Episode 9
Submarines, Sovereignty, and Strong Personalities
With Francis Leach & Parnell Palme McGuinness
Show notes
Guests: Parnell Palme McGuinness and Francis Leach
This week we discuss political tribalism, careers across media and politics. Labor passing budget measures, Allegra Spender’s protest, and AUKUS shifting to three used submarines and long timelines. AUKUS as deeper US integration, deterrence and sea-lane security, changing warfare via drones, nuclear sensitivities, and Australia’s energy and industrial strategy. We unpack Tony Abbott becoming Liberal Party president as potentially useful but risky for overshadowing leadership and demographics. We talk One Nation/Barnaby Joyce policy confusion, outsider vs insider politics, and end with our weekly predictions.
09:12 Tribalism In Politics
12:17 Week In Canberra
13:22 AUKUS
19:56 Defense And Deterrence
22:11 Tech And Future Warfare
27:30 Neoliberalism And Industry
33:08 Tony Abbott Returns
40:37 Abbott As Future Or Folly
43:39 Barnaby One Nation Policy Gaffe
44:15 One Nation Contradictions And Doubts
47:58 Outsiders Versus The System
52:15 Kiss Of Death Predictions
Full transcript
Read itHide it
Transcribed automatically, so expect the odd misheard name.
Damian DamjanovskiWhat's your poison? Say it straight. What's your poison? Drink with me. Welcome to What's Your Poison, the show where people who disagree about almost everything agree that it's better to do so over a drink. My name is Damer Domyanovsky. I'm a principal here at General Strategic. And I'm joined by my evil twin, Mr. Peter Lewis. Peter, happy Friday. What's your poison? Happy Friday. My poison's got a Little short story to it, I was tasked with finding an Inner West branded beer today as a gift for somebody. And what I found out was they brand their politicians. You can get a hawk, you can get an elbow, but I had to go all the way to Batch Brewery to get a Marrickville original. ⁓ I'm about to have my first taste of it, but I'm assuming it's gonna taste very Marrickville. Tastes like a craft beer. That's Marrickville. There's no edge to Marriottville anymore. It's just a warehouse of breweries. I gotta admit, I'm back to a lemon weapon because it's just so hard to say no to a hard rated or a hard solo as us ⁓ classicists call it. So cheers to you. ⁓ and who have you brought along this week, Mr. Lewis? I've got ⁓ a very good friend of mine who must be Australia's premier political polymath. ⁓ Francis Leach. I'll just give you a really short CB and embarrass Frank because I think there'd be a whole hour podcast talking about your life, mate. But ⁓ I first became aware of it when he had the coolest job in Australia, which was hosting the Triple J Morning Show nationally. ⁓ then he managed to talk himself into being a sports reporter and he sort of covered major events. He used to be on the Outsiders Couch, which is the sports version of the insiders. Then for some reason he rings me one day and says, ⁓ what do you think about working for the CFMEU? Gave him some life advice and he still took the job, worked in the ACTU, because started working with a bunch of, you know, this is what I say, a polymath, doing it all. And then ⁓ worked for a number of MPs over the last couple of years, including the great Ann Urkhart, my favorite Australian politician. Jess Walsh had a go with Zoe against Tim Wilson. So a few war stories there and finished off with ⁓ Basim Abdo, who's one of the most interesting young politicians in Australia, we might get to that as well. But Francis, that's a lot to be carrying around in your head any one day. But how are you and what's your poison? What a mad life. ⁓ my poison is in fact a neighborhood brew, and because I can't keep away from politics, I bought this when I was down with my friend Tracy Hutchison, who ran in the seating to pee in in the l the recent ⁓ by election, the Victorian state election. ⁓ and her ⁓ she was an ex Triple J reporter. Indeed, we we we stick we we stick pretty close, us Triple J people and she ran and ⁓ so she had her ⁓ her a party at the neighborhood brewery. And so I I never turn up and not buy from the local brewery. You've got to buy, right? You can't just turn up and do a bought a bunch of and it's actually very good, I've got to say. So well done to those people down on the morning to Peninchula. I love your work. Yeah. Did you have the shrinkflation I discovered today? A case has become sixteen cans. What? Like and a six pack's become a four pack and a case has become sixteen. It's like the Tim Tans of craft beer. Outrageous. You know how the French started a revolutionary bread? This is our moment. When they start taking away our beer, we start heading to the barricades. ⁓ that's when we're gonna go to the Centre of Independent Studies for an independent ⁓ bit of modelling on this. So, Darma, who have you bought along today? ⁓ I've brought a ⁓ along ⁓ Parnell Par McGuinness, who is a great friend and obviously has a very esteemed ⁓ history across the the center right of politics. ⁓ I'll let Parnell talk about some of her amazing achievements, but not just in Australian political life, also ⁓ over in Europe, in Germany. She's done some interesting work over there. She's currently with the Centre for Independent Studies doing some very important work ⁓ and campaigning on a number of issues that ⁓ I think all Australians should or do care about. So, Parnell, what's your poison this week? Well, mine does a have a really interesting story like you guys just told. I've got my favourite whiskey, the Balvini twelve year old. I just like I'm part of the whiskey club, but I've finished off all the interesting whiskeys, so I'm just back to the standard. Whiskey clubs? So I didn't know about these things. How do I join? ⁓ you j like I send you a referral link, that's how, and then I get a freebie. ⁓ Panel, I've always wanted to ask you this to start off. In your column, which I read avidly, ⁓ you have this beautiful fig leaf that you have worked for the liberals and the German Greens. What did you do for the Greens? And then I'm going to give you a bit of a t a quiz because I've got Patty Manning's inside the greens, 550 pages of a book that needed You're assuming that the Greens is the fig leaf. It could be that the Liberal Party is the fig leaf. She's been an entrist, I thought but but what was the gig? So it was a very small piece of work. Just as I should say the Liberals' work was a very small piece of work. And so when they asked me, when they said, ⁓ we have to put a disclosure at the end of your column to say that you've worked for the Liberals, I said, Well, to be fair then, we should also disclose that I've worked for the German Greens. So what I did for them, this is years and years ago when I was ⁓ you know, bumming around Germany being terribly feckless, ⁓ I did some work for them on their When the Greeds were well, when everybody was doing their EU policies and the j and the Greeds were writing up their policies on on various things, including free movement of peoples. So I worked on the free movement of peoples, which is incredibly ironic. So this would have been just post unification or a bit further down? No, no, this was a bit later on. ⁓ but you know, it's all of