Episode 6

Budget and Budget in Reply

15 May 20261 hr 5 min

Show notes

Guests: Fiona Scott, and Fiona Scott.

Budget Week in Canberra, the impact of the budget on Labor and the Coalition, and the issue of trust in politics and broken promises. Housing affordability and the political blame game surrounding it. Dark economic scenarios and homelessness measures.

Takeaways

  • Budget Week in Canberra
  • Impact of the Budget on Labor and Coalition
  • Trust in Politics and Broken Promises Housing affordability is a critical issue
  • PRRT and gas tax are topics of public interest Political identity crisis
  • Impact of community independents
  • Gambling advertising ban

Chapters

  • 00:00 Budget Week in Canberra
  • 07:03 David Pocock's Influence and Personal Life
  • 16:18 Discussion on Family Trusts and Political Impact
  • 23:12 Dark Economic Scenarios and Homelessness Measures
  • 42:49 Identity Crisis in Politics

Full transcript

Read itHide it

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.

Peter LewisWelcome to What's Your Poison? The show where people who disagree on everything agree it's best to do so over a drink. My name is Peter Lewis. I run a central media Australia's progressive media agency and joining me is my evil twin, Dharmajan Jannosky, former Morrison, inside man and principal at General Strategic. G'day, Damo. And what is your poison this week?

Fiona Scottyou

Damian Damjanovski⁓ Good Friday to you Peter Lewis, my poison this week is a hibiki Japanese Harmony Whiskey that I'm very much enjoying after a long week of budgets and budgets in reply down in Canberra. You and I got to spend some time together obviously down there and have some shared interesting experiences Mr Lewis, tell me about that and what your poison is.

Fiona ScottOkay. Okay.

Peter LewisYeah, I'm still, well, I'm still down here. I'm back in the room hotel, which is like the last chance hotel for Canberra. And I've rated the mini bar with a ⁓ traveler Australian lager, which feels to me like a totally generic brand, but it's ultra low carb. So I'm all up for that. But budget week is a big week, right? And we've got our guests will share it with us, but a lot of it is, you know,

Fionayou

Fiona Scottyou Okay.

Peter LewisWe say Canberra is Hollywood for ugly people and this is like Oscars week. but also, but that's nicer. Yeah. But I did have a first time experience with you last night. You smuggled me into a liberal fundraiser where they were all very decent people. They drank better. The cocktails were better than a labor fundraiser and

Damian DamjanovskiThis is a Christmas for ugly people. Budget week.

FionaMet Gala, Met Gala.

Fiona Scottyou Okay.

Peter LewisThey dressed a lot better, but apart from that, you could have been, I'll take you to one of ours at some stages, almost as bad.

Damian DamjanovskiThey're much of a muchness and for those listening at home who might not be ⁓ in this fear, which I think is most of our listeners to be fair, budget ⁓ every year, what happens obviously is the treasurer gets up and announces the budget for the coming year and then the opposition leader gets the opportunity to do his budget in reply and some of the cross-party, so Pauline Hanson delivered her budget in reply, which was very sadly, very sadly cut off.

Peter Lewis⁓ did she?

Damian DamjanovskiFrom delivering the full speech. I believe Allegra and a few of the others did like a know teal-esque budget So everyone gets the opportunity to do an in-reply But the two that are really paid attention to is the government of the day and the opposition of the day But let's dig into that in a minute. I think we've got two amazing guests this week Peter. I'll introduce you to mine first former MP for Lindsay one of my favorite people Fiona Scott Fiona What is your poison? Tell us a little bit about your journey?

Fiona ScottOkay.

FionaSo I had to go back to my roots and got myself a good affinity gin which is from the gross file in the Hawkesbury. It's amazing. So it's a lovely gin. It's won a heap of awards as well which is pretty awesome but it's full of a lot of local botanical vote notes you know.

Fiona ScottOkay. Okay.

Peter LewisAnd do you have that neat or with tonic or how do you take it?

FionaIt is actually, I would never do a gin neat, but this one here is actually pretty good and you put like a bit of lemon in it, it's just pretty sweet.

Peter LewisYeah.

Damian DamjanovskiIt's from Western Sydney, so you're just meant to inhale it on an oily rag if you can. That's the...

FionaYou could sniff it as well.

Peter LewisSo, so Fiona, you've won Lindsay, think. Did you? Oh, go on, sorry. Okay.

Fiona Scottyou

FionaNo, no, I had it finished. You've got to have like the mixer. The mixer has to be right. A gin is only as good as its mixer. And yeah, big chunk of ice and a bit of lemon from my lemon tree that I dehydrated and it's kind of, you know, it's good to go. Yeah, good fun. As I said, liberals, the cocktails are better.

Peter Lewis⁓ Let's let's say how you go. So you famously won. It is true. You won Lindsay. Was it in was it in the year that ⁓ the liberals swept to power or the one before was it 2010 or 2013?

Fiona ScottOkay.

Fiona2013 but then came very close in 2010 when you know it was a whole whatever but I had like a 32, 33, 35, 30 something day campaign.

Peter LewisI've got to ask you this because you first came on the radar when your glorious leader did that press conference ⁓ and he said she's got a certain sex appeal. How did that go? Like, how did that feel at the time? And do you have any battle scars from that?

FionaMm-hmm. Well, I'm drinking on a Friday night, so it's all good.

Fiona Scottyou

Peter LewisSorry.

FionaHe wasn't talking about me, he was clearly talking about a different Fiona Scott because there is more than one of us.

Fiona ScottYou

Peter LewisWell, this is right. So, Damo's brought a Fiona Scott to What's Your Poison, but I'm taking your Fiona Scott and raising you one with my Fiona Scott, who is the wonderful Chief of Staff of David Pocop, former Labor staffer through that period, I think. And you guys have a history, don't you?

Damian DamjanovskiYou

Fiona ScottIndeed. in the 20, we do. So in the 2013 campaign, in fact, I remember one morning getting a phone call from 2GB wanting to interview Fiona Scott. And I was like, ooh, I could really sink this campaign. I didn't. for the subsequent more than a decade now, I think we continue to get each other's phone calls and emails, which is fantastic. Correct.

Peter LewisUhhh

Damian DamjanovskiYeah

FionaYou

Peter LewisAnd I understand you've got a bit of a pack that you haven't used that to each other's disadvantage. So tell us a bit about that. And was that just informal or was it actually like a handshake?

FionaMmm.

Fiona ScottYou

FionaWell, we only met each other about a year ago, two years ago. yeah, so you made that decision on that one. And then the first time I became aware of you was not long after I got elected. into my inbox comes the whole weak labor strategy, the whole attack, everything. And it came into my inbox.

Fiona ScottYeah, I think so. I'm

FionaAnd I looked at it and I was just going, oh shit, you know, like, what do I do with this? And I was like, do I like flick it off to Christopher Pine, who was the attack dog? And then I was like, What did she get of mine? So I was like, I just went bin because I don't want to poke the bear on this one. So yeah, I'm just going to bin that and no, I never received it.

Fiona ScottExactly. It's mutually assured destruction.

Peter LewisThat is M.A.D. right?

Damian DamjanovskiI gotta say though, I- Yeah. Just a reminder guys, like the people listening to this who don't live in the Canberra bubble or work in these circles will not believe that this is how this kind of stuff operates. Like we have to keep up some kind of semblance of no no it's all organized, have excellent security procedures, everything's under control. Now how do the two of you tell each other apart and ask for the purposes of today's show? How do we know which Fiona we're talking to? Do we have a way, like does everyone have a preferred middle name? ⁓

FionaHahaha

Peter LewisI just reckon when we say Fiona it's all in.

FionaOregon's all in. We're kind of used to it. I've already had two phone calls for her this week and Fiona's had, well was the last time you had a phone call. Like there's at least one or two a week, easily.

Damian DamjanovskiHa ha ha ha ha ha

Fiona ScottChaos. I guess. Easily. Yeah.

