Episode 8

West Wing, House of Cards, Veep

With Jacqui Munro

30 May 202655 min

Show notes

Featured guest: Jacqui Munro MLC (NSW)

Political decisions seen through the lens of the West Wing, House of Cards, and The Thick of It. State-owned development and housing affordability in New South Wales. The challenges posed by bureaucratic regulations in construction, the impact of unions, fire ratings, and excessive paperwork. The data centre inquiry and governance, the lack of clarity in policy making and the potential economic and social opportunities. AI sovereignty and capability development, the need for a sovereign AI model and Australian AI capability, as well as the importance of data training and sovereignty

Full transcript

Read itHide it

Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.

speaker-2: Welcome to What's Your Poison, the show where people who disagree about everything agree the best way to do it is over a drink. My name's Peter Lewis. I write for Guardian Australia. I also run campaigns for the forces of light. Joining me is my evil twin Dame Damnanowski, ⁓ principal of General Strategic. Hey.

speaker-0: What do you Does that mean that we we ⁓ You're the darkness. We're the darkness.

speaker-2: Always the darkness. until proven otherwise. I don't put skulls in my office. I don't know if it's insane. ⁓ what are you drinking this week and how's your week been?

speaker-0: Gives the light its flavor. I've had an excellent week. I'll start with what I'm drinking because it's a favorite of mine. So I don't know if you remember Passiona from being a kid. So this is a Brookvale Union vodka passion fruit, which is basically alcoholic childhood. And I'm all for it. It is excellent. So that I'm loving it.

speaker-2: You didn't grow up with West Coast cruisers, but I feel like it'd be pretty similar to that.

speaker-0: So it was ⁓ it was ⁓ much more rocket fuely. But what about you? What are you drinking this week?

speaker-2: I ha I am making a statement tonight in in solidarity to our guests who we're about to meet, you don't need to drink alcohol to have a good chat about politics. So I'm actually having a Carlton Zero. I think one of the great advances in technology, probably more significant than AI, has been the improvements in zero alcohol beer over years. I think that the the gold standard is heaps normal, but I'm gonna give the Carlton Zero a

speaker-0: Go. Well choose to that. I will say that as a generally a whiskey drinker I'm yet to meet a zero alcohol whiskey that doesn't just taste like iced tea. Fair crap. ⁓ so I'm hoping these advancements come. But I understand with beer it actually is pretty

speaker-2: I'm also toasting tonight the great James Valentine whose memorial service I attended today. I did for a number of years on seven ⁓ two The People's Pole with James, ⁓ including questions like do you shower before bed or after bed? Do you urinate standing out of

speaker-0: Yeah. Like the scrunchy, foldy toilet paper, like some of the best debates. And I there's an entire generation that doesn't know James Valentine because they're not of that era of and I actually feel that Australian culture as a as the Australian what it what is our communal values is actually lesser for the fact that we don't have James Valentine like personalities.

speaker-2: Is that the Liberal Party members of the And I was thinking about today in the context, which we might get to in just sec, about how we we come together for conversations. And so much of what civic life is is sort of working out things we don't agree with. But James's stuff was just really about the minutiae of life and celebrating that. and also if I'm gonna go out, like at his memorial service, Kate Sabrano, Arcapella, Paul Kelly Arcapella, and then Jimmy and Mahalia Barnes. It was ⁓ and sorry in Sydney Town Hall, packed to the rafters, friends friends. family in the middle, listeners in the upper decks. It was packing and they ended up with, you know, the old treme, ⁓ New Orleans style marching band, playing music out into the street. So it was quite a thing. So I am feeling ⁓ yeah ⁓ but yeah quite sanguine but it was also a beautiful experience. And ⁓ who will be bought who have you brought us along?

speaker-0: They went. quite reflective I imagine as well. ⁓ ⁓ so this week I'm I've brought along to to brutalise ⁓ one of my favourite ⁓ in so in New South Wales we don't call them senators, we call them members of the Legislative Council, which is the upper house in New South Wales, ⁓ and one of my personal favourite political entities, ⁓ which is none other than Jackie Munro, who's here with us. Jackie, welcome to the show. Thank you, sir. ⁓ and what is your poison this week?

speaker-1: So today I've got the Warrigamba Slammer, the Lake Air with Air.

speaker-0: Cheers. Cheers. Cheers in the soda water. ⁓ thank you for proving that we are not here purely as alcoholics to get drunk every week. We can actually enjoy conversations without alcohol.

speaker-2: It's a virtue, yeah.

speaker-1: I'm happy to enable ⁓

speaker-2: This cat. I've met you once ⁓ off the back of Audrey Tang's visit a couple of years ago and I I I think we got connected because you were interested in thinking about different ways of democracy working. ⁓ one of my observations is everyone was excited for a couple of months that it's all gone nowhere, but how's it been going for you?

speaker-1: So I think about this a lot because of my role in politics. I'm thinking about how we deal with conversations more effectively. And why I I heard about Audrey Tang probably six years ago, someone gave me a copy of ⁓ Frankie magazine with an interview with Audrey. So it was something that I saw like she was such a a social leader, she had this tech background. background and she was something so different in a democracy because she was tech like her native digital environment gave her an expertise and an insight into a world that is not often represented in institutional politics I would say. So when I got the opportunity to come and meet her, I jumped on it and I often talk about the impressive nature of Taiwan's democracy and even things like the way that they vote, they or they count the votes, they have an invitation to all the different parties that are represented on a ballot paper to come and set up cameras at the voting station, at the counting station, so that there are multiple verifiable videos that demonstrate that that is a correct counting process.

speaker-0: It was like a two point ⁓ scrutineering.

speaker-1: Totally. And not only do they just does a scrutiny and just put it in Well yeah, you actually see the scrutiny and they read out the entire ballot. They go, This person got one, this person got two, this person got three. They hold it up for all the cameras to see so you can verify that this is the the ballot paper and they put it down and then they count the next one. Yeah, it takes a long time but it's there's a real trust in their democracy as well.

