that the bottom down. Can I give you my take on the whole failure of the voices? It's a little rant, but we're over drinks. It's the allegory of the MCG. So one of the famous days in the Australian union movement was ⁓ just before the 2007 election with the Rights at Work campaign where
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Lenore TaylorMm.
Damian DamjanovskiHmm.
Peter Lewisthe union movement half filled the MCG for a day of protest. And the genesis of that was, I claim some guilt for this. One of my key jobs as a union spin doctor was crowd inflation. So whenever there was a protest, I would work my contacts with the police association and always get a factor of five amplification. So if there was 100 people, 100 people, get 500.
Lenore TaylorWhy you and Donald Trump?
Peter LewisThousand people, got five thousand, ten thousand, we claimed fifty thousand and it would be printed in the paper. During work choices, there were some serious rallies. Melbourne got fifty thousand at one point and we claimed a quarter of a million, two hundred and fifty thousand, and it was printed in the papers. We got two hundred and fifty thousand. then so the ACTU, Greg Conway said, oh, we've got two hundred fifty thousand. Let's book out the MCG. We can fill it because it's only one hundred thousand seats. So the day comes along.
Damian Damjanovskiyou
Peter LewisAnd we only half fill it and everyone's looking for the excuse. ⁓ you know, it's raining. The trains were like, no, everyone was there. It was just that we believed our own bullshit and we only got, you we only ever had half an MCG. And the reason that's an allegory, I think the problem, we were doing fine with our engagement with First Nations. Everyone believed that we were more further down the road than we was, but then we decided we have to put it to a vote. And we couldn't fill the MCG. We did not get the numbers to get there. And I feel like that is a lesson in when we're in the middle of something, believe what we want to believe because we're around everyone else that agrees with us. we did the work to make it land. They're into the allegory.
Damian DamjanovskiYes, the...
Lenore TaylorI I mean, think we've all sort of, no one here is claiming, you know, very deep, deep expertise in Indigenous service delivery. I guess I feel uncomfortable with ⁓ any analysis that sort of blames, looks like, looks like it could be blaming the family for the death of the girl. Like the, it was a terrible situation and clearly there were failures there.
Peter LewisHmm. Hmm.
Lenore TaylorBut it was a family that loved that little girl and I just, you know, I just think you have to be careful not to look like you're blaming them.
Damian DamjanovskiAbsolutely. sorry, just building on, on, on Peter's thing as well. Cause I think Lenore, your point's really good, but just, um, not connecting it to the voice, but I think. Peter, I agree with you. The, the, the echo chamber effect is very real and on the voice.
Peter Lewiswhich wasn't just progressive politics, was corporate Australia as well. We were all there and we didn't bring the nation with us.
Damian Damjanovski⁓ yeah, we flew on the Qantas planes that said yes on the side of them while they overcharged us for the breakfast biscuit. ⁓ If it's even a biscuit anymore, I think you now just get a few crumbs in a packet and they call that breakfast. No, it's a piece of banana bread. But why didn't Albo just legislate this bloody thing first, demonstrate that it worked and then take it for a vote? Why would you tactically fuck up in that way? And it was a fuck up. And we can say that in retrospect where like the ambition was great. I don't.
Peter LewisTigger biscuit? God.
Damian Damjanovskideny him the ambition. But the statistics of referendums succeeding in Australia is very thin. Legislate the thing, show that it's functional, show that it's not a threat, and then take it to the vote. What the fuck was that about?
Peter LewisYeah, yeah, it was caught up on the day. No, I don't think I think it was there was this genuine sense within labor that in three terms, we could it was almost Keating S that we do voice, then Republic and then treaty. And there was this momentum. It was a classic thing that you read you misread the mandate. The mandate was because no one liked your boss. Like that was really what that election it was.
Damian DamjanovskiHubris? Like... Yeah. And they were tired of COVID bullshit. There was a big part of that as well. They didn't like the boss, but they also, there was a lot of COVID wrapped in that.