Peter LewisSo before we go into our reflections, just my, I'll call it my Fiona Scott and your Dames. So you worked for Labour ministers and then you were a really key person in that last parliament when David Pocock had the one, he had the casting vote in the centre. How different is it this cycle from that cycle? Cause it's not, people stopped calling you apart from Fiona Scott. anyone else stopped calling you?

Fiona ScottYeah, totally different. ⁓ Not everyone. There's, you know, there are some pretty smart people in the government who know that they're still only a vote or two away from needing David again. they're ⁓ smart enough to know that continuing those relationships is a good thing to invest in. Others have just not interested at all.

Damian DamjanovskiIt's a...

Fiona ScottBut I mean, David's influence is so different now, right? Like he's about to overtake the prime minister in terms of number of Instagram followers. And, you know, we've launched this. ⁓ we're four. I would think we were like 14. Yeah, very, very close. ⁓ Yes, I think we've we've got him to. ⁓ really? I didn't know.

Peter LewisMmm.

Damian DamjanovskiI think he has.

Peter LewisWhat about tie-dye?

Damian DamjanovskiYou Toto's a girl! Did you know this? Toto's a girl! Yeah! I didn't know either! Toto is a girl dog!

Peter LewisHow did you find this out, Tom?

Fiona Scott⁓

Damian DamjanovskiBecause Toto wore a dress to Albo's wedding and I thought it was like a gender bender thing and then Jules, my partner, was like, no no, Toto's a girl and I'm like no, Toto's an idiotic name for a girl, why would you call a girl dog Toto? And then we looked it up and it's a girl. Yeah.

Fiona ScottWow, okay.

Peter LewisThe other thing that listeners may not know, my Fiona also last year married Ed Huzik. Congratulations on that. So you're kind of in this, I don't know, I'm not asking you how you lived your life, but it's A, it's very Canberra, but B, how do you navigate all that stuff?

Fiona ScottHa ha ha ha.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Fiona ScottIt's very Canberra! Well, there's a few Chinese walls and yeah. But I mean, it's probably easier than if I was the other Fiona Scott and try to do it across that divide. I'll say that.

Peter LewisGrown ups? Yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiSo you weren't content. So Fiona, you weren't content enough being outside the tent in a work context. You needed to be outside the tent in a personal context as well. You just needed to be on the outside in every regard. So this is fascinating, I think, because again, to people not inside the bubble, think a lot of people assume that if you're on one side or the other side or the middle or wherever, that it's very...

Peter LewisThere was a movie about that. I'm sure there wasn't a movie in the States about that. Yeah.

FionaYeah.

Fiona ScottClearly, yeah, everyone.

Damian Damjanovskiadversarial and that you kind of dislike or hate people from the other side but in reality we all have a laugh, we all have a beer, it's all very collegiate and very professional there's actually very few proper rivalries where it's like people deeply dislike each other and usually it's people disliking each other from their own tent not from the other side which is quite ironic.

Peter LewisHmm.

Fiona ScottCorrect.

FionaHahahaha

Peter LewisYeah, I always heard the real enemy in the coalition was the national, like the Libs and the Nats, but now they've got all these other enemies. they've got lots of enemies now. ⁓ And Labour's always had the factions built in and the training ground of young Labour is to learn how to count and to hate. you know, there are lots of bad behaviours. ⁓ I also would ⁓ challenge that people that listening to this are outside the Canberra bubble. I think our audience is the Canberra bubble, but just saying.

Damian Damjanovskithe libs and the libs and labour and labour. Let's chat about the... yeah.

Peter LewisAnyway, ⁓ let's talk about the budget. ⁓ Why don't I'd rather and I don't want to kind of just do that, the the dueling talking points. But what does it mean for labor and then maybe what does it mean for the coalition? So I don't know. How do you guys think like obviously, labor set this up as the this is the whole point of being a labor government. This is the one that sets our second term agenda and then the.

Damian DamjanovskiWilson. Hmm.

Peter Lewisthe war hit and the economic conditions made things harder. But god damn it, we're going to go and change ⁓ the tax settings ⁓ in a significant way, although over time. ⁓ I'll start with you, my Fiona, like looking at someone who's worked on the Labor side and also now with the independents, how do you think it went?

Fiona ScottLook, I think the sense I get is that it's landed pretty well. There are specific areas that are really certainly we're seeing it ping, ping, ping in our inbox, things like the NDIS cuts. There's obviously concern around that, even though I think there's also like, that's a weird one because I mean, it's hitting hard in the community. It's hitting hard for people who are impacted, who have uncertainty. But politically there seems to be an actual shared understanding that this scheme wasn't sustainable and it wasn't going to be able to continue without serious reform, right? So the housing stuff, I don't think the broken promise is sticking despite the Murdoch media ⁓ front page blitz this week. I think the more interesting, yeah, well, think the interesting thing is the young people and Triple J ran this really hard this week, like,

FionaHmm.

Peter LewisWhat about the Communist Manifesto? More so.

Fiona Scottpulling the ladder up, know, the older generation pulling the ladder up behind them. That seems to be sticking more with people, ⁓ particularly the younger people that labour were trying to target. So I find that really interesting.

Peter Lewisyou're taking away our chance to use the rorts that you've used.

Fiona ScottCorrect. But in taking away those rorts, Labor are giving them the opportunity to get into the rorting system, I guess, a sense, or like to own a house, right? Which is what both sides of politics, both major parties are actually pushing for, is for young people to be able to own a house.

Peter LewisMmm.

Damian Damjanovskiyou Hey Scott, what do you reckon?

Peter LewisWhat a beat.

FionaI think the budget was highly problematic for Labor in multiple places. think in around the capital gains tax, getting to the housing market, the not being able to actually build as many houses. So then coming back was what 35,000 houses or something. That's really problematic. The immigration numbers that aren't matching pace with the amount of houses being built. I mean,

Peter LewisThanks.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Fiona Scottyou

FionaI've seen on all sides for a while people think that they can tweak with the financial modelling of buying houses whilst not actually addressing the supply and not addressing the immigration numbers meeting the supply. bring in as many people as you like. I don't really care. Well, I do care, but just bring in as many people as you like, but have the support services and the infrastructure for the people when they arrive. If you've brought in 5 million people over five years, which is what it will be, you know, then

Peter Lewisyou

FionaWhere's the houses for people to live in? And when you look at a two bedroom house in Penrith or two bedroom apartment in Penrith, these seven, $800,000, that's absurd. That is nuts. And where's the jobs that accompany that? that sort of challenge that I don't think sitting there and just saying, it's all the fault of CGT is a cop out. Build some more bloody houses.

Damian DamjanovskiIt's batshit.

Fiona ScottOkay.

FionaDeal with the regulation that costs somebody $100,000 before they've put a shovel in the soil. Deal with some of that sort of challenge. Really take on local government and state governments who are the biggest challenge here, not federal government or, your respect, we'd like to say the feds have big leaders here, but the leaders sit at the state and they live with local governments that are completely defunct. And it's great, Labor put some money towards an AI program.

Damian DamjanovskiMm.

Fiona ScottOkay.

FionaBut what if the states don't take it up? What if local government doesn't take that up? mean, tie some funding to make these stupid tiers of government do their jobs. so I think really, I mean, to sit there and say we can do it with tricky finance, I don't think he's great. The AI tech sector hasn't liked the capital gains ⁓ measures, the CGT stuff too. And I think that's really misguided around the discretionary trust.

Damian DamjanovskiThanks.

Fiona ScottMm. Mm.

Damian DamjanovskiHmm.

Peter LewisSo do I too.

Fiona ScottSo

FionaLike sure you might have the odd millionaire and a discretionary trust but people who are actually using discretionary trusts are going to be small business family business. you're profit you distribute if you're distributing profit in a discretionary way that means you're distributing profit to people who are not financial investors in that business. You know what that is? That's a stay at home wife. It's a stay at home wife.