speaker-0: Jesus, how long does counting take?

speaker-2: And there's I think there's a real question whether it is the unicorn because it is in such a position of contest the future of Taiwanese democracy, but it's really interesting that it has been done then and that whole movement emerged from, you know, student demonstrations a decade ago. ⁓ so, you know, it almost it wasn't like a academic exercise. It actually came out of a crisis, which is interesting too.

speaker-1: And that's a whole

speaker-0: It's quite a young democracy as well, so.

speaker-2: Yeah. Yeah, and and a really diverse one as well. So I I'm I'm also

speaker-1: Also just like just quickly on that, the thing about Audrey Tang is that she has been committed to this idea of radical transparency. Not just to say it, but in her whole life. And that was something that I was really drawn to, this idea of radical, demonstrated values in her transparency.

speaker-0: And and i it's something to be said. One one thing I always enjoy fighting with people over is digital ballots versus paper ballots. And for someone who's as digitally heavy as myself, I love a paper ballot. And I do not think ballots should be digitized. Because I think there is something irrep irrep irreplic irreplicably.

speaker-2: Mm.

speaker-0: That's the one. This is Something that cannot be replicated about a paper ballot with a pencil or a pen that you sit and write and someone can scrutine over your thing. However, I do believe that Australian education system has failed us by not allowing people to know that you can strike through a seven or a zero so that it cannot be confused for everything else. This is something the Europeans got right for

speaker-2: And you can't dimple a Chad digitally either. So how's it going up at Macquarie Street? You are a member of an opposition. It's nine months out to an election against what I've said before is my least favourite Labour government ever. How are you feeling? ⁓ Like what's survive up there?

speaker-1: This government has made some really strange bedfellows out of members of parliament. And this week we saw this situation where the Greens and the Liberal Party and former One Nation members and the Animal Justice Party have come together to condemn the government for not engaging in radical transparency and in fact being

speaker-2: We didn't

speaker-1: Well, yeah, we we didn't set it up, but the Labour Party set it up for themselves. And I think that we i people often think about politics as this game and it's easy to characterize what has been going on in terms of we're kicking out senior ministers of the government out of the chamber and they get marched out by the black rod as a game, as a political stunt. But it's actually not. It's actually protecting the really important institution of our parliaments to be able to scrutinize executive government and those are not ⁓ they're not esoteric or ephemer ephemeral principles they are actually real and it means that yeah I mean we're not getting the information that we need to make good policy.

speaker-0: And and it th the the Minnes Labour government in New South Wales is is

speaker-2: Your favourite Liberal government, by the way.

speaker-0: Let me come back to that. But it is bec developing a reputation for being particularly secretive ⁓ and in some ways feeling like it's above the law on a lot of different measures. But I want to come back to so obviously you're you're a liberal politician and I think most of our insider listeners kind of get the differences of the factions in the parties, but we actually have lot of listeners who are not political insiders and don't realise that like th they paint the Liberal Party with the brush of you're the right wing conservatives and the Labour guys with you're also specialists and they don't realise that Labour has formal factions Labor has formal factions of left wingers and right wingers. which that's what they're called, right? Just the left and the right

speaker-2: Well yeah, but then there's within the I just digress to one thing because I want to share this. Within l the left, there are two factions, the hard left and the soft left. If you are in the left, why would you ever join the soft left? Surely it's like a contradiction in terms. It's like the flat round.

speaker-0: Socialist Anyway.

speaker-1: Yeah, like not only are the left and the right factions like clearly defined, they have separate constitutions.

speaker-0: Yeah, so it's like we're formalized. ⁓

speaker-2: No no we don't you guys don't have any wets anymore, do you? Or are you it?

speaker-0: Well so so let's come back to so Labour has two formal factions of the left and the right and sub-cabals within that of soft left, medium soft left, semi-firm left, hard left, whatever it is.

speaker-2: They sort of change and sometimes I have been certain.

speaker-0: If you if you're listening to this and you're not sure who to picture in this, if you think of someone like Chris Mins, he's a a Labour right guy, right? So it's easy to confuse him with, well, he should be in the Liberal Party, because it's what you wouldn't normally think of as someone who would be a liberal politician. Conversely, if you're an album's a left guard

speaker-1: think that people look at minz and go, he should be in the Liberal Party?

speaker-0: I th ⁓ that's a really great question. I'm not sure I don't I know how to I was gonna say 'cause he's well spoken and down to worth, but there you go. We've all got different views on that.

speaker-2: We should just stop cheering for our side.

speaker-1: I would say that he deserves to be in the Labour Party because he's controlled by the unions. Right. So I think And that is like the fundamental difference.

speaker-2: So what got you to join the libs? Like what sorry, are we gonna

speaker-0: Liberal Party also has factions, but they're not formalized like Labour. So while in Labor side grouping. We have grouping. So on the Labour side it's very formal. There's two entrances, do you want to be on the left or the right? In the Liberal Party we all go through the same door and kind of coalesce towards different parts of the same ballroom. Now you would put yourself on which side of that ballroom?

speaker-1: So I would call myself a moderate liberal. Yep. And in my in my political ideology, I would consider myself a moderate liberal because I believe in liberalism, smaller government, general social progressiveness, but small government when it comes to the economy. Yep. Support for business and enterprise, a a bias towards liberty wherever possible, but not a libertarian. And I also think that the kind of Judeo Christian values that have set up most Western liberal democracies for success are are valuable.

speaker-0: Yeah. And and and I think one of the the key features, if you don't mind me saying, of your politics and and your kind of ⁓ moderatism within the Liberal Party is ⁓ you are staunchly not a climate denier. ⁓ you are

speaker-1: Yes, like like most of my Liberal Party colleagues in the state parliament.

speaker-0: Yeah.