that stuff, all of that bureaucratic stuff takes an awfully long time. So it's ⁓ They you know, and then they have to they have to conceive it and then they have to write it up and then they have to turn it over and so on. And so they were all unifying their ⁓ their various policies and submitting them to the EU and saying this is how we conceive of what the what our part in the EU will be. ⁓ and so I was I was on the free movement of people stuff, which I believed back then, but I also was living in At the same time in a ghetto that clearly wasn't working. And it started dawning on me that there was a little bit of you know that what I was writing about in practice didn't work out quite so well. ⁓ and so maybe that was the beginning of my real political awakening. That's fair. Well, the other thing I wanted to just before we get into the politics, ⁓ you had a very famous dad who gave you the double P. That he had, who also went on a pretty remarkable political journey. I know Frank knows a bit about this story too, because we're all gr we we all brought up in the left to hate PP McGuinness because he'd been the communist who'd rat it out. But he was he he'd been a communist. He worked for Bill Hayden as a policy guy. And then he ended up editing quadrants. So he did that whole journey. ⁓ what was it like growing up knowing like with a dad like that? Well, I mean, obviously I didn't know anything different. So it was great. I mean, it was fine. It was just what it was. Everyone hated everyone's father. It wasn't until I was older that I thought, ⁓ my God, like I I got to hang out with John Newfont on my balcony when the when he came over, you know, famous indigenous journalist, ⁓ who was just absolutely marvelous, a really thoughtful guy and would just drop around. You know, I I got to hang out with these people who were from my dad's past and would mingle from my dad's present and they would argue with one another and it was, you know, a wonderful environment. But of course I I just thought that this is how people live. I wish they did find out. I wish we had that sort of still that conversation ongoing. I'm just wondering with Dad, was he still talking to his former comrades or was or I there would have been some bridges that were completely broken because of the way the ideologies spit, but he still able to have those difficult conversations with people? Across the ideological divide and have a contest of ideas or was it just too broad? Insofar as they would speak to him, he would always speak to them. Okay. So he was always big on debate. And in fact, you know, he'd drink at the Unity Hotel in Belmane, which is ⁓ was just up the road from where we were. Home of Labor, yeah. ⁓ and so he'd drink there and of course he'd get joined at at the table by various people who wanted to pick pick a hole on his column or have a barney with him and he loved it. You absolutely loved it. Because he was writing for the Oz, wasn't he? So you totally followed in those. He moved between papers. So he was of of course he was editor in chief of the Financial Review for a while. And then he also ⁓ worked for he came back and was a ⁓ wrote for the Australian, was a columnist for the Australian, ⁓ and then also moved to the Sydney Morning Herald for a while. So I like he wrote for everybody. At some point. I think ⁓ we've got a a good theme, Peter, this week of ⁓ polymaths, both Parnell and Francis, obviously, and the heritage there. Parnell as well. We shouldn't just talk about her dad anyway, either. Like, exactly right. I think ⁓ it's quite fascinating because I think for people who don't aren't on the inside, the assumption is that so you you pick a team and you kind of stick it out for life and you've Well, can I say that, Damien? I I had I had a recent experience of that because I've been heavily involved in the Labour politics and the year liver, which is deep in my family history. I came to it late. But ⁓ it was always gonna happen at some point. But when I stepped out ⁓ three or four years ago because Zoe Daniel was a a dear friend and someone I admire enormously, ⁓ because I think she was a great candidate and one of the people that I think should be in Parliament, ⁓ and stepped away from my Labour affiliations, that was difficult because I I made that choice, not because ⁓ because ⁓ on an ideological basis, but because I thought this person is someone who should remain in Parliament. So I ran her campaign. But I you know, it was hard and there were some people and two there are a lot of people within the traditional party system that understood the pragmatic nature of that. Right ⁓ to the very top I had those conversations, but there were some people in the Labour Party at a very high level who still haven't forgiven me and never will because the tribalism is so deep. And I think that's corrosive. ⁓ and it's not good. It's not good for our politics, our body politics in general. It's we need to The only reason I hang out with Damien is that no one on the left likes me anymore. So I think it's gotta find a new tribe. And I mean look Warren Mundine's one of the more famous Labour defectors, isn't he? He's he's probably one of you Yeah, they I would say that's a history. There's a history. There's a huge history of Labour rats, like the but they're the politicians, the staff as it's different Billy Hughes started it during World War One. Yeah, that was a big one. But I I I think that's a bit different in that he Mundine was bitter and he's bitter and called it out. Was I was able to go back to Labour Party and work in Parliament, which is what we are what amazingly so. But ⁓ but I think it's you don't get a lot of examples of people in the centre right moving over to Labour though. I don't think there's a lot of examples. Well, no, but there should be more, I think. There was Robert Mann, of course. Robert Mann lo moved in that direction. ⁓ Would you say Cheryl Kernel? I don't know enough about it. She crossed the threshold, literally. Yeah. Yeah, but before we move into the week's politics, I have to ask Parnell about the ⁓ the sign over your shoulder, the never be boring. Is this a a life motto or Well, look, it sort of. I was in a bar in c in Laos with a friend of mine and ⁓ you know, it was this little cocktail bar with this wonderful v you know, wonderful vibe. And they had a they had a bunch of postcards up and around the walls and and posters and one of them said, we ⁓ all God does is watch us And kill us if we get boring. We must never ever be boring. And it turns out that was a quote from the Borneck book. But I didn't recognise it. I just really liked the quote. It stuck with me. You know, all God does is watch us and kill us if we get boring. Kill us if we get boring. Never be boring. Wow. No, I love that. That's awesome. I'll moving on to the the week. Obviously, it's been a big week. It was a sitting week in Canberra. ⁓ Labour managed to pass its budget measures in the lower house, not without a bit of a a fight. ⁓ I think most notably was obviously the lovely Allegra Spender, ⁓ the teal for Wentworth, ⁓ decided to protest against it after being the one to table lot of the measures. It was her her policy and then went, wait a minute, my voters might not