Peter Lewis⁓ I reckon

Fionaof a tradie who is distributing funding to do that. So you have just smashed contractors, tradies, farmers. Overwhelmingly, that's what it is. And it's not a tax raising measure for these people. Overwhelmingly, it might be an income protection measure. So I think there's a whole range of aspects that are hugely problematic and it's going to really ripen.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter LewisBut this is the interesting thing. I reckon even if everything you say is true, Labour is still done what they want to do on this. And we'll talk about the liberal response in a sec. I just want to stay on Labour for a sec, Dharmai. I reckon with the biggest challenge with the family trust particularly is that the only people that know how it works are people that are using them. So it's almost like this, unless, you know, if a rot happens and no one

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter Lewisknows it's a rort, is it really a rort sort of thing. And I don't know how much, because it is, it's outrageous.

Fiona ScottOkay.

Damian DamjanovskiWell, yeah, it's one of these things where to set it up, like it's not a cheap operation to set it up and then to maintain it, right? This is where you have to get lawyers and accountants involved. ⁓ And unless you're making good coin, you generally don't have the disposable cash to get a good accountant and a good lawyer on board to correctly set up a discretionary trust. So I think you're right on that. But what I was going to say is to Fiona's point,

FionaI don't actually agree with that, having known who's the... yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiThere are now a lot of systems out there specifically designed for small businesses to basically borrow the discretionary trust as it was previously used exclusively by the wealthier class and apply it to small business owners who exactly like Fiona said, there might be a stay at home, whatever it is, but basically to redistribute that trust.

Peter LewisSo again, it's the socialization of the rort across the entire system. And at some point,

Damian DamjanovskiAnd this is what

FionaNo, but Peter, I disagree with that as well. And the reason I disagree with that is that if the discretionary trust is being used, so you're a man in a van, tradie of some description, and you've earned a certain amount of income. And so once you've paid your company taxes and everything else that's come through your business, you've then got your profit. So let's see how this goes if there's double taxation here, because there's a very chance that it could be. Then if the woman, if you've put it against your wife, who might be

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Fionayou know, stay at home with some kids and what have you, but she might be doing the books for the business so it doesn't have an income elsewhere. If her income through this then means she's paying a income tax, but also is then ⁓ cut out for things like family tax benefits, childcare subsidies and all the rest of it. There's reasons people will make those decisions. And so this is going to have a massive impact. And once again, we want to build houses and what you're just going to completely piss off all the trades.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Fionaall the farmers, all of the rest of it.

Damian Damjanovskisecond.

Peter LewisMafia, now what do you reckon?

Fiona ScottWell, I don't think it's, I just don't think it's that big an issue in the electorate and I don't think it's going to, you know, be a massive vote changer and I don't think it's going to be something that we're talking about in three months time, to be perfectly honest. ⁓ I just think, you know, particularly for the, again, for the voter cohort that Labor was going after in this budget, you know, what is it like 70 % of them haven't read a news story or a newspaper in the past 12 months? Like this is gone. straight over their heads, no interest. Like, the people it does impact, I absolutely concede it will have, you know, a significant impact, but that's a fairly limited cohort.

Peter LewisHmm.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter LewisAnd do you guys agree the broken promise won't hurt like I know that was your sense Fiona with the book case. I think the one thing they've done is I really like the stick. I'm going to be really honest with you about the fact that I've been dishonest. Like I think there's something there's an incredible stick here that is kind of situation of change. I'm to be honest. I've changed my position.

Damian DamjanovskiBut this happens all the time, Howard did it as well with the GST, the idea of breaking a promise went to a legend.

FionaHe took JST to an election. He went to election.

Peter LewisHe went to an election, but he also bought in core promise, non-core promise. was, and like, to be honest, the whole thing is a bit of a farce. It's just the way that.

Fiona ScottCorrect.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, yeah, this is...

Fiona ScottBut it does add to this declining trust in politics, right? And that is an issue and that's fuelling the rise in One Nation. So in that sense it's problematic. I think more so than in this one policy area or one broken promise.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah. It is. I tried bringing in the core promise, non-core promise with my partner, it didn't work.

Fionaand fueling in the rock.

Fiona ScottAlso, it wasn't a promise, it was a statement. Didn't you watch 7.30? It was a statement. Correct. ⁓ Sorry, Fee.

Peter LewisHa

FionaAnd also fueling the rise, it's also fueling a rise in people.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah

Peter LewisIt was a position. It was a position. Our position has changed.

FionaBut Fiona, I just want to pick up that it's also fueling a rise in people voting for the man you work for now.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, so let me just zoom it out for one second. So I think ⁓ on the promise and the broken promise thing, right, we all know that politicians regularly will break promises if they feel it's, you if it's in their interest, right. So they do the political calculus to go, is it worthwhile breaking this promise by breaking this promise? A, am I losing votes or B, can I gain votes by breaking this promise? They obviously made the calculus. And what's really interesting about the labour budget

Fiona ScottMm.

Damian Damjanovskior the only budget, the budget from Labor is they did not go after any sector or any ⁓ part of the economy other than this was the thing, right? It wasn't a big thing, but it was the thing. And what we saw in the budget reply as well is this was also the thing. So both sides have clearly signaled that housing affordability is the issue. And we know and normal people know that is the number one issue.

Fiona ScottHmm.

Damian Damjanovskisome of it gets wrapped into cost of living, whatever else, but housing affordability is the number one, two and three issue. The Labour side have gone, well, who's to blame for housing affordability? It's the investors. It's the investors that's the problem. And the Liberal side have gone, it's the immigrants, right? It's the immigrants. What neither side have bothered to do is point out the fact that the arseholes in this situation is the 30 years of politicians who've gone, it's politically inconvenient for us to say the thing that we need to say out loud, which is,

Peter Lewisinvestors.

Fiona ScottHmm. Okay.

Damian Damjanovskithe only way we can make housing affordable is for house prices to go down or to increase your wages by a factor of 10. Right? So the, it's, you don't need an economist like treasury zone modeling showed that all these changes that labor's proposing in the budget, 75,000 houses over 10 years, that's seven and a half thousand houses a year. When we need, you know, a hundred to 200,000, like it is pissing in the wind into our own faces. Like it is pointless.

Fiona ScottCorrect. ⁓ huh. Yeah. It's a signal. It's a signal, though, and it suggests a shift. I've got to be honest, like, we were really surprised at how far they did go. Like, we weren't expecting them to just limit negative gearing to new supply. We thought, oh, maybe they'll cap it to one property or two properties. in a sense, Labor did go further, certainly, than I was expecting. I don't know, Peter, what you'd...

Peter LewisMarthiana? Yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiIt's a signal.

Fiona Scottwere anticipating like because they have just been so timid in government to to date like this was a bit like ⁓ shit okay you are prepared to spend some political capital ⁓

Peter LewisMmm.

Damian DamjanovskiBut then Fiona, grandfather? If the whole point is to say the investor class is the issue here, why let them can keep the benefit? Why not say, okay, well, you can keep it for two more years, but if you haven't disposed of your property within this three-year moratorium, then you're gonna get the full slog. Or if you downsize, you'll get a 50 discount. Or if you do a new build.

Fiona ScottYeah, no, I totally agree. It doesn't fix the policy outcome. Yeah. then yeah, yeah, yeah.

Peter LewisMm.

Fiona ScottAnd that's what like we model. We model these six different options looking at all the different grandfathering arrangements looking at the different kind of caps and They've just gone with very sorry grandparenting my apologies Sorry Senator McKinn

Damian Damjanovski⁓ It's a grandparenting arrangement or grandpersoning arrangement.

Fionathink we can be gendered here and can blame the men so we can just call it grandfathering. That's fine.

Peter LewisYou're so work.

Fiona ScottYeah, we probably can, actually.