speaker-2: And to be fair, in government you practised what you preached and

speaker-1: Absolutely. Yeah. Not that I was in that government, but absolutely supported that and was a staffer in that government.

speaker-0: Yeah. Yeah. So sorry Peter interrupted you.

speaker-2: I was just interested at how you I c I think you've answered the question preemptively anyway, but so you you were drawn to the Liberal Party for a set of values that resonated. Like that's not the coolest thing to do.

speaker-1: Yeah. Yeah.

speaker-0: I don't think I don't know so I'm gonna explain why.

speaker-1: Thing to do either, but when I was at high school, like I was doing economics and I'm praising Howard for his economic policies then, but I didn't join until I got to uni. And I grew up on ABC, by the way. Like you're talking about James Valentine. Absolutely, I grew up with a way for me to experience politics. And I listen like every morning when I'm going to ban practice at school or whatever extracurricular activity it was. always had ABC seven ⁓ two or RN on and it you know it was Frank Hell

speaker-0: I'm I'm all for the ABC. I I learned English from open learning on the ABC and Benita from play school. Like that's how I learn English.

speaker-1: And it is it's accessible and I mean we I believe very strongly that we need a national broadcaster. Like that's as a

speaker-0: Maybe not two, but we do need one. We could probably merge them together.

speaker-1: Yeah, I mean SBS runs ads, like they have a stream of income for themselves. It's like

speaker-2: So we might talk a bit more about your work later, but before then I thought we'd just do a bit of a review of the week in politics. But given that we've spoken about the budget the last two weeks, I thought we'd play a little game today, which is inspired by a book that I read a few months ago, The Hour of the Predator, by a guy called Giuliano De Impoli, who was an advisor to an Italian prime minister whose name escapes me at the moment.

speaker-0: Given the number of Italian prime ministers they've had, they must have a lot of advi former advisors to Italian Prime Ministers.

speaker-2: I don't yeah, I don't but he's he's he's written a couple of books, one of which was very acclaimed around ⁓ Putin's politics, but this one is really a bit of reportage. But there's this thing at the start that really got me, and he said when we're going around the world with big political meetings or dealing with big issues, they sort of had a ratio that every issue can be explained by the proportion of the issue which is emerging as a storyline from the West Wing versus a storyline from House of Cards or a story. line from the slash thick of it. So think about that. So you've basically got your West Wing is the idealism and trying to make the world a better place and doing the grand things that Martin Sheen taught us all was very important in the formative years. ⁓ Yeah, Kevin Spacey just doing the worst p possible things until he did the worst possible things and then the show got really bad when he wasn't able to be on it anymore. And then the craziness of whether you're a fan of Veep or the Thick of It, which is basically incompetence, chaos, and chasing your own tail. So let's talk about the budget, Damo, in which of those three or what do you reckon the the balance of this

speaker-0: That's a really good framing for this question. So my guess is that if you were in the tent in the PMO, ⁓ the Prime Minister's office or in the treasurer's office, and you were working on this, you genuinely felt you were in the You thought here we are on the blue carpet in the corridors of power, finally sticking it to that rich upper class who's been getting away with it for too long. And we're gonna everyone's gonna be backing us. Like finally we get to do something.

speaker-2: In the western.

speaker-1: This is power.

speaker-0: think the rest of the use this is we this is why we're here. Yeah we finally get to do something good. Australia saw nothing but the thick of it. They saw the V and they went, what how

speaker-2: This is the white right way to

speaker-0: have you guys managed to cock up a budget where you basically announced nothing for me other than taking some money off people, getting rid of the idea that I should aspire to something and maybe I'll get 250 bucks in a couple of years' time. ⁓

speaker-1: And also appearing to make what are potentially totally life-changing, significant changes to our taxation system like two weeks before budget nine. Like if you are going to break an election promise, at least have a lead up of a couple of months where you're going to have an open conversation with the people of Australia. Like I can understand why a party might want to go back on its election promise and it's not ideal. And I don't think it's a good thing. Yeah. But sometimes like you know, you can't predict the future. So sometimes you have to understand that things change.

speaker-0: Prepare for right? Like even when you go to GPS if you go to a GP, they warm up their hands before they stick your finger for a rectal exam. Do you know what I mean? Like they do you the courtesy of warming up the gel and warming up their hand before they stick a finger up to check for prostate cancer. Like where was Jim's warmth?

speaker-2: Go to a tree.

speaker-1: Sension.

speaker-2: Where was Jim's warm Vaseline is your question?

speaker-1: And the reason but the reason that there was no warm-up is because he didn't know that he was giving you the exam before it occurred to him.

speaker-2: Maybe you should so I so I think that's a fair point. I think that once the drones started hitting, which was all the AI stuff, it was peak beat for a little while in there. I reckon the and I think there was an excess of West Wing in there. Because I think they honestly like and I honestly believe they're doing the right thing. And and to your point before, they are trying to structurally change the way tax works so it's less like the shareholder society that Howard had. And I think there's an honest debate to be had. What they lack

speaker-0: Less like that prosperous society we had for twenty five years.

speaker-2: No, no, no. Which it w which is which has stopped Which has stopped delivering to the extent that now nativist right wing parties are turning up here like everywhere else that put all the guns into globalisation individual. ⁓

speaker-1: But it's been a long time since Howard was in the

speaker-2: But his a his his structure of the economy has basically remained. But can I make my point which is I think they were deficient in house of cards. I don't think they were ruthless enough. And what you are saying is so the Machiavellian part of this had to be to understand where this stuff was coming and actually prepare for their own meme wars with nurses with Albow standing beside them to get the same. So I I just think there was heaps of vision, there was organized chaos and panic. But I don't think there was the ruthless ⁓ bit in the middle that makes ⁓ you know, politics actually deliver and I don't know if that's

speaker-0: ⁓ I did get that.