Peter LewisYeah, they didn't like your boss either. But I don't know, like I believed it. I believed it. I thought we would have three terms that we'd be moving Australia to a better place. ⁓ And it didn't happen. And it hasn't happened.
Lenore TaylorYou
Damian DamjanovskiSo do you think that as a result has now killed off the republic movement as well?
Peter LewisI... Lenore, what do you reckon?
Lenore TaylorYou can't, I do not think you can have a republic referendum before there's some sort of recognition of Indigenous Australia. I think, yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiSo, Lenore, are you a Republican? May I ask you, is that a very personal question? So, I'm, okay, I'm going to tell you, as a conservative, I should be a monarchist. As a centrist, I should be a Republican. I am down the line on this. I love the idea of a Republic. No one's yet to convince me on a great model for who we'd pick as our head of state, because I don't want politicians picking. And you know what?
Lenore TaylorI am absolutely, yes I am.
Peter LewisAre you Dharmaya or you a constitutional monarchist? Isn't the US a great working model of what it could look like if you had a popular elected pro?
Damian Damjanovski⁓ but the thing is also love the monarchy, not for any other reason that I think heritage is important. I think history is important. think the idea of people who are meant to represent our, our, our better angels and our greater demons is important.
Peter LewisHmm.
Lenore TaylorBetter angels? Have you had a look at them lately? Man ⁓ man! They're a bunch of grifters!
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter LewisThe imps!
Damian DamjanovskiYou, I'm sorry, but you can't, no, no, no, no, no, no. You can't, you can't shit on Lizzie. Lizzie was an example of an upstanding civic participant for the better part, like for three quarters of a century.
Peter LewisAndy?
Lenore TaylorYes, yes. And I also have a bit of a soft spot for Charles, I've got to say, but I don't see what he's got to do with us. That said, it's not high on my list of high priorities for reform. Yes, I'm a Republican. I'm not going to die in a ditch on doing it sooner rather than later.
Peter LewisYou clearly watched the crown. My only So I reckon the timing of the, was it 98 or 99, Lenore? I can't, 98. So, and Howard played it like a song and Reethy was like, Reethy split the That was brilliant way of killing it. But it was at a time when globalization was peaking the end of history, like people going, why do we need to re-consolidate the nation state? I think there will be off the back of this, you know,
Lenore TaylorI think.
Peter Lewisthe crisis and the breakdown of American influence, there is going to be a departure back into nation states. And I am curious, I'm not predicting, but I think over the next decade, the idea of why we, it may come back in some form as the world reconfigures. And I think sovereignty and nationalism are going to become a thing again, more than they have been over the last 30 years.
Damian DamjanovskiHmm. Isn't that important though? Have we not proved globalization? Not great. Like from the progressive side of politics, have we not figured out, hey, you know, getting that $20 t-shirt at Cotton On is costing some poor Vietnamese kid, ⁓ you know, their fingers, their effort, and they're only getting a dollar in it. Like haven't we proved the globalization thing ain't all it's cracked up to be?
Peter Lewisand
Damian DamjanovskiLike how do you reconcile that progressive side of like nation's
Peter LewisI've always been anti-globalization, but Dr. Trump's a champion to kill globalization. Sorry, Leno.
Lenore TaylorI mean... I'm interested in what you think, Peter, about whether a republic could precede any ⁓ recognition of Indigenous, because I don't see how can.
Peter LewisUnless it goes hand in hand and contiguous.
Lenore TaylorWell, you want to run a two-pronged referendum. You're always ambitious.
Peter LewisWell, I don't know.
Damian DamjanovskiSorry, explain to the dumb guy in the room why the Indigenous recognition stuff has to come first.
Lenore TaylorI think it would be a difficult ask to not prioritize it. not, you know, like it would be a difficult ask to not prioritize it. I think in terms of national identity, many people would see it as a more important thing to do.