Damian DamjanovskiAlright, so it's a- is there a-

Peter LewisHey, the other part of the budget that I thought was really interesting was the dark scenario. So we know that the economy is going south, but the dark scenario is pretty freaking dark. It's oil at $200 a barrel, 7 % inflation. Like they say, we're not going to go into recession, but there will definitely be a slowdown. There's going to be a slowdown anyway. But I thought I did a thing with, um, labor last night for members and Claire O'Neill was on there. And she was also talking about the homelessness measures. And I think.

Fiona Scott⁓ yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

FionaYeah, that's huge.

Peter LewisThere's this other part of the budget that if those dark scenarios are right, two things are going to happen. There's going to be a lot more people falling through the cracks. know, at the moment, social housing is like a 10 year waiting list. I know, but it's just going to be worse. Yeah. And that, and so that's my, and so the really bold thing that I was sort of thinking on, maybe they'll have a crack, but maybe they need a crisis is like the fast rollout.

Fiona ScottMm-hmm. Hmm. But there already are. Look how many people live in tents. I mean, look what happened in Wagga. Like, this is everywhere.

Peter Lewischeap, cheap public housing, but they've got these modular like some somebody can sort of pump something out for 250 grand a pop now you just need to build the manufacturing infrastructure like why

Fiona ScottYes.

Damian DamjanovskiYou can prefab and Peter, but the problem is the unions got into this prefab stuff decades ago, which is why most of the states won't allow prefabbed houses or prefabbed units. The technology has been there for decades, but this was a sweetheart union deal done. If Labour wanted to do something, they could. They could pave the way for, prefab housing. Absolutely.

Fionaand a lot of it's not considered.

Peter LewisBut what about when you guys, when you guys rent?

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, we did a shit job of it as well, I'm not doubting that. But, I don't, but...

FionaAre you too? But a lot of it's not built to what is considered code.

Peter Lewistalk about Fiona like that?

Fiona Scottyou

Damian Damjanovski⁓ but we have the worst building codes in the world, Fiona. Come on!

Peter LewisBut is tent code, like if someone's in a tent. And I just get, the entry level just needs to be a lot lower.

Fiona ScottCorrect, exactly.

FionaBut you look at like the shipping containers, but you look at say you can get into a shipping container like 20, 30, 40 grand, right? Which will expand out to the side and it'll be like, you know, a 20 foot square two bedroom house, right? But they don't make code. Now I live on some acreage and I could put multiple things like that on my property.

Damian DamjanovskiI mean

Fiona ScottMm.

FionaBut I can't actually legally rent it out because it's not considered to code. And because it's in a temporary structure, somebody can only live in it for 60 days, 90 days, and they have to move out again. So, 100 %

Fiona ScottMm. Yeah. And that's to your earlier point about local councils. Local councils won't let tiny homes, you know, take hold. It's madness.

Damian DamjanovskiBut the... But the fibro houses built in the 1890s are somehow up to code and okay. Like this, it's madness. It's absolute madness. But the...

FionaCorrect.

Fiona ScottYes. So Labor did put some money towards this prefab housing in the last budget, but they just kind of haven't actually spent it or done anything with it. ⁓ There's one. No, I was going say like there's a CRC who's doing some great work here and they did a great expo in Sydney last year with the New South Wales government. So like it's it's absolutely there and they're looking at it now even in like in sort of medium density, multi-res.

FionaYeah, but.

Damian DamjanovskiYep. Yeah.

Peter LewisBut other thing I hear is, Mmm.

Fiona Scottbut it just needs more support to expand its scale.

Peter LewisAnd they've actually got to build the manufacturing capacity here. Otherwise you're prefabbing overseas and then it's too expensive, which goes to supply chains.

Fiona Scottto manufacture it here. Correct. Yeah. 100%. I mean, we manufacture some in Canberra, to be honest, of the prefab. It's pretty awesome, but it's very small scale. No, I wish I could, but no.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

FionaIt's all from China.

Damian DamjanovskiSo let me get... Yeah.

Peter LewisIs that an achievement of Pocock?

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, well, while we're talking to Bookshelf Fiona about this, I guess my one question as a a Pocock staffer is, was there any notable absences for you from the budget?

Fiona Scott⁓ That feels like a real gift last year. Let me think, maybe $17 billion worth of revenue from a gas tax? don't know. Yeah. So we've talked a lot about spending.

Peter LewisFull toss!

Damian DamjanovskiSo for a lot of our listeners who don't know what David's been campaigning on and this idea of a gas tax and a PRRT, could you explain it in a few words or less, please?

Fiona ScottOf course, simple terms. So the petroleum resource rent tax is the tax that we have had in place for a long time to try and collect a return on gas exports in offshore commonwealth waters. Unfortunately, it's a shittily designed tax that gets gamed by the big gas companies. And so we don't get a lot of money for it. The government reformed it with the Greens two years ago, I think now. And it's actually now collecting even less revenue. So in this budget, they did all this pre-media drop saying, oh, PRRT has gone up by 400 million. But then you look at the receipts and it's actually gone down by 100 million. So in February at Estimates, David was quizzing Treasury about this. And he's like, how much do we get from PRRT? OK, 1.5 billion per year. How much do we how much do Australians pay in beer excise? And Australians pay more in beer excise than they do than what we collect in PRRT. And this just went viral, right? Like this little clip's been viewed over 10 million times on socials. And it's just kind of like sparked this outrage in the community. And I know the, you know, the gas industry has really pushed back and said, but we pay company tax and we do this and we do that. But it's just like this one tax compared to, you know, when you're comparing one for one, people were like, how is this possible? Like we have a trillion dollars worth of national debt and always got a $3 trillion sovereign wealth fund.

Damian DamjanovskiMm-hmm. Well.

Fiona ScottHow are we in this situation and why, again, after decades, politicians won't do something about it and start taxing these big-ass multinational gas companies for our gas?

Damian DamjanovskiSo I'm curious for everyone's views on this obviously, not to debate the finer points of the PRRT because that would be a very dull economics based podcast. I'm very interested in the campaigning component of it. And I think the campaigning concept of ⁓ framing this through the view of the actual beer excise, which is something everyone understands is the cost of my beer goes up and I know I pay some tax on it.

Fiona ScottMm. Very. Yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiI was actually curious, I wish David had done it with Ciggy's because as a smoker I have paid more excise I think than the entire gas and minerals industry. Personally I've... ⁓

Fiona ScottI can probably give you that.

Peter Lewisthan the gas industry. Personally, personally, you pay more in cigarette tax than Chevron pays.

Fiona ScottBlack market tobacco stuffed the budget this year, but anyway, yeah.

FionaOff chart. ⁓

Peter LewisHave you gone to Chop Chop? Yeah.

Damian DamjanovskiWell look, me, I have not, unless the ATO is listening obviously, I have not paid for an Australian cigarette, I think in eight years. And I refuse to, like $60 is literal, like it is theft on behalf of the Australian government for a product that is supposed to be legal. $60 a packet is torture, especially for poor people who over-index on smoking. Like it is idiotic, like they have well and truly contributed their fair share for the health outcomes of, you know, smoking your whole life. Like at this point, there needs to be reform. Anyway, my Fiona Scott, thoughts on the PRRT and this kind of absence of the Labour Party, like they've been very quiet on the gas thing. ⁓ Why do you think they've gone so quiet on it?

Fionamaybe they have a fear of the lobby that's going to come behind it on the other side. ⁓ I mean, look, think Australians want to know that they get a fair share of the resources that come out of the ground in Australia. And you look at other countries, even look at the Middle East right now, look at the wealth in places like

Fiona ScottOkay. Thank

FionaDubai and Abu Dhabi and Saudi Arabia and the money they get from the resources. She's just rolling her eyes whilst this is being said. Sorry if I'm giving you your talking points. But Australians do want to see that and it's about seeing the right balance of that. Now there is a complex tax arrangements between again state federal governments, resources, rebates and

Peter LewisAsterisk supplies.