speaker-1: problem with the West Wing angle is that sure you can feel like you've got this vision. I actually didn't get into West Wing. ⁓ really? The thick of it is my favorite. It's so clever.

speaker-0: Well the thick of it is an amazing piece of writing. And i if if you do enjoy the thick of it, I will say to anyone who has a subscription to Binge is ⁓ Ianucci is on the current season of Taskmaster, which is fucking hilarious to watch him doing all those tasks because he's just such a clever man and he's such a great writer. ⁓ to me he's like Andrew Denton is our version of Ianucci where it's like this very smart, dry person who just works at a different level to the rest of the

speaker-2: What's about you with you Josh or Toby?

speaker-0: Yeah.

speaker-1: What about you?

speaker-2: a speechwriter. I I was sort of a Samsung ideal

speaker-0: Sam C. Horns. I love this framing. I can I'm gonna be thinking

speaker-1: Like okay, everyone ⁓ thinks that they're doing the right thing and Western it's like full of vision, ⁓ my god, but but what you risk is really crossing that line into hubris. Yeah. And that's where I think this budget is. Like it crossed that line into we think that we are so correct that we're not even going to talk about

speaker-2: Which sounds a bit more like work choices when Howard had his massive

speaker-1: Yeah, yeah, that's right.

speaker-0: And I think when you don't have what seems to be an a a credible opposition, let's call it, and I'm not discounting the efforts of ⁓ the Federal Liberal Party, 'cause they are fighting, but it doesn't feel credible to Labour right now because it feels like one nation's eating them on one side, the two is on the other side. So do we really need to worry about these guys?

speaker-1: Wilson's ⁓ Tim Wilson's press club speech, which was what, was it last week? God, it's gone so quickly. It was excellent. And it really demonstrated what liberal values can deliver and should be delivering.

speaker-2: I think at least it gives you guys something to believe in. Like I'd much rather see the Liberal Party fighting for an economic agenda than trying to fight one nation on the right over immigration. And I think it was really interesting how fast they've dropped that because they've actually been drawn into, you know, a a a contest of substance. Now I still think Labour holds the cards, they've got a big majority, they've got political capital to and maybe I'm I'm Maybe this is all very house of cards. They said we're gonna take some heat, but we've got enough seats to lose. But ⁓ it is a consequential change and everyone says, well, why don't they do things of consequence and they've done them?

speaker-1: And and I do think that the it has given us a point of difference. You're totally right about that. And it has also given us something to sink our teeth into policy wise. Because one of the problems that we're facing in New South Wales is that the Labour Party is not giving us any policy to talk about, to dig our heels into. So we I mean we have ideas. Yeah, yeah, we have ideas, we have policies, but we don't have anything to respond to. So there's no like what's the buttons

speaker-2: What do you reckon the battle lines for the next election in New South Wales will be? Like what what are what are there gonna be policy debates or is it just gonna be waiting for one nation or you

speaker-1: Well, I don't see. I I don't know where Labour can go. So they'll possibly talk about housing, but we're like forty percent under their delivery target. They might talk about data centers, but we found out last week from ⁓ the secretary of the Premier's department that there will be no data center strategy, despite the major there will be no literally the line, there will be no data center. Okay, come back later. But

speaker-0: We need we need to come back to this in a

speaker-1: Like what what is the plan? There is no vision, there's no future forward agenda.

speaker-0: Surely more than any other state in this country or territory, housing affordability in New South Wales is issue one, two and three, far and beyond what it is in Victoria or Queensland, maybe WA.

speaker-1: We are now at the bottom of the table when it comes to economic growth. The ⁓ housing market in terms of approvals and completions is certainly completions is almost down the bottom, if not running last, to any other state or territory. So other states are actually getting this done in a way that New South Wales is not.

speaker-0: I mean, we can't end up as a state of landlords and renters exclusively. Like that that is not the economics of a state. What like how could Labour possibly go to the election with anything remotely resembling a plan to do anything different from what they haven't done in the past four years?

speaker-2: Well on housing, my criticism of them is all they're doing is running a developer get rid of any planning and let it rip. Like I think they've got to be more intentional in how they enter the market and they've got to I don't know where you are on this but social and ⁓ like th they they mix up social and affordable, but the affordable's not really affordable and they're building all this really expensive stuff. I reckon there needs to be a massive build of really low cost stuff just to get people, particularly if we go down economically off the back of Iran, just to keep people off the street.

speaker-1: Yeah, like this is what I'm about to say is not Liberal Party or coalition policy, but I have been an advocate for a change to land value tax to actually use land more efficiently and have better levers of control over different parts of the state so that we can use land buildings more efficiently, so that land banking isn't so prevalent, so that vacant apartments and homes aren't so prevalent. Like we need to be thinking about land as a it's It's not capital and it's not labor, it needs to be dealt with in a different economic framework. That's right.

speaker-2: I'm taking back what I said about zero alcohol beer, but zero alcohol Carlton is really bad.

speaker-1: I think that's the PSA of the whole episode.

speaker-2: ⁓ can we talk a sorry

speaker-0: So are you w are you in favor of a state owned developer? I'm curious. I've we've never discussed this before.

speaker-2: I actually think you need s like this the argument for a state-owned anything is to interrupt into the market to change the behaviour of other incumbents. I work with the community housing sector, which Luke Alpstrap is now running. ⁓ But I think not for prof like the the idea that every development is part of a sort of an effort to maximize profit ⁓ for the developer like creates its own reality and I think finding those disruptions in the market. So whether it's you know a public like it's not necessarily s reconstituting the Department of Public Works, but having governments setting the rules more mindfully because the state's basically being run by developers at the moment.