Damian DamjanovskiDo you genuine question? ⁓ because again, like I came here in the early nineties from, Yugoslavia. So do you think most Australians associate the indigenous identity as part of their Australian identity?
Peter Lewisyou
Lenore TaylorI think most Australians think that, you know, First Nations as original inhabitants is part of the Australian identity. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, that's interesting.
Peter LewisI reckon we've gone backwards from the Yothi-Yindiya Treaty though, 20 years ago.
Lenore TaylorMm.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, cause it was a great song. haven't had a good indigenous song really at that scale of treaty since then. That was a banger.
Peter LewisOh, he needs a song and we'll solve the problems. Hey, Lenore, the other drink that we drink, but it's your turn. News media, it's not called the bargaining code. I think it's called the bargaining incentive. You were intricate in the last round of negotiations where your enemies became your friends and there was a united front from the media companies.
Lenore TaylorUh-huh. drink. It is. I went before the Senate committee with News Corp. I did.
Peter LewisDid you have a shower afterwards?
Damian DamjanovskiOkay.
Lenore TaylorNo, were actually, you know, we actually really agreed and you know, they're quite pleasant.
Peter LewisYeah, no. So what's your take on where things are up to now? Because it's slightly different. My understanding of it is that the government says we're going to tax you unless you do a deal, but the tax is going to be higher than the deal. Go off and do deals. that like A is a good policy. B, do you think it's going to deliver what the sticker says?
Lenore TaylorMm-hmm. Great. think it's reasonable policy in that you pay the tax whether you are running news or not. the situation that caused difficulties last time we met, okay, we're out of here, we're not running news, so we don't have to do deals, can't reoccur. ⁓ I think there are definite discussions to be had and hurdles, one of which is obviously the platforms don't want to pay the tax. They are saying it's a digital services tax. They will complain to Trump.
Damian DamjanovskiSo.
Lenore Taylorthat might lead either to retaliatory tariffs or to some sort of legal WTI style legal ⁓ challenge in the States, which was one of the design features of the form that the former code was designed to try and avoid that more so than this one. I think there's also potentially ⁓ issues in that it says that the government was trying to ⁓ soften the blow for the platforms. Like you don't have to go and do a deal with every single person and their cat.
Peter LewisAmen.
Lenore TaylorHowever, they said you have to do four deals. Now that could mean that, you know, the ABC News 9 and 7 do deals and everyone else is locked out. And I think a lot, there's a lot of nervousness amongst smaller players about that. I'm not at the Guardian anymore, but if I were at the Guardian still, I would be quite nervous about that because if there's incentives to do deals with much smaller players, I worry that the Guardian might be a bit sort of stuck in between the two parts of the policy.
Peter LewisWho proposed that?
Lenore TaylorSo I think there's a long way to go. And the bigger point is
Peter LewisHe said for like, sorry, when or is it for large or could they just go, we'll do a deal with the conversation with crikey with the guardian and.
Lenore TaylorWell, they've got to actually make up the amount of money. Like they've got to, so I don't think so, no. And also, yeah, but to my mind, the bigger problem is that the whole thing is sort of being superseded over time by AI. Like the bigger problem for media organizations now is that the AI companies are hoovering up at what we do often without paying and, you know, giving it back to people in AI generated summaries.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Sorry, go. Sorry,
Peter LewisOkay. It's yesterday's battle.
Damian DamjanovskiI thought you said you guys offered it for free? I thought you said you guys offered it for free? Wasn't that the whole spiel? Well, well, well, hang on, suddenly you're discriminating against non-humans.
Lenore TaylorPardon?
Peter LewisTake humans.
Lenore TaylorNo, no, I think, I mean, if someone's going to make, if someone's going to make money out of it, then I think they should give us a payment. Yeah, precisely.
Damian DamjanovskiSo it's one of those terms and conditions apply. Hey, can I ask you a genuine question?