Fiona ScottNo, no.

FionaRoyalties that are paid into state governments and all the rest of it. There is a lot of lack of transparency in this space that's not necessarily fully understood by the Australian public and when a certain senator Synthesizes it down simply that you know, you pay more probably for a local gin In tax then something like that that has cut through and so it is a conversation that when we are we're out I think the timing

Fiona ScottOkay.

Fionathat your office has done this, that your David's done this, Fiona is also exquisite. That whilst we see diesel at $3 a litre in the middle of the planting season and you know, we are selling our gas overseas and coming back and paying an international price for it. Same with coal and the cost of our energy bills and all of that stuff. Yet we have all this naturally occurring resources here to be an energy superpower.

Fiona ScottYeah. Yeah.

FionaThere's something here that just doesn't make sense. Now, is it the PIRT? I don't know. I'm not going to get into that part of the argument, but there's a big space in this area that for the Australian public when they're paying $3 a litre for diesel and when the winter crops come out of the ground at Christmas and oats is double the price and your Christmas shopping bill is going to be through the roof because that's when it's going to hit. People are going to ask why and it's because of

Fiona ScottYeah. Correct.

Peter LewisMm.

Fiona ScottYeah.

Peter LewisIt's gonna happen.

FionaAll these other resources that other countries are really wealthy on and we aren't. Now I appreciate people like Eugenia Reinhart are paying massive company taxes and everything else but there's something here in Australia that I think Australians want to see more transparency in this space and that's probably why you guys have had such a major hit on this. Maybe it's the modeling from Treasury to make it more complex to be nimble enough to reply to it but it's not like this is she just bubbled up overnight.

Fiona ScottOkay.

FionaI mean, yes, I ran, brought it on, but it's been bubbling away for a long time.

Peter LewisCan I just, can I?

Damian Damjanovskifound its moment.

Peter LewisSo can I do it's not I'm not defending the government. I think the I think the government would have loved to have done something on this tax. But the real politic at the moment is they are shit scared of running out of fuel and they have done deals with those fuel nations where it's basically guarantee your supply. We guarantee our gas. And I just don't think fiddling with the price signals at the moment. So I just don't think they can move.

Fiona ScottHmm. Yeah.

Peter Lewisat the moment. I also sorry, you push back.

Damian DamjanovskiBut I was just going to say, isn't that a case for, and again, just for listeners, any gas that comes from onshore, so the stuff that comes from CSG and stuff, is ⁓ subject to a royalty that's paid to a state. The PRRT is only relating to gas that comes from the Commonwealth, which is generally the gas they're extracting out of the water, know, 50 kilometers

Fiona ScottMm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Offshore.

Damian Damjanovskioff well more than 50, 100 kilometres off the coast of Australia, right? So it's that specifically. The gas industry does obviously pay its fair share of royalties when it comes to stuff that's from inland. The PITIT question is specifically the stuff that's offshore, so that should be pointed out. Peter, to your point, is there not then the case to make that the fact that they have, I don't want say room to play with, but the fact that they... have adhered to the PWT as it is, rather than paying some exorbitant rate, has given us the wiggle room to be able to negotiate these kinds of terms for oil, which we need. And we just don't have a supply of oil in Australia. We do not have a reasonable supply of oil. And it's stuff we need. We all decided we want to live in this globalized world. Yeah, it's like we all want to one day get to a non-fossil fuel-based world. But in the meantime, we need not just oil.

Fiona ScottHmm. you

Peter LewisWe are still a fossil fuel based economy.

Damian DamjanovskiWe need all the byproducts of oil that people never think about until shit like this happens where we go, actually, we need the helium that's a byproduct of that process because without it, modern society stops because we can't make chips and everything you have has chips in it. We need sulfur dioxide because it goes into 30,000 other products. We need ammonia that comes from that to make fertilizer. And without that, we don't have food. Like it's literally a 25 to 30%. They are because 30 % impact on our food.

Peter LewisMmm.

Fiona ScottHmm. Now we're real.

Peter Lewisand the food prices are going to go up. Fiona, one of the Fiona's is right on that. Can I just say one more thing that it showed? Like I think.

FionaIf you haven't worked out yet, Peter, the Fiona's are right on everything.

Fiona ScottHahahaha

Peter LewisYeah, particularly when they agree. So one more point here that I think the original sin has been the design of the tax and retrospectively changing a tax is hard. And it just makes me think as we, and this is like a random thing to throw out if anyone wants to take it up, they're welcome to it. But at the moment, we're about to sort of become the Saudi of data centers. Apparently, I really hope that we design it properly so we

Fiona ScottOkay.

Damian Damjanovskibirth of the Fiona party here at Live On Air.

Fiona Scottyou ⁓ yeah.

Peter LewisYou know, the populist line is all this, can't we have a Norwegian sovereign wealth fund? Let's, if we're going to do this, let's have a cultural data fund, like an Australian fund that's an ongoing income stream for the destruction that this technology is going to do to our workplace and our society.

Fiona ScottMm. Mm, 100%. Well, in your bleak, sorry. I was just going to say in your bleak picture that, know, Treasury, the bleak scenario that Treasury painted in the budget papers, like the other thing to think about in that is the job losses from AI, right? Which, you know, 10 to 30 percent ranges. Like, that's extraordinary. And it's just not being planned for. Just like housing isn't being appropriately planned for. Like, these things just aren't being. And, you know, I get the argument.

Damian DamjanovskiSo, you go Fiona, sorry.

Peter LewisNah.

Fiona ScottDon't know about, you know, now is not the right time or when is the right time, right? Like these companies are making extraordinary profits again now they made extraordinary profits during Ukraine. I think it just shows that our government are really bad negotiators, right? And I know that because I negotiated with them for the last four years, like they're terrible negotiators and it's like, you know, it's mutually assured destruction. They need our gas. We need the oil. Like, and you look at Japan and how much money Japan is making off Australian gas and now Singapore as well.

FionaIt's crazy.

Fiona ScottIt's nuts and I think we keep being told that we're a wealthy country and Australians don't feel wealthy they feel poor.

Damian DamjanovskiNo, I totally agree. So you're right, we don't feel wealthy other than when we look at our property holdings and we realize we have by far in the 1 % of the world. But let's put that to one side. The only thing I'd add to that Fiona that I think might be a point of consideration is one of the reasons a lot of people are outraged about the labor budget is because they feel like the rules of the game were changed and they were planning for a set of rules.

FionaMm.

Peter LewisHmm. you Mmm.

Fiona ScottYeah.

Damian DamjanovskiNow the rules of the game if you are saving up for five to ten years in order to buy a house, like the time scale on that is a 20 year time scale. If you're implementing a gas project somewhere in the middle of the ocean and you're trying to, and you you read up on how they do gas exploration, you know, they drill nine, ten times, nine of them are duds, one might be a hit. They plan in 50, 60 increments. So you can appreciate their side of the argument, which is...

Fiona ScottMm. Mm.

FionaMm.

Damian DamjanovskiWe have to work on horizons where we can't be subject to the whim of, you know, you're changing governments and changing views on this, that and the other, because we started this process 30 years ago and we need to realize 30 more years of gains of that, because that's the horizon that we work to. I guess I'm trying to put that hat on and go like there is an argument there as well of, you know, we don't want to be a country where it's like, well, we can't do with Australia because you never know what the fuck they're going to do next. Not saying that this is that.

Peter LewisHmm.

Fiona ScottHmm. Mm. Mm.

Damian DamjanovskiBut that is their argument and there is some merit to it, I guess.

