Episode 7
Capital Gains, Enhanced Games, and AI Pains
Show notes
The budget one week on, CG and the media/political class response, hypocrisy and political posturing. The inaugural enhanced games and what it means for athletes. The impact of data centres and AI .
Takeaways
- Budget and Taxation
- Media and Political Class
- Hypocrisy and Political Posturing Political dynamics between parties
- Impact of AI on society
Chapters
- 00:00 Introduction and Poison Choices
- 06:28 Taxation and Budgetary Measures
- 22:56 Media Bias and Political Hypocrisy
- 30:26 Hierarchy of Disdain for Political Figures
- 58:26 AI Impact
Full transcript
Read itHide it
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.
Damian DamjanovskiWelcome to What's Your Poison? The weekly podcast where people who disagree over pretty much everything agree that it's better to do so over a drink. My name is Damian Damianowski. I'm a director here at General Strategic and my evil twin here is Mr. Peter Lewis. Peter, happy Friday and what is your poison?
Peter LewisHappy Friday, Dame. ⁓ I am drinking a Crispy Boy Lager from the ⁓ Milton-Ula-Ula region where I choose to spend as much time as I can. And I've also got a few leftover olives that have got chilli in the middle of it. So if I keep over at any stage, you will know why. How's your week been and what's your poison?
Damian DamjanovskiOoh, that's why. It's been an interesting week. I'll start with my poison first, cause it's a particularly odd drop. So this way, as usual, I've got a whiskey with me. ⁓ but this week is a Swiss Alpine whiskey called Santis malt, which sounds like it would be garbage coming from Switzerland, but it is incredibly good. It is matured in old oak beer cask. is sweet, smoky. ⁓ and it's one of the best whiskies I've had in recent memory. I'm.
Peter LewisI don't think the Swiss have got a reputation for whiskey today.
Damian DamjanovskiThat's what I thought as well, but apparently it's a, it's a cottage industry over there, which pretty much everything in Switzerland is. So I'm very delighted to be drinking it and more delighted at the fact that we have our colleagues, Juliana Burgess and Peter Stahl joining us this week again. So welcome back to Jules and to Mr. Stahl. What is your poisons?
Peter StahelAlright.
Julianna Burgess⁓ Hey, Starla, you go first.
Peter StahelI've got a pipsqueak. Yeah, little creatures pip squeak.
Damian Damjanovskicreatures that one right.
Julianna Burgess⁓ and you've got some little creatures behind you as well.
Damian DamjanovskiSome teddy bears there.
Peter StahelYes. ⁓ they just hear the... Yeah, that's right. I'm coming out as a furry.
Peter LewisWhat's the teddy bear shtick there? Is it identity related or?
Damian DamjanovskiYou know how Matt Canavan always has the screen in the background with like some subliminal message? So the teddy bears is your subliminal message.
Peter LewisYou Make Australia great again.
Peter StahelNo, we're having a slumber party themed ⁓ house party in the next couple of weeks. So this is part of the decorations ⁓ that I've been ⁓ collecting in the lead up. ⁓ My week has been pretty quiet actually, which has led to a lot of doom scrolling. We can talk about that later.
Damian DamjanovskiHow exciting. You're a exciting. Jules, what's your poison this week?
Julianna BurgessThis week, as always, I have a lovely drop of white wine. This time it is a Tim Adams Pinot Gris, which is a little bit darker than usual. It's almost bordering on a rosé, I reckon. And I've got some greenery in the background, like the true liberal that I am. There you go.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, looking at all our shots, we're all very black and white.
Peter LewisWhat a greenery. Why do leaves have a greenery in the background? that like that just makes it? Yeah.
Julianna BurgessI'm being ironic. I'm being ironic. So we hate nature.
Peter StahelAre they real?
Damian DamjanovskiNow, obviously last week we, last week we had our guests, Fiona Scott and Fiona Scott straight after the budget and budget and reply. ⁓ Mr. Lewis this week we've, we've, we've seen the budgets kind of start to settle in a little bit. We've seen the media and different cohorts start to find their feet on a position on the budget. I I don't think it's particularly worth talking about budget and reply as it never really is. Cause it's a, one of those hypothetical things of
Peter LewisThat's plastic trays. Hmm.
Damian DamjanovskiIf we were in government, this is how we do things, but it's not an election year, it essentially doesn't matter. So let's just focus on the budget. What's your read on how A, the media class and the political class have taken the budget and B, as a poll star, where do you reckon the pundits are sitting on the budget at the moment?
Peter LewisMmm. pundits or the punters? Because we're the pundits and like we never get it right.
Damian DamjanovskiThe punters. Sorry, the punters. English is my second language, you have to forgive me the occasional mix-up.
Peter LewisSo the way I'm actually looking at this budget and I'm sort of, in the field at the moment. So I don't know what the punters think of that. We can talk about some of the polls. I'm thinking about the idea of asymmetrical warfare, right? So normally the budget is two major powers who are one of them is government, one of them's opposition. And so we give our budget, we give our budget and supply. They could sort of cancel each other out. And then the show moves on as if nothing happened.
Julianna BurgessMmm. Mmm.
Peter LewisThe difference is it feels I'm not going to say it feels like Iran, but it's a major power that is the government. There's no effective opposition. There's all these little drones sort of going around and it's that they're not actually going after the budget. They're going after budgety things and ⁓ causing all sorts of mischief. And I don't think and I think it's a different ⁓ challenge than normally you're mostly worried about experts. And this time, the ⁓
Julianna BurgessMm.
Peter LewisThey're basically being undermined by AI-generated sloth, ⁓ which is this whole, which has been launched. Yeah, the sloth again, it's been launched by a guy who stood as a UAP candidate for Parma, who's admitted he decided to go for the meme over the truth. And ⁓ yeah, it's proving at least in terms of capturing attention. And I'm not just saying.
Damian Damjanovskiwhich has been very effective.
Julianna BurgessSloppy gander.
Peter Lewismedia attention, I've got reason to feel like it's cutting through a little bit as well. And I think there's a bit to talk about here coming off our discussion about what did, which, which of the many hills did the liberals want to fight this on? I actually think that fighting it on aspiration, know Jules has written a piece about this that we might get into later. It's probably the best place for the Libs to be, but the reality is they're a hugely weakened power. And I don't know if there's they can fight the war, but there is a disruption that is not unlike the kind of major power versus small incendiaries. So that's where I think it is at the moment.
Damian Damjanovski⁓ I might switch over to you Jules for a second, because I think you can look at this budget as very much trying to tackle tax on a few fronts, right? So there's obviously changes to negative gearing, changes to CGT, changes to discretionary trusts. There's a few different components in there. The coalition, meanwhile, in its budget and reply, floated a few balloons around, ⁓ you know, indexation on
Peter Lewisyou
Julianna BurgessMm.
Peter LewisThank
Damian DamjanovskiTax brackets, which is a big one that obviously needs to be costed because that removes a lot of money out of the budget, but then also changes on immigration numbers, changes on how we allow immigrants in based on how many houses we build as well as what we give immigrants. So it's like they flew a few balloons, but the one that seems to have landed, what would you say it is Jules?