Peter LewisDoesn't The Guardian have a deal with one of the AI companies though for their content?
Lenore TaylorYes, yes, yes. But I mean, as a general, like, but not with all of them. And as a general point, the the premise of the original news media bargaining code and this was the was the ⁓ hoovering up by the platforms of the digital advertising revenue. And that is increasingly less of a problem than the hoovering up of what we do and giving it back to people in summaries which don't mention us and which we weren't paid for the, you know, the import data. So, you know, it's still relevant, but it's going to be less relevant over time. And those AI companies are going to be different from the three platforms that are hit by this. So now it's Facebook meta and TikTok is now hit by the NBI as well. ⁓ I think Google's pissed off that LinkedIn is that they think that Microsoft LinkedIn should be in as well. But, know, so there's a lot of there's going to be a lot of detail argued about, but basically it's an OK design, I think.
Damian DamjanovskiLinkedIn for some reason. Lenore, genuinely want to understand this. So I was a huge supporter of the news media bargaining code, which was the original one. And now this is the news media bargaining incentive, as you mentioned. One of the big design differences is if I'm TikTok and I go, okay, cool, fair enough. I don't want to pay you any money. So I'm just not going to carry your news. I still have to pay a tax for news that I'm not publishing or disseminating.
Lenore Taylor⁓ Yep. Mm-hmm.
Damian DamjanovskiHow is that not a digital services tax? how is that not just a tax on how you're a digital company?
Lenore TaylorI think that's an extremely good question and one the platforms are likely to prosecute with the President of the United States. Yes, I think I agree. I agree with you.
Peter LewisAnd if it is, then when have we previously hypothecated attacks to one industry, which is my other like profit.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, taxes, taxes. But this is my point here, Peter, is this is exactly what we did with Uber and taxes in New South Wales. went, Uber's illegal, you're not operating illegally. And then everyone, yeah, but we really like Uber. We're not going to stop using Uber. We're not going to go back to taxes just because you don't like it. Also, they haven't innovated over the past 40 years. It's a bit shit. It smells and they always overcharge me. We're going to go to Uber instead. And then the government went, ⁓ fuck, we've got to support the tax industry somehow. So why don't we put a dollar 10 flag fall on every fair? This is the exact same thing where we're going, hang on a minute, like with respect, and I'm not referring. Well, to some degree, like never, but let's look at this objectively away from our, our individual roles and journalism and all that. go, it's not like journalists didn't know the digital revolution was coming. They didn't know. It's not like they didn't know that these changes were happening. They chose not to invest in innovation. They chose not to change their platforms. They chose not to build the tools that would attract people.
Peter LewisBut you saying the media's like a taxi that's smelly and corrupt? Well, maybe you are.
Lenore TaylorYou Wait up a sec, wait up a sec. What innovation do you think would have avoided the decline in advertising revenue to the platforms or the AI challenge now? Like what the hell could we have done?
Damian Damjanovskiokay. so again, the guardians somewhat of an exception here in the UK, but you look at the Australian market, most of these platforms had to be pulled kicking and screaming from print editions into digital editions. They were late to the game compared to the U.S. counterparts. While the whole world had moved to the internet, here they were still like, okay, well we'll publish it the next day online in a truncated format.
Lenore TaylorOkay, so you mean like if they'd actually done that got the rivers of gold and set that set that up as businesses online, that's what you're talking about. Yeah, okay, that's a point. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, yeah. The thing that made them the most money, the classifieds, it was not hard to see when the internet came around in the early 90s. ⁓ shit, people are moving this online. It took them two decades. It took them, well, yeah.
Lenore TaylorMm-mm. Correct. That was one of the reasons why I wanted to go to The Guardian by the way because we were trying to convince Fairfax to do live blogs and they were like, no, we don't want to do that.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. And that's the thing is it took them two decades to try to innovate. By the time they did, most of the market was eaten away by the Facebook's, Google's, Craigslist's in the US and all the other markets around the world. And then they went, ⁓ all our revenue is gone. We, we need some money, please government. Can you tax those guys that took all our revenue away because they get the ads, not us. It's like, well, where did your money go? Just to shareholders?