speaker-0: It was it was your mob that got rid of all this during the Hawk and Keating years, right? So they they undid a lot of the public housing infrastructure that had existed since World War Two and allowed a single income woman who was in the typing pool to be able to afford her own home in Sydney, ⁓ without a partner, like just on her own. Like that all started getting undone. Like we still think of this as a new problem. This problem started in the late eighties as we started Turbocharged because what happened was ⁓ shit, the investment in new ⁓ buildings has gone down. So the Howard era introduced all these changes, which is basically, as you said, turbocharged the inequity, allowed a lot of people to get into homes, but then further kick the problem down the road so much that we're now in this situation where we don't have state or federal developers. Correct. ⁓ that there's no one out there going, Well, we're building specifically for the purpose of getting someone into a home rather than for creating a profit.

speaker-1: Land command.

speaker-0: We have Lankon. Which we don't utilize.

speaker-2: I think we're talking about this the other week though with the Fionas that just like there is all this new technology, there's prefab technology and the potential to manufacture local

speaker-0: And I saw Clara O'Neill mention this at her NPC finally, a bit of after the amount of two years we've been talking about this, I'm like prefab is a big thing. We we pay the highest prices for the worst quality of construction in the world. Like if you tell people in Europe No, we do. I'm sorry, I know we have a lot of regulation.

speaker-2: She's listening to what So

speaker-1: But okay, but this is where I get back to unions and I was at a sorry, I cut you off. I was gonna say that I was at a very large scale development ⁓ recently having a look at what they were doing, building materials, they've got a very high standard of green ⁓ materials, renewable energy embedded, all all the things that you want like glass and internal temperature controls, whatever.

speaker-0: No no no keep going.

speaker-1: It it sounds amazing and it looks amazing and I think it will be world leading in some of the technologies that it employs. But they said that their building probably had about thirty million dollars of extra cost because of unions and fire ratings that were totally out of step with global requirements for fire rating. Like Europe have lots of wood in their houses but have nowhere near the type of restriction or ⁓

speaker-0: Safety or not.

speaker-2: I understand that came from the developers, so it might be a bit like my crowd inflation that you times it by a factor of five. But I I admit that we do pay our workers more than most places.

speaker-1: It's out of step with But no no no it's not it's not paying workers. It's it's actually requiring fireproofing

speaker-0: It's the bureaucracy. Like let's let's be Luke made billions off of Safety Culture, which is literally an entire platform designed to checklist all the bureaucratic bullshit that happens on a construction site. That was born in Australia, that company, for good reason. The amount of bureaucratic paperwork that needs to compliance that needs to be ticked off here, to build a house that is a worse standard than the US, then parts of South America, than anywhere in Europe, and increasingly parts of Southeast Asia, you go, that is crazy. Like we still don't mandate double glazed windows.

speaker-2: And next off we're gonna look at the auctions in Sydney this week. ⁓ so we're a real estate show here. ⁓

speaker-0: So

speaker-1: Was speaking to someone recently, very recently, who said that they were living next to a construction site. They happen to be in building certification. They look at the site and they're like, ooh, there's a lot of dust coming off that site. That's like pretty bad. He managed to go in and look at the forms that were submitted to council and all their approvals. There were like 2,000 pages of these are the things that need to be done to make sure that this worksite is compliant. And the one thing that could have been done to make this a safer Building site was that the contractor just hosed down the site a bit. But that very simple and effective measure. But like when you lose it within two thousand pages, like

speaker-0: I have to tell you one anecdote here before we move on to data centers because i this one particularly fucking grinds my gears. So I have a good mate of mine, they own a dance studio in the what is possibly one of the worst councils in the country, which is inner west. And their dance studio was down the road from the town hall. It was in an old building, the Albert Palais, which has been around for like ninety five years. So they had the bottom floor, which was subground, big three hundred square meter place, then a dance studio, they had a big swing. So they're trying to get their license approval from Inner West Council saying, Hey we We've got a dance studio, we're running it here. Previously it was a wedding, ⁓ you know, like a wedding venue. Now we're just running it a dance studio. Not a huge change. ⁓ they couldn't get their license to operate the venue because they had to have four different people check and come in and put the flood plan together. And they're like, What flood plan? We're we're in like heart. They're ⁓ but there's a canal over there. And it turns out the venue had a full-time pump there to extract water in the occasion that there might be some catastrophic flood. where everyone couldn't get it. And that wasn't enough. They needed to have life preservers on premise in order to meet their requirements in a dance studio in Leichhardt because of flood risk. Like the level of bureaucratic insanity to run a business in some parts of Sydney is ins like it's crazy. And I don't get it. Well yes, that can help with that. Speaking of

speaker-2: Thank God we've now got AI. ⁓ speaking of

speaker-1: But okay, just on that, sorry. Okay, yeah, you've got AI, but you've still someone still has to make a decision of whether those life preservers are being put in. Like the AI will tell you, okay, yeah, it's a one in one hundred year flood risk. But someone has still said, ⁓ no, that's like yeah, it means we still need to protect these small children in the event of a catastrophic flood that's very difficult to imagine.

speaker-2: So you you've basically got honourable ends and it's whether the means to achieve those are doing the job. But but I also think there is a sense that, you know, red tape is code for regulation that people want to either make them feel safe or make the make things fair. Like there are

speaker-1: I'm not a libertarian. I'm not a libertarian, but

speaker-0: Increasingly on Monday it would ⁓ be

speaker-2: Libertarian housing. Libertarian housing policy would be wild though, like just build it build it in the

speaker-1: can. But I mean in a way, yeah, I mean it's difficult because the the calculation that developers make obviously they don't want to flood the market because they want their their Well they want to maximize their profit.

speaker-2: why we need to have a disruption in the like I do think land banking is cynical and contrary to the public interest. I do too I feel like we should move on. and we were going to focus the discussion a bit about the around the inquiry you've been doing into data centers in this up just to ⁓ you've got an AI evangelist, an AI skeptic here but now we've got somebody that knows what's going to be

speaker-1: I do too.

speaker-0: So tell us about the inquiry.

speaker-1: Okay, so do you want me to talk about AI first or data centers within

speaker-2: Yeah, let's talk about the work you've been doing and then maybe round back.