Julianna BurgessYeah, well, I mean, we can look at the budget and reply, sure. But I think the one that's been the most salient is Tim Wilson's press club address in the week. And I think that really outlined, you know, the position that they're hoping to take through, which is that this budget is an assault on aspiration. mean, Pete mentioned that I wrote about this and I did. So I called this a triple whammy on Australians that want to build wealth for themselves, which case it is. Peter, I am interested to talk to you about the polling of what you've seen coming through from the public, but, you know, by all accounts, from what we've seen from the startup and entrepreneurial community, they are really feeling the brunt of what this is going to do to them. So I think the liberals, yeah, choosing aspiration and the assault on aspiration. Yeah, sure. But, you know, like it's a loud community that has to unfortunately be the ones to spearhead it because unfortunately there are, you know,
Damian DamjanovskiHmm.
Peter LewisIt's a pretty small community, like it's a lab community, but it's a pretty small community, isn't it? Notwithstanding that the tech council's already doing a deal on, but yeah.
Julianna BurgessYeah, do you know what I mean though? Like sure it might be, you know, the tech bros that are out there spearheading it all, but it is, you know, the single mum that's started a hairdresser salon that's going to be impacted as well. It's just they're maybe not the ones that have the platform to be able to speak as loudly.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Peter LewisBut so, yeah, I think that the bet that the Libs are taking is that this is a normal cohort and not a fringe group. ⁓ You know, the counter thing is on paper, a lot more people are going to be better off if that money goes into tax cuts than people that are taking the concession. So there's this.
Julianna BurgessYeah.
Peter LewisSo I think it'll play out over the long term. where I think it has worked for you guys, you have not had a story for young people for a long time. And at least you're giving it a shot, right? At least you're giving it a shot.
Julianna BurgessYeah. Yeah. And some of like some of the people that have come out, you know, speaking about how they're worried as an entrepreneur, it is the 29 year old Rachel Wild, who started TBH skincare when she was 25. Like it's not just who you'd sort of picture as the big end of town Scott Farquhar Atlassian types. It is more than just sort of that typical liberal base, which I think is really good.
Peter Lewisyou So it's sort of people that the bed is there are enough people that would like to be the person like that that you can actually build a counter narrative. And look, I thought the other interesting thing was for all the time at the press club on Wednesday, he didn't mention immigration, I think once. So that's not where. Yeah. ⁓
Julianna BurgessExactly. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiNot even once, No, that's a balloon that they didn't want to.
Julianna BurgessYes. Yeah, that's what I mean. I think it's moving away from that. And I think it's important to look at that Tim Wilson speech is how they actually do want to set it up going forward.
Damian DamjanovskiSo, so, so from a political perspective, I think it makes sense that the more the coalition can make this not just about startups and tech bros who are, you know, starting online businesses and then selling them for hundreds of millions, if not billions of dollars, the more they can rope in small businesses into this narrative, the more defensible the position becomes. I think
Julianna BurgessYeah. Yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiIf it becomes just tech bros versus the government, your average punter doesn't really care about that fight.
Julianna BurgessMm.
Peter LewisBut, know, there is another bit, the Daniel Petri. Sorry, we'll bring Pete, my pet in a sec. Sorry about this. But Daniel Petri, who is a very successful fund manager and startup guy, saying this is all bullshit. This is Trumpian. Like even if you are paying more in tax, like the government provides the services that gives you your start and your startup. And so that's where there will be an interesting debate on values. And I think we said last week, Dharmay, that
Julianna BurgessSorry.
Peter LewisWhat this budget is significant and it will have a longer shelf life because it is actually attacking the shareholder society that Howard created and it's trying to create a different society that's more balanced in the interests of wage owners. And so there is a legitimate debate. ⁓
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, but, but, it is worth pointing out there. Sorry. And Peter Stahl, I'm curious on your view on this, but there is a, it is worth pointing out that those startups and those small businesses are still paying tax and will still continue to contribute taxes through income taxes, like everyone else using the systems that help employing people. ⁓ the question is whether or not the government in
Peter LewisOkay. you
Julianna Burgessemploying people who pay tax. Yeah.
Peter Lewiswhen they have a payday, how much they pay.
Damian DamjanovskiWhen they have a payday, given that they're the ones who take the government has not assisted in the risk component. The government has not gone, you know what? We're going to back you. Here's a hundred grand interest free. Go start your startup. And if we lose the money, we lose the money. Right.
Peter LewisBut often there is government startup support. Sorry, I just have my chili.
Damian Damjanovski⁓ the vast majority of these guys aren't plugging into those, primarily pretty piss poor, ⁓ government initiatives to like help startups, but Pete style thoughts.
Peter LewisThat's hot. Ahem.
Peter StahelWell, the rhetoric and the politics of the argument is brilliant, but the and I think the Libs are just counting on the fact that it won't matter that the policy is nonsense. This is just such a small group of people. But the problem is, I think for Labor here is that it is going to land with what is a pretty large group of people in the middle who think of tax as a punitive thing and that loopholes and discounts and structures and ⁓ similar tax minimization measures are what smart people do. ⁓ so that aspiration landscape is a safe place to be because you never have to prove it doesn't apply to people. You can just say, this won't be available to you.
Damian DamjanovskiYes, this is like basically people if the government came out and said, ⁓ we're going to we're going to tax lottery winnings as of tomorrow. Even though the vast majority of people aren't going to win the lottery. The idea of it annoys them.
Peter StahelYeah. And in some cases there ought to be better on the lottery, I'd say.
Peter LewisAnd to be fair, we've for decades tried to construct winning public narratives to actually call out the bullshit of tax concessions. And it's so hard, isn't it, Peter? Like people...
Damian DamjanovskiWhy is it this hard?
Peter Stahel⁓ Well, partly what I just explained, there's a self interest test and it extends beyond the self interest of the current reality. It's what, you know, I aspire to be someone that gets ahead. I aspire to be someone that could access these loopholes and tricks that other people who have invested smartly and done the right thing or done, you know, invested sensibly. And because most people don't really know what CGT is or even negative gearing. ⁓ there's a tendency to think, ⁓ maybe that could be something that I could access in the future.
Damian Damjanovskibeing a nation of punters we're just taking a gamble that one day I might get
Peter Lewis⁓ Yeah, we are this wildly optimistic society in a way. It's kind of that American thing. was that famous West Wing line that was like, the problem is everyone thinks they're going to be the person using it one day. people are more likely to think that they're going to be ⁓ using, well, I think first they don't actually understand what family trusts are, but they think they're going to. succeed rather than need welfare and social housing. So there's a lot less support for those things than there is for maintaining.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Which is ironic, obviously, because statistically people are more likely to need social services than they're ever going to need to rely. So the real winners here, can we agree, is probably going to be accountants and lawyers who help people set up. Because they're going to get a lot of new business going, how do I do one of these trust fund things that I keep hearing?