like this. ⁓ I think we should slow down and consider, which which was a hilarious faux pas. ⁓ AUKUS suddenly went from being a Two old submarines, one new one, two three old submarines. And hilariously at Senate estimates, nobody from the department could answer that other than to say, ⁓ no, no, no, we always wanted three used submarines. That's what the Department of Defense has always been looking for. ⁓ and Tony Abbott, ⁓ now president of the the Liberal Party. So that's that's an interesting one. I don't know where you want to start, Peter. Well, almost go, I don't know, w which order, but that that feels like a lot to dig into. I thought You know, let's start with AUKUS and I'm I'm particularly interested in your take up front. So Labour is committed to a policy not of their making that if they designed it, I don't think they would have designed, but they made a pragmatic political decision before not the last election, but the election before that. Nothing. No, just jump in there, Peter. They they they also took they also took that policy decision decision within twenty four to forty eight hours of being in Correct. So it was a absolute decision ⁓ To to not be tampered. They did not want to be tampered by it. So they decided to get in in the slipstream of it without consideration. But instead of not being wedged on a piece of performative border protection, they instead have this hundred year commitment to a failing American empire. And I think, you know, they've got to they've got to own that. ⁓ they're trying to manage it. It's an unstable regime. A lot of people inside the Labour Party are starting to go WTF and we haven't even got to looking at the real deal, which is not the subs, but the technology, and we totally lock ourselves into the American tech dystopia forever. Before before I pull the failing American empire and and and the other things thrown in there. I think it's fair to say that, you know, Labour's never been a necessarily a big supporter of bud of defense expenditure when they're in government. And now that the the idea of going against AUKUS might be more palatable to some in Labour. I think that that I think they're showing a bit more of their true colours, which is we never really wanted to support this in the first place. If it was up to us, the whole world would get along. We'd sing Kumbaya and we'll we'd all everything would be great. ⁓ dismissing the realities of everything that's going on in the world. You you don't want to give away too much, but you n you you you were working in there. You must have seen Labour coming on that. Like that was They were damned if they did, they were damned if they didn't. And they just Yeah, course they they they had to go along with it. But I I I don't think and I still to this day, I'm not sure that Labour understands the point of AUKUS is not just submarines. The point is The technology. The US like we are not just an ally of the US. Like we are embedded without the five Eyes network, without the the assurance policies, without our shared technology base. We're not a middle power. We're a nothing. Like the That alliance is one of the only things that holds back. And I'm not talking just about China, but like we have a lot of frenemies within our zone. ⁓ and the threat of the United States and the United States military and making sure they are as embedded in the Australian military complex as possible is what keeps them from looking at Australia as a target. What do you guys reckon? I know. I reckon you just want China to hurry on over so that you can go straight to communism. Isn't that the point of the budget? Well at least it'll run of it'll run efficiently then, finally. No, I mean seriously. It's of course Dave's completely right. That is well and it should be obvious to anybody that that's what it's about. I mean, that's literally what Trump has been doing with his whole tariff scheme. It's not really about tariffs. It's about the nations of the world paying for the protection that they get from the US. And essentially and we become a protection racket. And for well, but you know, what because they've been actually of that protection racket. That's right, that's right. I I would like to jump in here and say that the the the the World Order established after World War Two established the rules based order created the greatest growth, economic growth in the history of mankind. And the reason why it did was because We established peace and and free transit of of goods and services across borders in a mostly peaceful way, which benefited all parties. So the United States grew exponentially as a consequence of the success of the rules-based order. It was not just a unilateral deliverer of power, energy, and military force. It w fully understood as the Marshall Plan at the very start of this established that it was in its own best interest to buttress and improve the the quality of the ⁓ economies ⁓ beyond its own borders. In order to elevate its own economic power. It's in its own self interest to make sure that its allies are economically stable, it's politically stable and prosperous. And intervened in so many democratic movements to assert its power too. And it cannot just be a it can't transactional arrangement. And if that's what this has become, we're in real trouble. Well, but it I mean, on the other hand, like the the US has been begging the rest of the world to pay a little bit towards their own defence for years now. And they were screwing around because they could. So, you know, Germany's defence spending was at one point three percent. Right? That is just But the trade off was to be serfs in their global economy. Like we were like they were getting their payments economically, not through How? In what way? Because the whole world bended to the power of American corporations until the whole value? Just the satisfaction, or was there actually some some tangible benefit that we can I no, I think there was a legitimate ⁓ mutual self interest and the values that America purported to sell were values that people wanted to be part of, right? Well, that the there was the economic, there was the values, but but they've chi and the values have shifted. They've gone way ahead of us in terms of individualism in my view. Like ⁓ maybe, but I think that the economic benefit to the US that's worth noting is as long as the world trades in US dollars, the US has an unfair economic advantage. So of course it's in their best interest. But but I mean I would say that we've come close in the last three or four years where the US dollar was not going to be the principal currency in the world. And we've got very, very close to people thinking that we're going to revert back to the gold standard as a consequence of the instability going crypto We're going crypto. Well that's it. But just want to say that. We're not going crypto. The only labor person I've ever met who wants to go crypto. The only labor person I've met who knows what crypto is. One in eight Americans have crypto. Their long term plan is to get us all using their d de decentralized currency base. And then we're genuine surfs forever. And then we can go seasteading, you know, and be truly free on international waters. So just just