Peter LewisThey're all following it now.
Lenore TaylorBut I don't, I mean, I think I accept your point that the Australian media companies were slow off the mark with ⁓ going digital. That's true. But I think, ⁓ you know, they had, even if, I think there were bigger forces at play that were eroding their ad revenue on site as well. it's not only that that was happening. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiOh, of course, but that's any business has macro forces at play, right? And you have to respond to the conditions, but it's not to say that they were blindsided by this overnight change where their ad revenue suddenly disappeared. It gradually diminished over a period of 20 years in which time most of these platforms chose not to innovate their way out.
Peter LewisAnyway, I must say.
Lenore TaylorBut then by your argument then the whole, the media all around the world were equally flat-footed because everybody is under the same cost pressures. And it's only the very big companies that have the economies of scale to sort of really be profitable. like small media everywhere is struggling.
Peter LewisWould you be happy that the media disappears, Nami, and it's just class?
Damian DamjanovskiNo, no, absolutely not. What I'm delighted is in its place, what we've seen is a blossoming of new independent, smaller, whether you want to call them boutique or garden variety, artisanal medias that are either industry specific or area specific have cropped up in their place, which is great.
Peter LewisThey still feed off the output of the mainstream media. So many of those blog sites are still...
Damian DamjanovskiI don't think Politico takes that much off the newswire, they service a very specific clientele. Capitalbrief here in Australia does the exact same thing, there's plenty of examples, that's the innovation cycle.
Peter LewisYeah, yeah, yeah.
Lenore TaylorI've got no problem with that argument if the sites you're talking about are actually doing journalism. The problem I have is that a lot of what is flooding people's news feeds is ⁓ online opinion and all sorts of things. I have no problem with that in and of itself, like the more the merrier, like have a political debate. love that. But it's not the same thing as journalism. It's not finding out stuff you wouldn't know if we weren't here, which should be the mainstay of a journalist's job. I worry that we've, you know, in an old-fashioned newspaper, you used to have like 20 news stories for one opinion piece. I reckon now we'd have like 500 opinions for one news story. Like the shoe leather journalism of holding people to account that we always blather on about and... finding stuff out that people wouldn't know and going to AGMs putting in FOIs. There's so far fewer people doing that and so many more people putting their mugs on Instagram and giving you their two cents worth.
Peter Lewisexpensive, isn't it?
Damian DamjanovskiYes. I mean, look, that's exactly what me and Peter are doing here. But, sorry, just to follow up on that, no, no, but you're a qualified journalist, Lenore. Please don't degrade yourself to our level. But can I just add to that? And again, not to be the rude capitalist here, but people have demonstrated with their clicks, feet and dollars that they don't give enough of a shit about the journalism.
Peter LewisAnyway, just to round it off. ⁓ Just to round it off.
Lenore TaylorAnd me!
Peter Lewisqualified. There is actually.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd not everyone, but overwhelmingly, they're not buying the quarterly essays or the, you know, some are subscribing to The Economist, but not a lot. They're not buying those things. They're happy to take the sugar hits, not the vegetables. And you're right. In the old newspapers would give people, you know, a few sugar hits and their daily dose of vegetables that they need to get. That model didn't survive.
Lenore TaylorWell, mean, Newscop announced a record profit today. The Guardian is profitable. Nine is profitable. So and I also think that you hit a tipping point where there's so much AI slop and so much stuff. I mean, my argument was always people are going to come back because they all are sticking with us because they know they can trust that it's true.
Peter LewisThis is Dan's theory as well. Yeah. Hey, just to round out this conversation, which is terrific, I do think it's beautiful that all the media companies are putting out joint releases and holding hands and singing kumbaya. I was quite involved in the last round of News Media Value and Code. I was doing some advocacy with the Australia Institute. I have never had a better run in the media than when I was arguing for more money for the media. I was being asked to write off ends, left, right and center.