Peter LewisYeah, at some point in their life, you
Julianna BurgessYeah. and migration agents for people planning on leaving.
Damian DamjanovskiYep.
Peter LewisJust ⁓ a dirty secret, both Peter and we run our companies through family trusts so we know how it works, which we.
Damian Damjanovski⁓
Julianna BurgessI was gonna say we're all involved in businesses here. So like we should be the ones that are feeling the brunt of this, right?
Peter LewisBut because I know how it works and I don't use all the tools at my disposal, I might add, like I'm not distributing the income amongst my children or anything, but it is outrageous. And if people knew how they work, there would be revolution on the streets, but it's just like they don't.
Damian DamjanovskiNah, completely. So, so, all right, taking a step back and looking at the politics of this, we've seen that Albo now may actually need to walk back some of these changes on discretionary trusts, because there's been a very clever political positioning of this as potentially a bit of a death tax and nothing is more toxic in Australian politics than the idea of a death tax of the government taking things from you after you die and stealing it off your children.
Julianna BurgessHmm
Damian Damjanovski⁓ how was this political calculus not made on the labor side of the fence? How was this not seen early on carved out?
Julianna BurgessYeah.
Peter LewisMm-hmm.
Julianna BurgessI'm, I'm, yeah, I'm curious about this too. Sorry to cut you off there. I'm curious, just in general, the consultation process across a whole heap of cohorts seems to have been really lackluster. Like how is the startup and entrepreneurial community not consulted more thoroughly as we just talking about before. just, feel like I'm confused as to how, yeah, how it happened. The mechanics.
Peter LewisBye! I think they saw the main game as housing. And I think, like most people, they're not as embedded in the world of tax minimization as probably the Liberal Party is. So they didn't see as many things coming. Can I just say on death tax, you know that we had estate taxes
Damian DamjanovskiSo they should have consulted with the Liberal Party first, just to understand how these trusts and...
Julianna BurgessHahaha
Peter Lewisup until the 80s and Joe Biochi-Peterson bought them in in Queensland because he wanted all the retirees to come and die in Queensland as a tax dodge. And then instead of the other states going, go, they all said, we'll match it to keep you old people here so we can do it too. It was the most bizarre bit of ⁓ tax policy I've ever seen. now most countries have an estate tax, but we have made it untouchable.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, it's a, we have.
Peter LewisIf you want a fairer society, of course there should be a contribution back. Like, why should the kids of someone get everything and there's no contribution to the state? I don't get it.
Damian DamjanovskiBut Peter Starr, explain to me how any of these budgetary measures are sensible policy to get more housing on the market. That's the name of the game here. And where I keep coming back to is the government must have known that it was going to have to eat shit over this budget. And if they had to eat shit, why are they nibbling? Why are they not doing it? Like just eat the fucking sandwich.
Peter LewisHow about, yeah, because you've got such a majority, right?
Peter StahelWell, just on the traps that weren't spotted that you were mentioning earlier, mean, those are the things they didn't fly kites on. And that's why governments fly kites and lead up to a budget. They want to make sure they've checked their blind spots. And you can't necessarily do that in groups or with polling. So testing it in a live, contested, media or stakeholder environment allows governments to kind of iron some of that stuff out. I wouldn't be surprised if the legislation genuinely hadn't been written yet, or at least was in its very early stages. ⁓
Damian DamjanovskiSurely they've been thinking about this for longer than a couple of weeks though, they knew the budget's coming up, they've got an agenda.
Peter StahelI think they'd be feeling pretty pleased with themselves at the moment, to be honest. mean, yes, they didn't know they were going to have to eat shit. And I think thus far things are fairly tame and potentially resolved with some, narratives killed anyway, with some tweaks at the edges.
Julianna BurgessMm-hmm.
Damian DamjanovskiDo you think from a government perspective, having to walk back on one measure, for example, a carve out for death or estate taxes, would they consider this budget a win if that was the only thing they had to walk back?
Peter Stahel⁓ they won't know if the budget's a win for some time yet.
Peter LewisI still think structurally it's a significant change and it gives labor something to believe in. And I reckon they will. do agree. There's probably, I think there might be a tech bro carve out. There's this argument that, you know, there's two things there. There's the founders that make a squeal in dollars and they can pay their taxes. There's those that are working for low wages in terms in return. for share options inside some of the startups. So think they're having a bit of a look at that.
Peter StahelYeah, there's a much, I think there's a much more powerful thing at play than the specifics of the policy and how many new houses are going to be built and how much price is going to come down and how many new homeowners are going to be in the market, which I think doesn't really get through to many people. But I think what does get through is a shift in positioning from everything's fine to, ⁓ no, we accept there's an emergency now and things need to be.
Peter Lewisyou
Peter Staheldealt with as if there's an emergency. And I think that's what we'll probably be getting through to people at this point. The trap in that for the government, though, of course, is that if the audiences thereafter to firm up with these policies don't see a meaningful difference at some point between now and halfway through the next term, there'll be another whole new group of people that will be saying,
Damian DamjanovskiHmm.
Julianna BurgessMm.
Peter LewisMm.
Peter Stahel⁓ well, we haven't tried this lot. Let's give them a go.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Well, cause the, and again, my follow up question to that is in which case who's the winner from this budget? Cause the only handout is the, what is it? The waiter, whatever they're calling it. So there's a $250 tax offset, which is basically going to get gobbled up by inflation.
Julianna Burgesswhich doesn't come until 2028 anyway, right? So it's not like it's gonna be an immediate.
Peter LewisHasn't Chama's calculated up to 3,000 or something?
Damian DamjanovskiI think that's over a ⁓ very large forward estimate. So who's the winner here? Who's this budget designed for? Who is it meant to be winning over?
Julianna Burgess10 year period. So over a 10 year period. So 3000 in 10 years.
Peter LewisYeah. Yeah, yeah. I think it's meant to be changing the broader narrative of what labor is there to do. Is it just there to manage the status quo or is it there to change things? And being attacked is actually good because it sends the signal that you are doing something. And I did think there's a real risk if labor just manages, particularly at a time that we're moving into a financial downturn, then that scenario gives someone else a go. So why are they there? So they are there to change the structure of the balance in Australian society. And then, you know, the closer you get to the centre of labour, the more excited they are about this budget. I think for their challenge is to, you know, out the wrinkles. But they're also they've done something that's hard. And the fact that they've been bashed. is kind of like for people looking at out of the corner of their eye, proof that it's hard. ⁓ Can we just say, just on that media, like News Limited ⁓ has been pretty feral. Chris Warren wrote it, who's the former national secretary of the MEAA and a great, man. He's writing media for Crikey now. He did point out that News Corp's controlling share of the REA group is its largest income stream in Australia.
Damian Damjanovskiit's proof that it's worth fighting for.
Julianna BurgessHmm.
Peter LewisAnd that has not been disclosed. There is this whole, there's the ideological push, but there's also a material financial push behind New Zealanders assault on our labour this time.