Peter LewisSo, Damo, this show is not just about serious topics. We like to talk about fun things as well. So let's talk about the liberals. And look, thank you so much, you two, for letting me in the room last night. And I don't think I'm going to betray much. I'll just give you my short rundown. I thought, my Fiona, it was interesting. They were totally pumped up because they thought we've now got a fight to have. I think that There is a truth here, guys, that the last two election cycles have basically been campaigns against first Scott and then against Peter. Like they've been, the campaigns have been about your leader and this has actually put something that you can actually fight for. So that was my first thought. My second observation was you had, and this wasn't the main business fundraiser, this was one done and it was a really nice event down at Manukah. But there was Angus Taylor came and spoke, then Andrew Hastie, then Jacinta.

Fiona ScottOkay.

Peter Lewis⁓ and then, ⁓ Tim Wilson, thought Tim was the most like compelling of your speakers that night. but I also, but the one thing I thought was interesting and I don't know if it's a technical fact, but, but when Angus Taylor came and he said, conservatism is back. And it was like, I just think that's not the cause you guys are going populist and that's different to conservative. And I just felt like.

Damian DamjanovskiTim is a very compelling speaker.

Peter LewisHe's not quite sure who the enemy is at the moment. And you can see, I felt in the budget in reply, like get rid of net zero. Let's pull up the walls on immigration. ⁓ Let's keep the taxes the way they are. Like he's really looking at one nation rather than labor at the moment. Is that a fair assumption? Like I know that after the weekend, that's kind of the burning platform. I don't want to be unfair about this, but I said my first thing was, I think you've got a fight to have. I just don't know if fighting it on immigrant. Like if you were going there, because what Labour's actually done is start unwinding the Howard shareholder economy a little bit or rebalancing it. Like that is a fight you guys can have, but that's not what I'm hearing. I'm hearing all this other stuff.

Damian DamjanovskiIt's a good point and I'll hand over to my face Scott in a second. would add to that that the fight to be had, because all these fights are about framing, right? So either it's a fight or not depending on how you frame it. If it's framed around this is a desperate fight by the Labour government against Australian aspiration, because the Labour government wants us all to be salaried employees who one day join a union and don't aspire to anything more.

Fiona ScottOkay. Okay.

Damian Damjanovskithan being in a government owned house. that is a really good framing that we could work with. Cause that is a, it's really easy to draw the line from their chair. I'm worried about is that the parties, I don't say fear of Pauline, but the concern about Pauline is high enough that we've spent a lot of talk time talking about migration, forgetting that a huge component.

Peter LewisFight for that.

FionaThanks

Damian Damjanovskiof the Liberal Party membership and the people who vote Liberal, like myself, I'm an off the boat immigrant, I came here in 91, is immigrants who a lot of their extended family are here on permanent residency visas, right? That is something that I don't know how the calculus went into that, that we go hang on a minute, my cousin who's slowly waiting to become a citizen because the process is complete torture, you want to rob him of all his rights when he contributes tax? He's a good citizen, he's never been arrested, he doesn't do any bullshit. How about instead of that you take away the funds from the multi-generational citizens who do nothing but suck off the teat of the government? I would rather that. Because I tell you what, I don't meet a lot of immigrants who come to Australia to suck the teat. The migrants I meet, and I'm sorry, I know I'm not meant to talk anti-liberal as a liberal guy, but this one actually really riled me up because I'm like, nah, you don't attack migrants because we built this fucking country.

FionaThank Hmm.

Fiona ScottYeah. Yeah.

Peter Lewisyou you

Damian DamjanovskiLike, ⁓ as it currently stands, we've physically built this country, we've made it into what it is, we come here to work, to pay our taxes, and to enjoy a life free of conflict and free of interracial conflict. Do not pull that away from me.

Peter LewisYou

Fiona ScottYes. Yes.

Peter LewisHey, it's so interesting. Albo spoke at this Chifley research thing today and he sort of came in and it was mainly like reading a speech, but he went off speech and got really animated around. Angus Taylor is saying there's Australians and there's migrants. I think it is, I think there is something that's going to roll out. That's going to be quite damaging.

Fiona Scott⁓ yeah. Very.

Damian DamjanovskiNo, no, there is, and I'm telling you Peter, and again, I'll hand over to my Fiona in a second, because sorry, I think I need to get this out. And a lot of my mates are either fresh immigrants or first or second generation immigrants who've done nothing but hire people, create businesses, and help, you know, do the best for their kids and family. This genuinely pisses me off, and it's anti-liberal, it's anti-Mensian, and I fucking hate that we're going down this path because it is idiotic. It is genuinely idiotic. Sorry, Fiona.

FionaWell, thank you. Um... Great. There you go, it's being fed.

Fiona ScottThis is a bit harder than the gas tax one I got.

Damian DamjanovskiSorry.

Peter LewisYou've got no official role in the Liberal Party, just let loose Fiona, no one's listening.

FionaSo I read this book the other d-

Damian DamjanovskiYou

FionaYeah, I read this book the other day. It was great. Can I talk to you about the wine that I've got? I think this is a bottle of wine. Isn't that great? It's from Lake George. It's like in the Canberra area. Well, was that a good distraction?

Peter LewisThrow in another glass, you're mixing it with the gin.

Damian DamjanovskiYou No, that's a good distraction. Sorry, I didn't mean to put you on the spot, Fiona. This is one that has genuinely riled me up.

FionaNo, look, I can appreciate, right, and try not to get myself limped in the process, I can appreciate the sentiment to a point as to what is driving all of this. And Labor have had the Greens for a long time and have worked out how to navigate that relationship. The Liberal Party, on the other hand, has, and I don't mean to insult your boss, Fiona, but...

Peter Lewistrina whales.

Fiona ScottThank you.

FionaI look at certain things that David Pocock says around small business and hunting even and you know I'm probably going to have to a lot of liberals by saying this but Menzian liberals would have had a place for somebody like a David Pocock. Now, ⁓ I've also found a challenge the word conservative. What is it to be conservative? Why would you create Raspberry Conserve? Because there's something valuable that you want to save. can see it's actually a positive thing. ⁓ Even David's position around.

Fiona ScottThanks.

Fionaconservation and his net zero positions, you know, that there's reasons because you want to leave things for future generations. So the liberals might sit there and say things, you know, we're leaving a budget for future generations and blah, blah, blah. Why can you say that about a financial thing, but you can't say it about conservation, which is a similar thing. And so I think there's a challenge for the Liberal Party right now to

Fiona ScottYeah. Mm.

Peter LewisMm.

Damian DamjanovskiMmm.

Fionayou know, this view of do you go left or do you go right? I don't think politics is left or right. I think it's an orb. I think it's a sphere. And I think really, if you keep going to the left, you end up to the right. If you keep going to the greens, you end up at Pauline Hanson. And there's sometimes there's places where you see they get to the same point from completely different angles. And it's not so. you know, I think there's this piece for the Liberal Party.

Fiona Scottyou

Fionawhen you've had a lot of the moderate smaller liberal spaces to have been lost to Teals and to, you know, the David Pococks of this world, but then now you've got Pauline Hanson on the other side. So one school of thought is, well, do you have to race to the bottom of the world of where Pauline Hanson is to try and get that vote back or, then forget about the Teal vote. But if you go there, you're never getting the Teal vote back. So.

Fiona ScottMm. Exactly.

FionaIt's this existential crisis of ideology as to who you are. And I think what I saw this week from liberals and even people who I think traditionally may have identified as conservatives, they're not conservatives, some of these people I'd call nationalists, ⁓ sort of sitting there saying, particularly where Angus was on Wednesday morning when he was coming out hard on the economic messaging. that it was actually straight into the sweet spot of where the Liberal Party should be. And the other miscalculation I think that's happened, particularly maybe even from the Labor Party, is if you look at the FARA results, which has shaken the large organisational parties to the core. Inexperienced Labor people will go, well, this is an existential crisis for the Liberal Party and the National Party. See you later. Thanks for coming. That's bullshit.

Fiona ScottMm.

Peter LewisAgree, agree.