speaker-1: Okay, so the data center inquir inquiry was set up. ⁓ we agreed with the Greens that there was not enough clarity in policy making to either maximize the opportunity, the economic opportunity and social opportunity, or to protect people if data centers are going to come in and take out all our water and all our energy. So we I mean again, the Labour Party is really bringing us together on the left and the right because

speaker-2: They're not asking either three.

speaker-1: Yeah, there's no there's no clarity, there's no strategy, there's no governance. It's like what's the point of getting into power if you're not actually going to make some decisions that allow us all to flourish? And We've had four hearings now as of today. So we're in the Macquarie room today from nine a.m. till two forty-five and we've heard from a range of witnesses. So we've heard from Data Centres Australia, which is the new peak body, we've heard from we heard from one of the ministers today, the Minister for Water. We've heard from Green Peak.

speaker-2: What did the Minister of Water have to say about that green piece? ⁓ the green piece.

speaker-1: So Greenpeace Nature Conservation Council. Yeah, we've heard from the ⁓ Urban Development Institute of Australia. So we've really had a wide range of witnesses, which has been super interesting. We've heard from some ⁓ we've heard from a union. We we've heard from AI specialists, academics. So it has been super interesting.

speaker-2: My good friend Claire Pullen from Riders Guild at one of the

speaker-1: That's right, that's right. And I was on an AI inquiry a couple of years ago as well where we dealt a little bit more with that specific copyright issue. Yeah, yeah, totally. So

speaker-2: It's actually part of data synthesis.

speaker-1: What has emerged is that everybody wants clarity just like we do, and there is very little clarity forthcoming. And the idea that New South Wales would not have a data center strategy which sorts out a set of perhaps precincts, which maps where data centres should be going, whether it's close to water and energy, what kind of grid connections, how many we want, what kind of capacity we can. ⁓ We can deal with what kind of community benefit sharing schemes we might want to implement, what kind of investment data centers could or should be making into local infrastructure. At the moment it's a free-for-all.

speaker-2: There's a huge demand for them, isn't it? Like the pipeline's massive.

speaker-1: The the pipeline is massive and one of the issues that we're finding at the moment is that data centers are trying to invest in renewable energy projects, but because renewable energy projects are stuck in the planning pipeline at the moment, that has pre prevented data centers from being able to get into per power purchasing agreements.

speaker-0: So just for people who don't know, so data we we already have a lot of data centers. So we've got a huge amount of data centers.

speaker-1: We have ninety in New South Wales. Not quite at the scale that they're now being

speaker-0: Yeah. So we with smaller data centers, which is where things like your bank does all its transactions between banks and all that kind of stuff. ⁓ it's where everything happens, modern life happens. Yeah. So they're they're generally big warehousey style blocks with no windows. If you've driven past, you know, grounds of Alexandria or one of those places, you've passed a data center. Yeah. They require a lot of water to stay cool because they generate a lot of heat. Like all all that computer processing generates a lot of heat. And conversely they also require

speaker-1: Every I mean

speaker-0: a stupid amount of electricity in order to keep it running and nonstop electricity because they're running twenty four seven, it's not the kind of thing you shut off at night. So yeah so the big concerns there are land use. Yep. Because you can't build them up. You you generally need to build them out, not up for cooling purposes or something or earthquake there's a whole bunch of reasons

speaker-2: Final witness for the day.

speaker-1: Yeah, well w I raise the question. I think

speaker-2: ⁓ do you build it up or

speaker-1: The Yeah, yeah. Well, what I would say is that data center operators have an incentive to make to maximize the use of the land that they have. They have the incentive to make the data center as efficient as possible when it comes to cooling and energy use. So they the fact that they look the way that they do at the moment, which is pretty spread out. Maybe they've got I don't know 20 stories maybe. ⁓ 20 stories are so high at most. I would say that that represents a kind of technical limitation because you would go up.

speaker-0: Yeah, they they th they still need to. The the h hundredth of a millisecond that it takes the data to get from point A from po to point B matters on the scale that they're working on. So they've got some

speaker-1: Yeah, that's true. Sometimes. And I think this is the reality is that we need different types of data centers for different things. So we need a smaller data center to sit next to the ASX because we need that data to be moving really quickly. And so a lot of fintech and banking happens around that area, around Martin Place and Winyard, because it is super low latency between the

speaker-0: That's the speed at which things get from

speaker-1: ⁓ Exactly. So the

speaker-0: And that's sorry, that's different to like the you know, the the data center that needs your that where your Google Drive stuff.

speaker-1: Yeah, or like Netflix or something.

speaker-2: We also had evidence from the hyperscalers who are trying to do their training centers here because that's another level. Well the hyperscalers are the the people building the models. So it's anthropic, it's open AI, Microsoft, and they've been trying in Canberra to get this deal where Australia basically becomes a hub of the training, which beyond the need to manage the ASX or to manage businesses. Yeah, it's the next level of year.

speaker-0: Ex explain what a hyperscaler is though.

speaker-1: Yeah, that's Totally. So we have heard from Data Centres Australia, which is the new Pete Body.

speaker-2: Well

speaker-1: What? Has become ⁓ what has become an interesting conversation through the inquiry through multiple witnesses, including the Clean Energy Council today, is that data centers can actually play a really helpful role in a majority renewable grid because we actually need stability that can be generated by a massive power user. So that stability in the grid that can be ⁓ that and it can almost be. Like a battery equivalent because the enormous amount of renewables that are is operating during the day, whether it's rooftop solar or wind farms and solar farms, yeah, people are now paying to put that energy back in the grid. Data centers can actually smooth out the use of energy, so it's actually it can be quite beneficial to the point that we heard today. Power prices can be pushed downwards because of

speaker-2: Yeah, the the other thing sorry Dun, the other argument I've had in favor of it is that if we were in a position that we could use renewables to train data and then other parts of the world, that actually becomes a green export like the green hydrogen or the green. That's kind of interesting.