Damian DamjanovskiFair, but I mean, you know, the AFR has gone after the budget pretty hard as well. And the ABC hasn't been easy on it either. ⁓ I do see your point, but ⁓
Julianna BurgessYeah. Yeah, but you know, it's just, it's media biased and in the end of the day, it has happened to every PM and every government since I can remember reading the news. So I don't think that's going to change anytime soon.
Peter LewisYeah. I've got to give News Limited a bit of credit in that the moment they're expecting the government to go to war with ⁓ Big Tech to give them their money out of the News Media Bargaining Code, but it has not led them to running soft on the government in any way whatsoever. Yeah, that's right. The code.
Damian DamjanovskiNews media bargaining incentive. I'm happy to move on from the budget after this. just want to follow up on what you guys just said there, Peter's like, is this a first step? Is this budget like a soft entry into more changes? Because hearing Chalmers' budget speech made me think, all right, you want to tax wages less than you want more taxes on wealth and consumption.
Peter LewisThank Thank you. ⁓ you
Damian DamjanovskiAnd I was like, well, tax on consumption is an increase to the GST. Why aren't we touching things like GST or actual wealth taxes, land taxes, the kind of stuff and, know, God forbid it should ever be mentioned, but you know, the PRRT was something that was floated beforehand. I'm not, not in favour of increasing the PRRT, but I understand the arguments for it. Why has Labour chosen to stay away from that and just focus on this thing? What do we think?
Julianna BurgessHmm.
Peter LewisOh, well, I think you do one thing well, because if you do like the lesson from Bill Shorten was you do 10 things and no one understands any of it. So you do one or two things well politically. I think the next budget will be about tax cuts under the auspices of ironing out bracket creep. I thought the most interesting contribution in the last week was actually the crazy brave call from Angus Taylor to index bracket creep, because that would just cost the budget a bomb. But it is. You know, Ken Henry, for instance, the former Treasury Secretary, has said, of course you should be doing that. So that's interesting.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, but it's interesting that... Sorry, Ganges.
Julianna BurgessYeah. And small business, small business taxback bracket group as well. mean, sure there's, you know, carve outs for small businesses in the budget, but the definition of a small business has not changed since 2007. Like how can that, how can we say they're operating in the same? I think it's 2 million revenue and 6 million in assets, I believe, but that hasn't changed since the early 2000s.
Damian DamjanovskiWell, I think.
Peter LewisWhat's the definition of a small business out of interest? And then what's the medium? I don't know, whatever. Yeah.
Damian Damjanovskiabove that. Yeah, 10 million in revenue and employing fewer than 20 people. ATO accounts it as 10. Depends who you ask, they all define it slightly differently. But it's interesting on that because charmers on insiders made the very good point that like, ⁓ you know, we can't give people back all their like, yes, bracket creep is important. And I think Taylor stepped into this trap as well being like, well, we can't give everyone their tax ⁓ bracket creep back.
Julianna BurgessI don't, I don't, yeah. No, it's 2 million in revenue, isn't it?
Peter LewisMm.
Julianna BurgessYeah.
Damian DamjanovskiAt once because that will just cause too much inflation. So it's better if the government keeps your money that shouldn't should be yours to begin with, because we don't trust you not to spend it. Like, I don't know if you can get more patronizing than that from both, know, treasurers and shadow treasurers being like, ⁓ you know, we can't trust you guys to keep the money. So we'll just have to. Like we all know that this is basically a Ponzi scheme where governments collect more than.
Peter LewisI ate a surprise.
Julianna BurgessYeah.
Damian Damjanovskithey should be collecting because people go up in brackets and then hand it back to you as a tax offset or as a ⁓ tax break. Like it's a complete bullshit thing. ⁓ absolutely. it's been going on for, mean, Frazier was the last one who tried to introduce indexation and had to roll it back very quickly because it's literally the only lever that these governments have to give you a tax break anytime they go to an election. ⁓
Julianna BurgessYeah. ⁓
Peter LewisYeah, that is bullshit. It's a bipartisan bullshit party though. Yeah. Cough and I'll there.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd I'm surprised that more of the media and people haven't called it out as we need to end this racket and let people actually be taxed appropriately.
Peter Lewisfeel like we're getting too pointy headed. How have the Greens been playing this?
Peter StahelI mean, I think they're using good, I think they're using good messages on tax because they're ⁓ doing ⁓ a better job than most to give people a reason to count themselves out of what they're proposing. So talking about the super wealthy and ⁓ the 1 % ⁓ is a better, a better bet than
Julianna BurgessThey wanna go harder.
Damian DamjanovskiHmm.
Peter Stahelintergenerational ⁓ fairness narrative, I think, for the Greens. ⁓ But it's so difficult for them to get cut through. I don't think people are hearing what they're saying.
Peter LewisSo what is the equivalent of the drones? that, and I don't know if you guys know where that came from. Is that just bottom up or is somebody coordinating that? But why is the left not as good at the moment as the right at running?
Peter StahelWhat do you by that's the environment?
Julianna BurgessHahaha
Damian Damjanovski⁓ But the greens are just going to wave this through style, right? Like they're just going to, they're going to go look, we wish it went further, but at least it's something, wave it through.
Peter Lewisyou
Peter StahelI don't know, there might be some parliamentary jockeying, ⁓ but yeah, ultimately, mean, this is a couple of key things they've been asking for, so you would think so.
Julianna Burgessthat I'm interested in talking about the Teals slash community independence. So as we would have all seen, Allegra Spender's tax white paper basically suggested everything that was introduced in the budget, if not a harder version of it. Yet she's now teaming up with the tech council and whatnot to protest. Like it's just, I think it's that particular type of hypocrisy that actually pisses people off in the community.
Peter LewisMmm.
Damian DamjanovskiShe's suddenly realised she has a lot of wealthy constituents and donors.
Peter LewisYou hate the tail smooth than anyone, don't you Jules?
Julianna BurgessI'm keen to unpack that. I really do. No, I don't. don't. I don't hate anyone. Hate's very strong word, but I just, don't like hypocrisy.
Peter Lewis⁓ And also it's worth noting too that Pocock was pushing back on some of it too after that very compelling call from one Fiona Scott to the other Fiona Scott that there's a place for David in our party. And so he seems to have answered that sirens call this week.
Julianna BurgessYou
Damian DamjanovskiBut yeah, absolutely.
Julianna BurgessCan we say that started on the podcast? Was this the home of David Pocock joining the Liberal Party?
Damian DamjanovskiYou're right though, Jules. There is a huge hypocrisy when some of these tears, I mean, we asked talking about Spender specifically, who's now backtracked and gone, well, it was a white paper. It was up for discussion. I didn't mean it as a policy position. It was a press club speech. mean, like there's a reason why politicians generally don't do white papers. ⁓ And now she has to walk back for her constituents and some of her wealthy donors.
Peter LewisThese two
Julianna BurgessIt was a press club speech with announcements and everything that went with it. Yeah, like.
Peter LewisIn the hierarchy of disdain for teals, who do you guys have the highest level of disdain? So Monique is the high bar in disdain.
Damian DamjanovskiMake Ryan.