bringing us back to the topic. So The the political play here from Labour, right? So I I'm curious as to what everyone thinks. We've gone way out there. Yeah. They have to swallow the fact that the US has basically gone, look, we're gonna slightly renege on the deal here. You're gonna get three used subs that are gonna be, according to Deputy PM Miles, at least fifteen years old by the time they arrive. We're not gonna get any new subs, and it's at least another fifteen years before we build our first sub in Australia. Can I just jump in on this and say The fifteen years I think is irrelevant. What it's really about is these platforms become the ability to project power, which Australia as a seagoing nation desperately needs. And I I really do take issue with those on the left and labor party who look at the bill and just go, $360 million or whatever it is, it's a lot of money. Yeah, well yeah, we rely absolutely, lock, stock, and barrel as a nation, on having free sea tra ⁓ lanes and the ability to trade freely. And if we do not have A deterrent force that projects power and the capacity to actually have that as we are a really vulnerable. And we saw that during the pandemic, where we couldn't even make the most basic things because we'd become a service nation of just delivering raw materials to other nations and and buy back in bulk. And I will say that that's a consequence of a neoliberal policy of previous governments who thought, you know, the sun was going to shine forever and that we would have free trade that would just deliver cheap goods to Australia after delivering Our natural resources without imposing any tariff or any cost on actually extracting those resources. And now we're struggling without any sort of ⁓ sovereign wealth fund to actually pay for the things that we want. But the legacy of all that stuff is so profound and it's that they're so very vulnerable that yes, the submarines are really, really important. I'm and it's such short termism, it's really easy for people to go, ⁓ who needs submarines? Well, I'm telling you, we need submarines, we need the capacity to project our power beyond our borders. And to protect ourselves. So I am all in all because it's not the best arrangement. What the hell have I better than paddling around in a couple of Collins Car submarines like we're still in a Cales Navy? Apart from that little diversion engineer, I was about to say this is why they won't send you back into the Labour Party. Is this official teal policy though? I should also say that ⁓ Francis has started the ABC overnight shift, so he's not being political on this podcast at all. No, I'm nobody's I'm nobody's prison. This is me thinking, I need the submarines to protect me. Well and and I think what's interesting, Francis, just to build on what you said, is obviously what we're seeing in Iran and what we've seen in the Ukraine is the nature of warfare's changing where ⁓ like for like ⁓ capacity in terms of armaments, where it's no longer a ⁓ fight of my billion dollar missile versus your billion dollar missile. It's now your billion dollar missile versus my one thousand, twenty thousand dollar drones. And that changes the economics of warfare. And weirdly, Australia with its ⁓ ghost bat and the ghost shark. So if you if if you're listening and you don't know what they are, basically Australia's been at the forefront of developing both autonomous flying wingmen to jet fighters, which is called the ghost bat system, and autonomous s small submarines that are based like drones in the sea, ⁓ called ⁓ ghost sharks. And this technology is significantly cheaper. than the hundreds of billions we're spending on the nuclear subs, but you c you need both. You need a handful of the the big crazy weapons and then the ability to produce tens of thousands of these inexpensive ordinances. I know I'm owning the floor here a little bit, but I'm a little bit obsessed with this topic and I'll I'll ⁓ I'll ⁓ we've seen you go but the the the important part later if you're over yeah yeah the important part is that that that that un the the the unknown is is powerful. So having the capacity to have a su a nuclear submarine that can be undetectable and in waters where they can't be found pr produces the moment or at least the dynamic of the undone, which is a moment for pause for any possible ⁓ hostile force. And that's really, really important. The the the biggest concern for me after watching Vivid is that we can't get drones right. Like if we can't get display drones to display for ten seconds at a vivid flight show How are we going to be Like this is beyond AUKUS. One of the reasons we're having this debate is because people don't like or people on the left don't like the idea that Australia might get used to having nuclear powered something. So, you know, we like to forget the Lucas Heights reactor. ⁓ and AUKUS seems like a a sort of sly way of getting nuclear into Australia, which frankly I'm all for. Like, I mean, let's bring it on. ⁓ so you would be, yeah. It's that's not in a derog no, that's not in a derogatory way. Like I think there is a certain generation which is I got politicized as a member of the nuclear disarmament party. My first vote, I think we said a few weeks ago was Garrett. I've always been an anti-nuclear guy. ⁓ I still am an anti-nuclear guy. But I think the bigger thing is nuclear power. No, let's not go there now because I think there's a whole show. But I wanted to move to the bigger point is I think for the left. We are making a long-term strategic decision that our future is tied to America's. And more and more people are saying we don't want that future. We don't want China, but they are our largest trading partner. And then you've got a guy like Mark Carney turning up saying, Let's build our own middle power autonomy across some middle powers, because we know, particularly with the tech which we're signing up to, don't love China, don't love America either. Like we've got to find a better way of getting there, and we're locking ourselves out of that if we go down this path. No, no, no. But I'm gonna lose three one on this because I think Frank's with you guys. But anyway, that's just hear me out. Isn't that the equivalent of people going, I don't want to vote Labour and I don't want to vote liberal, so I'm gonna vote for my community independent and we'll find a third way to do politics. And it's like, yeah, people have had this dream for a hundred years. I know we end up with these uneasy cold. Like sorry, twenty percent. Sorry, I gave him an extra one. What do you reckon, Panel? Like there's so the politics of this is interesting because I think Frank and I are demonstrating within Labor there is I don't I'm not gonna pigeonhole you as a pragmatist, but I feel like we've got a different position on this. And I think that will play out under the surface at ALP National Conference in July. Massive. Yeah. And you know, like I'm interested, you know, what's the vibe you've just been working in a like with a Palestinian MP in outer Melbourne, like what's the vibe on the ground, do you think, towards AUKUS? Like when I poll it, most people are okay with it. Like I'm not pretending I've got the world on my side. I think it's a false