speaker-0: It's also a skill example.

speaker-1: ⁓ absolutely. And I think that the question about resource use seems to be less about energy and more about water. So the water concern and the water constraints for Australia and for New South Wales are definitely the thing that is that needs to be worked out more than the electricity grid.

speaker-2: And the other tricky bit is the copyright that these guys have trained their models on

speaker-1: It's a bit of a separate issue.

speaker-2: But in terms of the hyperscalers, like they would be operating illegally in Australia if they wanted to do that without sorting the copyright issue out.

speaker-1: Well, I think that most hyperscalers are now looking at copyright agreements. Like they have realized globally that's right. And that I mean obviously it's difficult to go back, but there are like each hyperscaler has started building out agreements with specific organizations that license data now.

speaker-0: So And so the concerns with these data centers, land usage, water usage, power usage. The opportunity there is that we could actually become a hub for the region because we're politically stable, geologically stable. We've actually got a lot of really good fiber connections through the sea to a lot of neighbors, which is really beneficial. Yeah. ⁓ and we could also get the opportunity to actually train people in because you still have you still have humans who have to operate these data centers, keep them online, put them together, flick cables over, whatever else it is they do.

speaker-1: Yeah. And we spoke about apprentices today actually and the opportunities for

speaker-2: have to do something when AI takes all the drugs. ⁓

speaker-1: Yeah.

speaker-2: get there like I I I floated last week the idea of ⁓ a sovereign wealth fund around like so if it's gonna be as big as this with data centers and AI maybe that's where you're alluding to but sh why shouldn't we be taking a stake in that? Yeah. We like why why should we just be assuming that we're gonna be able to tax these guys when evidence says they'll find a way of not paying the taxes.

speaker-1: Yeah, I I think it's a really good question and I think it's an interesting one. This is where I go back to thing like Libras like Landykes, for example. Like if we are going to we are going to make the most of the investment opportunity over time. Like land tax is such a yeah a simple way in my mind. Like it's quite an elegant way to ensure that people who are making lots of money. And and actually we heard today a really interesting

speaker-2: You get the Georgia sin.

speaker-1: Yeah, I love a Georgist. I love a Georgist, Henry George. And George came to Australia. Like he was here in the late 1800s. And actually we globally died to the Georgist. Really? Like his grandfather or something. Definitely some of our earliest prime ministers were influenced by George. And it explains why we have a reasonably sophisticated land valuing system. It's much more sophisticated than most. I know, I know. Absolutely. And and I have reached out to them as well. Yeah, I think it I think it's a really interesting way that we can capture value that is all of ours, right? Like yeah, private property rights are very important, but they're

speaker-0: There are some communal things that we can we hear and you know we we we've your mate Andrew Charlton often gets up and and you know tells every Australian business that they need to start leaning into Australian AI instead of all this foreign AI. That's my Andrew Charlton impression.

speaker-2: I think he's slightly better spoken than that, but

speaker-0: He's a Paramount MP now, so he needs to get the ball in there. the thing is

speaker-2: But

speaker-0: The thing is we we don't have any Australian AI. Not true it's Australian AI. And and the fact is But taking a stake in the big boys is not the same as having sovereign capability of AI. And we can't come into this twenty years after these things have developed when we've had unfavorable conditions for twenty years for entrepreneurs and innovators and go, you know what? We want an AI model. It's like sure, okay, well let's invest a hundred billion dollars in building one like the money up.

speaker-2: But we take a stake in the big boys, but you go.

speaker-1: Right. And and Yeah, and that is actually right. And ⁓ Dr. Su Kaye, who is the director of the UNSW AI Institute, gave evidence to us today and spoke about exactly this. Like the the sovereign AI model or or the definition of sovereignty is really loose at the moment. And federal labor seem to be saying, well, sovereignty is just what we can get from someone and we bought it. But real sovereignty is actually capability development, it's actually having model that exactly like health data. It's not just language. It's actually much language it you can Yeah, it can be sensory based data.

speaker-0: Having our own intellectual property.

speaker-2: Yeah. Right. Did you see when ⁓ Mark Carney, the Canadian PM, came to Australia, he was talking about middle powers operating on a

speaker-1: Yeah. I am so I'm so interested in that. And I

speaker-2: Yeah.

speaker-0: The Kansuk LLM the Kansuck LLM where it's like Canada, Australia, New Zealand and the UK getting together and going Because at the moment, like as we've talked about, they're taking different approaches to their arms race because you said it on me. But we're standing here.

speaker-1: It could be kanta.

speaker-2: Of the

speaker-0: Got all these politicians going out there and going, Well businesses need to use Australian AI and you go, Great, sh show it to me. Like invest in it. Get like pave a way forward for there to be an Australian alternative.

speaker-2: engine and then there is the data and I think one of the things we we look at it as one thing and there's all these different component parts so I'm particularly interested in the Australian data that is training the models because I think that's really valuable and it's and you know it it it reflects our values and if you could find a way of doing that I think it would be a better model. But then there is also like how do you run how do you run a health business using

speaker-0: I don't This is where and again this is where we deeply disagree and my libertarianism comes out where I go every time government gets involved, what happens is a company comes in and goes, Great, we want to train on your data to produce an Australian-centric AI. And we go, hang on a minute. We need to set up a six-year parliamentary inquiry process into how you're going to use our data, what copyright you're going to pay like we we end up in a process like

speaker-1: Revolutionized the way that government data was used. Yes. Like, absolutely revolutionized it. And he and Professor Ian Opperman, who is our chief data scientist, now a commissioner at the ACCC. By the way, State Labour cut the chief data scientist position in New South Wales as soon as they got in. Literally, two months later, Federal Labour picked up Ian as the federal chief data scientist. Like the data is the key. Yep. And Dominello oversaw a rollout of open. Open data, open government data was interesting. Absolutely. And it was about making data useful.