Julianna Burgessyou
Damian DamjanovskiIt's hard to listen to Monique without feeling like she's talking down to you.
Peter LewisShe is a physician. ⁓
Julianna BurgessAnd where else? I'm from that area. it's.
Damian DamjanovskiJust former physician. Manique Raine would definitely sit on top of that list for me. So I don't know about you, Jules. You're a Melbonite.
Julianna BurgessYeah, I mean, you know how much I love Gisele. So I'd have to say Bradfield. Nicolette. Yep, yep. That was devastating for us.
Peter LewisCheers.
Damian DamjanovskiNicolette. Nicolette Bowl.
Peter StahelIt sounds to me like this dynamic is quite similar to the dynamic between the Labor Left and the Greens.
Peter Lewisyou you
Damian DamjanovskiHahaha.
Julianna BurgessI can imagine. Yep.
Peter Lewishatred of the labor left to the Greens.
Peter StahelThe hype for that is there. Yes.
Julianna BurgessYeah, let labor and liberal have more love for one another than the extremes,
Peter LewisEven the day after the election, like, Albo was being so gracious to Dutton, but he was going like, fuck you to Adam Band. It was so obvious, wasn't it? ⁓
Damian DamjanovskiYeah.
Julianna Burgessyou
Damian DamjanovskiThat was amazing. ⁓ Before we move on to our next topic, just a bit of housekeeping. ⁓ as our podcast is growing, recommend anyone who's listening to the podcast, if you're enjoying it, please share it with someone else who might enjoy it. We did try to run some ⁓ YouTube audience building ads to basically be a follow on YouTube clip to other people. Unfortunately, Google believes that we are a election ad for some reason. So every time we mentioned a politician's name, apparently with the
Peter Lewisalways supporting!
Julianna BurgessNot the teals, not the teals.
Damian Damjanovskihilarious bit. So if anyone from Google is listening, help us out. Apparently in the first episode where we literally mentioned every single politician and political party, they allowed that through and it was promoted and our audience grew, which is great. But all the subsequent episodes, I went through a very frustrating process with Google ad support who were like, no, no, you mentioned Angus Taylor. I'm like, yes, but we're not campaigning for him. It's political commentary. like, no, Google counts that as political advertising. And I'm like, but We're not, if anything, we're doing the opposite of advertising for Angus Taylor, but we also make, I couldn't tell you who knows with Google anymore. So we can't rely on Google to help us build our audience. So if you are listening and you are enjoying it, or you think someone else might enjoy it or hate it, then please share it along. On that note.
Peter StahelWere you talking to an AI?
Julianna Burgesswas going to say that.
Peter LewisWhile we're talking, before we go on to serious matters, can we just talk about fun stuff, particularly the latest wave of defections to One Nation from the Liberal Party? Peter, my Peter predicted this, I think, was when we last had him on the show. Episode one, that never saw the light of day.
Damian DamjanovskiLibro. the lip.
Julianna BurgessYou did.
Peter Stahelepisode one.
Damian DamjanovskiNow to be fair, think Holly Hughes, who's probably the highest profile recent affection, I believe had handed in her liberal party membership a while ago before she bought the pub. ⁓ She bought the pub, which I haven't yet to go to, but is on my list of places to visit. ⁓ Peters and Jules, if we all want to do a road trip out, we should see if Holly will have us for a live episode. I'm sure she'd say yes. ⁓ Holly's good fun.
Julianna Burgess⁓ where is it?
Peter LewisSo we like Holly, do we?
Julianna BurgessWhy not? Do reckon we can get Pauline on the episode? That'd be fun.
Damian DamjanovskiIf we can get Holly and Pauline together, then you that's how we build the audience. ⁓ and then obviously Tina McQueen, ⁓ is the other one. So Tina, for those who don't know, you've probably seen her in the newspapers, often spotted sitting with Gina Reinhart at Mar-a-Lago in Florida at a Trump event. ⁓ and sky after dark, course, Tina's a fair bit to the right of right, I'd say she's, she's got singular views.
Peter LewisAnd sky after dark, she does a fair bit of action there, doesn't she? Are these just chances, do you reckon? Like, you know, I know that Holly got done over by whatever you're.
Damian Damjanovskipre-selection processes here.
Peter StahelYeah, we're still talking about the disaffected at this point. But the panic's about to set in.
Peter Lewisbecause there's not much ideological consistency between those two.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. I think in reality, what you're seeing happen is previously a lot of people would sit in the big tent party that is the liberal party because, you know, it's meant to be liberal in its acceptance of differing views and opinions. ⁓ and also because they had nowhere else to go. Like it was previously unthinkable that you would defect for one nation or, you know, occasionally maybe family first or something like that. But there was nowhere, no other ship that would take you. ⁓ post Barnaby defecting. over to one nation. been, there's now, ⁓ a well, ⁓ increasingly well trodden path of, ⁓ center right and far right liberal people who are like, well, there's another big 10 I can go to now. And I don't think this is, be the last of them either, if I'm perfectly honest. I think you'll increasingly see more and more of the previously disaffected coalition, not just liberal, but also maybe some ex-NATs. Moving over to the One Nation side of the fence, potentially increases One Nation's legitimacy, potentially increases their standing, but certainly gives them more expertise than they've ever had before.
Julianna BurgessYeah. I think there's a little bit of self-interest in it too. mean, is it because they couldn't get pre-selected for one of the other parties half the time? Maybe. I know that happened with the, I can't remember his name, but the One Nation guy that won Sarah. I know he tried Labour and then tried Nationals. I think it was. Yeah. Like I think these are the kinds of people that, you know, try a few parties.
Damian DamjanovskiDave, David, uh, Farley Farley.
Julianna BurgessThey used to just go off and become an independent in themselves, but now they have options for a smaller party to join. So I feel like there's that element there too.
Damian DamjanovskiI this is where having more seats in parliament would have helped because these people would have run as independents or would have flown the flag of the Liberal Party or the Nats in that instance. But I definitely don't think it's the last of it. hope Holly's keen to come on the show one week and talk us through it. I might actually reach out to her and see if she's keen to chat through it.
Julianna BurgessYeah.
Peter Lewis⁓ definitely. I reckon I want and then get maybe get Kate back as well. Like a one nation and a green would be awesome. Don't you reckon?
Damian DamjanovskiGod. Yeah. That would be very, very fun.
Julianna BurgessThat'd be fun. ⁓
Damian DamjanovskiI would like to talk about, so this coming week, ⁓ the inaugural enhanced games beginning in Las Vegas. ⁓
Peter LewisThis will be right in your headings though, my prediction is you are going to love this, aren't I?
Damian Damjanovski⁓ James Magnuson. We've got some great Aussie talent there. ⁓ Obviously it's backed by a whole bunch of billionaires who basically go, well, why don't we let people basically, you know, have a little bit of agency over their bodies, put whatever they want into it, and then see how fast they can swim, run, jump over things and do all the fun things that the Olympics and the other official bodies don't let them. And I am all for it. But I imagine Mr. Lewis, that this is a hard no from you.