FionaThe Liberal Party received baseball pats on the part of the Labor Party, the Uni Party. And I think there's a degree of hubris in ⁓ Labor's budget this week and the way Labor have behaved, not realizing that the belting that the Liberal Party is copying right now is actually coming for them too. And so they might see it happening to the Liberal Party, but it's actually coming from them in their primary vote as well.

Damian Damjanovski⁓ yeah.

FionaSo when you come down to this sort of policy area, Damo, there's people trying to navigate what those things mean. I mean, I can appreciate because of people trying to get into houses as to why and where a policy for like that comes from. There's probably a couple of visa classes I would have maybe added. But I probably, I'd probably don't do that because I don't want to get myself into trouble what I would say in criticizing anything. But, but I do understand why people

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Fiona Scottyou

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Fionafeel the way they do about those things and when your taxes are going up and you can't afford anything, you can't get into houses, it's a matter of just finding where that point is again and hence why you're seeing some of these things come out.

Damian DamjanovskiAnd I do see as much as I have my anger on that approach, I do see that a lot of the people out there don't know who to blame. And not saying that it's easy to blame immigrants, but they see more migrants now than they ever have seen.

Peter LewisHmm. ⁓

Damian Damjanovskiand they naturally ask the question, well, how can they afford to live here? Where are they living? Do we have enough houses for them? Are they clogging up my this, that and the other? ⁓ I don't think that's necessarily a great view. I don't think it's necessarily a fair and balanced view, but I do respect the fact that there's anger on the other side as well. Looking for someone to blame.

Fiona ScottSo on.

Peter LewisCan we go to my Fiona? Like, so let's talk about the teals and the independence. I know that David's not an officially a teal, but if you were gonna do a poster boy for the vibe, don't call me teal. They've actually got a branding problem.

Fiona ScottDon't call him too. ⁓ He left the C200 mothership. He left the mothership. That's over. Yeah. Correct.

Damian DamjanovskiIsn't he? Well, I'm pretty sure he took the teal money.

Peter LewisHe didn't need them anymore. They threw him out of the nest and he flew. But what's your take? Like, so you've worked inside labor and now you've worked with a community independent, let's call him, and a growing network. What is your take on their impact on the politics? Not so much using the Liberal Party as a reference point, but the parliament as a reference

Fiona Scottthink they are having an impact and I think on a lot of issues, know, David and others on the crossbench end up being the effective opposition, right? And he's also, you know, leading the charge on key issues and working collaboratively with the coalition, with the Greens on, for example, aged care, right? Like we have made Sam Ray's life absolute hell and deservedly so because the, you know, the state of aged care in this country is appalling and the you know, hiding things and behaving, you releasing the Murphy review on Budget Day, releasing the Aged Care Waitlist report on Budget Day when everyone was in lockup. That's outrageous and that pisses people off. Like punters see that and they hate that dishonesty. And I think, you know, the other point that, you know, something that David and Senator Hanson don't have a lot in common, but, ⁓ you know, one of the things that I think voters like about both of them is they know what they stand for. There's these values, right? There's this, you know, and I think with the major parties and particularly maybe the coalition, there's a bit of a what do you stand for and are you consistent in your values? And I just want to pick an example. I don't want to be mean, but I just want to pick an example from budgeting reply that goes to housing. So one of the things that Mr. Taylor said is that he would get rid of Housing Australia, right? Housing Australia was set up by the coalition government. Like it was called something different, but you guys set it up. And one of the reasons that housing in this country is such a mess is because the policy keeps changing, like on all these changes of government, right? So I just think it's so frustrating that there can't be some more ⁓ multi-partisanship on some of these really fundamental issues. And I guess, my question for the Liberal Party is what are you doing? Like, is your strategy to not lose seats to One Nation or is it to try and win back seats off the tails? Like, what is the plan?

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Peter LewisHmm.

Damian DamjanovskiIt's very bold of you Fiona Scott to assume that there's a plan.

Peter LewisCan I ask one more question on the tails just before we roll it? So I, I, you know, I welcomed the tails with open arms because they destroyed your government. Um, but I also have reservations that individuals that are like, if you replicate that out and you have lots of small parties and lots of independencies, such a complex system that I think it's too much to ask individuals to run.

Fiona ScottBecause we have a plan. Let me tell you. Mm.

FionaYes, but our system was designed to be like that.

Peter LewisSo I just don't like, what's your sense of like the cognitive overload of all these elected reps just must be on 11. Like where there's not the networks and the structures around them that either the labor or the liberal governments would have or even the oppositions would have. Like, is it just an interruption or is it a future operating principle of politics, my friend?

Damian Damjanovskiyou

Fiona ScottYeah. Well, that's our challenge for 2028, right? Are there ⁓ more community independents after the 2028 election or less? Because it's going to be a defining moment for the independent movement as well. ⁓

Damian DamjanovskiYeah, I think if I can add in there, it's a really fascinating thing. So like, you know, I'm a liberal guy and you know, I love the party. But first and foremost, I consider myself Australian and you know, I love our democracy more than I love the party. I would agree with what Fiona said, which is honestly in a in a normal world where the Liberal Party had all of its eggs and ducks in a row.

Fiona ScottMm.

Damian DamjanovskiDavid Pocock would fall within the Liberal Party as would most of the Teals as we know, right? As would parts of what is now One Nation because by design the Liberal Party is a big tent party that is meant to have fundamental values around things like personal responsibility paired with personal freedoms and where possible get government the fuck out of your life and I still hold by the founding principle that

Fiona ScottMm.

Damian DamjanovskiI believe most Australians, if given the choice, would like the government not to be in their life unless absolutely necessary. And I think that's one of the huge points of difference between the liberal principles, which is a liberal school of thought where we can have many different ideas about how to get there, with some common values which is government is not the answer to everything. We do not need government to intervene because government's like a big opioid. We take it once and then we're hooked on it. We want government to fix every one of our problems, but in reality, government kind of can't.

Fiona Scottyou

Damian DamjanovskiSo I agree with you Fiona that yeah, like these community independents and these teals are a signal of something. I'm just not sure if the signal is.

Fiona ScottYeah, but I think

Peter LewisIs it the same? Is it the is it the same signal, Fiona, as one nation? Like are they different signals or are they the same signal?

Fiona ScottNo, well, so Paul Murray made a really interesting point on election night by election night in Farah where he said one of the things that got One Nation over the line. No, no, I didn't think I'd ever say them. I'm not saying that. He's lovely. ⁓ Is ⁓ the volunteers, right? So they were able to mobilize an absolute volunteer army in Farah and they were deeply motivated volunteers. And that's what community independents do. And that's why they've been successful is

Peter LewisI've never heard those words in the same sentence before, but go on.

Fiona Scottable to, you know, we had 2,200 volunteers in 22 and it was phenomenal. And that's, that is how you change hearts and minds is with those conversations and those volunteers. So, and I think what people like about the community independence is that they feel like these people are working really hard for them. They're not rolling out the lines of the day. They're not rolling out the talking points. They're getting stuck in and they're generally representing. genuinely representing their communities on really key issues. Like we see this in the ACT all the time, where David will go out really hard on something because people have come to him and been like, this is stopped, like you need to do something here. Whereas the three law house labor reps will be like, ⁓ I can't possibly say boo. And actually you probably could.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

Fiona ScottBut, you know, and it's only ever, to your point, Damo, it's only ever been a liberal senator who's, you know, crossed the floor to back one of David's bills or one of David's motions.

Peter LewisYour better half looks like he's getting close to it, Fiona.

Damian DamjanovskiBut but but Fiona that's kind of the point right is like and I'm not trying to like shit on the Labour Party for no reason but but Labour votes as a caucus right? Labour is militant about its caucus voting and and the whole point of the Liberal Party is you can vote your view you can have a dissenting view from the whole and so again I think we're saying the same thing which is in the past when people wanted someone who represented them from the community they put them up as a Liberal candidate

Peter LewisYou

Fiona Scott⁓ Tribal.