speaker-0: And New South Wales is the best base of opening.

speaker-2: But it was also about restoring faith in the public. You know, one of the things I've been doing because I did a lot of work for the public sector f union for years. Yeah. And we used to always do this research where what's a public servant? ⁓ they're the person with the cardia and, you know, whinging about the world. And all of a sudden the image changed because people are having a really good customer experience.

speaker-1: remarkable and it's a big risk because if all of the if that rollout of ⁓ service neuth wales the updated service ne southwales app for example in covet if that had gone wrong it would have decimated confidence in government service delivery for probably a decade and it would be very difficult to have any faith that governments could engage in digital service delivery.

speaker-0: I mean you y still to this day you go to other states and ⁓ many of them are their minds are blown at the idea of digital licenses still. Totally ⁓

speaker-1: Blockchain secure technology. Like this was in 2019, 2007.

speaker-2: And I still

speaker-0: Do I have to fill out a paper slip when I come back from overseas that no one's ever gonna read?

speaker-2: The bigger thing that I think that Victor did with that service New South Wales was you basically automate the ninety percent but you have a really good personal experience for the ten percent as a point of friction. And that's a really resource.

speaker-1: That's where digital. Yeah, that's where human experience and digital technologies are at their best where AI, my my hope is that AI can make us more human. But I am also rather than transhuman. Yeah, well sure. Absolutely.

speaker-2: Because we did have the Pope this week talking about this.

speaker-0: So I'm very excited about that. Just if anyone from the government is listening, Peter Lewis and I are available to build an Australian LLM donations starting from sixty billion dollars upwards. We are happy to

speaker-1: I would like a chat bot version of this podcast where it's just both of you but AI version.

speaker-2: We're halfway there with Klaus. ⁓ I reckon it's time to get into predictions as well.

speaker-0: What are your so my just I'm recapping on my last prediction about the enhanced games. I thought James Magnus. He absolutely

speaker-2: he didn't finish and worse, he lost to people that weren't taking drugs. No, but I think that's great. That's what

speaker-0: Because it's a demonstration of you know what, does the drugs themselves are not the answer, right? They're they're an element.

speaker-1: Exactly. I think that was a fabulous result for like this kind of looks maxing, toxic.

speaker-0: Well for everyone except for enhanced who pumped a lot of money into this event and their share price.

speaker-2: You're you're you're on a three strike ⁓ straight. So you've your predictions have flopped the last three weeks. What's this one?

speaker-0: I'm gonna go the other way 'cause I'm expecting my prediction to flop this week. Okay. I think ⁓ Albo and Chalmers are gonna have a smooth sailing introduction of all their budgetary measures into legislation.

speaker-2: What with green support or with and what's the ⁓ are the coalition gonna what are they gonna do?

speaker-1: Totally shouldn't vote again.

speaker-0: They'll vote against it obviously. But I I I think I I'm intentionally predicting that so it fails, obviously. ⁓ because I've now had three in a row that have been completely misproven. So my hope is that they don't get it through smooth sailing. But that's my prediction.

speaker-1: I think that the government will finally finally release the two documents that it the state government, New South Wales Labour, will finally release the two documents that the upper house has been calling for. So there's a character reference provided by Chris Minnes, with Jamie Clements, and the second one is the Saka report, which is the the Honourable Justice Saka wrote a report for government about ⁓ hate crimes and how legislation should interact with social behavior relating to things like free speech. And the government is putting forward legislation about this issue, but refusing to release this review that the taxpayers paid for.

speaker-2: And but s follow up question, do you think the revelations will be red hot or much ado about nothing and it's just being an exercise of power?

speaker-1: Red hot. Why would you go through all of this? It's shocking.

speaker-2: I don't lock upper houses. No one locked upper houses.

speaker-1: Let's

speaker-2: All right, so I'll finish with my prediction, which is pretty niche. The Indian Premier League, which is this This is cricket. This is cricket, but it's it's twenty over cricket. It's this thing that's emerged over the last twenty years. It's become this, you know, with a population of a being it's taken over cricket. and I've become quite addicted to watching the KO mini of a T twenty which goes for eighteen minutes, which is everything is just either a six or a wicket, but it's got its own certain rhythm. But the dominant player is a fifteen year old who has scored the most runs the most like he he he hits it about a f every second ball a four or a six. There's a kid called Suravanchi and ⁓ in a pot and it's it's just so amazing to watch most he's mainly playing against people, you know, 25 to 30. And this is a huge like these are this is a big serious league, but it just shows what a country of a billion people there is going to be the black swan. And it is just amazing to watch a 15 year he he debuted year ago at fourteen and like I look at it it's it's just amazing to watch. So if even if you're not into cricket, if you are subs if you are sort of giving your charity to ⁓ KO and Murdoch, I don't think they own them anymore, but I'm still but it's worth having a look at. ⁓ the Rajasthan Royals to win the IPL. The Rajasthan Royals

speaker-0: Rajasthan Royals.

speaker-1: KO for F1. So

speaker-2: He's a big team and he's amazing. Anyway, on that note, if you like this, share it. I haven't done all that stuff that we should be sharing and all that. But also general strategic on Substack, burning platforms on Substack. Are you on Substack? Jack are you on Substack?

speaker-1: Yeah, I'm on Substack. Yeah, thanks. I wrote a lot about middle powers actually in my last one. Yeah, yeah, quite right. I'm empty. I don't know if I can cheese you with an empty. That's even worse last year.

speaker-0: Writings on there all all her own work. Thank you for coming in. Hi. Thank you for watching us. This has been Murphy the Dog, by the way, who's very ⁓ patiently been sitting at my feet waiting for us. No, he loves it. ⁓ we'll be here again. Like, follow, subscribe. We'll be here again next Friday. Thank you very much. ⁓ we'll see you next week. Thanks.

speaker-2: Coming in and not talking with us.