Julianna BurgessYou
Peter Lewisthose party poopers. ⁓ you know, I just think that, you know, the idea of being the fastest runner is being the fastest runner, not being the fastest runners souped up on performance enhancing drugs. ⁓ I don't know. I think there's something existential in, you know, what we're talking about here. But and you know, it strikes me as a bit similar, like if it just becomes effectively a contest of.
Damian DamjanovskiCan't we have both?
Peter Lewispharmacology and technology, it becomes a bit like the computer chess, that there was this thing that, you know, a computer is going to beat everyone in chess, but person to person chess is still a thing because you actually want to see what people can do rather than what, you know, the technology can do. So I don't know, like notwithstanding the concerns about health and like, I'm not a, you know, a puritan on taking, you know, performance enhancing anything, but
Damian DamjanovskiHmm.
Peter LewisI don't know. I just think.
Peter StahelI put it in the same category as that fake wrestling that's incredibly popular.
Julianna BurgessWhat's fake wrestling? What is this?
Damian DamjanovskiReally?
Peter LewisUFC! Like when they don't actually hit each other they're just doing performative.
Peter StahelYeah, but it's wildly popular and there's sort of there's this cognitive dissonance where some people are like, yeah, yeah, I know it's fake. And then other people are, no, no, no, it's real. But it kind of doesn't matter because it's just the spectacle of the whole thing. It's just it's just another coliseum sport, you know.
Damian DamjanovskiSo, Stile, I'm going to assume that you're not a Formula One fan.
Peter Stahelno, yeah, not really a sports ball person and motorsports. ⁓ Yeah, probably put it in the same category.
Peter LewisHe doesn't like sports pool.
Damian DamjanovskiLet's start it. See, as a Formula One fan, where it's not just about how fast you can drive, it's about a combination of how well someone can construct a car and then how well someone can drive it. I am all in favor of the enhanced games. I don't think it should take over from the Olympics. And again, like for those who don't know, the rules are basically if it's approved by the FDA, which is the American version of our TGA, then you know, people...
Peter LewisThat is. Bye.
Damian Damjanovskistart there, what they call their protocol. they're more monitored by doctors through the enhanced games process than any Olympian is ever overseen during Olympic sports. But I think there's something amazing in the fact that we're finally a little bit more transparent about this kind of stuff in sports, because a lot of these athletics and swimming championships have had dirty secrets around doping for decades. And I like that someone's come out and gone, well, why don't we put it out in the open? and see what we can do.
Peter LewisWhere do you sit on this, Jules? Are you a libertarian?
Julianna BurgessI'm really mixed with it, to be honest. Like ⁓ a big part of me does have that, know, classic libertarian liberal perspective that's, you know, consenting adults to whatever you want with your body. I don't really care. But it's also, Peter, I get where you're coming from in that it is quite icky. Like sports people are always, you know, heroes for children. children are mentally cut to these people and, you know, aspire to be them. And I think, you know, if children are getting confused that this is what... they should be looking up to. I really do worry about that.
Peter LewisYeah. Instead of wearing the club jersey, you have the club peptide. Like it would be fantastic.
Damian DamjanovskiHang on, hang on, hang hang hang
Peter Stahelthen
Damian DamjanovskiI know if you've looked at a club jersey or an Olympic sponsor lately, but the biggest Olympic sponsors are people like Anheuser-Busch who are selling kids alcohol. I don't know that that argument necessarily holds.
Julianna BurgessIt just...
Peter StahelAnd how do we actually think they've been going with that whole being ⁓ idolized by children, like being someone to look up to? The football codes aren't doing too well.
Julianna BurgessYeah, but... Yeah, look, they could be going better, but do we need to give them... Do we need to give them yet another instrument to use to not be an idol for children? Yeah, I don't know. I find the whole thing a little bit icky, to be honest.
Peter LewisBut, and are they going to have the green screen so that if anyone dies, they can put them down without the crowd watching?
Julianna BurgessYou
Damian DamjanovskiShhh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh,
Julianna BurgessI'm not going to lie. really, I don't know too much about this topic. I haven't really looked into it all that much ⁓ at all. Does everyone, does everyone have to be on an enhancement? Like are there categories? Is it like you're on the peptides, you're on the steroids? Like how does it.
Peter LewisGreen Shower could have been a shotgun, that's all you need for the enhanced game.
Damian DamjanovskiWell, look, if anyone is. No, no, there's plenty of athletes who are, there's plenty of athletes who've chosen to compete.
Peter LewisIt could be like the Paralympics where you have different drugs and then you've got one for stoners like that go really, really slow as well. Like the disenhanced games. I'm up for that.
Julianna BurgessThat's what I mean. Yeah, like, is cocaine in there? Like...
Damian DamjanovskiI think, so you don't have to be enhanced to necessarily compete. It's actually more about transparency. there are lots of ⁓ athletes who are competing without any kind of ⁓ enhancing drugs or any kind of protocol as they call it. ⁓ Part of the reason is that a lot of the world athletics and swimming bodies will ban you if you compete in the enhanced games with drugs. So there are people
Julianna BurgessHmm. Fair, because it does stay in the system for a long time.
Damian Damjanovskicompeting, you know, commando style, if you will. ⁓ but they'll be competing up against people who have all kinds of different routines. And I think James Magnuson is one of our Australian poster boys for this in the swimming. we'll see if he can break some records, but not that any of those records will necessarily be ⁓ counted on the world stage. I think as the inaugural year, it'll be interesting to watch. no one's carrying it in Australia. So think you have to watch it on YouTube if you want to watch it. ⁓
Julianna BurgessDo they have an opening ceremony? That's what I want to know. Can I watch that?
Peter StahelPerhaps we could apply this transparency principle to politics as well. We could have politicians declaring their ⁓ advantages, their material advantages in their multiple personality disorders and their narcissism. This is going to help me in my campaign. I better make sure everyone knows about
Peter LewisYeah, lots of drugs. Hi.
Julianna BurgessYou
Peter LewisWhen I was thinking that, like, what would an enhanced political games look like? Like what, are the performance enhancing drugs for politics?
Julianna BurgessDon't wanna know.
Damian DamjanovskiMoney and media connections. think they're the two main drugs that matter,
Peter LewisPfft. Before we put a pin in this, is there like a is, is this just chancing or is there a broader philosophy behind the games by the people that are sort of backing it in?
Julianna BurgessPower and fame.
Damian DamjanovskiI mean, again, the broader philosophy is pretty much around, you know, humans plus prosthetics in the form of drugs, in the form of equipment, in the form of mental prosthetics is just as valid as humans alone. So why don't we see how far we can go? Like that we're not a species that is designed to be. Just as we are, are always meant to expand beyond that, whether it's the extended mind, the expended body.
Peter LewisWow, that's very pure to Yavin,
Damian DamjanovskiIs that a bad thing though, Peter? And if so, why? I know you're a Puritan on all things, but-
Peter LewisWell, this is where we get into this is where we get into class versus me. Like I, I want like when I read something, I want it to be written by a human. When I watch a game, I want it to be a human. Like, I don't know. Like, you know, I do think there's something more profound about games that people play rather than enhanced games. I, I don't think, I don't think that what compels us to watch sport or at least me is necessarily
Damian DamjanovskiSee ya.