economy that goes on that they see the money that's spent or the money that's attached to the AUKUS project relative to their personal needs when it comes to service delivery. ⁓ and that they the idea is that you need to be able to just shift that money across in order to provide services that are required in those communities and should be available to those communities. It's hard to have that strategic argument around well, the only reason why we can be able to at any point provide a stable economy and a society that feels stable is to have a security setup that allows us to do that. So it's not easy. It's a very difficult conversation. I I feel like we could talk about AUKUS for some time, but I do I do want to move on. I don't know if if Parnell you had any further thoughts before we tie up on it No, I mean I think it's been very well summed up. Like I would I would put myself one hundred One hundred percent in Frank's camp there, except for the little excursion into neoliberalism. ⁓ which which which was, you know, everything it was like tick tick tick tick. Whoa. I always I always like it when we when we have these little excursions, especially on neoliberalism, because you you're sort of you you have all of that strategic stuff absolutely right, but this blind spot on how we got rich enough to be having these problems. ⁓ it's Like we are until we weren't. So yeah, but but we are. We are rich. And neoliberalism, you know, these this free trade did get us there. Now, absolutely, we should probably have had a bit of what I call strategic sovereignty thinking coming in here. Like, I don't believe in national sovereignty because that's how nations stay poor, is not trading with others. But we should be strategic about the goods and services that we lead in. For instance, if China is dumping goods into Australia cheaply because it wants to make us dependent on them, or it can make them cheaply and would rather offload them here. But I think rather the first is more of the problem, then we should examine that. If BYD cars ⁓ are too questionable for ministers to drive about in because they might have compromising conversations, which are reported back to China. Perhaps we need to have a discussion about whether BYD cars should be imported into Australia. So we did it with Huawei, didn't we? We we we banned it. That's right, exactly. And so I do think we need to. You also closed down the automobile industry with glee. Yeah, but nobody was buying the cars. Strategically an issue that we don't have I mean, you know, like if we really supply chain, I don't know. It's not a strategic issue that we don't have a car industry. It's a strategic issue that we don't have a viable element. Manufacturing industry ⁓ we can't print our own houses to make cheap houses in state. Because we haven't electrified fast enough. We can't electrify without energy. Sorry, Francisco. That's a massive strategic own goal, not to have the foresight to protect heavy industry because heavy industry at any point in any ⁓ nation's ⁓ history has to be capable of pivoting and being available military and strategic production. Which is exactly what Trump's done in Detroit, right? He basically said to all the car makers. Now the best what has caused Co invest, not profitable heavy industry in Australia to go out of business. It's the fact that ⁓ we have it we have high wage prices and now we also have high energy costs. Now you can have one or the other. You can't have both and heavy industry. So there is no point. There is absolutely no point making our energy ⁓ high price. I'm happy for us to be a high wage company ⁓ country. Let's keep that. But then if we're gonna do that, we're gonna have to allow resources to be used that are available in Australia to bring down the price of energy because we're not there yet with renewables, and having the government propping up these heavy industry taxpayer money. I know I think your position's absolutely right for now, but strategic vision requires the ability to plan and to deal with the transition. And so they will get to a point where we can afford a you know renewable load that will allow us to have heavy industry and we need to be able to endure to that point. Do you think the Chinese are thinking that in short term isn't that because the cost of their energy might be so high that they're not going to endure with their long term strategic plan with whatever industry they're in. We need to be able to say, yes, we will we will absorb heavier costs for our industry in order to preserve a strategic capacity and then move to a ⁓ self sufficient green energy or a renewable energy process in the long term, but we we can't just think about it in the short term. Yeah, no. So let's keep up our strategic dependence on China by importing more solar panels from China, which we no longer make ourselves because we can't afford to make them because of the high wages and high energy costs. And solar panels do require energy to manufacture. I mean we've just we've gotten ourselves into this stupidity loop, like this complete idiocy where we are subsidizing things from taxpayer money that really need to just be done properly in Australia, which Australia has the capacity for, and which are causing sovereign risk on in the bigger picture. So and and and I'll add to that Panel before we move to the next topic. There is no reason given our natural resources and our renewable resources that Australia should not be the cheapest energy market in the world. Absolutely we should be the lowest energy per joule. market in the world and we are nowhere near that. Well that's because we've had fifteen, twenty years of climate wars and we haven't had an ability to actually move forward. You've got to forget that we we spent from two thousand and eight onwards without Climate drink. When everyone says climate we drink. That's true. The Greens shock down now after the the attempt to try to have an emissions carbon trading scheme. I blame the German Greens influence for that. It was part of our Speaking of climate war. That was that poison pill. That was that poison pill those years ago. Speaking of climate, we're gonna move everyone along. No, every time we say climate, we're drinking, and it's hard for going. One of Australia's greatest climate warriors, Tony Abbott, is now the president of the Federal Liberal Party. ⁓ Parnell, I'm gonna start off with you. Is this a strategically genius move by the Liberal Party or is it a serious blunder? It might be a bit of both. ⁓ bear with me for a second. It is Tony obviously has a very well, he's very good at campaigning. He was he was a great campaigner. He does have a strong persona which is very popular among one nation voters. If One if the Liberal Party is to win voters back from one nation, then it could do worse than put Tony in that role so that they know that the person who was there for the issues that they care about is now in charge of the Liberal Party. Having said that, there is a bigger problem, which is that one nation voters are largely happy with where they are at. There is no burning cause to to go back to where they were now. Be a little less crazy. No. And they and there are, you know, and so we are there are big