Lenore TaylorRemember what Paul Keating said. Remember what Paul Keating said, Peter. Back to the horse called self-interest.
Peter LewisIt was like... ⁓ At least it's dried.
Damian DamjanovskiI think for what it's worth, just to round this out before we talk about very quickly about budget next week, because we're already at 50 minutes. I think the AI slop, while I don't disagree with you, it is slop. The speed of the AI slop moving from slop to what we might traditionally consider pretty good journalism will be a faster journey than any of us expect. And I think it will get there.
Lenore Tayloryou
Peter LewisI reckon this is a discussion for another day, which I'm not sure you're right. I think it's hit a wall and people are smelling the slop, including Klaus's slop now. so just so you know, Lenore, Dhame puts a daily bit of slop out and it's not like I love Klaus, like as much as I can love a predictive text engine, but I, I,
Lenore TaylorMm-mm. I know I've seen it. ⁓
Damian Damjanovskiis great.
Peter LewisThere is a world, so my mate Nick Davis has got this megapixel theory. I'll just run it with you guys here. So remember, everyone used to think, how many megapixels do you have in your camera? And it used to mean a thing because it meant it was a better photo. But at some point, it gets so good that it doesn't matter how many megapixels, it's just a really good photo. And his theory is that the LLMs have got to that point now and they're not going to go much further. And now there's going to be a period of consolidation working out what they're useful for and what they're not. And writing is not something they're useful for. You can smell it. It is not good. And people...
Lenore TaylorBut in any event, they can't find out information that isn't already there. by definition, they can't. They can't do journalism. They can very happily summarize something. And that kind of trained monkey journalism, fine, do it. I don't care. But the proper...
Peter LewisI can't do journalism. Maybe.
Damian DamjanovskiJust explain why, just for our listeners, Lenore, for our listeners, explain why they can't do it.
Peter LewisThey can identify patterns. Yeah.
Lenore TaylorWell, because, I mean, OK, let's say you want to find, you know, a source tells you that a minister is corrupt and you want to put it, you put in five FOIs and you have coffee with six people and someone gives you a clue about something and then you go and ask someone else and you triangulate it all and you put together and write a story. There's no way that AI can do that. If there were bits of that information available on the Internet somewhere, they could suck it all in incredibly effectively. but they couldn't go and find the pieces of information that weren't already there.
Damian Damjanovskinot sure that's entirely true. It's a great point of view. I'm not sure that's entirely true. And I'm not sure that will be true for in another six months. Cause I think other than the physical coffee, there's no other bits of that that you couldn't get AI to do today. Not necessarily well, but you couldn't, you could get it to do today.
Peter LewisI reckon this is a conversation for another day because we're kind of rounding it.
Lenore TaylorWe should continue this conversation. ⁓
Peter LewisDumb intern. Dumb intern.
Damian DamjanovskiI'm very excited to have this. Tell me about, we've got budget next week. It's going to be a big budget.
Peter LewisYeah, let's do our predictions for the week because I feel like this is the round out. So this is our shout section. I don't know if I warned you about this Lenore, but you've got to give us your prediction for the week. But we'll start off with Dharmay. He's probably going to be hanging around camp.
Damian DamjanovskiYes, I'll be hanging around Canberra like a bad smell next week. Looking forward to all the rubber chickens. I think it's going to be a painful budget for a lot of people, but potentially the budget charmers needs to pass, which is what I'm really interested. The changes as we've discussed at length, Peter Lewis, CGT and negative gearing in this country after fucking change. If anyone under 40 has a hope of owning a house, I'm shocked and surprised that The Albo government hasn't tried this sooner, but I guess they feel hopefully emboldened enough to do this now where we overturn the overly generous tax benefits we give to old landowners and old house owners so that young people can actually have a parcel of Australia to call their home.