Peter LewisIt being it's the contest between people rather than the contest between technology for that. You I'm old.
Damian DamjanovskiBut it's a fiction as well, Like you watch movies and you enjoy movies knowing that those movies are fictions, right?
Julianna BurgessYeah, but so far created by people. know AI, sure, there's that debate, but the art and the craft behind the movie is usually human.
Damian DamjanovskiSome yes, some no. I'm sure we all shared a tier in the opening sequence of up, right? And yes, that was written partially by it. It was written by humans, but it was crafted by machines. It's entirely 3D rendered environment that made me cry.
Peter LewisWould you read a book that was written by an AI? I've never asked you this.
Damian DamjanovskiI reckon I probably have already.
Julianna BurgessYeah. I'm sure I've read so many articles lately that are written entirely by AR.
Peter LewisArticles, yeah, there's lots of slop out there, but would you sit down and invest, you know, a week's evening reading in a book if it had been machine written?
Julianna BurgessIf I enjoy it, yeah.
Damian DamjanovskiI don't, wouldn't make the decision based on how it was written. Like what tools were, it was, were used to write it. Cause unlike, unlike you, and I think this is where we do differ wildly on this is the origin doesn't matter to me. It's what it made me think, what it made me feel, whether it moved me, if it entirely came from a machine, good on the machine and whoever coded programmed and trained it.
Peter LewisDoesn't just become a dildo then an intellectual dildo. They have a purpose. Yeah. It's not the same. I don't know. I, Peter, Jules, I don't know.
Damian DamjanovskiWhat's wrong with Dildos? Right? I'm not anti-Dildo.
Julianna BurgessYes, no, I agree with Dharmir over there. just, yeah, the creator doesn't bother me.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah. Yes. Yeah, so I'm any more than I would read something written by a ghostwriter. Like it doesn't bother me at all. and I think what's more interesting to me now, and I'll only touch on a little bit because I know we're reaching our mark is
Peter LewisWhat have we spoken about this week? Anyway, let's reach our mark.
Damian Damjanovski⁓ I think the AI conversations that we're having at the moment are a huge red herring. And I'm a big believer in this now. I think we're having a lot of conversations around what AI is producing the data centers. would be hosted in who's paying for copyright, all these kind of very high level erudite conversations. And what I'm seeing coming out of China where
Julianna Burgessbudget.
Damian DamjanovskiThe number of models they're producing are a hundred times more than what's coming out of the US is a completely different paradigm because they're not designing them for giant data centers. They're not designing them to be big anthropics that you pay 200 bucks a month on. They're designing that. Sorry, for people who are listening who don't know a lot about this, this is the 10 second or the two minute version of it is there's basically you've got a couple of big companies over in the US who've spent
Peter Lewisyou
Damian Damjanovskitens of billions of dollars developing AI models, right? So they learn from experts, they figure out what to say and how to say it in what order, and then they sell it to you for 20 or 200 bucks a month on very expensive hardware that sits inside a data center somewhere, which is what you're talking to when you talk to ChatGPT or Claude or Copilot or any of those things. The Chinese have not been allowed to buy those chipsets, right? So they've been blocked out of buying those Nvidia chipsets that run those data centers. So they've had to get more creative with how they do it. And what they've done is gone, well, we'll make more efficient models that don't need these giant data centers. And then we can embed those models into consumer electronics and the kind of shit we sell from our factories. Now they didn't spend hundreds of billions of dollars developing it. So they did something called distilling, which is where they go, well, we'll make a pretty dumb AI, but it still needs to learn things. Those guys over at OpenChat, GPT and Anthropic already learned stuff. So I'll just ask it questions. And the response it gives me, I'm basically learning by copying its answers. And that's called distilling. So that's what they're doing. And they're doing it at remarkable speed in models that are much more efficient, that don't need data centers to run on, that can run on consumer grade hardware, i.e. the thing you have at home, your MacBook, even down to things like the chip inside your TV. That's what they're doing it for. And so while we're focused on this big conversation of Who's going to pay for the rights to the copyright, this, that, and the other on these big data sets? So while we think we can stem the tide of AI, the Chinese are going in a very different direction. And my instinct is they might win the consumer race at the end of the day.
Peter Lewis⁓ yeah. Because the other thing is it is also an ideological one where instead of because they do not want an like the West is going for an eye of God, I that just does everything and replaces everything. They don't want to challenge the state. They're doing things that will enhance the state rather than challenge it. And it's actually on environmental grounds, but also on design grounds, a far better way of doing it than the big.
Julianna BurgessHmm.
Damian DamjanovskiWhat's really fascinating is this last week while Trump was over with Xi in China, getting back to the politics of it, he brought all the billionaires and tech bros over with him, including ⁓ Jensen. Jensen Wang, who's the guy at Nvidia, The trillion dollar company, which is building the tech that all this AI runs on, has been saying for years, we need to let China buy the chips. Otherwise they're going to develop their own thing. And everyone's like, ⁓ yeah, ha ha ha. You're saying that out of self-interest. He went over on the trip as well and was like, well, we can open up.
Peter LewisI want to do deals and trying to go, we don't need your shit.
Julianna BurgessAhem.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd Trump was like, well, we can open up sales of Nvidia chips to you guys now finally. And the Chinese went, no, thanks. We're good. We're doing our own thing.
Peter LewisPlus Taiwan makes lots of them. We don't need you guys. Gee, was a little tech bro discussion. Anything anyone wants to add to that?
Damian DamjanovskiSorry.
Julianna BurgessI just, I actually have a question. I've heard so many people in the last couple of weeks talk about why aren't we developing Australia's sovereign AI? Like why aren't we developing the next anthropic competitor? Like, I just feel like I don't think Australia or our government or anyone in the industry can grasp how far behind we actually are. And I think you've just really illustrated that, but do you want to add anything? Does anyone want to add anything about, you know?
Damian DamjanovskiI'll let everyone else had something before I put my two cents on this.
Julianna Burgesshow like how we've really, I feel like we've probably really, you know, done ourselves a disservice of not thinking about this sooner and not trying to at least, you know, be one of the players in the field when it comes to developing this technology.
Peter LewisWell... Well, I floated today in ⁓ the ⁓ people's publication, The Guardian Australia, the idea that we should be looking at AI the way the Norwegians looked at oil. what people don't get is that Anthropic and ChatGP have a huge problem, which is they don't have anywhere to do their big model training. And so there is a world in which we could situate it in Australia. renewables out in the desert doing the training centers. They've got two problems. They've got a problem of copyright. They've got a problem with social license, but the deal could be investment in there like all co-investment off the back of what we've already given them, which is our IP. Like I think there is a model where we could get some ongoing benefit out of it. I'll be, ⁓ and I threw that out in the Guardian today and I've never been flamed as much. Normally I'm, I'm showered in love, but I was just getting everyone going,
Julianna Burgessso it's not too late.