problems in the Liberal Party with just simply losing demographic after demographic. Like they lost women, they lost ⁓ minor you know, so immigrants, they they're good at losing groups and now they need to bring them together. So that's like the t shirt. You should have that as your other sign. Good at losing groups. On the other hand though, I would say that Abbott is very popular among many Chinese people and like and Indian immigrants. That he he he actually has Is that the budgie smugglers or what what's his other word to them? No, it's simply that he stands for something, you know, frankly, they're socially conservative. He's socially conservative. It makes a lot of sense to them. They like his strong personality. The reason why there are a lot a lot of immigrants supporting one nation, actually, the same sort of thing. the issue is that I think women are now a bit of a a a group who've been lost to other, you know, to the to the other group. And I'm not sure Tony is the right person to win them back unless he's gonna bring in new policies which which directly speak to them or, you know, unless Angus Taylor is going to be bringing policies which speak to them and Tony will understand how to sell them and how to be in the background of that. And of course the other problem is simply that Tony is a such a strong personality that somebody who feels quite managerial like Angus Taylor is going to be drowned out by him. And I think that the Liberal Party is making the mistake of not leaning into Angus's feel of a sort of a bit of a, you know, polite managerial, competent person. And the smartest idiot, as Malcolm Turnbull called him as well. Most qualified idiot. Most qualified idiot. Like a bit quiet. And he's but you don't you need to you need to lean into that stuff. You need to say, you know, here is our wonk. This guy is the is is smart, but he is a a new when we elect a wonk. When did we elect Dewan? But we don't mind him the fact that he's a nerd. He's a nerd surrounded by people with good policies. He's not I I reckon he looks like we we did elect Kevin Kevin Rudd. Kevin Rudd was a Kevin Rudd was a nerd. To me, Angus Taylor looks like Ken from Ken and Barbie with a silver spoon. Like he's just there's nothing to like about it. Like lot of lot of people bought those Ken dolls, mate. Yeah, I refer to he's referred to regularly as the empty suit because that's what he is. Can I just say though, can I just respond? Can I have a crack on Abbott though? And can I have a crack on Abbott? And want to throw a full toss to Francis at the end. So, firstly, I have always respected Abbott, and I think that what where he is different to other politicians is he's got a moral core to him, his Catholicism, just noting I'm with his Pope at the moment, I'm considering converting to Catholicism off the back of the encyclical. But I remember. Yeah, when he became opposition leader, you could see how much like his sense of because he's got a moral core, he's got a sense of purpose. And I remember being in a urinal at the Walkley Awards with a young Anthony Albanese saying, Abbott's gonna be formidable and he was going, Yeah, mate, he's hateless. And like that was before he had the teeth done. So I actually think that he is an asset to the party, a bit like you, Parnell, but you know. The problem is he's also the avatar for the loss of your left flank. Like he was the first one to lose his seat to the Teals. And it just sends a message to all those people that have gone the the the sort of where it's it's it's it's because they're so focused on one nation, it's sending them the message, we're not for you guys anymore. The world has changed since that time. And I mean, you know, the top is the top piece of evidence for that that Energy is now contestable again. Net zero is contestable again. So the things that were certain and you know final when Abbott lost his seat, ⁓ the fact that the idea that climate was more important than anything else, these sorts of ideas have been washed away by reality. Abbott is coming back in at a time when the world has been mugged by reality. And he might be the right person to take that through. I mean, I find it also very ironic that in a sense, here is a guy who is deeply at heart a BA BS ⁓ Bob Santa Maria type conservative, who, however, fought his the twenty thirteen election on libertarian economics and is coming in at a time when the Liberal Party has finally found its liberal, classical liberal core again, and is going to be Need to guide its fight on that. So that's the other interesting thing about this. I think he's going to need to not just ⁓ take on the world having been mugged by reality and make something out of that, but pick up the ⁓ the economic side of it and show that he can help the Liberal Party prosecute that. Pan Panel, well I don't disagree with you on any these points. Isn't traditionally the purpose of the federal president is essentially a ceremonial. It's a I know. We're talking about him as though he were there. We're talking about him as though he's he's the the organ the leader in the house. Well that's your problem here. Can I just say this to me, coming from you know, Melbourne Central, is like Essendon Football Club hankering after James Heard. James Heard, the the the darling of the Essendon Football Club oversaw the disastrous banning of the football club for for drug charges. Peptides peptides and his own Enhanced games, Damian. Yeah. Yeah. Terrible. You know, and keep going. At at the moment is being you know, once again faded as a potential return to coaching because they're so enamored of a time when he, as the ⁓ big darling of the club, could take them somewhere. He was good on the field and now he's playing the coaching role, yeah. Tony is ⁓ I agree with one one thing Tony ever has, which Paul Inhanson has, is authenticity. He is who he is, and everybody will you cannot try ⁓ fault. Tony for that. I I met him a few times. I actually quite like him as he as a person, incredibly good character and fun to hang around with. Disagree you can disagree amiably with Tony Abbott and there's a whole bunch of things about him that you might that people on the left might not like. But that's okay. I've got no problem with that. But the idea that he somehow represents the future for the Liberal Party and can somehow outflank the one nation that I think is a folly because one nation is a vote on emotion and it's on a rage. It's not on it's not on consideration. And it's not on an on ⁓ an observable and considered ⁓ understanding of the facts. So I don't think that's gonna work for him. And the other thing for in a strategic ⁓ position is that you're setting up two polar opposites of power here. So Tony Abbott is the president, as if he becomes because he's so high profile, people are gonna go to him for his opinion on everything. And he might willingly give it. And he've got a leader in parliament, he's trying to give it something as well, he's got a whole range of different considerations, which are difficult to negotiate. So you're setting up a really difficult circumstance for both of them, which I don't think can work. So look, he's a So Wayne Swann has been AOP president for about six years. So he's managed