Peter LewisAnd I also note that Tim Wilson's Uncle Jeff is out there again playing his greatest hits from 2019, revving everybody up. Do reckon they're going to have a go at family tax as well, which family trusts, which I think is because the problem with like family trusts are the biggest rort, but the only people that know it's a rort are people that have family trust. Like if other people knew what was going on, like, yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiYep. Yep. Yeah, I'm not sure. People have enough money to put it into a trust. You've got to enough money to pay the accounts and the lawyers.
Lenore TaylorBut it's kind of connected too, isn't Because people own properties through their trusts. Yeah.
Peter LewisYeah, it's wild. What's your prediction for the budget, Lenore? Or more for the week? You know, you know.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Yeah.
Lenore TaylorI don't have a prediction, more a kind of something I'm perversely looking forward to. I agree with what Damien said about the capital gains tax and negative gearing, like bring it on, long overdue, but I'm really looking forward to the spluttering opinion pieces in some of the papers from wealthy owners at multiple properties screaming about intergenerational warfare and how it's all really unfair and how they might have to sell their 49th home.
Damian DamjanovskiOkay.
Peter LewisI just want to see ⁓ how dominant the grandfather is in the conversation. My concern as someone that is invested in labour having a successful second term is that they make it look really big, but then when you peel it away, everything's grandfathered and it's on the never never and it's not going to have a huge impact.
Damian DamjanovskiThat's my honest concern from a, from a citizen perspective is that it's going to look like it has teeth, but ultimately it's going to be a cardboard cutout that falls over much like the fucking housing fund where nothing's been built. It's going to be one of these things where it's a great announcement, but nothing behind it.
Peter LewisWhat then? dollar 20. But the other thing that I'm interested in is I really like I'm a bit obsessed by this. think the economy is going to go a lot further south than people expect. I'm going to be really interested in what the projections are, because, you know, this case scenario, if if this, you know, blockade in the Middle East ended tomorrow, the tail on that is months and months and months and months. These ships move at the pace of a pushback. Australia will be OK with fuel supply because we've done all the deals, but it's going to be more expensive. That's going to flow right through the economy because we're an energy based economy. So I'm interested in whether that's being factored in because if it's not factored into the budget, it is just going to be a shimmer. Like it's going to be based on this model.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, especially food.
Lenore TaylorMm-hmm.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd somehow Woolies will make a record profit again and we'll keep swiping those everyday rewards cards and hoping they give us some back.
Lenore TaylorAnd the budget will have to make some assumptions about how long it goes on, which will be interesting.
Peter LewisBut I wouldn't, so I think that's going to be the most interesting and it's going to be almost tea leaves, but I think that's going to be the real story. think without this, this would be their reform. This is why we have Labour governments, people, this is it. But this constraint is worse than the GFC. It's probably as significant as the pandemic that you guys dealt with. And like it would knock. Is this as usual? ⁓
Lenore TaylorThis is the year, yeah.
Damian Damjanovskibut a slower, slower band-aid to pull off. It's going to be a real slow burn for people. ⁓ I'm excited for next week. Regardless, I look forward to it. If you're sad enough to watch the budget, Tuesday night, 7 p.m. should be a lot of fun. Jim Chalmers and Budget and Reply on Thursday by Angus Taylor, the leader of the opposition.
Lenore TaylorMm.
Damian DamjanovskiI was just going to say a big thank you to you, Lenore, that this has been amazing. Stay on the line. Stay on the line with us for a minute. Peter, as always, and every week, thank you for a lively, interesting, and challenging conversation. I appreciate you.
Lenore TaylorIt's been fun.
Peter LewisCome back. Yeah. You're my favorite evil twin, Dimey. Let's do it again. Cheers. Bye.
Damian DamjanovskiYou're my favorite. Thank you everyone. We'll see you again next week.
Lenore TaylorSee you.