Peter LewisYou're up on AI, which I sort of feel myself because I'm it. But, know, I'm by default a resistor of AI. But I was sort of saying if we're to do it, let's let's at least get a good deal out of it and not wait 40 years and then whinge that we've really got a bad gas tax structure. Let's set it up right from the start. But I don't know. The Greens have called a Senate inquiry into data centers. So we might put that up as a submission, the people's submission on a Norwegian style fund. And then
Julianna BurgessYeah. Yeah, exactly.
Damian DamjanovskiYep.
Julianna BurgessYeah.
Peter LewisIt was all ready to go this morning and then Pauline put out, we want a Norwegian get style gas tax regime. So ⁓ yeah, me and Pauline. So, let's get let's get someone from One Nation on soon. I reckon I can get them in on this one.
Damian DamjanovskiPeter Stahl, what's your thoughts on the data centers from a more left of center perspective? Missed opportunity or something we should tax the shit out of?
Peter StahelYeah, well, there's a world in which the social license on the environmental and community stuff really slows things down to the point that bubbles start bursting and that you know, especially with the global economy going the way that it is at the moment. don't know. Yeah, I don't know. I think there's just there's so many scores of possible scenarios that it seems like a fool's game to predict. But ⁓ I'm with you in a sense, Damian, that the way to avoid the worst outcomes is to dive in and for people to feel like they have agency over the way that this goes. but that's easier said than done.
Damian DamjanovskiYeah, absolutely. Right. I think Jules, I don't know if you've got a specific view on this other than what are we doing about it, but
Julianna BurgessYeah, I don't, I just think we've fallen behind in the race and I just feel like, you know, Australia has all of the capability and all of the capacity to be a leader in this. And I just feel like unfortunately, decisions made recently and you know, when the coalition was in government have just not put us in the right position. Peter, I'm sorry. I haven't, I haven't read your analysis today, but I'm excited to read it and see.
Damian DamjanovskiI'd agree with you on that.
Peter Lewisthink an analysis is probably putting it too highly, but thank you very much for that kind word.
Julianna BurgessNo. Opinion.
Damian DamjanovskiI have read your opinion. ⁓
Peter StahelYou can actually categorize pieces by number of analogies and if there's more than six analogies or metaphors, then it's not analysis anymore.
Peter LewisBut I did get a great line into the headline, Australia should fjord a better path. thought that was, that was me. That was me.
Peter Stahelyou
Julianna Burgess⁓ I like that. That's fun.
Damian DamjanovskiIt was an line. I will say not just on your piece, but to Jules's question in general. ⁓ Having heard multiple ministers and governments and esteemed experts talk about this, the horse has so far bolted on Australia's ability to have any kind of true AI sovereignty that I think we do need to get slightly fucking real.
Julianna BurgessYeah.
Peter LewisSo shake down the hyperscalers. ⁓
Damian DamjanovskiYou could but but to my point about the Chinese models I don't think it matters that the hyperscalers are a current blip that actually will matter to enterprise more than anyone and even enterprises at some point soon will switch and go actually.
Peter LewisBut I'm going to keep it out of consumer. don't think it should be in consumer. don't, don't think Wankbot should be on the market. And I will continue to say this as long as anyone asks me.
Peter StahelIn what? In what industries or policy areas do we currently have sovereignty?
Damian DamjanovskiWhy? Well, very few. And I guess my point is that I'm not sure treating things like AI data centers the same way we do natural resources where we go, well, let's tax it and build a sovereign wealth fund does justice to the various ways in which this technology is still developing and how far behind we are, like how truly far, but like this isn't like right now it's a data center question, but not for the reasons people think it is if.
Peter Stahelwhich is a natural resource question.
Damian Damjanovskiin terms of power. But what I'm saying is I don't think it's going to be a data center question for all that much longer.
Peter StahelI think that's, I think that's on.
Peter LewisBut also these guys have committed the crime of the century and they've got to pay for it. Like there is there is a payday coming.
Damian DamjanovskiAnd they have in the US with some of their, they've settled a lot of those copyright claims in the US.
Peter LewisOr not giving some crumb. Arkham, whackham. We better get around to predictions, otherwise we're going to be doing.
Damian DamjanovskiWhat's your prediction for this next week, Mr. Lewis?
Peter LewisWell, off the back of your very poor prediction last week that the Straits of Amos will be open in a week's time. I'm going to predict that it won't it won't be open in the next week. And that is the tipping point when shit goes really bad. So most of the analysis is that you could if you could get it reopened by the end of May, there's a chance that.
Julianna Burgess⁓ yes.
Peter LewisIt will be a downturn, not end of days. But if it gets passed in, then that dark scenario in the budget becomes very real. Oil at $200 a barrel, 7 % inflation. Nobody talking about young tech bros and capital gains tax anymore because I think things will be going south very quickly. next week is the week where, and so maybe
Damian DamjanovskiHmm.
Peter LewisWith that prediction, maybe next week is when the bombs start dropping to try to make something happen again. But next week is a crunch week in terms of global recession.
Damian DamjanovskiHmm. That's a, that's a big call. That is a big call. Mr. Stahl.
Peter LewisSorry, that's a dark way to end the week.
Peter StahelYeah, I think with the next round of polls could very well be the moment that the panic starts to set in with the LNP ⁓ when there's a bit more data to show that their overtures on ⁓ one nation style policies haven't won back a single voter from that area and actually lost them the whole audience in another area. And yeah, things could get really funky in the LNP if they start to realize that the strategy isn't working.
Damian DamjanovskiMmmmm
Julianna BurgessI'm going to be so boring and say, I think there'll be a clawback of the discretionary trust measures as well as potentially a little bit of a softener on some of the CGT measures and a bit more than just that tech exemption that they were talking about. I think there'll be a bit more consideration there.
Peter LewisCome on, what's your hot tip, given that the last two haven't landed, don't they?
Damian DamjanovskiAll right. I'm hoping this one does land. reckon James Magnuson is going to place in the top three on a hundred meter freestyle at the enhanced games. I'm hoping he gets the gold, which give him a net him a million dollar prize, but I'm going to say top three. Well, he's actually trimmed down for it. So he put on a lot of bulk and found that it was too bulky. he's, his new protocol has him like really trimmed down and slender for this one.
Peter Lewisand then his body will explode. So he's gone from peptides to mangiaro.
Julianna BurgessSo bit of oisempic.
Damian DamjanovskiSemiclutes.
Peter StahelI reckon when I find out the answer, Damien, it'll be from you.
Damian DamjanovskiI hope so. ⁓ Peter Starr, thank you very much for joining us this week. Julianna Burgess, thank you very much. Mr. Lewis, as always, thank you. It's been a pleasure. look forward to our chat next Friday. If you're watching for the first time, please like and subscribe the video and share it on to someone who might enjoy it as well. Thank you very much. We'll be here every Friday around 4pm.
Peter LewisThanks, guys.
Julianna BurgessThanks.