it not overshadowing, but he wasn't as big a personality, obviously, as the mad monk. No one is. No full banner when when Wayne took on that role, the way that the people on the right are talk Tony ever taking over. And is there Panel and Damian will load this, is there a deeper internal political discussion within the Liberal Party about Tony's ascension to that role within the dynamics of the New South Wales Liberal Party in particular and the power struggle over who controls the liberal between the wets and and the more conservative people. Is it about buttressing ⁓ Angus Taylor's role as a leader? All of those things are embedded in there as well. So I think it's a really difficult circumstance for him to navigate and for the party to navigate because they will at some point he will say something because Tony won't walk away from a microphone. He's not he's not going to be the guy that goes I'll defer to the leader and there will be a a moment where he'll say something that's at odds with a parliamentary party or the parliamentary leader that's gonna make it difficult and it's gonna be it's gonna be I think it's gonna be trouble because he is at heart a retail politician that wants to be involved in the main game. He doesn't wanna be I don't see him as a person who wants to be the the the guy in the back room doing the having the quiet conversation. That's just who he is. I just think he's the wrong guy for the wrong role, but the right person for the right party. I I think you're right, Francis, and I think it it does present a problem for the Liberal Party. That said, yet to be proven it this could be Tony in his elder statesman years deciding that he's okay playing a role to be in the background. So let let's let's give him a bit of a Damien lead singers are always gonna be lead singers. Yeah. Well, look thank you for that analogy. I was I was struggling with your sports analogies, Francis. I was I was gonna ask you to explain it to me using Star Wars or Lord of the Rings or something. So ⁓ No, appreciate it. Hey, look, let's move on to our final topic of the week that that's worth just really quickly touching over, which is Barnaby not knowing what his policies were in relation to One Nation, whether or not their One Nation is going to steal the houses of permanent residents or kick them out or what he was going to do. Is this first cracks of One Nation or is this just Barnaby being Barnaby? I think that it's not first cracks. There are many, many cracks. I was being generous. Yeah, yeah. Look, I mean that this is what's gonna happen, what's gonna start happening more and more. So ⁓ One Nation is fundamentally a party about having lost trust in politicians and having and feeling like the politicians are no longer the servants of the people, but all of a sudden the masters of the people. ⁓ and so it's gonna take a lot before. One nation voters will look at something like that and say, ⁓ gosh, I can't support this party anymore. Having said that, their policy platform has an internal contradiction. If you are an a ⁓ national sovereignty-focused party who is, however, fundamentally distrustful of institutions, how do you build policy from there? And this is this tension is going to go through every policy like this. ⁓ permanent residence housing issue today. There are contradictions in their platform which pe which mean that people can't go back to first principles when on air to come up with the policy that is roughly what their party is going to stand for. These things are going to happen again and again. One nation supporters aren't going to care about a single incident, but they'll start getting That's the point though. Like will there be will there be a tipping point where it goes crazy, crazy, crazy, d or does And is it I think that these when these things start reverberating online, people will start conceiving their own doubts. And when people start conceiving their own doubts, that thing, whatever they're doubting, is going down because it's really hard to shake people in their own opinions. Francis, I might just throw to you, I think ⁓ you know, whether or not one nation, other than having the grievance of immigrants are to blame but not having consistency over an actual immigration policy. ⁓ is in your view, is Barnaby just a a big crack that's now showing how shallow they are on the policy front, or was it just Well I think that I think that incident is a crack that shows that they have no policy or sophisticated policy on this. Barnaby himself, not so much. I think he's probably the smartest person in that room. Agreed. And the most and the and but the most policy wise person in that room. And it must be killing him. It must be killing him not to be in charge because we're talking about someone Through the National Party twice, not once, but twice made deputy prime minister. And he ratted on them, using a Labor term, he ratted on them in order to ⁓ to to to deal with his own ambition. So he's got his own thing going on. But the thing for them, I think, is that once again we will see, and maybe it'll play out ⁓ in the Victorian state election. I've got no doubt that one nation in the Victorian State Election will pick up seats for the first time. They it the the move is so strong. And they will see candidates a bit like what we saw in Queensland in nineteen ninety eight. having to actually deal with the hard grind and the boring nature of parliamentary process and politics and not being up to it. And people starting to understand, ⁓ yeah, well, yeah, the grievance is one thing, but this doesn't work in getting things done. So there it could be a blessing for the for both major parties, with the state election in Victoria coming up at the end of this year and a federal election, say 18 months hence. So that's what I think is is possibly there. But the grievance is real. I know it's real. I've seen it. I've talked to people in the communities that I've worked in. People feel completely disconnected from ⁓ from traditional politics and they're angry and they feel like it's a time to burn the whole thing down and it it's a really dangerous time for the major parties, but it's not irretrievable. But because a lot of the fixes that we have to try and find are long term, this is a really dangerous time. I th I think that's a really great point and and as you say, politics is fun, governing is boring. And on that, I might just throw it to Peter. Now we used to have a great section at the end of our shows, Peter. Now before we get there, can I just give my take on OneNation? Sorry, guys. So I actually think we are no longer looking at politics as left and right, but inside outside. And so the challenges Labour face the same challenges the Libs have faced. And so I see more in common with Teal and to an extent Green and one nation voters who say the system's just not working anymore. And those that have been charged with government are still defending the system. That's a really dangerous place to be when you're the incumbent. But it's also becoming hard when you're someone that's preparing to govern. So you're actually c trying to come up with an alternate program. I think the Libs have given up on that now and they're just trying to get back into