Damian DamjanovskiAnd somewhere we've lost that, where we've over-professionalized our candidates and our whole process to the point where we're no longer representing the community, we're now representing, I don't even know where the pipeline is for the Liberal Party these days, but you know what mean, the law graduates from the University of Sydney, which are little clones of one another. anyway.

Fiona ScottYes. you you

Peter Lewisfeel like, particularly because we stuffed up the recording, because I started off in Old Parliament House and there was no Wi-Fi, we've kept you guys a long time. We normally, I don't know if we even warned you, we normally finish this off with predictions for the week ahead. So we might just do that cold. I'll start off though, something very interesting happened today and I'm not sure if it'll be next week or the week after, but Pope Leo has signed his in sick.

Fiona Scottyou

FionaGeez, I haven't even thought about that. ⁓

Peter Lewisencyclical on AI, which is going to be a really big deal in the Catholic Church, but also it's a big deal of his papacy. He named himself after the original Pope, Leo did an encyclical on the Industrial Revolution, which was, you know, about the dignity of labor, but also the sanctity of property. wasn't like the communist, it wasn't like a Jim Chalmers budget, if you believe the telegraph, but I'm really interested to see a how he lands it, because he's been really critical of the use of automated weapons in war. And he's also been pushing back hard on Trump. So I'd be interested how this South Side Chicago Padre who's ended up in the Vatican is going to frame the AI debate, because I think we all need some guidance on that.

Fiona ScottYes.

Damian DamjanovskiI don't know if you know this Peter, but they did a big conference over in the US, a ⁓ theological conference to discuss what religion AI would be and they settled that apparently AI is Buddhist. Buddhist is the religion. Now obviously not all religions turned up for various reasons. ⁓ Now Klaus didn't go, but there were a few sects that, but like, know, the Mormons showed up, the Orthodox showed up, the Catholics showed up.

Peter LewisDid Klaus go?

Fiona ScottOkay.

Damian DamjanovskiThe Jews didn't because then they'd have to shut off the AI every Saturday, which is not a great way to run AI. ⁓ But no one came from the Islamic sects, but it was basically a discussion about ⁓ what religion artificial intelligence would be. And the most settled on answer was, in fact, Buddhist because it's non-material.

Fiona ScottHuh. Okay.

Peter LewisAI is an expression of atheism. think there is no morality or godliness in it. Anyway, we can either talk about that or your predictions, whatever you want.

FionaTIK TIK

Damian DamjanovskiI'll give you my prediction first and I'll hand over to the Fiona's.

FionaWell did you see, sorry just on your point, sorry Damo, but did you see, I think it was last week or the week before about Gabby, the robot that's just taken their vows to be a Buddhist monk?

Damian DamjanovskiNo! See?

Peter LewisNo, but I will have to look into it and put it on burning platforms next week. That's my other podcast that I keep saying.

FionaMmm.

Fiona Scottyou

FionaYeah, so...

Damian Damjanovski⁓ Mark? I'm going to make a bold prediction for this coming week, Mr. Lewis, ⁓ which is that I think now that ⁓ Trump has left China, I think that the Strait of Hormuz will be open to free trade as of next week. By the end of next week, my guess is that there has an agreement has somehow been made to open up the Strait of Hormuz for trade indefinitely.

Peter LewisWell, hopefully that's a better prediction than last week's, which was that the Teals would win Farah. But just saying.

Fiona ScottHey, she increased her primary.

Damian DamjanovskiHahaha

FionaHa ha ha!

Peter LewisMy Fiona, we got a prediction for the week. What's in David's diary? What's going on?

Damian Damjanovski⁓

Fiona ScottLook, I think next week's going to be very much about, ⁓ know, gas will continue, but there's going to be a bit of a pivot towards gambling and gambling advertising ban and how we can ⁓ influence the legislation before it hits parliament in September. So keep your eye out for a particularly pointy letter.

Damian DamjanovskiDoes David just hate fun?

Peter LewisAre you gonna do your defensive slapping now? Like we've got a couple of minutes.

Fiona Scottyou

Damian DamjanovskiI was tempted to, but this is one of those things that I do not understand why we need to, like why government needs to get involved. Like let us have some bloody freedom. Yeah, just let us have some freedoms.

Fiona ScottGambling advertising. You can punt as much as you want, but people need to stop committing suicide, like, because they are absolutely being hounded to death by gambling companies. You know, it's all about the inducements. It's all about people who are self-excluding. you know, mean, Ladbroke's breached BetStop 500 times. Like, this... It's a really serious issue. And for people who do have gambling addiction, gambling advertising is so poisonous and it's so poisonous for our young people. And again, it's something that is not a left or right issue. It cuts across party lines. know, there is such a huge ⁓ percentage of people in the community who don't want to see gambling advertising bans and Peter Dutton's policy on this was stronger than what Albo has put forward. like, it's just we're in this weird space and it's got to change.

Damian DamjanovskiYeah.

FionaBut I think it's because organised sport and things like that are such a powerful lobby because they're completely funded by it. But they were able to break away from tobacco back in the day. You're right. Peter Dutton was very strong on this.

Fiona ScottYep, go to break the nexus.

Peter LewisSo.

Damian DamjanovskiAlso disagree with- I also disagree with that!

Fiona ScottSorry, on that quickly, can I just say, can I just say it's 4.1 billion demo, the tobacco excise. 4.1. One year. So PRT 1.4, tobacco 4.1.

Peter LewisYou

Damian DamjanovskiThat was just one year. That's one year.

Peter LewisOI That. ⁓ wow. Fiona to prediction before we close off.

Fiona⁓ well, I'm kind of lost in liberal land, so I think we'll be discussing our existential crisis for the next week.

Fiona ScottCan we predict the next president?

Peter LewisLike it's like Groundhog Day. Hey, this has been a great discussion. I feel like we should just bugger off and do a weekly podcast with the two Fiona Scots. I reckon that could go off big time, dammit.

Damian DamjanovskiScott on Scott.

FionaYeah.

Damian DamjanovskiIt's also because you both have first names that are last names, which makes it like extra confusing, like it's compounding levels of confusion. ⁓ Thank me.

FionaDo you have brothers? Yeah.

Fiona ScottMe? I'm a brother.

Peter LewisWhat? You don't have a Scott Scott, do you?

FionaBecause, no because, no no no because the amount of times that people go, ⁓ I spoke to Scott the other day and I'm like Scott, that's my brother, no your brother and I'm like, hmm that's not his name. But the amount of times that my, like people say they've been speaking to my brother and I spoke to Scott and I was just wondering Fiona if you copped the same about your brother with having a surname as a first name.

Peter LewisScotty! Scotty!

Damian DamjanovskiScott Scott

Fiona ScottYeah.

Peter LewisAnyway, it's like we've worked out it's good to have an evil twin. I reckon you two are now officially evil twins as well. So go forth and enjoy, enjoy the adversity, adversary.

Fiona ScottSadly, they're.

FionaNo

Fiona Scott⁓

Damian DamjanovskiWelcome to the club.

Fiona ScottThanks for having us.

Damian DamjanovskiSo I just want to say a big thank you to both Fiona Scott for having us Peter Lewis as always. Thank you. It is always a pleasure talking to you. We all love these conversations. If you're listening at home, please ⁓ subscribe and share the podcast wherever you find it with your mates because we want to keep doing this indefinitely. Both Fiona's you're always welcome back.

FionaThank you.

Peter LewisYeah, we had a couple of random people come up saying they were listening to it last night, too. So there is more than just you and me.

Damian Damjanovskinear celebrity status. Yeah, no, it's great. I look forward to our chat next week, by which time hopefully the Australia Formals is open. Absolutely. Thanks everyone. Appreciate you.

FionaMm-hmm.

Peter LewisAnd I will have these guys back again for sure. Yeah. Take guys.

Fiona ScottThank you.

FionaBye.