the game. And, you know, fair call for that. But it is also, we are losing that like assuming I I think on in terms of Actually having to run a country for serious people doing it, I think we're probably a unity ticket. Like we all disagree, but we will basically say there are certain parameters around which we look at politics. But the outsiders don't. It's tear the show down and they're given more and more reasons to tear it down every week. And we're gonna have this global crisis that's caused ironically by a populist who doesn't know what he's doing that's gonna make everyone's life worse. But the one thing I'll say, if you look at the stuff they're putting out. particularly the animations of Please Explain, they run rings around us. They're funny. It's like an a river in Sha South Park. And so they are gonna beat us on story because we haven't got a story about how the centre works anymore. That's so true. But but don't forget, they don't want to they want to burn the political establishment down. They don't want to burn Australia down. I mean you should never sort of confuse the two. They are not trying to trash the nation. But they will burn it down by neglect. Like they will like it won't be intentional. It will be by neglect. and that I don't know if it's possible, but it's not exactly the worst thing in the world. Like this is a political establishment which has become sclerotic, which has become presumptuo, which serves itself and not the people. So I do think that there is a great wake up call that needs to happen and maybe, you know, to the But we c we can't do it with humour though. Sorry Frank. You can't just jump in there and say, I mean I know what Punel say, I just think the frustration, but I will just say the parliamentary democracy in this country it through all of its travails and all the problems it's produced and and all of our frustrations, that's produced an incredibly prosperous, dynamic Stable, safe incredible country. They're all about frustration. The idea of burning it all down, if it's a binary choice and starting again, is absolute nonsense. I I just cannot buy the idea anybody wants to burn down the concept of parliamentary democracy. What they want to burn down is the is the corridors full of lobbyists crawling around and well no you think that Gina Reinhardt is as the as the patriarch of of one nation. And unless she's non-binary. ⁓ Sorry. Transition. I want Gina to transition to be the patriarch of the nation and I will retire. My work is done. But do you think that's not again? But if you think of the one nation with a with a matriarch or any sort of a benefactor of of enormous wealth that will fund their campaign and provide an aeroplane and drive their campaign. So is in any way a replacement that will further advance democracy and opportunity for ordinary Australians. Do you think that that's I'm not making the case for one nation. I'm just making the case against what they're in. Frank, you did you have a response to that? It was at least I'm not bludging on the taxpayer. Like and it kind of works. But but that's a the the the the realistic alternative here is, and and unfortunately no, no voter really wants to a Labour Liberal Alliance government is no is ⁓ that elec elections should be funded by the taxpayer. So or can we At least we know someone that understands the inner working of German alliance politics, Parnell. You could become like the deal maker to see. We are at our time limit for the week. I we could happily talk for hours more, which is the idea of these things, but unfortunately I'm gonna have to bring it to a close. But before we do, we used to do these predictions at the end of the show, which I think we're now gonna start calling the kiss of death, as four weeks in a row now. Predictions from me at least have completely fallen flat to say the least. So I I'm gonna lean into that and say, Peter, what is your kiss of death for the coming week? So it's quite personal. So I've never been invited to a film premiere on the red carpet, but on Saturday night, my wife's ⁓ nephew is directing a gay conversion therapy horror movie called Leviticus, which has taken Sundance by storm. So I don't know if there's a palm dior or something for the Sydney Film Festival, but I'm predicting he's gonna win it. Amazing. Love that. Panel, your kiss of death for the week. ⁓ here's a punt. I know that there's polling coming out of the field next week. and one of the questions that we'll be asking will be around the budget reply. ⁓ whether people think that ⁓ welfare should be extended to ⁓ permanent residents or whether or sorry whether it should be limited to citizens in the way that we've already done the polling the public love it par now. Exactly. We had love. That's what I was gonna say. I think it's I think people are gonna go Who are you using? Who who are you I'm not using anyone on this. I I just I talk to everybody. Straight to panel. But anyway we had polling on our site that shows you're right. ⁓ is it? Okay. I didn't write a column on it clearly but it's there. Francis, your kiss of death for the week? My kiss at Death of the Week will be that Barnaby Joyce will be sent somewhere with Pauline Hanson ⁓ just saying yes to whatever she says. In a pub somewhere. Can I just say did anyone watch that's been that's been grilled on a table? Did anyone watch the Faraby election? It was really creepy, Barnaby with his arm round Pauline. I had Gareth and Cheryl vibes all over me. Like there is something creepy going on. ⁓ my footage it is So are you saying Vicky has something to worry about? And my kiss of death for the week is ⁓ Tuesday morning Australia time will be WWDC, which is the big Apple Developer Conference over in San Francisco, where they're unveiling the next version of the iOS operating system. I think I think there's gonna be some crazy good AI integration and I'm hoping the share price ⁓ skyrockets as a result. So what do I need to get on, Damien? Tell me now, I'll go and buy some shares. Well, now would be the t well, look at the This podcast can't possibly provide you with financial advice. But we are and past performance is not an indicator of future success. No, but we are on Substack that has a prediction app. Like do you want to We do have a prediction market on our on our predictions. Australia needs something like Australia needs right now is more ways to pump more, yeah. Just note, Francis, that the last four weeks of my predictions have gone the other way. So maybe short against Apple just to be safe. ⁓ I'd like to thank you both, Francis and Parnell, for joining us this week. What a vigorous, lovely conversation on a whole bunch of topics. You're both very welcome back anytime. Peter, as always, it is a pleasure to chat to you every single Friday. I hope we keep doing it for the indefinite future. If it's your first time watching, please ⁓ like, subscribe, do all the things that the kids ask you to do. If you watch it regularly, share it with someone that you enjoy. We appreciate you and your time. Have a great week. Thanks, everyone. Thank you. Thanks, Ta. What's your poison? Say it straight. What's your poison? Drink with me. ⁓ What's your poison? What's your poison? What's your poison?
